Horse wouldn't, not running a least, they would move into one at a trot like modern police horse do.
I was arguing that case for high speed collsions, at lower speeds like those you suggested they would probably be unharmed by any collsion, although they might lose their footing once there are enough bodies underfoot.
Yes it depends on the situation, line formations increased the psychological impact of a charge at contact but more importantly before, the main aim of a charging cavalry was to get the infantry to rout before reaching they reached them, a solid wall was the best way of doing this.
This book has a excellent description of how charges worked, including with the wedge formation.
http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=l...charge&f=false (starts on p.20)
I would say there is a lot of difference between a few horses maintaining formation and a couple of hundred, this is why cavaly would usually only charge when fairly close, so as to prevent the formation breaking up too much.
Yes but if one goes down in the front when moving at speed you've got the potential for a rather nasty ten pin bowling type situation. Hence why I believe the speed was quite slow (note the the book I link states the same thing).
Yes I think the way cavalry operates in general is pretty inaccurate for the TW seires as a whole, I can see why they done it though, one can imagine the endless number of angry rant threads that would have sprung up had CA decided to with a more realistic portrayal.
Bookmarks