Nameless small mafia [Concluded]

[sapi]

I figure that I might as well open this thread while I sort out the back-story and exact setup of the game ~:)

I'd like 12 players, please.

More details will come in time :grin2:

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

In!

[Sarathos]

Second!

[FactionHeir]

:gah:

[pevergreen]

:bow:

[shlin28]

In!

[Caius]

Why not?

[Beefy187]

Im surprised that theres still spot left for me

Count me in :2thumbsup:

[Ignoramus]

In.

[Warmaster Horus]

In.

[Andres]

In.

[Tratorix]

in.

[Northnovas]

Sign me up to make a the dirty dozen.

[sapi]

And then there were 12.

PMs will go out tonight, the first day phase will start in a few hours time (because if I start it now, I can't keep it to 24 hours thanks to rl commitments) ~:)

[sapi]

Role PMs have been sent, and all players should have received them.

It is now the first day phase, which will last roughly 24 hours.

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Vote: Northnovas

For being new.

[Andres]

Vote : Northnovas

To start an unreasonable, absurd bandwagon against a new player :devil:

[FactionHeir]

vote: Omanes

For being so inconsiderate against a new player and thus out of character to his usual behavior.

[Andres]

vote: Omanes

For being so inconsiderate against a new player and thus out of character to his usual behavior.

And how exactly is Omanes acting out of character?

[FactionHeir]

Omanes is the welcoming kind to new players and helps them get along rather than ruthlessly voting for them.

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Omanes is the welcoming kind to new players and helps them get along rather than ruthlessly voting for them.I am helping them get along. Removing them from play, henceforth saving them from the terrorisation which other players inflict late on in the game.

[FactionHeir]

Bad excuse. Try again. :tongue2:

[Warmaster Horus]

Vote:Andres
For trying to help a bandwagon get started. He even says it himself.

[Northnovas]

D'uoh! for being new. I would like to abstain the first round but since there are only a limited number of people and finding some logic I would have to vote for the person with the highest post count; caused most likely from jumping on bandwagons.

Vote:Andres

[shlin28]

Vote FactionHeir

For picking at a (in my opinion) pointless point

[Vuk]

Please update the title. :bow:

[Beefy187]

Vote: Vuk

For requesting update on the title :laugh4:

[pevergreen]

Vote: Beefy

As if you went home!

[Beefy187]

Unvote Vote: Pever

Sif i would stay.. I failed my test btw :laugh4:

Ill do better next year.. I promise :sweatdrop:

[Ignoramus]

Vote: Beefy

For failing his test.

[sapi]

Northnovas - 2 (Omanes, Andres)
Omanes - 1 (FH)
Andres - 2 (Horus, Northnovas)
FH - 1 (shlin)
Beefy - 2 (pever, ignoramus)
Pever - 1 (beefy)

There is a three-way tie, between Northnovas, Andres, and Beefy.

The next vote will lynch.

You may only vote for one of these three people.

[Killfr3nzy]

Vote:Northnovas.

[sapi]

Northnovas has been lynched.

It is now the night phase, all orders to me, please ~:)

[Andres]

Vote:Northnovas.

Why? Explain! :whip:

[Northnovas]

Why? Explain! :whip:

I think it was revenge :skull:

https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1668507&postcount=311:grin:

[Sarathos]

Hi guys, sorry for being inactive, exams and such. Looks like I missed this voting round but I will be in for the next one :2thumbsup:

[Beefy187]

Pfft.. Lurker... :laugh4:

Welcome back Sarathos

[Killfr3nzy]

I say we vote Sarathos next, for lurking.

[Andres]

I say we vote Sarathos next, for lurking.

I say you are deliberately ignoring my question: Why did you vote Northnovas? Give us an explanation please.

[Killfr3nzy]

He seemed to be voting in tandem with Warmaster, and because I'm assuming there's two mafia and WH wasn't on the list, my vote went North.

[sapi]

Night phase extended, as some people can't seem to get their orders in on time.

If anyone has late orders twice during the game, they will be WoGged :bow:

[Caius]

I'm sorry I'm not that active, I'll try to be active from now.

[FactionHeir]

I'm sorry I'm not that active, I'll try to be active from now.

That means Caius has a role.

[Caius]

That means Caius has a role.
Nah, I'm just a plain townie. Why do you think that?

