Log in

View Full Version : The Proscription (Small Mafia Game) [Concluded]



Warmaster Horus
07-31-2008, 15:21
Well, I believe it's my turn. So here's a new small mafia game, hosted by yours truly, Warmaster Horus.

Setting: It is 82BC, and the Roman Republic is in turmoil. Sulla has been named Dictator to restore the Res Publica, and to "purge" the Senate, he has decided to use proscription (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proscription) against his foes. In the Great City, there are many informers who work for him.
In a villa not far from Rome, Sulla has invited 12 Senators, and placed them in the care of his freedman Lucius Cornelius Chrysogonus.
Unfortunately, amongst these Senators are 2 informers, whose objective is to kill the ten others. Upon learning this, the Senators decide to take action, but they don't know who is an informer.
Daily, the twelve will convene and choose, democratically, who will be considered as an informer. Death will follow.

Roles:
9 townies, 1 pro-townie and 2 informers. Pretty much standard setup, really. The pro-townie role will be hidden until the end of the game.

Rules:
Standard rules. Votes and un-votes must be bolded (eg vote:WH). You must unvote AND write the name of your original vote before changing your vote (eg unvote:WH, vote:Andres)
Voting takes place in the day as usual and townies can do nothing at night. No revealing in private, all reveals must be made in this thread. The dead cannot post their night actions or roles but can still speak and advise. No pictures, no quoting PMs... You know, the usual stuff.

Added info:
The game starts in a day phase, and one kill per night.

Signed up: 12/12
Factionheir
Quintus.J.Cicero
Caius
Ichigo
El Diablo
Sarathos
Fenring
makaikhaan
anelious phyros
Eliit Tuhkur
Andres
Sigurd Fafnesbane

Sign ups closed, pms going out.

FactionHeir
07-31-2008, 15:31
In. How many night kills?

Quintus.JC
07-31-2008, 17:44
Finally a chance to be a senator, count me in. :yes:

Caius
07-31-2008, 18:50
Wanted to be senator in some AAR and couldn't, now I have a chance

Csargo
07-31-2008, 18:50
:soapbox:

El Diablo
07-31-2008, 23:01
Hey I am in.

Sarathos
08-01-2008, 00:51
Throw me in.

Kralizec
08-01-2008, 14:43
In.

seireikhaan
08-02-2008, 01:37
:charge:

anelious phyros
08-02-2008, 02:56
I"M IN! But i'll be kinda inactive through out it, alot of work I have.:grin3:

Ferret
08-04-2008, 10:29
you called?

Warmaster Horus
08-04-2008, 10:50
Yep, can I consider you in?

If so, then I'd like only 2 more. If nobody comes up in the next 36 hours, I'll start the game with a night phase.

Ferret
08-04-2008, 14:55
yeah I'll be in, I'll be in Germany for a couple of days but should still be able to play.

Warmaster Horus
08-06-2008, 01:12
Because of RL issues and other stuff, sign ups will be open for about another day.

Andres
08-08-2008, 13:34
Can I still be in?

Warmaster Horus
08-08-2008, 14:40
Of course. I've been busy working on the mini-mod for the EB interactive campaign (shameless advertising here: follow my sig!), but the roles are prepared and I'll send them out tonight.

Quintus.JC
08-09-2008, 12:34
Isn't this supposed to be started already...

Sigurd
08-09-2008, 12:48
If you want an extra player to fill the last spot, I am willing to step in.

Warmaster Horus
08-09-2008, 14:23
Ah, cheers Sigurd!
Now I don't have a reason to delay this... Sending PMs now.

Warmaster Horus
08-09-2008, 15:02
And it's on! All PMs are sent, and if you guys have any questions, just PM me.
The game starts with a night phase. So those who have a pm to send me, send it!
Day one starts in 24 hours.

FactionHeir
08-09-2008, 15:09
*is horrified at the current chaos*

anelious phyros
08-09-2008, 15:22
*is horrified at the current chaos*

Current Chaos?

Sarathos
08-10-2008, 01:58
Are we going to start or keeping questioningWarmaster PM's?

Csargo
08-10-2008, 02:30
FoS: Anelious

anelious phyros
08-10-2008, 02:57
Are we going to start or keeping questioningWarmaster PM's?

we've already started I think.

Ferret
08-10-2008, 12:35
yeah it's night phase so there's not much talking but we have started.

Quintus.JC
08-10-2008, 14:36
FoS: All the Optimates. :stare:

Warmaster Horus
08-10-2008, 16:24
Night one finished.

On the morning after the arrival of the 12 guests, they were to meet up for lunch. One of them didn't come: Sigurd Fafnesbane. The Senators marched to his room, and discovered his dead body on the floor, a dagger stuck in his throat.
One of the Senators declared: "This is the work of informers! I advise that we try to find who the murderer is." Sulla's freedman, amused, said: "Indeed, you eleven choose one of you to die tonight. We'll see how far this brings you..."

