October Screenshot Competition Poll [Archive]

MarcusAureliusAntoninus

10-28-2008, 19:42

Time for the poll:

1- "Thracian ambush" by ludwag
https://img77.imageshack.us/img77/561/ambushws9.jpg

2- "The Dard Defeat" by Legosoldier
https://i376.photobucket.com/albums/oo202/legosoldier/0001.jpg

3- "Farewell brave nobles!" by chenkai11
https://img516.imageshack.us/img516/9748/85169687qy3.jpg

4- "Into the Fray We March" by TWFanatic
http://img33.picoodle.com/img/img33/3/10/4/f_IntotheFraym_19c0a5c.jpg

5- "At the Edge of the World" by Ibn-Khaldun
https://i259.photobucket.com/albums/hh311/ibnkhaldun/TW%20games/eb_pic1.jpg

6- "The Loyal Makedonian" by Maion Maroneios
http://img29.picoodle.com/img/img29/3/10/6/f_attalosm_eb8ac6e.png

7- "Mount Sinai 225BC" by Centrio Nixalsverdrus
https://img134.imageshack.us/img134/6105/93petra09wo2.jpg

8- "The Last Stand" by Smeel
https://img185.imageshack.us/img185/1595/laststandcopytb3.jpg

9- "Wooo! look! Epikletoi with swords!" by bobbin
https://i56.photobucket.com/albums/g177/0404625/Image3.jpg

10- "Going grocery shopping: 'Hmmmmmmmm, doctor said more fruit...'" by k_raso
https://img525.imageshack.us/img525/9332/asdfnz5.jpg

11- "Lost and Alone" by King Vasiliyi
https://img201.imageshack.us/img201/2897/rometw2008100816115277lj5.jpg

12- "Battle of Megalopolis (331 BC)" by SwissBarbar
https://img512.imageshack.us/img512/6786/unbenannt9gl8.png

If you didn't find your picture here, it means that it no longer loads or does not fit the rules of the competition.

Centurio Nixalsverdrus

10-28-2008, 20:42

Hmm, tough decision between mine, Maion's and ludwig's, but in the end I spontaneously decided for ludwig's. I like the feeling of it...

Ibrahim

10-28-2008, 21:22

Hmm, tough decision between mine, Maion's and ludwig's, but in the end I spontaneously decided for ludwig's. I like the feeling of it...

yeah, its a tough choice this time. they're all quite good-or darn funny.

Mediolanicus

10-28-2008, 21:44

7- "Mount Sinai 225BC" by Centrio Nixalsverdrus

One of the best pics I've ever seen.

SwissBarbar

10-28-2008, 21:47

since i won't vote for myself, i vote ludwigs. Could be used for a history-book, very nice picture

desert

10-28-2008, 22:30

I'm surprised that I'm the only one so far who has voted for Smeel's uberscreen.
For shame.:smash:

Apgad

10-28-2008, 22:34

Should #2 be "Dark Defeat"?

I like the Thracians here...

General Appo

10-29-2008, 00:29

Maion. By the way, is there gonna be a November competition?

MarcusAureliusAntoninus

10-29-2008, 00:30

Maion. By the way, is there gonna be a November competition?
Probably.

Maion Maroneios

10-29-2008, 00:38

TWFanatic deffinately:yes:

Maion

||Lz3||

10-29-2008, 01:29

Smeel, it's so romantic :2thumbsup:

Centurio Nixalsverdrus

10-29-2008, 01:38

7- "Mount Sinai 225BC" by Centrio Nixalsverdrus

One of the best pics I've ever seen.
Wow. :bow: :bow: :bow: Thank you.

Darkvicer98

10-29-2008, 01:45

Even though i haven't tried out this mod yet, i'm really tempted. Its a tie between "The Loyal Makedonian" by Maion Maroneios and "The Last Stand" by Smeel. Both are superb.

Hooahguy

10-29-2008, 01:56

go getai!
w00t!

Aemilius Paulus

10-29-2008, 03:18

Am I the only one who gets this:
____________ for #4 and 6?

This is only temporary, right?

EDIT: deleted the duplicate, the picture is now showing on my computer.

Maion Maroneios

10-29-2008, 03:20

Well, no, same goes with mine. But I'm sure it'll get fixed soon, don't worry.

Maion

desert

10-29-2008, 03:23

Hmmm. I'm not seeing any duplicates.

Aemilius Paulus

10-29-2008, 05:16

Anyway, I voted for #1, Thracian ambush, by ludwig.

TWFanatic's and Centrio Nixalsverdrus were both superior in terms of graphics, being the most aesthetically pleasing screenshots. Especially Centrio Nixalsverdrus' masterpiece. However, there was just something movie-like about the seemingly standing general, the standard-bearer and the charging masses of his soldiers of ludwig's picture.

