View Full Version : Mini Mafia Game Star Wars: Rebels [In Play]
http://community.ew.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/Star-Wars-Rebels-Season-Two-Mid-Season-Trailer-Official-4450-2-612x380.jpg
Game Information:
- This game is based on the Star Wars: Rebels TV show. The mafia are the protagonists of the show and the town are Imperial Antagonists that appear within. There are at most 3 mafia and seven town.
- There will be no cults, no jesters, no roles which can influence voting / the lynch, no false alignment reveals. No bastard mechanics.
- There are more roles than I initially intended, but I wouldn't call it role madness. It also might not be totally balanced.
- 48 hour day, 24 hour night. Phase change at 10 AM PDT.
- There is night chat, but I will implement brief no-posting times around the deadlines.
- Several of the last few games got intense and didn't end well, so hopefully this can be a bit more fun & friendly to serve as something of an additional palate cleanser, and also get this section going again. :yes:
Player List: 9
Csargo
El Barto
GeneralHankerchief
Lex-Kat
Manasi
Montmorency
Snerk
Sooh
Zack
Sub List:
none at this time
Rules
1. Role PMs:
Don't talk about the role PM, except that you may say what role and alignment you are, any powers you may have.
Do not quote your role PM, do not screenshot your role PM. Don't talk about what time you got the role PM. Don't challenge people to prove their town status by describing the layout or formatting of the role PM. Do not reference it, explicitly or in a way that bends around the spirit of "don't discuss your Role PM." Do not speculate what is in someone's Role PM, do not refer to any wording or pictures in your Role PM, I'd prefer if you refrain from saying "Role PM" altogether. That's not what this game is about.
2. Outside communication:
Don't talk about this game outside the game thread or mafia chat.
Do not talk about this game with spectators or other players, publicly or privately, outside of this game thread. Unless the game host has given you a specific communication channel to use, private communications are not allowed in this game.
Also, do not talk about other ongoing games in this thread.
3. Voting
Vote: Zapp Brannigan
During the Day phase, you must Vote: in bold, with a colon (I count votes using ctrl + f "Vote:", so this makes it a lot easier for me). You do not need to unvote to vote for someone else. If you want to unvote, use Vote: Unvote even though it looks weird. To vote for no lynch, use Vote: No Lynch.
Hiding your vote in a spoiler, or some other weird thing, is a good idea if you like not having your vote count.
There is no mechanic for "hammering" a majority lynch before the deadline, and there won't be locked votes in mustlynch.
4. Activity
Post and vote at least a few times each Day phase.
If you go an entire day phase (48 hours) without any game-relevant posts [e.g. a single post saying "sorry I'm out all day" does not count], I will replace or modkill you, depending on sub availability. If there's a potential issue with your schedule, let me know and we can work it out.
There is no activity requirement for night.
5. Phase lengths
48 hour days, 24 hour nights
I know some people like longer or shorter phases, but this is the compromise we all have to live with. Phases end at 10 AM United States Pacific time. I believe this is 5 PM GMT.
6. The right to edit posts
Please do not edit your posts. I will permit a one minute grace period.
The first time is a warning. The second time your vote doesn't count that phase, third time is a modkill. Pretty simple rule, there's no reason you can't follow it.
If an edited post contains a vote or unvote, that vote doesn't exist and I will act as if it never happened.
7. Tied votes
First past the post.
If there is a tie, the first wagon to get to that total will be lynched. For example:
Bob has 4 votes.
Fred has 3 votes.
Someone changes to Fred, putting him at 4 votes.
If Bob is still at 4 votes, Bob is lynched.
I use this method because it avoids random chance having a significant influence on the game's outcome, and also avoids delaying the game or being overly complex.
8. Flavor gaming
I'll discourage it, but it's not explicitly disallowed. It will, however, be useless.
10. Victory
Town wins when both mafia have been eliminated. Mafia wins when they reach parity with town, or parity is mechanically unavoidable.
11. Sample Role PM
“Make no mistake. From now on, failure will have consequences.”
―Tarkin
https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ7ggDHrGYWdZ6x3iYWuxWx-MtrdMXrofuRMa_CBc5AtJEJ7Htx
Player, you are Grand Moff Tarkin.
You are Vanilla Empire.
You win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.
Good luck, have fun, read the rules, PM me with any questions.
12. Anything else
If you have a question about anything else, ask me PRIVATELY. I will not answer or address questions asked publicly. Any complaints/critiques about the game setup during the game may be directed privately. After the game, you may complain or critique about setup publicly if you desire, but please keep such concerns constructive.
* I just remembered - when a player is lynched or dies their full role and alignment will be truthfully revealed.
These rules were mostly copy-pasted from Zack's Heathstone Mafia, which was itself copied from ATPG's Pokemon Mafia.
It is now Night 1.
Game Updates
Player
Role/Faction
Died
Zack
Zeb/Rebels
Day 1
GeneralHankerchief
Agent Alexsandr Kallus/Empire
Night 1
Manasi
The Grand Inquisitor/Empire
Night 1
El Barto
Sabine Wren/Rebels
Day 2
https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/a6ced9e6-2503-419b-bc94-da09aaf7da77/scale-to-width-down/627
The game has now officially begun 1 hour early, and you can start posting and voting.
Everyone has their PMs. The game has started. If you have any questions, PM me.
Please read the rules. Don't talk about Role PMs, etc.
Remember to be civil and that this is a game -- don't be a jerk.
glgl and have fun :whip:
Living Players: 9
Csargo
El Barto
GeneralHankerchief
Lex-Kat
Manasi
Montmorency
Snerk
Sooh
Zack
It is now Day One.
Voting ends in: tunnel snakes rule
https://i.imgur.com/kK6SXft.gif
Csargo is super evil. I feel it in the force.
Montmorency
04-11-2018, 22:54
Csargo is super evil. I feel it in the force.
So you're saying he's Town? Smells like a slip.
El Barto
04-11-2018, 22:54
vote: Snerk for not doing an ISO of Csargo.
Csargo is super evil. I feel it in the force.
No comment. I plead the fifth. Help, help I'm being repressed.
El Barto
04-11-2018, 23:43
He said all that without an ISO to back it up so I'm not moving my vote. The Random Number Gods command it.
Montmorency
04-12-2018, 00:21
No comment. I plead the fifth. Help, help I'm being repressed.
So you're against the violence inherent to the system, eh? Sounds like a slip.
Time to stir the hornet's nest.
Vote: Zack
Zack-Csargo-Snoke
GeneralHankerchief
04-12-2018, 00:50
Vote: Manasi
~:handball:
Lock town
Also not much of a fan of Monty so far.
Montmorency
04-12-2018, 00:54
Will you tell us, Bothan? Tell us what we need to know?
“But I don’t know!” Zack cried. “I know nothing of what you ask!”
Effortlessly, the Stormtrooper snapped Csargo's tether, and hoisted him before him, held him as though he were a doll. Snerk shrieked,
“Papa! Papa!”
Once again the question thundered through Zack's soul. He wept, tore at the turf.
“I don’t know! I don’t know!”
Beneath the huge trooper's gauntlets, Csargo went very still, like a calf caught in the jaws of a wolf. His terrified eyes turned from Zack, and rolled upwards beneath their lids, as though trying to peer at the figure behind him.
“Csargo!” Aëngelas screamed. “Csaargoooo!”
Animal violence overcame Zack , and he strained at his leash, gagged inarticulate fury.
And a husky voice in his soul said: You will come to know the power of the Dark Side …
“Beaaassee!” Zack wept. “I don’t knoooowww …”
The Dark Side …
“I don’t know! I don’t! I don’t! Beaase stop! Beaasse!”
Zack crumpled, grasped his head between his hands, beat his face against the turf.
The cold felt good against his broken lips.
And again they asked the question.
I don’t know …
These things make you weak, the Imperial Officer said, watching his soldier tossing Csargo like a sack to cold grasses. With a look, he gave him to the slavers. Once again, he asked the question.
The monster then gave his weeping son—sweet, innocent Snerk—to the slavers, and once again asked the question.
I don’t know what you mean …
Always, the same mad, incomprehensible question.
Who are the Rebellion?
GeneralHankerchief
04-12-2018, 00:58
Vote: Monty
Montmorency
04-12-2018, 00:58
BTW I was going for spicy, not mean guys. Sorry.
It was stylistically designed to be harsh, and I couldn't undo that, but I tried to diminish the effects of it (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oGRv8Zu1fU8). :creep:
So you're against the violence inherent to the system, eh? Sounds like a slip.
Time to stir the hornet's nest.
Vote: Zack
Zack-Csargo-Snoke
https://i.imgur.com/KHRGG8f.gif
Lock town
Also not much of a fan of Monty so far.
Why not?
BTW I was going for spicy, not mean guys. Sorry.
It was stylistically designed to be harsh, and I couldn't undo that, but I tried to diminish the effects of it (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oGRv8Zu1fU8). :creep:
https://i.imgur.com/h8cj7iF.jpg
Montmorency
04-12-2018, 01:30
https://i.imgur.com/h8cj7iF.jpg
Come to think of it, isn't this pocketing?
Come to think of it, isn't this pocketing?
https://i.imgur.com/fYAUu0L.gif
El Barto
04-12-2018, 02:08
Will you tell us, Bothan? Tell us what we need to know?
“But I don’t know!” Zack cried. “I know nothing of what you ask!”
Effortlessly, the Stormtrooper snapped Csargo's tether, and hoisted him before him, held him as though he were a doll. Snerk shrieked,
“Papa! Papa!”
Once again the question thundered through Zack's soul. He wept, tore at the turf.
“I don’t know! I don’t know!”
Beneath the huge trooper's gauntlets, Csargo went very still, like a calf caught in the jaws of a wolf. His terrified eyes turned from Zack, and rolled upwards beneath their lids, as though trying to peer at the figure behind him.
