Results 1 to 28 of 28

Thread: True descendants of the Thracians

  1. #1
    Ambiguous Member Byzantine Prince's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    4,334

    Default True descendants of the Thracians

    Some time ago another org member told me that Vlachs are actually descendants of Thracians. Is this at all true?

    Now I know Bulgarians claim the same but that's far from being true since they are mixed in turks and romanians and mostly bulgars. They even speak a slavic language. So they are not thracians. Vlachs on the other hand speak an ancient language only similar to Romanian, so they are definetly the real thing. But are they Thracian?

  2. #2
    Scruffy Looking Nerf Herder Member Steppe Merc's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    New Jersey, USA
    Posts
    7,907

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    No one in any part of the world is a truly pure decandant of any ancient culture.

    "But if you should fall you fall alone,
    If you should stand then who's to guide you?
    If I knew the way I would take you home."
    Grateful Dead, "Ripple"

  3. #3
    Ambiguous Member Byzantine Prince's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    4,334

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Well then that ancient culture was not pure either, so what's your point?

    *sigh* I could make the same types of pedantic comments for every thread in the org(and sometimes I do), but you know I didn't mean *pure* pure. I meant that have kept the traditions of laguage and have some of the same DNA as that ancient culture.

  4. #4
    Ja mata, TosaInu Forum Administrator edyzmedieval's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Fortress of the Mountains
    Posts
    11,389

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Thracians = Bulgarians + Romanians

    It's a mix of it. Thracia was the south of Romania + the north of Bulgaria.
    Ja mata, TosaInu. You will forever be remembered.

    Proud

    Been to:

    Swords Made of Letters - 1938. The war is looming in France - and Alexandre Reythier does not have much time left to protect his country. A novel set before the war.

    A Painted Shield of Honour - 1313. Templar Knights in France are in grave danger. Can they be saved?

  5. #5
    Ambiguous Member Byzantine Prince's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    4,334

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Errr Thracians = ancient peoples whom Dacians(Romanians) were related to
    Bulgarians = people's who came from the steppes to Thracia(now bulgaria) in the 13th century

    I think you have it mixed Edyz. Bulgarians are Turk and Slav mixed together.

  6. #6
    TexMec Senior Member Louis VI the Fat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Location
    Saint Antoine
    Posts
    9,935

    Default Re : Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Quote Originally Posted by Byzantine Prince
    Bulgarians = people's who came from the steppes to Thracia(now bulgaria) in the 13th century.
    That's six centuries off. The Bulgarians consider 681 the birthyear of their state.

    I think Edyz is right. The Thracians are to Bulgaria and Roumania what Celts are to Britain in France. Some pockets of their language survive, their genes have been assimilated into the main ethnic populations that now populate their lands.
    Anything unrelated to elephants is irrelephant
    Texan by birth, woodpecker by the grace of God
    I would be the voice of your conscience if you had one - Brenus
    Bt why woulf we uy lsn'y Staraft - Fragony
    Not everything
    blue and underlined is a link


  7. #7
    Ambiguous Member Byzantine Prince's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    4,334

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    How is he right? This is what he said:
    Quote Originally Posted by edyz
    Thracia was the south of Romania + the north of Bulgaria.
    Here are some map to refute that.


    A quote from teh encyclopedia:
    Quote Originally Posted by Encarta_Microsoft Corporation
    The region that is now Bulgaria was at one time included in the Roman Empire as part of the provinces of Thrace and Moesia. Slavic and Turkic tribes settled in the area between about the 4th and 6th centuries ad. One branch of people known as Bulgars, who had established a large state near the Volga River on the east side of the Black Sea, invaded the Balkan Peninsula in the 7th century. They set up a state between the Danube River and the Balkan Mountains, an area that was then claimed by the Byzantine Empire. Byzantine armies failed repeatedly to dislodge the invaders during the 8th and early 9th centuries. By the end of the 9th century the Bulgarians had annexed considerable additional territory and laid the foundations for a strong state under Khan Krum, who reigned from 803 to 814. The Krum armies inflicted a devastating defeat on an invading Byzantine force in 811 and, assuming the offensive, nearly succeeded in 813 in taking Constantinople (present-day İstanbul, Turkey), the capital of the Byzantine Empire.
    So they came from Russia and invaded the area known as Thracia. They then got invaded by the Turks and mixed with them far more then any others. I don't think they are very Thracian, although I'm sure they have some thracian blood in them.

