Log in

View Full Version : Small Mafia Game Storm's End [Concluded]



Pages : [1] 2

Visor
07-03-2013, 12:23
Storm's End is one of the strongest castles in the Seven Kingdoms. It is the main seat of House Baratheon, and before it, the ancestral seat of the Storm Kings extending back many thousands of years. The castle is said to be protected by spells woven into its very walls that prevent magic from affecting it or passing through it.

Lord Robert Baratheon took the majority of the Stormland forces with him. He left his younger brother, Stannis, and a small garrison to hold Storm's End. Following Robert's defeat by the Tyrell host at the Battle of Ashford, driving Robert away from his base of power, the Tyrell host advanced directly on Storm’s End, laying siege to it.

Two hundred and eighty three years after Aegon's landing, the small force of Stannis Baratheon sits in the fabled castle of Storm's End besieged by the huge Tyrell host whilst his brother takes to the field to take back Lyanna and depose the Mad King Aerys II. Stannis was ordered to hold Storm's End, and so he shall, until the end.

Welcome to another mafia game, based upon the events of Robert's Rebellion, specifically the siege of Storm's End (from G.R.R.M's series A Song of Ice and Fire).

Rules:
•24 hour days and 24 hour night phases. Phases may be extended if needed and if I require.
•You may talk after death. However, no out of thread info, etc. No "I can't say why, but lynch 'x'." If you do so, I will first give a warning, then ban you from talking. This may change depending on how many players I get.
•Don't quote anything I say to you, however, paraphrasing is fine. Don't discuss the time of PM's, or the length or writing style, as it means nothing.
•No screenshots, etc.
•You may talk to players outside the thread.
•You will vote for players you want lynched during the day, using the format, Vote: Visorslash. Votes must be in bold to count. If you wish to unvote, simply: Unvote; Vote: ATPG. You don't need to do a semicolon, I just think it looks nice.
•If you are replaced or WOG killed, please do not post in the thread anymore unless it is an apology. If you are replaced by choice, please don't comment in the game.
•If you think you won't be around during the night phase to give your night action, you can always PM me your night actions in advance.
•Votes that end in a tie, no lynch.
•No lynch is allowed.
•Don't edit posts with votes. I won't count them. Feel free to misrepresent the tally, I do my own anyway. If I can be convinced otherwise, I will change the rule.
•This game will have roles.
•If you miss three day phases in a row or 4 in total with any reasonable excuse or informing me why you will be WoG'ed. No exceptions for role.
•Have fun. This is not an option . If you don't think you'll have fun with this game... don't join it. Nor if you feel you won't be able to participate.
•Alignment will be revealed on death, not role.


Players 18/18:
1. Makrell
2. LazyMcCrow
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
10. Darth Feather
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
12. B-Wing
13. Yay!
14. Riedquat
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Reserves:
1. Chaotix

Makrell
07-03-2013, 12:39
in dibs on davos seaworth, or the bastard if i must

LazyMcCrow
07-03-2013, 13:15
Blessings to The Mother - I'm in.

autolycus
07-03-2013, 14:39
Mother? Really, Fear the StraInger!

edse
07-03-2013, 15:42
StraInger? lol, that was lame :P

El Barto
07-03-2013, 16:20
I've never read A Song of Ice and Fire, that way I can just fantasise about what is going on here, make wild assumptions, incorrectly interpret basic stuff that I should obviously know, etc. etc. Bring it on!

Double A
07-03-2013, 17:32
[insert Double A signup post]

rickinator9
07-03-2013, 17:38
Going into the breach!

Ibn-Khaldun
07-03-2013, 17:42
A Song of Ice aNd Fire!

BSmith
07-03-2013, 18:39
In for me please!

Darth Feather
07-03-2013, 20:47
Never heard of Song of Ice and fire. But a mafia game, In

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-04-2013, 00:38
Colour me in...

Double A
07-04-2013, 03:02
Never heard of Song of Ice and fire. But a mafia game, In

vote: DF

B-Wing
07-04-2013, 03:23
I have heard of Song of Ice and Fire, but don't really know anything about it. Regardless, I want in. The rules mandate fun-having, and I am strongly Pro-Fun. Can you give us an idea of how vanilla this game will be? Sounds pretty factional, which interests me. :sneaky:

Visor
07-04-2013, 03:58
I have heard of Song of Ice and Fire, but don't really know anything about it. Regardless, I want in. The rules mandate fun-having, and I am strongly Pro-Fun. Can you give us an idea of how vanilla this game will be? Sounds pretty factional, which interests me. :sneaky:

Depends how many people sign up (it will be a small game though). There may be more then one faction and/or goal. Just see how I feel about it and the numbers.

Jarema
07-04-2013, 05:44
in!

Darth Feather
07-04-2013, 09:00
vote: DF

Hey, I HAVE been living on Jupiter lately so it's not my fault.
(After googling it, I found out I just didn't know the name, I saw the books in a library and in book shops.)

Chaotix
07-04-2013, 09:52
Put me down as a reserve in case you don't get 17.

:bow:

Riedquat
07-04-2013, 19:25
Oh! Yo quiero!! Innnn! :yes:

Thanks Visorstain!!

Visor
07-05-2013, 14:17
Arjos SalmonSoil (?)

Just need three more players and I can start this.

Visor
07-06-2013, 01:43
Hate to double post/bump my own thread, but a final piece of information before the game starts:

The game will start tomorrow regardless of how many players have signed up. However, depending on the amount of players, the scum team/town power roles will change accordingly.

Possible setups:
2 Cults and a neutral
2 cults
1 cult 1 mafia
1 mafia some neutrals
Mafia (members don't know each other) and some neutrals
1 cult

If there is a cult, there will be restrictions, etc to not make the game unbalanced. Every faction will get a chance to suceed.

Ishmael
07-06-2013, 07:24
I'll be in, please.

White_eyes:D
07-06-2013, 14:49
IN if it's not too late.:bow:

HopAlongBunny
07-06-2013, 14:55
in if needed

SalmonSoil
07-06-2013, 22:04
Woo Game of Thrones IN

Visor
07-07-2013, 00:49
Alright that's everyone. I'm going to send out role Pms sometime today, and hopefully get the game underway.

Visor
07-07-2013, 03:52
Alright, all role PMs have been sent out. I will writeup a short introduction and then let the day start.

El Barto
07-07-2013, 04:14
So, when is winter coming?

Visor
07-07-2013, 04:34
Begin Day 1

Stannis ground his teeth. The banners of Tyrell and Redwyne flapped in the breeze outside the fabled castle. No doubt they were feasting even now on all manner of delicacies whilst his men starved. He turned away from the walls and began to walk back to the keep. The Onion Knight had brought them much needed supplies, but onions did not replace anything of substance. "M'lord!" was the call from Davos Fleabottom. The man was a smuggler, but he had also saved them from eating the dead, he was certainly an interesting man. "There's talk of surrendering in the garrison. Some of the men think they're better off with the Tyrells." Stannis' teeth clenched as he heard the news. "Find them and bring them to me, I'll give them to their Tyrells, though not in the manner they intend." he said with a gesture to the catapults near the walls. Davos nodded and went off to tell the garrison about the traitors.

Cressen had warned him of this, and now it had happened. There wasn't much you could do to stop it though, almost a year of low supplies whilst the enemy feasted outside the gate would drive men to forsake their vows. Still, traitors must be punished, and the punishment would be death.


Day 1 will end 24 hours from this post at 1:30 PM GMT +10.

Alive:
1. Makrell
2. LazyMcCrow
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
10. Darth Feather
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
12. B-Wing
13. Yay!
14. Riedquat
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Double A
07-07-2013, 05:59
vote: DF because it's day 1 and DF is basically New Beefy as far as my day 1 voting habits are concerned.

Ishmael
07-07-2013, 06:32
vote: Double A

Because killing Renly is fun!

Jarema
07-07-2013, 06:57
vote: Ibn-Khaldun because I do not think voting for the host is worthwile

Double A
07-07-2013, 07:35
vote: Double A

Because killing Renly is fun!

unvote, vote: Ishmael :stare:

Darth Feather
07-07-2013, 08:16
vote: DF because it's day 1 and DF is basically New Beefy as far as my day 1 voting habits are concerned.

Is that to be considered a compliment? :book2:

That put aside: randomvote: WhiteEyes:D

Riedquat
07-07-2013, 08:34
Vote: Autolycus

Ibn-Khaldun
07-07-2013, 10:45
Vote: Makrell

Because I'm hungry..

LazyMcCrow
07-07-2013, 11:34
Yay! Jarema is Jarema again. Vote: Jarema

Jarema
07-07-2013, 12:15
yay!

BSmith
07-07-2013, 13:36
vote: Lazy

rickinator9
07-07-2013, 13:42
vote: Double A

Because killing Renly is fun!

Renly's cool

Vote: Ishmael

HopAlongBunny
07-07-2013, 13:49
Vote: SalmonSoil

White_eyes:D
07-07-2013, 14:49
Vote:edse

edse
07-07-2013, 17:54
Vote: Ibn Khaldun You were better of as The King.

Double A
07-07-2013, 18:00
Nice job edse, making your lies so obvious, now no one can possibly think you're scum.


Is that to be considered a compliment? :book2:

The hell if I know.

Makrell
07-07-2013, 18:11
vote:A*2

B-Wing
07-07-2013, 20:45
I didn't realize Game of Thrones was part of Song of Ice and Fire.
vote: Makrell

El Barto
07-07-2013, 22:35
Nice job edse, making your lies so obvious, now no one can possibly think you're scum.
But he's on my Mafia Team PM…

B-Wing
07-07-2013, 22:52
But he's on my Mafia Team PM…

A clue!

BTW, how do y'all feel about going for a tie (resulting in no lynch) since it's Day 1? Is that generally a good idea?

El Barto
07-08-2013, 01:20
A clue!
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/ff/Solid_blue.svg/100px-Solid_blue.svg.png

BTW, how do y'all feel about going for a tie (resulting in no lynch) since it's Day 1? Is that generally a good idea?
No idea.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-08-2013, 02:08
Vote: Darth Feather

SalmonSoil
07-08-2013, 03:10
Vote: SalmonSoil

vote: HopAlongBunny

Voting for SalmonSoil is a well known scumtell.

Double A
07-08-2013, 03:24
But he's on my Mafia Team PM…

You've obviously deluded yourself into thinking he's your partner, when, in fact, he is your target. Happens all the time, really. Even the host gets confused sometimes.