“Csargo!” Aëngelas screamed. “Csaargoooo!”
Animal violence overcame Zack , and he strained at his leash, gagged inarticulate fury.
And a husky voice in his soul said: You will come to know the power of the Dark Side …
“Beaaassee!” Zack wept. “I don’t knoooowww …”
The Dark Side …
“I don’t know! I don’t! I don’t! Beaase stop! Beaasse!”
Zack crumpled, grasped his head between his hands, beat his face against the turf.
The cold felt good against his broken lips.
And again they asked the question.
I don’t know …
These things make you weak, the Imperial Officer said, watching his soldier tossing Csargo like a sack to cold grasses. With a look, he gave him to the slavers. Once again, he asked the question.
The monster then gave his weeping son—sweet, innocent Snerk—to the slavers, and once again asked the question.
I don’t know what you mean …
Always, the same mad, incomprehensible question.
Who are the Rebellion?
Give us more.
Montmorency
04-12-2018, 02:32
Give us more.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9VPCm_LJYGA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdphvuyaV_I
Alright, that's enough pop culture for one round. Floor is open.
Vote: GH
I feel it in my soul. Honest.
El Barto
04-12-2018, 05:50
Vote: GH
I feel it in my soul. Honest.
Feeling the call of the random number gods is most compelling evidence that you actually do have a soul.
So you're saying he's Town? Smells like a slip.
These are not the scums you're looking for.
Vote: GH
I feel it in my soul. Honest.
GH lock scum. Vote: GH
Current Vote Tally
2 - GH (Csargo, Snerk)
1 - Snerk (Barto)
1 - Manasi (Zack)
1 - Zack (Monty)
1 - Monty (GH)
Not voting/Posting: Lex-Kat, Manasi, Sooh
Live Long and Prosper
I ALMOST FORGOT THIS GAME EXISTED OMG!
Hi :D
I ISOed Csargo.
Pretty sure he's a bad boy.
Vote: Csargo
GeneralHankerchief
04-12-2018, 16:44
Why not?
It just feels like theater from him (more than usual, anyway). There wasn't any real hint of, like, that townie paranoia.
I think I'm finally being able to get a bead on Monty after all these years of not being able to so I want to explore the feeling and see if I'm right.
GeneralHankerchief
04-12-2018, 16:45
I ALMOST FORGOT THIS GAME EXISTED OMG!
Hi :D
I ISOed Csargo.
Pretty sure he's a bad boy.
Vote: Csargo
I know that part of this is playing into the joke, but is any bit of the vote legitimate?
I know that part of this is playing into the joke, but is any bit of the vote legitimate?
No.
GeneralHankerchief
04-12-2018, 16:57
No.
Dang.
Any legitimate impressions so far?
I ALMOST FORGOT THIS GAME EXISTED OMG!
Hi :D
I ISOed Csargo.
Pretty sure he's a bad boy.
Vote: Csargo
https://media.giphy.com/media/l0Iye4ixa0pANa3yU/giphy.gif
Dang.
Any legitimate impressions so far?
Not really. I just hurried to post to tell you all that I exist still. Going to have to read again. My eyes started glossing over when I saw Monty's.... whatever that was.
Hellooooo.
Thanks Zack xoxo
GH weird so far, feels too easy to push on to Monty.
Csargo null, Zack lock town.
Sooh's already posted more than I expected (xD) so probably okay with her right now.
Overlooked everyone else, I'm in the middle of a JJ episode I'll be back after a phone call love you guys
It just feels like theater from him (more than usual, anyway). There wasn't any real hint of, like, that townie paranoia.
I think I'm finally being able to get a bead on Monty after all these years of not being able to so I want to explore the feeling and see if I'm right.
Outside of that one post, he seems fairly similar to usual. A bit more engaging than last game though, which is interesting.
Hellooooo.
Thanks Zack xoxo
GH weird so far, feels too easy to push on to Monty.
Csargo null, Zack lock town.
Sooh's already posted more than I expected (xD) so probably okay with her right now.
Overlooked everyone else, I'm in the middle of a JJ episode I'll be back after a phone call love you guys
https://media.giphy.com/media/2CdwFeWTJ2xFK/giphy.gif
Hellooooo.
Thanks Zack xoxo
GH weird so far, feels too easy to push on to Monty.
Csargo null, Zack lock town.
Sooh's already posted more than I expected (xD) so probably okay with her right now.
Overlooked everyone else, I'm in the middle of a JJ episode I'll be back after a phone call love you guys
If it wasn't clear, I dislike this post in particular.
green apple is best apple btw.
It just feels like theater from him (more than usual, anyway). There wasn't any real hint of, like, that townie paranoia.
I think I'm finally being able to get a bead on Monty after all these years of not being able to so I want to explore the feeling and see if I'm right.
:inquisitive:
I waited 15 minutes to log into Hearthstone for the new expansion, then it crashed once I finally got in and now I have to wait again. :wall:
Vote: GH
Vote: unvote
Vote: Manasi
Did I get the formalities right?
Just got off probably the most useless phone call of my life.
this is probably how zack feels whenever i call him
SAD!
Doing a more indepth run through now so y'all can get a taste of my god reads.
GeneralHankerchief
04-12-2018, 18:47
:inquisitive:
You disagree?
Also something something third vote on the wagon probably nothing but still sideeying it a bit.
Lock town
Also not much of a fan of Monty so far.
Why? It seemed like pretty random posting which I would expect is normal from ~everyone in this game.
You don't seem to be memeing so pardon me if I misread a SHITPOST as a real post.
:dizzy2:
Sooh and Lex-Kat. Sup?
Why didn't you ping me I hadn't posted at this point either? :(
If Snerk flips mafia one of his partners is in here PROTIP
It just feels like theater from him (more than usual, anyway). There wasn't any real hint of, like, that townie paranoia.
I think I'm finally being able to get a bead on Monty after all these years of not being able to so I want to explore the feeling and see if I'm right.
Ignore my post asking for elaboration thank u GH
Still think it's a bad read.
Outside of that one post, he seems fairly similar to usual. A bit more engaging than last game though, which is interesting.
Csargo so towny oh MY GODDDDDD.
GeneralHankerchief
04-12-2018, 18:50
Why? It seemed like pretty random posting which I would expect is normal from ~everyone in this game.
You don't seem to be memeing so pardon me if I misread a SHITPOST as a real post.
:dizzy2:
The lock town bit was me messing around but the Monty bit was real.
And I do like your Snerk bit in the post after this (don't feel like quoting it).
Okay I'm here.
Town: Zack/Csargo
Mafia: GH
teehee
Why didn't you ping me I hadn't posted at this point either? :(
If Snerk flips mafia one of his partners is in here PROTIP
Because you're unworthy! /hisses
GeneralHankerchief
04-12-2018, 18:52
Okay I'm here.
Town: Zack/Csargo
Mafia: GH
teehee
I suppose I'm owed a misread after thinking you were the most likely Csargo partner last game.
Because you're unworthy! /hisses
Legit tho y
That's scummy as shit my dude
Sooh saying there isn't enough to go off when I've already solved half of the game smh
Can I rep the org in champs
That's scummy as shit my dude
It is nicht. I didn't ping you because you're incapable of inactivity.
It is nicht. I didn't ping you because you're incapable of inactivity.
I believe this is a made up reason but god damn is a good made up reason.
Why do you think it's made up?
Csargo so towny oh MY GODDDDDD.
Do you think so? Why? I'd say this is sub-par if I'm honest.
I waited 15 minutes to log into Hearthstone for the new expansion, then it crashed once I finally got in and now I have to wait again. :wall:
Vote: GH
Get wrecked.
Sooh saying there isn't enough to go off when I've already solved half of the game smh
+1 scum point
Why do you think it's made up?
Uhhhhh.
It's too sassy. Or something.
Idfk.
Do you think so? Why? I'd say this is sub-par if I'm honest.
Because we're having the same thoughts.
+1 scum point
nvm we not melding anymore u ded bitch
nvm we not melding anymore u ded bitch
https://media.giphy.com/media/EWdsP9gHR9OFy/giphy.gif
Unvote: GH, Vote: Manasi
I suppose I'm owed a misread after thinking you were the most likely Csargo partner last game.
Don't bring up the past GH, please, it hurts.
Uhhhhh.
It's too sassy. Or something.
Idfk.
Fair enough I guess.
You disagree?
Also something something third vote on the wagon probably nothing but still sideeying it a bit.
I struggle to see how that read could have been genuine :yes:
https://media.giphy.com/media/EWdsP9gHR9OFy/giphy.gif
Unvote: GH, Vote: Manasi
LMfao do you actually have a scum read on me
Legit tho y
That's scummy as shit my dude
:crazy:
It's a good thing this wagon is forming now so it has time to fizzle out before EOD. :2thumbsup:
:crazy:
Who me
Is it that weird
Idk
He pinged two out of three 0 posters
Whatever
Who me
Is it that weird
Idk
He pinged two out of three 0 posters
Whatever
Why would it be suspicious unless you think he's slipping that he's a wolf with you or something? Bizarre to call it wolfy fypov.
Why would it be suspicious unless you think he's slipping that he's a wolf with you or something? Bizarre to call it wolfy fypov.
Meh, dunno. First thought was that he was trying to get one of his partners to start posting by slipping them in with another 0 poster. Still think it could be the case.
so bizarre
Did I ever ask why you have my uncle as your org pic?
LMfao do you actually have a scum read on me
Yeah, I do. For various reasons. All of them really good ones as well. The best reasons really.
Meh, dunno. First thought was that he was trying to get one of his partners to start posting by slipping them in with another 0 poster. Still think it could be the case.
so bizarre
Pullin a GH eh? Why would you assume that was the case? Honestly. I can't finish my thought gg class.
