View Full Version : Historical sources
KLAssurbanipal
09-22-2019, 12:32
I found Hittites in one screen:
https://totalwar.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Hetyci-z-TWS-Troy.png
Some sources of units (screens) and heroes (box artwork), but Achilles and Hector (from trailer) have a fantasy look.
https://totalwar.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Mykeńczycy-z-TWS-Troy-1.png
Philippus Flavius Homovallumus
09-22-2019, 17:08
I found Hittites in one screen:
https://totalwar.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Hetyci-z-TWS-Troy.png
Some sources of units (screens) and heroes (box artwork), but Achilles and Hector (from trailer) have a fantasy look.
https://totalwar.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Mykeńczycy-z-TWS-Troy-1.png
Actually, Achilles and Hector are wearing variants of Archaic (as opposed to Mycenaean) armour - which makes a sort of sense, if this is based on Homer's epic as well as history.
22876
22877
Note the "bib" like Achilles is wearing.
See also: https://stefanosskarmintzos.wordpress.com/2012/02/19/the-early-archaic-hoplite/
Note the depiction of the full panoply there - you'll see the arm guard Achilles is wearing.
Hector's helmet seems to be modelled on the 8th Century find from Argos:
22878
Meanwhile, Hector's body armour is a composite type that has been speculated about for Archaic hoplite.
The only thing that's particularly fantastical is Achilles Helmet, and really only because the cheek pieces are hinged.
So, broadly speaking the two heros are depicted as historical elite "noble" hoplites from the Archaic period, as Homer and his audience would have imagined them.
KLAssurbanipal
09-22-2019, 19:23
Helmets, armours, shields, greaves of Achilles & Hector are fantasy. Some of them slightly refer to historical ones, but nothing is well imitated. However, we know from Rome 2 that CA can accurately reproduce discovered weapons and armours. Arm guards of Achilles look fantasy. I can't find any similar to them. Hector's helmet is completely differ that the 8th century helmet from Argos. Completely differ design and form. In my opinion this helmet is more similar to LotR/Warhammer Elves. I have few thousands photos of ancient armoury but I can't find their helmets, cuirasses, arm armours, greaves, shields (I accept only the Achilles shield based on Homer's description). I'm writing book "Historia uzbrojenia. Ilustrowana encyklopedia" (History of armament. Illustrated encyclopedia) in Polish language. The first volume is about ancient helmets.
https://totalwar.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/mm.png
Archaic full armour:
https://totalwar.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Archaic-hoplites-full.png
https://totalwar.org.pl/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/495115d80ee645efc37.15922048-TWS_TROY_Hero.png
Philippus Flavius Homovallumus
10-14-2019, 01:30
I've taken another look at the sources you posted and I think both Hector and Achilles are wearing a sort of mashup of sources.
Hector's body armour seems to be based on this: https://www.hellenicarmors.gr/en/armor/diomedes-armor/
I've seen a vase with a similar shaped helm, but with a more rounded dome - the more pointed dome is what made me thing of the Argos helm.
Achilles' armour is very angular but most the panoply looks like a version of archaic Greek armour, the helm is the same form as some of the ones in the red-bordered box you posted - again more angular.
Both panoplies are broadly plausible but in both cases they have abbreviated armour on their feet and achilles in particular seems to have had his pauldrons shrunk in the wash.
KLAssurbanipal
10-14-2019, 19:45
Achilles and Hektor have very loose variations on the armour of this era. However, Hector's helmet is a completely strange, too complicated construction and it bothers me the most. It looks a bit like Gondor helmet from LotR.
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.