Large mafia game Clues and Evidences - SIGNUPS

[Darth Feather]

My results:

jarema Medium killer
Sprig: Dark haired killer

Therefore i vote darth feather But OFC the killers can do cheating stuff.

What method of research did you use?

[Makrell]

What method of research did you use?

An uncertain one. But still, it is all ive got for now.

[Andres]

I learned that Ferret was lynched

[Riedquat]

One of our movie analysts decided to publish his results. According to him, person who killed Jimmy had dark hair.

My results:

jarema Medium killer
Sprig: Dark haired killer

Therefore i vote darth feather But OFC the killers can do cheating stuff.

So we have,

Night 0 kills:
Jimmy: dark hair*
Jarema: Medium killer

Night 1 kills:
LazyMcCrow: no info
Sprig: dark hair

Night 2 kills:
Beefy: no info

----------------

Dark haired players:
DF, Makrell, Bsmith, Bwing and Andres

Medium players:
DF, Riedquat, Ignoramus, Ishmael, edse

Makrell, why the need to reveal your own results when you could do it anonymously? And while I'm at it, the asterisk * mean the info come that way, two different sources leading to a dark haired killer.

Vote: Bsmith

[BSmith]

If the reports are to be believed, then I think you have just helped triangulate one of our killers. The only dark haired, medium person is DF. Jarema and Sprig were both shot, so they are probably the same killer. vote: Darth Feather

Jimmy and Lazy were both poisoned. Are there two reports of a dark haired killer of the two them, or just one? I am still curious why the poisoner didn’t kill last night. If someone was role blocked then we might have our candidate for the poison killer as well. I suppose it is possible that the killer just missed getting orders in as well.

[Csargo]

Vote: Darth Feather

Bandwagon yay

[Diana Abnoba]

Yes, I think the only medium sized dark hair person is DF. So Vote: Darth Feather

[Ishmael]

Having re-read the OP it seems that a result of a 'medium' killer actually gives an equal probability that they are 'rather small' or 'rather large.' This would therefore bring Makrell and BSmith into the equation as well. The killer could have also apparently worn a wig, but I'd assume there's something preventing them from doing that all the time since it would render half the town's roles useless, so I'll assume that's correct for now. So, to prevent too much of a bandwagon forming:

vote: BSmith

[Makrell]

So we have,
Makrell, why the need to reveal your own results when you could do it anonymously? And while I'm at it, the asterisk * mean the info come that way, two different sources leading to a dark haired killer.

I think we can only reveal certain info and only some days. I am still of the belief that everyone should share all info at all times, because everyone cant be wrong.

[Darth Feather]

I guess defending myself is not really going to help. I am medium-sized and black haired, but if Makrell used camera's it might as well be a brown-haired rather small or rather large person.
Therefore: Vote: BSmith (I am a watcher BTW)

[Andres]

Makrell, why the need to reveal your own results when you could do it anonymously? And while I'm at it, the asterisk * mean the info come that way, two different sources leading to a dark haired killer.

Roles are revealed upon death, so if DF turns out be innocent, then either Makrell lied or his results aren't trustworthy. In the hypothesis DF is innocent, we'll end up lynching Makrell and then we will learn how much investigation results are worth in this game.

[Andres]

Unvote; Vote : Darth Feather

Sorry man, but you're the only medium dark haired one.

[Makrell]

I guess defending myself is not really going to help. I am medium-sized and black haired, but if Makrell used camera's it might as well be a brown-haired rather small or rather large person.

I agree completely. They may be wrong, but given the variables i have been presented you are the one where it crosses.

To add i assume as everyone else also have investegative skills they have come to the same conclusions as me? We are many players, if someone says sprigs killer is blonde, obviously you shouldnt vote DF.

[Darth Feather]

Unvote; Vote : Darth Feather

Sorry man, but you're the only medium dark haired one.

No problem, in your stead I would most likely have acted similarly.

[dcmort93]

I think at this point the evidence points to Darth Feather although all manner of tricks may be afoot

[Darth Feather]

I think at this point the evidence points to Darth Feather although all manner of tricks may be afoot

Trust your instincts and you will know I am not evil.