Montmorency
04-12-2018, 23:54
There was one fatal problem with GH's post. Yes, he mischaracterized my style - I don't usually do paranoid on D1 - but that was not the worst of it. This is him making a serious case like that hardly 10 posts into the game. Agenda much?
Vote: GH
Be aware this is again a 3-vote wagon.
I also see Manasi and Csargo are back to normal. Manasi over Csargo. Don't kills meh.
El Barto
04-12-2018, 23:55
Be aware this is again a 3-vote wagon.
Vote for whomever is third on the bandwaggon and you'll find a mafioso. Supposedly.
Vote for whomever is third on the bandwaggon and you'll find a mafioso. Supposedly.
https://i.imgur.com/M6WLRou.gif
Unvote: , Vote: Monty
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 00:30
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MC9AjN5l4Gs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MC9AjN5l4Gs
https://i.imgur.com/QFDkukK.gif
El Barto
04-13-2018, 01:14
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MC9AjN5l4Gs
Are you hardclaiming Palpatine? ;)
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 01:20
Are you hardclaiming Palpatine? ;)
From a certain point of view, I am softclaiming.
El Barto
04-13-2018, 01:59
I wish I had a role that enabled me to call you a meatbag for that.
Wow, you guys chat a lot.
Sorry I haven't done anything yet. I'm still trying to get back into the swing of coming to this forum on a regular basis.
So, um, for now I'll Vote: Zack. He was third for the votes on GH, until Snerk abandoned wagon.
<tbody>
Player
Votes
By
Csargo
I
Sooh
El Barto
GeneralHankerchief
II
Montmorency, Zack
Lex-Kat
Manasi
I
Snerk
Montmorency
II
Csargo, GeneralHankerchief
Snerk
I
El Barto
Sooh
Zack
I
Lex-Kat
</tbody>
Did I miss Manasi's vote? :confused:
Oh! And sorry I edited the post. The table just looks better with a border.
El Barto
04-13-2018, 05:34
From a certain point of view you should be WoG'ed and banned from any further games for a year.
And I don't know you well enough to know if you are joking. If so... ha ha? :confused: If not... ~:rolleyes:
Hellooooo.
Thanks Zack xoxo
GH weird so far, feels too easy to push on to Monty.
Csargo null, Zack lock town.
Sooh's already posted more than I expected (xD) so probably okay with her right now.
Overlooked everyone else, I'm in the middle of a JJ episode I'll be back after a phone call love you guys
Wait. How have I already posted more than you expected?
Sooh saying there isn't enough to go off when I've already solved half of the game smh
In my defense I said that before you posted :P
Hi Lex
Have we played together before?
Idk but here's me trying: Were I mafia I'd try (and fail) to emulate Zack's approach to this d1. Not too vocal, not too confrontational, while pointing out some flaws in some arguments. unvote, vote: Zack. It's my guess for the d1 vote.
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 10:53
So it's like I thought. What it amounts to is most everyone holding back. That suggests 3 Mafia and a healthy PR mix. No one wants to commit. And don't be fooled by the post count, it's mostly frittering by Manasi, Csargo, and I. I don't know what scum-Manasi would be trying to achieve (other than a general thread-orientation and mood) by her posting, but Manasi clearly looks more like 2017 scum-Manasi than anything. (Honestly Csargo hasn't done much to differentiate from last game, but patience is warranted.)
Csargo
Zack
Sooh
Snerk
Barto
are all playing studiously null.
Unfortunately, GH is not present enough to make me comfortable toward EOD. I had hoped he would bring some activity and clarify the direction of the round.
100% there is going to be a sudden, Mafia-driven flurry of late-day activity and we won't have a good base from the rest of the day to navigate it. And I'm only sporadically available at EOD.
So it's like I thought.
I thought it first!
What it amounts to is most everyone holding back.
If I had something I'd give it.
That suggests 3 Mafia and a healthy PR mix.
Why?
Unfortunately, GH is not present enough to make me comfortable toward EOD. I had hoped he would bring some activity and clarify the direction of the round.
Clarify the direction of the round? Really?
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 11:22
Interesting vote by Snerk.
Here's a tally (please check this) and a summary of day activity to guide us:
2 - GH (Zack, Monty)
2 - Monty (GH, Csargo)
2 - Zack (LexKat, Snerk)
1 - Snerk (Barto)
1 - Csargo (Sooh)
NO VOTE (Manasi)
*Game begins. Barto makes first vote on Snerk. Zack votes Manasi. Monty susses Snerk and Csargo on basis of flavor and their word choice, votes Zack. GH emerges:
Lock town
Also not much of a fan of Monty so far.
Monty posts flavor text about Csargo-Snerk-Zack team, prompting GH to vote him. Csargo questions this and votes GH, feeling it "in [his] soul". Snerk follows suit voting onto GH, pings Sooh and LK.
*Sooh appears and votes Csargo. GH asks whether her vote is legitimate, she claims not.
*Manasi arrives for tweetstorm. GH is shady for push on Monty, Csargo null, Zack lock town. Sooh's posting makes her OK.
*Csargo dislikes Manasi's entrance; on GH vs. Monty:
Outside of that one post, he seems fairly similar to usual. A bit more engaging than last game though, which is interesting.
*Zack appears and finds GH's case disingenuous. Zack (voting Manasi) switches onto GH and Snerk (voting GH) switches onto Manasi
GH quips about Zack being third on wagon
*Manasi's storm: Challenges GH on Monty. If Snerk flips mafia one of his partners is Sooh or Lex-Kat. Csargo now so towny. Zack/Csargo Town, GH scum. Banter between Snerk and Manasi, Snerk sussed for pinging 2 of 3 0-posters, earmark (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?153343-Star-Wars-Rebels-In-Play&p=2053775769&viewfull=1#post2053775769) for Zack challenging Manasi on bizarreness of scumread. Csargo towny because mindmeld.
*GH weakly defends probity and seriousness of Monty case, reps Manasi for partner analysis of Snerk
*Csargo asks Manasi about town read, feels his own play is sub-par, tells Zack to get wrecked for voting GH. Gives Manasi scumpoint for claiming to have solved game, Manasi reacts negatively, Csargo switches from GH to Manasi
Don't bring up the past GH, please, it hurts.
*Manasi on Manasi wagon:
LMfao do you [Csargo] actually have a scum read on me
It's a good thing this wagon is forming now so it has time to fizzle out before EOD. :2thumbsup:
Yeah, I do. For various reasons. All of them really good ones as well. The best reasons really.
Pullin a GH eh? Why would you assume that was the case? Honestly. I can't finish my thought gg class.
*Monty appears and switches from Zack to GH, becoming next third-on-wagon
*
Vote for whomever is third on the bandwaggon and you'll find a mafioso. Supposedly.
Csargo switches from Manasi to Monty
*Monty banter about claiming with Barto
*LK emerges, offers tally, votes Zack, banters with Barto
*Sooh responds to Manasi's mentions of her, greets LK
*Snerk switches from Manasi to Zack
Idk but here's me trying: Were I mafia I'd try (and fail) to emulate Zack's approach to this d1. Not too vocal, not too confrontational, while pointing out some flaws in some arguments. unvote, vote: Zack. It's my guess for the d1 vote.
Re: Csargo, he claimed a solid scumread on Manasi and then without commentary voted me as soon as I voted GH. Seems salient.
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 11:28
I thought it first!
If I had something I'd give it.
Why?
Clarify the direction of the round? Really?
As we've seen in Org games, thread activity has certain thresholds and feedback loops. If there's a low level of activity and for reasons of personal or team strategy people hold their cards close, there's not a spark to get a real train of discussion going. And Logic brought up the possibility of 3 scum and role semi-madness in the setup. I think this thread is what manifests in that scenario. Certainly I'm comparing against the back-to-back small game we just had.
What do you mean? Without GH giving his take on the scene, pushing back on his wagon, suggests rapid revisions in the game state are possible only in late-day commitments. This may be emerging already with the Zack wagon.
The troublesome thing is that it will be very hard to tell what's going on while it's going on.
So it's like I thought. What it amounts to is most everyone holding back. That suggests 3 Mafia and a healthy PR mix. No one wants to commit. And don't be fooled by the post count, it's mostly frittering by Manasi, Csargo, and I. I don't know what scum-Manasi would be trying to achieve (other than a general thread-orientation and mood) by her posting, but Manasi clearly looks more like 2017 scum-Manasi than anything. (Honestly Csargo hasn't done much to differentiate from last game, but patience is warranted.)
Csargo
Zack
Sooh
Snerk
Barto
are all playing studiously null.
Unfortunately, GH is not present enough to make me comfortable toward EOD. I had hoped he would bring some activity and clarify the direction of the round.
100% there is going to be a sudden, Mafia-driven flurry of late-day activity and we won't have a good base from the rest of the day to navigate it. And I'm only sporadically available at EOD.
So where is everyone else in your list?
Interesting vote by Snerk.
Here's a tally (please check this) and a summary of day activity to guide us:
2 - GH (Zack, Monty)
2 - Monty (GH, Csargo)
2 - Zack (LexKat, Snerk)
1 - Snerk (Barto)
1 - Csargo (Sooh)
NO VOTE (Manasi)
*Game begins. Barto makes first vote on Snerk. Zack votes Manasi. Monty susses Snerk and Csargo on basis of flavor and their word choice, votes Zack. GH emerges:
Monty posts flavor text about Csargo-Snerk-Zack team, prompting GH to vote him. Csargo questions this and votes GH, feeling it "in [his] soul". Snerk follows suit voting onto GH, pings Sooh and LK.
*Sooh appears and votes Csargo. GH asks whether her vote is legitimate, she claims not.
*Manasi arrives for tweetstorm. GH is shady for push on Monty, Csargo null, Zack lock town. Sooh's posting makes her OK.
