FriendlyFire
09-24-2010, 03:25
Cry "Havoc", and let slip the dogs of war – Shakespeare, Julius Caesar
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Hound.jpg
The Hound of Molossos
This is an Epeiros campaign AAR, played in Europa Barbarorum with BI.exe and DarthMod formations on H/M difficulty. I've always had a fondness for Epeirote empires, but my last attempt at an AAR in the RTR FoE mod (Sons of Epeiros - a Fate of Empires AAR (http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showthread.php?t=321368)) foundered due to AI stupidity. This time things look much better: I'm 40 years into an EB campaign, the various empires are expanding nicely, and I have many pages of notes and several hundred screenshots. Even if it all crashes tomorrow there's enough to keep the thread going for a while! I'm trying not to blitz, and to use character personality traits to guide (or at least explain) in-game decisions. I'll call out any time I have to use force diplomacy or move_character to keep the game interesting. Finally, this AAR is dedicated to whoever first came up with the idea of a "recovered documents" style of AAR, and to all the members of the EB team who put together the fabulous set of historical quotes in the game. All feedback welcomed – hope you enjoy it!
Editors note: the following series of documents were recently recovered from what are believed to be the royal tombs in the old Epeirote capital of Ambrakia. That they survived at all is extraordinary enough, but their true value lies in the insight they provide into the military and political issues confronting an ancient empire. They were originally written as a series of missives from a royal advisor to a young prince, and it is clear that the advisor wrote of history as it really happened, using access to secret state archives that contain precise counts of men, material, and treasure. These educational documents were in some sense the crown jewels of the kingdom, which may explain their presence in the tombs.
Unfortunately the original author is unknown, and the copies recovered are clearly not the originals: they show evidence of multiple hands, and they have been decorated with illustrations of the battle scenes described. It seems likely that these documents were copied afresh for each new prince, with the artwork being embellished over time. We can only hope that the text was not similarly altered. For this translation the battle scenes have been recreated for modern eyes, removing some of the more improbable feats that they depict. Additionally, we have added translations of military unit names, modern dates, and geo-political maps showing the known expansion of other empires. However, it is cautioned that this is a preliminary translation, and some inconsistencies may remain.
Hail Kleronomos Basileios! Your father, may his glories never fade, has charged me with instructing you in some of the military and political arts, so that when your time comes you may prove an equally worthy Basileus. Since you are currently campaigning, I have decided to begin by writing for you some short histories of the kingdom, which will be conveyed to you by messenger. I hope that these messages may illustrate some of the more important points worthy of your attention, and that when you return we may talk further on them. I understand that others will instruct you in nautical and economic knowledge, so I will touch only lightly on these matters. Please understand that I will be telling you certain things that are not widely known, and they should remain that way. Should any of the seals on these messages already be broken when they reach you, you will of course know what to do with the messenger. All glory to Epeiros!
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Dodone.jpg
Wintry Dodone
For the start of your education, we shall return to the first year of the 127th Olympiad (272 BC), and some discussion of our ancestor, Pyrrhos Aiakides. Although his glories in that year are known to history, what is less obvious is how he arrived at some of his decisions. Most obviously, we shall begin with the Battle of Pella.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Galatians.jpg
Galatian mercenaries taunt the enemy before the Battle of Pella (272 BC)
At this time, Pella was the capital of the Makedonian kingdom of the Antigonids. However, their attention was elsewhere, as they were fighting the Greek city-states of Athenai and Sparte to the south. Pella had been left weakly defended by a garrison of just 6,000 men, commanded by the first-born son Alkyoneus Argeades. Of his men, 2,400 were levy pikemen (phalangitai deuteroi), 2,400 were light skirmishers (akontistai), and 1,200 were slingers (sphendonitai ).
