Log in

View Full Version : EB Summer Mini-release: Historical Battles



abou
07-30-2008, 18:24
http://img37.picoodle.com/img/img37/4/7/13/f_release0m_a61b0f1.jpg

Chairete! The EB Team is proud to release four historical battles to satisfy and whet your appetite at the same time for future releases. Included in this release are (in chronological order) The Battle of Ipsos, The Battle of Raphia, The Battle of Panion, and The Battle of Magnesia.

http://img33.picoodle.com/img/img33/4/7/13/f_release1m_49ba063.jpg

But wait. Weren’t these battles supposed to be released a long time ago and be a part of The Antiochos III Battle Pack?

Yes, they were. Unfortunately, reality set in. The truth is that making these battles and getting the AI to perform how you want is frustrating and probably impossible (on top of research and terraforming). Scripting, once seen as salvation and now a limitation, is not a very good solution as the script and the AI seem to be in conflict with each other. A possible solution was to create new army formations for the AI, but lamentably no one stepped forward to help.

Other problems included inherent difficulties with more than two armies on the field. In previous versions the ratio of these large battles was 25:1. After much time spent learning the nuances of historical battles, 50:1 seemed to be the better arrangement as each side could be reduced to one army each. Regardless, problems in AI behavior continued.

After a year in traction it has been decided that the battles should be released lest they never be released at all. A consequence of this is that the way they play is not ideal and the AI often rearranges itself or does things that it quite frankly should not because the army formations don’t exist for the engine to access. Therefore, as a word of warning, don’t be upset if you fire up Magnesia and you wonder to yourself just what the hell the Seleukid army is doing.

In the case of Panion, and to a lesser extent Magnesia, it should actually be considered a multiplayer battle. Even then, don’t let certain things get in the way of your enjoyment. Go ahead and give it a shot.

Finally, due to time constraints the description for Magnesia is being released incomplete. In the future it will be completed, but in order to make a summer release before the fall semester it was necessary to leave it at the current 4,000+ words. Look for the dashes signaling breaks in the narrative.

http://img33.picoodle.com/img/img33/4/7/13/f_release2m_794c903.jpg

Why are all the battles about the Seleukids?

That is a good question; a question that has several parts for its answer.

First and foremost, the battles involving the Seleukids (and Antiochos III in particular) are fairly well documented. Not only do we have historians such as Livy and Polybios, but also references here and there among authors that give us information. These battles also have major effects on several regions on the EB map as a result of their aftermath so their importance cannot be questioned. Perhaps the historian John D. Grainger put it best in describing his attempts to get approval for a book on Antiochos III:

So a king who ruled all the lands from India to Greece for a third of a century is not regarded as a suitable subject, yet the half-mad emperors Nero and Caligula rate repeated study. The effect on world-history of these two men must be rated as minimal; that of Antiochos is almost as great as that of Alexander or Constantine.

To touch upon another reason, EB is about educating others on history. The Seleukids have for the past several decades slipped under the radar. To paraphrase historian Frank L. Holt, there is this chasm between Alexander the Great and Rome, which is usually leapt over and not given a second glance. The EB Team finds this to be a great disappointment because the Hellenistic age should not be viewed through Rome-colored lenses – especially with the recent publications of new examinations on the subject. So the object is to pull (if just for a moment and only gently) the player’s attention away from Italy and toward the usually ignored and vast expanses of Asia.

http://img33.picoodle.com/img/img33/4/7/13/f_release4m_28481ce.jpg

What about other battles? Battles such as Cannae!

A lot of battles were planned and have had at least some work done on them. As stated earlier, reality got the better of them. There were many such as The Battle of Sellasia and The Battle of Bibracte as well as a few others focusing on Antiochos III. They still may be completed, but who knows when.

Cannae, however, seems to be the one battle that keeps coming up; however, it should be mentioned that in all honesty the battle would be impossible. The amount of scripting required to achieve that historic victory is well beyond the limits of the engine to be done as a playable battle – let alone a person. Besides, everyone knows about the slaughter at Cannae, but does everyone know about the near-total destruction of the Ptolemaic army at Panion? There is a reason that it is sometimes referred to as The Great Battle of Panion.

http://img34.picoodle.com/img/img34/4/7/13/f_release5m_d59a56c.jpg

So what can be expected for the future?

Who knows? Given time there could be several more battles. As mentioned above, there are a few that are at least partially completed. Until then, enjoy these four and keep your fingers crossed.

http://img37.picoodle.com/img/img37/4/7/13/f_release6m_c3d61f8.jpg

To Install

Download the file here (https://www.europabarbarorum.com/ccount11/click.php?id=48) or at the Europa Barbarorum website. The file is a self-extracting archive made by the excellent program 7zip. Simply make your "Rome - Total War" folder you target directory and extract.