*Csargo dislikes Manasi's entrance; on GH vs. Monty:
*Zack appears and finds GH's case disingenuous. Zack (voting Manasi) switches onto GH and Snerk (voting GH) switches onto Manasi
GH quips about Zack being third on wagon
*Manasi's storm: Challenges GH on Monty. If Snerk flips mafia one of his partners is Sooh or Lex-Kat. Csargo now so towny. Zack/Csargo Town, GH scum. Banter between Snerk and Manasi, Snerk sussed for pinging 2 of 3 0-posters, earmark (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?153343-Star-Wars-Rebels-In-Play&p=2053775769&viewfull=1#post2053775769) for Zack challenging Manasi on bizarreness of scumread. Csargo towny because mindmeld.
*GH weakly defends probity and seriousness of Monty case, reps Manasi for partner analysis of Snerk
*Csargo asks Manasi about town read, feels his own play is sub-par, tells Zack to get wrecked for voting GH. Gives Manasi scumpoint for claiming to have solved game, Manasi reacts negatively, Csargo switches from GH to Manasi
*Manasi on Manasi wagon:
*Monty appears and switches from Zack to GH, becoming next third-on-wagon
*
Csargo switches from Manasi to Monty
*Monty banter about claiming with Barto
*LK emerges, offers tally, votes Zack, banters with Barto
*Sooh responds to Manasi's mentions of her, greets LK
*Snerk switches from Manasi to Zack
Re: Csargo, he claimed a solid scumread on Manasi and then without commentary voted me as soon as I voted GH. Seems salient.
You seem to misunderstand my humor, which is okay, it's pretty bad tbh. I don't have a solid scumread on anyone at the moment. I thought Manasi deserved more scrutiny than she got in regards to her Snerk comments, the whole thing was odd to me, plus she didn't even vote, very non-committal. I'm not a fan. It's like what GH did but worse imo.
Current Vote Tally (as of Post #100)
2 - GH (Zack #40, Monty #78)
2 - Monty (GH #14, Csargo #80)
2 - Zack (Lex-Kat #86, Snerk #94)
1 - Snerk (Barto #7)
1 - Csargo (Sooh #28)
Not voting: Manasi
Live Long and Prosper
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 14:02
So where is everyone else in your list?
I've mentioned everyone except Lex-Kat (LK), who has just the one introductory post of substance.
You seem to misunderstand my humor, which is okay, it's pretty bad tbh. I don't have a solid scumread on anyone at the moment. I thought Manasi deserved more scrutiny than she got in regards to her Snerk comments, the whole thing was odd to me, plus she didn't even vote, very non-committal. I'm not a fan. It's like what GH did but worse imo.
So you're fine with lynching in Manasi, GH, Monty?
Live Long and Prosper
Uh oh. Crunchy moments.
I've mentioned everyone except Lex-Kat (LK), who has just the one introductory post of substance.
So you're fine with lynching in Manasi, GH, Monty?
Uh oh. Crunchy moments.
Ah, I must have glanced over that then.
I'm fine with lynching anyone at this point. There's no one that has stood out as particularly townie from my perspective. Of the people playing I'm most suspicious of Manasi, GH, Zack, and you so far. The rest are null really.
I've got a test in about and hour, but I should be back before EoD hopefully. I'll reassess then, hopefully people with be around.
Hi Lex
Have we played together before?
I don't think so? :inquisitive: I only posted for one other game here, back in 2015, and I failed to play. :shame: I am trying to be better about it this time.
And since that means I am an unknown on this site, I will try to rectify that... somewhat. I am a quiet player. I don't try to make a lot of flashy posts about nothing just to talk. I usually respond to other posts.
I still think Zack is suspicious, but that could be said for a lot of players, since it is only Day 1, and it is hard to get a good read on anyone at the beginning of the game.
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 17:30
I'm catching up and will do a general "take on the thread" post once this is done, but for now I'm just letting everyone know that I'll be afk/on mobile for the weekend starting in 4 hours and my activity level will be spotty at best.
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 17:34
Oh crap, didn't realize we had under 30 minutes. That can wait. Will try to get it in regardless.
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 17:35
Monty, it's fair to say that you've been fairly active this round, and I appreciate your summary of the game, but the thing that strikes me about it is that there aren't really any conclusions. In my experience I find a lot of narration without much opinion tacked on is a mafia trait, because it looks like you're doing something when you're actually not. So, if you're around, my main question would be what conclusions you drew, if any, from that exercise?
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 17:48
Ok, let's briefly talk about the other leading wagon, Zack.
I'll first preface this by saying that I historically do not have a good read on Zack. And FWIW it goes both ways, which I think he'll freely admit. Secondly, he has a lack of commentary in general this phase. The only things we've seen from him are a) his being skeptical of my case on Monty, and b) his being skeptical of Manasi's case on Snerk. This is kind of interesting because I think both Manasi and myself are the people he's most friendly/comfortable with in general in this game.
So what does this mean? First of all, it's not nearly enough data for me to be able to read him accurately. It doesn't really strike me as odd the fact that he's singling out both Manasi and me to interact with; if he was only gonna do it to two people I would expect we be the two. I do think town!Zack would work to develop a more holistic take of the gamestate in general so I'm a bit worried that he hasn't, but that could also just be a general lack of enthusiasm on his part and him not really being fully in the game yet.
It's not enough for me to be fully comfortable with placing a vote on Zack yet. I might do it for self-pres reasons but I'm also ok with risking a rand to get the person who I feel is more likely to flip guilty - Monty. Especially considering that I'm not going to be around much for D2 (but I'll be fine on D3 should we get there).
-------
So my suggestions, should I die, are as follows:
- Hold Zack's feet to the fire. Get him to give takes on everybody, not just the usual suspects.
- Csargo is probably town, let him do his thing.
- Manasi is... uncertain? I really did like her Snerk take, regardless of its accuracy. I kind of want to see it explore it more. Further study required, see how she acts on D2. Gun to my head, town.
- Ask for Zack's take on Barto because apparently he's a better Barto reader than I am. See if it passes the smell test.
- Get Lex-Kat comfortable enough to let her do her thing. Don't worry L-K, Barto was joking. Probably.
- Just have Snerk keep getting into a groove. In spite of Manasi's case I kind of dug his most recent posts, I think he's trying to approach the game and figure it out in his own way.
Hm. Not sure what this makes the team. Not really going to worry about that right now.
I'll be around until EOD if anyone else is.
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 17:49
Monty, it's fair to say that you've been fairly active this round, and I appreciate your summary of the game, but the thing that strikes me about it is that there aren't really any conclusions. In my experience I find a lot of narration without much opinion tacked on is a mafia trait, because it looks like you're doing something when you're actually not. So, if you're around, my main question would be what conclusions you drew, if any, from that exercise?
That Mafia don't want to engage, unless Manasi is Mafia muddying the waters. There wasn't much to conclude about individual players, as I pointed out, especially you since you were absent after beginning of day.
2-2-2 is something you don't want to disrupt anyway, unless LK or Csargo are scum and set it up. But both being scum is unlikely, and scum wouldn't like to create a triple tie and I liked LK's entrance well enough.
Maybe I could see scum shying from taking up your case and voting me, thus making Zack the counter wagon. But that's something to investigate in hindsight.
I don't see much reason not to lynch you right now and let the night hat sort the rest. Unless you want to lynch Manasi?
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 17:51
That Mafia don't want to engage, unless Manasi is Mafia muddying the waters. There wasn't much to conclude about individual players, as I pointed out, especially you since you were absent after beginning of day.
2-2-2 is something you don't want to disrupt anyway, unless LK or Csargo are scum and set it up. But both being scum is unlikely, and scum wouldn't like to create a triple tie and I liked LK's entrance well enough.
Maybe I could see scum shying from taking up your case and voting me, thus making Zack the counter wagon. But that's something to investigate in hindsight.
I don't see much reason not to lynch you right now and let the night hat sort the rest. Unless you want to lynch Manasi?
So you think the mafia are basically in your pile of nulls then, plus me? For the most part the active people were townie?
I don't particularly want to lynch Manasi today, as outlined above.
-------
Also this really isn't much of anything but I think there's only two mafia and not 3 as someone pointed out.
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 17:53
I pointed that out. I think the evidence becomes clearer later, so it's just a possibility to entertain.
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 17:56
Vote: Manasi
On phone, so no more reasoning for this phase.
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 17:56
Zack vs. me. vs. Manasi. Wasn't expecting that.
Vote: Zack
Montmorency
04-13-2018, 17:57
Just to say: GH more likely to post himself clear with time
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 17:59
Actually not sure what I want to do here. Don't know how I feel about things all of a sudden.
3 - Zack (Lex-Kat #86, Snerk #94, GH #114)
2 - Manasi (Csargo #111, Monty #113)
1 - GH (Zack #40,)
1 - Snerk (Barto #7)
1 - Monty (GH #14)
1 - Csargo (Sooh #28)
Not voting - Manasi
Zack was lynched
“It's just something about the feel of their helmets on my fists.”
―Zeb
https://lumiere-a.akamaihd.net/v1/images/zeb-orellios-s3_1587d51d.jpeg?region=0%2C0%2C1560%2C878&width=600
Zack, you are Garazeb "Zeb" Orellios. You win when the Rebels have reached parity with the Empire.
You have the chance to recruit Agent Alexsandr Kallus to the Rebel Side.
Begin Night 1.
Since it'll be my weekend,
Night Ends APPROXIMATELY Live Long and Prosper
Csargo
El Barto
GeneralHankerchief
Lex-Kat
Manasi
Montmorency
Snerk
Sooh
You may Post
DEAD:
Zack, Day 1
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 18:15
Initial feeling is that the zack wagon is clean, assuming 2 mafia. If 3, less certain. Manasi CFD attempt skeeved me out a bit. Think Monty might be a little better looking than Csargo from it?
Also think Manasi looks decent ish just because she was a semi out of nowhere counterwagon attempt vs a flipped mafia.
Will have more later before I leave.
