View Full Version : Rock & Roll Hall of Fame IV: The Reality Show [Concluded]
It's a private joke; JHT being his usual snarky self
If that was true, I would not have been able to vote. Therefore you are scum. :beam:
If that was true, I would not have been able to vote. Therefore you are scum. :beam:
I don't understand what you're talking about here, care to explain?
In the first game I played under JHT's hosting, I had a role that couldn't vote. I like to remind him (in good spirits, it doesn't bother me) about it every so often. So if he were to do something like that for you, then he would've made me unable to vote. :beam:
Scum.
In the first game I played under JHT's hosting, I had a role that couldn't vote. I like to remind him (in good spirits, it doesn't bother me) about it every so often. So if he were to do something like that for you, then he would've made me unable to vote. :beam:
Clearly you missed this, then:
Vanilla mafia, with the auditions as the only non-vanilla component.
Why would the host give you a role that cannot vote in a game that is completely vanilla? The comparison you're trying to make and the reasoning behind it are poor, because there's a marked difference between a 'special' role in a supposed vanilla game and a simple joke between two friends.
The host is more than welcome to post the Fabia Cerra video, but it is entirely inappropriate for these fora; I'm sure that he'll continue the joke through to my audition at the end of this phase, too.
I could say more, but I'm dead, and can't share PM's from the host therefore.
EIther way, you're scum.
Either way, you're scum.
You can continue to say that for as long as you see fit, but it isn't going to change the fact that it's wrong.
Zack and his claim to be a joker in a vanilla game, on the other hand...
You can continue to say that for as long as you see fit, but it isn't going to change the fact that it's wrong.
Zack and his claim to be a joker in a vanilla game, on the other hand...
I don't believe he would do that, balance reasons. You are scum. :beam:
Obviously he's being sarcastic. He should still die. Then you.
classical_hero
10-17-2011, 12:19
Secura, thou dost protest too much.
Secura, thou dost protest too much.
Doesn't the lady always? :P
johnhughthom
10-17-2011, 17:02
Doesn't the lady always? :P
Yes, but he's talking about you.
:clown:
johnhughthom
10-18-2011, 00:00
ORG IDOL
https://i405.photobucket.com/albums/pp139/johnhughthom/images-15.jpg
End of Day Five
Tally:
Zack: 7 (Arjos, landlubber, Beskar, Zack, Secura, Cpt B, ch)
There was a unanimous verdict for todays eviction, a discrepancy between the performance he claimed he was going to do for the audience and his actual performance saw Zack ejected from the competition, strangely he disappeared before he could be interviewed ahead of his departure.
As they sat in the director's booth, the tv execs were discussing the canteen, "two contestants in a row put down with illness and refusing to come out of the bathroom? I tell you, there is something fishy in that beef stew."
Updated audition queue:
Classical Hero
Beskar
Voted off:
Montmorency
autolycus
B_Ray
Skooma
Zack
Killed:
Warman
Visorslash
TLD
Lazy McCrow
Auditioned:
Visorslash
landlubber
TLD
Arjos
Capt B
Csargo
Zack
Alive
Arjos
Classical Hero
Flax
landlubber
Beskar
Csargo
Cpt B
Secura
Flax and Secura feigning illness and skipping the auditions?
Well I know who are Zack's buddies XD
Montmorency
10-18-2011, 01:20
Can't be that simple.
Well I know who are Zack's buddies XD
There's another joker?
In all seriousness I think there's a mafia and a townie in that pair, my money is on Secura...
LazyMcCrow
10-18-2011, 09:15
Please excuse my seilence since my murder. Happy to follow what is going on, but feel as clueless about who is guilty as I did when I was alive. :/
johnhughthom
10-19-2011, 00:04
ORG IDOL
https://i405.photobucket.com/albums/pp139/johnhughthom/images-15.jpg
End of Night Five
And we are live, back in the Org Idol house, get ready for our next contestant, Classical Hero!