[Killfr3nzy]

Because only people with roles have to send in orders, and you seemed to be apologising to sapi for sending them in late.

[Warmaster Horus]

Erm, actually...

Night phase extended, as some people can't seem to get their orders in on time.

If anyone has late orders twice during the game, they will be WoGged

I'm sorry I'm not that active, I'll try to be active from now.
The first said someone didn't send their orders. The second said he wasn't that active. The two things may be related, but then again, one doesn't mean the other.
To me, he seemed to be apologising to US, the players, for not participating. You will notice, of course, he wasn't voting last round. Which explains his apologies.

[FactionHeir]

Or you are mafia and covering your buddy.

[sapi]

Sarathos died in the night ~:)

24 hour day phase starts now.

All players, except Sarathos and Northnovas, are alive.

[FactionHeir]

sapi, can you post a list of roles?
Like number of mafia, number of pro-town roles etc.

[Andres]

Vote : Ignoramus

Where you the one who wasn't able to get in his orders in time?

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

I'm a little weary over voting on who didn't send in their orders. Although on that regard Ignoramus is possibly the best option, there is a possible chance that he may have a much more "honest" role than one would expect.

Anyhow, for now, I will:

Vote: FactionHeir

In my opinion, I consider his actions over Garci's apology (see here (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?p=1753910#post1753910)) rather over the top. Any sensible mafioso would avoid such a mistake, and I don't think that Garci' is the type to trick us through WIFOM arguments.

[FactionHeir]

That's quite a poor reason to vote me on Day 2. Because I said someone else was suspicious?

FoS: Omanes

[Caius]

Are you hiding something FH? Somehow I can't trust in you.

[Andres]

Are you hiding something FH? Somehow I can't trust in you.

Well, eh, off course you can't trust him. We are playing mafia.

Any particular reason why you distrust him more then the other players? And if you are suspicious about him, then why didn't you vote him?

If you are able to provide good reasoning, it won't be seen as retaliation. So, what's keeping you?

And we need more discussion. pevergreen, shlin28, Vuk, Beefy,... Why are you guys so silent?

[Caius]

I think FH is like a computer Backdoor(not Backroom :P) He waits for a mistake to lead him to be lynched.

Vote:FH

Talk, :whip:

[Ignoramus]

Vote: Warmaster Horus
Why would he defend Garsci? He doens't know if he's a villager or not.

[Beefy187]

Who actually kills Sarathos?? He was being suspecious...:sweatdrop:

[pevergreen]

Inactive = end of year exams for our group.

We all have our last exam today (beefy has finished)

So after today, i am active!

[FactionHeir]

Vote: Caius

Not a retaliation vote, but voting him for evading my question and now asking me to talk without providing any ground of evidence or answering the question I asked first.

[Beefy187]

Oh no pever. Some of the peoples have their exams next week

If I was the host I would want the mafia to win so he can get the most fun out of it. So I wouldnt wait for night orders for the people with honest roles. I got the feeling that Ignoramus is the one we are after since I havnt seen him play for a while and therefore dont know how easy Sarathos gets him self lynched...

Also... Thats for voting me for failing my exam :sweatdrop: Ill try harder next year (Which also means Ill be on the Org less often...:no: )

Vote: Ignoramus

[Killfr3nzy]

Damnit, someone night-killed my target.
I say we lynch pever, because if he is mafia, then I'm not going to give him the satisfaction of winning.

[Beefy187]

Ill laugh if Pever dies tonight:laugh4:

There would be huge "Kill Killfr3nzy!!" Bandwagon

[Killfr3nzy]

Yeah, but it'd be like the Finger of Auto-Lynch v2.0 - Night Edition.
Also I have an awsome ace up my sleave which would get everyone to unvote me.

[sapi]

sapi, can you post a list of roles?
Like number of mafia, number of pro-town roles etc.
:no:

:grin2:

:bow:

[Beefy187]

Will it be on the first post?

[Killfr3nzy]

It's kind of hard when we don't know what roles there are, and there are no hints in the lynches or night kills......
Begin the random lynchings!

Well, uh, continue the random lynchings!