Initial feeling is that the zack wagon is clean, assuming 2 mafia. If 3, less certain. Manasi CFD attempt skeeved me out a bit. Think Monty might be a little better looking than Csargo from it?
Also think Manasi looks decent ish just because she was a semi out of nowhere counterwagon attempt vs a flipped mafia.
Will have more later before I leave.
Look at their interactions. The likelihood of them being scum together is pretty high imo. There's no way you cannot see that. I've been harping on Manasi for the better part of the entire phase, so I'm not sure why you're surprised my vote went there at EoD.
Honestly, no idea why Monty switched in the end, but Manasi was definitely worthy of voting there I think.
Wait wtf EOD was at 1 PM I'm sorry.
Also rip Zack :(
Sorry babe.
Yeah it's been a hectic day or two but I think everything I'm doing is within my villa range. Compare this game to the HS game and I think you'll see that. Don't really remember how Csargo was reading me that game but I do think I've been playing pretty similarly.
Wait lmao can we talk about this conversion thing or no because lmfao
Wait lmao can we talk about this conversion thing or no because lmfao
https://i.imgur.com/Hej7o3J.gif
Wait wtf EOD was at 1 PM I'm sorry.
Also rip Zack :(
Sorry babe.
Yeah it's been a hectic day or two but I think everything I'm doing is within my villa range. Compare this game to the HS game and I think you'll see that. Don't really remember how Csargo was reading me that game but I do think I've been playing pretty similarly.
You dun goofed.
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 19:38
Look at their interactions. The likelihood of them being scum together is pretty high imo. There's no way you cannot see that. I've been harping on Manasi for the better part of the entire phase, so I'm not sure why you're surprised my vote went there at EoD.
Honestly, no idea why Monty switched in the end, but Manasi was definitely worthy of voting there I think.
Disagree, I don't think Zack would have shaded Manasi like he did if they were partners. Feel like they would have hard townread each other and try to barrel through the game.
Also feel like Zack would have posted more too.
https://i.imgur.com/d4OjYe0.gif
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 20:00
:crazy:
Why would it be suspicious unless you think he's slipping that he's a wolf with you or something? Bizarre to call it wolfy fypov.
This is Zack shading Manasi, Csar (context is her bit on Snerk). It's not as strong as I initially thought but I'm still not sure mafia!Zack takes this approach with a partner.
This is Zack shading Manasi, Csar (context is her bit on Snerk). It's not as strong as I initially thought but I'm still not sure mafia!Zack takes this approach with a partner.
I mean it's so mild. To me it seems fairly likely with hindsight especially, but I'm not nearly as knowledgeable on either of their playstyles. Judging purely on how Zack approached this game, I'ma vote Monty tomorrow I think.
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 20:42
:crazy:
Why would it be suspicious unless you think he's slipping that he's a wolf with you or something? Bizarre to call it wolfy fypov.
I mean it's so mild. To me it seems fairly likely with hindsight especially, but I'm not nearly as knowledgeable on either of their playstyles. Judging purely on how Zack approached this game, I'ma vote Monty tomorrow I think.
I think that's definitely a good place to start.
Idk about the Manasi thing, I just... really think Zack would have played differently if that was the case.
Snerk also a good choice to look at - it was Manasi's going after Snerk that prompted Zack's shade.
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 20:42
Right, I need to clear my multiquote. Sorry.
GeneralHankerchief
04-13-2018, 20:46
Wow, you guys chat a lot.
Sorry I haven't done anything yet. I'm still trying to get back into the swing of coming to this forum on a regular basis.
So, um, for now I'll Vote: Zack. He was third for the votes on GH, until Snerk abandoned wagon.
<tbody>
Player
Votes
By
Csargo
I
Sooh
El Barto
GeneralHankerchief
II
Montmorency, Zack
Lex-Kat
Manasi
I
Snerk
Montmorency
II
Csargo, GeneralHankerchief
Snerk
I
El Barto
Sooh
Zack
I
Lex-Kat
</tbody>
Did I miss Manasi's vote? :confused:
I don't think so? :inquisitive: I only posted for one other game here, back in 2015, and I failed to play. :shame: I am trying to be better about it this time.
And since that means I am an unknown on this site, I will try to rectify that... somewhat. I am a quiet player. I don't try to make a lot of flashy posts about nothing just to talk. I usually respond to other posts.
I still think Zack is suspicious, but that could be said for a lot of players, since it is only Day 1, and it is hard to get a good read on anyone at the beginning of the game.
Lex-Kat is almost certainly town.
I think that's definitely a good place to start.
Idk about the Manasi thing, I just... really think Zack would have played differently if that was the case.
Snerk also a good choice to look at - it was Manasi's going after Snerk that prompted Zack's shade.
The problem with playing like that is once one dies their post's are scrutinized pretty heavily, so if you're buddy-buddy it's fairly obvious, of course I guess that's all WIFOM in the end though isn't it.
That's true. Maybe Manasi was right all along...
https://i.imgur.com/zF4gpzc.gif
Townish: GH, Lex.
If there's bussing it's Lex. A Zack lynch was looking unlikely when she voted for him, with only one vote and very little heat on him in general. If I or GH bussed, it's pretty ruthless. I don't think there was bussing though.
Scummish: Manasi, Barto, Monty
Manasi was shifty overall. Barto too, with minimal content.
If Monty is scum it could provide some answers to why the mafia seemed reluctant to try a more aggressive attempt at a mislynch.
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 00:06
Aces. I feel super good. We've got a few lock clears.
I was wrong about 3 scum. Zack had a conversion power. Makes sense now.
Snerk, you started the Zack wagon early in the day when there was no pressure on him. Pretending like LK is a likelier candidate for partner is NAGL.
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 00:09
Bye anyone want to claim Alexander Kallus?
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 00:14
Snerk, my apologies.
I had it mixed up. I thought you voted Zack after he voted GH for some reason. My bad.
:shame:
Snerk, you started the Zack wagon early in the day when there was no pressure on him. Pretending like LK is a likelier candidate for partner is NAGL.
No I dropped the vote a few hours before EOD. And it tied him for a lynch. Hardly no pressure.
El Barto
04-14-2018, 02:38
And I don't know you well enough to know if you are joking. If so... ha ha? :confused: If not... ~:rolleyes:
I was riffing on Monty's Palpatine impersonation.
Wait. How have I already posted more than you expected?
You mentioned Zelda recently so you can't be done playing that yet.
Vote:Manasi
Vote: Manasi
On phone, so no more reasoning for this phase.
The one at :53 and the other at :56, what the hell were you two doing?
Bye anyone want to claim Alexander Kallus?
Fishing for partners, man?
I was riffing on Monty's Palpatine impersonation.
You mentioned Zelda recently so you can't be done playing that yet.
The one at :53 and the other at :56, what the hell were you two doing?
Fishing for partners, man?
https://i.imgur.com/2HyHFQK.gif
https://i.imgur.com/1pogcs7.gif
I was wrong about 3 scum.
And I still find it suspicious that you thought there was three scum before Zack's flip. Can't elaborate on this, would bend some rules, the peeps will see it if they see it and make up their own minds.
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 11:28
I was riffing on Monty's Palpatine impersonation.
You mentioned Zelda recently so you can't be done playing that yet.
The one at :53 and the other at :56, what the hell were you two doing?
Fishing for partners, man?
Zack had a conversion power eligible just for Alexander Kallus. Whoever claims Alexander Kallus is lock clear. Therefore, it is in Town's best interest to have Alexander Kallus come forward.
And I still find it suspicious that you thought there was three scum before Zack's flip. Can't elaborate on this, would bend some rules, the peeps will see it if they see it and make up their own minds.
We'll talk about this in the morning.
I was on the right track with my analysis at EOD. The Mafia had a volatile situation in which they didn't want to interfere needlessly, with at best a tie looming between two townies (me and GH). I disagree with GH that scum-Zack doesn't interact with scum-Manasi that way, though it's not a strong indicator. And I don't think we can expect both scum to have very similar behavior, or else in theory GH would be the best candidate for D1 play most similar to Zack (excepting EOD). What Zack did, he shaded GH and voted him, and OTOH hand shaded Manasi with slightly more detail while not pushing her at all. At a time when Manasi was almost dominating the thread. Isn't this a common scum-play dichotomy to create deniability or misdirect instincts?
Csargo vs. Manasi: The way Csargo jumped at the CFD opportunity onto Manasi suggests that Csargo was trying to take heat off scum-Zack. If Manasi's flip does not end the game, Csargo is >75% scum.
IMO this is fine, because we never lynch inside:
Monty
GH
Snerk
Sooh
Lex-Kat (except LYLO)
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 17:58
Orbital strike incoming
Manasi look out
Hi Csargo
P.S. Sooh is Innocent Child again
Grand Admiral Thrawn
Admiral-sama! Notice me! :on_woo:
SOOH IS MECHANICALLY CLEAR DO NOT LYNCH
End of night 1.
Please do not post.
Update may take a while: posting from mobile
GeneralHankerchief was killed"Send a probe to investigate. All leads must be pursued."
―Kallus
https://lumiere-a.akamaihd.net/v1/images/agent-kallus-s3_46fb5ec2.jpeg?region=173%2C0%2C1333%2C751&width=600
General Hankerchief, you are Agent Alexsandr Kallus. You begin the game as team Empire, and win when both of the Rebels are eliminated. Or if successfully recruited by the Rebels, you win when the Rebels have reached parity with the Empire.
You are optionally recruitable to the rebel side.
Manasi was killed
“There are some things far more frightening than death.”
―The Inquisitor
https://lumiere-a.akamaihd.net/v1/images/The-Inquisitor_38078668.jpeg?region=0%2C0%2C1920%2C1080&width=600
Manasi, you are The Grand Inquisitor.
You are team Empire and win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.
You may select one player each night. You see if that player leaves, or if anyone visits your selected player.