Night One summary:

Killed:
Sigurd Fafnesbane

Alive:
Factionheir
Quintus.J.Cicero
Caius
Ichigo
El Diablo
Sarathos
Fenring
makaikhaan
anelious phyros
Eliit Tuhkur
Andres

Day One has started; you have 24 hours. Vote!

FactionHeir
08-10-2008, 16:29
vote: anelious

anelious phyros
08-10-2008, 16:35
Vote:ET
random.

Caius
08-10-2008, 16:43
Vote:Andres

Andres
08-10-2008, 16:50
Vote : Ichigo

Csargo
08-10-2008, 17:09
Vote:anelious

You're sooooo mean Andres. I've been a good little senator.

Sigurd
08-10-2008, 20:16
Damn you Sulla.. I'll get you for this. My ghost will breach the boundaries of Elysium and hunt you and your cronies. Watch over your shoulder, I might be there :stare:.

El Diablo
08-10-2008, 20:54
Vote Fenring

Random and I have no clues....................................yet....

ED

Ferret
08-10-2008, 21:50
alphabetical voting FTW!

vote:Andres

Andres
08-10-2008, 21:57
One day, I'm going to change my username into "myself"...

Caius
08-10-2008, 22:45
One day, I'm going to change my username into "myself"...
Abstain might do the trick.

FactionHeir
08-10-2008, 22:46
How about Aandres :tongue2:

Quintus.JC
08-10-2008, 23:04
We need to sort out our Populares and Optimates.

anelious phyros
08-10-2008, 23:20
We need to sort out our Populares and Optimates.

I call populars!

Sarathos
08-11-2008, 10:49
So, whats happening guys...

Andres
08-11-2008, 11:10
Nothing unusual, just me getting lynched because my name starts with an A :mean:

Warmaster Horus
08-11-2008, 16:57
Tally:
Anelious: 2 (FactionHeir, Ichigo)
Andres: 2 (Caius, Eliit Tuhkur)

Eliit Tuhkur: 1 (anelious phyros)
Ichigo: 1 (Andres)
Fenring: 1 (El Diablo)

You've got 4 hours or so to untie this. If in 4 hours, there's still a tie, both get lynched :evil:

Quintus.JC
08-11-2008, 18:04
Lynching both of them is a bit harsh... who is more likely to be innocent?

I have absolutly no idea right now. :embarassed:

Kralizec
08-11-2008, 18:16
A threeway lynch might be fun, but it didn't exactly help in Soviet Mafia. So...

Vote: Anelious

Caius
08-11-2008, 20:06
A threeway lynch might be fun, but it didn't exactly help in Soviet Mafia. So...

Vote: Anelious
Why did you save your buddy Andres?

Andres
08-11-2008, 20:17
Unvote; Vote : Anelious

Nothing wrong with self-preservation :shrug:


Why did you save your buddy Andres?

Or maybe Fenring is a mafioso who wants to keep me alive instead of anelious, because people have a bad habit of lynching me when I'm innocent...

FactionHeir
08-11-2008, 20:36
I thought there is only one anti-town?

Sarathos
08-11-2008, 23:32
Or maybe Fenring is a mafioso who wants to keep me alive instead of anelious, because people have a bad habit of lynching me when I'm innocent...
Exactly the same story with me, and I always get lynched.
Vote:Andres

anelious phyros
08-12-2008, 02:15
I wasn't going to Andres but just for that -

unvote:ET voted:Andres

Caius
08-12-2008, 03:49
Unvote:Andres
Vote:Anelious

Not so fast.

EDIT:Actually, Andres and Anelious will have to be lynched. WH gave 4 hours, and the tie was not broken at all.

Kralizec
08-12-2008, 04:34
Or maybe Fenring is a mafioso who wants to keep me alive instead of anelious, because people have a bad habit of lynching me when I'm innocent...

You have insulted my honour. As a Roman, there's only one thing I can do.

Unvote: Anelious
Vote: Andres

El Diablo
08-12-2008, 05:06
Hold on that make it a tie again and that makes it no good for the Senate..

Thus a toss of the coin... tails.

Unvote Fenring vote Anelious

My appologies if I have gotten this wrong..

FoS Fenring for attempting to get the double lynch

ED

Andres
08-12-2008, 08:55
Unvote:Andres
Vote:Anelious

Not so fast.

EDIT:Actually, Andres and Anelious will have to be lynched. WH gave 4 hours, and the tie was not broken at all.

I think the tie was broken when Fenring voted anelious.

Interesting developments afterwards though...

Quintus.JC
08-12-2008, 10:27
Someone needs to do a tally. Who exactly's gonna be lynched? :dizzy2:

Warmaster Horus
08-12-2008, 11:31
Sorry it's about 14 hours late. Family issues I don't want to delve in.
That said, all votes have counted.

