Mafia v. Cult [Concluded]

[El Barto]

This is a semi-open setup. There will be three factions in this game.
1) The town, uninformed majority which wins by eliminating all others.
2) The mafia, who kill people at night and win by outnumbering all other factions.
3) The cult, who attempt to outnumber everyone else by converting them into their faction.

-Mafia cannot be converted by the cult.
-Cult will get a starting nightkill immunity.
-There will be some town characters impervious to either the mafia's nightkill or the Cult's conversion (same number of both, total number announced when game starts).
-Some other roles might be available if there are more players than the bare minimum. I'll decide whether to announce them depending on what roles they are.
-Editing posts is not allowed.
-I haven't decided yet whether to allow private communication or not. It depends, partly, on the number of players.

Day will last 48 RL hours, Night 24. Tied votes are to be settled by tiebreaker rounds.

I'd really like there to be at the very least 20 players.

Join! Join! Join!

1. Raith Kemmler
2. Choxorn
3. Jarema
4. Golden1Knight
5. Csargo
6. GeneralHankerchief, wha be owin' me ten doubloon
7. seireikhaan
8. Zain
9. Pelican
10. landlubber
11. Al Sipsclar
12. Kenning
13. BSmith
14. Askthepizzaguy
15. Cuthillius
16. Zack
17. Sooh
18. Scarlett Aria
19. Visorslash
20. Severing Viper.

Reserves:
1. atheotes

The game's started in post #52 of this same thread.
Day One (post #140): ScarlettAria is lynched.
Night One (post #150): BSmith is killed by the mafia.
Day Two (post #240): Zack is lynched.
Night Two (post #258): Kennigit is killed by the mafia.
Day Three (post #359): seireikhaan is lynched.
Night Three (post #381): No one is killed.
Day Four (post #459): Golden1Knight is lynched after a tiebreaker vote.
Night Four (post #468): GeneralHankerchief is killed by the mafia.
Day Five (post #555): Askthepizzaguy is lynched.
Night Five (post #570): Visorslash is killed by the mafia.
Day Six (post #609): Pelican, Cultist leader, is lynched.
Night Six (post #620): Csargo is killed by the mafia.
Day Seven (post #640): Al Sipsclar is lynched.
Night Seven (post #645): Sooh, Cultist leader, is killed by the mafia.
Day Eight (post #762): Cuthillius is lynched.
Night Eight (post #773): Zack II is killed by the mafia.
Day Nine (post #814): Jarema is lynched.

People marked with a double question mark (??) are yet to confirm their signing up.

[Raith Kemmler]

Battle royal? More than 2 sides?

I am in.

[Choxorn]

Intergalactic.

[Jarema]

-There will be some town characters impervious to either the mafia's nightkill or the Cult's conversion (same number of both, total number announced when game starts).

I am really concerned about balance here. Converting player to your cause is much much more powerful than just killing him. I think that either there should be more players immune to conversion than to night kill (or even no players immune to night kill besides cult leader), or there should be more anti-cult than anti-mafia roles on the town side

anyway, it seems to be interesting. In.

[Golden1Knight]

In.

[Csargo]

In.

[landlubber]

In.

[El Barto]

I am really concerned about balance here. Converting player to your cause is much much more powerful than just killing him. I think that either there should be more players immune to conversion than to night kill (or even no players immune to night kill besides cult leader), or there should be more anti-cult than anti-mafia roles on the town side

Worry not, my Eastern European friend, this is why the setup is only semi-open. :)

[GeneralHankerchief]

[GeneralHankerchief]

7. @GeneralHankerchief: could you make it an infractable offense not to join?

Only in games I host. Abuse of power is way more fun when it's selective.

[seireikhaan]

[Zain]

I will play.

[landlubber]

Have to drop out of this-- my life just got a lot more busy

[Pelican]

Hi! I'm interested, but before I join I want to be sure of the general environment. I see a lot of players I recognize from GitP and CivFanatics around here, is the vibe here similar? I ask because I'm looking for some more games but I don't think I could handle anything above a casual level of play and I don't want to be a letdown to my team and the other players in general.

[El Barto]

Yes, the style is largely casual but you are expected to play seriously and be at least midly useful (well, that's what your teammates will expect… otherwise they'll lynch you for inactivity if, or rather when, they run out of ideas, which for such imaginative people happens surprisingly often).

[landlubber]

Rejoining.

[Al Sipsclar]

Rejoicing.

[Kennigit]

I'll probably join, but I'll confirm later

[BSmith]

I'll join against my better judgement. (general RL issues and yet more international work travel in the next couple of weeks - I'll be in Dublin from 1/26 to 2/1 if anyone here will be there and wants to meet up. Let me know).

[Pelican]

Yes, the style is largely casual but you are expected to play seriously and be at least midly useful (well, that's what your teammates will expect… otherwise they'll lynch you for inactivity if, or rather when, they run out of ideas, which for such imaginative people happens surprisingly often).

Alrighty, thanks. I'll be in then.

[Kennigit]

I'll confirm I'll be in

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'm in nothing right now, but I generally don't invest heavily in a town v mafia v cult setup.

So when I join and say I'm a meat shield...

Cue Zack pointing out it's never been true approximately now.

Meat shield pizza. You need the bodies, I'll be a body.

[Cuthillius]

probably be in my best interests not to, but...

I can't not, really, if pizza's in. I just realized. Have we even played together? If so, when? I remember playing in each other's games, but...

hm

And hey everyone else!

[Askthepizzaguy]

probably be in my best interests not to, but...

I can't not, really, if pizza's in. I just realized. Have we even played together? If so, when? I remember playing in each other's games, but...

hm

And hey everyone else!

Yes, I remember lynching you over on CFC not too long ago.

[Cuthillius]

Yes, I remember lynching you over on CFC not too long ago.

Ah, right. The game when I was gone.

[Zack]

FINE!

[Raith Kemmler]

I'm in nothing right now, but I generally don't invest heavily in a town v mafia v cult setup.

What's don't you like with a battle royal?

[El Barto]

'Mon lads, we're nearly there! Only four more players for a decent start!

[Askthepizzaguy]

What's don't you like with a battle royal?

Not my cup of tea, prefer straight mafia v town.

[Sooh]

I'll in if you make me vanilla :P