View Full Version : Hannibal
Some of you who are really interested in the tactical aspect of his game may be interested in a special on the Discovery. channel. It covers the life of Hannibal as a general, and goes over quite a few of his famous battles. If your big on tactics, check it out. Discovery usually replays their specials 3-4 times a week (seems like). Check it out, you might be interested.
Crimson Castle
09-26-2002, 21:59
I think the History Channel is doing a special on the Spartans.
Cool. I saw one on Julius Caesar before. He was one nasty bastid, but if he was on your side you were sorted http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/wink.gif
Yeah that special on Hannibal was great. Had some nive insights, neat little annimations of the battles. There are some amazing tactics he was able to pull off.
Highly recomended,
Sepiche
Hey Sepiche,
How about the one where he had the Gaul infantry give way in the middle, then bent the outside around the Romans. Finally bringing up the rear with his heavy cav. That was just amazing to me that he could see that in his mind, and then actually execute it properly. I can't believe 60,000 Romans died in that one battle.
Ahh, Cannae, the "Perfect Battle." It so obsessed generals throughout the years ... John Keegan says that it (specifically Schlieffen's obsession with it) helped cause the First World War.
AcePylut
09-27-2002, 00:03
When is the special on the Spartans?
I just read "Gates of Fire" by Steven Pressfield, and fell in love with the Spartans.
If you haven't read it, pick it up, it's a great read that details the Battle of Thermopaylae, where 300 Spartans (and assorted other greeks - sum total of 4k soldiers and helots) held the Persian might (numbering around 1-2 million, but history thinks Herodotus got his numbers off by a factor of 10 and there were only 300k Persians) for a week at the mountain pass.
The book is just a great read... I recommend it to anyone interested in history.
AcePylut,
If you like Spartans check out "Thermopaylae" the book it is a fictional type history, it goes allot into the spartans customs, it is told in the perspective of a slave who becomes a squire. It came out about two years ago.
solypsist
09-27-2002, 00:38
moved to History forum.
Yeah, that was really the battle I was thinking of. That blew my mind. The fact he was able to pull that off was incedible and the disipline of his troops was unbelievable.
How about the part where the Roman soldier rode into his camp and threw his brothers head on the ground and rode out? I can't believe they didn't hear his huge steel balls clanking together as he rode up. http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/biggrin.gif
Sepiche
Wellington
09-27-2002, 01:12
Two very good related articles (first one posed as a question, the second the replies) from the Society of Ancients discussing Cannae and the resons for the Roman catastrophe -
http://www.soa.org.uk/main/resource/articles/cannaeroman.htm
http://www.soa.org.uk/main/resource/articles/cannaereprise.htm
Well worth a read!
Wavesword
09-29-2002, 17:26
I wonder if Hannibal said after Cannae "I love it when the plan comes together."
------------------
Lay your sleeping head, my love,
Human on my faithless arm;
Time and fevers burn away
Individual beauty from
Thoughtful children, and the grave
Proves the child ephemeral:
But in my arms till break of day
Let the living creature lie,
Mortal, guilty, but to me
The entirely beautiful.
lol @ wavesword
and B.A. replies 'i'm not getting on that elephant, hannibal.'
------------------
indeed
clansman
10-18-2002, 18:32
I hear they're going to make a Hollywood blockbuster about Hannibal due for release next year. Apparently that Van Diesel bloke (Triple X), you know the freak from Pitch Black, is going to play Hannibal. Here's hoping its a stonking flim!
Can anyone confirm this or am I talking PAP.........again!
Wavesword,
"I love it when a plan comes together"
CLASS
George Peppard. R.I.P.
Azrael
ShadeFlanders
11-15-2002, 10:35
I remember reading Caesar's final battle versus the Belgians, pure brilliance. The battlefield was a sorta valley, with the Belgians on one side of it and the Roman camp up on the other side. The Belgians already outnumbered the Romans but the Belgian leader Ambiorix decided to wait for the germanic cavalry that was on its way to help the belgians. Ambiorix knew that attacking through the valley without the cavalry to support them would be suicide.