Silence.
Classical Hero!
Er, Classical Hero!
It's now Day Six.
Updated audition queue:
Beskar
Voted off:
Montmorency
autolycus
B_Ray
Skooma
Zack
Killed:
Warman
Visorslash
TLD
Lazy McCrow
Classical Hero
Auditioned:
Visorslash
landlubber
TLD
Arjos
Capt B
Csargo
Zack
Alive
Arjos
Flax
landlubber
Beskar
Csargo
Cpt B
Secura
Montmorency
10-19-2011, 00:08
So Classical, Flax, and Secura won't audition. I don't think we would be so lucky as to have got them all, but I'm sure there is one scum there. My bet is on classical.
Oh and forgot, Vote: Secura
Montmorency
10-19-2011, 00:41
Ooohhhhh.
Oh god, I am so, so sorry.
landlubber
10-19-2011, 00:43
Do you have any clue why you didn't audition, Flax and Secura?
My guess is that seeing how mafia auditions were such a giveaway, john picked a townie and a mafia and removed them from the audition list due to illness...
Or our legs are being extremely well pulled :P
Alive:
landlubber - auditioned
Arjos - auditioned - successful audition
Capt B - auditioned
Csargo - auditioned
Beskar - has not auditioned yet
Secura - illness
Flax - illness
I have not read through the thread fully yet, but Arjos's audition makes him stand out compared to the rest of them. I have read over all of his posts and think he would be a good lynch from what I've read. I'll wait to vote until I've read the rest of the thread.
classical_hero
10-19-2011, 09:08
That was such a surprise, of me being killed, not. It is obvious who it is.
That was such a surprise, of me being killed, not. It is obvious who it is.
Indeed.
Vote: Secura
Just so I don't get magically killed before my audition, here is my role-pm with the clip now:
Beskar
Frank
You are town, vote each day phase for who you think is mafia, and pray you don't die at night.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0abFoHZDZY
Do you have any clue why you didn't audition, Flax and Secura?
I don't, no. I'm rather confused about the whole thing.
landlubber
10-19-2011, 23:24
You should post your audition, then, if you know what's good for you. Otherwise, you're probably gonna get lynched.
As for my vote, since I haven't seen a response from Secura, at the risk of appearing bandwagon-y, vote:Secura.
johnhughthom
10-20-2011, 00:04
Round over, write up commencing.
You should post your audition, then, if you know what's good for you. Otherwise, you're probably gonna get lynched.
As for my vote, since I haven't seen a response from Secura, at the risk of appearing bandwagon-y, vote:Secura.
I did, quite some time ago actually. (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?137457-Rock-amp-Roll-Hall-of-Fame-IV-The-Reality-Show-In-play&p=2053385234&viewfull=1#post2053385234)
landlubber
10-20-2011, 00:17
My apologies. Having trouble keeping up with who's posted what for some reason.
johnhughthom
10-20-2011, 00:21
ORG IDOL
https://i405.photobucket.com/albums/pp139/johnhughthom/images-15.jpg
End of Day Six
Tally:
Secura: 3 (Arjos, Beskie, landlubber)
The vote was a unanimous decision, amongst the contestants that actually votes. The final audition was due for this phase.
"Let's welcome our latest hopeful, the artist formerly known as Beskar!"
....
"Tea-axe?"
"Okay, what's going on?"
It's now Night Six.
Auditions finished:
Voted off:
Montmorency
autolycus
B_Ray
Skooma
Zack
Secura
Killed:
Warman
Visorslash
TLD
Lazy McCrow
Classical Hero
Auditioned:
Visorslash
landlubber
TLD
Arjos
Capt B
Csargo
Zack
Alive
Arjos
Flax
landlubber
Beskar
Csargo
Cpt B
"Okay, what's going on?"
Ditto XD
TheLastDays
10-20-2011, 07:43
What the ...?