Visor
07-08-2013, 04:14
Tally with 20 minutes to go:
2 Ishmael (Double A, Rickinator)
2 Double A (Ishmael, Makrell)
2 Ibn-Khaldun (Jarema, edse)
1 White_eyes:D (Darth Feather)
1 Autolycus (Riedquat)
2 Makrell (Ibn-Khaldun, B-Wing)
1 Jarema (LazyMcCrow)
1 Lazy (BSmith)
1 SalmonSoil (HopAlongBunny)
1 edse (White_eyes:D)
1 Darth Feather (Gaius Scribonius Curio)
1 HopAlongBunny (SalmonSoil)

Visor
07-08-2013, 04:34
End Day 1

"So none of you have any idea who is going to betray me, us? You all think that someone else did it?" Stannis said, the venis bulging in his neck as he talked. The men where looking at each other. They obviously had no idea. "Come back tomorrow and we'll do this again, and there had best be results." Stannis walked off back to the castle. Mace Tyrell had sent yet another letter asking Stannis to dine with him. Stannis crushed it into a ball and threw it away. Mace throught himself a sound tactictian, yet he sat here with a massive host doing nothing. The fool thinks he can win against Robert by feasting. Well so be it. Soon enough he will be feasting his eyes on the dead traitors. Stannis would see to that.


Tally:
2 Ishmael (Double A, Rickinator)
2 Double A (Ishmael, Makrell)
2 Ibn-Khaldun (Jarema, edse)
2 Makrell (Ibn-Khaldun, B-Wing)

1 White_eyes:D (Darth Feather)
1 Autolycus (Riedquat)
1 Jarema (LazyMcCrow)
1 Lazy (BSmith)
1 SalmonSoil (HopAlongBunny)
1 edse (White_eyes:D)
1 Darth Feather (Gaius Scribonius Curio)
1 HopAlongBunny (SalmonSoil)

Night 1 will end 24 hours from this post at 1:30 PM GMT +10.

Alive:
1. Makrell
2. LazyMcCrow
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
10. Darth Feather
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
12. B-Wing
13. Yay!
14. Riedquat
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Visor
07-09-2013, 15:46
Just waiting for a few more orders. Round will end in the morning whether I have them or not. I will not be as lenient later in the game.

Visor
07-10-2013, 01:03
Alright round's over. Bear with me as I ensure my results are correct and do a writeup.

Oh and I have changed my name back to Visorslash because I was getting sick of typing it into the username bar then realising it was incorrect.

Visor
07-10-2013, 01:26
End Night 1

The cook, commonly known amongst the garrison as Riedquat was busy preparing what little food they had for the next day. Meals had to be portioned, drink had to be rationed, and he was in charge of it. Which is why when he heard the footsteps in the kitchen he turned around to yell at the intruder that no-one has business in the kitchens. The words died in his mouth as he saw the intruder carry as crossbow. Instead he asked, "Killing the cook? Gods be good man, have you lost your wits? You want to kill the cook, who keeps everyone alive? Stannis is no idiot, run along before I report you." the false bravado washed over deaf ears as the killer approaches him. "Get in the oven old man."

"Do you take me for a fool? Kill me now and be done with it you bastard. The Seven will judge you accordingly."

The crossbowman considered his options for a few seconds before firing the quarrel in between the eyes of the cook. At that range he was unlikely to miss, and the bolt ripped a bloody hole. The cook gargled blood as he fell to the floor, his life over.

--------------------

"Put your stick up, I fancy a bit of training. Always a good time to pratice." the man turned around to see a Sargent standing there. He tossed the man a sword and he grabbed it. Before he could think to swing, the man was on him, hammering blows left and right. He stood no chance, the blows reeling off until he fell to the ground. "I yield, I yield!" he shouted, covering his head.

"A shame, better luck next time then!" the sargent said with a glimmer in his eyes.

--------------------------------

Sleep came difficult to the men of Storm's End. Especially those asked to betray their leaders. He held the paper rose in his hand. He had unfurled it, only to note what was asked of him. Stannis was a hard man. He knew the Tyrells were less so. Maybe if they knew he had helped them, he might get a lordship or at least a knighting. That would be good. He would have something for his kids to uphold. A man does what he must for his children. With a heavy heart, he threw the rose into the fire, and walked out into the night to meet with the man. It was the right thing to do, wasn't it? End the siege for all? He did not know, yet he walked on, the choice was made.


Summary: Riedquat was killed!
He was the Cook!

https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRcDZ6m5WsasFL-r855-up5B59blkl3fiiL1hyd9d5sDKZXFCNvnQ

he was Town!


Day 2 will end 24 hours from this post at 10:30 AM GMT +10.

Alive 17/18:
1. Makrell
2. LazyMcCrow
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
10. Darth Feather
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
12. B-Wing
13. Yay!
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 1/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.

Jarema
07-10-2013, 07:06
vote: Ishmael as I have no lead

Makrell
07-10-2013, 07:19
vote: riedquat
same reasons

Darth Feather
07-10-2013, 08:47
vote: riedquat
same reasons

Did you actually read the write-up? :rolleyes:

Ibn-Khaldun
07-10-2013, 08:54
Vote: Makrell

Ishmael
07-10-2013, 09:52
vote: Ibn-Khaldun

When I've got nothing else to go off, I may as well target vote-only posts.

Darth Feather
07-10-2013, 10:41
Actually Makrell is behaving really odd-fashioned. Yesterday: Makrell votes Double A for no reason which is fine. Then he votes Riedquat (who is dead), for the same reasons why he voted him yesterday (which he didn't)

Vote: Makrell

edse
07-10-2013, 10:44
Vote: Makrell for wifom

rickinator9
07-10-2013, 14:50
Vote: B-Wing
I want to taste those tasty Wings in my mouth!

LazyMcCrow
07-10-2013, 15:10
Who would kill Riedquat? vote: El Barto

autolycus
07-10-2013, 18:34
Actually Makrell is behaving really odd-fashioned. Yesterday: Makrell votes Double A for no reason which is fine. Then he votes Riedquat (who is dead), for the same reasons why he voted him yesterday (which he didn't)

Vote: Makrell
My guess is he means same reason as the person above him cast their vote (no lead). I think he's clean.
Vote:Ibn-Khaldun based on vote only post. Ishmael's approach makes as much sense as any.

B-Wing
07-10-2013, 19:40
Anybody who claims they can build a case by analyzing Makrell's posts is either lying or fooling themselves. :rolleyes4:

vote: rickinator9

Also...


[...] the venis bulging in his neck as he talked.

:surprised:

Darth Feather
07-10-2013, 19:43
Anybody who claims they can build a case by analyzing Makrell's posts is either lying or fooling themselves. :rolleyes4:

vote: rickinator9

Also...


What was his reason for saying 'same reasons', then?
You seem to know what he meant, then explain it to me.

B-Wing
07-10-2013, 21:08
I don't know what he meant. I never know what Makrell means. ~;p That was my point.

LazyMcCrow
07-10-2013, 22:34
What was his reason for saying 'same reasons', then?
You seem to know what he meant, then explain it to me.

You're a bit pitchfork-ey for day one aren't you? ...meh probably not.

Ibn-Khaldun
07-10-2013, 22:43
Voting someone who is dead is weird. And that is why I voted Makrell.

El Barto
07-10-2013, 22:52
Who would kill Riedquat? vote: El Barto
Actually, I asked for you to be killed in the Mafia QT but was overridden. vote: LazyMcCrow.

HopAlongBunny
07-10-2013, 22:57
Crimes against grammar

Vote: Darth Feather

El Barto
07-10-2013, 23:47
Do you mean his neglecting to use 'If'?

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-10-2013, 23:50
Crimes against grammar

Vote: Darth Feather

On account of his crimes against syntax, Vote: HopAlongBunny.

El Barto
07-10-2013, 23:52
If I weren't busy OMGUSing LazyMcCrow, I'd totally switch my vote onto you, Plebeian scum.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-11-2013, 00:55
Anachronistic insults don't bother me.

As an aside: if you are genuinely interested in the complexity and intricacies of late Republican politics PM me...

As it is, I think you just enjoy baiting me...

Visor
07-11-2013, 02:03
End Day 2

Maester Cressen, known around the garrison as Makrell for his fondness of fish was the chosen target for today. Stannis was stunned. Did they really think his own maester was plotting to betray him? Stannis didn't believe so, but they had chosen, and he must now do what was necessary. As he prepared to load the maester into the catapults, he asked for a word. With the calmness of a man who knows his fate is unavoidable, he told Stannis that throwing him into the Tyrell horde was a bad idea. Who knew how long the siege would last, and it would be better to keep him in the dungeon. Remaining rations were low and there was no need to waste good meat. Stannis saw his opportunity to keep Cressen alive and he took it, banishing him to the dungeons.

"You fools must choose better. Cressen was a good man, honest and loyal. I will await your choice on the morrow." he said walking off the walls, teeth clenched.


Tally:
1 Ishmael (Jarema)
3 Makrell (IK, Darth, edse)
2 IK (Ishmael, autolycus)
1 B-Wing (Rick)
1 El Barto (Lazy)
1 Rick (B-Wing)
1 Lazy (El Barto)
1 Darth (HAB)
1 HAB (Gaius)

Summary: Makrell was lynched!
He was Maester Cressen!

http://images5.fanpop.com/image/polls/990000/990692_1333404105725_full.jpg

he was Town!


Night 2 will end 24 hours from this post at 10:30 AM GMT +10.

Alive 16/18:
2. LazyMcCrow
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
10. Darth Feather
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
12. B-Wing
13. Yay!
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 2/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.

Darth Feather
07-11-2013, 09:23
Crimes against grammar

Vote: Darth Feather

Please enlighten me, I don't see my mistake.

Visor
07-11-2013, 15:39
Update might be a bit late, staying up to watch the ashes.

Makrell
07-11-2013, 18:20
no healing tonight :(, unless someone frees me from the dungeons

Double A
07-12-2013, 17:36
Visor I'm still here, I just forget to check the org every day.

Yes I am aware of how sad that is.

Visor
07-13-2013, 01:36
End Night 2

Jarema decided tonight would be his rest night. He would keep up his strength so that he could he could have the strength to fight more traitors. Stannis was the commander, and he knew that Stannis was a just man. He would reward his faithful servant. Faith does not stop a sword through the neck however, and in the morning, the body of Jarema was buried, along with his meager belongings. The maester would normally say the words, or sometimes the priest. Stannis had no maester anymore however, Cressen being put in the dungeon. So it was with an awkward speech and poor wording, that Stannis Baratheon sent off the sargent to join the Seven.