Tally:
anelious: 5 (FactionHeir, Ichigo, Andres, Caius, El Diablo)
Andres: 4 (Eliit Tuhkur, Sarathos, anelious phyros, Fenring)

anelious is lynched! Write up to be inserted when I can do it.

Lynched:
anelious phyros

Killed:
Sigurd Fafnesbane

Alive:
Factionheir
Quintus.J.Cicero
Caius
Ichigo
El Diablo
Sarathos
Fenring
makaikhaan
Eliit Tuhkur
Andres

Day One over; pms please.

Andres
08-12-2008, 12:14
I'm still alive :jumping:

FactionHeir
08-12-2008, 12:50
So explain why we voted Andres again?

Ferret
08-12-2008, 13:53
Because his name starts with an A :laugh4:

anelious phyros
08-12-2008, 14:09
Oc, too bad gents. Really stupid thing to do, oh well. I'll drop by now and then to see if I can help.

Warmaster Horus
08-12-2008, 16:56
Day 2:

At the dawn of the next day, all the Senators alive were anxious. Were there going to be more deaths? This was confirmed when makaikhaan's body was discovered in the middle of the entrance hall, with a large kitchen knife planted in his throat. Once more, Sulla's freedman proposed democracy to try to rat out the informer.

Lynched:
anelious phyros

Dead:
Sigurd Fafnesbane
makaikhaan

Alive:
Factionheir
Quintus.J.Cicero
Caius
Ichigo
El Diablo
Sarathos
Fenring
Eliit Tuhkur
Andres

Day 2 has started; vote :whip:

FactionHeir
08-12-2008, 17:42
Hmmm I don't really see why someone killed makaikhaan. He didn't seem active at all in this game in the first place. But it seems that this someone knows of his potential...

Now my analysis. There was only 5 hours between night and day so anyone not active during that time is obviously innocent.

El Diablo, Sarathos: Not even online - definite innocent
Sigurd, Caius, Ichigo: Cannot tell last online, but haven't posted during that time. Possible innocent.

Andres, myself, Quintus, Elite Ferret, Fenring all active during that time - possible guilty.


Still, vote:Andres

You escaped narrowly. What do you have to say?

FoS: QJC and Fenring A hunch.

Quintus.JC
08-12-2008, 18:27
Lots of people aren't talking too much.

@Faction heir.

My hunch tells me that El Diablo's time has come, I just feels that he is the mafia, in this one or possiblily in Caius's one. Sarathos we can presume innocent...probably.

For now no voting from me yet.

Ferret
08-12-2008, 18:59
FH has a good point about the time (even though it makes me possibly guilty :laugh4:) so I'll vote:Andres as well, because he is on that list and I want a vote that means something, rather than all on that list getting one vote...

El Diablo
08-12-2008, 20:57
"Once again I come back to the senate forum to see my name besmirched by senators who see shadows at every corner. As proven by independant sources I was not even online when the alleged assassination occured. Yet you still fear me. My name and honour are above reproach"

That wee bit of IC dribble is just my way of stating that not only was it not me it COULD NOT have even BEEN me!

Vote Fenring Start talking - this game and Caius's

Quintus.JC
08-12-2008, 21:08
Ok, so the alibi proves El Diablo to be innocent, my attention is fixed to Ichigo, Fenring and Caius then, say something the trio.

for now Vote: Fenring

Sarathos
08-13-2008, 01:15
Vote:Ichigo,where art thou Ichigo?

Csargo
08-13-2008, 01:24
Vote:Ichigo,where art thou Ichigo?

Somewhere you don't wanna be...:help:

Sarathos
08-13-2008, 01:47
Somewhere you don't wanna be...
Ok. Unvote, Vote:Fenring.

anelious phyros
08-13-2008, 02:59
Just want to point out the last three posts. (not mine) I'm not sure if there can be 2 kills because of 2 mafia or not but if so then Sarathos and Ichigo look like the guys.

Kralizec
08-13-2008, 04:47
:inquisitive:

You're not seriously suspecting me because of this, are you?

Or maybe Fenring is a mafioso who wants to keep me alive instead of anelious, because people have a bad habit of lynching me when I'm innocent...

Vote: QJC

For posting and witholding a vote at first, then bandwagoning the first vote that comes along.

Sarathos
08-13-2008, 05:07
Just want to point out the last three posts. (not mine) I'm not sure if there can be 2 kills because of 2 mafia or not but if so then Sarathos and Ichigo look like the guys.

Considering there has only been two kills I don't see how you could possibly know who the mafia is.


El Diablo, Sarathos: Not even online - definite innocent
Sigurd, Caius, Ichigo: Cannot tell last online, but haven't posted during that time. Possible innocent.
I do apologise for not being online but as FactionHeir says that does make me innocent.

El Diablo
08-13-2008, 06:01
Okay I have taken a punt on Fenring in another game and will do so again.

QJC you are a bit too quick to jump on the bandwagon....