[sapi]

It's kind of hard when we don't know what roles there are, and there are no hints in the lynches or night kills......It's that way for a reason; I'm interested in seeing the gang mentality that develops ~:)

Lord of the Files, anyone? :grin2:

[Beefy187]

I never got it why that guy got killed... and eaten (right?) :juggle2:

[Killfr3nzy]

Piggy got squashed, that wierd-ass kid got beaten to death (or something similar) but I don't think they ate anyone.
But then, I wasn't paying attention in English, so I dunno.
Dibs being Jack (please be the conch-shell guy).

[Beefy187]

I swear someone got eaten..

Dibs killing Jack (and changing the whole plot..) :laugh4:

[Warmaster Horus]

Vote:Killfrenzy
What would that ace be, exactly? Some role you have? Detective maybe? But, if so... Your target someone night-killed... You would have gotten the information anyway.
Somethings don't add up.
Or maybe your ace is a mafia buddy who'll kill the one who denounces you? Please, explain.

[Killfr3nzy]

Why? You seem the most scummy player to me so far, perhaps you are North's partner? Revealing now as detective would be quite a stupid move, unless I had found a mafioso for certain.

I agree, something doesn't add up...

Detective maybe? But, if so... Your target someone night-killed... You would have gotten the information anyway.
Not quite sure what this means. No-one who's died yet has had thier role revealed, not even hints of thier role.
Please tell me if you meant something else by this.

Vote:WH.

[Warmaster Horus]

What I meant was that if you were a detective, and you sent your orders investigating...Sarathos. You would have received info about him, as in whether he's guilty or not.

Oh, by the way, I should mention I am the detective. I investigated Killfrenzy last night, because his reason:
He seemed to be voting in tandem with Warmaster, and because I'm assuming there's two mafia and WH wasn't on the list, my vote went North.
seemed... odd, to me. Because of this, I resolved to investigate him. Yes, I'm the one sapi was waiting for. Sorry again!
Anyway, lynch KF. He's a mafioso. And if there's a Doctor out there... Save me tonight!
As for proof... Well, I'm most certainly dead tonight (unless Doc's ready to save me), and... I presume I'm not allowed to quote PMs?

[FactionHeir]

I'm somewhat doubtful of your reveal, but given that there was only 1 kill last night (unless one of the mafia still didn't get their orders in after extension), if we lynch KF now and the game doesn't end, we can lynch WH next turn.

unvote: Caius vote: KF

[Warmaster Horus]

Mate, we're in a small game. 2 kills per night+1 lynch severely reduces the town's chances. Oh, by the way, there are probably 2 mafiosi, in other words, lynching me next turn wouldn't help. But, we'll see.

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Warmaster Horus' reveal is questionable. I, for one, dislike it. Why reveal this early on and risk a death now? Surely a normal detective would prefer to remain anonymous till he had a large assortment of information rather than one little nugget.

So Warmaster Horus, any reason for this potentially fatal choice? Why now, and not nearer the game's conclusion?

[Warmaster Horus]

A mafioso is a little nugget? Well, what happened to the good old "a detective for a mafioso"? Also, I remember a small mafia where there was 1 mafioso. Maybe it's the case here... I don't know. It's unlikely, true, but...
Anyway, why not look at him? His stuff was WIFOM, clearly.

[Tratorix]

Eh, Wh's reveal does seem a bit convient, but i'll bite. Vote:KF
I doubt he would really claim detective this early to escape a lynching.

By the way, sorry for missing the first round.

[shlin28]

Sorry for missing this round...

Vote KF

As others have said...

I say we let the doctor protect WH, and, if there is another real one, let the detective investigate him too.

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

A mafioso is a little nugget?In a way, yes. It probably would be wiser, and less suspitious, to reveal the truth after both mafiosos, presuming that there are two, have been uncovered. Regardless, I am inclined to believe you:

Unvote: FactionHeir
Vote: Killr3nzy
I say we let the doctor protect WH, and, if there is another real one, let the detective investigate him too.The only problem is that we don't actually know if there really is a doctor or not. sapi hasn't mentioned the idea publicly, so there's no real way of finding out the truth.