Summary: Jarema was killed!
He was the Sargent!

https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRDrGfB1xw9h9yFHmEwBqZZNwlyM0g5p gjkk_pjSdBkxakESA-E8w

he was Town!


Day 3 will end 24 hours from this post at 10:30 AM GMT +10.

Alive 15/18:
2. LazyMcCrow
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
10. Darth Feather
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
12. B-Wing
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 3/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.

El Barto
07-13-2013, 03:10
Yay!

rickinator9
07-13-2013, 04:48
Yay!

What are you celebrating, El Barto? That you are one more step closer to your goal?

Ishmael
07-13-2013, 05:01
vote: Darth Feather, for being awfully quick to leap on Makrell.

[Insert usual disclaimer about this 'case' being used solely because I have nothing else to go off]

El Barto
07-13-2013, 05:53
What are you celebrating, El Barto? That you are one more step closer to your goal?
I'm celebrating that it's finally Friday, that I'm free again, and that I've got my motor running for a wild weekend.

Jarema
07-13-2013, 09:21
Yay!
thats no longer my name, mister cat-lover

SalmonSoil
07-13-2013, 15:03
Vote: Edse for sealing Makrells fate.

Us fish people have to stick together.

Darth Feather
07-13-2013, 15:58
Vote: HopAlongBunny What is my grammatical mistake?
:confused:

rickinator9
07-13-2013, 21:23
Yay! Jarema is Jarema again. Vote: Jarema

Wants to get rid of Jarema. He can't vote him away so he kills Jarema. Too lazy to cover up his tracks afterwards.

Vote: LazyMcCrow

Besides, why isn't the crow at the wall? He must be a deserter and you know what happens to deserters. They are punished!

Double A
07-14-2013, 00:59
Vote: LazyMcCrow

I guess that's a reason?

Visor
07-14-2013, 02:58
End Day 3

Not many words were said today. The morale of the garrison was low and the food levels even lower. In the end they settled on LazyMcCrow with a measly two votes. Stannis was furious, ths was not how they were supposed to vote. They would never defeat their enemies if they let them run amok. Still Stannis was true to his word, and Lazy was executed that night. His belongings proved that he had no real traitorous leanings. Yet another wasteful death. He was leading a garrison of incompetent fools who couldn't even vote to save their life.


Summary: LazyMcCrow was lynched!
He was a Footsoldier!

http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120517225402/gameofthrones/images/9/94/Stark_soldier_1.jpg

he was Town!


Night 3 will end 24 hours from this post at 10:30 AM GMT +10.

Alive 14/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
10. Darth Feather
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
12. B-Wing
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 4/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.

rickinator9
07-14-2013, 04:07
Mi'lord Stannis. Almost everyone is still sleeping in their beds, even if it is already noon. Perhaps we should use them to bombard them Tyrells!

Double A
07-14-2013, 07:35
Mi'lord Stannis. Almost everyone is still sleeping in their beds, even if it is already noon. Perhaps we should use them to bombard them Tyrells!

When was the last time you got to bugger someone with an arrow? They know how far our weapons reach.

rickinator9
07-14-2013, 14:46
When was the last time you got to bugger someone with an arrow? They know how far our weapons reach.

Even if they don't manage to hit the target, we still have the benefit of having more food for ourselves.

El Barto
07-14-2013, 21:47
thats no longer my name,Yay!

mister cat-lover
Why do you hate freedom?

Visor
07-15-2013, 00:04
If I wanted to host a vanilla game, I would. Get your orders in!

24 hour extension for night, or near enough.

Jarema
07-15-2013, 15:46
Why do you hate freedom?
that was just descriptive

El Barto
07-15-2013, 19:51
that was just descriptive
Yay!

rickinator9
07-15-2013, 20:29
If I wanted to host a vanilla game, I would. Get your orders in!

24 hour extension for night, or near enough.

Just WOG the scum if you have to, or take no orders if they are too late.

LazyMcCrow
07-15-2013, 22:21
Meh. I couldn't get on the last couple of days. No idea what happened apart form being deaded/ Good luck town.

El Barto
07-16-2013, 00:19
Just WOG the scum if you have to, or take no orders if they are too late.
Yay!

Double A
07-16-2013, 05:39
Wisdom teeth coming out tomorrow, expect... I have no idea.

Visor
07-16-2013, 08:41
Wisdom teeth coming out tomorrow, expect... I have no idea.

Stay on the drugs and its all fine. Good luck tomorrow.

Got the orders in thanks for that. Will post update tonight, after I come back.

Visor
07-16-2013, 15:28
End Night 3

Darth Feather hated being a mortician. Not only did he hate the smell of dead bodies, there was also the look, and feel. He hated having to study the cadavers, but it was the only trade he knew. He blamed his father for that, there was an opening, and he was thrown into it, any coins for the family were good coins. Well his father was gone, and the coins were now his. Not that it changed much, though the dead often held trinkets and secrets. Still he made no secret of his displeasure.

When the crossbowman arrived at the scene he knew his time was up. He fought, as would everyone would, but the man with the crossbow was deadly accurate and he never stood a chance. He joined the corpses he hated in life, in death. Sometimes you just couldn't escape your work, no matter how hard you tried.

The Rose was angry. His convert had been killed. That wouldn't matter though, as he had a plan. Another convert, another flower, another rose in the garden. Eventually they would strangle all other life. And that would start now.


Summary: Darth Feather was killed!
He was the Mortician!

http://img.poptower.com/pic-54270/jerome-flynn.jpg?d=600

he was a Cult member!


Day 4 will end 34 hours from this post at 10:30 AM GMT +10.

Alive 13/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
12. B-Wing
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 5/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather. cult, killed Night 3.

rickinator9
07-16-2013, 16:30
Oh no! Not Bronn!

HopAlongBunny
07-16-2013, 20:23
I hope he pre-paid his funeral expenses.

rickinator9
07-16-2013, 23:25
Hmm, so not only there is a cult, it also managed to spread.

autolycus
07-17-2013, 01:46
Vote:El Barto
Posted but didn't vote yesterday.

B-Wing
07-17-2013, 04:28
Whomever placed me in jail last night, please PM me. I would like to offer an idea.

vote: Darth Feather
His avatar looks more cultist than the rest of you.

Ishmael
07-17-2013, 05:57
Whomever placed me in jail last night, please PM me. I would like to offer an idea.

vote: Darth Feather
His avatar looks more cultist than the rest of you.

Wait, you know there's a cult but you didn't see that Darth Feather died? Interesting.

Still, vote: HopAlongBunny, on a hunch.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-17-2013, 11:40
Vote: Rickinator

You've been very chirpy, and I sense that something isn't quite right. It may just be excitement at a Game of Thrones theme, but since I have nothing else...

edse
07-17-2013, 12:40
Vote: rickinator9 Two posts without voting, afraid to take a stance?

SalmonSoil
07-17-2013, 13:09
Wait, you know there's a cult but you didn't see that Darth Feather died? Interesting.

And seeing as Darth Feathers death is how we know there is a cult, ima go ahead and vote: B-Wing

rickinator9
07-17-2013, 13:28
Vote: rickinator9 Two posts without voting, afraid to take a stance?

I don't like being to first guy to vote. It has only ever brought bad things to me(like being lynched).

Vote: Edse
We know the mafia was (most likely) one of the afk guys last day and Edse didn't vote that day. Might aswell try.

BSmith
07-17-2013, 14:20
And seeing as Darth Feathers death is how we know there is a cult, ima go ahead and vote: B-Wing

This is most likely a townie mistake. It's not very likely that B-Wing would forget one of his fellow cult members like that. Of course it could be a cunning ploy to make us think that, but I am going to go with the simplest explanation for now.

Jumping on this, however, earns my vote. It is not an original idea to you, and smells of an excuse to vote for someone. vote: SalmonSoil

Ibn-Khaldun
07-17-2013, 14:50
Vote: Ishmael
I get bad vibes from you.

Double A
07-17-2013, 16:47
Does anyone else find it hilarious how many often DF is scum of some sort?


Stay on the drugs and its all fine. Good luck tomorrow.

Got the orders in thanks for that. Will post update tonight, after I come back.

Operation was fine, did not get high on drugs. No funny stories to tell. My mouth doesn't even hurt at this point. Probably due to the painkillers, which means I can't drive, but I don't actually feel any different.

Anyway, I would appreciate a replacement, if possible. At this point all I want to do is watch Star Trek for a week.

White_eyes:D
07-17-2013, 18:42
Vote:El Barto I get a "dance for me townies, dance" scum vibe from you.:inquisitive:

B-Wing
07-17-2013, 19:28
Wow, thank you for catching my mistake there. This makes 3 out of the last 4 games in which I've made some type of stupid mistake involving players names or statuses.
unvote
vote: edse
For reasons that do not yet exist.

HopAlongBunny
07-17-2013, 20:03
Vote: rickinator9

rickinator9
07-17-2013, 22:27
I might aswell give out my role, but then the scum will kill me in the night. I am essential for the town's victory.

edse
07-17-2013, 23:16
Alright.

Unvote: Vote: B-Wing Now there is a reason for your vote.

El Barto
07-18-2013, 02:05
I believe this is the curent tally…
[INDENT]El Barto 2 (autolycus; White_eyes:D)
HopAlongBunny 1 (Ishmael)
rickinator9 2 (GSC; HopAlongBunny)
B-Wing 2 (SalmonSoil; edse)
edse 2 (rickinator9; B-Wing)
SalmonSoil 1 (BSmith)
Ishmael 1 (Ibn-Khaldun)[INDENT]
I'm not sure whether to vote for B-Wing for his purported ignorance of someone dying or for HopAlongBunny who votes on 'grammatical mistakes' or really on no reason of his own at all now on rickinator.

Why does the host not include tallies in his updates?

Vote:El Barto
Posted but didn't vote yesterday.
Haven't other people done that as well?

Vote:El Barto I get a "dance for me townies, dance" scum vibe from you.:inquisitive:
No, Mr. Bond, I expect you to dance… we didn't dance much at my birthday though.

HopAlongBunny
07-18-2013, 02:39
...or really on no reason of his own at all...