  8. #8
    Magister Vitae Senior Member Kraxis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2002
    Location
    Frederiksberg, Denmark
    Posts
    7,129

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Well there isn't much left of the Thracians... Their languages (they spoke several) seems lost, and their makeup seems lost as well. Most Thracian tribes are described quite different from how the people of the region look today.

    So I dare say that the Thracians are gone. Of course their blood run in a few of us (not me I think), but so does many other peoples, and their governing traits and culture does not exist.
    You may not care about war, but war cares about you!


  9. #9
    Dux Nova Scotia Member lars573's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Location
    Halifax NewScotland Canada
    Posts
    4,114

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    The thracians were absorbed into the Slavic peoples that moved into what is now Bulgaria and Wallchia(SP). So were the Turkic Bulgars that conquered the Slavs in Bulgaria then became part of them. Both Thracians and the Bulgars left some cultural and linguistic remenants in the Bulgaria of today.

    The Vlachs are the decendants of the Romans. Both of the very small Romano-Dacian population that was left behind after the legions left Dacia and Romans who migrated from Moesia superior and infirior (provinces located in what is now Serbia more or less) to the Transylvannian plateau after the Slavs moved into the Balkans in the 600's AD.
    If you havin' skyrim problems I feel bad for you son.. I dodged 99 arrows but my knee took one.

    VENI, VIDI, NATES CALCE CONCIDI

    I came, I saw, I kicked ass

  10. #10
    "'elp! I'm bein' repressed!" Senior Member Aenlic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    The live music capital of the world.
    Posts
    1,583

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    It should be pointed out that the first Principality of Wallachia was begun by a family descended from Cumans. Basarab, the ruler who established the principality has a Cuman name, as does his father Tihomir.

    The area itself was first Thracian, but was a welcome mat for many incursions after Rome. First the Visigoths, then the Huns, then the Kutrigur Huns, then the Avars, then Bulgars from the south, then Slavs from the north, then Pechenegs, then Cumans, and finally the Mongols. After the Mongols left, the remaining Cumans established the above principality. Later they were conquered by the Ottomans. Attempting to draw a line from the Thracians to the Vlachs is impossible.
    "Dee dee dee!" - Annoymous (the "differently challenged" and much funnier twin of Anonymous)

  11. #11
    dictator by the people Member caesar44's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    the holy(?) land
    Posts
    1,207

    Smile Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Quote Originally Posted by Steppe Merc
    No one in any part of the world is a truly pure decandant of any ancient culture.
    Well , could not define it better !!! (but think about the Jews and some of the Chinese)
    "The essence of philosophy is to ask the eternal question that has no answer" (Aristotel) . "Yes !!!" (me) .

    "Its time we stop worrying, and get angry you know? But not angry and pick up a gun, but angry and open our minds." (Tupac Amaru Shakur)

  12. #12
    Patria Nostra Romania Member Gemenii XIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Colonia Ulpia Traiana Augusta Dacica Sarmisegetusa
    Posts
    46

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    The Vlachs were the purest decendants of the Roman Legionnaires Gemina XIII and nearby Roman settler from Moesia (modern Bulgaria and Serbia). The name Vlach is a barbarian word for Roman, and the principality of Wallachia is literally Romania. This name was given by the Saxons when they invaded the Roman Empire and also was given to the southwestern region of Britain; Wales (because more Romans probably lived there when the saxons invaded Britain). Of course no one can say that he or she is a pure descendant of anything anymore for example: an Italian cannot say that he descends from Julius Caesar's family because a lot has changed in Italy over time, as in other countries. However, it is more likely that most of ones ancestry is Roman if he or she are from Italy, Spain, Romania, Portugal or France because these areas, for the most part, remained unchanged after the barbarian invasions. This is evident through the romance languages that are spoken in the areas and the last names of the inhabitants (particularly in Romania). As for the Thratians, they are not Romanian. Studies have shown that the closest people to Thratians are actually modern Albanians. They descend from an old Dacian tribe the "Carpe" which were defeated by Emperor Domitian and resettled in southern Illiria (modern albania). To this day the Albanian language is thought to be the closest spoken to that of the Dacians/Thratians. A good example of this is the word "carpe", in albananian, it means rocky or stony (I cant remember which because I am not Albanian and don't speak their language). Also, the name of the "carpathian" mountains (located roughly in modern Romania) has absolutely no significants in romanian. However in Albanian the carpathians would simply be rocky or stony mountains.
    PS
    Ill post the link to this statement when I find the article again if any one is interested
    ____________________
    Patria Nostra Romania

  13. #13

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Wow, let's be very careful about equating ethnicity with language spoken. In the example given, the lands who speak Romance languages (France, Spain, Portugal, Italy) were subjected to considerable barbarian invasions and migrations, not to mention the fact that the Romans replaced the Gauls and Iberians in any case, and so there was considerable diversity. As several people have said, there is no way of successfully tracing the decendants of a people (who may already be very ethnically diverse in any case) from 2,000 years ago, especially in an areas subjected to so many invasions as the Balkans; so many turkic, germanic and slavic tribes have settled there in the past.