To Maion Maroneios: If you just edited your submission a little bit, like numbers 4, 8, and 9, I would have probably voted for it. Try to use the blur tool a little bit, next time! The editing is what turns a screenshot into a picture/work of art!

Maion Maroneios

10-29-2008, 07:13

I know, I just wanted this picture ''pure'' if you get me. Next time I'll probably to some editing.

Maion

ludwag

10-29-2008, 10:16

LUDWAG! my name is LUDWAG, not IG! now everybody thinks my name is ludwig :(

SwissBarbar

10-29-2008, 10:26

haha, thats MarcusAureliusAntoninus fault :laugh4: :laugh4:

lets call you "lude" , thats easier *G*

ludwag

10-29-2008, 15:35

call me lud. thats cool

Wausser

10-29-2008, 17:08

Voted for

4- "Into the Fray We March" by TWFanatic

Ibrahim

10-29-2008, 19:55

so my choice is winning:yes:

Aemilius Paulus

10-29-2008, 23:51

Hmmmm, just as I was typing "ludwag", I happen to notice that the author of the first submission was "ludwig" as odd as it was, and I changed it so not to offend the author. I do remember conversing with ludwag, not ludwig prior to this, but I guessed it was another manifestation of my far from rare absent-mindedness rather than the mistake of MAA.

However, since MAA is such a legend at the .Org EB forum, I'm just going to take his word. After, all, if the Big Brother says 2+2=5, then so be it. Just kidding. My apologies for misspelling your name, ludwag.

ludwag

10-30-2008, 00:46

that was a very good apology, and I am very honoured that you voted for me. I voted for myself, is that a bad thing to do? I was going to vote for The Last Stand but TWfanatic got so many votes very fast :( I think his picture is good, but not very good composed (?). Dont know the english word, is it compose? But next competition I will photoshop it so it gets more smooth and clean. I think it is good that we have a screenshot competition so that we can share screenshots, without just tossing in every screenshot we have, but chose one. But i think we should have more often and that more people should join.

ezekiel2517

10-30-2008, 05:23

close call between 4 and 1... but 1 just looks better to my taste :2thumbsup:

nice competition altogether

chenkai11

10-30-2008, 07:48

I just wanted to show my appreciation to those who voted #3. Thank you.:bow::bow::bow:

Just a thought......is this a screenshot competition or a photoshop picture contest?

Just a thought...... I really mean it. Promise.

johnhughthom

10-30-2008, 15:19

I think a better title for 10 would have been "I wonder how many apples I can get on my sarissa?" I agree with you chenkai11, too much editing for my tastes this month.

Centurio Nixalsverdrus

10-30-2008, 18:55

Time to get Gimp finally, I think. ~:(:coffeenews:

Lovejoy

10-30-2008, 19:34

I think 6 is prob the best EB picture Ive have ever seen. It really show the beutifulness of EB. The detalis are amazing!

ludwag

10-30-2008, 22:51

I diddnt like it at all. Too small and to little perspective to make it epic. Just pressed the pausebutton right time, and moved the camera there.

Tarkus

10-31-2008, 00:31

I diddnt like it at all. Too small and to little perspective to make it epic. Just pressed the pausebutton right time, and moved the camera there.

I'm sympathetic to your point of view, ludwag -- and I really liked your artwork, by the way -- but I had to go with Maion's. Yes it's small and simple, but in my view it shows the quality of the EB artwork that is to be center stage in the competition. I agree with others that this shouldn't evolve into a Photoshop contest.

My two cents' worth...

chenkai11

10-31-2008, 01:58

I think a better title for 10 would have been "I wonder how many apples I can get on my sarissa?"

lol, interesting title.

The General

10-31-2008, 13:51

Was a tough choice between #4, #6 and #8, but I decided not to vote #8 because it was so heavily edited (although purrrtay), and while #6 captured a neat moment, in the end I decided to go with TWFanatic's picture, which, to be honest, not only is bloody impressive but also damn pretty.

machinor

10-31-2008, 20:02

For me it was a tie between Maion's and Nixalsverdrus'. In the end, I voted for Maion. But #7 is still a very very very close silver medal.

Pontius Pilate

11-01-2008, 01:51

Loyalty unto death

I voted for the "The Loyal Makedonian". TWFanatic's was good too, but I disagreed with the Photoshop thing. Maion Maroneios' was simple, picturesque, untouched, and pure.

Reno Melitensis

11-01-2008, 09:26

4- "Into the Fray We March" by TWFanatic, nice picture.

Cheers.