This. I am as townie as you can get but I am also clueless :p
I can see nothing to indicate the scum; I have discovered nothing to indicate the scum; all votes up to this point are random.

Visor
07-18-2013, 02:52
Why does the host not include tallies in his updates?

:stare:

https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?144701-Storm-s-End-IN-PLAY&p=2053536600&viewfull=1#post2053536600
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?144701-Storm-s-End-IN-PLAY&p=2053537167&viewfull=1#post2053537167
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?144701-Storm-s-End-IN-PLAY/page4 (I did have a tally for Lazys lynch, but I overwrote it. It was 2-1-1-1-1 etc.

In any case, 2/3 and one which wasn't necessary really. Bad El Barto.

Visor
07-18-2013, 03:09
End Day 4

Stannis rounded up his men only to find they had nothing for him. He clenched his teeth in anger. His men had less brains combined then a court fool. He sent for Ser Davos to talk with plans for the days ahead and left the men to their pitiful dinner.


Summary:No Lynch!

Tally:
2 El Barto (autolycus, WE:D)
2 Edse (Ricki, Bwing)
1 HAB (Ishmael)
2 Ricki (Gaius, HAB)
2 Bwing (Salmon, edse)
1 Salmon (Bsmith)
1 Ishmael (IK)

Night 4 will end 34 hours from this post at 10:30 AM GMT +10.

Alive 13/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
12. B-Wing
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 5/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather. cult, killed Night 3.

El Barto
07-18-2013, 17:36
This. I am as townie as you can get but I am also clueless :p
I can see nothing to indicate the scum; I have discovered nothing to indicate the scum; all votes up to this point are random.
Random voting after Day One? Sorry but I'm voting you tomorrow.

Bad El Barto.
:boxedin: Please don't WoG me! I can't raise my children to be proper mafiosi! I might even start reading Game of Thrones if you let me live!

Visor
07-19-2013, 01:44
End Night 4

B-Wing had an important duty. As Captain of the Guard it was his job to ensure his men were onside and keeping morale high. His job was invaluable in keeping the garrison in order. Unfortunately for him, tonight was the night chaos struck. As he paced around the barracks floor, the man with a crossbow was once more ready to strike. He approached the Captain, who didn't look particularly shocked at this turn of events. They shared a look, then with a cry, the Captain charged, pulling his sword out of its scabbard. The first quarrel took him in the chest but it was not enough to stop the charge. The captain ran past with his blade swinging wildly at the crossbowman to miss. He then slipped in and ripped a jagged line across the Captain's neck, leaving him to bleed out.


Summary: B-Wing was killed!
He was the Captain of the Guard!

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_SniTwfm5BwE/TDtESR2BJkI/AAAAAAAACmQ/U3qaX1DFCRc/s1600/Jory+Cassel.jpg

he was Town!


Day 5 will end 24 hours from this post at 10:30 AM GMT +10.

Alive 12/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 6/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather. cult, killed Night 3.
12. B-Wing, town, killed Night 4.

HopAlongBunny
07-19-2013, 06:54
Most of you are quite busy at night...don't you people ever sleep!!!

The only person I have observed that stayed put all night was El Barto; and that was last night.
The question is... what are the rest of you up to!

Ishmael
07-19-2013, 08:02
The question is... what are the rest of you up to!

That's a good question. vote: HopAlongBunny

Same (lack of) reasoning as yesterday - it's a hunch, but a reasonably solid one.

edse
07-19-2013, 14:54
Vote: Ishmael isn't a tracker a positive thing?

rickinator9
07-19-2013, 16:25
Vote: Ishmael isn't a tracker a positive thing?

A false tracker isn't

Vote: HopAlongBunny

Chaotix
07-19-2013, 17:01
By the order of Visorslash, I have replaced Double A.

Vote: Ishmael

Why vote for someone with a known night action? It's very easy to confirm whether he's telling the truth.

BSmith
07-19-2013, 18:48
A false tracker isn't

Vote: HopAlongBunny

Do you know something or is this just conjecture?

If it is just conjecture I am inclined to vote: Ishmael as well. If you have something more solid to base your statement on, then I am more than willing to switch my vote.

autolycus
07-19-2013, 21:43
Vote:Ishmael A tracker is not a killer or a converter, which need to be our priorities for now.

HopAlongBunny
07-19-2013, 21:57
I will go with consensus.
Vote: Ishmael

Did not visit; but was visited.
Can I, or should I reveal all my nightly tracking? It makes no sense to me, but it might help others to make connections I am too dense to understand.

El Barto
07-19-2013, 22:34
Most of you are quite busy at night...don't you people ever sleep!!!

The only person I have observed that stayed put all night was El Barto; and that was last night.
The question is... what are the rest of you up to!
I was going to ask why on earth a tracker is so clueless, but…

I will go with consensus.
Vote: Ishmael

Did not visit; but was visited.
Can I, or should I reveal all my nightly tracking? It makes no sense to me, but it might help others to make connections I am to dense to understand.
Since you claim not to know anything, and we have both a cult and a mafia out there, you should either post it here for all to see and draw conclusions or send it to (a) poster(s) whom you trust. But trackers and watchers not sharing their findings only helps the non-towns.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-19-2013, 22:36
Now that you have mentioned it in passing, I think the information ought to be made public so that, as you say, others can assist in drawing connections from them...

Vote: Abstain

El Barto
07-19-2013, 22:47
Voting for the GM is not allowed.

And I didn't just say that in passing, it's just the only point of my post. Trust the defenders of the demagogue to use trickery with words.

HopAlongBunny
07-19-2013, 23:10
Ok, dump of observation:

Night 1: track autolycus => visits Ishmael
Night 2: track Ibn-Khaldun => visits edse
Night 3: track BSmith => visits Double A
Night 4: track El Barto => does not go out and is not visited.

El Barto
07-19-2013, 23:35
Oh right, you've outed three people who have Night Abilities. We have to work on that.

Alive 12/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
15. Ishmael
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 6/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather. cult, killed Night 3.
12. B-Wing, town, killed Night 4.
+

Ok, dump of observation:

Night 1: track autolycus => visits Ishmael
Night 2: track Ibn-Khaldun => visits edse
Night 3: track BSmith => visits Double A
Night 4: track El Barto => does not go out and is not visited.
None of the visitors or their hosts have died. Could those six people (autolycus, Ishmael, Ibn-Khaldun, edse, BSmith, and Double A) explain what night results they got?

Ishmael
07-20-2013, 01:39
Oops, I clearly misread HopAlongBunny's post. I assumed he was referring to the abundance of posting during the night phase, although looking back there was only one post then :embarassed:. I blame posting late at night myself. It's probably far too late for me to explain all this, but I'll put it out there anyway.

unvote

El Barto, I did not receive any information/results from the host last night phase (or any previous phase, for that matter). That seems fairly conventional - to the best of my knowledge, people aren't normally informed of tracker visits.

White_eyes:D
07-20-2013, 01:39
Vote: Ishmael Lets see how if HopAlongBunny is right.:shrug:

Honestly though...I am more suspicious of who was going visiting others.:inquisitive:

Visor
07-20-2013, 02:09
Alrighty. Ishmael is clearly the majority lynch for today. Writeup to come shortly.

Visor
07-20-2013, 02:15
End Day 5

Ishmael was dragged to the block. As a loyal guard of Stannis, he knew he wasn't a traitor. But loose lips sink ships and now he would be sent to judgement by the Seven. As the headsman stood with the axe at the ready, the guard stopped his struggles. He had done his best, and it wasn't enough. Now he would suffer the consequences.

"The seven have judged you and found you wanting. For the crime of treason I sentence you to death. Any last words?"

"All I did, was to protect you m'lord."

Stannis gritted his teeth. He gave the order and whirled around as the axe swing down, decapitating Ishmael in one strike.


Summary: Ishmael was lynched!
He was a Guard!

http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130111172456/gameofthrones/images/1/14/Yoren_profile.jpg

he was Town!


Night 5 will end 32 hours from this post at 6:30 PM GMT +10.

Alive 11/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
7. Rickinator9
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 7/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather. cult, killed Night 3.
12. B-Wing, town, killed Night 4.
15. Ishmael, town, lynched Day 5.

Visor
07-20-2013, 02:17
Note the extended timeframe for night orders. I will be away until then so you have more time to get your night orders in.

Chaotix
07-20-2013, 04:58
Bah. After HopAlongBunny's results were revealed I would have changed my vote to one of the three players who did some visiting.

There was no way that bandwagon was going to be overturned, though, and I returned too late anyway.

Tomorrow, we need answers from autolycus, Ibn-Khaldun, and BSmith.

Note that BSmith visited Double A on night 3. I am Double A's replacement, so I'll check to see he received any incoming night result that night.

El Barto
07-20-2013, 17:47
We also need to know what happened to edse, and see if the versions match.

There is a Cultist there, I know it.

Visor
07-21-2013, 13:41
End Night 5

Rickinator9 was not about to be lax in his duty. His compatriot had been killed earlier that day and he was not about to die standing still. Axe in hand he patrolled the corridors for the threats posed. However, an axe can't stop a crossbow. He was found lying dead outside the barracks. Their numbers were dwindling. Hard decisions would need to be made.

The Rose smiled. Another member of the cause. There was no way he could fail now.


Summary: Rickinator was killed!
He was a Guard!

https://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lleh9zYotD1qhu9p7o1_500.png

he was Town!


Day 6 will end 22 hours from this post at 8:30 PM GMT +10.

Alive 10/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Double A
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 8/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather. cult, killed Night 3.
12. B-Wing, town, killed Night 4.
15. Ishmael, town, lynched Day 5.
7. Rickinator9, town, killed Night 5.

edse
07-21-2013, 14:04
I think Curio is a good lynch.

Vote: Curio

El Barto
07-21-2013, 19:36
OK, I'll bite. Why is he a good lynch? Fish Finger of Suspicion: edse.

edse
07-21-2013, 23:08
OK, I'll bite. Why is he a good lynch? Fish Finger of Suspicion: edse.

Uhm... Because he's not me?

Come on, there only a little more than 12 hours left of the day, someone must have found something out tonight.

Ibn-Khaldun
07-21-2013, 23:42
Vote: White_eyes:D

Since I know B-Wing was investigating him on the night B-Wing was killed then he is my top suspect. Also, it is written in the write-up:


He approached the Captain, who didn't look particularly shocked at this turn of events.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-21-2013, 23:43
@ edse: Why? Do you have an investigative result that has me wandering about visiting people? More compellingly, an investigative result that names me guilty?

