PDA

View Full Version : The Catiline Conspiracy: A Small Roman Game [Concluded]



Warmaster Horus
08-21-2007, 09:30
Ave players of the Gameroom!

As the more astute of you will have noticed, this game will be set during the Catiline (or Catilinarian) Conspiracy of 63BC. For more information about that event, check this (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catiline_conspiracy)out.

So, there will be two main conspirators, representing the whole conspiracy. It will be the role of the influential men of Rome (or of this forum) to find them, and kill them.

There will also be a pro town role.

Every player will be given the name of a player in the real conspiracy. This name will be given:
-when a player is lynched
-two days after the death (by the mafia) of a player.
And it could be a clue as to the involvement of the player in the Conspiracy.

Any questions, don't hesitate to ask!

EDIT: Ah, yes, I knew I forgot something.
You enter, you play. If you don't participate for 2 days, I'll find a replacement.

Sign ups: 12/12 FULL

Andres
pevergreen
Twilightblade
Ignoramus
woad&fangs
Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca
Shlin28
Tiberius of the Drake
Sarathos
Roadkill
Ichigo
CountArach

Andres
08-21-2007, 09:33
Nice setting for a mafia game Warmaster.

In!

pevergreen
08-21-2007, 09:39
So in

Twilightblade
08-21-2007, 10:14
Looks to be an interesting game IN!!

Ignoramus
08-21-2007, 10:57
In!

woad&fangs
08-21-2007, 16:04
:rtwyes: Yay!!!, I get to help bring about the fall of the Romans *cough, cough* I mean.... go townies!!!

Caius
08-21-2007, 16:06
In!

shlin28
08-21-2007, 16:36
In!

Tiberius of the Drake
08-21-2007, 19:26
im in

Sarathos
08-22-2007, 02:16
Sure why not, im in

RoadKill
08-22-2007, 03:41
I'll join

Csargo
08-22-2007, 04:11
:soapbox:

CountArach
08-22-2007, 04:32
In!

Killfr3nzy
08-22-2007, 05:58
Innage.

Warmaster Horus
08-22-2007, 11:21
Sorry KF, we've got everyone we need. However, if someone's going to be replaced, I'll PM you, okay?

Sign ups closed, PMs going out as soon as I'll wrestle the computer from my parents again (likely in a couple of hours).

EDIT: Pms being sent.

Warmaster Horus
08-22-2007, 21:45
Alright! PMs have been sent, all. If there are any problems, questions, requirements, PM me.

The story:
Bodies began to pile up in the streets. Bodies of plebeans and patricians alike. No concern was shown, until the death of Quintus Caecilius Metellus Pius. The noble general's death demanded some investigation, and after some digging around, the Senate discovered evidence of a future Conspiracy, designed to overthrow the Republic.

The augurs were consulted, and no information was found. Gaius Julius Caesar, Pontifex Maximus, was asked to pray to Jupiter Optimus Maximus.
As the Supreme Pontiff entered the Senate to inform the men that he had not been able to learn anything, a voice was heard, grand, strong and resonating throughout the halls.

"Men of the Republic! I have heard that treachery is amongst you. I am Jupiter Optimus Maximus, and I speak the Will of the Gods. I hold you dear, and I tell you that you are not safe.

There is a way, however, to save yourselves. Find the twelve most important men to you, and let them congregate in the Senate by day. During that time, they will have to decide who will be given Supreme Punishment, who will be thrown from the Tarpeian Rock. They will do this in the manner you so adore. Democratically.

Those twelve men will be locked inside day and night. They will be given accomodation inside the Senate, and the doors will be opened for the punishment and when there are no more foes in the Senate.
Pro Senatus Populusque Romanus!"

After these words, the roman citizenship voted to see who would enter. After twelve names were found, those men were ushered inside, and they were locked in.

Would the Republic remain strong? Or would it crumble because of treachery? Only time will tell.
That, and the will of the Gods.


Okay. That's it.
It's day. Start voting. Tomorrow, at midnight (GMT+2), will be the first execution.

Csargo
08-22-2007, 21:52
Sasaki's not playing so I'll go with the next green guy...Vote:Andres

Warmaster Horus
08-22-2007, 21:56
And keep a tally, please.

woad&fangs
08-22-2007, 21:57
It was Tiberius of the Drake, in the Imperial Bedroom, with his sword.... look he's wiping blood off of his sword, he must be guilty.

Vote: Tiberius of the Drake

FoS: Andres
His new avatar looks rather suspicious(and kind of like a beady eyed gorilla if you ask me).

Edit:
Tally
T of the D: 1(woad&fangs)
Andres: 1(Ichigo)

Andres
08-22-2007, 21:58
Vote : Ichigo

Elitism: he only wants to vote moderators.

Tally:

Ichigo: 1 (Andres)
Andres: 1 (Ichigo)

Caius
08-22-2007, 21:59
How can you know that?

Andres
08-22-2007, 22:00
It was Tiberius of the Drake, in the Imperial Bedroom, with his sword.... look he's wiping blood off of his sword, he must be guilty.

Vote: Tiberius of the Drake

FoS: Andres
His new avatar looks rather suspicious(and kind of like a beady eyed gorilla if you ask me).

Unvote ; Vote : woad&fangs

Meatballing + he insulted my new avatar :bigcry:

Tiberius of the Drake
08-22-2007, 22:07
*note to self: change avatar message*

Vote: Woad&Fangs

He looks rather Barabarian to me...

and its not nice to insult people's avatar :thumbsup:

edit: tally
Andres:1
Woad&Fangs: 2

Caius
08-22-2007, 22:10
Vote: Abstain.
Well, might change the vote to w&f

Csargo
08-22-2007, 22:13
Unvote ; Vote : woad&fangs

Meatballing + he insulted my new avatar :bigcry:

You gotta admit it is kinda creepy.:sweatdrop:

woad&fangs
08-22-2007, 22:43
wow, people really love to bandwagon me.:sweatdrop:

shlin28
08-22-2007, 22:52
Vote: Abstain.

