MOD review site

[ICantSpellDawg]

we have so many sites that review full games. why not have a site that reviews mods for full games? like a "planet modification" if you will. it would be interesting to have a hub of comparisons for the different mods, rating them on ingenuity, professionalism, stability, graphics etc

what do you think?

[Duke John]

Something like this?
http://mods.moddb.com/4881/napoleonic-total-war/ :wink:

Although no real reviews, I guess the user comments are usually enough to get some feedback wether the mod is any good.

I think standard reviews would not work really well as most modders tend to be defensive. You spend hundreds of hours making a game in your free time with no reward except for finishing something and the feedback of fans. A review which would rate your mod as a 4/10 doesn't make you feel good. Mulitiple user reviews (such as at Amazon.co.uk) would work better as you get a more evened out review.