  14. #14
    "'elp! I'm bein' repressed!" Senior Member Aenlic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    The live music capital of the world.
    Posts
    1,583

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    My personal belief, not backed up by anything except conjecture, is that the proto-Indo-Europeans, the original source of the many branches of the Indo-European tribes and languages, came from the Black Sea valley prior to the great flood around 7500 BCE which created the current Black Sea.

    This area would have been much more fertile than the so-called fertile crescent. With the forbidding mountains of Anatolia to the south, the most likely routes of exodus as the valley filled quickly would have been southeast, northeast, north, and northwest. These areas are precisely the areas from which the list of suspects for the origins of Indo-European arise a couple of millenia later. The Thracians to the northwest, the steppes people to the north, the Central Asian tribes to the northeast, and the tribes of the Caucasus to the southeast. To date, the Thracians on the eventual northwestern shore of the new Black Sea, in what is now Bulgaria, still have the record for the earliest known examples of massive gold and copper mining and working, as early as perhaps 4500 BCE. We'll probably never know much about what if any civilization flourished there prior to that massive flood; but Bob Ballard found tantalizing signs of settlements, including the characteristic mounding of continual settlements building up on top of each other, near the banks f what used to be rivers now under the Black Sea.

    In the end, I suppose that would mean that almost all of the later invasions into what was once the domains of the Thracians were made by people who were distantly related to them anyway. So maybe it's a moot point.
    Last edited by Aenlic; 08-14-2005 at 06:14.
    "Dee dee dee!" - Annoymous (the "differently challenged" and much funnier twin of Anonymous)

  15. #15
    Magister Vitae Senior Member Kraxis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2002
    Location
    Frederiksberg, Denmark
    Posts
    7,129

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    One small correction:

    The Black Sea was as a lake about 2/3rds of the current Black Sea. Remember that quite a few very large rivers run into the area and would thus have formed a very large lake.

    But yes, there were people living at the foot of the Anatolian highlands as Bob Ballard found a small village about 100 meters down under water.
    You may not care about war, but war cares about you!


  16. #16
    Patria Nostra Romania Member Gemenii XIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Colonia Ulpia Traiana Augusta Dacica Sarmisegetusa
    Posts
    46

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Quote Originally Posted by KingOfTheIsles
    Wow, let's be very careful about equating ethnicity with language spoken. In the example given, the lands who speak Romance languages (France, Spain, Portugal, Italy) were subjected to considerable barbarian invasions and migrations, not to mention the fact that the Romans replaced the Gauls and Iberians in any case, and so there was considerable diversity. As several people have said, there is no way of successfully tracing the decendants of a people (who may already be very ethnically diverse in any case) from 2,000 years ago, especially in an areas subjected to so many invasions as the Balkans; so many turkic, germanic and slavic tribes have settled there in the past.
    The truth is that there are few and far between historical documents implementing the ethnicity of the people in the Bulkan region during the barbarian invasions. Therefore, the language argument is the best option for determening the ehtinicity of people in the Bulkans. There are 6th century Saxon and Hunnic scriptures mentioning the Vlachs north of the danube in what was called Wallachia (corresponding to modern Romania). That is how we know that Romans lived there during that time. As for modern eastern Roman ethnicity, just look at Romanias geography. It is surrounded by slavic countries. If the Bulkan region was heavely invaded and assimilated by these people (as you said), than why is it that the Romanians managed to preserve their romance language (which is closest to Vulgar Latin grammatically) over the course of histoy? This we do not know. That is why my earlier post stands. And if you read carefully I too said that the ethnicity of the people whom speak these romance languages are not 100% known, however, it is more likely that their ethnicity are closer to that of the Romans as opposed to other countries such as Germany, Poland, Holand ect. Mind you I am speaking of national not individual ethnicity.