Trying to sound neutal, no point in this game. we might get lucky if we vote someone (1 in 6!) therefore
Vote: Inca man

Andres
08-22-2007, 23:02
Well, might change the vote to w&f

Why would you do that for?

Caius
08-22-2007, 23:25
Well, i will explain.

WH said there was a pro role. I have a feeling that he is the guy.

Sarathos
08-22-2007, 23:34
Vote: Woads and fangs for starting the vote based on avatars.......wtf?

Andres
08-22-2007, 23:37
Well, i will explain.

WH said there was a pro role. I have a feeling that he is the guy.

If you think w&f has a pro-town role, why would you consider switching your vote to him then?

woad&fangs
08-22-2007, 23:43
Actually, Caius, I'm just a normal townie for once so and I don't understand why you thought I had the pro town role. I would appreciate it if you explained your thinking.

unvote; Vote: Sarathos

Ichigo started the voting by voting for Andres because he is a moderater so no I did not start the voting. Also I voted based off of Tib's location not his avatar. In my opinion the first round is all meatballing until someone says something odd that gets the discussion aimed at them. In this case it is Caius's abstain vote. I am still suspicious of Caius until he explains why he thought I had the protown role.

Warmaster Horus
08-22-2007, 23:47
*Re-reads the topic. Frowns*

Hmm... Seems I'm forgetful tonight.

There are two pro-town roles. Sorry guys for having forgotten that.

Csargo
08-22-2007, 23:49
Actually, Caius, I'm just a normal townie for once so and I don't understand why you thought I had the pro town role. I would appreciate it if you explained your thinking.

unvote; Vote: Sarathos

Ichigo started the voting by voting for Andres because he is a moderater so no I did not start the voting. Also I voted based off of Tib's location not his avatar. In my opinion the first round is all meatballing until someone says something odd that gets the discussion aimed at them. In this case it is Caius's abstain vote. I am still suspicious of Caius until he explains why he thought I had the protown role.

pro role. parole. patrol. patron. pat ran. Vote:W&F

Sarathos:1
Woad&Fangs: 3
Caius:1

Andres
08-22-2007, 23:54
:inquisitive:

Unvote ; Vote : Ichigo

Sarathos:1
Woad&Fangs: 2
Caius:1
Ichigo: 1

Twilightblade
08-22-2007, 23:56
Vote: Sarathos

I think that you were trying to justify a random vote with any reason possible
My reason isn't much better but it is better

Edit:

Tally
Sarathos:2
Woad&Fangs: 2
Caius:1
Ichigo: 1

Csargo
08-22-2007, 23:56
Why Have You Foresaken Me!?!?

Ignoramus
08-23-2007, 02:09
Vote: Sarathos

Sarathos, that has to be the lamest excuse for voting for someone. I know that we've got no evidence to go on at the start, but why then try and make it based on suspicious behaviour?

Sarathos
08-23-2007, 03:08
How is that being suspious??? :inquisitive:

Is anyone elses reason that much better??? i.e. TBlade and Ignoramus...

Twilightblade
08-23-2007, 04:23
Tally
Sarathos:3
Woad&Fangs: 2
Caius:1
Ichigo: 1

RoadKill
08-23-2007, 07:08
:thumbsdown: Everyone has forgotten about me, anyways Vote: Caius

Sarathos
08-23-2007, 08:54
Meh, I dont care anymore. Town can die in a fire cause they're not getting my help anymore. GG lynch guys

Andres
08-23-2007, 08:58
I think Sarathos' vote was just a random vote. What other reasoning should he have provided with no more then a few posts in a game that just started?

Anyway,

Caius, I'm still wondering:


If you think w&f has a pro-town role, why would you consider switching your vote to him then?

Unvote ; Vote : Caius

Sarathos:3 (w&f, Ignoramus, TB)
Woad&Fangs: 2 (Sarathos, Ichigo)
Caius:3 (shlin, Roadkill, Andres)

pevergreen
08-23-2007, 09:26
Meh, I dont care anymore. Town can die in a fire cause they're not getting my help anymore. GG lynch guys
This is the type of attitude we get from bad townies.

You are no loss as a lynch.

Andres
08-23-2007, 09:39
This is the type of attitude we get from bad townies.

You are no loss as a lynch.

Do you think he's guilty? Or do you have another suspect?

Twilightblade
08-23-2007, 09:40
yeah sarathos if your going to act like that get replaced by killfr3nzy he might actually want to play

pevergreen
08-23-2007, 09:41
Guilty? Unlikely. Any benefit to the town? No.

Main suspect is W&F. He seems to be like Roadkill was when he started playing. Hopefully he'll get better, so I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt. Now in Caius' case, im going to wait upon a reply.

FoS: Caius

RoadKill
08-23-2007, 09:49
Guilty? Unlikely. Any benefit to the town? No.

Main suspect is W&F. He seems to be like Roadkill was when he started playing. Hopefully he'll get better, so I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt. Now in Caius' case, im going to wait upon a reply.

FoS: Caius

Exactly what he said, I have the exact same attitude as Woad&fangs, so I really doubt hes guilty. Its usually becuase of that attitude that gets me lynched anyways.

RoadKill
08-23-2007, 09:51
Guys ignore my previous post on top, I thought Woa&Fangs was Sarathos, so just replace sarathos into it.

Andres
08-23-2007, 09:54
Guys ignore my previous post on top, I thought Woa&Fangs was Sarathos, so just replace sarathos into it.

You do not have an edit button...?

Ignoramus
08-23-2007, 10:18
Either Sarathos is pulling a bluff, so that we won't lynch him, or otherwise he's merely a townie that's lost interest in the game.