Begin day 2
Csargo
El Barto
Lex-Kat
Montmorency
Snerk
Sooh
You may now post
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 18:40
Hmm. Well, not everything can go our way. :sweatdrop:
It has been a pleasure towning with you, GH. You will be avenged.
Csargo, what do you have to say for yourself?
I mean, I could ask you the same thing...
Sooh, can you confirm Monty's role claim on you?
As far as you saying I was trying to start a cfd, I just moved my vote to who I wanted to lynch at the time. There's no way I'd try to save Zack if I was scum there, because that's just a terrible idea, it has no chance of working when >50% of the players just post a couple times a day. That's just exposing yourself for <1% chance of success, it's foolhardy.
It's Csargo or Monty then. Mechanically I'm leaning Monty, tonewise I'm leaning Csargo.
Ooooooooooooooooooooooooor.....
vote: El Barto
what?
Also, Monty, do you feel like sharing how you were able to allegedly kill Manasi and clear Sooh in one night? You seem to have a lot more toys than I do.
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 19:26
As far as you saying I was trying to start a cfd, I just moved my vote to who I wanted to lynch at the time. There's no way I'd try to save Zack if I was scum there, because that's just a terrible idea, it has no chance of working when >50% of the players just post a couple times a day. That's just exposing yourself for <1% chance of success, it's foolhardy.
Kinda wifomy.
The only possibilities then are Barto and LK, and it would be gauche to suspect LK at this point.
It's Csargo or Monty then. Mechanically I'm leaning Monty, tonewise I'm leaning Csargo.
Ooooooooooooooooooooooooor.....
vote: El Barto
what?
Huh? I'm about as lock-clear as you can get.
Look, I get that Manasi probably had a watch on GH and knew his killer, so if we lose this game it's because I managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory again with my grandstanding.
But we're still heavy favorites to win.
Also, Monty, do you feel like sharing how you were able to allegedly kill Manasi and clear Sooh in one night? You seem to have a lot more toys than I do.
I started knowing Sooh's alignment. I'm her bodyguard.
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 19:29
BTW, if it's the "three scum" thing, I get what your'e saying, but it's just an error and not even GH realized it clearly.
Also this really isn't much of anything but I think there's only two mafia and not 3 as someone pointed out.
Huh? I'm about as lock-clear as you can get.
Well that's perhaps a stretch but you're not the best lynch today.
Csargo is. By quite a bit too. I doubt we'll get much out of this day phase tbh.
unvote, vote: Csargo
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 19:49
Well that's perhaps a stretch but you're not the best lynch today.
Csargo is. By quite a bit too. I doubt we'll get much out of this day phase tbh.
unvote, vote: Csargo
Everything in this post is :inquisitive:
Csargo Sooh El Barto Lex-Kat
Kinda wifomy.
The only possibilities then are Barto and LK, and it would be gauche to suspect LK at this point.
Huh? I'm about as lock-clear as you can get.
Look, I get that Manasi probably had a watch on GH and knew his killer, so if we lose this game it's because I managed to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory again with my grandstanding.
But we're still heavy favorites to win.
I started knowing Sooh's alignment. I'm her bodyguard.
Well, you can look at my past games. My actions are more bizarre as town than scum. My posting style is always very similar. Obviously you can use your own judgement though.
Sooh can confirm Monty's alignment, so once(if?) she shows up that'll be good, L-K and Snerk are good because of vote's on Zack, probably L-K more than Snerk, but that's just my opinion. That just leaves me and Barto basically.
There's two lynches left, choose wisely.
Everything in this post is :inquisitive:
In my country that face represent awe and respect. So thank you.
But Monty, who do you think we should lynch today and why?
BTW, if it's the "three scum" thing, I get what your'e saying, but it's just an error and not even GH realized it clearly.
I'm not sure what you're saying here, GH clearly knew there were only two mafia.
If Tak is mafia he can consider my feelings hurt for a lack of scum effort.
Montmorency
04-14-2018, 20:13
In my country that face represent awe and respect. So thank you.
But Monty, who do you think we should lynch today and why?
Your D2 so far, Csargo's D2 so far, and the fact I just killed our most important PR have kind of thrown me. I was planning on voting Csargo off the bat if Manasi's flip didn't end the game.
I'm not sure what you're saying here, GH clearly knew there were only two mafia.
You're saying he employed bathos? Maybe.
Anyway, the point is I didn't read the full rules.
Town wins when both mafia have been eliminated. Mafia wins when they reach parity with town, or parity is mechanically unavoidable.
11. Sample Role PM
“Make no mistake. From now on, failure will have consequences.”
―Tarkin
https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ7ggDHrGYWdZ6x3iYWuxWx-MtrdMXrofuRMa_CBc5AtJEJ7Htx
Player, you are Grand Moff Tarkin.
You are Vanilla Empire.
You win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.
Good luck, have fun, read the rules, PM me with any questions.
If Tak is mafia he can consider my feelings hurt for a lack of scum effort.
*Barto, not Tak.
Your D2 so far, Csargo's D2 so far, and the fact I just killed our most important PR have kind of thrown me.
You got to keep 'em guessing.
unvote, vote Barto
El Barto
04-14-2018, 22:00
Zack had a conversion power eligible just for Alexander Kallus. Whoever claims Alexander Kallus is lock clear. Therefore, it is in Town's best interest to have Alexander Kallus come forward.
You're not answering about your :53/:56 shenanigans with Csargo. Not that you can both be mafia, obviously, but still.
Oh, and now I get it about Alexander Kallus.
unvote, vote Barto
Oh I'll just quote you right back:
what?
Montmorency
04-15-2018, 04:34
Damned overconfidence.
OMGIS
'K whatevs, let's keep it simple
Vote: Barto
Or Csargo today
El Barto
04-15-2018, 05:23
Vote: Barto
Sorry -why?
Montmorency
04-15-2018, 05:24
You're scummy enough.
Start talking, maybe?
El Barto
04-15-2018, 05:41
You're scummy enough.
Start talking, maybe?
I am always scummy (see my signature for reference).
What do you want me to talk about? It's hard to defend against accusations when all you do is say ‘vote: El Barto’.
El Barto
04-15-2018, 06:07
OK, it's slightly-after-2-a.m. so I'm off to play videogames or sleep, whichever happens first.
C'mon, Monty, why do you keep dodging the question of why you suddenly piled on with Csargo? Let us say I believe you on Sooh, if you were going to kill Manasi anyway then why telegraph it like that?
btw why did Csargo do the sudden vote change?
It's simply mechanically impossible for both of you to be scummos trying to pocket Sooh, so what is going on?
Montmorency
04-15-2018, 06:27
OK, it's slightly-after-2-a.m. so I'm off to play videogames or sleep, whichever happens first.
C'mon, Monty, why do you keep dodging the question of why you suddenly piled on with Csargo? Let us say I believe you on Sooh, if you were going to kill Manasi anyway then why telegraph it like that?
btw why did Csargo do the sudden vote change?
It's simply mechanically impossible for both of you to be scummos trying to pocket Sooh, so what is going on?
Manasi CFD: Because I wasn't sure about lynching GH anymore and preferred Manasi dead. As the night results testify to.
Do you have anything whatsoever to say about the game course or the players? Minding that we have two lynches barring unforeseen role intervention, and that Csargo and Barto are the two scummiest players mechanically and possibly tonally, LK and Snerk (though acting egregiously today) have the Zack wagon to their credit, and Monty and Sooh are mechanically cleared?
In my country egregiously means witty and handsome.
Barto, whom do you think we should lynch today and why?
Also Monty, perhaps get down off your high horse? Let's recap your game:
-joins last ditch attempt to save a scum from the block d1 by voting for most valuable town role instead
-finishes the job n1 with a shifty kill nobody was asking for
-abandons all self made plans and votes Barto instead for d2
Knowing Sooh's ID (not yet confirmed) needn't be a lock town ability.
The thing that's most working to your favour is claiming a kill the same night GH was mafia killed.
El Barto
04-15-2018, 18:15
Manasi CFD: Because I wasn't sure about lynching GH anymore and preferred Manasi dead. As the night results testify to.
Yes, yes, I've already noticed that Manasi and GH are clear. btw why kill Manasi?
Do you have anything whatsoever to say about the game course or the players? Minding that we have two lynches barring unforeseen role intervention, and that Csargo and Barto are the two scummiest players mechanically and possibly tonally, LK and Snerk (though acting egregiously today) have the Zack wagon to their credit, and Monty and Sooh are mechanically cleared?
We need more posts. I'm not sure about a D1 lynch giving anybody much credit. It would've been too much for them to simply pull out on D1's EOD. OTOH this is a short/mini game so we could call D1 our F9.
In my country egregiously means witty and handsome.
Thanks for the free Swedish lesson. It will prove useful when visiting Finland soon™.
Barto, whom do you think we should lynch today and why?
You for entering cunicular mode and voting me with no excuse, Csargo for being shifty and not being me, Monty if Sooh doesn't show up to clear him up.
Where the hell is Sooh? Where's Lex-Kat? I can't get a read on people who don't post.
Montmorency
04-15-2018, 19:02
Also Monty, perhaps get down off your high horse? Let's recap your game:
-joins last ditch attempt to save a scum from the block d1 by voting for most valuable town role instead
-finishes the job n1 with a shifty kill nobody was asking for
-abandons all self made plans and votes Barto instead for d2
Knowing Sooh's ID (not yet confirmed) needn't be a lock town ability.
The thing that's most working to your favour is claiming a kill the same night GH was mafia killed.
I admitted all that a few posts up. So help me beat Mafia, I obviously can't do it on my own. Do you still believe
I doubt we'll get much out of this day phase tbh.
You got to keep 'em guessing.
Yes, yes, I've already noticed that Manasi and GH are clear. btw why kill Manasi?