Pyrrhos had already claimed the title of King of Makedonia, and now intended to drive the Antigonids into the sea. Facing their capital, he commanded over twice as many men as the city's garrison, with a total army numbering almost 14,000. This consisted of 4,800 phalangites and 2,400 skirmishers from Epeiros itself, 2,400 levy spearmen from the pacified lands of Illyria (phyletichoi Illyrioi), and 4,000 locally-recruited Galatian mercenaries (Galatikoi kluddolon). Finally, Pyrrhos brought 36 war elephants (elephantes Indikoi), loaned to him by his ally Ptolemy II Philadelphus of the Ptolemaioi.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Pella.jpg
Forces present at the Battle of Pella
Prince, it is important to discuss two lessons before we even note the events of the battle. The first lesson is the use of overwhelming force of both numbers and equipment. Neither of these factors is enough on its own, but possessing them both and using their advantages wisely cannot but guarantee success. For example, the war elephants allowed Pyrrhos to assault the city walls immediately, and the Galatian mercenaries were fearsome opponents who could swarm the Makedonian phalangites. However, these advantages could have been countered by a wise defender: the Makedonian slingers could have inflicted many wounds on the lightly-armored Galatians, and the javelins of their skirmishers should have been enough to rout the notoriously unpredictable elephantes. It was to Pyrrhos's enormous advantage that his opponent Alkyoneus was a young lad of 20 years, inexperienced in the ways of war, and did not use these tactics.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Alkyoneus.jpg
Young Alkyoneus Argeades and his phalangites before the battle
The second lesson is one worthy of royal attention, and it is to attack your opponent whilst his attention is elsewhere. Let us consider the alternative: had the Antigonids not been trying to expand their own kingdom by conquering the old Greek city-states to the south, Pyrrhos might have faced the full might of the Makedonian army, and we ourselves might not be here today! However, with their attention distracted and such a weak garrison left in place, their capital fell easily to Pyrrhos, as history has told us.
Pyrrhos began the battle by sending his skirmishers sprinting up to the walls. There they unleashed showers of javelins, causing the Makedonian slingers to fall back in disarray, and opening the way for an elephante to break down the main gate.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Slingers.jpg
Makedonian slingers retreat from the main gate under a shower of javelins
Following this, Pyrrhos ordered the Illyrian spearmen through the gate and towards the enemy skirmishers, who were advancing down a side street. His use of the Illyrians in this way is interesting: one might ask why he did not use the Galatians instead, who were perhaps more suited to close combat in city streets. However, it is clear from his records that Pyrrhos wanted to keep the precious mercenary force intact for future battles – their presence at this battle was mainly symbolic, and they took no part in the actual fighting. By contrast, the Illyrians were expendable, and although they received the honor of being first to enter the city, they were to pay for this with heavy losses. Impetuous troops willing to pay such a price for glory will always find a place in your armies.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Illyrians.jpg
Illyrian spearmen fight Makedonian skirmishers in the side-streets of Pella
The battle now moved to the center of town, where Pyrrhos's skirmishers had chased the retreated slingers, only to be confronted by Alkyoneus and his mounted bodyguards. Pyrrhos, who was previously leading the elephantes slowly up the main street, now charged into the attack. Another important lesson here is for a leader to be present at critical moments. Thus do you lend the weight of your bodyguard to the fray, and give your men renewed heart and vigor by your very presence alongside them. Pyrrhos did both, taking full part in the cavalry battle that resulted in the death of his opponent Alkyoneus.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Pyrrhos.jpg
Pyrrhos and his bodyguards in the confused cavalry battle around the square of Pella
It is well-known that Pyrrhos now won the battle by ordering his elephantes to directly charge the enemy phalanx on the central square, while he himself circled his bodyguards around and attacked the phalanx from its vulnerable rear. This brought the battle to a swift and bloody conclusion, albeit at some cost to the great beasts.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Elephants.jpg
The end of the Battle of Pella, as the Makedonian phalanx is beset by Pyrrhos and his elephants
Again we may ask why Pyrrhos chose this course of action, when he possessed twice as many phalangites of his own, who could have speared the Makedonian phalanx between two oncoming walls of sarissas. What he find from his records is that Pyrrhos wanted both to preserve his own phalangites, and to rid himself of the elephantes! My lord, while elephantes are a glorious and potentially battle-winning weapon, they are also ruinously expensive to the royal treasury. The funds required for their care and feeding could easily support a small army, and Epeiros's finances were at this point precarious. After their losses at the battle of Pella, Pyrrhos returned the elephantes to Ptolemy II Philadelphus, along with his copious thanks. The Ptolemaic king took glory in the accounts of how his elephantes won the battle, Pyrrhos saved Epeiros from bankruptcy, and history was none the wiser.
