A mafi(y)a game

[seireikhaan]

unvote; vote: Double A

Last time, I seem to recall he spammed up the thread D1 despite not being an actual player. This time, he's on the roster, but is nowhere to be seen.

I say, now I say, this here's a boy usin' his noggin. Looks to me like as good a reasnin' as any today. Where you at, Double A? Give us some bluster, boy, so we know you aint dead already!

Unvote: GH
Vote: Double A

[El Barto]

TIEBREAKER ROUND

With the current tally:

GeneralHankerchief: Zack
Riedquat: Ishmael;
johnhughthom: Visorslash;
Winston Hughes: johnhughthom; landlubber
Csargo: Riedquat
Autolycus: Kagemusha
seireikhaan: BSmith; Csargo
Iskander 3.1: autolycus
Visorslash: GeneralHankerchief; TexCat;
Ishmael: Iskander 3.1
Double A: Winston Hughes; seireikhaan

not voting: Double A

We have no choice but to continue until one of you is voted to death. Therefore, whichever vote first breaks the tie will end the round, hopefully while your adorably handsome GM is still online.

[autolycus]

Clearly, I will shift to Visorslash, so that all his focus is on my game :P

[El Barto]

DAY ONE

GeneralHankerchief: Zack
Riedquat: Ishmael;
johnhughthom: Visorslash;
Winston Hughes: johnhughthom; landlubber
Csargo: Riedquat
Autolycus: Kagemusha
seireikhaan: BSmith; Csargo
Visorslash: GeneralHankerchief; TexCat; autolycus (tiebreaker)
Ishmael: Iskander 3.1
Double A: Winston Hughes; seireikhaan

not voting: Double A (1')

1. Zack
2. Csargo
3. landlubber
4. Double A
5. Visorslash, townie, lynched on Day One
6. BSmith
7. GeneralHankerchief
8. Iskander 3.1
9. seireikhaan
10. Kagemusha
11. johnhughthom
12. Riedquat
13. autolycus
14. TexCat
15. Ishmael
16. Winston Hughes

It is now Night One.
Time remaining for this phase:

[Visor]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Errors
The following errors occurred with your submission
You have included a total of 135 images in your message. The maximum number that you may include is 50. Please correct the problem and then continue again.

[Csargo]

Tis a cruel world...

[GeneralHankerchief]

Good god that was a messy tie.

[landlubber]

All I wanted was to actually play with Visor. You had to crush that dream, didn't you?

[Askthepizzaguy]

[El Barto]

NIGHT ONE

BSmith was found dead in the morning. He was a townie!

1. Zack
2. Csargo
3. landlubber
4. Double A
5. Visorslash, townie, lynched on Day One
6. BSmith townie, killed by the mafia on Night One
7. GeneralHankerchief
8. Iskander 3.1
9. seireikhaan
10. Kagemusha
11. johnhughthom
12. Riedquat
13. autolycus
14. TexCat
15. Ishmael
16. Winston Hughes

It is now Day Two.
Time remaining for this phase:

[GeneralHankerchief]

Vote: Double A

WoG bait, part of the tiebreaker last round, lynch lurkers in vanilla games, etc etc etc.

[El Barto]

GM's note: If anyone's missing a results PM, drop me a line.

[TexCat]

vote: seireikhaan

Also part of the tiebreaker and the object of BSmith's vote.

[Riedquat]

Day 2 with substance. I formally accuse Zack of killing BSmith!

[GeneralHankerchief]

Formally?

[Zack]

We're all friends here, no need for such stiff formality.

[landlubber]

I like the logic against vote:Double A, he's certainly more cautious now than we're used to. Deserves some pressure.

[Ishmael]

In the interests of not piling too many votes on the Double A bandwagon (yet),

vote: Kagemusha

I tend not to think that the tie yesterday really indicates anything, so I'm afraid this is essentially a random placeholder until more people show up.

[Ishmael]

Vote: Double A

WoG bait, part of the tiebreaker last round, lynch lurkers in vanilla games, etc etc etc.

Wait, why would you want to lynch WoG bait? I mean, if they appear at the last moment before being WoGed (WoGged? WoG'd?) that could be considered suspicious, but it feels like it would be a waste to lynch somebody who is effectively already dead, otherwise. I suspect I'm missing something obvious here.

[Winston Hughes]

So many choices, but I'm a sucker for formality.

vote: Zack

[Riedquat]

1x1

To be freaking clear, I'm telling you Zack killed BSmith!!

I will need a good doctor tonight.

[TexCat]

unvote
vote: Zack

[BSmith]

Avenge Meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.....

(yet another early game death for me. )

[GeneralHankerchief]

Kind of wish you had delivered this accusation a bit later on in the round so we could get more unrelated discussion out of it, but hey, I'm always up for a mafioso being lynched.

Unvote: Double A
Vote: Zack

[Riedquat]

I'm not a fan of drawing a bright and big target on my back so early either, but better be sure than sorry later with a possible drop of participation.

[Kagemusha]

Ok. This was easy. Good job Riedquat. Vote: Zack

[Zack]

[Kagemusha]

We dont have much to go with at this point, but while Zack is the clear lynch to test the claim of Riedquat. I have to FOS: GH.

Old friend. If we assume Zack is indeed mafia and mafia tends to distance from each other at the start of the games usually.The one who seems most distant from Zack based on the first round and start of this one is you GH, with Zacks vote against you in the first round. Just wanted to point that out if i get killed early in this game too. So i have to embarrass myself with my ramblings while i still can.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Just so this isn't a completely wasted round (well, aside from the lynch obviously):

Wait, why would you want to lynch WoG bait? I mean, if they appear at the last moment before being WoGed (WoGged? WoG'd?) that could be considered suspicious, but it feels like it would be a waste to lynch somebody who is effectively already dead, otherwise. I suspect I'm missing something obvious here.

A couple of reasons: First, I don't know El Barto's exact WoG policy, so I was playing it safe until we got some clarification (either by Barto saying something or Double A showing up). I've both presided over and played in vanilla games in which lurker mafiosi did just enough to avoid the WoG, so I wanted to at least draw attention to those who were less active. Secondly, I placed my vote extremely early on in the round. Since I think the whole FoS, etc. thing is useless, I'll shift votes around a lot in a phase, especially a longer one.

[GeneralHankerchief]

We dont have much to go with at this point, but while Zack is the clear lynch to test the claim of Riedquat. I have to FOS: GH.

Old friend. If we assume Zack is indeed mafia and mafia tends to distance from each other at the start of the games usually.The one who seems most distant from Zack based on the first round and start of this one is you GH, with Zacks vote against you in the first round. Just wanted to point that out if i get killed early in this game too. So i have to embarrass myself with my ramblings while i still can.

Well, I can't really defend against this.