We need more posts. I'm not sure about a D1 lynch giving anybody much credit. It would've been too much for them to simply pull out on D1's EOD. OTOH this is a short/mini game so we could call D1 our F9.
Thanks for the free Swedish lesson. It will prove useful when visiting Finland soon™.
You for entering cunicular mode and voting me with no excuse, Csargo for being shifty and not being me, Monty if Sooh doesn't show up to clear him up.
Where the hell is Sooh? Where's Lex-Kat? I can't get a read on people who don't post.
I figured it like this:
Mechanically, rule out everyone but Barto, Csargo, Manasi.
Kill one of them N1.
Killing Csargo or Barto tells us very little about interactions, but killing Manasi implicates Csargo if Manasi town (Csargo CFD to save Zack).
It went horribly wrong just because she was the PR she was. If Manasi were VT, you could have called it "collateral damage within tolerable limits". :creep:
You for entering cunicular mode and voting me with no excuse, Csargo for being shifty and not being me, Monty if Sooh doesn't show up to clear him up.
What is cunicular mode and does it unlock any new powers?
Anyway, saying you want to lynch everybody doesn't get us anywhere. Tell us your preferable lynch for today and we'll take it from there.
I admitted all that a few posts up. So help me beat Mafia, I obviously can't do it on my own.
https://media1.tenor.com/images/ea557837dedd2e731c44915ff0c641fd/tenor.gif?itemid=5878288
Here I am! And I can't believe I got a Rebel Scum!! :2thumbsup:
Okay, enough backpatting for my part. And I doubt I'll get lucky a second day. Who do we have left? Three dead, out of 9 players.
<tbody>
Player
Death
Role
Day 2 Vote(s)
By
Csargo
El Barto
II
Montmorency, Snerk
Lex-Kat
Montmorency
Snerk
Sooh
Manasi
Night 1
The Grand Inquisitor
GeneralHankerchief
Night 1
Agent Alexsandr Kallus
Zack
Day 1
Garazeb "Zeb" Orellios
</tbody>
I have no idea how to read what's been posted so far. Monty seems less scummy to me, for the moment. El Barto reminds me of a player from my home turf, Murska. Which makes me want to vote for him, just for that. ~D
Sooh is quieter than I am, so there is nothing to read there. But Snerk has jumped from El Barto to Csargo, then back again. He also comes from a strange country, evidently, that believes in strange things.
So I'll vote for Snerk.
Montmorency
04-15-2018, 19:39
LK, do you have any comment to make on the mechanical revelations?
Right, so scum Snerk on the job d1 goes something like this?:
"Few hours to EOD and all things pointing towards a mislynch. Nice"
"I know, why don't I out of the blue bus my only scum partner (and mafia recruiter!!) for no apparent reason whatsoever and tie him for a lynch. That'll be good"
"Woopsie :)"
He also comes from a strange country, evidently, that believes in strange things.
So I'll vote for Snerk.
In my country voting for someone in mafia games is a sign of affection ~:wave:
El Barto
04-15-2018, 20:32
In my country voting for someone in mafia games is a sign of affection ~:wave:
In that case then first I'll vote: Snerk and then i'll get on to answering Monty's posts.
btw Csargo is online upvoting posts but he isn't posting nor voting, so I'm highly tempted to vote for him instead.
El Barto
04-15-2018, 20:47
I figured it like this:
Mechanically, rule out everyone but Barto, Csargo, Manasi.
Kill one of them N1.
Killing Csargo or Barto tells us very little about interactions, but killing Manasi implicates Csargo if Manasi town (Csargo CFD to save Zack).
It went horribly wrong just because she was the PR she was. If Manasi were VT, you could have called it "collateral damage within tolerable limits". :creep:
OK, mechanically…
We have D1, Zack is lynched. Everybody still alive after D1 who voted for Zack is not mafia. That gives us three players cleared, plus (according to you) you yourself and Sooh. Three remain, i.e. yours truly, Manasi, Csargo.
Manasi and GH die so (always going by your reasoning)
a) can you be 100% sure that one of them didn't just get trapped into parking the vote rather than looking suspicious?
b) It is 100% sure that Sooh is cleared, I suppose?
c) why me over Csargo?
What is cunicular mode and does it unlock any new powers?
If you spoke Latin or had played with me earlier you'd know it means you're tunnelling.
Anyway, saying you want to lynch everybody doesn't get us anywhere. Tell us your preferable lynch for today and we'll take it from there.
On the basis of OMGUS, you tunnelling scum! and OMG-You're-now-in-the-lead-with-me I'd be happy to park my vote on you until dusk.
I have no idea how to read what's been posted so far. Monty seems less scummy to me, for the moment. El Barto reminds me of a player from my home turf, Murska. Which makes me want to vote for him, just for that. ~D
I haven't played with Murska in forever! We should get him here. But I don't agree with voting me.
Sooh is quieter than I am, so there is nothing to read there. But Snerk has jumped from El Barto to Csargo, then back again. He also comes from a strange country, evidently, that believes in strange things.
So I'll vote for Snerk.
!! Tempting.
Right, so scum Snerk on the job d1 goes something like this?:
"Few hours to EOD and all things pointing towards a mislynch. Nice"
"I know, why don't I out of the blue bus my only scum partner (and mafia recruiter!!) for no apparent reason whatsoever and tie him for a lynch. That'll be good"
"Woopsie :)"
This is the post in question Mr. pocketing Csargo has gone for.
So vote: Csargo.
In that case then first I'll vote: Snerk and then i'll get on to answering Monty's posts.
btw Csargo is online upvoting posts but he isn't posting nor voting, so I'm highly tempted to vote for him instead.
I'm just waiting for Sooh to confirm Monty's claims.
Also, I don't see the point of arguing when we're the de facto lynches the next two days. Since Monty shot someone.
El Barto
04-15-2018, 21:08
The point of arguing is that I know what my alignment is but I don't know yours so I'd rather lynch somebody who might just win us the game.
The point of arguing is that I know what my alignment is but I don't know yours so I'd rather lynch somebody who might just win us the game.
So, then what do you want to argue about?
El Barto
04-15-2018, 21:24
Lynching you over me?
Lynching you over me?
I mean, your first post in the thread was a vote on Snerk, and then all subsequent posts lacked any sort of substance and were mostly jokey. You never moved from Snerk, which is fine, but you weren't doing anything related to trying to progress any sort of reads, at least publicly.
You could say I did the same though, so we're still at the same impasse. I voted Manasi at the end of the round though, and you could say that was an attempt to save Zack. I pushed Manasi previously in the round though, so I feel like my move was justified at least somewhat by my previous statements, etc.
So basically it comes down to who people think is scummier.
It just comes down to the opinions of the four other players to decide that really.
Montmorency
04-15-2018, 21:54
https://youtu.be/OaPZHh7F1Rk?t=10m
If it weren't for all of D1, I would probably vote for Snerk.
Sooh
You're our only hope
Well I'm sorry I've rubbed you the wrong way today Monty. Perhaps I've had too much coffee. Or not enough coffee I dunno.
El Barto
04-16-2018, 01:20
You could say I did the same though, so we're still at the same impasse.
That's why I said ‘lynching you over me’.
That's why I said ‘lynching you over me’.
Sorry, my brain is mush today.
Basically, you'd lynch me because I've done more, which with hindsight looks far worse than your low-key coasting.
El Barto
04-16-2018, 01:44
Basically, you'd lynch me because I've done more
Nah, nah, your brain is really mush. I'd lynch you because you're not me and there's probably no other viable candidate at this point, with a town this inactive.
Nah, nah, your brain is really mush. I'd lynch you because you're not me and there's probably no other viable candidate at this point, with a town this inactive.
Look we've come full fucking circle mate. NO U!
Vote: El Barto
Montmorency
04-16-2018, 02:03
https://www.shutterstock.com/video/clip-1339804-stock-footage-an-older-woman-wringing-her-hands-as-if-very-anxious-or-worried.html
El Barto
04-16-2018, 02:37
Look we've come full fucking circle mate. NO U!
Vote: El Barto
Vote: Csargo then, for teh lulz.
Montmorency
04-16-2018, 03:35
Policy:
1. It would have been nuts for Snerk to pile onto Zack on D1, with minimal pressure on either of them, with Zack holding a conversion power, with only either 2 or 3 more day phases to survive. Not even Pizza would pull this type of crap.
2. If LK is scum, let her have her busing lurker victory
3. The mechanically simplest scenario involves lynching Barto and Csargo
We have nothing to fear but fear itself
El Barto
04-16-2018, 04:18
Policy:
1. It would have been nuts for Snerk to pile onto Zack on D1, with minimal pressure on either of them, with Zack holding a conversion power, with only either 2 or 3 more day phases to survive. Not even Pizza would pull this type of crap.
2. If LK is scum, let her have her busing lurker victory
3. The mechanically simplest scenario involves lynching Barto and Csargo
We have nothing to fear but fear itself
1) Snerk's not that good, so the odds are heavily in favour of your being right.
2) Why?
3) Csargo and Barto, I'd prefer.
I'm not good enough to play terrible? Well thank god for that.
Tally, I believe:
Snerk: Lex
Barto: Monty, Snerk, Csargo
Csargo: Barto
Tally update as of post # 198
3 - Barto (Snerk #162, Monty #164, Csargo #193)
1 - Snerk (Lex-Kat #175)
1 - Csargo (Barto #195)
Live Long and Prosper
Let's make it interesting unvote, vote: Csargo
2 - Barto (Monty #164, Csargo #193)
2 - Csargo (Barto #195, Snerk #200)
1 - Snerk (Lex-Kat #175)
El Barto was lynched.
“This is gonna be fun. Very fun.”
―Sabine Wren
http://starwarsblog.starwars.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/sabine-trials-of-the-darksaber-header-1536x864.jpg
El Barto, you are Sabine Wren. You win when the Rebels have reached parity with the Empire.