[pevergreen]

Im always happy to lynch KF

Vote: KF

[Beefy187]

Sorry Jack... The bandwaggon came a round early lol:laugh4:

Unvote: Vote: KF

[Killfr3nzy]

Oh man, I'm cracking up here. You'll be kicking yourselves post-game.
Just a sec, I gotta go get my awesome ace, as I promised you all.
Drumroll, drumroll please. Thank you.
I'm reaching up my sleeve, here comes the best reason ever for not voting me......

https://img77.imageshack.us/img77/5840/acefe1.th.gif (https://img77.imageshack.us/my.php?image=acefe1.gif)

What cracks me up the most is that I've worked out who the mafia is, and I'm not gonna tell you guys. No town victory for you. :whip:

Cya post-game.
/wave

[Beefy187]

His bluffing.. Lynch him already:whip:

[Tratorix]

What cracks me up the most is that I've worked out who the mafia is, and I'm not gonna tell you guys. No town victory for you.

Your not gonna tell us cause then we'd definitely lynch you, and we'd know your partner, scum. :yes:

[Killfr3nzy]

Yes, because obviously if I'm mafia, and going down, I'd then name my partner.
Everyone, try not to make statements that will make you look stupid later (at least within this game), cause you might feel bad afterwards.

Note; This isn't an attempt at a ploy. No-one unvote me unless you suddenly decide someone looks guiltier than me. Here, I'll help you guys.
Vote:Killfr3nzy.

*Looks towards the sky, points upwards*
"I'm coming for you, God."

[Ignoramus]

Vote: KF

[Killfr3nzy]

You know, if everyone votes for me, I can ninja the title from Ichigo.
At least I think it was Ichigo in Motep's game, he was the mafia Spy?

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Killr3nzy's actions are changing my view slightly. His speech sounds like that of a frutrated innocent, rather than that of a typical dying mafioso. He isn't making excuses, and he also isn't trying to move the suspition upon somebody else.

Unvote: Killr3nzy; Vote: Warmaster Horus

So then Warmaster Horus, how do you explain these actions? More to the point, why are you trusting in your supposed investigative results - do you know if they are 100% accurate?

[sapi]

KF has been lynched.

Orders, please :bow:

[FactionHeir]

Hmmm the game continues. WH is next.

[Warmaster Horus]

2 mafiosi. 1 kill per night. Simple as that.

1 down, 1 to go.

[FactionHeir]

I don't remember a mafia game ever where there were two mafia and only one kill per night.

[Warmaster Horus]

There will be 2 Mafiosi/spies and 10 townies/soldiers.
Every night the mafia can kill one person.

*cough* My small mafia had 1 kill per night too, unless I'm much mistaken. Those are only two examples.

[Killfr3nzy]

*cough* WH is hugely scummy-looking, as I can tell you that without a doubt I cannot have been mafia. That would also fit with my previous theory of him and North being mafia.
But hey, I'm obviously guilty, don't let me play mind games with yas. Good luck guys.

[Warmaster Horus]

Scummy looking - why? Because I revealed early? Because I delivered a mafioso who uses retaliation votes? Please, explain.

[Northnovas]

*cough* WH is hugely scummy-looking, as I can tell you that without a doubt I cannot have been mafia. That would also fit with my previous theory of him and North being mafia.
But hey, I'm obviously guilty, don't let me play mind games with yas. Good luck guys.

I am innocent, I tells ya. You got it all wrong!
I have never had 'relations' with that .............:inquisitive:

[Andres]

Why would Warmaster's reveal not be genuine?

I for one am not going to do the mafia's job by lynching the detective the next day phase.

Off course, all this suspicion about Warmaster Horus makes it a difficult decision for the mafia: "will we kill him or will we hope for his lynching the next day?" :juggle:

It must be tough being mafia now...

What's it going to be boys?

But in the end, it won't matter, since all you dirty scumbags will get lynched eventually :devil:

[FactionHeir]

Are you saying us townies will all get lynched so you mafia will win or the other way around? Your words are very ambiguous....

Btw, change the title, will ya.

[Andres]

Are you saying us townies will all get lynched so you mafia will win or the other way around? Your words are very ambiguous....

I wasn't aware you were a townie... :inquisitive:

Are you one? Why are you so eager in getting the detective lynched?

Besides, KF's behaviour has been suspicious. Remember his vote for Northnovas round 1? He broke the tie without giving any reason and without letting the town use the opportunity to have more discussion.


Btw, change the title, will ya.