A big thanks to PicOodle! for the image hosting.

This is savegame compatible.

||Lz3||
07-30-2008, 18:32
:jawdrop: ~:shock:
YAY!! :bounce: :medievalcheers:

overweightninja
07-30-2008, 18:34
Cheers team!

TWFanatic
07-30-2008, 18:53
Reading that made me feel almost guilty for not studying Seleucid history. I am guilty of virtually everything abou mentioned about the flaws and shortcomings of the study of this period of history. I am ashamed to admit that I heard of the battle of Panion before. They just don't teach this stuff. My local public and college libraries don't have any literature on the Seleucid Empire except for that viewed within the narrow prism of Roman imperialism.

That is why I am glad to have EB, it has certainly broadened my horizons. Kudos to the team for releasing these battles even if the artificial unintelligence won't do what it's supposed to. Nobody will hold that against you.

Leviathan DarklyCute
07-30-2008, 19:21
FUCK YEAH I LOVE YOU I WANNA HAVE YOUR BABIES FUUUUUUUUUUCK
don't take it the wrong way...

Dutchhoplite
07-30-2008, 19:31
Great work guys :beam:

I haven´t been trough all the battles yet but at the Ipsos battle the Makedonian elephants turn into ballerinas, turning little circles, and the rest of their army starts milling around...

People with the same problem??

satalexton
07-30-2008, 19:37
oh my, perhaps I should stop rolling over the AS for once and play as AS...

eliad91
07-30-2008, 20:30
Very good! :medievalcheers:
3 cheers to the EB team :rtwyes::rtwyes::rtwyes: !

Anakuj
07-30-2008, 20:56
Thank You abou, and any other EB members who contributed in this great pack!!! The battles are incredible! :2thumbsup:

Hooahguy
07-30-2008, 21:03
does this work with v1.0? :shame:

Sarkiss
07-30-2008, 21:15
awesome, thanks!:thumbsup:

Kepper
07-30-2008, 21:42
Thanks :2thumbsup::2thumbsup:

Sir Edward
07-31-2008, 03:27
amazing work way to pull out all the stops. I will be sure to check it out this weekend, very excited.

Tartaros
07-31-2008, 04:08
Great work!!:beam:

DeathEmperor
07-31-2008, 05:37
Words cannot express my gratitude, but I shall do the best with what I know.

As a fan, researcher and historian of the Seleukids and the Diadokhoi I extend the most sincerest and heartfelt thank you to the EB team both for making these battles and bringing the spotlight upon this overlooked period of history. I literally have tears of joy in my eyes just thank you for this!

:balloon2::balloon2::2thumbsup::2thumbsup::balloon2::balloon2:

Leão magno
07-31-2008, 09:52
Impressive... as always!!!!!! About asia being forgotten... Remember the Barbarians too!

Maion Maroneios
07-31-2008, 16:39
Wonderful guys, again ashtonished by what you've managed to pull off!

General Appo
07-31-2008, 18:20
Wow, freaking great! Played all of them, and even though I´ll agree that the Seleukids were a bit crazy at Magnesia, it was really good play.

Reno Melitensis
07-31-2008, 20:17
Lets history repeat itself, to war :skull:we march.

I am very proud to play EB. Many Thanks.

Cheers.

brymht
07-31-2008, 21:31
hmmm. I click on the link and see "page not found"

Tartaros
07-31-2008, 22:39
"page not found"
probably your firewall to high?
i have to unable my firewall for downloading.

Tellos Athenaios
08-01-2008, 00:08
Either that, or try right click -> save target as.

||Lz3||
08-01-2008, 01:32
I actually started a Seleukid campaign after playing those battles even when I had said before that I would keep away of phalanx based factions :2thumbsup: those battles are awesome :balloon:

abou
08-01-2008, 03:30
Glad to hear you guys are enjoying yourselves. I hope that some of you are willing to give Panion and Magnesia a try as multiplayer battles.

I suppose this also means we will have some awesome screenshots for this month, right?

TWFanatic
08-01-2008, 03:42
I wouldn't take screenshots from historical battles--too small.

||Lz3||
08-01-2008, 06:46
I have a quite good -in my opinon- screenshot of the battle of Ipsos, I'm just waiting for the contest :beam:

keravnos
08-01-2008, 12:26
Abou has gone above and beyond... Again! :yes:

ΕΥΓΕ!

Ibrahim
08-01-2008, 16:19
sweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeet!

sadly though, my laptop is off for repairs (broken screen)

Leviathan DarklyCute
08-02-2008, 00:12
Say, what about the Battle of Zama? Could we see it in the future? That would be awesome!