This game is weird, I blame the thom.
classical_hero
10-20-2011, 08:26
He should be the artist formerly known at Beskar.
LazyMcCrow
10-20-2011, 08:36
Tea-Axe.
:inquisitive:
TheLastDays
10-20-2011, 09:22
Sounds like a Hip Hop "artist"
I already posted my role-pm in the round before. Interesting...
Perhaps a mafia ability to preventing auditions instead of doing kills?
Eitherway, have a list with a link to everyone who is alive and their videos would be good. Anyone who hasn't got an audition/video needs to remedy that asap.
That doesn't really make sense.
Everyone's audition has been posted who is still alive, and Arjos is the only one who's audition is different.
Csargo I love you too, but the real auditions that stand out are those like Zack's (his was from the simpsons), so the mafia is hiding among those who haven't been auditioned...
landlubber
10-20-2011, 22:57
Csargo I love you too, but the real auditions that stand out are those like Zack's (his was from the simpsons), so the mafia is hiding among those who haven't been auditioned...
By that you mean... Beskar and Flax?
I think one of them yes...
johnhughthom
10-21-2011, 00:00
ORG IDOL
https://i405.photobucket.com/albums/pp139/johnhughthom/images-15.jpg
End of Night Six
"Well, it appears the audition schedule has been fulfilled."
"Fulfilled indeed Tom, though we didn't hear from too many of them, perhaps that was for the best."
"For the best is right Diane, these people are awful."
"Awful indeed Tom. Oh, another one was killed last night, Arjos or something he was called. Who cares though?"
"Who cares is right Diane."
It's now Day Seven.
Auditions finished:
Voted off:
Montmorency
autolycus
B_Ray
Skooma
Zack
Secura
Killed:
Warman
Visorslash
TLD
Lazy McCrow
Classical Hero
Arjos
Auditioned:
Visorslash
landlubber
TLD
Arjos
Capt B
Csargo
Zack
Alive
Flax
landlubber
Beskar
Csargo
Cpt B
What happened to Ollie Williams and the weather forecast!?
And folks, eyes on Beskar, his whole text claim, all like Secura...
landlubber
10-21-2011, 01:33
Out of the five of us left, Beskar's stands out to me. He didn't perform on Got Talent, Idol, or X-Factor, just like Zack. Also, I don't understand why he didn't actually post his video when he made the text claim. I was expecting him to post it a few days after that, but it took him this long. He's the best choice, from what we know.
Vote: Beskar.
TheLastDays
10-21-2011, 08:14
It's Secura. kthxbye
LazyMcCrow
10-21-2011, 09:14
It's Secura. kthxbye ...Isn't she already voted off?:dizzy2:
Interesting votes, but totally incorrect. Can I say I already predicted a few rounds back that this was going to happen? :laugh4:
Yes, make a mistake today and it is the lynch-pin turning. The comments about me not posting the video were fraudulent as I gave all details as necessary and even posted my role-pm when I suspected this was going to happen. I am actually a really bad choice to be lynched.
Cpt. Blackadder is going to be counted for an inactive and TheFlax isn't active himself. This leads it to the conclusion there are only three voters.
Discounting myself as I am not mafia, that either leaves it to be between Landlubber and Csargo who posted during the night.
Arjos was killed, this could be argued that this makes Csargo look incorrect and look like a simple townie. However, I have played with Csargo before as another player (Swords in the Moon) and hosted a game he won in (Noblesse Oblige), he is far from stupid and it could simply be a distraction in order to try to cover up the story for himself. It could be that the mafia also killed Arjos and is then trying to get Csargo on-side. Either way, Csargo is the most dangerous person in this game alive.
However, Landlubber made a big mistake, he jumped for one of the framed targets. The reason I never posted my video was diliberate, because I know I would have been night killed otherwise. With the cover that they cancelled my audition, it makes a great move for them to 'frame me'.
In short, it is either Landlubber or Csargo...
oh man, so reminds me of Netherworld, except now I am not actually the mafia and have to decide, grr.