  17. #17
    Patria Nostra Romania Member Gemenii XIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Colonia Ulpia Traiana Augusta Dacica Sarmisegetusa
    Posts
    46

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    [QUOTE=Kraxis]One small correction:

    The Black Sea was as a lake about 2/3rds of the current Black Sea. Remember that quite a few very large rivers run into the area and would thus have formed a very large lake.
    QUOTE]

    I also heard about this but thats just a geological theory. Another theory states that the black sea and the caspian sea were once one big sea. Yet, they seperated because this sea was resting on two tectonic plates. In which case the black sea couldn't have been a lake because the caspian sea is a sea not a lake.

  18. #18
    Magister Vitae Senior Member Kraxis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2002
    Location
    Frederiksberg, Denmark
    Posts
    7,129

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Since they are pretty far apart you are going more than a mere 8000 years back in time. You are speaking of perhaps millions of years. That is quite far outside our timeframe of discussion.
    I'm not going to argue that they were not connected, I simply don't know, but not this close as the Indo-Europeans certainly did go down through the Caucasus, which would have been impossible if there had been a sea blocking their way.
    You may not care about war, but war cares about you!


  19. #19
    "'elp! I'm bein' repressed!" Senior Member Aenlic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    The live music capital of the world.
    Posts
    1,583

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Quote Originally Posted by Kraxis
    One small correction:

    The Black Sea was as a lake about 2/3rds of the current Black Sea. Remember that quite a few very large rivers run into the area and would thus have formed a very large lake.

    But yes, there were people living at the foot of the Anatolian highlands as Bob Ballard found a small village about 100 meters down under water.
    Yes, indeed. My post apparently wasn't clear. I wasn't implying that the Black Sea valley had no sea in it at the time of the flood; just that the flood was so large and fast that it pushed the people there out quickly, and in more than one likely direction. My mention of rivers was in reference to Bob Ballard. The way he located the remains of settlements was to first try and locate areas which looked likely as the underwater remains of where rivers once flowed into the smaller pre-flood Black Sea. He postulated that the confluence of these now flooded river channels and the old sea would be the most likely place for settlements. So that is where he looked. And settlements is what he found. It's possible, even likely, that there were other settlements around the circumference of the old water line; but Ballard hasn't yet looked, nor has anyone else. I'm pretty sure his main focus was where the Danube flows into the Black Sea. Other good places to look would be the Dnieper, the Dniester, the Don, the Kuban, the Kolkheti, the Yesilirmak, Kizilirmak and Sakarya river channels. The main problem to locating the old channels is sedimentation, especially in the shallower areas such as the northern banks, after 9500 years. But the advantages are obvious; these settlements would be relatively undisturbed since the flood.
    "Dee dee dee!" - Annoymous (the "differently challenged" and much funnier twin of Anonymous)

  20. #20
    Magister Vitae Senior Member Kraxis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2002
    Location
    Frederiksberg, Denmark
    Posts
    7,129

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Actually he was looking down by Turkey as he was really looking for Byzantine wrecks and not settlements but the slow Turkish authorities forced him to do something with his time. Impressive that he can use the sparetime to do somethat that spectacular... He has got to be the most talented sea hunter (sorry Clive but Bob wins hands down).
    You may not care about war, but war cares about you!


  21. #21
    Patria Nostra Romania Member Gemenii XIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Colonia Ulpia Traiana Augusta Dacica Sarmisegetusa
    Posts
    46

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Quote Originally Posted by Kraxis
    Since they are pretty far apart you are going more than a mere 8000 years back in time. You are speaking of perhaps millions of years. That is quite far outside our timeframe of discussion.
    I'm not going to argue that they were not connected, I simply don't know, but not this close as the Indo-Europeans certainly did go down through the Caucasus, which would have been impossible if there had been a sea blocking their way.

    No no. I was talking about millions of years back ofcourse. The theory you were speaking of states that the black sea was once a fresh water lake but if that caspian sea and the black sea were once one sea millions of years ago, than it wouldn't make any sense for the black sea (lake) 8000 years ago to have fresh water since the caspian has salt water. :)

  22. #22
    Magister Vitae Senior Member Kraxis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2002
    Location
    Frederiksberg, Denmark
    Posts
    7,129

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    It is not exclusive...
    It could have been fresh or salt, but the size of the thing leads towards a salt lake. The number of large rivers (the Black Sea is simply ringed by massive numbers of them) would bring enough sediment with them to salt up the lake. How salt is impossible to know.
    You may not care about war, but war cares about you!