We both know that you do not, so targeting me is a complete waste of everyone's time when we do have public results that require an explanation.

Today is the crux. We need to start finding cult members and/or mafia now.

Vote: Autolycus

Can you explain HopAlongBunny's results?

Ibn-Khaldun
07-21-2013, 23:44
Ok, dump of observation:

Night 1: track autolycus => visits Ishmael
Night 2: track Ibn-Khaldun => visits edse
Night 3: track BSmith => visits Double A
Night 4: track El Barto => does not go out and is not visited.

I did not "visit" edse.. I roleblocked him.

HopAlongBunny
07-21-2013, 23:55
Gaius sat tight last night.
Ishmael flipped innocent but perhaps autolycus has something to hide.
Shot in the Dark Vote: autolycus

Visor
07-22-2013, 00:17
24 hour extension will be given for this phase.

autolycus
07-22-2013, 00:57
I'm an anti-cult power role. I protect people against conversion, and unconvert converts, but I don't get results unless I failed. Last night I targeted edse. The night before, I was jailed. Before that was Double A. Night 2 was Lazy Mccrow, and Night 1 was Ishmael, as HopAlong said.

I'm going to vote:edse The only night we didn't see a mention of the Rose converting someone was Night 2, the night Ibn blocked him.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-22-2013, 01:22
No mention of converts N2 or 4 (IIRC), suggesting instead that the cult can only convert once every two nights.

Your claim is also internally inconsistent. If you protect from conversion and unconvert recruits and only get results if you fail: what were your results last night?

You targeted edse and didn't get a result saying that you failed. Then you vote for him?

autolycus
07-22-2013, 02:43
You're right about night 4, I missed that. I protected/unconverted edse last night, which means he can't be a convert, but it doesn't mean he couldn't be the original. Since I missed that there wasn't a conversion night 4, I was using the lack of conversion night 2 as a lead.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-22-2013, 02:52
Fair enough...

Unvote; Vote: BSmith

What say you about creeping about in the night?

Chaotix
07-22-2013, 04:44
Vote: white_eyes

:shrug:

Still not really sure what is going on here.

Ibn-Khaldun
07-22-2013, 07:15
Let's not do the ties again..

autolycus
07-22-2013, 11:38
unvote, vote:Bsmith

BSmith
07-22-2013, 14:46
I am a bad lynch. I am a role blocker. Here is who I have blocked every night this game:

N1 – B-Wing
N2 – Darth Feather
N3 – Double A
N4 – Rickinator9
N5 – Ibn-Khaldun

vote: white_eyes, as it seems we are tied for the vote atm, and I’d really rather not die today.

El Barto
07-22-2013, 16:35
It's tally time!
GSC: edse
White_eyes:D: Ibn-Khaldun; Chaotix; BSmith
autolycus: HAB
BSmith: GSC; autolycusYou still haven't said what you do at night, BSmith, but I also think that White_eyes:D's deathtouch is something worth investigating. If a tied vote didn't mean no lynch, I'd vote for you just to keep you in the game. :stare:

Chaotix
07-22-2013, 16:50
You're telling me both Ibn-Khaldun and BSmith are roleblockers?

I don't believe that could be true. Ibn-Khaldun, I'd like to hear your results last night. If BSmith's telling the truth, then your action should have been a failure.

BSmith
07-22-2013, 17:06
I blocked you (well, AA anyway) on N3... did you ask Visor if you got any results?

El Barto
07-22-2013, 17:24
It kinda can be true if there's one cult and one mafia. Otherwise the town would surely lose at least one member every night no matter what. But let's see about that result.

Chaotix
07-22-2013, 19:57
I blocked you (well, AA anyway) on N3... did you ask Visor if you got any results?

I asked him earlier, and he said I didn't receive any results.

But then, I don't have a night ability. So we shouldn't expect to see night results for roleblocked players who weren't using an ability anyway.

El Barto
07-22-2013, 21:54
We could always have BSmith block a potential scummo next night while HopAlongBunny watch-tracks him.

Ibn-Khaldun
07-23-2013, 00:09
You're telling me both Ibn-Khaldun and BSmith are roleblockers?

I don't believe that could be true. Ibn-Khaldun, I'd like to hear your results last night. If BSmith's telling the truth, then your action should have been a failure.

My roleblocks:
N1 - El Barto
N2 - edse
N3 - B-Wing
N4 - autolycus
N5 - Forgot to send my orders.

I never received any results PM's. So, I guess all my actions succeeded.

El Barto
07-23-2013, 00:18
I didn't get any results at all N1 either, didn't know I was roleblocked.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-23-2013, 00:26
I think what has become clear is that if you do not perform a night action, you do not receive notification that you were prevented from performing a night action.

BSmith and Ibn-Khaldun, what specifically are your roles? When you say roleblocker do you prevent all actions, or just specific ones (like murder for instance)?

Visor
07-23-2013, 05:52
6 hours or so left.

White_eyes:D
07-23-2013, 10:10
Well...regardless something about Bsmith's story doesn't quite check out.:shrug:

Rather then lynching a sorely needed townie I would prefer a tie...it's not like Ibn-Khaldun is not going to waste a night action checking me out.:brood: Vote:BSmith

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-23-2013, 10:41
Unvote: BSmith

Pending a reason not to. Right now the lynch is the only weapon the town has and to nullify it at this critical stage is pointless...

SalmonSoil
07-23-2013, 11:28
Pending a reason not to.

vote:BSmith

There ya go.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-23-2013, 11:35
Vote: White Eyes :D

Visor
07-23-2013, 12:25
End Day 6

Once again the garrison could not make up their minds. Stannis clenched his teeth when he heard the news. He clenched his teeth at pretty much everything.

"Order the garrison to prepare for attack. No-one leaves without my permission."

And so they did, the night was dark and full of terrors, but they all survived, to vote another day.


Tally:
Curio (edse)
WE:D (IK, Chaotix, BSmith)
BSmith (auto, WE:D, SalmonSoil)

GSC was five minutes late. Therefore we have a tie.

Summary: No one was lynched!

Day 7 will end 48 hours from this post at 9:30 PM GMT +10.

Alive 10/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Chaotix
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
16. White_eyes:D
17. HopAlongBunny
18. SalmonSoil

Dead 8/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather. cult, killed Night 3.
12. B-Wing, town, killed Night 4.
15. Ishmael, town, lynched Day 5.
7. Rickinator9, town, killed Night 5.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-23-2013, 13:06
My ire is successfully piqued.

Salmonsoil: How do you justify acting against the interests of the town?

Vote: White Eyes :D

Chaotix
07-23-2013, 16:08
Vote: SalmonSoil

El Barto
07-23-2013, 16:28
What happened to the night phase?

edse
07-23-2013, 17:01
Unvote: Vote: SalmonSoil you really needed to save him, didn't you?

El Barto
07-23-2013, 18:46
I still keep a pressure vote on White_eyes:D.

BSmith
07-23-2013, 19:06
Yeah, vote: white_eyes it is. That did look suspiciously like a saving vote.

El Barto
07-23-2013, 20:01
Vote:El Barto I get a "dance for me townies, dance" scum vibe from you.:inquisitive:
:tomato:

How about we dance to this tune?

You're completely scummy. We lynch you. You flip scum. Then Ibn-Khaldun and BSmith both roleblock SalmonSoil, in case he tries to kill/convert one of the two blockers. Then it's gallows time. :hanged:

autolycus
07-23-2013, 22:13
I'm torn. We have a cult leader and two converts out there, based on write-ups, which the team on White_Eyes could easily be, but SalmonSoil's vote does look awfully like a saving vote. Of course, Curio's was also a last second vote, but too late...

HopAlongBunny
07-23-2013, 23:56
Saved your scum-buddy and erased the night
Much too powerful to exist
Vote: SalmonSoil

Ibn-Khaldun
07-24-2013, 00:31
Which is it - Day or Night ?!

El Barto
07-24-2013, 00:32
I'm torn. We have a cult leader and two converts out there, based on write-ups, which the team on White_Eyes could easily be, but SalmonSoil's vote does look awfully like a saving vote. Of course, Curio's was also a last second vote, but too late...
Two converts? One of them is dead, I think the math doesn't add up.

Saved your scum-buddy and erased the night
Much too powerful to exist
Vote: SalmonSoil
How do you know he erased the night?

Which is it - Day or Night ?!
Day.

Ibn-Khaldun
07-24-2013, 00:34
In that case..

Vote: White_eyes:D

Ibn-Khaldun
07-24-2013, 00:39
Tally:

White_Eyes:D - GSC, El Barto, BSmith, Ibn-Khaldun
SalmonSoil - Chaotix, edse, HopAlongBunny

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-24-2013, 01:48
From the write-up it appears that Stannis made the 'night disappear':


Stannis clenched his teeth when he heard the news. He clenched his teeth at pretty much everything.

"Order the garrison to prepare for attack. No-one leaves without my permission."

And so they did, the night was dark and full of terrors, but they all survived, to vote another day.

This doubling up is pointless, it merely leaves both alive to continue their nefarious ways. I beseech everyone to transfer the vote to one in order to make this a sure thing...

Unvote; Vote: Salmonsoil

autolycus
07-24-2013, 01:53
Two converts? One of them is dead, I think the math doesn't add up.


Conversions seemed to occur on each of the odd numbered nights: 1,3,5. One killed, that's two converts remaining.

SalmonSoil
07-24-2013, 03:51
Saved your scum-buddy and erased the night
Much too powerful to exist
Vote: SalmonSoil

If I was scum why would I erase the night?

vote: White_Eyes:D to save myself.

Ibn-Khaldun
07-24-2013, 08:44
Unvote; Vote: SalmonSoil

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-24-2013, 09:01
Tally

SalmonSoil 5 - Chaotix, edse, HopAlongBunny, Curio, Ibn-Khaldun
White_Eyes:D 3 - El Barto, BSmith, Salmonsoil

Not Voting 2 - Autolycus, White_Eyes:D

Chaotix
07-24-2013, 21:48
Hmm...

LET'S MAKE IT A TIE

Unvote, Vote: white_eyes

BSmith
07-24-2013, 22:27
No. unvote; vote: Salmonsoil

autolycus
07-24-2013, 22:53
Vote: Salmonsoil
This prevents the last minute tie, and he feels more scummy of the two of them to me.