If it's option (b), then we shouldn't bother lynching him, as killfr3nzy should be a more active villager.

If it's option (a), however, then of course we should knock him off.

As I'm leading towards (b) at the moment, I'll change my vote to Caius.

Unvote ; Vote : Caius

Twilightblade
08-23-2007, 10:36
Tally
Sarathos:3 (w&f, , TB)
Woad&Fangs: 2 (Sarathos, Ichigo)
Caius:4 (shlin, Roadkill, Andres,Ignoramus)

shlin28
08-23-2007, 10:43
:inquisitive: People followed my lead! Yay!

Csargo
08-23-2007, 19:03
I don't see why your all going after Caius.

Caius
08-23-2007, 20:00
:thumbsdown: Everyone has forgotten about me, anyways Vote: Caius
I dont see the point. You just jump in the bandwagon, and nothing more?

Vote:RoadKill

Warmaster Horus
08-23-2007, 22:02
One hour left before the execution.

Andres
08-23-2007, 22:21
I don't see why your all going after Caius.

Would you prefer us to lynch you instead?

CountArach
08-23-2007, 22:27
Well, i will explain.

WH said there was a pro role. I have a feeling that he is the guy.
Vote: Caius

This line of thought is flawed and counter-productive. He also is making the assumption that it is W&F based on no evidence, unless they are scum buddies...

Csargo
08-23-2007, 22:47
Would you prefer us to lynch you instead?

If you think I'm guilty then sure, but so far all I've seen against Caius is that his English is hard to understand.

Warmaster Horus
08-23-2007, 23:28
Tally
Garcilaso:5 (shlin, Roadkill, Andres,Ignoramus, CountArach)

Sarathos:2 (w&f, TB)
Woad&Fangs: 2 (Sarathos, Ichigo)
Roadkill: 1 (Caius)


The next day, when the doors of the Senate opened, it was found that the man to be executed is Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus.

The General had done his best to defend himself, but his eloquence wasn't of the same caliber as his martial skills, and he quickly understood that he was going to die.

The 12 men went to the Tarpeian Rock, not far from the Senate. There they heard the same voice that had spoken the day before:

"You have chosen, I see. Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus, you have been found guilty of treason against the state. Step forward." He did, and an invisible force pushed him so hard he was flying for about 5 seconds, before falling to a painful death. The voice spoke one more time:

"Go back, chosen ones, to the Senate, to your accomodations. And tomorrow, with luck, there will be no threat remaining to Rome."


Garcilaso de la Vega was lynched. He was the General Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus.

PMs, if you please.

Sarathos
08-23-2007, 23:37
yeah sarathos if your going to act like that get replaced by killfr3nzy he might actually want to play

At that point i was going to be lynched, so it wouldnt of mattered what i acted like cause i was going out anyway. So maybe you need get get some real evidence before you make another bad vote....

Sarathos
08-23-2007, 23:39
Tally
Sarathos:3 (w&f, , TB)
Woad&Fangs: 2 (Sarathos, Ichigo)
Caius:4 (shlin, Roadkill, Andres,Ignoramus)

GG tally..??

Ignoramus
08-24-2007, 00:49
We killed Pompey?:thumbsdown:

Andres
08-24-2007, 09:04
We killed Pompey?:thumbsdown:

Yeah, we just changed the course of history. Caesar will be happy...

Caius
08-24-2007, 18:57
Thats why you should not lynched me!

Well done!

Warmaster Horus
08-24-2007, 19:20
Yeah, anyway...


The following morning, the eleven men remaining assembled in the main chamber to see what happened during the night.

There, they discovered the body of Woad&Fangs, so horribly mutilated (going into precision would earn me a few warning points, I fear) that they were unable to recognise who exactly it was. They sent the body away, and demanded an enquiry to discovery the identity (the in-game name, if you prefer) of the body.

They then sat down, and began once again, to argue.

It's now day 2. Tomorrow, at midnight, one will be executed.

woad&fangs
08-24-2007, 21:04
I have a hunch we're looking for Pever or one of his school friends.

Twilightblade
08-24-2007, 23:38
What gives you that idea?

pevergreen
08-25-2007, 00:27
We would kill each other first :laugh4:

Beefy187
08-25-2007, 00:51
you guys could all live in the senate house and spy on each other. That way no one gets killed.

Twilightblade
08-25-2007, 04:31
beefy what does that mean? It makes no sence (to me at least)

Killfr3nzy
08-25-2007, 07:42
We would kill each other first :laugh4:
I realize that I'm not playing, but I gotta agree that - with no better kill option - I would bump off someone from my school, just to secretly rejoice at thier bitching during school.

Beefy187
08-25-2007, 08:02
i know it defeats the purpose of the game but..
youll be safe if you all sleep in the senate house.:idea2:
because every one is watching you and youll know who the mafia is straight away..

ignore me.. im not even playing:sweatdrop:

Sarathos
08-25-2007, 08:19
you guys could all live in the senate house and spy on each other. That way no one gets killed.

Sounds like a plan beefy...

And what bitching would that be Killfrenzy????

Twilightblade
08-25-2007, 08:20
Its killfr3nzy

And it would be the constant questions of "why did you kill me?" that he enjoys

Ignoramus
08-25-2007, 09:27
Come on guys, stop quarelling and start thinking logically; we're playing right into the conspirators hands if we don't try and analyze the evidence that's before us.

I have a haunch that Tiberius is guilty. Woad&fangs voted for him in round one, and it might be that his guess made Tib nervous.

Vote: Tiberius

pevergreen
08-25-2007, 11:33
Very possible. But there is no way to let them learn if they die early :no:

Tiberius of the Drake
08-25-2007, 12:55
This m

Tiberius of the Drake
08-25-2007, 13:02
This may be my first online Mafia game but that does not mean I would make a mistake that obvious. Killing the person who voted for me last round would be like voting for friends.It would be too obvious. And Btw I know Ignoramus from a forum game we play together. :Smile:

EditOOPs: partail double post

shlin28
08-25-2007, 13:48
This is the type of attitude we get from bad townies.

