View Full Version : Mini Mafia Game Grin and Beard It [Concluded]
You know what to do.
Rules:
•24 hour days and 24 hour night phases. Phases may be extended if needed and if I require.
•You may talk after death. However, no out of thread info, etc. No "I can't say why, but lynch 'x'." If you do so, I will first give a warning, then ban you from talking. This may change depending on how many players I get.
•Don't quote anything I say to you, however, paraphrasing is fine. Don't discuss the time of PM's, or the length or writing style, as it means nothing.
•No screenshots, etc.
•You may talk to players outside the thread.
•You will vote for players you want lynched during the day, using the format, Vote: Visorslash. Votes must be in bold to count. If you wish to unvote, simply: Unvote; Vote: ATPG. You don't need to do a semicolon, I just think it looks nice.
•If you are replaced or WOG killed, please do not post in the thread anymore unless it is an apology. If you are replaced by choice, please don't comment in the game.
•If you think you won't be around during the night phase to give your night action, you can always PM me your night actions in advance.
•Votes that end in a tie, 24 hour round extension, with only the tied players being viable vote candidate.
•No lynch is allowed.
•Don't edit posts with votes. I won't count them. Feel free to misrepresent the tally, I do my own anyway. If I can be convinced otherwise, I will change the rule.
•This game will have roles. (probably)
•If you miss two day phases in a row or 3 in total with any reasonable excuse or informing me why you will be WoG'ed. No exceptions for role. Not voting is the same as not participating in my book.
•Have fun. This is not an option . If you don't think you'll have fun with this game... don't join it. Nor if you feel you won't be able to participate.
•Alignment will be revealed on death, not role.
Players 9/9:
1. Johnhughthom
2. Riedquat
3. Montmorency
4. El Barto
5. Choxorn
6. Count Arach
7. edse
8. Makrell
9. Darth Feather
Reserves:
johnhughthom
08-27-2013, 13:08
Yes.
Riedquat
08-27-2013, 13:42
In!
:bow:
Montmorency
08-27-2013, 16:15
Been a while since the last mini.
El Barto
08-27-2013, 20:36
It'll be fun to play this.
CountArach
08-28-2013, 01:55
Ready to grIN.
One more and we can start, hopefully I can get it started today if the last guy shows up.
Makrell can take my place. I will be a bit busy the following days.
I'll put both of you in. Starts tomorrow.
Darth Feather
08-31-2013, 12:08
I will be a reservist. :2thumbsup:
You can be in, 9 is better then 8.
Simple Vanilla game, 1 kill per night, no powers, 7 town, 2 mafia.
Begin Day 1
A threat to beardom was a threat to all hairkind. The evil fake beards had deigned it necessary to destroy manliness once and for all. They must be stopped!
Day 1 will end 24 hours from this post at 9:30 PM GMT +10.
Alive 9/9:
1. Johnhughthom
2. Riedquat
3. Montmorency
4. El Barto
5. Choxorn
6. Count Arach
7. edse
8. Makrell
9. Darth Feather
If you didn't get a PM you are vanilla town.
Montmorency
08-31-2013, 12:44
Vote: El Barto
Darth Feather
08-31-2013, 13:20
What do you say Random.org? Choxorn? ok, Vote: Choxorn
El Barto
08-31-2013, 20:10
Oh my Gob, you suck, Montmorency! vote:Montmorency
Vote: Count Arach
You are Number Six. Ergo, you must die.
Vote: Darth Feather Last in, first out.
CountArach
09-01-2013, 04:19
Vote: Makrell
johnhughthom
09-01-2013, 06:40
Vote: El Barto
Riedquat
09-01-2013, 06:52
Vote: edse
2 El (Monty, JHT)
1 Chox (Darth)
1 Monty (El)
1 Count (Chox)
1 Darth (edse)
1 Makrell (Count)
1 Edse (Riedquat)
1 Riedquat (Makrell)
17 minutes to go.
End Day 1
"El Beardo you are charged with crimes of a feminine nature. How do you plead!"
"Manly your honor!"
"WRONG! Guilty!"
El Beardo beardly had time to look around before he was shaved to death.
To their horror, he was an actual beard! They must catch the culprits soon!
Night 1 will end 24 hours from this post at 9:30 PM GMT +10.
Alive 8/9:
1. Johnhughthom
2. Riedquat
3. Montmorency
5. Choxorn
6. Count Arach
7. edse
8. Makrell
9. Darth Feather
Dead 1/9:
4. El Barto, beard.
Orders please. Glory to Beardstotzka.
El Barto
09-01-2013, 22:28
You see, you unbearddeserving fools? I am only mafia when not lynched! Now, in the name of Beardstotzka, vote someone else!