Your wish is my command :bow:

[Warmaster Horus]

Besides, KF's behaviour has been suspicious. Remember his vote for Northnovas round 1? He broke the tie without giving any reason and without letting the town use the opportunity to have more discussion.
Which is why I investigated him. I'll give you next night's results when/if I get them.

[FactionHeir]

Investigate me, will ya. Andres is bugging me :grin:

[Warmaster Horus]

I am. I am.

[shlin28]

I hope we will get a report on your investigation tomorrow? :inquisitive:

[sapi]

Warmaster Horus and Omanes were found dead.

It is now the day phase.

[Killfr3nzy]

And now, a personal message to the mafioso;
Very, very stupid move. Very. :no:

The rest of you;
Carry on.:2thumbsup:

[FactionHeir]

2 kills.
That means 1 from a mafioso and 1 from a serial killer role which only kills once every 2 nights.

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

Not necessarily - one of those deaths could have been a vigilante's kill.

[Warmaster Horus]

I found Factionheir guilty.

[FactionHeir]

That proves that WH wasn't a detective, but a secret role or someone trying to get people randomly lynched according to his whims. I'm just as much mafia as KF was.

[Warmaster Horus]

I'm just as much mafia as KF was.
Which means he is. Lynch FH.

[FactionHeir]

Would be quite stupid of a mafioso to publically question the revealing "detective" and then ask him to investigate, no?

[Warmaster Horus]

Perhaps you hoped killing me would stop me getting results?

[FactionHeir]

Perhaps you hoped killing me would stop me getting results?


Vote:Killfrenzy
What would that ace be, exactly? Some role you have? Detective maybe? But, if so... Your target someone night-killed... You would have gotten the information anyway.
Somethings don't add up.
Or maybe your ace is a mafia buddy who'll kill the one who denounces you? Please, explain.

That makes a lot of sense of course....not.:saint:

[Warmaster Horus]

Well, what can I say? I received a guilty for both you and KF.

[shlin28]

Vote FactionHeir

I trust WH

[pevergreen]

Triple Claim of detective.

Lynch them all.

Vote: Factionheir

[Andres]

Vote : FactionHeir

[Caius]

Vote:FH

[Beefy187]

Bah what the hell...

Vote: FH

[Tratorix]

Vote: FH

[Killfr3nzy]

Pever, only WH has actually claimed to be Detective...just so you know.

[Omanes Alexandrapolites]

In my honest opinion, I believe that Warmaster Horus isn't quite what he seems. Thats why I, a pro-townie, killed him last night - I assure you that he wasn't removed by a mafioso.

Doesn't it just seem very peculiar that he gets two guilty results in a row and in the first two rounds? What about Killfr3nzy and his innocent sounding final words? This adds up to provide a very guilty view of our so called "detective".

Of course there is an excuse, he could have been an "Insane Detective", in other words he gets guilty results for innocent people, and gains innocent results for guilty individuals. This is without his knowlage. If this is the case, then we quite simply should consider FactionHeir and Killfr3nzy innocent.

[Killfr3nzy]

I like this one.
Of course, he could still be mafia.

[Sarathos]

Sorry guys

Umm I think its pretty obvious, Vote: FH
You cant all be the detective

[FactionHeir]

Err when exactly did I claim to be the detective, please?

[sapi]

FactionHeir has been executed, to popular acclaim.

It is now the night phase.

Orders, please.

[Warmaster Horus]

So, Omanes, you're saying you killed me because my reveal was scummy? What was scummy in it?

I like your theory of "Insane Detective", though. Seems logical since the game continues.
Sorry guys, but I just relayed the info I got.

[shlin28]

Hmm... two potential pro-town roles dead, 7 people remaining, one/two mafia left...

My suspects:

Andres- seems innocent enough, apart from his "greeniness"
Sarathos- said too little
BSR- said too little
Beefy- said too little
Garci- said too little
Pever- said too little
Shlin28- said more than normal

Not much activities here is there? I say we lynch one of the lurkers :laugh4:

[FactionHeir]

I think pever seems more suspicious of the bunch.

[Ignoramus]

Vote: FH

[shlin28]

There are 13 people in this game???

Ignoramus- said too little and voted too late

[Beefy187]

I thought Sarathos died...

As my defence theres not much I can say when I say one thing and then no one replies for 12 hours... :wall:

I think the deadly plague is here in the gameroom.. No one is speaking up like they used to do...

