View Full Version : Serious Elton John Marraige poll (no gay bashing!!!)and discussion
Devastatin Dave
12-22-2005, 17:41
Do you believe Elton Johns marraige will have an impact on the debate about gay marraige. I for one believe it will moreso than othe celebrity homosexual unions. What's your opinion?
Duke John
12-22-2005, 17:52
You mean that Elton John is so popular that if he marries that all opposers start to accept their short-sightedness?
Strike For The South
12-22-2005, 18:03
meh
Hold on for just one second. Elton John is gay????
:jawdrop:
:san_grin:
Meh is right, it probably have no effect on the debate. Some fence-sitters may be more accepting of gay marraige, but they aren't the ones making the noise. The serious opponents and proponents will continue as before, it won't affect the debate at all. I'm sure it will be in the news for a good long time. :san_rolleyes:
Ianofsmeg16
12-22-2005, 18:54
Of course it will, they're celebrities, we hang on their ever move and copy their every action
Of course it will, they're celebrities, we hang on their ever move and copy their every action
Depressing.
I don't think it will make that much difference, possibly a little bit for the better.
More importantly, I am very proud that this Labour govt has extended the rights for homosexuals and other minorities and we have got to the point where gay people can now even marry. Never would have happened under a Tory administration. Well done Labour and the UK.
Yeah good old Labour. Err new Labour. My goodness, you are such a party boy! Save it for the Student Union elections matey.
Gay "marriage". Don't much care really. The world certainly hasn't ended like some seemed to think, nor has God struck the infidels down with holy fire. Though there is still time, he might be busy. Anyway if Elton John wants to give his lover rights to his property if he dies (or, for that matter, if they split) then fair enough.
Ianofsmeg16
12-22-2005, 19:13
Depressing.
isnt it so? but then again, thats life.
On topic, Gay marriages should have been legal ages ago, its just silly prejudices that have been going on since god knows when that have stopped it being so.
Gawain of Orkeny
12-22-2005, 19:15
Dave your falling for the hype, Gay marriage still isnt legal in the UK. He was joned in a civil union . Even the Brits aint that nuts. Only Canada and a few other nations actually have gay marriage.
Dave your falling for the hype, Gay marriage still isnt legal in the UK. He was joned in a civil union . Even the Brits aint that nuts. Only Canada and a few other nations actually have gay marriage.
Marriage in all but name - same rights, responsibilities and service. Even the news stations over here refer it as marriage, but if it saves your face and your demented belief system that it really isn't marriage, then sure, go for it.
Ser Clegane
12-22-2005, 19:35
Dave your falling for the hype, Gay marriage still isnt legal in the UK. He was joned in a civil union . Even the Brits aint that nuts. Only Canada and a few other nations actually have gay marriage.
Actually I think as far as Elton John and his partner are concerned, it apparently was a marriage and not just a civil union.
The fact that it is not a legally acknowledged marriage does not mean that it is no marriage at all (AFAIK "marriage" is not a church or state registered brand).
If you refuse to call it marriage, that's your choice.
As for Dave's question - I think the impact will be at most incremental, I do not think that a lot of people who are against gay marriage will change their mind based on this case.
The ones who are sitting on the fence might be influenced either way - the fact that this gay marriage involved some colorful celebrity does not necessarily give gay marriage a touch of "normality"
Strike For The South
12-22-2005, 19:37
meh Civil union is just used to side step the church. Two guys married they arent hurting anyone the apocolypse isnt here. So I see no reason why gay marrige isnt legal.
Yeah good old Labour. Err new Labour. My goodness, you are such a party boy! Save it for the Student Union elections matey.
I do support the good thigns Labour does and I liek to point them out, especially here. The reasoning is quite simply because people don't know / want to know the good thigns Labour does or cannot understand why they are different to the Tories. Labour are the only form of govt which makes sense for the country.
Del Arroyo
12-22-2005, 19:43
Gay Marriage is wrong.
Elton John is a popular and high-profile enough figure that his "marriage", however it turns out, cannot avoid having some impact on the debate one way or the other.
DA
I do support the good thigns Labour does and I liek to point them out, especially here. The reasoning is quite simply because people don't know / want to know the good thigns Labour does or cannot understand why they are different to the Tories. Labour are the only form of govt which makes sense for the country.
Get off your soapbox dude.
Taffy_is_a_Taff
12-22-2005, 19:58
JAG, admit it, you're employed by the Labour party propaganda arm aren't you?
"The reasoning is quite simply because people don't know / want to know the good thigns Labour does " was quite priceless.
You guys just can't handle the truth. :san_wink:
Adrian II
12-22-2005, 20:43
You guys just can't handle the truth. :san_wink:What JAG said. All these closet homosexuals posting against gay marriage are boring.
Of course it will, they're celebrities, we hang on their ever move and copy their every action
Yeah, now everyone wants to gay marry, even heterosexuals.
Geoffrey S
12-22-2005, 22:01
Should have some effect. Since they're such a high profile couple whatever happens will provide a clear example for future debates to use, either for or against gay marriage depending on how it goes.
