View Full Version : WU vs. SHU vs. WEI WHO WOULD WIN??
Who do you think would win in the battle of the kingdoms?????
I thought Wu was the strongest info on them plz!
Nope, Wei has a powerful strong hold, full of resources, advisors and warriors, that's the reason they were able to conquer Wu and Shu in history.
i see, but who lasted longest???
If you said the one who lasted longer and defended longer against Wei it will be Wu, if you say who lasted the longest from all of the three it will be Wu, and if you say which kingdom will win then all of them will depending if they have the confidence and resources that will help them.
thx ive been saying wu was better than shu but had nuttin to prove it! they did last longest and... did they have the second largest army????? thx http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/smile.gif http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/smile.gif
Whoops sorry Lu Meng I made a mistake actually I mean the following:
Lasted longest is Wei, because they manage to conquer Wu and Shu,
Lasted long enough to defend Wei from attacks is Wu.
Wu compare to Shu is a larger kingdom, umm you can say that they have the second largest army from the three, because more land means more recuiting of soldiers. Shu although is a heaven world like Zhuge Liang said, but was not as large as Wu to recruit as many as wanted. But they were strong.
About the largest army, Shu recruited large numbers of southern tribes people like Meng Huo's armies into the Shu kingdom, which enhance the numbers.
Wu did the same recruiting other different tribes into their kingdom, I forgot the name of the tribes but I try to remember next time.
Wei also recruited northern tribes like Cao Cao recuited a large number of Mongolias into his army force.
http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/smile.gif http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/smile.gif http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/smile.gif wow thx again!!!! this is way more than dw3 tells you. was zhou yu or tasci ci the strongest wu officers? was guan yu as good as some people say??? THX ALOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Gan Ning
05-14-2002, 06:04
Yes he was and i dont think there is any question to that!
guan yu was just a regular guy (im not saying i could beat him :rolleyes http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/smile.gif but any one could beat him!!!!!
Gan Ning
05-14-2002, 06:28
GAH!!!
Guan Yu was a regular guy, a very strong regular guy!
And ur wrong that ANYONE could beat him!
if a 25yr old soldier could chalange LORD GUAN to aduel and beat him. I would lt u tie my to a chair and beat the crapout of me.
so by the samelogic that u said: SOme1 who trained for yrs and yrs learning the ar of war could be killed by a mear not-learned man????
A privite could walk up 2 Lu Bu and kill him in a fight! Unless he ws sleeping i think not!
Theres one thing though, Mortal man with no limbs can not fight. But u tell me one man who can be stabbed in the heart and live. He was mortal. WAIT A SEC!!!! NO HE WASNT HES THE GOD OF WAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
GAH!!! GAH!!!! GAH!!!! G+A+H+!+!+!
Actually you might not like it when you know the real history, there are too many criticisms:
Guan Yu is very loyal but kind of over confidence,
Zhuge Liang is equal to Zhou Yu but not super talented.It's his loyalty and fighting skills that made him God of War. However, one thing is everyone in China considers him a god from his extraordinary face look.
Zhou Yu is a very kind person, he never have a war with Zhuge Liang,
Sima Yi wasn't the one who used fire to burn Jieting, it was Zhang He's strategy.
Sun Jian never took the Jade Seal at Luo Yang, the Jade Seal's location has been unknown for a long time. Therefore in real history Sun Jian is not a evil person, he actually killed Hua Shun, it was not Guan Yu who killed him.
Cao Cao never used 7,0000 troops to beat Yuan Shao 700000 troops, Cao Cao used 11,0000 troops to defeat Yuao Shao 30,0000 troops. The number are around that, kind of an estimate.
During Guan Yu's left hand have been stroke by an arrow, it wasn't the famous Huang Te who cured him, it was another doctor, because Huang Te is already died.
[This message has been edited by tienyi (edited 05-14-2002).]
i thought zhang liao defected to shu after yiling? did he? anyway thx for all that info!!! http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/smile.gif
Tenchimuyo
05-15-2002, 02:18
Well, Wei did end up been the one to unify the country didn't they?
------------------
A great warrior rarely reveal his true skills....
Gan Ning
05-15-2002, 02:40
Wei did it, Wei unifyed the country. DUHHHH
k wei unified the country? when? anyway... well...
Tenchimuyo
05-15-2002, 03:18
Anyway, I think Wei and Wu would have a stand off since Wei and wu had the advantage over economic prosperity and manpower. Plus, the Long River served as a natural barrier for the Wu. Eventhogh Shu's natural barrier of the mountaains serves them well, but their eocnomy and manpower does not match up to the likes of Wei and Wu.
------------------
A great warrior rarely reveal his true skills....
true, rivers are harder to cross because your visible and wu was a strong political power!
Very true Tenchimuyo and Lu Meng that's why in the three kingdoms Zhuge Liang said:
There you see the fifty-four counties of the west. Should you wish to take the overlordship, you will yield the Heaven's favor to Cao Cao in the north, and you will relinquish the Earth's advantage to Sun Quan in the south. You, General, will hold the Human's heart and complete the trinity. Jingzhou is to be taken first as a home, the River Lands* next for the foundation of domination. When you are firmly established, you can lay your plans for the attainment of the whole empire."
have u read three kingdoms more than 3 times? lol youre pretty smart about this stuff! go to www.threekingdoms.com (http://www.threekingdoms.com) to read book online! http://www.totalwar.org/ubb/smile.gif
That is a very good site.
And also pay a visit to the Gallery Section. It is still under construction (I think), but you can find details info on many characters from the novel.
[This message has been edited by pdoan8 (edited 05-15-2002).]
go to www.3kingdoms.net (http://www.3kingdoms.net) and find more info on places and weapons
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.