Unvote Fenring Vote QJC

ED

Quintus.JC
08-13-2008, 09:28
Let me get this clear, how many mafia is in this game?

Because if there're two, then that time equals innocent alibi suggested by Faction Heir would be worth crap because one of the mafia could easily stay off line and let the other do his dirty work, but if there's only one though, then the people offline at that time would be presummed innocent for sure.

Quintus.JC
08-13-2008, 09:31
I don't get the part where people accuses me of too quick to bandwagon, Faction heir and Elite Turkey voted Andres, thats 2 votes. Then El Diablo voted Fenring, then I voted Fenring. Wouldn't me voting Andres be more of a bandwagon then voting Fenring? :inquisitive:

Ferret
08-13-2008, 10:36
Elite Turkey!? HOW DARE YOU! I ought to OMGUS you for that... :clown:

FactionHeir
08-13-2008, 12:03
Oh wait, QJC is right, there are 2.

Scratch my innocence figures.

And that also means he's innocent.

unvote:Andres, vote: Sarathos

Because you have been behaving scummily.

Quintus.JC
08-13-2008, 13:58
Vote: Fenring

He was online, and he could have a partner that was offline at that time. They probably never intended for Faction Heir to come up with his theory, but Fenring looks the most suspicious right now.

Quintus.JC
08-13-2008, 13:59
Oh wait, QJC is right, there are 2.

Scratch my innocence figures.

And that also means he's innocent.

unvote:Andres, vote: Sarathos

Because you have been behaving scummily.

I don't see how that makes Andres to be innocent. :inquisitive:

anelious phyros
08-13-2008, 15:53
Hah! I told you!:grin3: I'm so smart. If i was alive i'd FoS:sarathos. :yes:

seireikhaan
08-13-2008, 17:40
Hmm... I was killed. Interesting. I'd say to vote andres.

Warmaster Horus
08-14-2008, 00:30
Tally:
Fenring: 2 (QJC, Sarathos)
QJC: 2 (Fenring, El Diablo)

Andres: 1 (ET)
Sarathos: 1 (FH)

If I'm not mistaken, it's a tie again.
Once the tie is broken, voting is over and lynching is coming.

Caius
08-14-2008, 03:00
I don't want to break the tie because I do not see too many evidence against both... except that Fenring is inactive.

Ferret
08-14-2008, 11:12
Well that's a good enough reason for me and I didn't see anything against QJC.

unvote:Andres
vote:Fenring

Warmaster Horus
08-14-2008, 12:34
Fenring is lynched.

Lynched:
anelious phyros
Fenring

Dead:
Sigurd Fafnesbane
makaikhaan

Alive:
Factionheir
Quintus.J.Cicero
Caius
Ichigo
El Diablo
Sarathos
Eliit Tuhkur
Andres

PMs please. Night lasts 24 hours.

Warmaster Horus
08-15-2008, 21:17
Day 3 starting.
As the remaining Senators gather for lunch, Sulla's freedman announces: "Ichigo has died during the night. You know the drill."

Lynched:
anelious phyros
Fenring

Dead:
Sigurd Fafnesbane
makaikhaan
Ichigo

Alive:
Factionheir
Quintus.J.Cicero
Caius
El Diablo
Sarathos
Eliit Tuhkur
Andres

Day 3 starts, 24 hours to vote.

anelious phyros
08-15-2008, 22:14
Odd...why kill Ichigo? Random? This is very odd. Wasn't he at the point to suspicion?

Csargo
08-15-2008, 22:16
:tongue: Truth is I was really mafia, but I was becoming too suspicious, so I killed myself to seem innocent :evil:

FactionHeir
08-15-2008, 22:48
vote:Sarathos

Quintus.JC
08-15-2008, 22:49
Killing Ichigo does seem odd, I don't think he's active that much...

Quintus.JC
08-15-2008, 22:51
vote:Sarathos

Care to explain why?

Ferret
08-15-2008, 22:59
He's another lurker I guess, I'm gonna vote:Sarathos until he at least makes a post this round.

Quintus.JC
08-15-2008, 23:25
He's another lurker I guess, I'm gonna vote:Sarathos until he at least makes a post this round.

He will, cos if he don't then he'll obvious been lynched.

FactionHeir
08-15-2008, 23:27
Sarathos has been acting strangely. Very strangely.

Quintus.JC
08-15-2008, 23:50
Sarathos has been acting strangely. Very strangely.

He was never really the talkative type, but in this game he isn't that aggressive and defensive... unlike he's other games.

anelious phyros
08-16-2008, 00:05
To be honest Sarathos seems normal to me. Lyncing him yet probably isn't best.

FactionHeir
08-16-2008, 00:39
Defending him rather vigorously, are we?

Csargo
08-16-2008, 00:39
Lynch Sarathos

Sarathos
08-16-2008, 00:50
vote:Sarathos
Why may I ask..?

anelious phyros
08-16-2008, 01:05
Defending him rather vigorously, are we?