By the way Gawain, I thought you should know now, so you can think of the face saving excuses before the time - From next month gay couples are legally allowed to adopt children here. Maybe you can pretend they are not children but instead 'kids' for we all know the difference between a kid and child is huge!
We are proud of this legislation over here, it is only a matter of time before your country see's rational progressive sense and adopts (ha!) similar legislation.
Adrian II
12-22-2005, 23:21
By the way Gawain, I thought you should know now, so you can think of the face saving excuses before the time - From next month gay couples are legally allowed to adopt children here. Maybe you can pretend they are not children but instead 'kids' for we all know the difference between a kid and child is huge!
We are proud of this legislation over here, it is only a matter of time before your country see's rational progressive sense and adopts (ha!) similar legislation.Again what JAG said, including the ha!
Good to have you back, m8. :san_cool:
Louis VI the Fat
12-22-2005, 23:29
Yeah, now everyone wants to gay marry, even heterosexuals.Well I would marry Elton John if I got to inherit all of his money...:san_cool:
Reverend Joe
12-22-2005, 23:34
I just want to say, for the record, I am opposed to gay marriage.
I am also opposed to straight marriage. :jester:
And I don't hate Elton John for being gay. I hate him for being a horrendously bad artist. But this is all beside the point.
The only people to be affected will be the Great Gasbags, who will trumpet both sides with increassed fervor. Other than that, no, it will have no effect whatsoever.
Uesugi Kenshin
12-22-2005, 23:42
By the way Gawain, I thought you should know now, so you can think of the face saving excuses before the time - From next month gay couples are legally allowed to adopt children here. Maybe you can pretend they are not children but instead 'kids' for we all know the difference between a kid and child is huge!
We are proud of this legislation over here, it is only a matter of time before your country see's rational progressive sense and adopts (ha!) similar legislation.
Hopefully the whole country will soon, but my state already did, Ha!
I don't know if they can adopt here (Vermont), but they have been able to get civil unions for a while know.
Alexander the Pretty Good
12-23-2005, 00:18
We will crush Vermont militarily.
Goofball
12-23-2005, 00:38
Yeah, now everyone wants to gay marry, even heterosexuals.
Darn right. I'm giving it serious consideration myself. I've had my eye on Navaros for quite some time now...
What do you think, Nav?
:san_kiss:
Del Arroyo
12-23-2005, 03:14
You see, this is why I may one day move to someplace like Latin America, where everyone thinks that Gay Marriage is wrong, and you can say it all day long and no one will question it. Because they simply can't see any reason to think about it otherwise. And I agree with them.
DA
Strike For The South
12-23-2005, 03:15
You see, this is why I may one day move to someplace like Latin America, where everyone thinks that Gay Marriage is wrong, and you can say it all day long and no one will question it. Because they simply can't see any reason to think about it otherwise. And I agree with them.
DA
Why is it so wrong
Louis VI the Fat
12-23-2005, 03:38
Why is it so wrongNow don't be so obnoxious, Strike. It's wrong because everybody says so and no-one questions it, geez.
Del Arroyo
12-23-2005, 03:40
Why is it so wrong
Because the two most beautiful things there are in this world are manly men and feminine women. These are the two ideals which should be aimed for. Yes, most people will fall somewhere in between, and indeed many may land quite near the middle (i.e. no-mans-land)-- and as a society we should be completely tolerant of these individuals and grateful for the contributions they make. But to celebrate homosexuality and put it forth as some sort of alternative paradigm is just plain preposterous.
And to officially sanctify such deviance by giving it a status previously reserved for what was traditionally the most important male-female bond, the child-rearing and family-building unit-- well, I'll let you follow my line of reasoning and finish that statement for yourself.
"But gays can rear children!" you say, "But gays can build families!" you say. And this is why I prefer not to debate it, why I prefer to simply leave it alone, and content myself with the knowledge that a solid majority of human beings on this earth believe that you are wrong and I am right.
DA
Strike For The South
12-23-2005, 04:52
So I see you are the offical end all on beuaty now. Its not the gays are going to stop and allowing there marrige takes care of some legal issues that without it would be very tough to solve. The bottom line is these people aint hurtin no one and as long they keep there responsibilties they should be allowed the same rights. I also love how you guys consider marrige to be a sacred instution when 50% end in divorce. Its not like there spitting on the pope for gods sake
Del Arroyo
12-23-2005, 05:15
I also love how you guys consider marrige to be a sacred instution when 50% end in divorce. Its not like there spitting on the pope for gods sake
"You guys" who? Me guys? Not sure who you're referring to. You are quite right, though, there is a great deal of divorce these days, and our decadent, gender-confused culture is the main cause of that. I never said marriage was sacred, but it is a useful ideal. Should we poop on an ideal just because now fewer people are following it?
Now granted, you will not find me out in the streets, thumping on a Bible and yelling to bring down the heavens. I'm not even religious. And you are quite right in that it's not as if Gay Marriage is coming out of the blue as the first or even the most disturbing incarnation of moral decay in America.