[FactionHeir]

Yeah, (almost) everyone just listening to Horus when voting too without making a comment :inquisitive:

[pevergreen]

*wakes up*
*sees nothing has happened*
*goes back to sleep*
*wakes up*
*slaps sapi*
*goes back to sleep*

[Beefy187]

Its not Sapis fault.. I just think the whole gameroom is having a nap recently.. Thus why the mafias are getting easy victories..

Cmon townies!! Wakeup!! :whip:

[Sarathos]

Im not dead :angry:

[Beefy187]

Sarathos died in the night ~:)

24 hour day phase starts now.

All players, except Sarathos and Northnovas, are alive.


You are :sweatdrop:

Andres- seems innocent enough, apart from his "greeniness"
BSR- said too little
Beefy- said too little
Garci- said too little
Pever- said too little
Shlin28- said more than normal
Ignoramus- said too little and voted too late

So thats the list of live players according to Shlin

[Warmaster Horus]

Yeah, (almost) everyone just listening to Horus when voting too without making a comment
I've already apologised! I got a result, I shared it with the others, what else can I say?

[Killfr3nzy]

Apologise some more?

Still not gonna tell you who the mafia is, btw. That's right; lynch me I get petulant.
Stick it. :laugh4:

[sapi]

Andres was found dead in the night.

-----
Omanes (N2)
Sarathos (N1)
FactionHeir (D3)
pevergreen
shlin
Killerfrenzy (D2)
Caius
Beefy
Ignoramus
Warmaster Horus (N2)
Andres (N3)
Brave Sir Robin
Northnovas (D1)

[Beefy187]

So assume that WH was right. We lynched 2 mafias. We still have kills.. So either theres was a serial killer role (2 mafias plus Omanes having ability to kill...and serial killer?) or WH was actually wrong..

Anyway I will

Vote: Ignoramus

For inactivity

[FactionHeir]

Guys, I think its pever.

[Andres]

Dead. Again.

:bigcry:

[Killfr3nzy]

Happy as I would be to see pever lynched, .......

[Tratorix]

WEll, following WH's investigations didn't work out like i'd hoped... :sweatdrop:
I was hoping he was either the detectivev, or a mafioso claiming detective. Looks like he was neither. So, I have no clue who to vote for, so...

Vote:Beefy

[shlin28]

Happy as I would be to see pever lynched, .......

Why? I don't see why he's so suspicious...

Vote BSR, for saying the obvious and lurking previously

Ignoramus and BSR are currently the most suspicious ones, since they currently lurk the most.

[Warmaster Horus]

BSR, I was a detective, getting wrong results. Unless there are 3 mafiosi. In which case, I could've had correct results.

[shlin28]

I doubt it would be 3 mafias, that would be way too unbalanced.

[Tratorix]

Ignoramus and BSR are currently the most suspicious ones, since they currently lurk the most.

I don't see how i've been lurking that much(at least anymore than I usually do) but whatever.

[Andres]

Why? I don't see why he's so suspicious...

Vote BSR, for saying the obvious and lurking previously

Ignoramus and BSR are currently the most suspicious ones, since they currently lurk the most.

Lurking is suspicious indeed. But lurking is BSR's usual style. Ignoramus has a tendency of getting WoG'ed if he doesn't have a role.

But if we are going to vote people who are saying the obvious, then:


So assume that WH was right. We lynched 2 mafias. We still have kills.. So either theres was a serial killer role (2 mafias plus Omanes having ability to kill...and serial killer?) or WH was actually wrong..

Anyway I will

Vote: Ignoramus

For inactivity

...

[Beefy187]

Cmon I had to say that coz no one seems to be analyzing our current status..

Caius havnt posted for a while I think
Ignoramus has been avoiding WoG by posting once per round
BSR has enough activity to not get WoGed

Thats our 3 lurkers.

Now actives.

Pever havnt said much
Shlin said more then usual (I think his innocent)
Beefy :clown:

I dont really know Ignoramus so Andres is probebly right. However Tran and RK won some mafia games by lurking the way through. So overall I dont like the lurking idea. And thats why im voting for Ignoramus.

[Ignoramus]

I struggle to maintain interest in mafia games when I don't have a role and no one's acting suspicious. It's much harder in forum mafia to pick who's guilty and who's not.