Nah, not really.

El Diablo
08-16-2008, 03:42
Vote Andres

He seems a bit too quiet..

"Speak up boy!!

Ferret
08-16-2008, 13:55
Very true, Andres hasn't posted since the first round and then it was only to make a vote with no explanation or complain about his name begining with A. Added to this someone who was killed by the mafia said to vote Andres. I think he has more evidence against him than Sarathos so I will

unvote:Sarathos
vote:Andres

Oh and El Diablo, congrats on making it past day one :wink:

Andres
08-17-2008, 20:43
I'm here. Sorry for the lack of participation, I had a very busy week-end.

Vote : Sarathos

I hope I can do some reading tomorrow.

Warmaster Horus
08-17-2008, 20:46
Tally:
Sarathos: 2 (Andres, FH)
Andres: 2 (ET, ED)
Tie; you know what it means: untie it!

And sorry for not stopping the day when I said I would. Family issues again.

Ferret
08-17-2008, 22:17
Thinking about it Andres does have a fairly good excuse, I haven't seen him post much except in LotR, where he is running for the position which requires the most activity, so that could eat up a lot of his time, as well as being a mod...

I don't agree with the evidence about Sarathos but this tie can't go on forever

unvote:Andres

Warmaster Horus
08-17-2008, 22:34
Sarathos has been lynched.

Lynched:
anelious phyros
Fenring
Sarathos

Dead:
Sigurd Fafnesbane
makaikhaan
Ichigo

Alive:
Factionheir
Quintus.J.Cicero
Caius
El Diablo
Eliit Tuhkur
Andres

Day 3 over; PMs please.

Sarathos
08-18-2008, 00:48
Well thats it for me. Sorry for my inactivity Warmaster, its kinda hard keeping up with Migard as it is. Good luck town.

Warmaster Horus
08-18-2008, 01:03
No problem; I understand perfectly, since I'm in there too. I've got probably 1 post per day in that thread, because it's rather confusing...

El Diablo
08-18-2008, 02:32
I got lynched in there because I couldn't keep up!
Go away for a couple of days and 20+ pages are added!

Crazy...

Quintus.JC
08-18-2008, 15:47
I got lynched in there because I couldn't keep up!
Go away for a couple of days and 20+ pages are added!

Crazy...

I got WoGed, at least your death was more honourable than mine. The activities in Migard is just crazy... :dizzy2:

Quintus.JC
08-18-2008, 15:51
Mmmm.... this doesn't look good, I was pretty sure that Sarathos and AP were the bad guys since AP defended Sarathos rather vigorosly when people was voting for him, but the game still doesn't end in town victory. Next round's gonna be critical.

El Diablo
08-18-2008, 23:43
Oh and El Diablo, congrats on making it past day one by Elite Ferret

Ha ha - I am a professional mafia player now. FoS flying left and right!!! Vote and Unvotes - got all the terms down now!

ED

Ferret
08-18-2008, 23:51
:laugh4:

Good for you :2thumbsup:

Warmaster Horus
08-19-2008, 00:15
Night 4 is finished, Caius has died!

Lynched:
anelious phyros
Fenring
Sarathos

Dead:
Sigurd Fafnesbane
makaikhaan
Ichigo
Caius

Alive:
Factionheir
Quintus.J.Cicero
El Diablo
Eliit Tuhkur
Andres

24 hours to vote.

Ferret
08-19-2008, 00:20
Andres has got lucky for the past few rounds, but we never really had a strong case against him. I have no idea who is mafia at the moment so I will sleep on it and give it a good look over tomorrow.

FactionHeir
08-19-2008, 01:58
I didn't even know Caius was playing.

vote: EF

Something isn't right.

El Diablo
08-19-2008, 02:03
Vote FactionHeir

Seems to be trying a bit too hard to apportion blame.

anelious phyros
08-19-2008, 03:12
Vote FactionHeir

Seems to be trying a bit too hard to apportion blame.


lol


Since there's no big leades and not to many people alive....I'm thinking A active member and then Andres.
Maybe the active member could be.......uh who's still alive agin?:rolleyes4:

El Diablo
08-19-2008, 03:29
It is just that FactionHeir stated that Sarathos and I were innocent as we could not have pm'ed any kiills during a night phase. Then as soon as someone said Sarathos was acting strange he was all over it.

AP said he did not think it was Sarathos and was asked by FH why he was protected his scum buddy.

He is acting like a cross-eyed frog and jumping all over the place...

....and hey, its just a hunch...

ED

Csargo
08-19-2008, 04:36
*is horrified at the current chaos*

I think this should prove him innocent.

El Diablo
08-19-2008, 05:05
Perhaps but I will wait for him to state his case before changing any vote.


ED

Csargo
08-19-2008, 06:21
Read your role PM carefully.

Quintus.JC
08-19-2008, 09:56
Mmm.... I thought Caius was more likely to get WoGed than anything else. Very strange indeed.