It is also to be noted that after this battle, Pyrrhos always refused to directly assault cities, and instead either forced the inhabitants out through starvation, or tempted nearby enemy armies into attacking and thereby drawing out the garrison in support. Some have speculated that the death-cries of the elephants on the square so affected Pyrrhos that he refused to countenance any further city assaults, believing them to always lead to needless losses.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Victory.jpg
The Makedonian capital of Pella falls to Pyrrhos
The following table shows the losses suffered and inflicted by Pyrrhos's army. These numbers are based on army records of pay and loot, which is largely apportioned based on the contributions reckoned by each unit to the battle.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Stats.jpg
Losses at the battle of Pella
Note in particular that the phalangites and Galatians were never engaged, suffering only minor losses to the enemy slingers in the opening minutes of the battle. While Pella was therefore not a profitable battle for these units, they would find much employment in the future. It is noted that Pyrrhos took special care to ensure that the Galatians did not further despoil the Makedonian tombs in search of treasure.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Tombs.jpg
The Makedonian Royal Tombs at Pella
Thus did Pyrrhos become Nikesas Pelles (Conqueror of Pella). He ordered that many of the Makedonian inhabitants be expelled, dispersing them to Epidamnos and Ambrakia, and that Pella should be ruled as an Epeirote-controlled military territory. My prince, you may know this is a somewhat heavy-handed and lengthy process of subduing a region, and it does not promote happiness or growth in the local population. However, it does offer troops from the area who are second-to-none in their fighting ability, if perhaps not as loyal as those raised from wintry Dodone itself.
During this year Pyrrhos also sent ambassadors to the Koinon Hellenon city-states of Athenai and Sparte, and to the Qarthadast outpost of Lilibeo on the island of Sicily, where Pyrrhos had previous campaigned. Although the Greeks strangely refused Pyrrhos's offer of a joint alliance against the Antigonids, they did agree to a furtherance of trade rights. And in return for a solemn promise that Pyrrhos would never ever again set foot on his mother's homeland of Sicily, Hamalcar of Qarthadast accepted (with some bad grace) that the old state of war should be suspended, and that sea trade could resume without hindrance. While battles win the attention of the populace, it is through the ties of trade that great empires are built, and these actions of Pyrrhos are worthy of your note.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Territory.jpg
Epeirote territory at the end of 272 BC
My prince, in my next missive I will expound on Pyrrhos's great battles for Demetrias over the next two years, and the lessons they hold for any military leader of Epeiros. May this message find you in good health.
[Game note: The elephants allow Epeiros to go on a massive blitz in the early game, but there's no fun in that. Far more engaging to disband the elephants, and then gradually build up to the point where you can recruit some more :) I'm also role-playing Pyrrhos's "dislikes attacking walls" trait.]
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Hound.jpg
The Hound of Molossos
This is an Epeiros campaign AAR, played in Europa Barbarorum with BI.exe and DarthMod formations on H/M difficulty. I've always had a fondness for Epeirote empires, but my last attempt at an AAR in the RTR FoE mod (Sons of Epeiros - a Fate of Empires AAR (http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showthread.php?t=321368)) foundered due to AI stupidity. This time things look much better: I'm 40 years into an EB campaign, the various empires are expanding nicely, and I have many pages of notes and several hundred screenshots. Even if it all crashes tomorrow there's enough to keep the thread going for a while! I'm trying not to blitz, and to use character personality traits to guide (or at least explain) in-game decisions. I'll call out any time I have to use force diplomacy or move_character to keep the game interesting. Finally, this AAR is dedicated to whoever first came up with the idea of a "recovered documents" style of AAR, and to all the members of the EB team who put together the fabulous set of historical quotes in the game. All feedback welcomed – hope you enjoy it!
Editors note: the following series of documents were recently recovered from what are believed to be the royal tombs in the old Epeirote capital of Ambrakia. That they survived at all is extraordinary enough, but their true value lies in the insight they provide into the military and political issues confronting an ancient empire. They were originally written as a series of missives from a royal advisor to a young prince, and it is clear that the advisor wrote of history as it really happened, using access to secret state archives that contain precise counts of men, material, and treasure. These educational documents were in some sense the crown jewels of the kingdom, which may explain their presence in the tombs.
Unfortunately the original author is unknown, and the copies recovered are clearly not the originals: they show evidence of multiple hands, and they have been decorated with illustrations of the battle scenes described. It seems likely that these documents were copied afresh for each new prince, with the artwork being embellished over time. We can only hope that the text was not similarly altered. For this translation the battle scenes have been recreated for modern eyes, removing some of the more improbable feats that they depict. Additionally, we have added translations of military unit names, modern dates, and geo-political maps showing the known expansion of other empires. However, it is cautioned that this is a preliminary translation, and some inconsistencies may remain.