[Beefy187]

Its much more intresting in Forum mafia coz theres logic and tactics involved in it. Where as in RL you just get bandwagon by all the players coz they dont like you..
(Eg.. Who ever Killfr3nzy votes get lynched in RL...)

I think its safe to say Ignoramus is innocent from what he said.

Caius is gone somewhere correct me if im wrong.

So for me its either BSR or Pever. Personally I find BSR slightly more suspecious then Pever
(Cough.. pever normally dies in earlier round so want to make him live.. cough.. )

Im not biased at all :sweatdrop:

Unvote: Ignoramus Vote: BSR

[shlin28]

Bah, too many lurkers.


I don't see how i've been lurking that much(at least anymore than I usually do) but whatever.
Well you do have the lowest amount of posts (when I checked yesterday).

If WH is the crazy detective, who's the real detective? :inquisitive: He could potentially help the town a lot.

[Beefy187]

Hey Shlin... Remember that time? Mafia game a while ago...

I asked everyone "who here is innocent" and you said "me:beam: "

We both got killed in the same night :smash:

But seriously... I want to hear something from Pever and Caius. If they have any useful info

[Caius]

Hey Shlin... Remember that time? Mafia game a while ago...

I asked everyone "who here is innocent" and you said "me:beam: "

We both got killed in the same night :smash:

But seriously... I want to hear something from Pever and Caius. If they have any useful info
I dont have too much to say here.

[Beefy187]

Pever?

[FactionHeir]

Can't we just all decide to vote one person rather than split votes all over the place? Vote pever! :)

[shlin28]

People seems to be obsessing bout Pever...

BANDWAGON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Unvote BSR, Vote Pevergreen

[Caius]

Vote:pever

[Beefy187]

Vote: Pever

You failed to be active.. Sorry mate..

[pevergreen]

Double Lynch.

Its Ig or BSR. Most Likely Ig.

Vote: Ignoramus

This is pretty much the order i would kill in, except andres would have died earlier and beefy would be dead.

[Tratorix]

Unvote: Beefy, Vote: pever :skull:

[Killfr3nzy]

You're all wrong, just so you know. The real mafia is sapi, and he's just conned you into thinking he's the host.
Ok, one of those two statements is a lie. Probably one.

[Beefy187]

Lemme gues... Your all wrong bit?

[Andres]

It seems to be a long day...

[FactionHeir]

*runs before Andres can lock him inside the thread*

[sapi]

It seems to be a long day...
Oh, :wall:

Sorry guys, the day is now over, and pever has been lynched.

Night orders to me please ~:)

[shlin28]

Hmmm... bandwagon on Pever? I have no idea I have so much influence amongst you guys :inquisitive: You never listen to me normally...

Caius, Beefy and BSR, to be lynched in that order.

[pevergreen]

Dam, as if you got me. :wall:

Dont lynch Beefy

[Killfr3nzy]

Is that an admission pever?
Looks like one.

[Beefy187]

Just out of intrest... Why dont you want to lynch me?

Do you think im valuable now?:laugh4:

[sapi]

Sorry about the delay; diarrhoea sucks ~:(

Ignoramus was found dead in the night.

-----
Omanes (N2)
Sarathos (N1)
FactionHeir (D3)
pevergreen (D4)
shlin
Killerfrenzy (D2)
Caius
Beefy
Ignoramus (N4)
Warmaster Horus (N2)
Andres (N3)
Brave Sir Robin
Northnovas (D1)

[Andres]

Caius and BSR need to talk :whip:

[Killfr3nzy]

I think it's been made rather obvious who the mafia are.

[shlin28]

THE GRAND REVEAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I'm the detective, BSR and Caius are innocent. Lynch Beefy!!!!!!!!!

Some might doubt the fact that I'm the real detective, but trust me if the town wants to win.


VOTE: BEEFY

Edit: Further proof of my detective-ness, I unvoted BSR the previous round because Sapi gave me a bonus investigation, and as soon as I found out BSR was innocent, I started the bandwagon on Pever :2thumbsup:

[Tratorix]

As much as I'd like to believe shlin's very timely reveal, something about it just doesn't sit right with me. But, I figure he's probably narrowed the field down to either himself, or Beefy. Going back over shlin's posts in the game, they seem very calculated to me. His usual style can be rather random(which often causes a lynch) but he doesn't seem to show any of that here. Furthermore, he constantly says we need lurkers to talk more, then simply jumps on the most convenient bandwagon. Except in the last round, where he seemed to be trying to start a bandwagon, first on me then on pever.