You are no loss as a lynch.

Vote: Pever
Every townies are valueble...

woad&fangs
08-25-2007, 14:02
If Tib was worried about my obvious meatball vote then I would be pretty dissapointed in him. My fingers of suspicion point to TwilightBlade, and Pever.

pevergreen
08-25-2007, 14:05
:shrug: He is no loss as long as he plays like that.

Warmaster Horus
08-25-2007, 19:40
Tie between pever and Tiberius. 3 hours and twenty mintues left to vote.

Csargo
08-25-2007, 20:51
Vote:pever Horrible reasoning pever a bad townie is still a townie

Tiberius of the Drake
08-25-2007, 21:36
Obviously im not going to vote for myself...

Vote: Pever

Warmaster Horus
08-25-2007, 23:09
Right, pever was lynched. He was Publius Clodius Pulcher.


The same event that had happened the day before happened now. The Senate doors opened, 11 men walked out, and just a few minutes later 10 men walked back in. Publius Clodius Pulcher didn't, though.

Pms, please.

pevergreen
08-26-2007, 01:01
:laugh4:

Great job.

Bad townie is still a townie, but no use if he is going to not vote and not play.

Tiberius of the Drake
08-26-2007, 01:16
Is it possible to vote for people who are already dead? :smile::smile:

JK.JK.

P.S. no insult or offense intended.

Sarathos
08-26-2007, 06:49
Its killfr3nzy

And it would be the constant questions of "why did you kill me?" that he enjoys

Why do you care...??? Its not even you name
I know for a fact that Killfr3nzy can stand up for himself and that he doesn't care if he name is spelt wrong. Nice waste of a post :no:

Sarathos
08-26-2007, 06:51
:laugh4:

Great job.

Bad townie is still a townie, but no use if he is going to not vote and not play.

It seems pever, that everytime I do attempt either of those I end up getting lynched..... :skull:

But niether the less I shall contine

pevergreen
08-26-2007, 07:41
Nethertheless.

@ Tiberius: Dont worry, nothing in a mafia game is taken seriously unless stated so. Your alliances can change game to game.

Andres
08-26-2007, 19:42
I'm back. Had a very busy week-end... ~:cheers:

Actually it was more like :barrel:

Pever was Publius Clodius Pulcher...

Hmmm... (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publius_Clodius_Pulcher)

CountArach
08-27-2007, 05:27
I'm also back - also had a heavy weekend.

And lol, I would hardly claim that Pulcher was a good man.

Warmaster Horus
08-27-2007, 11:31
Then again, was Caesar a good man? He conquered the rest of the world, brought a measure of peace to Rome, but still...


As the remaining men assembled in the main chamber, they discovered another body, that of Andres on the floor, similarly disfigured. The body was sent away, in order to find out who exactly had been killed. A messenger had come during the night, and had left a note on the floor:
"Honoured Senators, the physicians of Rome examined the body (woad&fang's) found yesterday, and were able to determine his identity. The poor man was Marcus Porcius Cato. May the gods have mercy on him."


Andres was killed. Begin voting. Day 3, lynching in a day and a half.

Killfr3nzy
08-27-2007, 13:05
Andres is always killed. It's karma for disturbing the mafia.

Andres
08-27-2007, 13:14
Killed. Again.

*sigh*

:bigcry:

shlin28
08-27-2007, 20:22
:thumbsdown: Everyone has forgotten about me, anyways Vote: Caius

Since there isnt much activity... I will Vote: Roadkill, for bandwagonning, we got 25% chance of lynching the right person, might as well go for it.

And 9 hours had past since the host promised the write-up... :whip:

Andres
08-27-2007, 20:33
Ignoramus sounds suspicious...

Tiberius of the Drake
08-27-2007, 21:34
Killfr3nzy ssems to be suggesting something....

Vote:Killfr3nzy

Andres
08-27-2007, 21:36
Killfr3nzy isn't participating...

Warmaster Horus
08-27-2007, 22:06
Updated. Sorry, I was out shooting pool.

shlin28
08-27-2007, 22:08
... seems like the we are just killing all of Caesar's future enemies...

Csargo
08-27-2007, 22:37
Could we have a list of who's still alive

shlin28
08-27-2007, 22:41
People who are still alive:

Twilightblade
Ignoramus
Shlin28
Tiberius of the Drake
Sarathos
Roadkill
Ichigo
CountArach

Andres
08-27-2007, 22:51
Vote: Sarathos

Sarathos, that has to be the lamest excuse for voting for someone. I know that we've got no evidence to go on at the start, but why then try and make it based on suspicious behaviour?

I responded to this with:


I think Sarathos' vote was just a random vote. What other reasoning should he have provided with no more then a few posts in a game that just started?

But I didn't vote Ignoramus.

Later on, Ignoramus posted this:


Either Sarathos is pulling a bluff, so that we won't lynch him, or otherwise he's merely a townie that's lost interest in the game.

If it's option (b), then we shouldn't bother lynching him, as killfr3nzy should be a more active villager.

If it's option (a), however, then of course we should knock him off.

As I'm leading towards (b) at the moment, I'll change my vote to Caius.

Unvote ; Vote : Caius

This sounds a bit too neutral, especially that first sentence. In the rest of that post, he states the obvious about Sarathos and then changes his vote to Caius, without any explanation :inquisitive:


We killed Pompey?:thumbsdown:

I don't understand why Ignoramus posted this.


Come on guys, stop quarelling and start thinking logically; we're playing right into the conspirators hands if we don't try and analyze the evidence that's before us.

I have a haunch that Tiberius is guilty. Woad&fangs voted for him in round one, and it might be that his guess made Tib nervous.