Mesa thinking, that jht and Monty both voting me like that can't be a coincidence. Mesa know that both hate-a mesa, but that's-a not enough.
End Night 1
Darth Beard was preparing his plans for the great beard festival when he was shaved."
First they came for the beards,
and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a beard.
Then they came for the mustaches,
and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a mustache.
Then they came for the stubble,
and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a stubble.
Then they came for me,
and there was no one left to speak for me.
He was a manly beard!
Day 2 will end 23 hours from this post at 9:30 PM GMT +10.
Alive 7/9:
1. Johnhughthom
2. Riedquat
3. Montmorency
5. Choxorn
6. Count Arach
7. edse
8. Makrell
Dead 2/9:
4. El Barto, beard.
9. Darth Feather, beard.
Montmorency
09-02-2013, 13:59
Vote: Choxorn
Riedquat
09-02-2013, 15:19
Vote: Count Arach
Darth Feather
09-02-2013, 16:18
I bet edse killed me
Vote: Darth Feather Last in, first out. :hanged:
El Barto
09-02-2013, 18:08
necrovote: jht
johnhughthom
09-03-2013, 01:09
Hmm, wonder why/when I put El Takewer on ignore.
Vote: Choxorn
As little reasoning as everyone else.
Riedquat
09-03-2013, 02:07
Hmm, wonder why/when I put El Takewer on ignore.
Vote: Choxorn
As little reasoning as everyone else.
:inquisitive:
You and Monty voted El Beardo yesterday, now you and Monty are voting choxorn today? I wasn't following El Beardo's call because it seems very unlikely both scum will be voting for same townie on day 1, but same couple choosing target in day 2 smell bad...
unvote; vote: jht
El Barto
09-03-2013, 02:15
It could all be part of a very clever plan by jht to frame Montmorency. Which, all the same, means johnhughthom should be lynched.
johnhughthom
09-03-2013, 02:22
I have evidence that Choxxy is unable to grow a proper beard. He has confessed.
El Barto
09-03-2013, 03:03
The same type of 'evidence' you had when I was lynched? No sir.
johnhughthom
09-03-2013, 05:26
I didn't claim to have evidence when I lynched you, it simply amused me.
Bah! My beard may not be Dumbledore-level awesome, but at least I'm trying! You're just a big phony.
Unvote, Vote: johnhughthom for being clearly a big, phony scum.
Rally
3 johnhughthom: Makrell, Riedquat, Choxorn
2 Choxorn:Montmorency, johnhughthom
1 Makrell: edse
1 No Vote: CountArach
CountArach
09-03-2013, 09:13
:inquisitive:
You and Monty voted El Beardo yesterday, now you and Monty are voting choxorn today? I wasn't following El Beardo's call because it seems very unlikely both scum will be voting for same townie on day 1, but same couple choosing target in day 2 smell bad...
unvote; vote: jht
This sentence doesn't make a whole lot of sense. You first claim that you aren't doing something because it seems odd (which I totally agree with by the way, it would be weird for them to vote together) and then you vote for JHT precisely because he is doing that. I don't find the evidence against JHT particularly convincing but I do think that Vote: Riedquat is our best move at the moment. I find the above to be the scummiest post made so far.
Montmorency
09-03-2013, 12:01
JHT is not my partner.
Unvote; Vote: jht
John's lynched, thanks for the tally.
End Day 2
Johnbeardthom spoke up in his defence. "I'd like to take my chance to acknowledge that you all suck, and that my dead beardmother could grow a better beard then your sorry excuses for hair."
Gasps were heard.
"What? Can't beard the truth?"
He was shaved soon after, but not before shredding two mustaches and breaking a stubble.
He was a manly beard!
Night 2 will end 24 hours from this post at 9:30 PM GMT +10.
Alive 6/9:
2. Riedquat
3. Montmorency
5. Choxorn
6. Count Arach
7. edse
8. Makrell
Dead 2/9:
4. El Barto, beard.
9. Darth Feather, beard.
1. Johnhughthom, beard.
Darth Feather
09-03-2013, 13:06
JHT is not my partner.
Translation: I am scum
But then again, not claiming scum would be scummy for you. :shrug:
Montmorency
09-03-2013, 13:12
Is that what you people think?
:uhoh2:
Riedquat
09-03-2013, 14:29
This sentence doesn't make a whole lot of sense.
You are lucky if you find just a bit of sense in anything I say! Sometimes I realize I write like a not very bright monkey in heavy drugs and sadly it is the best I can do. :clown:
El Barto
09-03-2013, 16:51
Oh really, jht, I hope you have an explanation for your shenanigans.