Gaivs
08-02-2008, 12:56
I wish I was able to recreate Ilipa, Id love to see that battle played out. Africanus' best battle by far.

abou
08-03-2008, 00:37
Those battles are certainly possibilities, it is just a matter of whether I'm interested enough to work on them. I would like to finish Bibracte at some point, maybe take a look at Pelusion, or do one of the battles from the Maccabees revolt.

Ilipia is the more interesting battle to me, but Zama would be easier. It depends on how I'm feeling and what time is available to me during the fall semester. Since the historical battles can be a somewhat separate branch from the rest of the mod - they're ability to be implemented without affecting the campaign game at all - I suppose I could put it to a vote if I were feeling democratic enough and leave their development a bit more open. As it stands though, I'm not feeling very democratic at all. :laugh4:

TWFanatic
08-05-2008, 23:27
Didn't you do Bibracte already? As for Zama, I recall that was done as well.

abou
08-06-2008, 06:01
Yeah, but neither were really of the quality for an official release by the EB team. I would have to rework terrain and units and everything. I'm also a bit of a perfectionist with my army placement - that's why the lines look so sharp when you start these battles, which also requires a bit of time.

Megas Methuselah
08-08-2008, 07:33
Holy ******* ****... :wacko:

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOH!!!!!
ROGIN?!
WOLOLOLOLOLOOOO!!!!!

*strips off clothes to command the battles, roleplaying as a Gaesatae*

BASP BASP BASP!!!!!!!

TWFanatic
08-15-2008, 23:11
@abou: Yes it is very hard to get lines straight and even. For some reason, they are always a little thinner then they appeared to be in the battle editor. It takes forever to get them just right.

My first go at Raphia:

https://img166.imageshack.us/img166/1232/rometwalx20080815175100su9.png

https://img169.imageshack.us/img169/7155/rometwalx20080815175107np8.png

I withdrew all of my heavy infantry (phalangites and royal guards) and won the battle purely with my cavalry, light infantry, and elephants on level hard. This was due not to any genius on my part; I simply drove off the enemy elephants on either flank with missiles and/or my own elephants then turned my ele inwards and rolled up the enemy phalanx from both flanks. With their formation completely broken, I charged my cavalry and light infantry in, effectively routing all of their phalangites, Galatians, Hoplites, and cavalry on contact. By this point, I had only a few casualties amongst my light infantry due to missiles and my cavalry due to the charge--I must have had a guardian PETA protestor watching over me because not one elephant fell. The rest of the battle was simply mopping up. I lost one ele eventually to some javelins from a rallied unit of Galatian mercenaries and some light infantry to a rallied elephant unit, but other than that casualties were minimal.

The same tactic works in pretty much all of the battles that have elephants in them. It's a piece of cake because the AI does not have a clue how to counter elephants. Its skirmishers do what their name implies--skirmish--before releasing a single volley of javelins and phalanx-flanks make excellent targets with their densely packed formations.

LusitanianWolf
08-17-2008, 18:55
Yay, this one, I wanst expecting :2thumbsup:

Atraphoenix
08-22-2008, 18:49
:smash: thanks I hope it will go on ... :smash:

||Lz3||
12-31-2009, 00:49
Does somebody have the files? it seems that they cannot be downloaded anymore. =(

And I really want to play magnesia.

Skullheadhq
12-31-2009, 11:01
They're already in 1.2, and I think Magnesia is bugged.
Didn't had this in this bug in the pack through...

spiritusdilutus
12-31-2009, 11:12
They're already in 1.2, and I think Magnesia is bugged.
Didn't had this in this bug in the pack through...

Yeah! Same here. I experience a CTD everytime I try to launch Magnesia. :furious3: :wall:

spiritusdilutus
12-31-2009, 11:26
Wait.. Everything is fine, now that I have installed the pack again. No more bugs :2thumbsup:

||Lz3||
12-31-2009, 20:01
They're already in 1.2, and I think Magnesia is bugged.
Didn't had this in this bug in the pack through...

Yep, that's why I'm asking for the pack, since the files in 1.2 are bugged.

Could someone please upload it?

||Lz3||
01-07-2010, 20:19
No one? =(

Skullheadhq
01-07-2010, 20:33
ftp://ftp.europabarbarorum.org/EB_historical_battles.exe

||Lz3||
01-08-2010, 20:40
Thank you, very much. :bow:

Weebeast
01-08-2010, 23:36
I remember playing as Crassus and the game froze during cut scene when Surena died. I'm going to assume this fixes it and also Magnesia of course. Many thanks.