Edit: Further proof of my detective-ness, I unvoted BSR the previous round because Sapi gave me a bonus investigation, and as soon as I found out BSR was innocent, I started the bandwagon on Pever

I find this suspicious too. Why would the host try to swing the game in the town's favour like that? He wouldn't even give us a roles list before, now he's giving out bonus investigations?:inquisitive:

So, shlin, if your really the detective, give us a list of who you've investigated through the game(and the results of course).

Vote: Shlin
(subject to change if shlin gives an explanation I find reasonable.)

[shlin28]

I got a bonus investigation because I investigated Sarathos (a dead person) for my night order :embarassed:

N1- Andres, innocent
N2- WH, innocent
N3- Sarathos/BSR, innocent
N4- Caius,- innocent

[Warmaster Horus]

I can't believe you would investigate someone on night 3 when that person died on night 1. :inquisitive:

[shlin28]

I didnt realise Sarathos had died!!!

https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1758742&postcount=129

I thought he was still alive, as evident in that post, and he voted as well! so that confused me too... see https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1758292&postcount=125

[Beefy187]

Meh lynch me and you still got a chance left..

If the game doesnt end lynch Shlin

[Caius]

Vote:Beefy

[Killfr3nzy]

Vote:Beefy

[shlin28]

You are dead...

[sapi]

Beefy was lynched.
Townie victory!

Omanes (N2) Vigilante
Sarathos (N1)
FactionHeir (D3)
pevergreen (D4)
shlin Detective
Killerfrenzy (D2)
Caius
Beefy (D5) Mafia
Ignoramus (N4)
Warmaster Horus (N2) Insane Detective
Andres (N3)
Brave Sir Robin
Northnovas (D1)

[shlin28]

YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Warmaster Horus]

Good job town! I'm still disgusted at my insanity (there's got to be a reason why I got that role...) but it was a nice twist.
Thanks sapi for hosting!

[FactionHeir]

Its because you are French :tongue2:

Thanks for hosting sapi.

[Killfr3nzy]

You are dead...

Well it worked the first time..... :shrug:

Notice there's 13 players on that list?
:2thumbsup:

[Beefy187]

Thanks Sapi for a nice game..:2thumbsup:

I didnt expect Shlin to be detective.. I thought detectives are bit more quiet :wall:

Also congrats to Fr3nzy for fooling us all... :laugh4:

Thanks :bow:

[sapi]

Good job town! I'm still disgusted at my insanity (there's got to be a reason why I got that role...) but it was a nice twist.
Thanks sapi for hosting!
It was random :grin2:

I wanted to try something different, and that seemed to balance out the fact that there was only one mafia ~;)

[Warmaster Horus]

It worked mate, it worked :yes:

[sapi]

It worked mate, it worked :yes:
I was sorry to do that to you, by the way: but you'll note that I never actually promised to you that your results would be correct ~:)

[shlin28]

You didn't say the results would be right either...:inquisitive:

I still cant believe Beefy didnt kill me, and killed Ignoramus instead, when even he said that I am the most innocent person...

[FactionHeir]

Since shlin and Beefy know each other, I'm surprised they didn't figure it that easily.

[shlin28]

I know Beefy? :dizzy2:

[Warmaster Horus]

I was sorry to do that to you, by the way: but you'll note that I never actually promised to you that your results would be correct
I know; and that's what made it work so well. I was convinced I got lucky, or that my reasoning was good. And so there I was, strutting proudly, shouting: "I got guilty on KF and FH"... GAH! I was kicking myself when Omanes brought up the possibility of insanity.

Good game all the same.

[Beefy187]

KF didnt join the game :laugh4: That was the funniest bit for me...

And I thought Shlin is just another humble townie since he was soo active...Damn...:wall:

And I dont know Shlin is RL..

[pevergreen]

And here I am, the unsung hero.

Check my posts in this thread.

Dont lynch Beefy

Heh. My faking of evil wins again!