End Night 2
Makstauche was breathing heavily. "Every moment I live is agony. Kill me."
The two fake beards were confused, but shaved him anyway.
He was a manly beard!
Day 3 will end 48 hours from this post at 9:30 PM GMT +10.
Alive 5/9:
2. Riedquat
3. Montmorency
5. Choxorn
6. Count Arach
7. edse
Dead 4/9:
4. El Barto, beard.
9. Darth Feather, beard.
1. Johnhughthom, beard.
8. Makrell, beard.
THIS IS LYLO, YOU MUST LYNCH CORRECTLY OR LOSE.
CountArach
09-04-2013, 13:18
Vote: Riedquat. Yesterday when I called him out for how illogical this post is:
:inquisitive:
You and Monty voted El Beardo yesterday, now you and Monty are voting choxorn today? I wasn't following El Beardo's call because it seems very unlikely both scum will be voting for same townie on day 1, but same couple choosing target in day 2 smell bad...
unvote; vote: jht
His reply was:
You are lucky if you find just a bit of sense in anything I say! Sometimes I realize I write like a not very bright monkey in heavy drugs and sadly it is the best I can do. :clown:
So rather than actually addressing why he changed his mind in the above post, he chooses to laugh it off with an "I'm illogical" post. I would like Riedquat to explain this change of heart to me.
Riedquat
09-04-2013, 14:14
Day 1: Monty and jht voting for El Barto, bartito got lynched and started calling scum both Monty and Jht, normal behaviour here
Day 2: Monty starts the vote going after Choxorn, El barto continues his crusade with jht as target, again, everything normal here, later comes jht and placed a vote in the same spot Monty did. Same voting pattern than previous day, to me that is really odd, more considering the numbers of players and the consecutive days.
That made me rise both eyebrows, and honestly fosing jht was pointless, he was a better vote candidate than random you! ;)
The odd thing of this is why I need to explain why I changed my mind, what was your mind to start with? why jht's vote didn't make you suspicious of him?
Has anything I've said makes sense to you now? Now I'm thinking you knew to well jht wasn't scum...
CountArach
09-04-2013, 15:16
Day 1: Monty and jht voting for El Barto, bartito got lynched and started calling scum both Monty and Jht, normal behaviour here
Day 2: Monty starts the vote going after Choxorn, El barto continues his crusade with jht as target, again, everything normal here, later comes jht and placed a vote in the same spot Monty did. Same voting pattern than previous day, to me that is really odd, more considering the numbers of players and the consecutive days.
That made me rise both eyebrows, and honestly fosing jht was pointless, he was a better vote candidate than random you! ;)
The odd thing, which you still haven't explained, is why what you discounted on day 1 was suddenly so much better on day 2 despite using the same logic.
The odd thing of this is why I need to explain why I changed my mind, what was your mind to start with? why jht's vote didn't make you suspicious of him?
As I said here (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?145259-Grin-and-Beard-It&p=2053545673&viewfull=1#post2053545673) it instinctively feels odd that they would vote together, particularly two days in a row soo the vote didn't seem any more scummy than others to me. Your posts that I am talking about here, and the fact that you haven't provided any sort of rational reason for changing your mind in the space of one post, are the only things so far that have leapt out at me as being really scummy.
Has anything I've said makes sense to you now? Now I'm thinking you knew to well jht wasn't scum...
So you resort to throwing an accusation back at me.
Riedquat
09-04-2013, 15:43
The odd thing, which you still haven't explained, is why what you discounted on day 1 was suddenly so much better on day 2 despite using the same logic.
:inquisitive: What I've discounted on day 1? I'm sorry but don't understand what you mean... How can I fin odd two persons voting for a third one??
it instinctively feels odd that they would vote together, particularly two days in a row soo the vote didn't seem any more scummy than others to me.
So, you also agree it was odd but not scummy? It is scummier noticing it is odd and placing a vote in the oddity...right!
So you resort to throwing an accusation back at me.
Not accusing, just doubting your... reasoning, to you what both Monty and Jht were doing was odd and not scummy, to me it was odd and scummy... and my vote change and "lack of reasoning" was more scummy than all posts on thread with less reasoning than mine. or at least less words on it them...
Montmorency
09-04-2013, 17:30
Vote: Choxorn
Why do you keep voting for me with no explanation, Monty?
Montmorency
09-05-2013, 01:17
Twice makes a pattern? That's no good.
Riedquat
09-05-2013, 02:41
I've this feeling we are about to lose and still can't make my mind who to vote for... (15 minutes later) so... I will vote for the less talkative of the group.. Vote: edse
Twice makes a pattern? That's no good.