Okay let's round up the suspects.

Andres is lucky to get this far, he has survived at least 2 tie votes (I think), but people keeps on voting for him without any strong case really, so that makes him innocent, but as so many people stated, Andres has been really quite, and he is still alive. Providing that only Mafia players don't get WoGed than it could be Andres, but I don't think he would make it that obvious. So it's not Andres.

Faction Heir has largely led a pro-town life, directing the lynches most of the time. However, a player as threathening as Faction Heir should of been killed long ago, at least if I were the mafia I would. Plus since this game still hasn't ended means that most of the lynches are probably wrong, so Faction Heir could be just pretending to be pro-town but in fact is leading the town into the wild-goose chase to direct the attention away from him. The biggest case I have against him is why a player of his experience who poses a big threat to the mafia hasn't been killed yet. Maybe Faction heir is the mafia, or maybe the mafia is somebody that Faction Heir has never accused yet.

El Diablo has had a fairly good game, nothing too suspcious. If my hunch is wrong then he is probably a townie, and that is what I think right now. But El Diablo is the only person left alive that hasn't been accused by Faction Heir. So could it be the devil that's doing the killing all along?

Elite Ferret has had an indifferent game, similiar to ED. Typical clueless townie guy, but all of this could be an act, he might not be giving anything away at the movement but if we pressure him enough then he might...

The murder of Caius is very strange since I don't think he poses any threat to anybody, so why kill him?

Quintus.JC
08-19-2008, 09:57
Vote: Faction Heir

Ferret
08-19-2008, 11:09
Well I was going to vote for FH after reading El Diablo's post but as some of you probably know I HATE the third on the bandwagon thingy, as I always get lynched for it no matter what else I have done that game...

Does anyone know if the mafia can still kill if there is just one of them? If so then we have probably already lynched one mafioso meaning there is only one left, so QJC's point about FH and El Diablo might be irrelevant.

Ah stuff it, I'll vote:FH anyway, he is the only one with any evidance against him.

FactionHeir
08-19-2008, 11:59
I think QJC's analysis is strange.

First you say I'm experienced and then you call Caius death strange. Something doesn't add up there. Besides, I rarely get night killed in mafia games early on.

That said, unvote EF, vote QJC

My feeling is that Andres is innocent btw, though normally he is a lot more active, especially early on.

FactionHeir
08-19-2008, 12:01
I think this should prove him innocent.

Damn, I was hoping to use that next turn to throw off the mafioso ~:)

El Diablo
08-19-2008, 20:57
Unvote FH vote QJC

Appologies FH..

Noobie in Mafia. :wall:

Quintus.JC
08-19-2008, 21:27
Why doesn't no body trust me, my cousin Marcus Tullius Cicero will explain things nicely... pity he's still in Greece. I had never even seen Sulla in my life, honest. :embarassed:

El Diablo
08-20-2008, 05:50
FH is innocent. I will vouch for him. I am a nobel senator.

I agreed to spend some time away from Rome, to calm myself.

But this murder must be avenged.

Csargo
08-20-2008, 06:14
Damn, I was hoping to use that next turn to throw off the mafioso ~:)

I'm sorry. :bow:

Quintus.JC
08-20-2008, 07:44
FH is innocent. I will vouch for him. I am a nobel senator.
.

You're not suggesting it's Andres or Elite Ferret are you? :inquisitive:

FactionHeir
08-20-2008, 10:27
Its either you or one (or both) of them.

Quintus.JC
08-20-2008, 11:56
I would unvote Faction heir if it wouldn't get me getting lynched.... All the talkative people seems innocent, could it really be Andres?

FactionHeir
08-20-2008, 12:03
Tell me something about the townie role PM QJC. Something that hasn't been posted yet.

Why? Because if we get 3 confirmed townies, we lynch someone else, one of us gets night killed and we have a 2:1 in the final round.

Actually....nevermind. It depends on if WH lets us shift the vote on someone else. Lets do the reveal next round, unless EF or Andres want to reveal.

FactionHeir
08-20-2008, 12:06
Hmmm it seems Andres is online and not posting.

Andres
08-20-2008, 15:24
Ave Senator FactionHeir!

Indeed, you are a noble Senator of the Republic.

Since you were horrified at the current chaos, I believe you are innocent.

Like you, I don't have any special role. Since I can vote during the day, I will:

Vote : Quintus J. Cicero


Tell me, what did you agree to but didn't happen?

Ferret
08-20-2008, 17:39
Ah yes, I missed that post of yours from the begining FH, thanks for pointing it out again Ichi, it seems we have caught a mafioso, and I believe it is the last one.

unvote:FactionHeir
vote:Quintus J. Cicero

Quintus.JC
08-20-2008, 17:54
You're making a big mistake, all of you. It's Andres! :rtwno:

Unvote: Faction Heir
Vote: Andres

Anyway I resign to my fate... Elysium awaits me.