Hail Kleronomos Basileios! Your father, may his glories never fade, has charged me with instructing you in some of the military and political arts, so that when your time comes you may prove an equally worthy Basileus. Since you are currently campaigning, I have decided to begin by writing for you some short histories of the kingdom, which will be conveyed to you by messenger. I hope that these messages may illustrate some of the more important points worthy of your attention, and that when you return we may talk further on them. I understand that others will instruct you in nautical and economic knowledge, so I will touch only lightly on these matters. Please understand that I will be telling you certain things that are not widely known, and they should remain that way. Should any of the seals on these messages already be broken when they reach you, you will of course know what to do with the messenger. All glory to Epeiros!
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Dodone.jpg
Wintry Dodone
For the start of your education, we shall return to the first year of the 127th Olympiad (272 BC), and some discussion of our ancestor, Pyrrhos Aiakides. Although his glories in that year are known to history, what is less obvious is how he arrived at some of his decisions. Most obviously, we shall begin with the Battle of Pella.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Galatians.jpg
Galatian mercenaries taunt the enemy before the Battle of Pella (272 BC)
At this time, Pella was the capital of the Makedonian kingdom of the Antigonids. However, their attention was elsewhere, as they were fighting the Greek city-states of Athenai and Sparte to the south. Pella had been left weakly defended by a garrison of just 6,000 men, commanded by the first-born son Alkyoneus Argeades. Of his men, 2,400 were levy pikemen (phalangitai deuteroi), 2,400 were light skirmishers (akontistai), and 1,200 were slingers (sphendonitai ).
Pyrrhos had already claimed the title of King of Makedonia, and now intended to drive the Antigonids into the sea. Facing their capital, he commanded over twice as many men as the city's garrison, with a total army numbering almost 14,000. This consisted of 4,800 phalangites and 2,400 skirmishers from Epeiros itself, 2,400 levy spearmen from the pacified lands of Illyria (phyletichoi Illyrioi), and 4,000 locally-recruited Galatian mercenaries (Galatikoi kluddolon). Finally, Pyrrhos brought 36 war elephants (elephantes Indikoi), loaned to him by his ally Ptolemy II Philadelphus of the Ptolemaioi.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Pella.jpg
Forces present at the Battle of Pella
Prince, it is important to discuss two lessons before we even note the events of the battle. The first lesson is the use of overwhelming force of both numbers and equipment. Neither of these factors is enough on its own, but possessing them both and using their advantages wisely cannot but guarantee success. For example, the war elephants allowed Pyrrhos to assault the city walls immediately, and the Galatian mercenaries were fearsome opponents who could swarm the Makedonian phalangites. However, these advantages could have been countered by a wise defender: the Makedonian slingers could have inflicted many wounds on the lightly-armored Galatians, and the javelins of their skirmishers should have been enough to rout the notoriously unpredictable elephantes. It was to Pyrrhos's enormous advantage that his opponent Alkyoneus was a young lad of 20 years, inexperienced in the ways of war, and did not use these tactics.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Alkyoneus.jpg
Young Alkyoneus Argeades and his phalangites before the battle
The second lesson is one worthy of royal attention, and it is to attack your opponent whilst his attention is elsewhere. Let us consider the alternative: had the Antigonids not been trying to expand their own kingdom by conquering the old Greek city-states to the south, Pyrrhos might have faced the full might of the Makedonian army, and we ourselves might not be here today! However, with their attention distracted and such a weak garrison left in place, their capital fell easily to Pyrrhos, as history has told us.