El Barto
07-24-2013, 23:01
Fish Finger of Suspicion: Chaotix.

J'accuse!

Visor
07-25-2013, 14:33
Tally:
WE (el s, Chaotix
S (edse, hab, gsc, ik, bsmith, auto

Standby for execution.

Visor
07-25-2013, 14:48
End Day 7

Stannis decided on ceremony today. He had two blocks brought out. Today, the traitors would get their just desserts. Treason was treason, and the punishment was death. To the garrison's surprise both White_Eyes:D and SalmonSoil were brought to the blocks.

"You may be wondering why I brought both of them here. I hope to show the rest of you what happens to traitors. We have held Storm's End for far too long to give in to treason." he turned to look at the two men, one with a resigned look on his face, the other with a grimace. "Last words?"

SalmonSoil spoke up. "You kept me prisoner, if you didn't expect this you're as stupid as you are ugly." he spat at the ground as the headsman cracked his face with the butt of the axe.

White_Eyes:D however had a things of far bigger importance to say. "You may think that you have won today. Yes, we conspired against you. Not for your death, we never had a hand in it, but for the safety of the realm. The tyrells would be good for the storm lords and Storm's End. In any case, you will search our belongings and find nought but paper. We did not kill anyone. I do not own a crossbow, my weapons are my words. You still have real traitors left to catch, for I was never a traitor to my lord. There will be others who seek to destroy you, and only working together will allow you to be free of the traitors." He stared at a certain member of the audience. "I bid you good luck, I have said all I can, may my deeds speak louder then my words."

He bowed his head into the block, whilst the headman forced Salmon's into his. Stannis frowned. "No. There is no need to waste good meat. Throw them into the dungeon. These traitors may serve us yet."


Tally:
3 WE (El Barto, SalmonSoil, Chaotix)
6 SalmonSoil (edse, hab, gsc, ik, bsmith, auto)

Summary: White_Eyes:D was killed!
He was the Rose!

http://i.lv3.hbo.com/custom-assets/enrichments/series/game-of-thrones/r5/images/houses2/people/detail/loras-tyrell.jpg

he was Cult!


SalmonSoil was lynched!
He was a former Prisoner!

https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcR6YlfAw9b3bPEV_VHrqH-0cz5z5IOEQeCmoZ0GeiJiLTxwnssC

he was Cult!


Night 7 will end 22 hours from this post at 9:30 PM GMT +10.

Alive 8/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Chaotix
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio
17. HopAlongBunny


Dead 10/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather, cult, killed Night 3.
12. B-Wing, town, killed Night 4.
15. Ishmael, town, lynched Day 5.
7. Rickinator9, town, killed Night 5.
18. SalmonSoil, cult, lynched Day 7.
16. White_eyes:D, cult, executed Day 7.

HopAlongBunny
07-25-2013, 15:10
T...t...two! cultists!!
Yea, what wondrous things we may accomplish by maintaining focus!
As a team we may yet withstand the storm and win through to calm clear waters :2thumbsup:

El Barto
07-25-2013, 16:54
He stared at a certain member of the audience.
So, there's at least one more cultist…?
White_eyes:D how do you like this tune, eh? The gallows dance suits traitors like you.

Ibn-Khaldun
07-26-2013, 01:17
Based on the information we have here in this thread then

autolycus - Can't be the killer since he was blocked N4 by me. Don't know about the cult.
edse - The same.
El Barto - Can't be the killer and he can't be the original cult "leader" since he was blocked by me on N1.
Chaotix (Double A) - Was blocked by BSmith on N3 so the above applies here as well.
BSmith - Role blocker?
Gaius Scribonius Curio - Haven't been blocked.. so he could be part of cult or he could be the killer.
HopAlongBunny - Tracker ?


So, the most likely mafia/cult (is there any cult left?!) are GSC and autolycus ?!?

El Barto
07-26-2013, 01:41
Why're we always assuming that there's only one strating cultist? For starters, Chaotix/AA did a far scummier thing, namely, his absurd vote change trying to bring about a No Lynch scenario, which would've saved the two Cultists (hadn't Stannis decided to kill both). I'd place him as scummier than GSC and auto.

autolycus
07-26-2013, 01:43
Based on the information we have here in this thread then

autolycus - Can't be the killer since he was blocked N4 by me. Don't know about the cult.
edse - The same.
El Barto - Can't be the killer and he can't be the original cult "leader" since he was blocked by me on N1.
Chaotix (Double A) - Was blocked by BSmith on N3 so the above applies here as well.
BSmith - Role blocker?
Gaius Scribonius Curio - Haven't been blocked.. so he could be part of cult or he could be the killer.
HopAlongBunny - Tracker ?


So, the most likely mafia/cult (is there any cult left?!) are GSC and autolycus ?!?
If you look at the first couple write-ups and this one, I'm pretty sure "The Rose" (White_Eyes) was the original cult "leader". I think we do have one cult member left,

I used my ability on edse on night 4, and there hasn't been a conversion since then, so he's not a cult convert.

Curio tried to cast a vote yesterday that would have lynched White_Eyes, so I'm 90% sure he's not cult.

Top suspects for cult for me at this point are El Barto and Chaotix, because they weren't on White_Eyes on Day 5 and aren't cleared by my ability. I'm dosing El Barto tonight, so unless I've misunderstood my role ability, he'll be non-cult by tomorrow if no one blocks me.

Priority now needs to be finding the killer. Top suspect for that seems to me to be GSC. Our roleblockers have proven their ability, HopAlong saw actions that we know were taken by a number of people, and edse, El Barto, and I have all been blocked. Unless the killer is able to ignore role-blocks or can kill and do something else, it seems to me like it has to be GSC.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-26-2013, 03:09
Unless I am very much mistaken HopAlongBunny scanned me doing nothing on the night Rickinator was killed (N5). Ditto El Barto with B-Wing (N4), so I'm not really sure.

Chaotix's action seems most incriminating to me, and the continued survival of the cult doesn't necessarily work against the 'killer'.

More thoughts later...

Ibn-Khaldun
07-26-2013, 10:13
HopAlongBunny scanned you not visiting anyone.. That doesn't mean you weren't killing anyone. HopAlongBunny may have the ability to track if someone uses their abilities on someone else but there is the possibility he does not track the killer. It seems that his role was to find out cult members not the killer.

You are still on my list of suspects..

Visor
07-26-2013, 13:01
End Night 7

HopAlongBunny was fond of animals. He loved rabbits especially, the cute fluffy things with big ears. So when he saw one hopping along in the dark near the castle gardens, he couldnt resist. He could have a pet of his own, and he could hide it in his bunk, there was no-one to see it with the siege going on. He crept towards the bunny as stood up and sniffed the air. It bolted and the his face dropped. Not just from the bunny escaping, but from the crossbow bolt in the chest. He collapsed and breathed his last, as he wished his bunny to escape from his killer. He heard a curse as the thwang of the crossbow hit stone and smiled as his eyes closed for the final time.


Summary: HopAlongBunny was killed!
He was a Knight of the Stormlands!

http://oyster.ignimgs.com/mediawiki/apis.ign.com/game-of-thrones/6/6a/Vardis_Egen.png

he was Town!


Day 8 will end 48 hours from this post at 9:30 PM GMT +10.

Alive 7/18:
3. Autolycus
4. Edse
5. El Barto
6. Chaotix
8. Ibn-Khaldun
9. BSmith
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio

Dead 11/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather, cult, killed Night 3.
12. B-Wing, town, killed Night 4.
15. Ishmael, town, lynched Day 5.
7. Rickinator9, town, killed Night 5.
18. SalmonSoil, cult, lynched Day 7.
16. White_eyes:D, cult, executed Day 7.
17. HopAlongBunny, town, killed Night 7.

Visor
07-26-2013, 13:08
The extension is for the weekend. Use it wisely.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-26-2013, 13:24
Quick thought for the evening: someone is lying.

Autolycus - Anticult (Not Roleblocked)
Edse - Blocked N2 (I-K)
El Barto - Blocked N1 (I-K)
Chaotix - Blocked N3 (BSmith)
Ibn-Khaldun - Blocked N5 (Bsmith)
Bsmith -(Not Roleblocked)
Curio - Stannis

Intuitive suspect: Autolycus, but I'd like to hear from others before jumping to hasty conclusions: we have 48 hours after all, we should get this right...

HopAlongBunny
07-26-2013, 13:56
Oh unkind fate :on_dead:

I had no access to my 'puter for a bit so this is likely good for town; I couldn't help anyhow.
The important thing is true however: The rabbit is alive!

autolycus
07-26-2013, 20:53
Quick thought for the evening: someone is lying.

Autolycus - Anticult (Not Roleblocked)
Edse - Blocked N2 (I-K)
El Barto - Blocked N1 (I-K)
Chaotix - Blocked N3 (BSmith)
Ibn-Khaldun - Blocked N5 (Bsmith)
Bsmith -(Not Roleblocked)
Curio - Stannis

Intuitive suspect: Autolycus, but I'd like to hear from others before jumping to hasty conclusions: we have 48 hours after all, we should get this right...

I was blocked night 4, I think by I-K, but I could be wrong. Also, I was tracked on night 1 to Ishmael, who didn't die.

Ibn-Khaldun
07-26-2013, 22:11
Yes, I blocked autolycus on N4.
I also blocked Curio last night.

El Barto
07-26-2013, 23:37
I stand by my previous accusations. vote:Chaotix.

Chaotix
07-27-2013, 01:32
Lynching me now would be a mistake.

There's clearly at least one mafia killer, and I am not him. There are 7 people left and thus 3 lynches left if one mafia, 2 lynches left if two mafia.

You don't want to waste one of those lynches on me. I'm not a threat.

El Barto
07-27-2013, 02:21
Interestingly, you still do not deny the accusations, neither do you even bother to explain why you tried to bring about a no lynch.

Once again, J'accuse!

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-27-2013, 03:19
Updated

El Barto - Blocked N1 (I-K); Tracked N4 (no action)
Edse - Blocked N2 (I-K)
Autolycus - Blocked N4 (I-K); Tracked N1 (visited Ishmael)
Curio - Blocked N7 (I-K); Tracked N5 (no action)

Chaotix - Blocked N3 (BSmith)
Ibn-Khaldun - Blocked N5 (Bsmith)

Bsmith -(Not Roleblocked)

Thoughts: we know that the killer has been present every evening, and has not missed a kill. Logically that would rule out everyone who has been roleblocked. However, that leaves us with one person: BSmith, one of those roleblockers. We have confirmation that Ibn-Khaldun's ability works: speaking of N4 Autolycus explictly said:

The night before, I was jailed.
We have no such confirmation from BSmith, as when he blocked Ibn-Khaldun on N5, he had not submitted orders...

