Polandball Mafia [Concluded]

[BSmith]

Punisher kill is curious. Paranoia setting in. Jarema, Double A and Seon all looking bad in my opinion as any of them would have been a logical choice for the kill.

[Punisher]

'and I will call you George'



Worth being dead just for that.

[Jarema]

vote: Visorslash. My top suspect.

[Visor]

That's a mighty curious kill.

Vote: Seon

I will admit i could be wrong on BSmith here, i don;t think he needs to pretend to think about a decision that potentially wins him the game if scum

fair play to him if he is.

Seon and jarremas votes are quite bad

[BSmith]

To expand on my initial thoughts regarding the night… Punisher makes no sense to kill unless the scum team is totally randomizing kills or is comprised of Jarema, seon and Double A. General consensus in the thread was that the scum were Sooh and Visor with punisher thrown out as the possible third with no real counter. Punisher and Visor are pure lynch bait assuming that hypothesis is wrong. My status has been uncertain as well, so I am also not a good pick to kill since it would probably be pretty easy to put a case against me and push my lynch as well.

Today Visor is the presumed lynchee, and if the scum team is still strong they will have a lot of influence on the vote. Push hard for the easy lynch and win the game. Quick votes on Visor with no further discussion – especially after the strange kill – reeks to me. Something has fundamentally changed here and there is no reaction to it. No pause. No cause for re-thinking. It feels procedural which is forced which is bad.

The logical kill last night would have been one of Seon, Double A or Jarema. That not happening leads me to believe that they are the scum team and of course scum won’t kill themselves.

I will also say that Seon’s last minute vote on Sooh last night struck me at the time. Not the fact that he did it – hell I asked him to. But the manner in which he cavalierly said “bye bye”. At the time it was nothing more than a weird feeling. But in context of the kill last night and the case above, it only reinforces my perspective this morning.

vote: Seon.

Somebody please walk me off this ledge…

[BSmith]

For the record I was all prepared to vote Visor today as well, but things have changed. Visor's comments above about me also help his case to some degree, but he is certainly capable of attempting to pocket me.

[Winston Hughes]

@GH

Would the scum be allowed to kill one of their own?

comprised of Jarema, seon and Double A.

In that case, you'd already have lost.

[Winston Hughes]

Looking at older GH games, scum weren't allowed to kill each other, but - and this is important - the scum numbers tended to be very low compared to what we're used to from elsewhere (Mafia X, for example, had only two scum in a much larger game than this).

[Winston Hughes]

Simplest explanation here is that Visor is last remaining scum. Anyone else I think kills BSmith last night.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Looking at older GH games, scum weren't allowed to kill each other, but - and this is important - the scum numbers tended to be very low compared to what we're used to from elsewhere (Mafia X, for example, had only two scum in a much larger game than this).

Two kills per night in that one though.

[BSmith]

In that case, you'd already have lost.

True. I haven’t paid that close attention to the numbers, but that is absolutely correct. Why do you think the others would have picked me to kill over any of the other three? What does visor gain by leaving me alive?

[Winston Hughes]

Two kills per night in that one though.

True, but the relative kill rate for the scum is still higher here.

[Winston Hughes]

True. I haven’t paid that close attention to the numbers, but that is absolutely correct. Why do you think the others would have picked me to kill over any of the other three? What does visor gain by leaving me alive?

You're actually contributing to discussion, and he needs someone else to try and convince the others, since there's little chance they'd have paid much heed to any arguments coming from his direction.

[BSmith]

Alright. I can see that line of logic. I need to let it sit for a bit. Hopefully others will contribute to this discussion. We could very easily be at LYLO and I'd rather not muck this up if we can avoid it.

[Winston Hughes]

Aye, that makes sense.

As it stands, you're pretty much lock town (which is to say, if scum you richly deserve the win), whilst Visor looks scummy on several counts.

The problem is that the other three survivors have given pretty much nothing in the way of content on which to make a judgement. Given that at least one - and possibly all - of them are town, the prospects of an innocent win still look rather bleak at this stage.

[El Barto]

BSmith, yuo of teamings up with Visorscum?

[BSmith]

Well, in the absence of any real further discussion (Winston not included), I'll go back to plan A: unvote; vote: Visor. I can see Winston's point and there are a few holes in my seon/AA/Jarema thought line. Gonna be pissed with myself if seon is indeed scum though.

Something is wrong when I am the most vocal player... just sayin.

[El Barto]

Yuo is of most vocal living player. Am angry, if not of killed, I would of most vocal living player.

[Double A]

going all in with BS
vote: Visor

[GeneralHankerchief]

Voting closed.

Visor has been lynched, stand by for the comic. Feel free to send in orders in the meantime.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Day 5

Day 5 tally:

Visor: 4 (Seon, Jarema, Double A, BSmith)
Seon: 1 (Visor)

It is now Night 5! The phase will conclude Saturday, May 21, at 20:00 US Eastern time.



Killed:
atheotes - Turkey
Winston Hughes - Japan
edse - Italy
Punisher - Ireland

Executed:
johnhughthom - Germany
El Barto - Somalia
Golden1Knight - Spain
Sooh - Finland
Visor - Russia

Wrath of God:
seireikhaan - USA

Still alive: (4)
Double A - France
BSmith - Serbia
Seon - Poland
Jarema - Brazil

[Double A]

Je have le last laugh, Russie! Hon hon hon!

[Winston Hughes]

I'm left hoping for a Tak/BSmith scum team, so at least we got beat by actual players.

[El Barto]

Je have le last laugh, Russie! Hon hon hon!

Of realitis? He of impeded use of your stronza ghigliottina.

I'm left hoping for a Tak/BSmith scum team, so at least we got beat by actual players.

Would of courseings like to comply, but is of improbable. You cannot into right this one, Winston.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Night 5

Final results:

Killed:
atheotes - Turkey
Winston Hughes - Japan
edse - Italy
Punisher - Ireland

Executed:
johnhughthom - Germany
El Barto - Somalia
Golden1Knight - Spain
Sooh - Finland - MAFIA
Visor - Russia - MAFIA

Wrath of God:
seireikhaan - USA

Survived: (4)
Double A - France
BSmith - Serbia
Seon - Poland
Jarema - Brazil

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Congratulations to the town and thanks for playing!

[GeneralHankerchief]

Have to head out so I'll have more to say later, but in the meantime, I hope you enjoyed this game because there probably won't be a sequel anytime soon. I should really stick to writing.

[BSmith]

Oh thank God...


Edit: that was a reference to the game result. Not the post right above.

[Double A]

FRANCE ALWAYS RIGHT

[Jarema]

I really liked the drawings.

As for the game, I was lost. I forgot how much I dont like games with no reveal...

[El Barto]

Am of happy! Felicitá!

Oh thank God...


Edit: that was a reference to the game result. Not the post right above.

Of sureties.