Pyrrhos began the battle by sending his skirmishers sprinting up to the walls. There they unleashed showers of javelins, causing the Makedonian slingers to fall back in disarray, and opening the way for an elephante to break down the main gate.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Slingers.jpg
Makedonian slingers retreat from the main gate under a shower of javelins
Following this, Pyrrhos ordered the Illyrian spearmen through the gate and towards the enemy skirmishers, who were advancing down a side street. His use of the Illyrians in this way is interesting: one might ask why he did not use the Galatians instead, who were perhaps more suited to close combat in city streets. However, it is clear from his records that Pyrrhos wanted to keep the precious mercenary force intact for future battles – their presence at this battle was mainly symbolic, and they took no part in the actual fighting. By contrast, the Illyrians were expendable, and although they received the honor of being first to enter the city, they were to pay for this with heavy losses. Impetuous troops willing to pay such a price for glory will always find a place in your armies.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Illyrians.jpg
Illyrian spearmen fight Makedonian skirmishers in the side-streets of Pella
The battle now moved to the center of town, where Pyrrhos's skirmishers had chased the retreated slingers, only to be confronted by Alkyoneus and his mounted bodyguards. Pyrrhos, who was previously leading the elephantes slowly up the main street, now charged into the attack. Another important lesson here is for a leader to be present at critical moments. Thus do you lend the weight of your bodyguard to the fray, and give your men renewed heart and vigor by your very presence alongside them. Pyrrhos did both, taking full part in the cavalry battle that resulted in the death of his opponent Alkyoneus.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Pyrrhos.jpg
Pyrrhos and his bodyguards in the confused cavalry battle around the square of Pella
It is well-known that Pyrrhos now won the battle by ordering his elephantes to directly charge the enemy phalanx on the central square, while he himself circled his bodyguards around and attacked the phalanx from its vulnerable rear. This brought the battle to a swift and bloody conclusion, albeit at some cost to the great beasts.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Elephants.jpg
The end of the Battle of Pella, as the Makedonian phalanx is beset by Pyrrhos and his elephants
Again we may ask why Pyrrhos chose this course of action, when he possessed twice as many phalangites of his own, who could have speared the Makedonian phalanx between two oncoming walls of sarissas. What he find from his records is that Pyrrhos wanted both to preserve his own phalangites, and to rid himself of the elephantes! My lord, while elephantes are a glorious and potentially battle-winning weapon, they are also ruinously expensive to the royal treasury. The funds required for their care and feeding could easily support a small army, and Epeiros's finances were at this point precarious. After their losses at the battle of Pella, Pyrrhos returned the elephantes to Ptolemy II Philadelphus, along with his copious thanks. The Ptolemaic king took glory in the accounts of how his elephantes won the battle, Pyrrhos saved Epeiros from bankruptcy, and history was none the wiser.
It is also to be noted that after this battle, Pyrrhos always refused to directly assault cities, and instead either forced the inhabitants out through starvation, or tempted nearby enemy armies into attacking and thereby drawing out the garrison in support. Some have speculated that the death-cries of the elephants on the square so affected Pyrrhos that he refused to countenance any further city assaults, believing them to always lead to needless losses.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Victory.jpg
The Makedonian capital of Pella falls to Pyrrhos
The following table shows the losses suffered and inflicted by Pyrrhos's army. These numbers are based on army records of pay and loot, which is largely apportioned based on the contributions reckoned by each unit to the battle.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Stats.jpg
Losses at the battle of Pella
Note in particular that the phalangites and Galatians were never engaged, suffering only minor losses to the enemy slingers in the opening minutes of the battle. While Pella was therefore not a profitable battle for these units, they would find much employment in the future. It is noted that Pyrrhos took special care to ensure that the Galatians did not further despoil the Makedonian tombs in search of treasure.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Tombs.jpg
The Makedonian Royal Tombs at Pella
Thus did Pyrrhos become Nikesas Pelles (Conqueror of Pella). He ordered that many of the Makedonian inhabitants be expelled, dispersing them to Epidamnos and Ambrakia, and that Pella should be ruled as an Epeirote-controlled military territory. My prince, you may know this is a somewhat heavy-handed and lengthy process of subduing a region, and it does not promote happiness or growth in the local population. However, it does offer troops from the area who are second-to-none in their fighting ability, if perhaps not as loyal as those raised from wintry Dodone itself.
During this year Pyrrhos also sent ambassadors to the Koinon Hellenon city-states of Athenai and Sparte, and to the Qarthadast outpost of Lilibeo on the island of Sicily, where Pyrrhos had previous campaigned. Although the Greeks strangely refused Pyrrhos's offer of a joint alliance against the Antigonids, they did agree to a furtherance of trade rights. And in return for a solemn promise that Pyrrhos would never ever again set foot on his mother's homeland of Sicily, Hamalcar of Qarthadast accepted (with some bad grace) that the old state of war should be suspended, and that sea trade could resume without hindrance. While battles win the attention of the populace, it is through the ties of trade that great empires are built, and these actions of Pyrrhos are worthy of your note.
https://i873.photobucket.com/albums/ab296/FoECarthage/DogsOfWar/272/272-Territory.jpg
Epeirote territory at the end of 272 BC
My prince, in my next missive I will expound on Pyrrhos's great battles for Demetrias over the next two years, and the lessons they hold for any military leader of Epeiros. May this message find you in good health.
[Game note: The elephants allow Epeiros to go on a massive blitz in the early game, but there's no fun in that. Far more engaging to disband the elephants, and then gradually build up to the point where you can recruit some more :) I'm also role-playing Pyrrhos's "dislikes attacking walls" trait.]