BSmith, what is your role exactly: how do you prevent night actions? Ibn-Khaldun, could you do the same, though I think I have the answer...

Chaotix
07-27-2013, 04:23
Interestingly, you still do not deny the accusations, neither do you even bother to explain why you tried to bring about a no lynch.

Once again, J'accuse!

You've already connected the dots. Need I spell it out for you?

El Barto
07-27-2013, 04:26
Ah, you're admitting you're scum. You die, Monsieur Chatoix!

edse
07-27-2013, 10:05
There must be something wrong about the blocks. Either a block or two failed or one of the blockers is lying.

Ibn-Khaldun

N1 - El Barto
N2 - edse Tracked
N3 - B-Wing
N4 - autolycus Confirmed?
N5 - Forgot to send orders when blocked by BSmith
N7 - Curio

BSmith

N1 – B-Wing
N2 – Darth Feather
N3 – Chaotix Tracked
N4 – Rickinator9
N5 – Ibn-Khaldun

If BSmith is lying, he's only covering for Chaotix at the moment. He was, however, tracked visiting Chaotix. If we consider a failed block, this is the most likely one.

Ibn-Khaldun on the other hand give two (three) possible covers, El Barto, autolycus (and Curio that claims Stannis who at least I regarded to be an NPC, do you have anything to support your claim?). There is no proof for either blocks so a mafia consisting of Ibn-Khaldun as a blocker and El Barto or autolycus as the killer is very possible.

All this together with Chaotix trick yesterday makes me Vote: Chaotix.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-27-2013, 10:27
Not sure whether the rules stretch to quoting PMs, but I can make the point, who were the guards (Ishmael and Rickinator) guarding otherwise? If you examine the writeup for the missing night and the execution of White Eyes, you will find that Stannis is directly responsible for both...

edse
07-27-2013, 10:29
And a tally

2 Chaotix: El Barto, edse

5 No Vote: autolycus, Ibn-Khaldun, Chaotix, BSmith, Curio

We don't need to take it this easy just because we have (had) 48 hours.

edse
07-27-2013, 10:33
Not sure whether the rules stretch to quoting PMs, but I can make the point, who were the guards (Ishmael and Rickinator) guarding otherwise? If you examine the writeup for the missing night and the execution of White Eyes, you will find that Stannis is directly responsible for both...

Okay, I just felt the actions were too powerful for a player to have control of so assumed they were game mechanics.

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-27-2013, 11:14
I want to hear more from BSmith.

With that in mind, Vote: BSmith

Ibn-Khaldun
07-27-2013, 11:22
My role allows throwing people into the jail during the night phase to protect and roleblock them. And so far my blocks have been successful (I guess?).

Anyway, I will vote for Chaotix as well for now.

Vote: Chaotix

BSmith
07-27-2013, 13:00
I am the master at arms. I keep my targets busy by practicing with them for the coming Tyrell onslaught. It is possible that my block will fail with certain people, but I have yet to have a failed night. I blocked Chaotix again last night due to his attempt to tie the vote. That action also grants my vote. vote: Chaotix

Chaotix
07-27-2013, 22:09
Ah, you're admitting you're scum. You die, Monsieur Chatoix!

No, I'm not scum.

I'm cult. Pay attention.

Listen to me. I can't kill. I can't convert. I am the last of my kind.

You know I wasn't killing last night because apparently BSmith blocked me. Yet somebody still died.

Don't lynch me. There is a mafia family or a serial killer that is still alive. You have 3 lynches or less to catch him. Lynching me would be a waste, especially when you could force the mafia to kill me instead. I am nothing but a distraction, and you're playing into their hands.

Hell, you could even get autolycus to de-convert me or something, if he's really capable of that. I sure as hell ain't winning as a cultist.

For now, vote: Ibn-Khaldun. I was getting a scum vibe from him even before I was converted.

El Barto
07-27-2013, 23:52
You do realise that we can't take it for granted that you can't convert, and that thus we get one roleblocker permanently assigned to you until you die?

Now, what's this about a scum vibe from Ibn-Khaldun who, strangely enough, is a roleblocker?

Chaotix
07-28-2013, 01:27
You do realise that we can't take it for granted that you can't convert, and that thus we get one roleblocker permanently assigned to you until you die?

Now, what's this about a scum vibe from Ibn-Khaldun who, strangely enough, is a roleblocker?

Nothing concrete. Just scum vibes from the way he's been playing. Very careful and not taking any risks, etc. At the same time there is already another roleblocker (BSmith) and I find it hard to believe there are two town-aligned roleblockers in this game.

If you won't believe that I can't convert, I don't know what else to tell you. You already killed "The Rose", he was the cult leader and the only one who could convert. If you de-convert me successfully, you won't even have to worry about it.

Regardless, I am arguing that it is a bad idea to lynch me today, because you still need to catch the mafia and you're running out of time. Let me live, and I am an extra meatshield that they'll have to get through first.

El Barto
07-28-2013, 01:40
I'm not willing to exchange the killing of an antitown player of no value except as 'meatshield' for the killing of a town power role on whom you have nothign but a 'vibe'. At best you might secure a no lynch, though how you'll do that is currently beyond me.

Chaotix
07-28-2013, 02:59
I'm not willing to exchange the killing of an antitown player of no value except as 'meatshield' for the killing of a town power role on whom you have nothign but a 'vibe'. At best you might secure a no lynch, though how you'll do that is currently beyond me.

Unvote, Vote: El Barto

You're not this stupid, Barto. That means your being deliberately obtuse. Probably mafia.

I never said you had to lynch Ibn-Khaldun. He was merely the best I could come up with at the moment. I haven't done much analysis, and I don't plan on it.

---

I'm no longer addressing El Barto. I'm addressing the rest of the town.

If you believe what I told you, it's idiotic to think I'm a good lynch. If you lynch me and the town loses, you deserve it.

If you just don't believe me... well, that's your call.

But here's what I'm telling you:

-I can't hurt you. I have no night kill ability.
-I can't make the cult any stronger. I cannot convert.
-I am the last cultist.

You can lynch me at any time. Or you can try to de-convert me. I won't stop you. Point is, I am a known quantity.

I just don't understand why you would continue to vote for me when there is clearly another mafia faction that is infinitely more dangerous to you than I am. You only have three lynches left. You have to make them count, because the scum are going to keep killing. If you let me live, that is one more lynch you can use to try to catch scum, and one more person that the scum have to kill.

If you decide to let me live, the scum will probably realize they have to kill me, and they will try to do that. I'll be killed instead of townies.

Make your choice. I've lost this game as a cultist no matter what. That happened as soon as I made my move last phase and both of my teammates got lynched. My only hope for winning is that I get de-converted, if that's possible. autolycus says it is; otherwise I wouldn't have even bothered with this nonsense and just accepted my death. But if I can be a townie, I can still win. And I can be of use to the town. That's what I'm going for here.

autolycus
07-28-2013, 03:48
Vote: El Barto
I actually agree with Chaotix. Conversions have shown up in thread before, so I don't think he converted anyone last night. I'll hit him tonight, and we'll be good on the cult front.

Why El Barto?

One of our blockers is lying or failed. The only case that makes sense if they're lying is El Barto and I-K in collaboration, with night 1 being a lie to clear El Barto. If El Barto comes up clean, we know a block failed, and can work from there.

autolycus
07-28-2013, 03:51
Just to be clear, I'm not saying I-K is scum, just that the only two person team that makes sense as far as I can tell is those two, so lynching El Barto removes both that possibility and El Barto as an SK immune to blocks.

edse, El Barto, have either of you made claims to abilities that I'm forgetting?

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-28-2013, 04:50
I am far less concerned with Ibn-Khaldun, whose ability we have confirmation of (via Autolycus) than by BSmith. The point that two pro-town roleblockers seems unlikely makes sense. So if one of our role-blockers is lying, it is far more likely to be BSmith.

I would urge the garrison to lynch BSmith over El Barto, who has been both role-blocked by Ibn-Khaldun and tracked doing nothing, or at the very least lynch Chaotix, who is a self-confessed traitor.

Tally

Chaotix 4 - El Barto; edse; Ibn-Khaldun; BSmith
El Barto 2 - Chaotix; Autolycus
BSmith 1 - Curio

Visor
07-28-2013, 09:30
3 hours left.

Ibn-Khaldun
07-28-2013, 11:20
Btw, did't we already had master-at-arms? A role that BSmith claimed?

Gaius Scribonius Curio
07-28-2013, 11:23
IIRC: I was sure that this sounded familiar...

It is best we probably stick with Chaotix this late though...

Ibn-Khaldun
07-28-2013, 11:26
B-Wing was Captain of the Guard. So that is why it sounded familiar.

Visor
07-28-2013, 12:30
End Day 8

Chaotix ordered to approach the gallows. Stannis had decided to hang this traitor, who had laid his claims quite bare for all to see. Ser Gawen Wylde, the man at arms had a big smile on his face as he ordered the man up the stairs with his sword. Today was a good day for him. He loved hanging traitors. As he hung the noose around Chaotix's neck, he burst out laughing. Stannis frowned, "What could possibly be funny about a hanging?" he asked.

"It isn't the hanging my lord that I'm laughing at." he said as he kicked the chair under Chaotix's legs.

"It's you."

With that, Edse and El Barto drew their crossbow and sword respectively. Stannis looked around at his two remaining garrison members, Ibn-Khaldun, his jailor and Davos Fleabottom, his saviour. Davos cursed and drew his sword and the Jailor ran off.

With a smile, Edse fired a shot at Davos, missing by an inch as Davos realised the fight was lost. He ran off to follow the jailor.

El Barto and BSmith cornered Stannis, who was clearly outmatched. "You'll cede lordship of Storm's End to me, Cape Wrath to El Barto and Edse will remain my trusty companion. With a high payrise of course. Now, you'll be wanting to agree to these terms, as the alternative is your death. After all, when you play the game of thrones, you either win, or you die. Maybe we'll let you be a lord under us, or maybe you'll take the black instead. I hear they need men on the wall. Choice is yours."

Stannis cursed. Bloody thieves they were. He looked out past the castle. Was that a direwolf banner?