In lieu of the Rebel team kill, you may elect to send a player a mysterious package. The player receiving a mysterious package may elect to open it in lieu of their normal night action 1 night after receipt. If it is not opened, the player expires at the end of the day night phase after the choice has been made. Once per game, you may elect to send both the normal nightkill and the mysterious package in the same night. This does not stack with Zeb/Zack's recruitment ability.
THE EMPIRE WINS
Lex-Kat“Anakin Skywalker was weak. I destroyed him.”
―Darth Vader
https://www.agentsofgeek.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/vader-rebels-jpg.jpg
Lex-Kat, you are Darth Vader.
You are team Empire and win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.
When you are lynched, the person you are voting for may also be killed if you so choose.
"Attention rebel ship, this is Commander Vult Skerris of the Imperial Navy. You are harboring a traitor to the Empire, surrender immediately or be destroyed."
―Vult Skerris
https://lumiere-a.akamaihd.net/v1/images/vult-skerris_49dcdb57.jpeg?region=0%2C0%2C1560%2C878&width=600
Csargo, you are Vult Skerris.
You are team Empire, and win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.
You have 1x antidote, which cures any countdown kill abilities, usable only at night.
"It is true. I am the vaunted Imperial Ace, Baron Valen Rudor."
―Valen Rudor
https://lumiere-a.akamaihd.net/v1/images/image_d2970dc9.jpeg?region=0%2C0%2C1799%2C1012&width=600
Snerk, you are Baron Valen Rudor.
You are team Empire, and win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.
You have 1x antidote, which cures any countdown kill abilities, usable only at night.
I]"It will be done, Grand Admiral.” [/I]
―Rukh
https://lumiere-a.akamaihd.net/v1/images/rukh_511387d7.jpeg?region=0%2C0%2C1920%2C1080&width=600
Montmorency, you are Rukh.
You are team Empire, and win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.
You have a 1x Vigilante kill. You begin the game knowing the identity of Grand Admiral Thrawn. Thrawn does not know your identity.
“There are things in the universe that are simply and purely evil. A warrior does not seek to understand them, or to compromise with them. He seeks only to obliterate them.”
―Thrawn
https://lumiere-a.akamaihd.net/v1/images/grand-admiral-thrawn2_bda317f3.jpeg?region=0%2C0%2C1560%2C878&width=600
Sooh, you are Grand Admiral Thrawn.
You are on team Empire, and win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.
You have 2x poison. A poisoned player expires at the end of the following night phase if not cured. You may use a poison to cure someone of the poison condition.
Logic's thoughts
OK, so I fouled this up a bit. I thought the optional recruitment, ability to intentionally delay the nightkill, and the other powers would have made up for town's advantage, but it turns out you guys are just better at figuring things out than I thought. I sincerely apologize to anyone that feels that I hamstrung them, or served up an unfair game.
Excellent. I love a good town rompage. GG everybody and thanks to Logic for hosting.
OK, so I fouled this up a bit. I thought the optional recruitment, ability to intentionally delay the nightkill, and the other powers would have made up for town's advantage, but it turns out you guys are just better at figuring things out than I thought. I sincerely apologize to anyone that feels that I hamstrung them, or served up an unfair game.
Nonsense. Town got lucky with it's d1 lynch and used the momentum to steamroll. Stuff like that is hard to account for, even more so in small games.
GeneralHankerchief
04-16-2018, 18:49
GG all! :yes:
Game was fun but I do think there was maybe one or two many powers running around. Kind of hard to account for swinginess in a game this small. Thanks for hosting Logic! :bow:
Montmorency
04-16-2018, 18:56
GG Town, no thanks to me.
GH MVP
Sorry Manasi
Barto, you had to swing first because Csargo was just purer lately.
Get wrekt scum
TOWN IS BACK
Logic
THAT's really a lot of killing roles. If we hadn't lynched Barto today, would there even have been a lynch round afterwards, one way or another?
Also, weren't you using Zack's post-deadline vote tiebreaker method. Barto looks to have been lynched randomly.
Montmorency
04-16-2018, 18:58
9 players is too few for delayed NKs IMHO
GG Town, no thanks to me.
GH MVP
Sorry Manasi
Barto, you had to swing first because Csargo was just purer lately.
Get wrekt scum
TOWN IS BACK
Logic
THAT's really a lot of killing roles. If we hadn't lynched Barto today, would there even have been a lynch round afterwards, one way or another?
Also, weren't you using Zack's post-deadline vote tiebreaker method. Barto looks to have been lynched randomly.
I may be mistaken*, but I had thought that I stated "first past the post**" for tie votes. I shall have to go back and check my rule setup. My deadline for acceptable votes was 10:00 my time, so I'm not sure what tie-breaker method you were expecting.
9 players is too few for delayed NKs IMHO
Yup. I figured that out when the Rebels said the Mysterious Package was not really worthwhile.
C'est la vie. OR ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ if you prefer.
*I was not mistaken
**This was indeed the rule posted initially, and never changed.
GG Town, no thanks to me.
Nah. D1 and N1 was a toss-up and you handled D2 just fine. GG
El Barto
04-16-2018, 19:31
So my hunch that GH could be converted was right, my other hunch (that Manasi wouldn't be vigged) was not.
*sigh* I remain the sole mislynch of the current mafia season at the .org.
Logic: if you feel you've fouled up… nah, you didn't, not quite. The town lucked out by hitting Zack on the basis of… nothing at all, really. Masons might be overpowered in such a small game, but they never got to use their powers. Games this small give such strokes of luck too big an influence and it's fair (well, not really, seeing as I lost, but you get the point :clown:) to just give them the win sometimes.
So, all in all, thanks for hosting and, next time, just make it so that anybody voting for me dies the painful death they deserve.
Also, I'd like to take this opportunity to plug the Rebels show, and Csargo's wicked mustache. (https://i.imgur.com/c04W5dB.jpg)
El Barto
04-16-2018, 20:45
I'm just waiting for Sooh to confirm Monty's claims.
This never happened so I get a moral victory.
So my hunch that GH could be converted was right, my other hunch (that Manasi wouldn't be vigged) was not.
*sigh* I remain the sole mislynch of the current mafia season at the .org.
Logic: if you feel you've fouled up… nah, you didn't, not quite. The town lucked out by hitting Zack on the basis of… nothing at all, really. Masons might be overpowered in such a small game, but they never got to use their powers. Games this small give such strokes of luck too big an influence and it's fair (well, not really, seeing as I lost, but you get the point :clown:) to just give them the win sometimes.
So, all in all, thanks for hosting and, next time, just make it so that anybody voting for me dies the painful death they deserve.
GH basically put a big sign on himself, that he was convertible after that one post. I'm assuming that's what he was doing with it.
If GH wouldn't have voted Zack, I'm pretty sure town would have lost this game. GH 99% would have been converted, if they could kill as well, plus Monty vig game would have reached parity immediately. Well Monty might have shot a scum, so who knows max like 2 rounds it would have went.
Also, I'd like to take this opportunity to plug the Rebels show, and Csargo's wicked mustache. (https://i.imgur.com/c04W5dB.jpg)
My mustache won us this game imho.
This never happened so I get a moral victory.
Yeah, ggs Sooh.
Montmorency
04-17-2018, 00:59
GH basically put a big sign on himself, that he was convertible after that one post. I'm assuming that's what he was doing with it.
If GH wouldn't have voted Zack, I'm pretty sure town would have lost this game. GH 99% would have been converted, if they could kill as well, plus Monty vig game would have reached parity immediately. Well Monty might have shot a scum, so who knows max like 2 rounds it would have went.
GH softed? Where?
That's treason.
GH softed? Where?
That's treason.
When he said he was pretty sure there were only 2 mafia instead of three. No one could possibly know that except scum/convertible GH.
Montmorency
04-17-2018, 01:04
When he said he was pretty sure there were only 2 mafia instead of three. No one could possibly know that except scum/convertible GH.
Lol Snerk
No1 reads rulez n PMs
Town wins when both mafia have been eliminated. Mafia wins when they reach parity with town, or parity is mechanically unavoidable.
11. Sample Role PM
“Make no mistake. From now on, failure will have consequences.”
―Tarkin
https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ7ggDHrGYWdZ6x3iYWuxWx-MtrdMXrofuRMa_CBc5AtJEJ7Htx
Player, you are Grand Moff Tarkin.
You are Vanilla Empire.
You win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.
Good luck, have fun, read the rules, PM me with any questions.
Lol Snerk
No1 reads rulez n PMs
ggs...
Montmorency
04-17-2018, 01:27
ggs...
Good god's sake?
El Barto
04-17-2018, 01:37
Here (https://quicktopic.com/52/H/tkEUGpgMrym) is our quicktopic.
No, I didn't think GH had softed. It was really a spur-of-the-moment hunch.
GH basically put a big sign on himself, that he was convertible after that one post. I'm assuming that's what he was doing with it.
If GH wouldn't have voted Zack, I'm pretty sure town would have lost this game. GH 99% would have been converted, if they could kill as well, plus Monty vig game would have reached parity immediately. Well Monty might have shot a scum, so who knows max like 2 rounds it would have went.
GH softed? Where?
That's treason.
When he said he was pretty sure there were only 2 mafia instead of three. No one could possibly know that except scum/convertible GH.
For those of you curious, here it is:
Lock town
Also not much of a fan of Monty so far.
Sorry I disappeared after my last post. I lost power soon after, and didn't get it back until early morning next day.
Good game. I had fun. Thanks for inviting me, Logic. ☺
Sorry I disappeared after my last post. I lost power soon after, and didn't get it back until early morning next day.
Good game. I had fun. Thanks for inviting me, Logic. ☺
You're invited to the next one as well, assuming I get to host 2-in-a-row.
El Barto
04-17-2018, 04:37
Hey, I've just realised we haven't done an ISO of Csargo again.
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.