Also I just realised Csargo hasn't voted all game...
Vote:Csargo
Mafia.
But Landlubber kept trying to make Flax look scummy by saying he didn't post his Role PM when he did do.. grrr....
I don't trust Landlubber much, he's been jumping from very helpful (making a list of who auditioned with link on day 3 IIRC) to downright absent. It reads pretty much like "Hey guys, I'm a townie and all, see I'm helping!" while not contributing all that much. (Though it can be said, few have contributed meaningfully this game, including me)
Now, for his reason of voting Beskar / Tiaexz, I'm really not convinced. Sure the video was posted pretty late in the game, but what does that really mean? What did the mass video reveal actually gave us, information wise? Except wild speculation, not much.
So I'm going to have to go with Vote: Landlubber
Guys the mafia has silly auditions videos, seeing how Flax and Beskar are going "side by side", maybe we were wrong with Secura and the last 2 mafia are them...
TheLastDays
10-21-2011, 16:17
...Isn't she already voted off?:dizzy2:
You're right. Well done, peoples. Then lynch Beskar, or whatever he's called now.
landlubber
10-21-2011, 20:43
But Landlubber kept trying to make Flax look scummy by saying he didn't post his Role PM when he did do.. grrr....
This was a mistake on my own behalf. I understand how easily it can be seen as scummy, so you'll just have to take my word for it, I suppose.
In response to Flaxxy, I can understand your reasoning, but I don't see how I've been very absent as of late. Sure, I was having spotty internet and missed voting a few days, but that hasn't applied for these last few days.
johnhughthom
10-22-2011, 00:00
ORG IDOL
https://i405.photobucket.com/albums/pp139/johnhughthom/images-15.jpg
End of Day Seven
Tally:
Beskar: 1 (lubber)
Csargo: 1 (Beskar)
lubber: 1 (Flax)
"Oh a tie, can we make them fight to the death?"
"No, it's much more mundane than that. I enter the three names into a list randomiser and which over one is at the top has to go home."
"You realise this is a tv show, right? That is the most boring play off I have ever heard."
"Shut up. landlubber, get your butt outta here!"
"Shouldn't we at least make everybody audition again? I mean some of the remaining contestants haven't even gone once."
"Shut up."
It's now Night Seven.
Auditions finished:
Voted off:
Montmorency
autolycus
B_Ray
Skooma
Zack
Secura
landlubber
Killed:
Warman
Visorslash
TLD
Lazy McCrow
Classical Hero
Arjos
Auditioned:
Visorslash
landlubber
TLD
Arjos
Capt B
Csargo
Zack
Alive
Flax
Beskar
Csargo
Cpt B
Montmorency
10-22-2011, 00:12
Mafia will win, I think.
landlubber
10-22-2011, 02:08
Mafia will win, I think.
I agree. The fact that I was lynched with one vote shows that the town needs coordinate their lynches better, because, depending on the number of mafia, we may have already lost if a kill goes through successfully.
Also I just realised Csargo hasn't voted all game...
Vote:Csargo
Mafia.
I voted in the first round :angry:
It's probably Beskar.
I voted in the first round :angry:
It's probably Beskar.
Not posting in the day but always seem to be around at night... Yeah, you are the Mafia.
You seem so sure about that.
You are clearly around to be sending in your night orders.
I'm guessing that's exactly why you are here now. :tongue:
I am always around, even when I am not.
You are not around during the day phase, but magically are during the night phase.
Skooma Addict
10-22-2011, 17:06
I am always around, even when I am not.
You are not around during the day phase, but magically are during the night phase.
I detect a distinct odor coming from you. Smells like scum. Now tell me Beskar of the Tea-Axes, why would that be?
Mafia will win, I think.
All due to town inactivity none the less :S
If we still have a shot next day phase and Beskar isn't lynched is likely over...