FactionHeir
08-20-2008, 17:54
EF, care to answer Andres' query? Or QJC for that matter?

Would help if you could.

Andres
08-20-2008, 18:01
I think Quintus' reply pretty much confirms his guilt.

FactionHeir
08-20-2008, 18:28
With neither of them responding I'm inclined to say its possible that they are both mafiosi. Which means we get one of them today and one tomorrow and we still win ~:)

El Diablo
08-20-2008, 21:07
The noose tightens.

Ferret
08-21-2008, 00:11
Ave Senator FactionHeir!

Indeed, you are a noble Senator of the Republic.

Since you were horrified at the current chaos, I believe you are innocent.

Like you, I don't have any special role. Since I can vote during the day, I will:

Vote : Quintus J. Cicero


Tell me, what did you agree to but didn't happen?

Sorry I was in a bit of a rush earlier (I have been in London all day so I had to check the whole org before dinner, which was out) and missed that last line.

I agreed to spend some time not in Rome, to perform calming techniques.

It's not accurate because of what it says in the first post, about not quoting PMs...

Warmaster Horus
08-21-2008, 00:31
True. It's been going on for a day, and I would really, really appreciate it if you would stop.

Day's over.

Tally coming up.

Edit:
Tally:
QJC: 4 (FH, ED, Andres, EF)
Andres: 1 (QJC)

Quintus.JC is lynched. PMs please.

Lynched:
anelious phyros
Fenring
Sarathos
Quintus.J.Cicero

Dead:
Sigurd Fafnesbane
makaikhaan
Ichigo
Caius

Alive:
Factionheir
El Diablo
Eliit Tuhkur
Andres

FactionHeir
08-21-2008, 00:34
I think its:

QJC (FH, Andres, EF, ED)
Andres (QJC)

FactionHeir
08-21-2008, 00:36
EF: Not quite satisfactory. What's it say in your OOC section?

anelious phyros
08-21-2008, 01:35
FH - He dosn't seem any differnt from all the other games i've played. Which I think is every single one.

EF - plain townie probably, or just one wicked mafia.

Quin - I've gotta slighty agree with FH and ED, it's quite suspicous....enough to lynch?

FactionHeir
08-21-2008, 01:38
Ehm, the day's already over :wink:

What do you think of us four (soon to be 3) survivors though?

anelious phyros
08-21-2008, 01:41
Ehm, the day's already over :wink:

What do you think of us four (soon to be 3) survivors though?

Yea, I know. Just putting that out there.
Well I basically just said it there though, but who's about to die quinn right?

FactionHeir
08-21-2008, 01:51
Quintus is already dead. We just lynched him.

Ferret
08-21-2008, 12:07
EF: Not quite satisfactory. What's it say in your OOC section?

Again I cannot quote exactly without breaking the rules FH...

But it says some things along the lines of being a townie, no special role, I can vote during the day but can't do anything at night. Then I am wished luck and the PM is signed by WH.

I'm afraid that I cannot give you anymore for I have now paraphrased my entire role PM bar a few sentences at the beginning, a mere greeting which would probably have been in a mafia PM anyway.

Back to the game I thought we had won personally with Quintus dead but as the game has continued that does not seem to be the case. As for who could be mafia I'm not sure, after reading my role PM again and going back over the thread it seems that all of us survivors have quoted or paraphrased parts of the townie role PM so that means either WH wanted to add suspence and end it on a day phase, leaving this night uneventful or he gave the mafia a townie PM in case this happens. But really you guys were lucky not to get WoGed, quoting role PMs is against the rules...

Quintus.JC
08-21-2008, 12:20
I know this doesn't make sense, but I was a innocent townie who by chance deleted his PM role by accident so now he is lynched by his supposed fellow townies... who is convinced of my innocence? :inquisitive:

Warmaster Horus
08-21-2008, 21:38
For RL reasons, Andres cannot participate in this game anymore.
Night'll end in the next 10 minutes.

Warmaster Horus
08-21-2008, 22:22
Night is ended, and FactionHeir has been killed. With Andres' suicide, this leaves El Diablo and Elite Ferret.

Write-up: In the morning, three persons were present in the Entrance Hall: Sulla's freedman, El Diablo and Elite Ferret. The freedman declared:
"Two men have died tonight, and one was strangled (FH), the other stuck a knife in his own heart (Andres). I fear it is time to end this charade." A sniggering could be heard then, and the other two turned to the one making that clichéd sound in end-of-mafia-games write-ups. He said: "Indeed, it is time. I am nearing the end of my mission, and it is a mission I will finish in public." He then took out a cord, and approached the one who had remained silent until then, and had time to shout one word before the freedman shut his mouth from behind:
"Ferret!"
For indeed it had been the one called Elite Ferret who was behind these murders. Sulla's freedman, once El Diablo was dead, came up to him and gave him a pouch, that made a sound like it was full of gold. He said: "Congratulations, I didn't think you could do it. Sulla will be pleased. Now, I know you were commissioned together, and that you probably think you should get the gold your buddy Quintus.JC should have gotten, but I don't agree with that. No, I'll keep it, and there's nothing you can do about-" He spoke no more.
For Ferret had brandished a knife, and stuck it in the freedman's neck. "Actually, I could do this. You talk too much. Thanks for the cash." Thus, he left the villa, and went back to Rome, no doubt to carry out more mischief...


