Log in

View Full Version : Good infantry/cavalry commander.


gosam
12-07-2008, 13:37
Some ethnicity traits describe the general as being more likely to be a good cavalry commander, like for instance the Makedones.

Is it an actual bonus or just for roleplay? Also if it is a bonus, how does it apply? Only if the general commands an army composed primarily of cavalry/infantry? Or is the bonus applied to any cavalry he commands, no matter the ratio?
Laza
12-07-2008, 15:03
I think such a commander is just more likely to get a good infantry/cavalary commander trait and thats all. I doesnt mean u get a hidden bonus.
Cyrus
12-07-2008, 17:06
No what I think he means is when the general already has the good cavalry commander trait does he have to have an army of mostly cav., inly cav. or just some; right?
Anyway I have no idea............
theoldbelgian
12-07-2008, 17:37
I think that he only has to have one unit of cavalry which is great with all the cavalry-bodyguard factions
Laza
12-07-2008, 18:12
No what I think he means is when the general already has the good cavalry commander trait does he have to have an army of mostly cav., inly cav. or just some; right?
Anyway I have no idea............

It only works when u have an army which is 100% made of the particular unit type. Otherwise there is no effect at all. Anyway u shouldnt even get a "good..."-trait as long as ur using mixed armies but u will get it easily when ur fielding an infantry or cav only army.
Alerion
12-07-2008, 18:16
It should be noted that the bodyguard doesnt count for that, which means if youre fielding only infantry armies with lets say the Casse, like I did, you can still get the trait even though your bodyguard is a "cavalry" unit.
Ca Putt
12-07-2008, 18:18
strangely it seems NOT to count whether the bodyguard is cav or inf(as KH i've got 2 FMs with "good cav commander")

but I'm not shure about fellow FMs in the same army

E: damn, to slow ^^
theoldbelgian
12-09-2008, 16:53
mmh thats strange when I was playing with the KH my general had a command star while only having his bodyguard from good infantry commander and do missile units(archers skirmishers?) count as infantry?
Olaf The Great
12-10-2008, 00:26
mmh thats strange when I was playing with the KH my general had a command star while only having his bodyguard from good infantry commander and do missile units(archers skirmishers?) count as infantry?
Infantry in this sense is any foot unit.
Cavalry in this sense is anything mounted.
Not sure where "Other" and "artillery" count go...
bovi
12-11-2008, 11:11
The bonus is applied when a majority of the army is composed of the unit type, not 100%. Otherwise the infantry bonus would be useless in vanilla, as all bodyguard units are cavalry.

As for ethnicities, these are no guarantee for any trait. However, they have an increased chance to have the traits prevalent in them.