[Makrell]

New theory, those who voted for someone similar to DF actually got a slightly different result (rather small or brown)

[Jarema]

Tally:
Darth Feather (6): Makrell, BSmith, Csargo, Diana Abnoba, Andres, dcmort
BSmith (3): Riedquat, Ishmael, Darth Feather
At the end of day, DF was a clear leader for the lynch, with a small minority wanting to kill BSmith instead.
So, without hesitation, Jaro killed him.
Unfortunately, no signs of criminal activity were found on his body or in his apartment.
‘I hope next time you will choose better. One-third of our personel is dead already’ Jaro said before walking to his chamber.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Darth Feather was an innocent tracker.

Night 3 begins.

[Makrell]

Im gonna go with Bsmith for next time. I guess soeone got rather small in their movies.

[Darth Feather]

[Jarema]

I am sorry, I was without internet access for few days. Now I am back, and as soon as I end working on things associated with my work, I will update results

[Jarema]

Edse was analyzing interesting drop of blood, when she died. It was caused by a lot of bullets that found their way into her belly.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Edse was an innocent genetic.

Acin was sleeping, when one of his friends vsited him. ‘Don’t you have a work to do?’ friend asked. ‘Here, eat this meal, it would make your efforts easier’. Soon, everything was easy for Acin.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Acin was an innocent profiler.

One of movie analysts decided to publish obtained results:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Jimmy: it seems like rather small person did it
Sprig: killer seems to be person of medium built
LazyMcCrow: it seems like a medium person with brown hair killed him

Day 4 begins

[Riedquat]

Ok... so we now have the following info...

Night 0 kills:
Jimmy: dark hair* and small person*
Jarema: Medium killer

Night 1 kills:
LazyMcCrow: brown hair*, medium person*
Sprig: dark hair, medium person*

Night 2 kills:
Beefy: no info

Night 3 kills:
edse: shoot
ACIN: poison

Again the asterisk marks unknown sources, rest are Makrell's results. Got it right? Can somebody point clearly who got killed how, I have not time right now to do it myself..

[Makrell]

Night 0 kills:
Jimmy: dark hair* and rather small person*
Jarema: Medium killer

Night 1 kills:
LazyMcCrow: brown hair*, medium person*
Sprig: dark hair, medium person*

Night 2 kills:
Beefy: rather Large person with red hair (EDITED IN MISTAKE FIXED)

Night 3 kills:
edse: shoot
ACIN: poison

Again the asterisk marks unknown sources, rest are Makrell's results.


Beefy was red hair and large person, so if i understand correctly this cant be the rather small/medium killer of nght 1 and 0.

Hair could be changed with wigs, but can height be changed to? i have no idea why we have so many different heights on the killers.
If my last result was semicorrect then it would point to the only to people to even nearly be of that height, Csargo and DCmort, but Who both have red hair. It is strange that noone has gotten their height right though, varying from large to medium throughout kills.

[Makrell]

Yea, large is not a size, ive asked Jarema about what it means, might bring some clarity

[Jarema]

If someone gets result of 'large', it is my mistake.

There are following sizes:
very small, rather small, medium, rather large, very large.

Person can be seen as belonging to bordering category (e.g. medium person can be seen as rather small, medium, or rather large). If you have seen medium killer, you know that it was NOT very small or very large person. But three options remain

[Makrell]

If all kills are commited by the same person(which i doubt) then it has to be someone medium, with hair. therefore ill Vote: ishmael for now.

[Riedquat]

If all kills are commited by the same person(which i doubt) then it has to be someone medium, with hair. therefore ill Vote: ishmael for now.

I'm sorry I am admittedly a bit distracted, but first thing first, from where comes beefy's killing information? It was already there or are you just revealing it?

...and Ishmael? Really? woow... I don't follow you logic.... or any logic to that matter :P

[Makrell]

I'm sorry I am admittedly a bit distracted, but first thing first, from where comes beefy's killing information? It was already there or are you just revealing it?

...and Ishmael? Really? woow... I don't follow you logic.... or any logic to that matter :P

I revealed beefy, scanned him this night.
And ishmael is the only one who can fit ALL the clues at the same time, here hair being red(might be seen as brown or dark) and her medium build(making her possibly rather small and rather large to cameras.)

[Andres]

Vote : Makrell