MAFIA VICTORY!!!

Congrats Quintus.JC and Elite Ferret!

Lynched:
anelious phyros
Fenring
Sarathos
Quintus.J.Cicero


Dead:
Sigurd Fafnesbane
makaikhaan
Ichigo
Caius
Factionheir
Andres (suicide)
El Diablo

Alive:
Elite Ferret

So, first of all I'd like to thank you all for participating in this! And again congrats infomers!
I said there were 3 special roles: 2 informers and 1 pro-town. anelious phyros was that pro-town player, and he could investigate one person a night; and at the risk of forfeiting his right to reveal kill one person during the course of the game. Unfortunately, he died during the first day phase, and that seriously hampered the town. I think his role was somewhat powerful, and if he'd been able to continue, could have made this a townie victory.
There are two other things I'd like to mention in this final write-up:
- after the second orders came in (I think it was the second night), I ended the phase just a few hours after it had started, and didn't start it 24 hours after, like I should have. Factionheir's nice analysis put the mafiosi in danger, and since it was my fault, I decided to inform them of anelious phyros' role. Since he was dead, it didn't really influence the game; I wanted the mafiosi to not feel too downcast after the second night.
- during the last day phase, the PM paraphrasing began. This was not strictly against the rules, but close to it. A solution came soon; the mafiosi approached me, saying they didn't stand a chance if this went on, and asked me for the townie pm. I lost because of that in Caius' game, and could understand how they felt. So I gave them the PM. In the end, it didn't do much difference. Andres, realizing it was nearly against the rules, PM'ed me and offered suicide. That happened for RL reasons which I do not know (if you read this Andres; all the best!). This left Factionheir, El Diablo and Elite Ferret. The first was killed, the last was a mafioso, and the guy in the middle didn't have a chance.

So, once again: congrats informers! And thanks everyone for participating!

Ferret
08-21-2008, 22:39
WOHOOOOOO! ALL YOUR GOLD ARE BELONG TO FERRETS!!!!!!!

:clown:

I'd like to say a very well played to FH, he nearly had us on numerous occasions, and did start the bandwagon that killed Quintus.

Quintus.JC
08-21-2008, 23:06
WOOHOOOO!!!! wait a minute, not so happy, I'm dead. :embarassed:

WOOHOOOOOO!!! We still won, well done Elite Ferret. :2thumbsup:

Well, all the last 3 remaining town did well. Faction heir's exceptional anaylitical skill could of had us on numerous occasions, El Diablo's judgement was spot on as he stuck with Faction Heir when many could of wavered, and Andres's experience and expertise showed up at the last second to delay our victory by one night.

We were fortunate to win, it could of all be so different if Andres had time to finish the game.

Big thanks for Warmaster Horus for hosting the game. It was most excellent. :bow:

FactionHeir
08-21-2008, 23:26
Thanks for hosting. I kind of figured you gave them the PM on the last day, and kind of knew it was EF because he and Quintus both didn't reply for a while. I didn't expect Andres to suicide though, thus forfeiting our chances. Soooo damn you Andres! ;~)

And uh sorry ap, but you questioned my day 1 reveal and I thought you were mafia :grin:

El Diablo
08-22-2008, 01:17
Thanks for hosting Warmaster and I am sorry that a "leaking" of the pm's occured.
I did not know that was against the rules.

That was awesome and well done Mafia.

Close FH we almost got them - well played.

anelious phyros
08-22-2008, 01:33
Thanx For hosting!!:grin3:

That's why I was bummed I got killed....finally get a role and the first round im dead!!:bigcry:
It was fun knowing FH was innocent though.

Ferret
08-22-2008, 10:45
Yeah Big thanks for hosting WH, this may well be my first win :laugh4:

FactionHeir
08-22-2008, 12:34
Heh you are a Ferret once again.

If it wasn't for you hesistating and not posting when you were online and active otherwise, you wouldn't have looked so scummy.

Ferret
08-22-2008, 18:40
I had to ask WH if he could send me a townie PM and he didn't come online for a few hours :laugh4:

I even tried putting invisible mode on for a bit to try and stop you seeing me post, and had the excuse that I only had a bit of time, and had to check on other parts of the org before leaving again...

Quintus.JC
08-22-2008, 18:48
One of us was less fortunate on that matter. :embarassed:

Warmaster Horus
08-23-2008, 00:38
Meh, sorry. But you came out of it okay :thumbsup:

Caius
08-24-2008, 02:53
One word: DAMN.