Saxon Showdown [CONCLUDED]

[Darth Feather]

Here's a tally

2 Abstain (TC, Jarema Yay)
2 Gaius Scribonius Curio (White_eyes:D, Fox Lelay)
1 Makrell (who is dead) (LazyMcCrow)
1 Ironside (DF)
1 Tincow (Montmorency)
1 Salmonsoil (edse)
1 edse (BSmith)
1 White_Eyes:D (El Barto)
1 abstain (Chaotix I guess)

Not voting: GSC, B-Wing, Rickinator9, riedquat, Autolycus, ATPG, HopAlongBunny, Salmonsoil, Ishmael, Csargo, Ironside

Please check the tally, it might still have mistakes in it.

[El Barto]

So the manor might just be a scumbag then?

I am calling it...town is boned.

1) you pretend dizziness on Day One
2) you know something way before it happens. only mafia can do that.
3) …¿?¿??¿?¿?
4) Prosit!

[White_eyes:D]

2) you know something way before it happens. only mafia can do that.

I wonder what you would think if I *gasp* actually made sense.

As for the knowing the future....I always make some kind of crazy out of my prediction which is either 100% true or I am "off my meds kind of thing".

[Ishmael]

I'll lay off Abstain, because he's going to be in enough emotional distress tonight as it is.

vote: Ironside, seeing as I haven't voted for you in a while.

[Chaotix]

unvote, vote: ABSTAIN

What's my vote now?

[Gaius Scribonius Curio]

Tincow: while I grant you the possibility of a corrupt mayor, I deem it unlikely.

A new mayor was due to take over in a few days, reportedly with powerful friends and a real determination to rid the city of this menace. Whether he would have the full support of the populace, or whether they would succumb to their inner criminal, remains to be seen.

The implication behind the game's premise is that the mayor is battling against the mafiosi. Whether that is for his own ends or not remains to be seen, but it is more likely prima facie that the mayor is pro-town, or at least a non-mafia, role. The only people who would know for sure are the mayor, his friends and the mafiosi.

I agree that the name itself is an annoyance, but this strikes me as a ready-made excuse. I would not put it past you to, as mafia, to attempt to lynch a known town role day 1 if you thought you had a chance. Abstain's own choices make it easy...

I think caution regarding the mayor ought to be the order of Day 1.

Vote: Tincow

[edse]

vOTE: aBSTAIN,

dIRE sTRAITS

He will die tonight anyway, why bother?

[edse]

Damn, I thought unvotes were needed :) didn't mean to change my vote.

Unvote: Vote: SalmonSoil

[Montmorency]

Because that would conflict with the the host's statement that the mayor is randomly assigned. Randomly assigned means anyone can be picked. If anyone can be picked, scum can be picked. Plus this game is specifically based on Capo, and the Capo Director was perfectly capable of being scum.

1. Not at all. It could be randomly picked from the set of non-scum players.

2. In Capo, the Mayor or what-do-you-call-it, was elected.

[autolycus]

vote:edse

More ties for the win!

[TinCow]

1. Not at all. It could be randomly picked from the set of non-scum players.

That is certainly a possibility, but it's just a possibility. The rules are not sufficiently clear for either of us to be able to prove our theories one way or the other for certain, absent a clarification from the host. This is mafia; when it's not clearly stated in the rules that a person is a townie, the default presumption must be that the person could be scum.

[Ferret]

Okay just to clarify, the Mayor is a guaranteed townie, and will remain so until he dies or the game is over. By randomly assigned I simply meant that any player could receive that role in the same way they would receive the role of detective, don etc, rather than a role that was assigned via a vote, such as the director in Capo.

My apologies for not making this clearer, it was intended to be public knowledge.

[B-Wing]

vote: abstain (the non-person kind)

I also vote that Visorslash change his name back.

[TinCow]

Ugh, I really do hate that name. Even so...

Unvote; Vote: Yay!

[Montmorency]

Unvote: Tincow

Counter-wagon go now!

Vote: Yay!

[Csargo]

The random Gods have spoken:

Vote: rickinator9

[Jarema]

Unvote: Tincow

Counter-wagon go now!

Vote: Yay!

unvote; vote: Montmorency

Mayor being clear innocent, I cannot vote for Visor anymore

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: TinCow

It's a cow, and it is made of tin.

Does it produce milk? Is it safe to drink?

Does it come out already pasteurized?

How does a metallic being generate organic secretions?

IT IS AN ABOMINATION AND MUST BE DESTROYED!!!!

[LazyMcCrow]

unvote: Dead Makrell who is dead. vote: Salmonsoil

[HopAlongBunny]

The gods of random.org do call for thee!

vote: El Barto

[Visor]

Vote: Yay

I will vote you until you die.

Fos on those lynching me today. I'm going to die tonight anyway.

[El Barto]

Vote: TinCow

It's a cow, and it is made of tin.

Does it produce milk? Is it safe to drink?

Does it come out already pasteurized?

How does a metallic being generate organic secretions?

IT IS AN ABOMINATION AND MUST BE DESTROYED!!!!

How do you know it produces milk, eh? The only way is to know because you have extra info! You suffer from Perfect information syndrome. Fish Finger of Suspicion: Askthepizzaguy!

The gods of random.org do call for thee!

vote: El Barto

Oh my Glob, you Suck!

[Riedquat]

Random org commands Vote: BSmith

[Chaotix]

In regard to Ferret's ruling.

Unvote, vote: abstain

This is the only way I can retract my vote and still save face.

[rickinator9]

Vote: White Eyes

Everyones who has white Eyes must be evil

[El Barto]

How broad has the multi-tie become now?

[SalmonSoil]

vote: Tincow. Although the host was originally ambiguous over whether the mayor could be mafia, possible interpretations ranged from unproven to confirmed innocent, whilst the rest of us are all just unproven. Thus Tincow tried to lynch the one person who actually had any kind of evidence at all pointing towards their innocence.

Vote: SalmonSoil Death to fishes! It's unnatural.

That is offensive to my culture.

[Ironside]

Vote: Gaius Scribonius Curio

The random gods have spoken.

[Darth Feather]

How broad has the multi-tie become now?

If I counted correctly there is only a tie between GSC and Yay now with three votes each.

[Jarema]

If I counted correctly there is only a tie between GSC and Yay now with three votes each.

Self-preservation is understandable motive I suppose. So, you will not be shocked that I unvote; vote: Gaius Scribonius Curio