Vote: Tiberius

In the first part of this post, he tries to look like the helpfull townie. Than he votes for Tiberius with bad reasoning.

I think Ignoramus is scum.

Tiberius of the Drake
08-27-2007, 22:52
OOps. thnx for the list though.

I agree with Shlin that we have a 25 % chance of gueesing the right person so

Unvote:Killfr3nzy,Vote: Shlin28

He seems to be trying to redirect any suspicon to others. it seems very mafiaesque move to me because Roadkill has done nothing recently.

woad&fangs
08-27-2007, 22:56
I agree with Andres that Ignoramus is acting scummy.

shlin28
08-27-2007, 22:57
When have I tried to redirect people's suspicions?

Csargo
08-27-2007, 22:57
I'm also back - also had a heavy weekend.

And lol, I would hardly claim that Pulcher was a good man.

Vote:CA Maybe you could give us your thoughts on the game so far?

@Andres: That's not very compelling. You can do that with anyone's posts in this game.

Andres
08-27-2007, 23:05
@Andres: That's not very compelling. You can do that with anyone's posts in this game.

You think so?

Tiberius of the Drake
08-27-2007, 23:15
@shlin: what I was trying to say is I dont like your reasoning.

Csargo
08-27-2007, 23:17
You think so?

I wouldn't of said it if I didn't think so

Andres
08-27-2007, 23:20
You can do that with anyone's posts in this game.

Can you do it with CA's posts? Shlin's? Twilightblades'? My posts maybe? Your own posts?

Twilightblade
08-27-2007, 23:24
vote: Roadkill you have been more inactive than me. What are your thoughts on the game?

Csargo
08-27-2007, 23:31
Can you do it with CA's posts? Shlin's? Twilightblades'? My posts maybe? Your own posts?



Vote : Ichigo

Elitism: he only wants to vote moderators.

Tally:

Ichigo: 1 (Andres)
Andres: 1 (Ichigo)

You knew my vote was random so why did you vote me? Kinda scummy.


If you think w&f has a pro-town role, why would you consider switching your vote to him then?

Attacking Caius because of a little slip up with his English. Why? Maybe because you figured it would be an easy lynch?


Unvote ; Vote : Ichigo

Sarathos:1
Woad&Fangs: 2
Caius:1
Ichigo: 1


No reasoning at all. I think Andres is mafia

Vote:Andres

Like I said anyone.

Twilightblade
08-27-2007, 23:34
Hasn't he been killed though?

woad&fangs
08-27-2007, 23:38
Andres was killed by the mafia night 2 so I highly doubt he is mafia.:clown:

Andres
08-27-2007, 23:39
It's not the same Ichigo. Where's the neutrality which is so obviously present in Ignoramus's posts?

Csargo
08-27-2007, 23:51
It's not the same Ichigo. Where's the neutrality which is so obviously present in Ignoramus's posts?

I wouldn't look for neutrality in your posts. Good players can always make their posts seem pro-town even when they're guilty.

Anyways I don't see the neutrality you see in his post in the first place. He was trying to figure what Sarathos's was doing. Well I guess I do see it since he's really just stating the obvious. I'll have to look read some more. I've still gotta read the TWC mafia game. :wall: :bigcry:

RoadKill
08-28-2007, 03:17
vote: Roadkill you have been more inactive than me. What are your thoughts on the game?

Inactive? You try writing 21 pms record everyones weapons stats, position, in Battle Royale and still have free time. But anyways I read through the thread, and its obvious Ichigo is trying to plan something scummy. As he also vote Andres even though he was dead. Meaning hes obviously trying to push every spec of suspicion on someone else. I also agree with Andres about Ignormous. So the biggest possibility of the two mafias would be Ignormous and Ichigo. I'll Vote: Ichigo

Twilightblade
08-28-2007, 03:33
True that :bow: Unvote

Csargo
08-28-2007, 03:39
Inactive? You try writing 21 pms record everyones weapons stats, position, in Battle Royale and still have free time. But anyways I read through the thread, and its obvious Ichigo is trying to plan something scummy. As he also vote Andres even though he was dead. Meaning hes obviously trying to push every spec of suspicion on someone else. I also agree with Andres about Ignormous. So the biggest possibility of the two mafias would be Ignormous and Ichigo. I'll Vote: Ichigo

How so? That wasn't a real vote, if you would have actually read the thread then you would realize that. Andres is innocent because he was killed. I was trying to say that Andres attack on Ignoramus wasn't good.

CountArach
08-28-2007, 03:48
How so? That wasn't a real vote, if you would have actually read the thread then you would realize that. Andres is innocent because he was killed. I was trying to say that Andres attack on Ignoramus wasn't good.
So, instead of trying to find evidence that disproves Ignoramus, you choose to attack Andres, a confirmed innocent. I really don't see how this will help the town in any way, except to defend Ignoramus. But, what if Ignoramus is scum? Can you find evidence that will prove him innocent? If not, perhaps he should be lynched.

However, I say we lynch you first Ichigo - You are playing as scum trying to defend a scum buddy, or at least try to get friends by defending people - Thus making them less likely to attack you.

Vote: Ichigo

Csargo
08-28-2007, 05:21
So, instead of trying to find evidence that disproves Ignoramus, you choose to attack Andres, a confirmed innocent. I really don't see how this will help the town in any way, except to defend Ignoramus. But, what if Ignoramus is scum? Can you find evidence that will prove him innocent? If not, perhaps he should be lynched.

However, I say we lynch you first Ichigo - You are playing as scum trying to defend a scum buddy, or at least try to get friends by defending people - Thus making them less likely to attack you.

Vote: Ichigo



You can do that with anyone's posts in this game.

Can you do it with CA's posts? Shlin's? Twilightblades'? My posts maybe? Your own posts?

Have a nice day.

