Random-ice-cream-flavoured friends of the friends [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

You were right about so many things but subsequently dropped them because you thought there were only three mafia (or at least that's the impression I got). You had me sweating for the entire game. I definitely had fun trying to outwit you but it was really damn hard. Good game, Pizzaman.

And that goes for you other townies, too.

Good game for you as well. Didn't know there were other roles. Felt 4 scums versus all vanilla would have been OP, so I aimed for whoever I thought was the scummiest at the time.

If Reidquat died and flipped scum it would have been a bad day for ya. But luckily for you, they stopped listening to me after I punished Ishmael for having the gall to replace in.

[Darth Feather]

We should have killed DoubleA or Riedquat yesterday and not BSmith.
That gave the mafia victory.

That and some confusing, yet great mafia play.

[Choxorn]

Yeah, I was thinking that too, and I would have probably changed my vote if I hadn't been busy or if I'd expected more than one mafia left.

[Ferret]

By the way, the second time there was no kill, I sent orders to kill Warman, thinking he and Elite Ferret were the same person.

I have never been more insulted in my life

Thanks for hosting El Barto.

The town started so well I thought we might absolutely nail it, not so much in the end...

[johnhughthom]

Very well played, scummers. I would never have guessed it was Riedquat and AA.

[LazyMcCrow]

gg and thanks for hosting. LOVE the roles you used. My scumdar was way off. Well played mafia

[Riedquat]

If Reidquat died and flipped scum it would have been a bad day for ya. But luckily for you, they stopped listening to me after I punished Ishmael for having the gall to replace in.

And we were preparing us for that scenery, town listened to you but decided Choxorn was more scummy than me...

I have never been more insulted in my life

Elite Ferret Warman88andalotofstuffmore I would be insulted too!

We should have killed DoubleA or Riedquat yesterday and not BSmith.
That gave the mafia victory.

That and some confusing, yet great mafia play.

With one of us killed earlier it was going to be a rough end for sure.

Good game everybody! And Bartito, thanks for hosting! Any day I will invite you with a complete "Menu Rosarino"

[Makrell]

is el barto and trewa the renewer the same?

zomg

[Double A]

I have never been more insulted in my life

Sorry about that. I was seriously wondering why Warman actually made a contributing post, though.

The town started so well I thought we might absolutely nail it, not so much in the end...

You might've if I hadn't been in Arizona the first few phases, though Ried would've had more time, more kills, and no partner to try to save.

[Choxorn]

is el barto and trewa the renewer the same?

zomg

Yeah, he's the same. He's also Takhisis on CFC.

[Makrell]

wow

mind is blown,

also people should use a similar theme across websites, for example fishtheme

[B-Wing]

Congratulations to my team mates, and good game to everyone! Entertaining game, thoroughly enjoyable to keep up with, despite being the first person lynched.

I thought this was a very interesting concept, El Barto, gracious host, and I thank you for your work. The bag of goodies is a cool alternative to power roles, and the fact that it passes on to a new player whenever its carrier dies is a nice way of ensuring balance. I like it a lot.

Would the Pentitos have flipped mafia if they had been lynched instead of murdered?

[Ishmael]

Nicely played mafia. Honestly, I never really suspected either of the surviving scum - I would have called for the lynch of either of the townies before either of the mafioso . Great job.

[El Barto]

Thanks for all the compliments! Seems that the crazuy setup worked out fien after all. And, compliments to you lot, because you actuallly played. Our KotOR game last year half-fell apart because of inactivity on both sides.

On Chaotix's antics: I allowed it because it was fair since I was also allowing Pizza, Diana, etc. to continue issuing opinions.

I'm not sure what I was expecting. Riedquat's role? Nope. Not at all.

Hah! I threw in a few cool roles and left it to the players to see if they figured out some things.

And I agree with Takhibartoreva about the bag. Would have been pretty helpful to the town if it had been used more than once, although it did have limited uses and Darth Feather had no way to know that it would go to someone else still with full uses if he died.

It would have been a waste if I used it early on I wouldn't have gotten a thing out of it. Once I was quite sure about some people being town, I was going to start watching LazyMcCrow, riedquat (I didn't realize he was scum), Choxorn and Elite Ferret.

I died before they did.

Well, it was intended for people to try and use it. You never thought of giving it away either.

Good game everybody! And Bartito, thanks for hosting! Any day I will invite you with a complete "Menu Rosarino"

Why on earth would I, of all people, want to have cat meat?

is el barto and trewa the renewer the same?

zomg

Yeah, he's the same. He's also Takhisis on CFC.

And I have many other usernames you might have stumbled upon without noticing… I'm EVERYWHERE.

I thought this was a very interesting concept, El Barto, gracious host, and I thank you for your work. The bag of goodies is a cool alternative to power roles, and the fact that it passes on to a new player whenever its carrier dies is a nice way of ensuring balance. I like it a lot.

The point of this was to have a jack-of-all-trades (without things that were pointless, like tracking, because the only other one out there would be the mafia killing, and with four mafias, this'd be too difficult to nail as there wasn't even a designated killer), and so the town would always have a power role, until the very end, but a rather limited one.

Would the Pentitos have flipped mafia if they had been lynched instead of murdered?

Awww yeah man! This might have given the mafia a clue about Riedquat, but it never happened.

[Choxorn]

Note to self: Everywhere is one of Takhisis's usernames on... some site.

[Ibn-Khaldun]

This was a good game.

[El Barto]

Well the thread title still says it's in play but the game's over. Who's hosting next?