I am going to be honest here, write down your notes on why am I scummy and please save them for post-game. I am truly curious how I am viewed as such, even as a town. :laugh4:
johnhughthom
10-22-2011, 18:56
Because you're Beskar, duh. Even when you're not. :wink:
johnhughthom
10-22-2011, 23:59
ORG IDOL
https://i405.photobucket.com/albums/pp139/johnhughthom/images-15.jpg
End of Night Seven
"Is this thing still going, what's this, fourteen episodes? Is anybody still watching?"
"Nobody was watching in the first place."
"I think we really screwed up with this one, think we'll get the sack?"
"Nah, nobody got naked and there were no wardrobe malfunctions. Everybody knows that would be worse than making awful tv programs."
"Yeah, good point."
"Oh! Somebody else was killed. Umm, how sad."
"Yawn."
Auditions finished:
Voted off:
Montmorency
autolycus
B_Ray
Skooma
Zack
Secura
landlubber
Killed:
Warman
Visorslash
TLD
Lazy McCrow
Classical Hero
Arjos
Cpt B
Auditioned:
Visorslash
landlubber
TLD
Arjos
Capt B
Csargo
Zack
Alive
Flax
Beskar
Csargo
Montmorency
10-23-2011, 00:09
Why did Mafia kill inactive town? I'm afraid there are 2 Mafia.
landlubber
10-23-2011, 00:25
Why did Mafia kill inactive town? I'm afraid there are 2 Mafia.
I can think of reasons that all three players would have killed Blackadder: Flax is mafia and killed Cpt B to keep Beskar and Csargo alive, both of whom are much more scummy than him in the town's eyes; or, The mafia is either Beskar or Csargo and they killed an inactive townie in hopes that they could persuade Flax to vote in their favor I'm sure there aren't two mafia, though, or the game would be over, wouldn't it?
Hosts have been known to let games continue in those circumstances in order to confuse the town further.
Montmorency
10-23-2011, 00:43
Dunno, most of the games I've read where 2 Mafia are left were in the end drawn out.
If Beskar is Mafia,he should have killed Csargo, as the Flax is friendly to him and CB isn't around to defend himself anyway.
The best argument against 2 Mafia, really, is that they wouldn't have let the last round be decided by chance. Unless they weren't being voted.
My final decision is that Csargo is Mafia no matter what.
Why did Mafia kill inactive town? I'm afraid there are 2 Mafia.
I killed Captain BA in Netherworld as he was completely unreliable in this situation and if Flax was killed, for example, a tie between me and Csargo could mean Csargo could lose.
I am obviously left alive to be the person to vote off, this is why I am too reliable to be night killed.
Csargo is obviously around during the night phase, even if he is not voting.
If theFlax is mafia though, he is in a very powerful position since Csargo is accusing me and I am accusing him. In short, if you're mafia Flax, goodgame. :bow:
Vote: Csargo
I just saw Csargo's video, he is very violent.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DUJ9Rlbnz_Q
Mafia.
I can think of reasons that all three players would have killed Blackadder: Flax is mafia and killed Cpt B to keep Beskar and Csargo alive, both of whom are much more scummy than him in the town's eyes; or, The mafia is either Beskar or Csargo and they killed an inactive townie in hopes that they could persuade Flax to vote in their favor I'm sure there aren't two mafia, though, or the game would be over, wouldn't it?
I agree with this, its a screwy situation. I prefer to labor under the impression that there is only one mafia left, because if there are two, its already over and it makes this round kind of pointless.
I'm not exactly sure where to go from there. Beskar in my opinion is a bit too convenient as a lynchbait, that's why I'm more tempted to vote Csargo at the moment, but I still have reservations.
Montmorency I'm not sure I fully understand your post.
"If Beskar is Mafia,he should have killed Csargo, as the Flax is friendly to him and CB isn't around to defend himself anyway."
That would have been pretty obvious, I think. The current situation is possibly the best move of either one of us, so as I said, its kind of screwy.