In a game this short, I'll consider it a pattern.
And this still isn't an explanation for your voting.
Vote: Montmorency
]Vote: Choxorn Montmorency is probably innocent (my opinion after his vote switch yesterday) and he seems quite sure Choxorn is mafia.
]Vote: Choxorn Montmorency is probably innocent (my opinion after his vote switch yesterday) and he seems quite sure Choxorn is mafia.
Why the hell does a completely irrelevant last-minute vote switch make Monty innocent?
You're just looking for a reason to vote for someone. And that makes you scummy.
Unvote, Vote: edse
Riedquat
09-05-2013, 19:16
You're just looking for a reason to vote for someone. And that makes you scummy.
Unvote, Vote: edse
:inquisitive: Unvote
There were three easy votes there, you, monty and me... picking you doesn't make him particularly scummy...
I'm not voting for him because he voted for me, I'm voting for him because of the reason why he voted for me. Seriously, the vote switch that is making edse think Montmorency is innocent happened 30 minutes before the end of the day and didn't affect the outcome in any way. He just went off of me and piled a bit more on the JHT wagon. How the hell does that make Montmorency innocent, and why the hell is it that Montmorency voting for me with no explanation makes me a mafia?
Hence, I think edse is a mafia trying to spare either himself or his partner, because if he's townie, he's got some pretty bad reasoning.
I'm not voting for him because he voted for me, I'm voting for him because of the reason why he voted for me. Seriously, the vote switch that is making edse think Montmorency is innocent happened 30 minutes before the end of the day and didn't affect the outcome in any way. He just went off of me and piled a bit more on the JHT wagon. How the hell does that make Montmorency innocent, and why the hell is it that Montmorency voting for me with no explanation makes me a mafia?
Hence, I think edse is a mafia trying to spare either himself or his partner, because if he's townie, he's got some pretty bad reasoning.
The only thing Monty's vote switch led to was bringing attention to him. He could have kept his vote on you and nobody would have questioned it. To me it's clear that Monty had no idea if jht was mafia or not and only wanted to distance himself from jht in case he really was mafia.
I had four choices yesterday and chose you to see the reaction. Nobody but yourself seems to be helping you though so Unvote.
Tally:
Choxorn (Monty
Edse (Choxorn
Riedquat (Count
No Vote: Riedquat, Edse.
Therefore, as per the rules, we have a 24 hour extension ending at 10:20 PM GMT+10.
You can only vote for Choxorn, Edse or Riedquat. Go!
Well, Vote: Riedquat then.
Riedquat
09-06-2013, 15:17
Doh! I knew I had something to do yesterday!
Wondering if one of us is scum, if not we already lost..
Vote: edse
CountArach
09-06-2013, 15:23
You're just looking for a reason to vote for someone. And that makes you scummy.
Unvote, Vote: edse
Unvote, Vote: Choxorn. I mean, looking for a reason to vote for someone is kind of the point of the game and this post is mine.
Well, yeah, but the town will look for GOOD reasons to vote for someone, while the mafia will look for any reason they can to get townies lynched. That's what I was accusing edse of.
Anyway, his explanation makes sense and I don't think he'd unvote me if he was mafia, so Unvote, Vote: Riedquat, because it's not me, and it's not edse, and if Arach and Monty are the two mafia then we've already lost anyway.
Riedquat
09-07-2013, 01:42
If I were scum in a game so small I would be flying really low... ;)
Riedquat has been lynched.
End Day 3
Riedstauche was cornered and shaved before he could utter a word.
He was a manly beard!
The two fake beards took off their disguises and shaved the other two before they could react. Now was the reign of manscapers!
Alive 4/9:
3. Montmorency, beard.
5. Choxorn, beard.
6. Count Arach, fake beard.
7. edse, fake beard.
Dead 5/9:
4. El Barto, beard.
9. Darth Feather, beard.
1. Johnhughthom, beard.
8. Makrell, beard.
2. Riedquat, beard.
Congratulations Edse and Count Arach!
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/sUZrppFNddF
CountArach
09-08-2013, 14:55
Soooo, is that game over?
CountArach
09-08-2013, 15:09
Wooo!
Well thanks for running that Visorslash.
Riedquat
09-08-2013, 19:02
Congratz scum! I need to learn to listen my interior voice more carefully!
Thanks for hosting Visor!
:bow:
johnhughthom
09-08-2013, 19:09
Well played fakes, thanks for the game, Visor!
My logic was right the first time. Why did I suddenly think it wasn't edse?
My logic was right the first time. Why did I suddenly think it wasn't edse?
Because I was too stupid to be mafia?
Thanks for the game Visor! Sorry for dragging it out a bit.
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.