PDA

View Full Version : The Secret Formula [Concluded]



Pages : 1 [2] 3

TevashSzat
09-09-2007, 02:31
Oh right.. Lets say if i am.. First ill get my self killed by getting attention. Then Shlin will get killed anyway next round or so. Very clever.

Then I would say this.. Which makes you think im innocent. Reverse phycology is extremely useful in mafia. Then ill just name two random players name. Those two get killed. People will go mafia is a noob. Thats the most obvious framing ever. then i might survive till the end killing every single one of you. Sounds like a plan.

If I am a mafia I will never tell you this. But then again I might be using reverse phycology. Hmm..So yea pretty much you guys only got three options
1. Lynch me just incase
2. Make a deal with me. Ill be quiet so let me live
3. Trust me im innocent

1 is the best. You got lots of people left anyway. Getting one lynch wrong wouldnt hurt much. 2 sounds good too. I got a feeling that im getting really annoying. I gotta go study anyway. 3 is a bit of gamble. But after accidently lynching me 5 games in a row, you could start trusting me a bit. Im only trying to help the town. Personally all the option is good. 1 and 2 makes my life easier. 3 makes me feel good. So i dont mind any options. Take your pick


EDITED
I prefer option 2. so i got something to do when i dont wanna study or when the test is over (Tuesday Australian time)

Lets talk more. We only got like 5 active players. If all of us gets killed we are doomed pretty much

I believe that you are getting way too defensive here. Normal townies wouldn't be so analytical in defending themselves especially when you arent necessarily bandwagoned on already.

Unvote, Vote: Beefy

Beefy187
09-09-2007, 03:07
Heh the thing is mate.. Im not normal. I take pride in being strange

GeneralHankerchief
09-09-2007, 03:09
*sigh*

Come on, guys. We've all seen this before. How many times have we falsely lynched Beefy in the past?

sapi
09-09-2007, 03:26
Safer to falsely lynch than falsely leave alive ~;)

RoadKill
09-09-2007, 03:59
*sigh*

Come on, guys. We've all seen this before. How many times have we falsely lynched Beefy in the past?

Maybe we'll get him as mafia this time! :beam:

Twilightblade
09-09-2007, 04:08
Safer to falsely lynch than falsely leave alive ~;)

you have my complete support in this sapi

Tiberius of the Drake
09-09-2007, 04:16
how many times has beefy been lynched falsely...5 games in a row now...

I just realised how sad it is that my first death was that i was eaten by a cannibal....

Beefy187
09-09-2007, 05:20
You have my complete support too Sapi. :sweatdrop:

Thats normally my attitude of lynching.How ever the normal rule doesnt seem to apply to me.

Only time I was playing strange/ normal which was "walking dinner" that time i was playing mafia. Every single other time i follow the exact same pattern.. I do either joke vote or random reasoning, get FoS or 1 vote, overreact and get paranoid, then getting lynched.. Oh well i suppose ull have to use my death wisely. You better win townies.:inquisitive:

sapi
09-09-2007, 05:24
You have my complete support too Sapi. :sweatdrop:

Thats normally my attitude of lynching.How ever the normal rule doesnt seem to apply to me.

Only time I was playing strange/ normal which was "walking dinner" that time i was playing mafia. Every single other time i follow the exact same pattern.. I do either joke vote or random reasoning, get FoS or 1 vote, overreact and get paranoid, then getting lynched.. Oh well i suppose ull have to use my death wisely. You better win townies.:inquisitive:
Well, hopefully we'll eventually realise it's normal for you :wall:

~:)

Beefy187
09-09-2007, 05:34
Hmm i hope so too.. Its not very fun for me getting lynched in 3 games simultaneously just because i wanted to catch the mafia.. :sweatdrop:

If I am innocent (I am too) im pretty sure at least one of the mafia is trying to be neutral on this case. Other mafia is rather quiet and he/she is going to stay quiet.

Jubal_Barca
09-09-2007, 07:33
Mafia Professional? You mean you can get paid for doing this? :laugh4:

I'm really mostly a good endgame or small game player, I'm afraid. THis is my largest ever game. Also, in the rules I use days can go on for up to a fortnight before a lynch which is way beter for analysis.

My hunch agianst woad is very minor;

The princess bride is a great movie. I really have to watch it again some time. The WIFOM involved with the two mafia kills is overwhelming and makes my head hurt. Vote: Sasaki A hunch.

My guess is that either this is a breadcrumb or something prearranged as a signal of some sort.

unvote woad


Hate this post from Xdeathfire;

I believe that you are getting way too defensive here. Normal townies wouldn't be so analytical in defending themselves especially when you arent necessarily bandwagoned on already.

Normal townies shouldn't be analytical? :daisy: my friend.

vote xdeathfire

Omanes Alexandrapolites
09-09-2007, 07:56
I don't believe that Beefy is who we are looking for. He always is eager to lynch and always does something which makes him look like a suspect, despite him actually being totally innocent. If you want to lynch him, do so when there is nothing else to go on - right now we have several good pieces of evidence upon shlin who is acting rather peculiarly.

Beefy187
09-09-2007, 08:44
:wall:

Just read the article on "how to be a good townie" on yahoo answers....

Ill be good if you let me live:yes:

Hepcat
09-09-2007, 08:50
Hmm i hope so too.. Its not very fun for me getting lynched in 3 games simultaneously just because i wanted to catch the mafia.. :sweatdrop:

If I am innocent (I am too) im pretty sure at least one of the mafia is trying to be neutral on this case. Other mafia is rather quiet and he/she is going to stay quiet.

I agree with Beefy, I think the Mafia are going to try sitting back not doing anything, but then I'm no expert on Mafia games.

Beefy187
09-09-2007, 09:00
Well the thing is.. after reading your post they will either get active if they are not experienced. Or stay cool if they are good. Or it could be you

Csargo
09-09-2007, 09:39
Shlin had a fairly valid reason to kill off Ichigo.

:inquisitive: I wonder what a valid reason is in your opinion. "He's so guilty did you see him post that s???? MAFIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA"

shlin28
09-09-2007, 10:51
Unvote, Vote TwilightBlade (If you see this as a scummy behaviour please feel free to vote for me, but TwilightBlade's revenge vote against Pever in round 1 is very suspicious in my mind, as I said before.)

shlin28: 3(omanes, stig, ca)
beefy: 2 (inca, xdeath)
kingwarman: 1(gh)
Zain: 1(tran)
Sasaki: 1(woad)
brave robin: 1(greaterkhaan)
xdeathfire: 1(barca)
barca: 1(Warmaster Horus)
zorg: 1 (beefy)
twilight:1 (shlin28)

Stig
09-09-2007, 10:55
Then why did you not vote for him earlier? Because now, that people seem to be going after Beefy you might still be saved?

Twilightblade
09-09-2007, 10:58
If it seems suspicious to you thats fine with me

but pever never said how I was playing diffrently which was the said reason for his vote

shlin28
09-09-2007, 11:03
Then why did you not vote for him earlier? Because now, that people seem to be going after Beefy you might still be saved?

:wall: Why... :wall: does... :wall: everything... :wall: I do seems suspicious to you?

I first voted for myself because I am sure I'm gonna get lynched, but then people started to put random pressure votes on random people, so I might as well join in; and why did nobody follow my advice on voting Twilight? :no:

Beefy187
09-09-2007, 11:22
Twilights vote on pever seems to be natural. Pever said abstaining is scummy so Twilight simply put on vote on him. Dont see how thats scummy Shlin..

shlin28
09-09-2007, 11:28
Unvote; vote: abstain

happy?

Beefy187
09-09-2007, 11:33
Wait Killfr3nzys in the game isnt he?
I dont like it when his silent. Its freaky.

Unvote: Zorg Vote: Killfr3nzy

CountArach
09-09-2007, 11:51
Unvote: shlin Which will tie him up with Beefy. Conversation = teh awesome. Unfortunately, I do not have time to do more than that.

Stig
09-09-2007, 12:05
If you really think Shlin would be quilty you would not unvote him, why did you really unvote him?

Husar
09-09-2007, 12:53
Well the thing is.. after reading your post they will either get active if they are not experienced. Or stay cool if they are good. Or it could be you
Well, after reading your post they will stay cool.:laugh4:

I have no idea who to go on right now. And please bear with me, I never read an article on how to be a good townie. Though for this game I was thinking more about being a good mercenary. ~;)

Am I right in thinking that a lot of the people playing here including me didn't post for quite a while, we have more than 30 players, don't we?:inquisitive:

Beefy187
09-09-2007, 13:17
we only got like 10 active players.. Rest are just slacking off.. Which is good. I suppose we have better chance of taking down the active players but for the sake of game play kill the lurkers which might get the rest motivated.

How to be good mercenary: Be extremely good at everything and demand more money:whip:

Dutch_guy
09-09-2007, 13:31
Am I right in thinking that a lot of the people playing here including me didn't post for quite a while, we have more than 30 players, don't we?:inquisitive:

It's probably because of the other large mafia game which is on right now.

Note how those killed there are active here, and vice versa.

:balloon2:

Husar
09-09-2007, 13:31
I demand more money Andres!

sapi
09-09-2007, 13:33
we only got like 10 active players.. Rest are just slacking off.. Which is good. I suppose we have better chance of taking down the active players but for the sake of game play kill the lurkers which might get the rest motivated.

How to be good mercenary: Be extremely good at everything and demand more money:whip:
Slacking off is good, as it gives you a better chance to take down the active players? ??

Vote: Beefy until you can explain that one :grin2:

Zorg
09-09-2007, 13:36
Its exam week, playing mafia is the slacking off :sick: .


Anyway, I think the Mafia are probably just going to be sitting back. Theres only two of them and they have 2 kills per night which is pretty powerful. Odds are we are just going to be killing off innocent townies, esspecialy if we vote for active ones.

The way I see it. We should vote for those who are non-active. Why you ask? Because odds are the mafia are being innactive now if anything. If we vote off all the people ACTUALY disscussing things than we are just killing off people who will actually do well at helping the cause.

Having read this however, (or noticing the trend) some mafia may try to become active (probably not straight away, but just enough away from this comment for people to not pick up on them being active). However the plus side of this is, if they are active theres a far better chance of them slipping up and of us actualy catching them.

For that reason, I suggest we don't hammer in on small mistakes by people who are active, and for now vote for those who are innactive. :logic:


So... on that note, I'm going to:

Vote: gkhaan

FactionHeir
09-09-2007, 13:42
I proposed this many pages before. So what tells me that you for instance aren't a Mafia that wants to get inactive townies lynched? Also, its not exam week for everyone, depending on age and location.

Zorg
09-09-2007, 13:49
Ah, but it is for me, beefy, Killfrenzy, twilightblade and pevergreen :sick: .