CountArach
08-28-2007, 05:30
Then why didn't you do it for other people?

Csargo
08-28-2007, 05:44
Then why didn't you do it for other people?

What would be the point? If I can do it to a confirmed innocent, then it can be done to anyone proving my point. There's no reason too.

Andres
08-28-2007, 08:11
What would be the point? If I can do it to a confirmed innocent, then it can be done to anyone proving my point. There's no reason too.

I was under the impression you expressed doubts about your own statement here:


Anyways I don't see the neutrality you see in his post in the first place. He was trying to figure what Sarathos's was doing. Well I guess I do see it since he's really just stating the obvious. I'll have to look read some more.

Aren't you saying here that maybe I am right about Ignoramus?

Csargo
08-28-2007, 08:31
I was under the impression you expressed doubts about your own statement here:



Aren't you saying here that maybe I am right about Ignoramus?

I said that his statement was neutral. It is possible that Ignoramus is guilty. You all seem to be misunderstanding my point.

Ignoramus
08-28-2007, 10:30
If I was scum, then why would I try and revive discussion when everyone went off topic? Surely it'd be to my advantage to lie low, as that way I'd be sure not to get lynched.

Twilightblade, however, has done nothing useful for the town. He gives no reasons for his accusations, whereas, I try and actually base my accusations on proof. He's been lying low, posting rarely, and escaped suspicion.

CountArach has also been "mysteriously absent". He says that he had a long weekend, hence his inactivity. Surely that would be very convenient for one of the scum; he could stay offline, while his co-conspirator sends in the kills and votes.

Twilightblade
08-28-2007, 11:22
I wouldn't say escaped if you are suspecting me

Nothing useful may be true so far but at least I havn't hindered

Warmaster Horus
08-28-2007, 23:20
Voting finished, Ichigo has been lynched.

The group trouped diligently outside to the Tarpeian Rock, with Lucius Sergius Catilina at their front. They came, he was thrown, they returned to the Senate.

Pms, please.

shlin28
08-28-2007, 23:22
:clown: We lynched Catilin! :cheerleader:

Andres
08-28-2007, 23:25
Good job townies :2thumbsup:

Csargo
08-28-2007, 23:26
Damn. Lynched for no good reason.

Andres
08-28-2007, 23:30
Damn. Lynched for no good reason.

That'll teach you, killing me so soon in the game.

Muhahahaha, welcome in Hell, Mister Catilina :devil:

Ready to be tortured...?

Csargo
08-28-2007, 23:44
That'll teach you, killing me so soon in the game.

Muhahahaha, welcome in Hell, Mister Catilina :devil:

Ready to be tortured...?

:surrender2: :scared: :creep:

CountArach
08-29-2007, 04:27
Woo!

Warmaster Horus
08-29-2007, 23:11
Twilightblade died. He was found in the same state as the other two dead. However, there was one essential difference: his head and hands were cut off, and found pinned to the Senate doors.

Begin voting. You have 24 hours.

shlin28
08-29-2007, 23:17
Sounds like Cicero, when he died his hands were cut off too :yes:

Csargo
08-29-2007, 23:21
Sweet.

Andres
08-30-2007, 09:30
Still alive:

Ignoramus
Shlin28
Tiberius of the Drake
Sarathos
Roadkill
CountArach

Twilightblade
08-30-2007, 09:37
Why could I not have been turned into a human pin cushen by arrows or something? Romans and their knives and squewers

Andres
08-30-2007, 10:39
Why aren't you living guys talking and voting?

Beefy187
08-30-2007, 11:03
if u lynch caesar or cato this turn lemme know..
Ill come laugh:beam:

shlin28
08-30-2007, 12:40
Cato was killed I think.

Warmaster Horus
08-30-2007, 13:47
You have 10 hours left, guys. If there aren't any votes, it'll be a random lynch.

As a guy I knew once said: "Fear the Random!"

Andres
08-30-2007, 13:53
Come on guys. We don't want a random lynch. Why not lynching Ignoramus because a) what I said before b) Ichigo was very eager to defend him :inquisitive:

It's a better choice then a random lynch...

woad&fangs
08-30-2007, 14:12
Lynch Ignoramus:birthday2:

Ignoramus
08-30-2007, 14:27
You want to lynch me because I post frequently? What's with that? It's far better to "lurch" when you're the mafia, because that way estute people can't discern your guilt.

Ichigo was silly in that all he did was unnatural. You could easily pick his guilt. But people like Count Arach, RoadKill, and shlin28, all haven't been posting much at all, because it's much easier to mask your identity if you're silent.

I enjoy being part of the town; it gives you a chance to study people's posts and work out who the mafia are. For this reason, when I get suspicions, I post them. If townies don't present their evidence, then they'll eventually get picked off by the mafia and the rest of the town, or in this case the Senate, will be none the wiser.

I'm voting CountArach, due to the fact that he basically hasn't participated at all, and is thus a prime candidate for the "absent mafioso".

Ignoramus
08-30-2007, 14:27
Opps, I almost forgot this:

Vote: CountArach

Andres
08-30-2007, 14:30
You want to lynch me because I post frequently? What's with that? It's far better to "lurch" when you're the mafia, because that way estute people can't discern your guilt.

Not because you post frequently. But now that you mention it, you are usually a lurker. When you get the role of townie that is :inquisitive:

Anyway, it's the neutrality in your posts that strikes me.


Count Arach, RoadKill, and shlin28, all haven't been posting much at all, because it's much easier to mask your identity if you're silent.

Diverting attention, are we?


I enjoy being part of the town; it gives you a chance to study people's posts and work out who the mafia are. For this reason, when I get suspicions, I post them.

