PDA

View Full Version : Proposal: 'Fantasy Congress'



KukriKhan
11-15-2006, 06:32
First of all, full disclosure: I stole this idea from here (http://www.fantasycongress.com/fc/), after hearing a story on US Nat'l Public Radio today.

The Concept: You may have heard of football, basketball, baseball or other sport "fantasy" leagues. All eligible players are listed, from which you pick your ideal team; those players accumulate points for goals scored, passes thrown, yards gained (or whatever we decide). In other words: productivity. Same thing for this 'fantasy congress' plan: we list members of the US congress (or MP's if we so decide, later), assign points for various productivity actions - like: introducing a bill (5 points), moving the bill through committee (10 points), getting a "yea" vote (20 points), getting the Prez to sign it (50 points).

What You Do: pick a 16-member team (4 Senators, 12 Representatives) from the list. Name your team. You make your picks by midnight GMT Mondays. Your team accumulates points throughout the week. Points are tallied on Sundays, after which you can change your picks for the following week.

What I Do: Provide the list of Members of Congress. Using The Congressional Record (http://www.gpoaccess.gov/crecord/index.html), and the guys at Fantasy Congress.com (that earlier link), award points (on Sundays) to MoC's, and then to your picked team.

Result: We determine a weekly winner team, based on points scored (winner gets bragging rights). And an overall "season" winner, based on points scored at the end of this Congress in January 2007 (winner gets... something tangible, to be determined).

Addendum: this is a test of interest; the current US Congress will change its member list in January 2007, at which time - if backroomers have interest in the project - we can make a more robust 'fantasy' game, tweaked to our own preferences. Maybe we could get some small monetary prize involved on a weekly/quarterly basis (to spark and maintain interest). Maybe we want to look at another legislative body (parliament, Bundestag, etc). The whole idea is to have a little fun while watching law being made.

If we get 12 "takers" (folks who want to play this test), I figure it'll be worth the organizing effort (12 being 10% of the daily average viewers of the backroom). If it flops, no problem... the concept was introduced.

Csargo
11-15-2006, 06:35
I think this would be fun. I'de be interested in doing it

JimBob
11-15-2006, 06:45
I'm in

Redleg
11-15-2006, 06:48
Sign me up for this one.

Oaty
11-15-2006, 10:05
Bribe via virtual money?

I'll give it a try

Aenlic
11-15-2006, 12:16
I'm in. I don't know how much legislation will actually get passed in the next month, though. It's pretty much a lame duck Congress; and with a new party taking control in 2 months, they're unlikely to allow anything through which isn't heavily bi-partisan. It might make more sense to go ahead and wait for the 110th Congress where there might (maybe, who knows?) actually be some work done.

KukriKhan
11-15-2006, 15:11
Good points, Aenlic. I thought we could use the 109th as a kind of test-bed to adjust our version of the game, for example: even showing up for work has been an issue sometimes with this congress, so maybe we want to award a point for every vote they render.

Then, when #110 officially comes in office, we could start a fresh game, with weekly scoring, and maybe quarterly (or monthly) summaries to determine the best "picker".

Something like that. We'll want to keep the mechanics and administration of the game as simple as possible, with the primary thrust for players being: pick the most productive MoC's.

Aenlic
11-15-2006, 15:52
Good points, Aenlic. I thought we could use the 109th as a kind of test-bed to adjust our version of the game, for example: even showing up for work has been an issue sometimes with this congress, so maybe we want to award a point for every vote they render.

Then, when #110 officially comes in office, we could start a fresh game, with weekly scoring, and maybe quarterly (or monthly) summaries to determine the best "picker".

Something like that. We'll want to keep the mechanics and administration of the game as simple as possible, with the primary thrust for players being: pick the most productive MoC's.

Sounds good. And certainly entertaining. Congress is always entertaining, in a "look that guy left his zipper down" sort of way. At least this way, they'll be of some benefit for once, however slight. :grin:

Don Corleone
11-15-2006, 15:56
Please sign me up, but doesn't this belong in the Gameroom?

KukriKhan
11-15-2006, 16:00
Please sign me up, but doesn't this belong in the Gameroom?

Yeah, but I thought we'd start out here in the backroom, to test the interest level first. Once we're underway, I'd ask our venerable Mods to move it.

Don Corleone
11-15-2006, 16:00
Question... will we get points for blocking or delaying nominations?

yesdachi
11-15-2006, 16:09
Neat idea, but doesn’t it require Congress to actually do something? :sweatdrop:

Don Corleone
11-15-2006, 16:25
I think you should also put in things like

-Having a special prosecutor appointed: 100 pts.
-Holding an impeachment vote: 100 pts.
-Having the impeachment vote pass: 500 pts.
-Shutting down federal offices in an effort to strongarm the president on budget negotiations: -1000 pts (BOO!!! Sure, screw the federal workers to make a point :thumbsdown: )

drone
11-15-2006, 16:27
Do you get points for bribes taken, being indicted, putting together the articles of impeachment, high dollar earmarks, etc. ~D

Edit->Gah! Don beat me to the cynical punch!

Alexander the Pretty Good
11-15-2006, 20:48
Sounds coolio. I'd like to give it a shot.

Marshal Murat
11-16-2006, 00:00
Any more spots? Eh? eh? Sign me up!

Xiahou
11-16-2006, 03:00
So, is someone going to create a league for us organs? Sounds interesting.

Major Robert Dump
11-16-2006, 07:17
I'm in, this sounds like a hoot. What happens if one of our picks resigns in shame or drowns in a drunken car accident in the port?

KukriKhan
11-17-2006, 04:26
Looking at the congressional calendar for the next 6 weeks - which is sparse in the extreme (OMG!!11!! don't attack us 'til February!!11!!) - let's put this project on the back burner until the 110th actually takes office.

Humble thanks to all the volunteers. :bow: And for all the excellent scoring ideas. I'm confident we can put together a Fantasy Congress game with an org-ish slant, when the time is right.

I promise to bring this back up in January 07. Thanks again.