TWFanatic

11-01-2008, 13:40

Looking close. A balloon to everyone who voted for #4. :balloon2:

Aemilius Paulus

11-02-2008, 14:40

A balloon to everyone who voted for #4. :balloon2:

Hey,that's illegal! You can't buy votes with money! :laugh4:

Sir Edward

11-03-2008, 05:40

Maybe I'm missing something but why are the winners no longer being added to the photo gallery on the website? Wasn't one of the original purposes of this competition was to highlight the changes made by EB. The first 6 winning picture made it on the website but then no more were included, I would be interested in seeing them all there, unless there is a bandwith issue that is stopping EB from including more images.

bovi

11-03-2008, 08:06

Hey,that's illegal! You can't buy votes with money! :laugh4:
That's why he's buying them with balloons instead :yes:.

johnhughthom

11-03-2008, 13:40

ludwag

11-03-2008, 14:18

I think there should be much more strict that photoshop is not allowed

Ibrahim

11-03-2008, 15:49

Looking close. A balloon to everyone who voted for #4. :balloon2:

I has a balloon!!

*adds to sig*

ludwag

11-03-2008, 16:09

I never got the baloon system. What is it?

Ibrahim

11-03-2008, 17:46

I never got the baloon system. What is it?

its part currency, part reward, part pet. all goody!

ludwag

11-03-2008, 18:15

everyone who votes for me gets 5 baloons

SwissBarbar

11-03-2008, 18:30

haha, i did :2thumbsup:

ludwag

11-03-2008, 19:49

so how to give away baloons? Just tell you I give you?

SwissBarbar

11-03-2008, 20:18

i don't know, didn't even realize that there was any system behind it :laugh4:

Foot

11-03-2008, 20:21

balloons are meant to be a rare commodity, saturating the market by giving out 5 balloons to every one who voted for you devalues them. You should only give them out for special reasons, voting in a screenshot competition is not a special reason.

Foot

SwissBarbar

11-03-2008, 20:40

getting a vote from ME is ... :laugh4:

nah, we're only joking

ludwag

11-03-2008, 23:30

yeah. I will very rearly give away baloons. So that when I do, it will be very big, and it will mean very much for that person

Aemilius Paulus

11-04-2008, 02:47

yeah. I will very rearly give away baloons. So that when I do, it will be very big, and it will mean very much for that person

Yeah, so far I have given away two balloons: one to MarcusAureliusAntoninus for his AAR, "The Pyrrhic Dynasty : A Makedonian AAR" a.k.a the greatest RTW/RTW mod AAR and to Wausser for his stunning Heroic Victory using the Romani.

||Lz3||

11-04-2008, 05:04

I can't add more ballons to my sig :sad: :cry:

and I got each one of them on a respectful and deserved maner :2thumbsup:

TWFanatic

11-04-2008, 05:18

That's why he's buying them with balloons instead :yes:.
Virtual balloons.:balloon2::balloon2::balloon2:

balloons are meant to be a rare commodity, saturating the market by giving out 5 balloons to every one who voted for you devalues them. You should only give them out for special reasons, voting in a screenshot competition is not a special reason.
I propose appointing a commotion to regulate the balloon industry.

I think there should be much more strict that photoshop is not allowed
--says the guy who sucks at photoshop.

In all seriousness, I used to think the same thing before I learnt how to edit images. I soon discovered that the more subtle the changes, the more broad an appeal they have (in general). From my experience, the best PSed screen shots don't fundamentally change the original image, they just remove graphics/computer related ugliness (jagged lines, poor lighting, etc.) and enhance the features already present. Think of a babe from the babe thread--I dislike those made of silicon or those wearing excessive mascara. A little something to enhance what's already there is always nice tho, and in regards to a more mature lady it doesn't hurt to smooth out a few wrinkles. Photoshop evens the playing field for people with crappy computers.

Maybe I'm missing something but why are the winners no longer being added to the photo gallery on the website? Wasn't one of the original purposes of this competition was to highlight the changes made by EB. The first 6 winning picture made it on the website but then no more were included, I would be interested in seeing them all there, unless there is a bandwith issue that is stopping EB from including more images.
I agree, especially now that I've won one.:smash:

They can probably only really use non-photoshopped screenshots.
There are some good photoshopped ones too.

desert

11-04-2008, 05:38

Virtual balloons.:balloon2::balloon2::balloon2:

Think of a babe from the babe thread--I dislike those made of silicon or those wearing excessive mascara. A little something to enhance what's already there is always nice tho, and in regards to a more mature lady it doesn't hurt to smooth out a few wrinkles.

Yeah, liek this, am i rite?

https://i494.photobucket.com/albums/rr309/desertSypglass/photoshop_girl1.jpg

chenkai11

11-04-2008, 06:22

What's the meaning of Screenshot anyway?

ludwag

11-04-2008, 11:48

I dont suck at photoshop.