And surely a mafia member would want the ACTIVE players lynchaed more than the innactive ones, seeing as its the active ones who will actualy catch them...

And I'm sorry if I didn't see you mentioning this before, as I said been a bit busy, but its good we're on the same page. By going for innactive players we increase our chance of bagging a mafia or just force them into the public and give them more oppourtunities to slip up.

Zain
09-09-2007, 15:18
After "lurking", as you guys called it, I've analyzed what's been going on. And one person seems unconsciously suspicious in my mind.

Vote: Stig

BTW: Tran... stop that.

Haudegen
09-09-2007, 15:21
Being a noob in this game, I don´t know if I make too much sense but why don´t we have a look at the persons who were murdered last night?

Among them we find Sigurd and pevergreen.

Looking further at these players I found it interesting that both of them have voted to lynch Husar. (Posting #72, #88). Although pever later changed his mind, it appears to me that both might have caught the attention of a mafiosi ...

Vote: Husar

FactionHeir
09-09-2007, 15:37
It could also be an attempt to frame Husar though on the other hand.

Stig
09-09-2007, 15:47
After "lurking", as you guys called it, I've analyzed what's been going on. And one person seems unconsciously suspicious in my mind.

Vote: Stig

BTW: Tran... stop that.
And tell me: why do I sound suspicous?
I always play it like this, read the other games. Tho I was a little less in the "oh lynch that guy" mode when I was mafia in Midgard Saga, since it got me killed in an earlier mini game.

Zain
09-09-2007, 15:55
This is the first game I've played, so going back into history won't tell me anything bro... lol

Either way, I don't have solid evidence, like I said, I feel "unconsciously suspicious" of the one they call Stig.

Nothing personal, yet.

TevashSzat
09-09-2007, 17:00
*sigh*

Come on, guys. We've all seen this before. How many times have we falsely lynched Beefy in the past?

If we do it enough times, he will eventually me the mafia. :2thumbsup:

But seriously, while I do think shlin is suspicious cause he killed Ichigo with his vote, I don't necessarily think thats what mafia would do b/c voting at the last second would draw attention especially if it was the vote that caused someone's death.

And Beefy, while the odds are that you aren't mafia, you keep on making me think your scum every single game with your posts

Andres
09-09-2007, 17:54
Tally:

Beefy: 3 (RK, Garcilaso, sapi)
Shlin: 2 (Omanes, Stig)

RK: 1 (w&f)
KingWarman: 1 (GH)
Zain: 1 (Tran)
Garcilaso: 1 (Xdeathfire)
BSR: 1 (GK)
Jubal: 1 (WH)
Xdeathfire: 1 (Jubal)
Killfr3nzy: 1 (Beefy)
GK: 1 (Zorg)
Stig: 1 (Zain)
Husar: 1 (Haudegen)

Abstain (7): shlin28, Dutch_guy, CA, FactionHeir, Hepcat, Husar, TB
Not voting (13): Sasaki, KingWarman, Prole, BSR, Killfr3nzy, Sarathos, Husar, gibson, Martok, Northnovas, Xiahou, The Amazing Me, Enoch.


Andres@Mafia two kills per night no matter what?

Yes.

RoadKill
09-09-2007, 18:08
Why am I not included in the tally?

Tratorix
09-09-2007, 18:25
Vote:Shlin

I think he seems scummier(is that a word?) than beefy. I think beefys probably innocent, so i'm gonna tie the vote up.

Hepcat
09-09-2007, 18:39
Unvote: Abstain
Vote: Killfr3nzy

Let's clear out some of the inactive people first. So I'll bolster up Beefy's vote.

RoadKill
09-09-2007, 18:56
Unvote: Abstain
Vote: Killfr3nzy

Let's clear out some of the inactive people first. So I'll bolster up Beefy's vote.

We could always just let them get Woged

Hepcat
09-09-2007, 19:49
But then who do we lynch? Nobody really has any decent reasons yet.

Andres
09-09-2007, 19:57
Why am I not included in the tally?

RK = Roadkill.

You voted Beefy.

Tally:

Beefy: 3 (RK, Garcilaso, sapi)
Shlin: 3 (Omanes, Stig, Brave Sir Robin)
Killfr3nzy: 2 (Beefy, Hepcat)

RK: 1 (w&f)
KingWarman: 1 (GH)
Zain: 1 (Tran)
Garcilaso: 1 (Xdeathfire)
BSR: 1 (GK)
Jubal: 1 (WH)
Xdeathfire: 1 (Jubal)
GK: 1 (Zorg)
Stig: 1 (Zain)
Husar: 1 (Haudegen)

Abstain (6): shlin28, Dutch_guy, CA, FactionHeir, Husar, TB
Not voting (12): Sasaki, KingWarman, Prole, Killfr3nzy, Sarathos, Husar, gibson, Martok, Northnovas, Xiahou, The Amazing Me, Enoch.

GeneralHankerchief
09-09-2007, 20:01
Eh, let's do the three-way tie. In Il Padrino (when he was mafia) Killfr3nzy didn't post at all in the thread in the early rounds.

Unvote: KingWarman
Vote: Killfr3nzy

Andres
09-09-2007, 20:06
This round will end within +/- 45 minutes.

Caius
09-09-2007, 20:10
I want to hear Killfr3nzy also. He could be hiding, enjoying how we lynch Beefy without a good reason.

Unvote, Vote:Killfr3nzy

Stig
09-09-2007, 20:17
Caius, why did you take off the tie. Is one of those other two your mafia friend?

GeneralHankerchief
09-09-2007, 20:27
Well, to keep the tie going then:

Unvote: Killfr3nzy
Vote: Caius

Caius
09-09-2007, 20:28
Caius, why did you take off the tie. Is one of those other two your mafia friend?
True. But I want to hear from Killfr3nzy!

Unvote:Killfr3nzy
Vote:Killfr3nzy
I will keep the tie.

Andres
09-09-2007, 21:14
Votes will be counted.

Andres
09-09-2007, 21:19
Tally:


Shlin: 3 (Omanes, Stig, Brave Sir Robin)
Killfr3nzy: 3 (Beefy, Hepcat, Garcilaso)

Beefy: 2 (RK, sapi)
RK: 1 (w&f)
Garcilaso: 1 (GH)
Zain: 1 (Tran)
Garcilaso: 1 (Xdeathfire)
BSR: 1 (GK)
Jubal: 1 (WH)
Xdeathfire: 1 (Jubal)
GK: 1 (Zorg)
Stig: 1 (Zain)
Husar: 1 (Haudegen)

Abstain (6): shlin28, Dutch_guy, CA, FactionHeir, Husar, TB
Not voting (12): Sasaki, KingWarman, Prole, Killfr3nzy, Sarathos, Husar, gibson, Martok, Northnovas, Xiahou, The Amazing Me, Enoch.

Tied between shlin28 and Killfr3nzy. The round is over once the tie is broken. You can only vote shlin28 or Killfr3nzy. Unvoting one of them will also break the tie.

GeneralHankerchief
09-09-2007, 21:21
Awesome, the tally says I voted for two people. :laugh4:

I urge everyone to keep their vote where it's at until both shlin and KF make a statement.

Andres
09-09-2007, 21:34
Awesome, the tally says I voted for two people. :laugh4:

I urge everyone to keep their vote where it's at until both shlin and KF make a statement.

Lies...

~;)

shlin28
09-09-2007, 21:34
I am active in this game, yet I am gonna be lynched cos one small mistake??? I suggest you guys vote the lurker Killfr3nzy... but then nobody followed my advice so far, so do whatever you want :yes:

Zain
09-09-2007, 21:36
I agree, SPEECH!!! SPEECH!!!

[edit] Oh well, I was late, trying to find a smilie to put... Someone else vote someone out, I'm riding the Switzerland train in this one.

Northnovas
09-09-2007, 21:53
Just missed the vote. :no: I started on the wrong thread (PBEM) to catch up from being a day away and the NFL opening games too many distractions. I will hopefully have a vote the next round.:inquisitive:

shlin28
09-09-2007, 21:55
You can still vote... its a tie, so vote :whip:

Northnovas
09-09-2007, 21:59
I want to hear Killfr3nzy also. He could be hiding, enjoying how we lynch Beefy without a good reason.

Unvote, Vote:Killfr3nzy


I'll vote:Killfr3nzy

Zain
09-09-2007, 22:02
... We were supposed to hear a speech from KillFr3nzy first...

Did you vote under Shlin's pressure? If so you shall be mutilated. :whip: :whip: :whip:

:egypt:

Andres
09-09-2007, 22:12
Voting closed. Stand by for execution.

GeneralHankerchief
09-09-2007, 22:19
You can still vote... its a tie, so vote :whip:

You know you just sealed your own fate with that one.

Zain
09-09-2007, 22:21
You know you just sealed your own fate with that one.

Amen to that! :yes:

woad&fangs
09-09-2007, 22:31
We wanted to lynch KillFr3nzy because he was lurking and then expected him to show up and make a speech? Also Schlin didn't tell him to vote for KillFr3nzy he just told him to vote.

RoadKill
09-09-2007, 22:33
We wanted to lynch KillFr3nzy because he was lurking and then expected him to show up and make a speech?

I agree with woad&fangs here, Killerfrenzy lurks for a while then when people preassure him, he shows up and gives a huge reasoning, I define this as scummy.

Andres
09-09-2007, 22:36
Day 2 : Conclusion - a bad mood.


"Sir! Sir!"

"What?"

"We have reached a decision, sir!"

"You did?" Andres said. He was clearly in a very bad mood that day.

The union man felt uncomfortable...

"Yes sir. We are convinced that Killfr3nzy is the other mafioso."

"You think so? I didn't hear KF all day. How can he have done something wrong?" Andres said, a bit surprised.

"Eh, democracy never fails, sir."

"It doesn't? Oh well, bring him to me."

"The townies threw the tied up Killfr3nzy on the floor, next to the captain."

Andres looked at the frightened KF. "Any last words."

"Killfr3nzy looked at Andres in agony. I... It... Ehrr... Please, have mercy! Oh please! I'm innocent! Don't kill me, please...!"

"Ok, ok, Andres said, I won't kill you."

Killfr3nzy was pleasantly surprised. "Th... Th... Thank you sir!"

"Ha! I was just kidding!"

"Noooo, no Sir, please!" Killfr3nzy started to cry...

"You don't appreciate a good joke? No sense of humour? Bah! Anyway, it's time to test my new whip. It's a brand new model, it gives the victim electrical shocks when it hits the body. Seems like fun. And it came with a free crate of Ciney Blond."

Andres picked up Killfr3nzy and dragged him into the bunker. After 30 minutes of screaming, Andres came outside. Well, it was short, but hell, this was great fun!"

The mercenaries looked troubled.


Tally:

Killfr3nzy: 4 (Beefy, Hepcat, Garcilaso, Northnovas) :skull:
Shlin: 3 (Omanes, Stig, Brave Sir Robin)


Beefy: 2 (RK, sapi)
RK: 1 (w&f)
Garcilaso: 1 (GH)
Zain: 1 (Tran)
Garcilaso: 1 (Xdeathfire)
BSR: 1 (GK)
Jubal: 1 (WH)
Xdeathfire: 1 (Jubal)
GK: 1 (Zorg)
Stig: 1 (Zain)
Husar: 1 (Haudegen)

Abstain (6): shlin28, Dutch_guy, CA, FactionHeir, Husar, TB
Not voting (12): Sasaki, KingWarman, Prole, Killfr3nzy, Sarathos, Husar, gibson, Martok, Xiahou, The Amazing Me, Enoch.

Alive (34)

Omanes
Stig
GH
Sasaki
KingWarman
Warmaster Horus
greaterkhaan
FactionHeir
Proletariat
Brave Sir Robin
Roadkill
Shlin28
woad&fangs
TwilightBlade
Sarathos
Husar
Beefy187
gibsonsg91921
CountArach
Martok
Xdeathfire
Garcilaso
sapi
Tran
Northnovas
Xiahou
Hepcat
The Amazing Me
Enoch
Dutch_guy
Jubal Barca
Haudegen
Zain
Zorg

Lynched (2)

Ichigo
Killfr3nzy

Killed (3)
Sigurd
pevergreen
Tiberius of the Drake

WoG
0


It's night. PM's please.

Csargo
09-09-2007, 22:46
I am active in this game, yet I am gonna be lynched cos one small mistake??? I suggest you guys vote the lurker Killfr3nzy... but then nobody followed my advice so far, so do whatever you want :yes:

Hypocrite

gibsonsg91921
09-09-2007, 23:53
whoops i totally forgot about this im gonna get back in action now

Zain
09-10-2007, 00:19
whoops i totally forgot about this im gonna get back in action now

Cool, it helps if you prescribe to the thread. That's what I do.

So, KillFr3nzy is out... now what?

Northnovas
09-10-2007, 00:30
... We were supposed to hear a speech from KillFr3nzy first...

Did you vote under Shlin's pressure? If so you shall be mutilated. :whip: :whip: :whip:

:egypt:

I guess it was pressure being a newbie to the game and not from one person. :oops: I should have waited. :shame:

Zain
09-10-2007, 00:55
I guess it was pressure being a newbie to the game and not from one person. :oops: I should have waited. :shame:

I'm new too... did you read the previous posts beforehand?

Zain
09-10-2007, 00:58
Hey Andres, does the death toll reduce to two if we kill one of the three murderers?

Caius
09-10-2007, 01:24
Now, I will put my FoS to the guy who voted KF, Northnovas. We were waiting for his answer. And he killed him!

Where is that bandwagon smiley...

Zain
09-10-2007, 01:28
I have a feeling Killfr3nzy would've been lynched either way...

Plus, I don't think a Mafia member would've been dumb enough to do what Northnovas did. Or you could say he did that on purpose to depend on the logic of people like me, either way, :wall: GAH

GeneralHankerchief
09-10-2007, 01:28
Nah, don't blame Northnovas for this.

Sasaki Kojiro
09-10-2007, 01:45
shlin seems to be a convenient target

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 01:55
Woaw hey guys, hows it going?

Caius
09-10-2007, 01:57
Why did you lurk?

EDIT:Sorry, I quoted the wrong guy

GeneralHankerchief
09-10-2007, 01:58
Why did you lurk?

It's called Mafia VII.

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 02:02
Why did you lurk?

But you didnt quote anyone...:huh:

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 02:04
So, GH, who do you think is mafia?

GeneralHankerchief
09-10-2007, 02:05
I don't know.

Caius
09-10-2007, 02:06
But you didnt quote anyone...:huh:
I quoted mistakenly GH.

Caius
09-10-2007, 02:06
So, GH, who do you think is mafia?
What about you?

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 02:07
No worries :2thumbsup:

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 02:07
So, Garcilaso, who do you think is mafia?

Caius
09-10-2007, 02:10
So, Garcilaso, who do you think is mafia?
I did not found a suspect. A lot of players are not fully involved in this, and I will follow them. Just to be sure the mafioso is not lurking.

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 02:15
There are only a couple people in the suspect loop:

I reckon TB is a bit too edging (settle down TB, just talking) because he was getting pretty drastic when pever just put a vote on them, Serious man, I get that all that time, especially from pever and you dont see me whinging...(well sometimes...). So i say you harden up and start playing and dont give people and reason to vote you.

Shlin i think is just being targeted but is innocent. He really has done nothing wrong, he is just under alot of pressure from everyone else.

Beefy is just trying to be active and help. Im in the same boat as Beefy in being falsely lynched EVERY GAME!!!!!!!!!!. Plus its kinda hard to understand what he is saying, so im not too sure.

There are too many people playing to go through them all, so thats it, for now..........

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 02:19
Just to be sure the mafioso is not lurking.

Yeah, that could be difficult

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 02:20
But you could go with Hepcat's idea and clear out the inactive's.....(was it Hepcat?)

Hepcat
09-10-2007, 02:28
No, Beefy said it first but I was thinking the same thing.

It's interesting though how lynching an inactive person worked like dumping a bucket of water on a wasp nest, all the lurkers now start coming out into the open, although now I'm probably going to get stung for advocating it. :sweatdrop:

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 02:38
Ok, thanks man. But isnt that what we want? The lurkers to come out....?

Hepcat
09-10-2007, 03:12
Yeah but I'm just expecting to get killed now. :laugh4:

TevashSzat
09-10-2007, 03:21
No, Beefy said it first but I was thinking the same thing.

It's interesting though how lynching an inactive person worked like dumping a bucket of water on a wasp nest, all the lurkers now start coming out into the open, although now I'm probably going to get stung for advocating it. :sweatdrop:

That is not in the favor of the townies. Lurkers usually are not mafia as if they were, it would be very suspicious after the first round of WoGs that there is one person still alive yet not posting much either. Mafias are usually average people that neither posts too much or too little.

Zain
09-10-2007, 03:42
Hey Xdeathfire, are you a mafioso?

(taking the direct approach)

gibsonsg91921
09-10-2007, 03:43
I think the mafioso is not one of the lurkers, but someone who is especially active in "trying to find out who it is."

Caius
09-10-2007, 03:47
I think the mafioso is not one of the lurkers, but someone who is especially active in "trying to find out who it is."
Why would you let win the mafia?

Beefy187
09-10-2007, 07:07
We got some lurkers motivated:yes:

I personally think killing one lurker is good to get others motivated. Killfr3nzy is a great mafia player and I thought killing had better chance then killing Zorg. Next turn we should go for active players.

Reason why i said lurkers are good is because they save us some time to find out who the mafia is.. Because there was only like 10 active members. So detectives can concentrate on those 10 peoples. Least one mafia and the cannival are in those 10. So if your still alive detective.. Stay quiet. and post your result when you get 2 or 3 guilty results.

(I finished my exams!)

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 07:09
I think the mafioso is not one of the lurkers, but someone who is especially active in "trying to find out who it is."

Both Shlin and Beefy come to mind, but then again they arent really trying to find out who it is, more just pointing the blame and defending themselves.

Beefy187
09-10-2007, 07:14
Then theres you who suddenly decided to get active..Its night time is it not?

Hepcat
09-10-2007, 09:06
Both Shlin and Beefy come to mind, but then again they arent really trying to find out who it is, more just pointing the blame and defending themselves.

To be perfectly honest I still don't understand how someone can know whether anyone is guilty unless they are the detective. So I think it's all just pointing the blame around the place until by fluke chance the townies win or the mafia kill everyone. I'm yet to see any real reason (at least what I consider a real reason) to accuse a specific person.

Or maybe I'm just not very good at picking up the hints.

Sigurd
09-10-2007, 10:10
:laugh4: :laugh4: :laugh4:

Real jokers!!!!!

Haudegen
09-10-2007, 10:46
:laugh4: :laugh4: :laugh4:

Real jokers!!!!!

What do you mean?

Sigurd
09-10-2007, 11:29
What do you mean?
Come on!!!
:beam:


Ok...
Weekend had me too busy to stop by and this is my second post after realising I was offed in the first round.
The Mafiosi are jokers, HAHA!!!! Killing me and pever in the first round... Yeah REALLY FUNNY!!!
So.. the mafia thinks the game is too boring without having a blood hound on their tail?

Well I am not going to organise a mafia hunt this time. Enjoy your game. :thumbsdown:

Husar
09-10-2007, 11:55
Well I am not going to organise a mafia hunt this time. Enjoy your game. :thumbsdown:
You mean you're not going to hunt me again? :inquisitive:

I'm reading here regularly but to be honest this time I have no idea what to post, until now that is. If you want, kill me as a lurker who usually posts a lot more or maybe I should just suicide but I'm tired somehow. :shrug:

Also the fact that I was lynched in Mafia VII for my usual throwing suspicion on myself sort of makes me want to shut up now since there is apparently no place for my weird humour anymore. :shrug:

pevergreen
09-10-2007, 12:13
@ Sigurd: Same here. Killing me = bad. Look out those mafia teams.

Zain
09-10-2007, 12:17
... Duh

Beefy187
09-10-2007, 12:24
Cmon Husar.. If theres not much talking it makes me wanna spam stupid posts... You dont like that happening do you?

Zain
09-10-2007, 12:33
Cmon Husar.. If theres not much talking it makes me wanna spam stupid posts... You dont like that happening do you?

I do... :beam:

No, but really, I just noticed something.

A player named, The Amazing Me has only posted 2 times in this thread, and two more times... everywhere else. And those were in the Hail New Members thread. He said that he had been invited to the Org to play the Mafia games there.

You think he was recruited to play a role?

Just a thought, also I saw that Enoch was viewing the thread for quite a while, even right now... :scared:

Just some observations guys. I'm off to school in a few minutes, I hope I'm not dead by the time I get back.

Enoch
09-10-2007, 12:48
I do... :beam:

No, but really, I just noticed something.

A player named, The Amazing Me has only posted 2 times in this thread, and two more times... everywhere else. And those were in the Hail New Members thread. He said that he had been invited to the Org to play the Mafia games there.

You think he was recruited to play a role?

Just a thought, also I saw that Enoch was viewing the thread for quite a while, even right now... :scared:

Just some observations guys. I'm off to school in a few minutes, I hope I'm not dead by the time I get back.

That is correct... Many pages to catch up on takes a while.

Being a student means weekends are for getting drunk and flirting with unattainable women.
I have barely recovered from a wild one and I must say... there is not much to go by here.

I am sorry I wasn't around during these last events.

Zain
09-10-2007, 13:08
That is correct... Many pages to catch up on takes a while.

Being a student means weekends are for getting drunk and flirting with unattainable women.
I have barely recovered from a wild one and I must say... there is not much to go by here.

I am sorry I wasn't around during these last events.

I'm glad I got your attention.

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 13:21
Well Enoch that teaches you something, you shouldnt be having wild parties you should be playing more mafia :whip:

Sarathos
09-10-2007, 13:24
Sorry guys, im going :focus:

Husar
09-10-2007, 13:37
Cmon Husar.. If theres not much talking it makes me wanna spam stupid posts... You dont like that happening do you?
It's not the stupid posts, it's the stupid suspicion.

Once people start suspecting others for completely minor stuff while two thirds of the players don't say anything, the game is almost won for the mafia. We had that before in the Black Hand or so hosted by Sasaki and Sigurd being Mafia won that without getting any major suspicion.

I make stupid posts myself and some serious ones in between, but something in this game tells me there is nothing to go by and we just rotate between you and a few other perceived suspects, leaving most others out.

For example it's very unusual for me not to vote in one round and yet noone seems to have noticed that I didn't vote last round despite visiting the thread several times a day. Everybody is either idle or circling around one or two suspects.

Maybe it's just the weekend or my own fault for being a loser(not really :beam: ) but this game needs more serious action and participation. Now I also have to admit that a whole lot of the players in this game don't tell me anything, a short introduction won't tell me much about some guy either but those of the newer players who are idle are very mysterious so it's hard to say anything about them, hoping for a a mighty big WoG to cleanse the list of alive players. Yeah, that's a good thing because fewer players make it easier to analyze each one. All the lynching rounds in the world don't help if you keep lynching the wrong guys and we've won mini mafia games with two mafiosi and three lynching rounds...

Now I'm waiting for the next kills, maybe they will give some hints, but for now the above is all I can say, no real suspects so far if you ask me.

Husar
09-10-2007, 13:38
Well Enoch that teaches you something, you shouldnt be having wild parties you should be playing more mafia :whip:
That is soo wrong!

This Husar needs more wild parties because the .org posters post slower than he can read so there is plenty of time left to party on a day.:dizzy2:

Xiahou
09-10-2007, 16:01
Frankly, I think it's tough to get make a good vote against anyone so early in a large game like this. The best we can hope for is discussion and to get players on the record now, for mid-endgame reference.

Perhaps we should be going after lurkers? Is there a stated WoG policy in this game?

Andres
09-10-2007, 16:16
Is there a stated WoG policy in this game?

From the townie pm (which is publicly available in the thread):


You are supposed to check the thread regularly and post at least once every day phase. Short absences are no problem and not participating during one or two day phases is no problem either. However, if you do not make a single post in the thread during three subsequent day phases, you will be killed by the host (usually referred to as WoG, Wrath of God). It will be an unpleasant dead.

:bow:

Jubal_Barca
09-10-2007, 18:30
So we defintiely shouldn't lynch lurkers - why kill someone who's going to die anyway?

I'm still marginally most sus of xdeath, but only marginally.

Andres
09-10-2007, 21:11
Night 3 : To pick or not to pick..

Zain left his tent to obey the call of nature. He slipped on some ice on his way to the nearest tree.


“Ice. Don’t you just hate ice?”

“Yeah.” Zain nodded in agreement.

The raven haired man came closer to Zain. “Let me help you.”

Zain reached for the mafioso’s hand. The raven haired man pushed him back onto the ground.

“Hey!” Zain said, a bit angry. “I don’t feel like playing games now. I need to go, the sooner the better.”

“I just wanted to help you Zain. I’m going to make sure you will never fall on the ice again…”

“How will you do that?” Zain asked.

The Mafioso showed an icepick.

“Ha!”, Zain shouted. “What are you going to do? Pick all the ice away? You’ll be busy for how long? A lifetime or 10? Give me a break. Leave me alone man.”

“Ok, I won’t use the tool on the ice…”, the raven haired men said. “But I will make sure you’ll never fall again!”

That said, the raven haired men swung the icepick. He hit Zain in the groin and left him to bleed to dead…


Roadkill was very upset about all what happened thus far. He needed some time alone. And he was in desperate need for a smoke.

He went outside and made a long walk. Several miles out of the camp, he paused to enjoy a Camel.

All of the sudden, he hears a sinister voice saying “0, 0, 0 …”

Following the sound, Roadkill sees one of the other mercenaries jumping in the middle of what seems a road, constantly saying “0, 0, 0…”

“This seems like a fun game” Roadkill thought.

And so, he also starts to jump on the middle of the road.

Suddenly, the man with the sinister voice jumps of the road as Roadkill gets run over by a high speeding snow scooter.

Pausing for only a moment, the Mafioso jumps back on road, saying “1, 1, 1…”


Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca was glad he survived patrolling into the tunnels. He stepped out the bunker and wanted to go to the kitchen.

“Hi Garcilassssso.” a strange voice said to him. “The night issss cold, isssn’t it?”

“Eh, yes,” Garci answered. “Where are you? Who are you?”

Silence. Garci started to think the paranoia was becoming too much for him. “Calm down, Garci,” he said to himself, “nobody talked to you, it is just your imagination.”

“I think you know too much…”

“Huh?” Garci said. “Oh, silly me, it’s probably the wind. Hehe, no need to be scared. Imagination. That’s all it is. We lynched the Mafiosi, we are safe now.”

The knife in his heart was not imagined though… The murderer turned the knife and pushed Caius of the cliff.

“Damn, it won’t be eassssy to get my trophie. Ssshould have thought of that before I pussshed him.”


Enoch sat slumbering on his night watch deep inside the mountain. He laughed to himself thinking of the easily fooled mercenaries and their captain. He received a pay check without having any qualifications as a mercenary, not even as an armed guard. His resume told blatant lies of diamond wars in Africa, armed guide at Svalbard and hired gun in Kosovo. This was too easy… As long as there was no trouble, he would do just great. The pay was good and the food was great. He had to do guard duty though, but he usually slept when no one saw. What could he do if there was a crisis anyway? He had planned his escape route if the need arose or if they were attacked.

The tunnels were a bit chillier than normal and he shivered a little. Suddenly a gloomy figure appeared in the tunnel. Its voice chilled him to the bone. “Enoch, what is this you have done” it said. The gloomy figure became a man with a recognisable face. “Ichigo?” The expression on the man’s face was that of anger, an accusing anger. “You are a phony… “Enoch was on his feet in a moment and started running towards the barracks. Suddenly two figures appeared in front of him and he had to skid to a halt. Killfr3nzy and pevergreen pointed accusing fingers at him. “You are an impostor…” Enoch bolted to another tunnel but fell to his knees when another figure suddenly stood there. “I hear you have done a naughty thing Enoch” The accusing finger of Tiberius pointed right at him and he felt an intense coldness in his chest. He scrambled to his feet and bolted for the last tunnel that led out to freedom. As he turned the last corner a large figure stood there waiting. “Your time has come Enoch, you will no longer deceive our brothers” Sigurd Fafnesbane pointed an accusing finger at him and suddenly he felt pain in his chest. Enoch screamed but no sound was heard…

The eyes of his body were wide open and a word was frozen on his lips. His life-force was long gone and the mercenaries wouldn’t be able to read the “Sorry” that was formed on his dead lips.



Greaterkhaan was also in the tunnels that night. He was surprised to see Enoch running and yelling like a madman. All of the sudden, he saw Enoch falling down. Apparently, he died out of fear. “I don’t want to go like this. I don’t want to die out of fear. I will leave this place honourably.”

Greaterkhaan grabbed his gun and fired a bullet into his head.


Day 3 : those bad jokes are killing us…


At dawn, Andres gathered the men.

“Men, things are getting out of hand. This morning we found Zain. He had some severe wounds. It looked very painful. The poor guy bled to dead. We also lost Roadkill last night. Apparently, he became the victim of a bad road kill joke.

We also found another headless body. A knife was shallowly buried under the ice. We found it, because some of the blood turned the ice red. We have reasons to believe that the victim was Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca.

The stress and the fear became too much for some of us last night. The early morning patrol found Enoch slumped in the tunnels. He died out of pure fear. Next to him, we found Greaterkhaan with a bullet in his head. It seems like the bullet came from his own pistol and thus we can assume that he suicided.

“Five townies lost! Five good men! Ha! Democracy never fails? Nonsense! You guys get voting, and maybe, for once, just for once, we might lynch scum today.”



Alive (29)

Omanes
Stig
GH
Sasaki
KingWarman
Warmaster Horus
FactionHeir
Proletariat
Brave Sir Robin
Shlin28
woad&fangs
TwilightBlade
Sarathos
Husar
Beefy187
gibsonsg91921
CountArach
Martok
Xdeathfire
sapi
Tran
Northnovas
Xiahou
Hepcat
The Amazing Me
Dutch_guy
Jubal Barca
Haudegen
Zorg

Lynched (2)

Ichigo
Killfr3nzy

Killed (6)
Sigurd
pevergreen
Tiberius of the Drake
Roadkill
Zain
Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca

WoG
0



Suicided (2)

Enoch
Greaterkhaan


It's day. Start voting.

Caius
09-10-2007, 21:19
Fos:
Omanes
Stig
GH
Sasaki
KingWarman
Warmaster Horus
FactionHeir
Proletariat
Brave Sir Robin
Shlin28
woad&fangs
TwilightBlade
Sarathos
Husar
Beefy187
gibsonsg91921
CountArach
Martok
Xdeathfire
sapi
Tran
Northnovas
Xiahou
Hepcat
The Amazing Me
Dutch_guy
Jubal Barca
Haudegen
Zorg

:P. Better keep talking, my death wont be forgotten so easily.

Zain
09-10-2007, 21:41
... what the heck?

I was just getting into this.

:furious3:

GeneralHankerchief
09-10-2007, 21:52
Vote: shlin28

Zain
09-10-2007, 21:54
... what the heck?

I was just getting into this.

:furious3:

... that was immature of me.

What I meant to say was, seeing as to how this is my first Mafia, what did I do wrong?

RoadKill
09-10-2007, 21:55
Oh doesn't that suck.


... that was immature of me.

What I meant to say was, seeing as to how this is my first Mafia, what did I do wrong?

You didn't do anything wrong, the mafia kill whoever they see fit.

Caius
09-10-2007, 21:56
You know, if the townies are not smart enough, they will win easiliy.

Zain
09-10-2007, 22:00
Oh doesn't that suck.



You didn't do anything wrong, the mafia kill whoever they see fit.

Yep, that sucks...



You know, if the townies are not smart enough, they will win easiliy.

I think the mafia are smart, because they killed the smartest of us Townies...





I'm disappointed. :cry:

gibsonsg91921
09-10-2007, 22:22
vote: Sarathos

Stig
09-10-2007, 22:23
Was I going after Shlin in this game, or was that the other?

Caius
09-10-2007, 22:25
Was I going after Shlin in this game, or was that the other?
check it youself :whip:

GeneralHankerchief
09-10-2007, 22:25
This game.

You're going after woad&fangs in mine.

Stig
09-10-2007, 22:48
check it youself :whip:
Nah, eventually people tell you ~D

Vote: Shlin

Caius
09-10-2007, 22:49
Nah, eventually people tell you ~D

Vote: Shlin
Lazy Stig :whip:

Tratorix
09-10-2007, 22:50
I'll Vote:Shlin.

The way he tried to tip the votes in his favor to save himself last round seems scummy.

woad&fangs
09-10-2007, 23:06
vote: KillFr3nzy He should have been next to die. what gives?

Tratorix
09-10-2007, 23:20
....

We just lynched KillFr3nzy. :inquisitive:

woad&fangs
09-10-2007, 23:32
....

We just lynched KillFr3nzy. :inquisitive:
oops.

Proletariat
09-10-2007, 23:39
I'm totally lost in this game, will try and catch up. Had a busy weekend

Beefy187
09-10-2007, 23:49
Hmm i had an wierd dream... Inca being the mafia.

So im guessing theres two mafias left.

Vote: Brave Sir Robin

Got a feeling that this mafia is picking the kills randomly. So theres a possibility that this mafia dont know the players very well. His one of more active member compared to the rest so theres a pretty good chance of him being one of the three killers.

I still dont think Shlin is guilty. Because he seems to have given up pretty much. Thats Sarathos like behavior.

Also
FoS: Gibsonsg91921

for just jumping in to bandwagon with out any reason.

Twilight, Sarathos, Zorg, and Amazing Me (correct me if im wrong) got exam week. So I doubt that theyll be active for couple days.

TevashSzat
09-10-2007, 23:51
vote: Sarathos

Can you perhaps provide a reason??

Vote: Sarathos

I dunno, doesn't seem that shlin is scummy, but based on what he did last round, he will probably get lynched this round.

Beefy187
09-11-2007, 00:02
Can you provide reason why your voting for Sarathos?

Sarathos seems to be spamming like he normally does. Soon as his back from his math exam im sure hell be spamming more. So im pretty sure its not Sarathos

TevashSzat
09-11-2007, 00:28
Whoops made an error there :furious3:

Unvote, Vote: Gibson Your dirty mind tricks shall not work on me!

gibsonsg91921
09-11-2007, 00:42
I voted Sarathos - he seemed a bit too inquisitive about who was mafia, like hes trying to hide that he is.

and whats FoS?

woad&fangs
09-11-2007, 00:46
Finger of Suspicion
And that's actually a pretty solid point. What ever happened to Lurker Pride, Sarathos?

Zain
09-11-2007, 01:58
I, the ghost of Zain, curse whoever it was that killed me!! :skull:

But, it's okay, because I'm gonna play in another one day, and win.

Beefy187
09-11-2007, 02:09
Sarathos changed his playing style i guess.. Normally he gets lynched real early but this time his still alive. So he could be somewhat motivated by that.

UnFoS: Gibson

You got some reason now. I shall UnFoS you:yes:

Twilightblade
09-11-2007, 02:33
Finger of Suspicion
And that's actually a pretty solid point. What ever happened to Lurker Pride, Sarathos?

Sarathos lurks then spams then lurks again most of the time

Northnovas
09-11-2007, 02:54
Okay, I still can't figure this out to actually have a suspect because I don't know anyone. However, the experience players finger each other with suspicion on statements that do not make sense to me this early in the game but they see something or have us believe they do.
I don't want to be a "lurker" but I don't know what to really say. Though I guess I did post a bad thing being impatient.:shame:

CountArach
09-11-2007, 04:09
Nah, eventually people tell you ~D

Vote: Shlin
Stig, you seem incredibly eager to see shlin killed. Is there any particular reason to this. I will FoS: shlin for trying to tip the vote at the end of yesterday, but I shall Vote: Stig for appearing far too eager to vote for someone.

Caius
09-11-2007, 04:28
When I voted Stig for voting me, everyone started a bandagon against me!

FactionHeir
09-11-2007, 04:41
Something I don't understand is how 2 people "suicided"? How come it doesn't count as WoG?

As for suspicions... what CA said just now seemed very un-townie like.
vote: CA

Hepcat
09-11-2007, 05:23
Personally CountArach is the person I trust the least. He always seems to just try and get whoever is voting voted against. If someone votes, he immediately acts as if that person is suspicious. :inquisitive:

I think he's hiding something.

Vote: CountArach

CountArach
09-11-2007, 05:30
Damn typing! I just realised I said:


but I shall Vote: Stig for appearing far too eager to vote for someone.
I meant to say too eager to kill a single person. Rather than thinking through new evidence, he just follows an old trail.

Hepcat
09-11-2007, 06:01
Damn typing! I just realised I said:


I meant to say too eager to kill a single person. Rather than thinking through new evidence, he just follows an old trail.

It's interesting how your post at the start of the game showed how determined you were to kill someone.


I would vote Hanky, but we all know that this is the way he feels.

Vote: Martok

Prove you are innocent.

I don't trust you. By your own reasoning we should be suspicious of you. My vote stays where it is.
:inquisitive:

Beefy187
09-11-2007, 07:16
Suicide is where the players ask the host to kill them. WoG is where the player get killed by the host fro not being active.

CA seems suspecious. But my vote stays. Maybe ill go for him next round.

All alive players should post what they think about CA or kills in the past rounds so least people get a clue about stuff.

Sarathos
09-11-2007, 08:08
Sarathos seems to be spamming like he normally does

I dont spam.....

Sarathos
09-11-2007, 08:10
I voted Sarathos - he seemed a bit too inquisitive about who was mafia, like hes trying to hide that he is.

Woaw woaw man, i just asked two questions. Just trying to make conversation and maybe a bit of evidence or hints.....

Sarathos
09-11-2007, 08:12
What ever happened to Lurker Pride, Sarathos?

I still got it Woads, dont worry. Its just in this game I cant lurk to much or I will get WOGED.

Sarathos
09-11-2007, 08:19
Sarathos lurks then spams then lurks again most of the time

You normally just get lynchd/killed......

Sarathos
09-11-2007, 08:21
Vote: TwilightBlade for being so negatibe, unhelpful and so ragey (if that is even a word). Settle down TBlade and help us win.

Sarathos
09-11-2007, 08:23
Well I think i have answered all the questions and aided the discussion a fair bit now, I have done enough posting so someone else please take over.

FactionHeir
09-11-2007, 08:40
Sarathos seems to be spamming like he normally does


I dont spam.....

You really could have put all that in 1 post, at most 2.

CountArach
09-11-2007, 08:44
It's interesting how your post at the start of the game showed how determined you were to kill someone.
[SNIP]
I don't trust you. By your own reasoning we should be suspicious of you. My vote stays where it is.
:inquisitive:
I don't understand... My reasoning is that insisting that someone is lynched at the exclusion of all other people's evidence and arguments (As Stig did) is both scummy and unhelpful. It generates no extra conversation.

Stig
09-11-2007, 09:21
Stig, you seem incredibly eager to see shlin killed. Is there any particular reason to this. I will FoS: shlin for trying to tip the vote at the end of yesterday, but I shall Vote: Stig for appearing far too eager to vote for someone.
Shlin has been acting suspicious for the last 2 days.
But then, so have you.

Mafia: Shlin and CA ... nice possibility.
I'd say we tie them up, and let them fight it out.

Beefy187
09-11-2007, 10:07
I could lynch Sarathos for 3 reasons
1. Spamming
2. Bad reasoning of the vote
3. For being who he is:laugh4:

Ok back to the topic. It would be appreciated if someone can make some tally because im a little busy right now. If its Shlin vs CA i say CA is more scummy. Also i dont like the way Brave Sir Robin, Sarathos, Twilightblade, Factionheir are playing. So FOS them all.

Northnovas
09-11-2007, 10:56
Suicide is where the players ask the host to kill them. WoG is where the player get killed by the host fro not being active.

CA seems suspecious. But my vote stays. Maybe ill go for him next round.

All alive players should post what they think about CA or kills in the past rounds so least people get a clue about stuff.

Though I cannot do a statement analysis from the post I have to go with what I have been told.

We are in a mountain area that has snow and therefore is cold.
2 townies have been lynched
2 committed suicide
6 members have been murdered
There are 3 killers I think. 2 are Mafia; raven hair and sinister. The other killer only descriptors hiss in his talk, likes collecting things possible serial

Day 1

2 murders to start mercs/ raven hair and sinister/ Bodies are decapped and mutilated the heads are found in the soup

no townies but a member is lynched ichigo

Day 2

pevergreen/ raven hair/ mafia/ MOD drug overdose
Sigurd/ sinister/ mafia/ MOD blowed up and blowed up good too
Tiberius/ hissy/ serial/ MOD mutilated and lunch

Killfr3nzy lynched

Day 3

3 more murders and 2 suicides

Zain/ raven hair/ mafia/ MOD ice pick bleeds out
Garcilaso/ hissy/ serial/ MOD knife in the heart
Roadkill/ sinister/ mafia/ MOD run over playing on the road

Suicides

Enoch
Greaterhaan

I don't who they are yet but there should be 3 person of interest.

Omanes Alexandrapolites
09-11-2007, 17:00
Vote: woad&fangs

Was this post (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?p=1669999#post1669999) just a misunderstanding, or a sinister attempt to ensure that you look innocent? This vote is subject to change should you provide me with an adequate reason for your "mistake".

I also want to point the finger of suspicion Sarathos, for his abnormal rapid posting spree. Have you lost your edit button through warning points, or are you trying to increase your apparent in thread post count to avoid any suspicion being aroused over you? Correct me if I'm wrong, but as far as I remember, this isn't his usual behaviour.

Finally, I want to think about shlin. I am beginning to doubt his guilt the more I consider it, but I still am yet to trust him after his peculiar voting and post analysis actions earlier in the game. I am willing to place these ideas down to the fact that he is still learning, though, for now at least.

Xiahou
09-11-2007, 17:26
Vote: Abstain
for now....

Jubal_Barca
09-11-2007, 18:35
I agree with omanes. vote woad.

Andres
09-11-2007, 18:35
Tally:

Shlin28: 3 (GH, Stig, Brave Sir Robin)

woad&fangs: 2 (Omanes, Jubal_barca)
CountArach: 2 (FactionHeir, Hepcat)

Sarathos: 1 (gibson)
Brave Sir Robin: 1 (Beefy187)
Gibson: 1 (Xdeathfire)
Stig: 1 (CA)
TwilightBlade: 1 (Sarathos)


Abstain: 5 (TwilightBlade, w&f, Prole, Northnovas, Xiahou)
Not voting: 12 (Sasaki, KingWarman, Warmaster Horus, shlin28, Husar, Martok, sapi, Tran, The Amazing Me, Dutch_guy, Haudegen, Zorg)

Andres
09-11-2007, 20:47
This round will end within approx. 30 minutes...

:whip:

shlin28
09-11-2007, 21:06
Meh, I dont mind getting lynched, but in case my votes gets me suspicious again... Vote: Abstain

Husar
09-11-2007, 21:23
Pity, seems like I missed this round by approximately 4 minutes.

Warmaster Horus
09-11-2007, 21:28
Same here. Anyway, I don't have time to check the thread out yet, since I've got to go to bed in 3 minutes.

Andres
09-11-2007, 21:40
It's still open, you can still vote.

You have another 30 minutes, still have to finish something else.

EDIT: Meh, you can vote until I post again in the thread.

Andres
09-11-2007, 22:13
Voting closed. Stand by for execution.

Andres
09-11-2007, 22:48
Day 3 Conclusion : The Bald and the beautiful...

Andres was busy with his camel. No, not the cigarettes, Andres doesn't smoke. A real camel. Now, what did he need a camel for, high up in the mountains, while it was freezing outside? Well, let me explain. It is...

"Sir!"

"Can't you see I am telling a story?"

"But there's nobody here sir? Just that camel? What is a camel doing here sir?"

"Well, I was about to explain, but it can wait. You have a new suspect?"

"Yes sir, I'm proud to present to you a mafioso."

"Again? Are you sure this time?"

"Yes sir!"

"Who is it?"

"It is shlin28!"

"Shlin28? What ever happened with shlin01, shlin02, shlin03, shlin04, shlin05, shlin06, shlin07, shlin08, shlin09, shlin10 and all the other shlins?"

"Eh, I don't know sir..."

"Whatever," Andres murmured. "Is he bald?"

"Bald sir?"

"Yep, I need a bald suspect, so get this guy's head shaven."

A few moments later, the bald shlin28 was brought to Andres. "You see this camel? It has an electrocution device in its' behind. We have to put in the head of our suspect and he'll be electrocuted to dead. In the process, the camel will die as well and we'll have meat for tonight. Isn't that clever? I bought it at Mithrandir's incorporated."

"I object!"

"Huh?"

Martok stepped forward. "Sir, I object! You cannot kill the noble camel. This is outrageous. I refuse to obey your orders any longer, you cruel, sadistic camel killer!! I rather commit suicide!"

Andres watched Martok. Martok stared back.

"Well, what are you waiting for? Christmas? Commit suicide!"

"Eh, well, I didn't really thought... Hmmm... I don't have a weapon. If I would have a weapon, I would commit..."

The mercenaries all offered him their weapons. Within 30 seconds, Martok found himself under a pile of guns, rockets, grenades, knifes, ... He couldn't get up, the guns were to heavy. Without even saying "thank you" to his helpful colleagues, he accidentally pulled the pin out of a grenade. Five seconds later, everybody was covered in little pieces of Martok...

"Ok, now, can we put shlin28 into the camel?"

Without even having the chance to say a few last words, the unfortunate shlin28 found himself stuck with his head into the camel.

"Oh, I forgot, any last words shlin28?"

"Mmmm, mmmm, crough, mmm..."

"Interesting. Now, where's the power supply. Ah, here it is! And switch!"

A short bzzzzzzzt, a shivering shlin28 and a shivering camel. Some flames coming out of both shlin28 and the camel and within 30 seconds, it was over.

"Ok, get rid of the body. Tonight we have roasted camel on the menu!"

The men cheered.

"Enjoy your meal and good night!"



Tally

Shlin28: 3 (GH, Stig, Brave Sir Robin) :skull:
woad&fangs: 2 (Omanes, Jubal_barca)
CountArach: 2 (FactionHeir, Hepcat)
Sarathos: 1 (gibson)
Brave Sir Robin: 1 (Beefy187)
Gibson: 1 (Xdeathfire)
Stig: 1 (CA)
TwilightBlade: 1 (Sarathos)


Abstain: 8 (TwilightBlade, w&f, Prole, Northnovas, Xiahou, shlin28, Warmaster, Husar)
Not voting: 9 (Sasaki, KingWarman, Martok, sapi, Tran, The Amazing Me, Dutch_guy, Haudegen, Zorg)

Alive (27)

Omanes
Stig
GH
Sasaki
KingWarman
Warmaster Horus
FactionHeir
Proletariat
Brave Sir Robin
woad&fangs
TwilightBlade
Sarathos
Husar
Beefy187
gibsonsg91921
CountArach
Xdeathfire
sapi
Tran
Northnovas
Xiahou
Hepcat
The Amazing Me
Dutch_guy
Jubal Barca
Haudegen
Zorg

Lynched (3)

Ichigo
Killfr3nzy
shlin28

Killed (6)
Sigurd
pevergreen
Tiberius of the Drake
Roadkill
Zain
Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca

WoG
0



Suicided (3)

Enoch
Greaterkhaan
Martok



It's night. PM's please

gibsonsg91921
09-11-2007, 23:39
edit:

Why did Martok commit suicide?

Andres
09-11-2007, 23:45
edit:

Why did Martok commit suicide?

Players commit suicide for various reasons. They usually inform the host through pm. The most common reason is real life.

FactionHeir
09-12-2007, 02:14
That sounded so wrong

Sarathos
09-12-2007, 09:34
Mmmm yes. Well is anyone likey to be WOGEd, cause there seems to be alot of constant non voters. Sasaki especially..........

sapi
09-12-2007, 09:51
That sounded so wrong
:laugh4:

Hepcat
09-12-2007, 10:41
That's got to be the most ... err ... interesting method of execution I've ever seen. :sweatdrop:

Stig
09-12-2007, 10:49
Mmmm yes. Well is anyone likey to be WOGEd, cause there seems to be alot of constant non voters. Sasaki especially..........
Interested in getting Sasaki killed the easy way?
Maybe I'll vote you next round

shlin28
09-12-2007, 16:26
Why do I have to be killed this way!!! :wall:

Omanes Alexandrapolites
09-12-2007, 18:10
Sarathos and woad&fangs, you are yet to respond to my requests for answers last round. They can be found here (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?p=1670908#post1670908) by the way.

I would also like to add Stig onto my suspect list. His behaviour is abnormal and he also seems desperate to lynch for a peculiar reason. Of course, I could simply consider the fact that he is acting strangely as an indication of his innocence - I'm positive that Stig, as a mafioso, would be more cautious.

Stig
09-12-2007, 18:35
Yup true, I draw too much attention like this.

Ofcourse we could start WIFOM'ing, but that ain't really a good thing

Hepcat
09-12-2007, 19:34
I'm still not sure about CountArach. If he is suddenly becoming a lurker to try and shake attention off him then it's not fooling me. :inquisitive:

Csargo
09-12-2007, 20:38
KILL HEPCAT RAR!!!

Andres
09-12-2007, 22:26
Night 4 – a deadly dead camel, strangling, KABOUM!

The camel meat wasn’t a big success… Everybody was upset about the killing of such a noble animal and the men refused to eat the meat.

Zorg however, was very hungry and he didn’t seem to have a problem with eating the meat of the rather filthy animal.

So, at night, he got out of his tent, looking for the dead beast.

“Looking for a piece of meat?” a sinister voice sounded in the dark.

“Eh, yes.” Zorg answered. “Aren’t you hungry as well?”

“Yeah” the man with the sinister voice said. “I heard the best parts of meat are, eh, well, where our captain has attached the electrocution device.”

“Oh no, I don’t want to put my arms in that.”

“Why don’t you put your head in it?” the man asked.

“That’s disgusting.”

The Mafioso drew his gun and pointed it at Zorg. “Get you head into that camel, now.”

“Eh, ok, ok, if you insist. I do hope it is indeed the best part of the meat…” Zorg put his head in the, hm, eh, well, you know what I mean, don’t you?

“Guess that saves me a bullet”, the Mafioso said and he pulled the switch. A short bzzzzzt, some flames and Zorg was no more…



Beefy187 was watching the stars. It was the first night without snow and the sky was very clear.

He didn’t notice a dark sneaky figure coming near.

The dark shadow held the remains of Zain’s groin in his hands.

“What’s that strange smell?” Beefy asked himself.

Before he could turn his head, he got strangled with said remains of said groin…

The last thing he saw, was a raven hair falling on his shoulder…


Nature called Proletariat. Beeing the only woman among a bunch of rude mercenaries, she had to make a long walk to find a safe spot to do what you need to do when nature calls.

While she was relieving herself in the torture chamber, the only place where she had some privacy, she noticed one of the mercenaries watching her.

“You dirty voyeur! Go away!”

“I am looking for my knife.”

“Well, there ain’t no knives here, you dirty, little pervert!”

“What a pity! I would have thought there were some here in the torture chamber. But look at what I found! A grenade! Thissss came from the pile Martok was buried under.”

“Oh, nice, a grenade, “ Prole said, unimpressed. “I never saw a grenade before! Oh, you are so cool and sexy. A grenaaade!”

“Do I ssssssmell sssssarcassssm there?”

“You bet you do! Go away man! Sick pervert!”

“Hmmm… Well, I have enough heads already. Maybe it is time for some KABOUM KABOUM!”

“KABOUM KABOUM? And what do you mean, enough heads?” Prole asked. Suddenly she realised who she was talking to. “Oh no” was the last thing she whispered before the maniac put a grenade into her mouth and chained her.

“Now I will try to get the pin out of the grenade with thissss whippy whip!”

Needless to say, our maniac missed quite a few times, but eventually, he was successful. And there goes the pin!

“KABOUM!”

The serial killer, covered in blood, brains and fractions of bone looked disappointed. “KABOUM? No KABOUM KABOUM? Boehoehoehoe :bigcry: ! I want my mama! Thosssse toyssss don’t work like they sssshould! No KABOUM KABOUM! Bah, I want more headssss! The headssss will tell me how to make KABOUM KABOUM!” The serial killer went back to the camp, happy like a child, constantly hissing “Headsss, headssss, KABOUM KABOUM! Hihihihii!”

Day 4 : Long live democracy!

“Sir!”

“Yes, Mister Union! I recon we had a peaceful night, without any killings?”

“Ehrm…”

“What?”

“We found Zorg with his head into the electrocution camel….”

“What? What was he doing there?”

“Apparently, he stuck his head into the camel and somebody pulled the switch. We also found…”

“What? More killings?”

“I’m afraid so, sir. We also found Beefy187 strangled with body parts from Zain. And Proletariat was, well, we didn’t really found her, but we found her necklace between some body parts, so we have reasons to believe…”

“Ok, ok, ok.. You still sure about the no torturing part?”

“Eh, hmmm…, that is, well…”

“Ok, ok, you wanted democracy, you’ll get democracy. Besides, I must say that I’m starting to enjoy this whole thriller. Go ahead guys. Vote.”

Alive (24)

Omanes
Stig
GH
Sasaki
KingWarman
Warmaster Horus
FactionHeir
Brave Sir Robin
woad&fangs
TwilightBlade
Sarathos
Husar
gibsonsg91921
CountArach
Xdeathfire
sapi
Tran
Northnovas
Xiahou
Hepcat
The Amazing Me
Dutch_guy
Jubal Barca
Haudegen


Lynched (3)

Ichigo
Killfr3nzy
shlin28

Killed (9)
Sigurd
pevergreen
Tiberius of the Drake
Roadkill
Zain
Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca
Proletariat
Zorg
Beefy187

WoG
0



Suicided (3)

Enoch
Greaterkhaan
Martok



It’s day. Start voting.

Stig
09-12-2007, 22:54
Vote: Sarathos, kinda too active to my liking

Beefy187
09-12-2007, 23:10
:applause:

Thanks mafia for being kind enough to kill me instead of lynching me. Good luck townies:yes:

Csargo
09-12-2007, 23:17
Sarathos seems like a good lynch. Kinda over the top and contradicting himself...

Twilightblade
09-12-2007, 23:42
But thats how sarathos is normally
I dunno but he seems clean for the moment

Beefy187
09-13-2007, 00:04
All 3 villains are still out there.. Cmon towns!!:whip:

I rekon Mafia decided that theyve got a better chance taking a nap then actively joining the discussion. So i suggest lynching someone who just manages to stay out of WoG and still not very active in the discussion.

GeneralHankerchief
09-13-2007, 00:08
Vote: Xiahou

Without commenting on your possible guilt in Mafia VII, Kommodus did mention in his Holmes report that you post less often when you're a mafioso, as if playing a more cautious game. I believe that this is the case here.

Husar
09-13-2007, 00:22
All 3 villains are still out there.. Cmon towns!!:whip:
Well, the first and second kill sound like they're done by one and the same person, no? The kills never mention two people but the guy has Zain's groin so the kills are successive. We might have gotten one already.

I am a bit suspicious of Stig for the reason Omanes mentioned, he seems very eager to lynch a certain person.

What GH says about Xiahou might be importantn but I got the feeling there were a few active players in GH's game who aren't all that active here.:whip:

Beefy187
09-13-2007, 00:34
This is from Northnovas theory

2 mafia
1 mafia is sinister
1 mafia is raven hair

from the kill description theres 2 mafia left.. And wierd cannival dude as well

Northnovas
09-13-2007, 00:50
Vote: Xiahou

Without commenting on your possible guilt in Mafia VII, Kommodus did mention in his Holmes report that you post less often when you're a mafioso, as if playing a more cautious game. I believe that this is the case here.

Interesting theory, I examined the post count and was surprised at the results. The dead people were basically the most active townies. We still have three killers.
Looking at the remaining townies with the exception of a few with high post count and when they posted the FoS can be drawn to a small group.

gibsonsg91921
09-13-2007, 01:04
Vote: Sarathos

I still don't trust u

Northnovas
09-13-2007, 01:23
Okay, this isn't an official talley. I can't believe I bothered to do this but I also didn't think I would get this far. In case of my demise here is another high tech graphic.

A lot of post say a vote or give clarification and a few were interesting when being looked at in the present.

There are some with very view that could raise FoS too. However, from what I have reviewed I think I could FoS mafia members and possible the serial killer and not by lowest post.
It's only one vote. mmmmm let me think here??:inquisitive:

Omanes 11
Stig 17
GH 18
Sasaki 5
KingWarman 1
Warmaster Horus 4
FactionHeir 20
Brave Sir Robin 9
woad&fangs 10
TwilightBlade 10
Sarathos 19 DID NOT POST TILL AFTER NIGHT 2
Husar 12
gibsonsg91921 5
CountArach 7
Xdeathfire 7
sapi 6
Tran 2
Northnovas 6
Xiahou 5
Hepcat 15
The Amazing Me 1
Dutch_guy 2
Jubal Barca 6
Haudegen 3

woad&fangs
09-13-2007, 01:32
looking at the posting tally(thanks Nov) my initial impression is that Sarathos has a lot more posts than usual and Sasaki has a lot less. All the other people I have played with seem at about their usual level of participation.
vote: Sarathos

Husar
09-13-2007, 01:36
Okay, this isn't an official talley. I can't believe I bothered to do this but I also didn't think I would get this far. In case of my demise here is another high tech graphic.
You know, when you're in the Gameroom you can just click the postcount number next to the thread to get exactly the statistic you just made, ordered by highest postcount.

Northnovas
09-13-2007, 01:50
You know, when you're in the Gameroom you can just click the postcount number next to the thread to get exactly the statistic you just made, ordered by highest postcount.

That is so cool I learn something everyday. The secrets of the ORG. Thanks,

Vote: Sarathos

Zain
09-13-2007, 01:52
You know, when you're in the Gameroom you can just click the postcount number next to the thread to get exactly the statistic you just made, ordered by highest postcount.

:laugh4:

Could've saved you a bit of time, eh Nov?

Beefy187
09-13-2007, 01:52
But nice idea and good work Northnovas!

As a dead mercenary wanting revenge for getting killed in the most gross way possible.. I shall continue supporting the towns eventhough im dead (Got nothing better to do)

If you keep killing active members youll find your self in big trouble. Reason of Sarathos having lots and lots of post are because he posted lots of short posts. This is getting too much attention and thus un mafia like behavior from me. I believe mafia was active on the first half and suddenly started to quiet down. So for the sake of game play I suggest leaving the member with lots of posts alone for now. Lynch the people who have posted for 5- 15 posts. The rest of the members under 5 posts can be left for WoG kill.

I would say the mafia are most likely not very experienced for killing the lurker (Zorg) and suicidal idiot (Beefy):clown: .

Theory one is the mafia has something against me and Zorg. Meaning Sarathos or Twilightblade is the mafia. But that is not likely

Theory two is mafia is new comer and killing people randomly.

Theory three is that mafia is highly experienced and if thats the case s/he is too good for my analysis.

Serial killer are probebly active member but he can be left for now because s/he has a possibility of killing the mafia which will save the townie one voting oppotunity.

I dont think Sarathos got any exams today so he can show up and defend him self. and i bet 5 bucks that what i said will be either ignored or half of it is not understandable/not useful.

Hire the real Holmes/ Kommodus. His analysis is far better then the wannabe Holmes/ Beefy:smash:

Proletariat
09-13-2007, 01:54
Oh, real nice way to go.

:help:

Northnovas
09-13-2007, 01:58
Theory one is the mafia has something against me and Zorg. Meaning Sarathos or Twilightblade is the mafia. But that is not likely.

It would have saved me some time!! Why would those 2 not be mafia? There was something in the exchange of post that made me suspicious and Sarathos did post after the 2nd night.

Zain
09-13-2007, 02:00
... seems like I've been ignored this entire time, and the only person who's said anything to me is Andres, when I asked him some questions.

Am I invisible? Or am I just the noob that nobody cares for?

woad&fangs
09-13-2007, 02:01
My vote for sarathos still stands but we should avoid lynching active players unless we are confident of their guilt. The mafia has already won to many games by getting rid of active members early and then just barely avoiding the WoG.

TevashSzat
09-13-2007, 02:53
Very tempted to bandwagon on Sarathos atm.

But, when looking at post count, Tran seems a bit too inactive given his usualy style of playing so

Vote:Tran

RoadKill
09-13-2007, 02:58
Just to remind you guys, don't listen to those who say let teh lurkers get Woged, becuase in a lot of mafia games, when I was mafia, I usually lurk and no one votes for me, and then I slowly get rid of everyone and win, look at farmtown, me and Tran lurked and won.

Beefy187
09-13-2007, 04:02
True that.. Then Sasaki will get suspecious.

Andres when is the lurkers getting WoGged? How many more nights do they have?

FactionHeir
09-13-2007, 04:08
Actually, I ran the post count thing as Husar suggested and found that everyone still alive seems to have posted at least twice in this topic, i.e. 1 for sign up, 1 during game (assumedly), so there won't be any WoGs sadly...
That said, it could be a Mafia lurker among them.

Still, I still suspect CA, so vote: CA

Zain
09-13-2007, 04:09
... seems like I've been ignored this entire time, and the only person who's said anything to me is Andres, when I asked him some questions.

Am I invisible? Or am I just the noob that nobody cares for?

No response once again?

FactionHeir
09-13-2007, 04:11
Wind must be funny today. Thought I hear voices or so. *shrug* :wink:

Beefy187
09-13-2007, 04:33
Hi Zain! :laugh4:
Who do you think the mafia is?

Hepcat
09-13-2007, 07:12
I'm sure it's CountArach, I don't trust him one bit. The only other person I have suspicions about is Sarathos, but I think CountArach is more likely. I think maybe he hasn't killed me because if he did it would look suspicious if the person who said he was Mafia died.
But I see through your tricks. :inquisitive:

Vote: CountArach

CountArach
09-13-2007, 08:14
It's because I'm Australian you filthy sheep shagger :wink:

FactionHeir, can you point me to the post where you summed up your suspisions of me?

As to Sarathos being guilty, I am not so sure. The kills so far seem to be those who he associates with in real life, and I highly doubt he would kill them for that reason. However, it wcould be argued we could invoke WIFOM and indeed that is why he is killing them. I would like to hear something from Sarathos.

Gibsong has been tweaking my suspicion a bit. Look at his last post for example:

Vote: Sarathos

I still don't trust u
A pure and blatant bandwagon. So I shall Vote: Gibsong

Omanes Alexandrapolites
09-13-2007, 08:35
Vote: Sarathos

You still haven't replied to this (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?p=1670908#post1670908). Neither has woad&fangs, but his comment could have simply been a mistake. Sarathos currently has no excuse for his peculiar and abnormal behaviour.

Sarathos
09-13-2007, 09:17
Guys settle down, the reason i didnt post till night two is that its exam week at school. I was strangly enough studing fo these and did know that game had started, I posted after night two so i didnt get WOGEd. And Stig if you think im too active i will lurk again if you want, i always get lynched for being inactive/lurking and now i am active and trying to help and im still suspious and prob going to be lynched...wtf guys :inquisitive:
Same thing applies to you Omanes

Sarathos
09-13-2007, 09:20
Sarathos currently has no excuse for his peculiar and abnormal behaviour.