Summary: Chaotix was lynched!
He was a Footsoldier!

http://images.wikia.com/gameofthrones/images/6/66/Stark_soldier_2x10.png

he was Cult!



GAME OVER!


MAFIA VICTORY!


Congratulations BSmith, Edse and El Barto!


Alive 6/18:
3. Autolycus, town.
4. Edse, mafia.
5. El Barto, mafia.
8. Ibn-Khaldun, town.
9. BSmith, mafia.
11. Gaius Scribonius Curio, town.

Dead 12/18:
14. Riedquat, town, killed Night 1.
1. Makrell, town, lynched Day 2.
13. Jarema, town, killed Night 2.
2. LazyMcCrow, town, lynched Day 3.
10. Darth Feather, cult, killed Night 3.
12. B-Wing, town, killed Night 4.
15. Ishmael, town, lynched Day 5.
7. Rickinator9, town, killed Night 5.
18. SalmonSoil, cult, lynched Day 7.
16. White_eyes:D, cult, executed Day 7.
17. HopAlongBunny, town, killed Night 7.
6. Chaotix, cult, lynched Day 8.

Visor
07-28-2013, 12:52
Role PMs:



Welcome Curio, you are Stannis Baratheon, the Commander of the garrison at Storm's End, and brother to the usurper Robert Baratheon. He tasked you to hold Storm's End and so you have after almost 10 months of siege.


https://i.imgur.com/OC9PGmf.jpg?1

Alignment: Town
Ability: As the Lord Commander you hold a lot of power in your position. Once in the game, you may choose to execute someone in addition to the lynch. This can only be done in the day. You also have the one time ability to keep a full night's watch which will ensure no-one can take action on a particular night. If you die or become indisposed/wounded it may have an effect on the town itself.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Execute a traitor using your ability.

Welcome B-Wing, you are the Captain of the Guard who is situated at Storm's End.


http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_SniTwfm5BwE/TDtESR2BJkI/AAAAAAAACmQ/U3qaX1DFCRc/s1600/Jory+Cassel.jpg

Alignment: Town
Ability: The Captain of the Guard holds some power in the runnings of the castle. You may investigate a person to find out whether they were active or not during the night.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Stannis Baratheon survives.

Welcome Makrell, you are Maester Cressen who is situated at Storm's End.


http://images5.fanpop.com/image/polls/990000/990692_1333404105725_full.jpg

Alignment: Town
Ability: As a maester you must know how to heal. Every night you may heal someone, which will either bring them back from a wounded state or stop them from taking harm.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Save at least two people.

Welcome BSmith, you are Ser Gawen Wylde who is the master at arms at Storm's End.


http://www.re-enactmentsupplies.co.uk/image/cache/data/men%20at%20arms-500x500.png

Alignment: Mafia
Ability: As a master at arms you are skilled in swordsmanship. You may spar with someone each night as practice for the Tyrell horde, they will be too tired to do anything that night. This will not work on certain characters however.
Victory: Eliminate enough people so that you can take over the castle.
Personal Goal: Kill at least two named characters.

Welcome autolycus, you are Davos Fleabottom, the infamous smuggler turned hero of the garrison at Storm's End. Without your supplies the garrison would've been forced to eat their own dead.


https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSsnvQhtxJrWWlWscewAJFvTGlZ0scgkoItiL11YMkkeMETJzV0

Alignment: Town
Ability: Smugglers are careful men and ones who like make sure that they can trust men to have their backs. Every night you may bring an extra portion of food and some words and promises to a person to ensure they are loyal to Stannis. If they are a new cult recruit they will turn back to townie alignment. Otherwise you will prevent the person from being recruited that night.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Bring back a cult member using your ability. You will not know if you have suceeded until after the game.

Welcome Riedquat, you are the Cook who is situated at Storm's End.


https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRcDZ6m5WsasFL-r855-up5B59blkl3fiiL1hyd9d5sDKZXFCNvnQ

Alignment: Town
Ability: You have no abilities.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Vote to lynch at least two traitors successfully.

Welcome Rickinator9, you are a member of Stannis's Guard who is situated at Storm's End.


https://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lleh9zYotD1qhu9p7o1_500.png

Alignment: Town
Ability: You are a guard to Stannis Baratheon. You will defend him with your life. The other member of the guard is Ishmael. As long as both of you are alive Stannis cannot be killed. You are not masons.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Stannis Baratheon survives.

Welcome Ishmael, you are a member of Stannis's Guard who is situated at Storm's End.


http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20130111172456/gameofthrones/images/1/14/Yoren_profile.jpg

Alignment: Town
Ability: You are a guard to Stannis Baratheon. You will defend him with your life. The other member of the guard is rickinator9. As long as both of you are alive Stannis cannot be killed. You are not masons.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Stannis Baratheon survives.

Welcome White_Eyes:D, you are The Rose who is a member of the garrison at Storm's End.


http://i.lv3.hbo.com/custom-assets/enrichments/series/game-of-thrones/r5/images/houses2/people/detail/loras-tyrell.jpg

Alignment: Cult
Ability: The Rose is skilled in deception. Each night you may leave a letter in someone's bed detailing that if they help you, the Tyrell's will be sure to reward them and that if they decide to show up at the well by midnight, you will know their loyalty. Only certain people will accept however. You can send letters every second night. However, your party cannot be more then three, otherwise the stink of traitor will be too large for the guards to ignore and they will crack down hard. If your letter is refused, you cannot act the following night. (For example, if you send it night 1 and it is refused, the guards will be on high alert, therefore you cannot perform any abilities the next night (this goes for everyone in your group. If someone fails an action, the whole group must be silent for the next night).

However, your new babes in arms may not be particularly loyal. I suggest not revealing your identity to them unless you make them members of your garden. A new recruit has no abilities, however a flower does. Making a new recruit a flower takes two nights, and lots of persuasion. However, you can be sure they are loyal.
Victory: Convince enough people that the Tyrells will be lenient to open the gate to let them in.
Personal Goal: Never have more then two members in the cult.

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/MiNQLs3YRxg

Quicktopic to discuss. I may change your PM according to the balance of the game.

Welcome El Barto, you are Ser Jon Cafferon who is a knight in residence at Storm's End.


https://i123.photobucket.com/albums/o294/yaboi32244/photo-richard.jpg

Alignment: Mafia
Ability: A Knight of the Stormlands, you have the ability to disguise yourself. If your target is killed your name will be mentioned, and you will take the person's name. Beware, I will eventually leave hints that he was disguised.
Victory: Eliminate enough people so that you can take over the castle.
Personal Goal: Have Stannis Baratheon lynched.

Welcome HopAlongBunny, you are a Knight of the Stormlands who is situated at Storm's End.


http://oyster.ignimgs.com/mediawiki/apis.ign.com/game-of-thrones/6/6a/Vardis_Egen.png

Alignment: Town
Ability: You may track a person to see who they visit.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Find a traitor.

Welcome edse, you are Ser Amory Rogers who is a soldier in residence at Storm's End.


http://images3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120523132531/gameofthrones/images/5/52/Jaqen_H'ghar.png

Alignment: Mafia
Ability: You may kill one person at night.
Victory: Eliminate enough people so that you can take over the castle.
Personal Goal: At least two of the mafia survive.

Welcome Yay!, you are the Sargent who is situated at Storm's End.


https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRDrGfB1xw9h9yFHmEwBqZZNwlyM0g5pgjkk_pjSdBkxakESA-E8w

Alignment: Town
Ability: Each night you may wound someone which will prevent them from taking action the next night.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Use your ability on a traitor.

Welcome Double A, you are the Footsoldier who is situated at Storm's End.


http://images.wikia.com/gameofthrones/images/6/66/Stark_soldier_2x10.png

Alignment: Town
Ability: One shot bulletproof.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Use your ability on a traitor.

Welcome LazyMcCrow, you are a Footsoldier who is situated at Storm's End.


http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120517225402/gameofthrones/images/9/94/Stark_soldier_1.jpg

Alignment: Town
Ability: You may send anonymous messages through me to the scum players.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Lynch scum of both alignments.

Welcome Ibn-Khaldun, you are the Jailer who is situated at Storm's End.


http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120704022818/gameofthrones/images/3/32/Mord.png

Alignment: Town
Ability: Each night you may throw someone in jail, to both protect and roleblock them.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Protect someone from dying and roleblock a traitor.

Welcome SalmonSoil, you are a Prisoner who is situated at Storm's End.


https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcR6YlfAw9b3bPEV_VHrqH-0cz5z5IOEQeCmoZ0GeiJiLTxwnssC

Alignment: Neutral
Ability: You can currently not do anything at night.
Victory: Survive the game.
Personal Goal: Outlive Stannis Baratheon.

Welcome Darth Feather, you are a Mortician who is situated at Storm's End.


http://img.poptower.com/pic-54270/jerome-flynn.jpg?d=600

Alignment: Town
Ability: Each night you may examine a corpse to determine how it died.
Victory: Eliminate all traitors to the garrison.
Personal Goal: Correctly identify at least three bodies.

Visor
07-28-2013, 12:58
Victory:

Edse, BSmith and El Barto achieved Faction Victory.

Edse, BSmith, El Barto, Gaius Scribonius Curio, Autolycus and Ibn-Khaldun achieved Survival.

Gaius, B-Wing, Rickinator9, Ishmael, edse, Jarema all achieved Personal Goals.

Visor
07-28-2013, 13:02
Quicktopics:


http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/qKBvxKX3dKMd (Dead and Spoiled QT)
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/5xFt3kyxTqB (Mafia QT)
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/tXwEMXYubt4nk (Recruited Cult QT)
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/MiNQLs3YRxg (Mainline Cult QT (pretty much empty))


Any questions/queries/complaints/criticism? Thanks all for playing and I hope you had a fun game, I enjoyed hosting it.

Visor
07-28-2013, 13:13
And a few more things:

Sorry to White Eyes, I could've balanced the cult a bit better, but you did well with it.
Sorry to BSmith and WE:D for mixing your roles up.
I heavily hinted in the writeup that the town needed the last cult member, because otherwise I feared they would think the game was over when the cult was lynched.
I did mention the setup on the first page.
The prisoner was a balancing role.
I know the game was unbalanced, but I don't believe it was to the point where no faction had a chance.
I probably could've done better writeups, and extended phases over the weekends.

There's probably a few more things, but that's it for now.

Oh, and go back and read the night 2 writeup. Notice anything different?