"My final decision is that Csargo is Mafia no matter what."
I'd really like to know why, because I'd like to get that kind of certitude when I vote.
Montmorency
10-23-2011, 06:59
I was outlining what I considered to be the best argument against two Mafiosi remaining:
Who voted yesterday?
Flax: Landlubber
Landlubber: Beskar
Beskar: Csargo
CB was AWOL town.
Csargo didn't show up.
If there were 2 Mafiosi, one of them would have been voted here. With 2 Mafiosi, they would not have allowed chance to determine the lynch, because if one of them had been random-lynched there, then the remaining one would have been in danger of losing on the last day.
If they had blatantly taken the heat off a voted scum, they would have still won 2-1 the following day.
That's why it's pretty much impossible for there to be 2 scum right now.
As for Csargo specifically, it's more of a hunch. My 'evidence' is tenuous and likely irrelevant:
He came in after 12 days of inactivity to make a case against Arjos (a proven townie). Arjos was killed that night.
He's scum and didn't vote to tiebreak yesterday because he wanted to avoid bringing attention to himself. He suspected Beskar. Beskar had a vote on him. He didn't really want to see Beskar lynched, though. He didn't actually think Beskar was Mafia, because he is Mafia. He wanted Beskar as lynchbait for the final round.
Also, I'm given to understand that he is a lurker by design.
Also, I'm given to understand that he is a lurker by design.
That is correct. Csargo usually simply lurks the entire game as townie or as mafia, lurks and randomly seems to 'pop up' to avoid being WoG'd as mafia.
Plus, I rather lose to TheFlax then Csargo via that, sort of a metagamey reason, but I made my choice.
TheLastDays
10-23-2011, 10:09
It's Beskar.
Yes it's clear that Beskar is the last mafia alive, he... mmmmm... he has a goatee! XD
But really all his reasonings are to deviate attention, vote him or perish :P
Montmorency
10-23-2011, 18:05
How about a friendly wager?
I want me to stay alive now, just to spite all these people saying I am the mafia, because they will rage about it then the game ends and they see I wasn't. Then they mysteriously never post again in the thread.
If I'm wrong I'd hat down to your towness and the mafia's apathy, but that's then and now is now :P
Few hrs left and only you voted though :S
Csargo strikes me as a lurker, who barely follows the game...
Flax I think is townie, while Beskar is the last mafia...
That's my feeling, don't stump on it :D
I'm going to have to vote the person I consider most likely to be scum. Vote: Csargo
johnhughthom
10-24-2011, 00:03
ORG IDOL
https://i405.photobucket.com/albums/pp139/johnhughthom/images-15.jpg
End of Day Eight
Tally:
Csargo: 2 (Beskar, Flax)
The final three contestants came together to vote the final person off, well two of them did anyhow and they agreed that the missing hopeful was clearly behind all the naughtiness that had ruined their chances of fame.
As Csargo was removed, well he had already left, the two remaining contestants looked at each other warily. "So," said Beskar, "shall we audition again and the winner gets the place in the band."
Slash.
Evil chuckle. "I think not."
MAFIA VICTORY
Mafia team:
TheFlax
Zack
Secura
Game mechanics:
Lots of pink.
Vanilla, except for the audition mechanism, which the mafia could choose not to do, and was cancelled when we were down to the final scum. I was rather amused when this implicated Beskar, I know he is going to say I made it up just to frame him, like I apparently changed the mechanics in the first game to deprive him of a victory. Mafia QT is here (http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/vMyiaTtwTTu), and what an optimistic bunch they are, though I did play on that a little...
Where's my joker victory?
landlubber
10-24-2011, 01:29
Oh, you.
Also, nice job, Flax. That was a well-deserved win on your part. :bow:
Montmorency
10-24-2011, 01:32
Wow, I did not suspect Flax at all, unless as a scum duo with Beskar.