This contradicts your attitude in previous games, when townie.

woad&fangs
08-30-2007, 14:35
Gah, the only guy that votes is a mafioso.

shlin28
08-30-2007, 14:58
Vote: Ignoramus :beam:

Andres
08-30-2007, 21:08
Come on guys! Vote Ignoramus :whip:

Warmaster Horus
08-30-2007, 21:48
1 hour and 15 minutes left. Tie between Ignoramus and Count Arach.

Vote!!! :whip: :whip: :whip:

Tiberius of the Drake
08-30-2007, 22:25
Vote:Ignoramus

Warmaster Horus
08-30-2007, 23:03
Since I won't be able to post a write up until tomorrow, I'll leave it open. Midday (12hours) will probably the maximum.

Sarathos
08-30-2007, 23:26
Vote: Ignoramus

RoadKill
08-31-2007, 04:24
I already posted my reasoning on Ichigo an Ignormous so Vote:Ignormous

Twilightblade
08-31-2007, 05:05
Tally
Ignoramus 5 (CA, shlin, TotD, Sarathos, Roadkill)

Overkill much?

CountArach
08-31-2007, 06:30
Ichigo was silly in that all he did was unnatural. You could easily pick his guilt. But people like Count Arach, RoadKill, and shlin28, all haven't been posting much at all, because it's much easier to mask your identity if you're silent.

I'm voting CountArach, due to the fact that he basically hasn't participated at all, and is thus a prime candidate for the "absent mafioso".
Wow, You mean apart from lynching Ichigo, a confirmed scum. I must be a really bad mafia then... :rolleyes:

Csargo
08-31-2007, 06:31
What a horrible partner you are CA. Gah Geez YOU'LL NEVER WORK IN THIS TOWN AGAIN!!!

Ignoramus
08-31-2007, 09:03
I don't like revealing this, but it's either that or getting lynched.

I am Gaius Antonius Hybrida. I can investigate a senator each night to determine their guilt or innocence with a 50% chance of success. I also have a 50% chance of surviving a murder attempt by the conspirators.

First investigation - Tiberius of the Drake - Investigation failed
Second investigation - Shlin28 - Innocent
Third investigation - CountArach - Investigation failed
Fourth investigation - Roadkill -Innocent

Now you may understand why I tried to be neutral. I didn't want to tip the conspirators off, but I've been forced to reveal my identity to try and talk sense into you.

Andres
08-31-2007, 09:28
Ok, this seems like a genuine reveal to me.

So,

Ignoramus (confirmed innocent)
Shlin28 (confirmed innocent)
Tiberius of the Drake
Sarathos
Roadkill confirmed innocent
CountArach

This leaves us with three suspects: CA, Sarathos and Tiberius.

CA seems like a good choice for now. Come on guys, switch your votes to any of these three suspects :whip:

shlin28
08-31-2007, 10:32
Unvote, Vote CA

Twilightblade
08-31-2007, 12:53
Tally
Ignoramus 4 (CA, TotD, Sarathos, Roadkill)
CA 1 (shlin)

If your gonna change do it fast

Sarathos
08-31-2007, 13:48
Probably a good bandwagon here, itf there is such a thing....

Unvote, Vote CA

woad&fangs
08-31-2007, 14:08
CA seems like a good lynch choice but if it turns out he is not the mafioso then I feel that Tib is guiltier than Sarathos.

Ignoramus
08-31-2007, 14:33
Tally
Ignoramus 4 (CA, TotD, Sarathos, Roadkill)
CA 1 (shlin)

If your gonna change do it fast

You forgot my vote.

Tally
Ignoramus 3 (CA, TotD, Roadkill)
CA 3 (shlin, Ignoramus, Sarathos)

RoadKill
08-31-2007, 15:58
IGNORMOUS YOU FAKE! I'm the detective you liar. Am I allowe to show my role?

RoadKill
08-31-2007, 16:00
Oh damn, I think I just scrweed myself over, I forgot I deleted everything for battle Royale. :furious3: Give me one night and I can 100% prove that I am the detective, lynch ignourmous, hes a liar, unless there is two detectives.

Edit - There is only a 25% of sucess for discovery of a player, while he says there is 50%

Edit - Okay, maybe i took it too seriously, as I reveiwed over the game and Ignormous just might be another detective. so unvote: Ignormous

Andres
08-31-2007, 16:02
Ignoramus is obviously the detective.

RoadKill
08-31-2007, 16:04
oh..... sorry didn't notice that but I still don't beleive Ignormous, why would there be two detectives. When there could be one detective and one doctor.

Andres
08-31-2007, 16:05
Yeah, I'm pretty confident CA is mafia.

shlin28
08-31-2007, 16:16
Two detectives????? Who should I trust...

Tiberius of the Drake
08-31-2007, 21:03
Ignoramus's evidence is good enough for me.

Unvote, Vote:CA

CountArach
08-31-2007, 21:53
Alright then, while we are in the business of Role reveals:

I am Marcus Tullius Cicero, one of the two consuls. It specifically said that I shared the Consulship with Gaius Antonius Hybrida.

This means I am a detective (Good guess with the role there Ignoramus)

So far, my investigations have been:

Andres - Quintus Hortensius Hortalus
Ichigo - Lucius Sergius Catilina
Ignoramus - Publius Cornelius Lentulus Sura

Now with a bit of help from Wiki:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publius_Cornelius_Lentulus_%28Sura%29


Publius Cornelius Lentulus, nicknamed Sura, (d. December 5, 63 BC) was one of the chief figures in the Catiline conspiracy.

In 70, being expelled from the senate with a number of others for immorality, he joined Catiline.

So yeah, Ignoramus is mafia.

Vote: Ignoramus

Andres
08-31-2007, 21:59
I also have a 50% chance of surviving a murder attempt by the conspirators.

How could I miss this part :wall:

Gah!

Lynch Ignoramus !

Csargo
08-31-2007, 22:00
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/member.php?u=2667 Someone has stolen my identity. :furious3:

Tiberius of the Drake
08-31-2007, 22:08
while were revealing roles...
I am Lucius Licinius Lucullus which, if you read up on it, means I am not Mafia.