Caesar knew he had draw out the Belgians (knowing their lust for battle) before their re-inforcements arrived. He ordered to change the look of his camp so that it would look like they were in dire straits and desertions were common. The next day he sent his cav against the belgians and ordered them to retreat as if routing after a short skirmish, at the same time the roman camp would have to pretend being in panic. The plan worked: the Belgians, sure of victory, chased the Romans while Ambiorix tried to stop them. The Roman infantry could charge downhill the completely surprised and disorganised Belgians. After some bloody h2h combat the romans pulled of an important victory. Ambiorix fled into Germania.
Rosacrux
11-15-2002, 10:41
Quote[/b] (clansman @ Oct. 18 2002,12:32)]I hear they're going to make a Hollywood blockbuster about Hannibal due for release next year. Apparently that Van Diesel bloke (Triple X), you know the freak from Pitch Black, is going to play Hannibal. Here's hoping its a stonking flim
Can anyone confirm this or am I talking PAP.........again
No... NO... NOOOO http://www.totalwar.org/forum/non-cgi/emoticons/eek.gif http://www.totalwar.org/forum/non-cgi/emoticons/eek.gif http://www.totalwar.org/forum/non-cgi/emoticons/eek.gif
Let the guy alone or get Some decent fella to act as him. G. Klooney would make a decent Hannibal (his mediteranean looks would add) or any other type of that type.
NOT that freak... gosh http://www.totalwar.org/forum/non-cgi/emoticons/redface.gif
I thought that G. Klooney was supposed to play King Leonidas in Gates of Fire.
Hah You think that's bad? Apparently there's another Hannibal epic in the making that stars none other than... DENZEL WASHINGTON Vin Diesel is half-african, Denzel all african. Both are slated to portray one of the greatest strategic/tactical minds the semitic world has ever produced How's that for historical revisionism? I wonder if Denzel will don prosthetic makeup and white/olive skin tones to really 'become' the character... http://www.totalwar.org/forum/non-cgi/emoticons/rolleyes.gif
So much for the fair and accurate representation of the flower of Carthage. I'm sure the original Phoenician colonists who founded Carthage are rolling in their graves...
Razorman400
12-01-2002, 11:25
What about Anthony Hopkins as the historical Hannibal. It could be his 4th Hannibal movie, lol.
When is that new Hannibal movie due in theaters by the way? It sounds pretty interesting.
Rosacrux
12-02-2002, 11:42
Denzel Washington as... Hannibal? http://www.totalwar.org/forum/non-cgi/emoticons/eek.gif
There's no hope then... But it could get even worst... they can make a truly-PC film about ancient Greece too, with a black Socrates, a chinese-lookalike as Plato and a Maori as Alexander... not to mention a Hebrew starring as Aristotle, and a mongoloid as Leonidas... now, that would be something.
tsk, tsk, tsk... bloody hollywood...
I suppose we better start digging up some ancient Phoenicians to act, eh? I suppose it would be better to have Hannibal portrayed by an English or Irish actor --- that's SO much more accurate. :rolling eyes:
Quote[/b] ]I suppose we better start digging up some ancient Phoenicians to act, eh? I suppose it would be better to have Hannibal portrayed by an English or Irish actor --- that's SO much more accurate. :rolling eyes:
Hah Your tone of sarcasm is duly noted. However, when you consider that Jewish-American actors routinely play non-semitic parts in Hollyweird then an Anglo or Celtic looking Hannibal isn't such a big deal (it's certainly less of a stretch than an African playing the part). 'Blue blooded' Phoenicians indeed. Jews and Arabs, much like their Phoenician cousins of old, are also of semitic stock. Those two groups alone comprise tens of millions of people. Hollyweird couldn't find more appropriate actors from the countless English speaking actors of said groups?
I am amazed how politically incorrect it has become to even consider casting actors who look the part. What's next? Jackie Chan as Shaka Zulu?
Antonio Banderas or Russel Crowe maybe.
Vin Diesel is an ass clown- I really can't understand what people see in him.
Even the Rock would be better than Diesel.
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.