GG then. :bow:
Thanks guys, it is a pleasure to be back and win my second victory as mafia. I was impressed the way some of you figured out certain things pretty accurately and I was afraid I would not be able to sneak by. I kept expecting Beskar to call me out. :clown:
If you check out the QT, you will see we expected to lose, badly. I think the fact that auditions were suspended after Secura's lynch was what really saved me in the end.
Thanks for the game JHT. :bow:
johnhughthom
10-24-2011, 01:46
I kept expecting Beskar to call me out. :clown:
To be fair to Beskie he did say to me on Steam chat today that he knew it was you, not sure why he didn't change his vote. Though he may have just been trying to get me to say something more than "no comment"...
Thanks for taking part everybody. :bow:
To be fair to Beskie he did say to me on Steam chat today that he knew it was you
Ahahahahah after this no townieness for Beskar! :D
classical_hero
10-24-2011, 03:06
I want to see Secura's and The Flax's auditions. BTW GG by The Flax, I just wasn't expecting there to be 3 mafia in this game.
Skooma Addict
10-24-2011, 03:40
Congrats to Flax, Secura, Zack and Beskar for their victory. :bow:
I want to see Secura's and The Flax's auditions. BTW GG by The Flax, I just wasn't expecting there to be 3 mafia in this game.
Actually, my audition got played for Zack because of a mix up. So he really wasn't lying when he said it wasn't his audition. :clown:
TheLastDays
10-24-2011, 09:25
I want me to stay alive now, just to spite all these people saying I am the mafia, because they will rage about it then the game ends and they see I wasn't. Then they mysteriously never post again in the thread.
You clearly don't know me :tongue:
I was wrong and I can admit that, not that it mattered anymore because we all were wrong about Flax, nice game mate :bow:
I knew it was Flax because he seemed so keen about the game to me in private. The problem was, if I voted for Flax, Csargo would have voted for me anyway.
So I thought "Well, I rather lose to Flax by getting night killed" and went for it. :laugh4:
Beskie is going to say I did this intentionally to frame him
That is actually true. I thought it was more cunning, for example "It was a mafia ability being used" hence why I posted my role-pm because I foresaw it occurring.
LazyMcCrow
10-24-2011, 10:36
GG. I can't pretend I had any idea who was mafia at any point in the game - it was good to read the QT - certainly proves the rule that it's never over til the fat lady sings... hey wait - I WAS the fat lady :stare:
classical_hero
10-24-2011, 11:33
After reading the Mafia QT, I just don't think that this game was well thought out. The fact that the Mafia could only win by not auditioning their tapes is not a good way to win. the clue that bound them together should have been much less obvious than them being Simpsons characters. The idea of the game was good, just that the execution was lacking.
TheLastDays
10-24-2011, 13:04
Interesting QT and I agree with what was said about mass reveals. In a game like this I think it should be forbidden for people to post their auditions before they were up, or even roleclaim, but since it wasn't and everyone started revealing I was playing along. Don't like being lynched when I'm town :shrug:
LazyMcCrow
10-24-2011, 13:21
Interesting QT and I agree with what was said about mass reveals. In a game like this I think it should be forbidden for people to post their auditions before they were up, or even roleclaim, but since it wasn't and everyone started revealing I was playing along. Don't like being lynched when I'm town :shrug:
yup agreed.
The fact that the Mafia could only win by not auditioning their tapes is not a good way to win. the clue that bound them together should have been much less obvious than them being Simpsons characters.
The main problem for us was that we had no cover roles whatsoever and couldn't throw them out during the performance phase; we either had to perform as we were (and I would've been lynched once you saw that I was Groundskeeper Willie!) or not perform at all, both of which were scummy as hell. We had to rely on inactivity and utter fabrication and it really didn't work for us.
Really, the game was stacked heavily in the town's favour and it's only through town oversight (such as the fact that the very first kill was Warman wondering how his killers got out of the TV!) and inactivity, in addition to sheer tenacity on Flax's part.