Maion Maroneios

11-04-2008, 14:35

What's the meaning of Screenshot anyway?
Emmm, I don't know, maybe a shot (picture) from a screen?

Maion

johnhughthom

11-04-2008, 19:13

There are some good photoshopped ones too.

My point was photoshopped screenshots aren't a good representation of the mod. Imagine the "why aren't my graphics as good as the screenshots?" threads.

ludwag

11-04-2008, 19:26

I allways think about that. We need to be in a place between having game-graphics screenshots and edited screenshots. But anyway I think everybody photoshop them way too much. And the crop them to small squeares too.

Centurio Nixalsverdrus

11-04-2008, 23:09

chenkai11

11-05-2008, 01:24

Emmm, I don't know, maybe a shot (picture) from a screen?

Maion

hmmm, you are right.

So, it should be "October Photoshop Screenshot Competition". :clown:

Aemilius Paulus

11-05-2008, 03:03

"Maybe I'm missing something but why are the winners no longer being added to the photo gallery on the website? Wasn't one of the original purposes of this competition was to highlight the changes made by EB. The first 6 winning picture made it on the website but then no more were included, I would be interested in seeing them all there, unless there is a bandwith issue that is stopping EB from including more images."

I agree, especially now that I've won one.:smash:

You didn't win the competition - yet. As we say in Russia, let's not divide the skin of a bear that has yet to be killed. Although it is very likely that you'll win.

Quite possible the reason why the winning pictures are not posted on the EB website is because they are photoshopped. The pictures on the websites are supposed to be clear and frank representations of the EB graphics. To photoshop them would be against all ethics (although not against the law as it is with real game developers - EB is a non-commercial modification). However, I am not saying that people should not edit pictures. On the contrary, I have mentioned it a couple of times on this and on the previous threads that an edited picture is the best one, with the most votes.

ludwag

11-05-2008, 09:08

You didn't win the competition - yet. As we say in Russia, let's not divide the skin of a bear that has yet to be killed
hehe, its like in a hollywood movie when russians allways say: "as we say in russia:.."

TWFanatic

11-05-2008, 18:47

http://pinkbunnyears.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/08/8-1-fat_lady.jpg

Now it's over.

Tellos Athenaios

11-05-2008, 19:31

You didn't win the competition - yet. As we say in Russia, let's not divide the skin of a bear that has yet to be killed.

In the Netherlands that becomes "let's not sell the skin of the bear before it has been shot."

Centurio Nixalsverdrus

11-05-2008, 21:35

In Germany we say "one shouldn't distribute the skin of the bear before he's killed."

SwissBarbar

11-05-2008, 22:17

oh, a competition of old sayings, cool. In switzerland we say "Wo chiemtemer ou häre, wenn jede wörd säge: "wo chiemtemer ou häre", ond kene gieng go luege wohäre das me chiem; weme gieng" :laugh4: :laugh4:

now translate that

||Lz3||

11-06-2008, 02:59

here in Mexico we say...

"don't sell the mil before milking the cow"

something like that... I don't really say it, no one really says it anyway

Nobo

11-06-2008, 10:56

In Germany we say "one shouldn't distribute the skin of the bear before he's killed."

really? we do?

||Lz3||

11-06-2008, 14:09

according to me... the poll is still open TW :smash:

Ibrahim

11-06-2008, 16:14

according to me... the poll is still open TW :smash:

and he's got a good 3-point lead.

Maion Maroneios

11-06-2008, 23:20

True, I was certain of TWFanatic's victory from the start:yes: I mean, his pic is just vastly superior in every aspect to the rest, IMHO.

Maion

Smeel

11-07-2008, 17:55

Thanks everybody who voted for me! :beam: Someone mentioned that my screenshot was too photshopped. well, yeah Not as much as you think, but of course, there are a lot of really marvelous unedited shots this month, and compared to them my sc wouldn't stand a chance unedited. :no: I did these two things, simulated depth of view and fiddled with curves. not that hard to do.

One funny thing about Photo-edit , take a look at the official Screenshots of Empire:total war. One shot, with a cavalry charge or something, And I'm 100% that someone have blurred the background to simulate focus depth. it's not even a good photo edit. None of the other screenshots has this edit. Evil Marketing people!

Aemilius Paulus

11-11-2008, 21:54

One funny thing about Photo-edit , take a look at the official Screenshots of Empire:total war. One shot, with a cavalry charge or something, And I'm 100% that someone have blurred the background to simulate focus depth. it's not even a good photo edit. None of the other screenshots has this edit. Evil Marketing people!

That's actually illegal. Unless the game developer specifically states which screenies/videos are actual game footage and which ones aren't. I have heard of more than just one major lawsuit concerning false advertising featuring edited screenshots/video previews. The plaintiff won by the way, and the company was forced to revise their advertising.