  23. #23
    Patria Nostra Romania Member Gemenii XIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Colonia Ulpia Traiana Augusta Dacica Sarmisegetusa
    Posts
    46

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    If the black lake had salt water than both theories stand

  24. #24
    "'elp! I'm bein' repressed!" Senior Member Aenlic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    The live music capital of the world.
    Posts
    1,583

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Quote Originally Posted by Kraxis
    Actually he was looking down by Turkey as he was really looking for Byzantine wrecks and not settlements but the slow Turkish authorities forced him to do something with his time. Impressive that he can use the sparetime to do somethat that spectacular... He has got to be the most talented sea hunter (sorry Clive but Bob wins hands down).
    Then it was probably the Sakarya river channel that he explored, not the Danube. That would have been Byzantine Paphlagonia.

    And the Indo-Europeans certainly did go down into the Caucasus. Armenian and the extinct Hittite, and the northern Iranian languages such as Ossetian are all Indo-European.

    There are two competing main theories for the genesis of proto-Indo-European. The most commonly accepted one is the Kurgan hypothesis, setting the genesis with the Kurgan peoples of the Yamna culture which stretched the length of the northern Black Sea shore to the northern Caspian Sea shore from 4000-3500 BCE.

    The competing theory, which I favor, is that the base language developed much earlier around 4500-3500 BCE, with the Black Sea flood as the instigating force for the spread. I had my dating off, by the way. The date for the deluge is around 5600 BCE, which makes it about 7500 years ago not 7500 BCE. Anyway, the Sredny Stov culture which was located on the north shore of the Sea of Azov (which was created when the Black Sea deluge occurred) predates and is the ancestor of the Yamna culture. It is postulated as the Urheimat or homeland of proto-Indo-European. More recent finds for this culture came after the Kurgan hypothesis gained widespread acceptance.

    An interesting aside, the Sredny Stov culture shows evidence of the domestication of the horse; and if correct would be the earliest evidence so far, slightly beating out the Samara culture for the record. Sredny Stov is also contemporary with the early proto-Thracian culture at Varna which has the current record for the earliest gold mining and working. Both would have been forced to their eventual sites by the Black Sea deluge, if the deluge theory is correct. This would make them both much more closely related. And if the proto-Maykop culture along the southern and eastern shore of the Black Sea has similar origins in the deluge, then I think it gives even more weight to my view of the origin of the language roots.
    "Dee dee dee!" - Annoymous (the "differently challenged" and much funnier twin of Anonymous)

  25. #25
    Magister Vitae Senior Member Kraxis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2002
    Location
    Frederiksberg, Denmark
    Posts
    7,129

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Well, the flood does seem a rather likely event for a mass exodus that spread in all directions (all the way to India for instance).
    And the flood is deeply ingrated in our minds, though that i not so great an argument as we can go back to when Britain was landlocked with Europe with a great plain in the North Sea. Also, there was a massive flood when the water broke through at Gibraltar.
    You may not care about war, but war cares about you!


  26. #26

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    I am born in Pleven, Bulgaria. My mother is from the lands of the Thracian tribe mizi and my father's family were refugees from Macedonia, near the Ohrid lake. I am who I am.

  27. #27

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Holy , someone quoted from Encarta encyclopedia in this thread. Speaking of ancient tribes...

    Venerable necro.
    Vitiate Man.

    History repeats the old conceits
    The glib replies, the same defeats


    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 



  28. #28
    Praefectus Fabrum Senior Member Anime BlackJack Champion, Flash Poker Champion, Word Up Champion, Shape Game Champion, Snake Shooter Champion, Fishwater Challenge Champion, Rocket Racer MX Champion, Jukebox Hero Champion, My House Is Bigger Than Your House Champion, Funky Pong Champion, Cutie Quake Champion, Fling The Cow Champion, Tiger Punch Champion, Virus Champion, Solitaire Champion, Worm Race Champion, Rope Walker Champion, Penguin Pass Champion, Skate Park Champion, Watch Out Champion, Lawn Pac Champion, Weapons Of Mass Destruction Champion, Skate Boarder Champion, Lane Bowling Champion, Bugz Champion, Makai Grand Prix 2 Champion, White Van Man Champion, Parachute Panic Champion, BlackJack Champion, Stans Ski Jumping Champion, Smaugs Treasure Champion, Sofa Longjump Champion Seamus Fermanagh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Latibulm mali regis in muris.
    Posts
    11,450

    Default Re: True descendants of the Thracians

    Quote Originally Posted by Born on the Balcans View Post
    ...I am who I am.
    Tautology, the one truth of philosophy.
    "The only way that has ever been discovered to have a lot of people cooperate together voluntarily is through the free market. And that's why it's so essential to preserving individual freedom.” -- Milton Friedman

    "The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule." -- H. L. Mencken

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO