PDA

View Full Version : Summer Campaign-Renaissance Bracket


Marshal Murat
05-01-2007, 02:52
The Renaissance Bracket is here with your suggested Generals.

Rules
There are 16 generals to be offered.
You vote for eight to continue on.
I am trusting that you will honor this system of voting for eight.
Choose your favorites.
This poll will be open for 7 days.
(Sorry, not locked for 7 days. Could a moderator wave his magic mouse and make this better?)
Lorenzo_H
05-02-2007, 09:52
Where is Charles V?

He was by far the most successful Renaissance General - look at his Empire when he died.
Husar
05-02-2007, 10:25
Where is Charles V?
Does a king count as general?
King Henry V
05-02-2007, 16:21
Where is Charles V?

He was by far the most successful Renaissance General - look at his Empire when he died.
His empire was mostly the results of his grandfather's political machinations in arranging so many marriages which resulted in the fabulous inheritance of Charles.
Lorenzo_H
05-05-2007, 20:47
Does a king count as general?
He stood in as a General as well as the leader of a nation.
Conradus
05-06-2007, 11:06
His empire was mostly the results of his grandfather's political machinations in arranging so many marriages which resulted in the fabulous inheritance of Charles.
That said, he didn't lose his empire to his enemies like France or the Ottomans. He fought many campaigns (they drained his treasury), was often victorious, but never managed defeat his opponents crushingly.
seireikhaan
05-15-2007, 14:14
Well, no big shocker here. Gustavus and Oda are one-two, as they were in my list. However, I had Oda just ahead of Gustavus.

And it just figures, the only one poll I managed to get a vote in on is the one my history is worst on(with the exception of Gustavus and the Japanese, I simply didn't know enough about the other generals)
cegorach
05-17-2007, 08:02
OK I took my eight.
Primary choices would be Sobieski (for fluid, aggressive warfare in any place) and Wallenstein for more methodical, slower approach.:book:



What I cannot understand is why Zolkiewski is rated higher here than Chodkiewicz ? OK. Zolkiewski took Moscow defeating 6-7 times larger army before, but Chodkiewicz was probably (at least I don't remember it happening) NEVER defeated which cannot be said even about Sobieski who lost two battles from 40 or so he fought.
Chodkiewicz even won a NAVAL battle with improvised fleet he put together in few days - that cannot be said about too many land commanders after all.