In a game like this I think it should be forbidden for people to post their auditions before they were up, or even roleclaim, but since it wasn't and everyone started revealing I was playing along.
I think by the time JHT realised that revealing en-masse would break the game, it was too late. :<
TheLastDays
10-24-2011, 23:23
The main problem for us was that we had no cover roles whatsoever and couldn't throw them out during the performance phase; we either had to perform as we were (and I would've been lynched once you saw that I was Groundskeeper Willie!) or not perform at all, both of which were scummy as hell. We had to rely on inactivity and utter fabrication and it really didn't work for us.
Really, the game was stacked heavily in the town's favour and it's only through town oversight (such as the fact that the very first kill was Warman wondering how his killers got out of the TV!) and inactivity, in addition to sheer tenacity on Flax's part.
I think by the time JHT realised that revealing en-masse would break the game, it was too late. :<
I totally agree and it's a shameful experience to have lost a game that was basically handed to us :sweatdrop:
And I wasn't blaming JHT or anything, just explaining why I did reveal, even though I thought it was silly.
johnhughthom
10-25-2011, 01:04
I totally agree and it's a shameful experience to have lost a game that was basically handed to us :sweatdrop:
Host is highly amused at the townies criticising a game, which was heavily inbalanced in their favour, that they lost. :laugh4:
The guys who were inconvenienced had their say a while ago, and took it well, offering advice rather than criticism, for which I am grateful. :bow:
I'll probably give up on hosting mafia games now, I seem to be better at non mafia, like my Game of Thrones game, coming after Capo. Shameless plug over.
My Role PM, as requested:
Secura
Groundskeeper Willie: Mafia
The geniuses at the tv company decided that combining animated murderers with real life talentless nobodies would be a surefire winner. The mafia team have one kill per night and win when all townies are eliminated.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=np-6kh0S7J8
I only wanted to be in the B-Sharps... :<
johnhughthom
10-25-2011, 19:37
I only wanted to be in the B-Sharps... :<
I had wanted all the mafia roles to be B-Sharps auditions, Willie's was the only one I could find, all the other videos had the entire scene.
Host is highly amused at the townies criticising a game, which was heavily inbalanced in their favour, that they lost. :laugh4:
Eh eh, I think the concept is fun, just need to make mafia's audition more similar to town's ones and no reveals allowed...
It ended quite silly though, ppl going inactive, and the last votes on the Csargo, who auditioned and wasn't a Simpson :S
Yeah what Arjos said.
Good game JHT, thanks for hosting. I didn't like that the mafia killed active people. :tongue:
I wish you had given me that nonvoting role.
Good game scumbags, even though I was killed early again.
Askthepizzaguy
10-26-2011, 13:26
Congratulations, Flaxy!
You very big win. :bow:
I didn't like that the mafia killed active people. :tongue:
As you can see from the QuickTopic, we didn't like doing it but it was pretty much the only way to overcome all the odds being stacked against us; being killed didn't stop you posting and pushing for my lynch, anyway.
I didn't like that the mafia killed active people. :tongue:
Come on man, our N1 kill was Warman.
johnhughthom
10-27-2011, 03:51
That's not very nice, just because he didn't even notice he was dead doesn't mean he wasn't paying attention. This could well have been the game Warman made a telling townie contribution toward, and you ruined it. I hope you are happy with yourself. :brood:
Askthepizzaguy
10-27-2011, 05:10
Keep strangling that kitten, John.
johnhughthom
10-27-2011, 16:40
Just in case poor Warman takes the comment seriously and cries and stuff, I would like to point out that it was entirely tongue in cheek. I mean me, mocking somebody for not making a townie contribution...
TheLastDays
10-28-2011, 10:49
Just in case poor Warman takes the comment seriously and cries and stuff, I would like to point out that it was entirely tongue in cheek. I mean me, mocking somebody for not making a townie contribution...
How's that master class in vote analyzing coming along?
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.