Visor's Small Mafia Game [Concluded]

[atheotes]

What is the case on Riedquat?

[Renata]

See, here's the thing. Dp is if anything even more scummy to me on re-read. I'm aware of confirmation bias, but still. His reads are, as you say, limp; his posting comes off as exceedingly self-conscious in places, etc.

Riedquat's just your garden variety shitposter with the possible exception of that one post feeling a little off with its 'prodding' of the day's main attraction. There's no real read here; there's no there there.

[Stork]

What is the case on Riedquat?

lol

he has 7 posts, read them yourself

[atheotes]

vote: Riedquat

I don't know if this is going to stay. Thinking more of advatages and disadvantages of killing either one, as opposed to which might be mafia.

Why would you do that given your suspicion of Dp101?

[Renata]

What is the case on Riedquat?

See other comments. The one post of his that I highlighted looks like it might have been him taking a poke at a townie Dp who was currently getting grilled, without getting his hands dirty. Basically showing no real willingness to engage with the game.

[atheotes]

Bad Stork, voting off wagons. Take responsibility, man.



You know what, I think DP needs to be resolved today. Is there a way to confirm you without lynching you?
Vote: Dp101

Whatever happened to "Dp must be resolved today"?

Any claim would be good.

I'll follow Stork. Vote: Riedquat

GN

[Renata]

Why would you do that given your suspicion of Dp101?

I feel like Dp is going to hang himself sooner or later if he's scum (maybe even if he's town), while posters like Riedquat are as hard to evict as mold in your shower. I'm not sure I'm keeping my vote where it is. It's hard to give up an actual read for potential long-term considerations and the repercussions of being wrong.

[atheotes]

lol

he has 7 posts, read them yourself

Duh...I did not find anything. Hence the qn.
I did not qn your vote because you already stated you dont want to lynch the top poster.
Monty is also voting to save Dp.

[Renata]

Neither bandwagon looks all that clean to me. Watch them be town/town.

[Renata]

vote: Dp101

It's tied.

[Newyn]

The more Renata talks, the more I get the feeling I should follow through with my initial read of Renata scum.

[atheotes]

I feel like Dp is going to hang himself sooner or later if he's scum (maybe even if he's town), while posters like Riedquat are as hard to evict as mold in your shower. I'm not sure I'm keeping my vote where it is. It's hard to give up an actual read for potential long-term considerations and the repercussions of being wrong.

I think i have played only one game with DP. he was universally town read. Pocketed by the scum and voted with them the whole game. He had the intent of "doing the right thing" throughout the game even when he was wrong about the conclusions he came to.
Here he is just trying to get out of the lynch and doesnt care who gets lynched in his stead.
I can understand people defending him yesterday. But I am very suspicious of anyone who is defending him now.

[Renata]

[Renata]

I think i have played only one game with DP. he was universally town read. Pocketed by the scum and voted with them the whole game. He had the intent of "doing the right thing" throughout the game even when he was wrong about the conclusions he came to.
Here he is just trying to get out of the lynch and doesnt care who gets lynched in his stead.
I can understand people defending him yesterday. But I am very suspicious of anyone who is defending him now.

Well, it's tied now. Unless someone else switches it's up to chance.

[atheotes]

I guess we have abt 9 mins to see who breaks the tie.

[atheotes]

Current Tally.

Riedquat - 5 (Choxorn, Stork, Al sips, Dp101, Monty)
Dp101 - 5 (GH, atheotes, Newyn, Askthepizzaguy, Renata)
Montmorency - 2 (El barto, Scarlett Aria)
Al Sipsclar - 1 (Bsmith)
Choxorn - 1 (Riedquat)
Newyn - 1 (Zack)

[Renata]

Either way, Al Sips needs to die.

[Stork]

newyn is here and mentioned nothing about the wagons which is riveting

[GeneralHankerchief]

Morning all.

I power-read the past four pages in 10 minutes, can sort of see the case on Riedquat but not budging on DP.

[Renata]

Morning, GH.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Also if Renata can pull off this level of conversation with Stork if they're m/m after five years out of the game then she deserves a damn medal. Going to safely rule that one out.

[Montmorency]

I think i have played only one game with DP. he was universally town read. Pocketed by the scum and voted with them the whole game. He had the intent of "doing the right thing" throughout the game even when he was wrong about the conclusions he came to.
Here he is just trying to get out of the lynch and doesnt care who gets lynched in his stead.

You noticed a difference in performance, yet you don't think this is explained by the fact that he has been the lead wagon for most of the day and in the other game he was never seriously at risk of the lynch, at any time?

You don't realize that these vastly different circumstances can produce a difference in reaction?

Especially given that this is D1? And that otherwise he has behaved just as we would expect from town DP?

As I said: come off it.

[atheotes]

You noticed a difference in performance, yet you don't think this is explained by the fact that he has been the lead wagon for most of the day and in the other game he was never seriously at risk of the lynch, at any time?

You don't realize that these vastly different circumstances can produce a difference in reaction?

Especially given that this is D1? And that otherwise he has behaved just as we would expect from town DP?

As I said: come off it.

I dont think these "changes in circumstance" explain his behavior.
Atleast i am voting my strongest scum read...

[atheotes]

Whats the rule on talking during the night?

[atheotes]

Oops.. it is not in the OP. but the next post says no talking in the night.
Apologies.

[Renata]

Unspecified in the OP.

[Renata]

Lol. Nevermind.

[Visor]

Gonna give it a pass but please don't talk at night.

Gonna manually tally the votes just to make sure, then gonna post the update, bear with me.

[Visor]

monty: el barto, scarlett
al sips: bsmith
dp101: GH, atheotes,newyn, atpg, renata
choxorn: riedquat
newyn: zack
riedquat: choxorn, stork, al sips, dp101, monty

[Visor]

dp101 was lynched (tied lynch between ried and dp101 resolved by rng)

he was town

22 hours for night orders