So being active and trying to help the town is abnormal...?????
And what do you want me to answer??? The only reason im posting alot is to help everyone and try not to look suspious by not posting and considered be a lurker, I really could care about my post count or number of posts in a thread.

Hepcat
09-13-2007, 09:42
It's because I'm Australian you filthy sheep shagger :wink:
:laugh4:

I knew that comment was coming sooner or later. ~D
But the truth is that I still don't trust you. The first time I voted for you was because you are an Aussie, the other times are because I think you're an evil Mafioso.

:inquisitive:

Twilightblade
09-13-2007, 09:44
Vote: Omanes
Sarathos isnt being unusuall, he lurks spams and then lurks again its what he does

Beefy187
09-13-2007, 09:46
Sarathos has been getting way too much attention. Sarathos isnt complete dumb ass like me. Im sure he would be more cautious and play in role (Lurk like always). If the game doesnt finish in the next 2 or 3 rounds then go for it. But unless you got no one better to vote for, Sarathos should be left alone. Right now there are some good lynch option available like CA and Tran.

Sarathos
09-13-2007, 09:47
I would like to hear something from Sarathos.
Ask away CA

Omanes Alexandrapolites
09-13-2007, 10:32
Vote: Omanes
Sarathos isnt being unusuall, he lurks spams and then lurks again its what he doesThat is not how I remember playing with him - he used to be a rather quiet player who most certainly didn't repetitively post like he is doing at current.

My vote still stands - it's clear that he still has post editing abilities, so the only excuse he could possibly provide to appease me cannot be used. He also contradicts himself here (https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?p=1672913#post1672913).

On a different note, why are you so eager to defend Sarathos twilightblade? Do you honestly trust in his innocence, or is the reason a little more sinister?

Husar
09-13-2007, 11:02
Oh, real nice way to go.

:help:
Reminds you of the chat in some way, doesn't it? :laugh4:

Vote: Sarathos

Well, two reasons:

1. he might be guilty because some of you say so

2. if he is innocent, we can finally stop talking about him and concentrate on someone else

for now he looks like the best choice because discussion is focused around him.

sapi
09-13-2007, 12:08
Vote: Sarathos

We're focusing too much on him, as Husar pointed out.
I buy much of Omanes' case
Double posting irritates me ~:)

Haudegen
09-13-2007, 16:07
I'm sure it's CountArach, I don't trust him one bit. The only other person I have suspicions about is Sarathos, but I think CountArach is more likely. I think maybe he hasn't killed me because if he did it would look suspicious if the person who said he was Mafia died.
But I see through your tricks. :inquisitive:

Vote: CountArach

Vote: Count Arach

I have still no clue, who is guilty or not. The case against Sarathos doesn´t seem compelling to me either. Therefore I´ll place my faith on Hepcat´s intuition this time.

shlin28
09-13-2007, 17:59
Some advice from the dead :beam:
1. The guy who killed Zorg is an idiot, Zorg is not really that active...
2. From this, it can be reasoned that the mafia is a newbie.
3. Ichigo seemed unusually upset when he was mistakenly lynched (sorry!), but as Stig said, a good townie does not fear death, so he could possibly have a role.
4. CountArach is suspicious, so is Sarathos, but Beefty said that it might be TwilightBlade, as I said before I had always thought Twilight suspicious.
5. Stig went after me like a merciless hound, but he seemed to be unsually concentrated on me, any evidence? He could be trying too hard, but he did not actually think about other people's possible scumminess...

Stig
09-13-2007, 18:47
It's my style Shlin, and actually I am concentrating on others, but I don't say so in the thread.

Tratorix
09-13-2007, 20:14
I'm sure it's CountArach, I don't trust him one bit. The only other person I have suspicions about is Sarathos, but I think CountArach is more likely. I think maybe he hasn't killed me because if he did it would look suspicious if the person who said he was Mafia died.
But I see through your tricks. :inquisitive:

Vote: CountArach


You're sure it's CA? I don't see what hes done so far thats really suspicious. You seem to be pushing for his lynching on next to nothing.

I'll Vote:Sarathos. Like Husar said, once he's dead we can move on to more likely suspects. Plus, the whole spamming posts thing is getting on my nerves.

Xiahou
09-13-2007, 20:26
They're both suspicious, but CA has far less posts than Sarathos. I tend to think that as mafia, both would want to maintain a lower profile.

vote:Count Arach

Let's hope we're right.

Andres
09-13-2007, 22:32
Voting closed. Votes will be counted.

gibsonsg91921
09-13-2007, 22:51
Gibsong has been tweaking my suspicion a bit. Look at his last post for example:

A pure and blatant bandwagon. So I shall Vote: Gibsong

Bandwagon? I'm the one who insinuated against him in the first place mister. You're next - acting kind of suspicious.

Andres
09-13-2007, 23:02
Day 4 : conclusion: no spamming.

"Sir!" the annoying Union man shouted.

"Yeah, what?"

"We found the last remaing mafioso sir."

"You think so?"

"Yes, here he is, it is Sarathos."

"Sarathos? Ah, well, he doesn't look guilty to me..."

"But sir! We saw him eating spam!"

"Sooo....?"

"Spam is not good! Spamming must be punished!"

"Spamming does not make a mafioso."

"But he annoys us sir."

"Ok, ok. 'Democracy' has decided. Who am I to argue with the majority."

"Well, it seems like the electro camel is broken, so we'll have to try something new... But today, I am too lazy to torture somebody to death. Any volunteers?"

Nobody said a word.

"Ok, well, instead of killing him, shouldn't we just warn him not to do it again."

"But sir, that won't the spamming. And a spammer is clearly a mafioso. Kill him!"

"Yeah!" the man shouted, "Kill the spammer!"

"Well, let us spam bullets on him, shall we?"

The men cheered.

Sarathos was put against a wall.

"Sarathos, do you have any last....?"

BAM BAM BAM! BAM BAM BAM ! BAM BAM BAM BAM BAM BAM...!

The men couldn't wait any longer and they kept firing at the unfortunate Sarathos. After thirty minutes, everybody was out of bullets. The body of Sarathos was nothing more but a pile of blood, flesh and broken bones.

"Reduced to spam. The only right way for him to die." the Union man murmured.

"Good night guys. Hope to see you all back in the morning..."

The mercenaries shivered...

Sasaki, The Amazing Me and KingWarman were still standing next to the body. All of the sudden, the camel came to life again and jumped upon the unfortunate Sasaki, The Amazing Me and KingWarman. Their heads got stuck into the camel. Sasaki tried to get out, but accidentally pulled the switch. Bzzzzzzt. Some flames and the three men were dead.

"What an unfortunate incident" Andres said, looking disappointed because he wouldn't have the chance to torture this silent trio...

Tally

Sarathos : 8 (Brave Sir Robin, sapi, Omanes, Stig, Northnovas, woad&fangs, gibsonsg91921, Husar) :skull:

CountArach: 4 (FactionHeir, Xiahou, Hepcat, Haudegen)
Tran: 1 (Xdeathfire)
Xiahou: 1 (GH)
gibsons91921: 1 (CountArach)
Omanes: 1 (TwilightBlade)

Abstain : 0
Not voting : 7 (Sasaki, KingWarman, Warmaster Horus, Sarathos, Tran, Jubal Barca, Dutch_guy)


Alive (20)

Omanes
Stig
GH
Warmaster Horus
FactionHeir
Brave Sir Robin
woad&fangs
TwilightBlade
Husar
gibsonsg91921
CountArach
Xdeathfire
sapi
Tran
Northnovas
Xiahou
Hepcat
Dutch_guy
Jubal Barca
Haudegen


Lynched (4)

Ichigo
Killfr3nzy
shlin28
Sarathos

Killed (9)
Sigurd
pevergreen
Tiberius of the Drake
Roadkill
Zain
Garcilaso de la Vega el Inca
Proletariat
Zorg
Beefy187

WoG (3)
Sasaki
KingWarman
The Amazing Me


Suicided (3)

Enoch
Greaterkhaan
Martok

It's night. PM's please.

Stig
09-13-2007, 23:15
wowah, you WoG'ed Sasaki ~D

Andres
09-13-2007, 23:17
wowah, you WoG'ed Sasaki ~D

No post in three day phases in a row. Rules are rules :shrug:

Beefy187
09-13-2007, 23:25
If youre a mafia and havnt posted for 3 days can you get WoGged?

Andres
09-13-2007, 23:28
If youre a mafia and havnt posted for 3 days can you get WoGged?

:yes:

Northnovas
09-14-2007, 00:48
Wow! 4 more people gone. However, the three WoG were not on my suspect list. If we are right with the vote then there should only be 2 killings???
If we are still guessing then there is gonna be trouble tonight.:help:

woad&fangs
09-14-2007, 00:51
Often times the mafia has a set number of kills per night regardless of how many are still alive. However if we lynch the serial killer or the mafia kills the serial killer than it will indeed be down to 2 kills per night.

Sarathos
09-14-2007, 01:06
GG guys yet another town lynch, looks the the experienced mafia players are losing their touch and the newbies bandwagon to easy...

An example of this was the fact that the discussion was based too much around me. That was all your own faults, no one had any evidence at all so I really dont see why I was even suspected. Also the fact that I lynched for being active really annoys me, I used to always lurk to let every else play the game and of course I always got lynched, now I try to be bold and active and maybe help out. This is the second time I have been lynched for being active, may I ask what the hell you guys want.!!!???

Csargo
09-14-2007, 02:00
A donut

Husar
09-14-2007, 03:00
Also the fact that I lynched for being active really annoys me, I used to always lurk to let every else play the game and of course I always got lynched, now I try to be bold and active and maybe help out.
You might try not to go from 0 to 100 in two games, just surface slowly. Your quadruple posting was rather over the top and thus you generated discussion. Sometimes you also have to try a new tactic and fail, I was lynched like that in Mafia VII. Ok, and I was away from the PC for a day.:laugh4:

edit: and by the way, I was mad about that at first but realized that I might have done the same and noone really hates me or anything so it's all fine and it's just a game after all.

Tratorix
09-14-2007, 03:08
Exactly. It's nothing personal Sarathos, but when you go from lurker pride to being one of the game's top contributers, people are bound to get suspicious.

Beefy187
09-14-2007, 03:32
Look what youve done townies.. You turn Sarathos in to miserable Emo..:laugh4:

If you turn out to be innocent ill give you a hug Sarathos.:yes:

and btw even though im dead..

FoS: Jubal Barca

You seem to be active in other thread. Why not in this game?

Twilightblade
09-14-2007, 05:05
A donut

A coffee wouldn't go amiss either