The whole two "detectives" accusing each other is a little suspicious and it would be risky to vote at the moment with another member caliming to also be detecttive.. therefore i cahnge my vote.

Unvote,Abstain

@Roadkill: can you prove that your detective?

shlin28
08-31-2007, 22:14
Three detectives??? Better trust CA... Unvote, Vote Ignoramus

And I am Crassus, the richest Roman ever!!! :laugh4:

Andres
08-31-2007, 22:15
while were revealing roles...
I am Lucius Licinius Lucullus which, if you read up on it, means I am not Mafia.

The whole two "detectives" accusing each other is a little suspicious and it would be risky to vote at the moment with another member caliming to also be detecttive.. therefore i cahnge my vote.

Unvote,Abstain

@Roadkill: can you prove that your detective?

Meh, we can lynch them both...

shlin28
08-31-2007, 22:25
while were revealing roles...
I am Lucius Licinius Lucullus which, if you read up on it, means I am not Mafia.

The whole two "detectives" accusing each other is a little suspicious and it would be risky to vote at the moment with another member caliming to also be detecttive.. therefore i cahnge my vote.

Unvote,Abstain

@Roadkill: can you prove that your detective?

Why do you want to abstain? There are only 6 people left, we have to lynch someone, on the tiniest chance of them being mafia!!!

CountArach
08-31-2007, 22:31
Yeah Tiberius, time is running out. We need to lynch Ignoramus now.

If I die, at least take him down the next day phase.

shlin28
08-31-2007, 22:33
Tally
Ignoramus 3 (CA, shlin, Roadkill)
CA 2 (Ignoramus, Sarathos)
Abstain 1 (Tiberius)

Warmaster Horus
08-31-2007, 23:43
Eh, I don't see what else could change the fate of this game...

Ignoramus has been lynched.

It was raining. Worse, it was a very great storm.
The party set out once more, one last time to the Tarpeian Rock. There, they put Ignoramus, or Publius Cornelius Lentulus Sura at the edge. The ground obviously was wet and slippery, making it difficult for Cicero (CA) and Hibrida (Roadkill) to hold Sura. The group waited for something to happen, as they were convinced of the soon-to-be-dead man's guilt. They waited for someone to say something, and that's what happened. A voice bellowed from the skies above:
"Well!"
Unfortunately, this came as such a surprise to the assembled men that they jumped. Sura slipped, and fell to his death. The voice said:
"Well, I didn't think that would happen... I was going to say something like 'You've decided, now throw him off' or ... 'Another day, another dead man...' But no! It was not to be... Tsk, tsk, tsk. Oh, well!
"I can tell you this: you have chosen well. The conspiracy that threatened your Republic is over, and you are safe. I congratulate you, although you were almost doomed. Now, go back to your usual businesses.
"And so ends the day's work..."


Finished! As you will have realized, Ignoramus was guilty. And, THE TOWN WON!!!
Here's the list of roles.
The town: (no night actions, just townies)
Marcus Porcius Cato:woad&fangs
Gaius Julius Caesar:Twilightblade
Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus:Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca
Marcus Licinius Crassus:Shlin28
Lucius Licinius Lucullus: Tiberius of the Drake
Quintus Hortensius Hortalus:Andres
Titus Annius Milo:Sarathos
Publius Clodius Pulcher:pevergreen

The Consuls: (detectives' equivalent)
Marcus Tullius Cicero:CountArach
Antionius Hybrida:Roadkill

The Conspirators: (mafiosi equivalent)
Lucius Sergius Catilina:Ichigo
Publius Cornelius Lentulus Sura:Ignoramus

Roles were chosen at random, just to reassure you. I think I'd have changed Ichigo, because of his notoriety. He was sure to be a target of the detectives.

Speaking of those, I know you'll say that was slightly unfair, but there were peculiarities: CA was sure to receive 100% correct answers, but Roadkill had 25% of not succeeding, and if it worked, only 50% of getting it right. I thought it would even the odds, a bit.

I think that's it. Questions, feel free to go.

Csargo
08-31-2007, 23:49
So I won right?

Warmaster Horus
08-31-2007, 23:51
Gah? No. I do believe you were lynched.

Csargo
08-31-2007, 23:56
Gah? No. I do believe you were lynched.

Nah. I can't die.

Caius
09-01-2007, 00:19
Wiki killed the game.

CountArach
09-01-2007, 01:51
Yeah, it really did, but ti was the only way the townies could win. Sorry Warmaster.

Sarathos
09-01-2007, 02:05
Yeah Town Won!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My First Finised Game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

RoadKill
09-01-2007, 06:00
ANDRES, I TOLD YOU SO!!

He was obviously lying when he said about the 50% thing, when I was the detective myself and I only had 25% of success

Edit - Don't ban me Andres

Warmaster Horus
09-01-2007, 10:17
Sorry Warmaster.

No problem. I actually expected you guys to check it out.

Andres
09-01-2007, 10:52
Edit - Don't ban me Andres

:devil:

~;)

Well, we all make mistakes... Anyway, it didn't matter really, if Ignoramus would have survived the next night, he would have been lynched anyway.

Nice fake reveal btw, Ignoramus :bow:

And thnx for hosting this one Warmaster :bow:

Ignoramus
09-01-2007, 11:38
I actually thought Twilightblade was the detective, and I didn't know that there were two detectives, due to the fact Warmaster's first post indicated that there'd only be one.

If CA had been lynched, then I would have killed one of my "confirmed" innocents, hoping to explain it away with the fact the mafia wouldn't want to risk their attack on me failing.

Twilightblade
09-02-2007, 02:32
Me a detective? Nah I've only ever been a cop or night watchmen

Edit: I don't think that I'm important/lucky enough to be a detective