So go on, ye wired zombies, ye who recieved your Elementary School from MTV, and your High School from Hollywood, and your College Degree from CNN-- do what ye will, I will not raise up my voice against you. But if you ask me, I will tell you the truth as I see it.
DA
Strike For The South
12-23-2005, 05:23
So go on, ye wired zombies, ye who recieved your Elementary School from MTV, and your High School from Hollywood, and your College Degree from CNN-- do what ye will, I will not raise up my voice against you. But if you ask me, I will tell you the truth as I see it.
DA
So the only reason I support gay marrige is becuase the libreal elite and media tells me to? Now I know youre smarter than that. So go on ye inscure hetro male keep oppresing a minorty whose only crime is being diffrent (much like being a christian now a days) these people who are not hurting anyone yet you are not secure enough to give them the same rights
Del Arroyo
12-23-2005, 05:39
No one said they shouldn't have the same rights. If a Heterosexual man marries a woman, it's called a marriage. If a Homosexual man marries a woman, it's called a marriage. I'm not saying that Homosexual men SHOULD marry women, but if they do, they will be afforded exactly the same rights as anyone else.
And who said that following a gay lifestyle was a crime? I don't think it's a crime. I am sorry if you feel that I have been oppressing you, either for being gay or for being a Christian (I'm not quite sure which). I am sorry if I seem insecure, but we all have our insecurities, you know. You may not quite have guessed mine, though.
DA
Marcellus
12-23-2005, 10:51
And who said that following a gay lifestyle was a crime? I don't think it's a crime.
But clearly you think that it is inferior, since you are not affording them the same rights as heterosexual couples (to express their commitment to those whom they love).
Samurai Waki
12-23-2005, 11:07
Not a particular fan of Elton John. Imagine listening to Benny and the Jets or Crocodile Rock for the rest of eternity? Absolute hell.
Aside from that, I dislike the stigma that gays get, like they're some kind of inhuman abomination. No. They just prefer men to women for the same reason that straight men prefer women to men, its all about the chemicals in the brain. Mind you, I don't dislike gays, I just sometimes have a hard time being around a guy that oggles other guys, or says things like "skiddles. or fabulous. or super." (I'm not trying to be durogatory, I know that most gays are about as similar as Jag and Gawain)
Call it whatever you will, I'd prefer we call all marriages civil unions, that way when you probably divorce the person that you formerly loved, you don't have to feel guilty about it. After all its just a 'civil union'. Damn hypocrits and their power vacuum :san_angry:
AntiochusIII
12-24-2005, 09:48
I doubt Elton John's marriage will have much impact, if at all.
But since we're reaching the favourite topic of mine again (alright, it's not "favourite" and I'm not that interested, in case people want to jump to conclusions :san_laugh: ) I still wonder why gay marriage is so wrong.
Because the two most beautiful things there are in this world are manly men and feminine women. If you're right, I might have to commit suicide.
I mean, my hair is long; I'm not tough; I don't have a girlfriend, or even a life. I'm, in fact, a little too neat and detail-concerned (otherwise known as feminine) for my own tastes.
Kill me.
By the way, I'm not gay, for sure. My passions still lie fully with girls and their magnificent femininity.
Also, are lesbians feminine? 'Cause they're hot. :san_kiss:
solid majority of human beings on this earth believe that you are wrong and I am right.As has been shown throughout history, the solid majority of us are prejudiced idiots, including me.
But to celebrate homosexuality and put it forth as some sort of alternative paradigm is just plain preposterous.Why? Because it offends you? You know, I'm offended by...erm...American football players. So the celebration of their oh-so-glorious successes in sports is just plain proposterous. :san_wink:
You may not quite have guessed mine, though.That sounds...suspiciously like...
All these closet homosexuals posting against gay marriage
Sorry. Can't resist. :san_cheesy:
Now, that makes me think of the first episode of the Boondocks, ("Tell me, what do you think about gay marriage?" is a question you should ask your new neighbor at first meeting) another product of mass-media America. Fortunately, it's not MTV.
Del Arroyo
12-24-2005, 10:24
I might have to commit suicide.
Kill me.
:san_shocked:
Dude, seriously! Think of all you have to live for.
Perhaps we all need to take a step back before this conversation gets out of hand. Sexuality and self-image are certainly not issues that are worth killing or dying over...
DA
AntiochusIII
12-24-2005, 10:26
:san_shocked:
Dude, seriously! Think of all you have to live for.
Perhaps we all need to take a step back before this conversation gets out of hand. Sexuality and self-image are certainly not issues that are worth killing or dying over...
DADon't worry! I'm joking, good sir!
:san_lipsrsealed:
I seriously I'm proud of my manhood as it is and won't commit suicide anytime soon. :san_wink:
Thanks for your concern, anyway.
I know I should've putted a "[j/k]" message. It's hard to interpret things from texts and avatars alone.
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.