Pub Crawl Massacre [Concluded] [Archive] - Page 2

Proletariat

11-10-2007, 02:07

After more drinking and arguing, it was decided that Warmaster had to go. It was just then that Tribesman was seen stumbling through the bar's entrance. He came over to the group once he recognised his Org buddies, and was quickly filled in on the evening so far. 'well , allow me !' he said. 'I've been waiting to try out my new axe !' And before anyone could stop him, Warmaster was hacked to bits. 'Now you drunks be careful, this is a dangerous night to be out drinking ! What a mad city !'

Voting:
Warmaster 2 - Xiahou, Andres
Beefy 1 - shlin
Caius 1 - FH,
Xiahou 1 - Beefy

Alive
----
Xiahou
Beefy
shlin
FactionHeir
Andres
Garcilaso

Killed
-----
Prole (narrator)
Ichi
pevergreen
Husar

Lynched
--------
Waldinger
Sarathos
Craterus
Warmaster

Husar

11-10-2007, 02:24

Yeah, Tribesman killed someone, my dream has become true. :2thumbsup:

Beefy187

11-10-2007, 12:23

Oh my... I though WH had more votes:sweatdrop:

Proletariat

11-12-2007, 14:37

Andres bought the farm, it's voting phase now, I'll post the write up when I get a chance this morning

Alive
----
Xiahou
Beefy
shlin
FactionHeir
Garcilaso

Killed
-----
Prole (narrator)
Ichi
pevergreen
Husar
Andres

Lynched
--------
Waldinger
Sarathos
Craterus
Warmaster

Andres

11-12-2007, 14:57

Hmmm... It's probably Xiahou then.

woad&fangs

11-12-2007, 18:38

I would lynch Shlin28.

FactionHeir

11-12-2007, 18:54

woad&fangs

11-12-2007, 18:56

I'll vouch on behalf of Beefy. He just isn't the kind of person that would use his first kill on the host.

shlin28

11-12-2007, 19:07

Vote Xiahou

See previous rounds for reason

FactionHeir

11-12-2007, 19:43

I'll vouch on behalf of Beefy. He just isn't the kind of person that would use his first kill on the host.

The problem is that while you don't think he would, isn't that good reason for him to do it?

Andres

11-12-2007, 22:06

Hmm Prole, would you WoG Caius if he sent PMs but did not vote in this thread? If not, I'll vote him, but otherwise....

vote: Beefy

Because Husar thinks Xiahou is innocent and Andres thinks the same of shlin. No-one has vouched for Beefy though and I don't know him well enough to determine whether he is guilty or not.

I didn't vouch for shlin28, I just said that he doesn't strike me as guilty.

Can you explain your vote for Beefy187? Why do you think he is guilty? Which posts in particular drew your attention and what is "wrong" with them?

Husar

11-12-2007, 22:46

I don't think Xiahou is innocent anymore, I said before that I wouldn't lynch him then but right now I think he'd be a good lynch, actually.
He or maybe FactionHeir.

FactionHeir

11-12-2007, 23:25

I didn't vouch for shlin28, I just said that he doesn't strike me as guilty.

Can you explain your vote for Beefy187? Why do you think he is guilty? Which posts in particular drew your attention and what is "wrong" with them?

To be honest with you, none of the alive have made any obvious comments that would point to their undeniable guilt, so its really just a 25% chance of lynching the right guy. Beefy started out making good comments and analyses but in the last few phases started lurking more and posting nonsensical stuff as if to hide something.

I don't think shlin is guilty just yet because he did vote a dead player (or was that a ruse?) and Xiahou...I don't know. I hardly ever play the same game as he does and he's a Senior Member too, so I'm not voting him just yet unless he incriminates himself further.

Caius...well I want to vote him, but he might get WoG'ed anyway depending on Prole's verdict, so I won't vote him unless she confirms that PMing but non voting players won't get WoG'ed.

Husar

11-12-2007, 23:38

Xiahou...I don't know. I hardly ever play the same game as he does and he's a Senior Member too, so I'm not voting him just yet unless he incriminates himself further.
What does being a senior Member have to do with mafia games?
And Xiahou was ranting a lot about how stupid and useless killing the gamemaster would be, maybe he planned it to use it as cover by making us believe that he'd never do such a thing.

The thing about Mr. Garcilaso not posting is interesting as well.

Xiahou

11-13-2007, 03:30

vote:Beefy
There really is no explanation for him still being alive at this point. He seems out of character from the few other games I've been in too.

Husar

11-13-2007, 03:46

Well, beefy did ask whether anyone could prove Xiahou's innocence... :inquisitive:

Proletariat

11-13-2007, 03:50

Gonna WoG Caius now, it should've happened at the beginning of this voting/drinking phase, sorry about that. Since that takes us down to four drunkards, I'll extend this voting a little longer (until morning here, roughly 10 hours from now)

Alive
----
Xiahou
Beefy
shlin
FactionHeir

Killed
-----
Prole (narrator)
Ichi
pevergreen
Husar
Andres

Lynched
--------
Waldinger
Sarathos
Craterus
Warmaster

WoGed
-------
Caius

Husar

11-13-2007, 04:35

One gone, four to go:

Does Beefy have an opinion on the matter? :inquisitive:

Could shlin explain his reasons again or quote them again because this is the last round? :inquisitive:

Could Xiahou expand a bit more as well for the same reason? :inquisitive:

And finally FactionHeir gave somewhat detailed thoughts already it seems. :2thumbsup:

Don't just abandon the game once it gets hot. :sweatdrop:

I wouldn't be surprised if our teetotaler wins this one, be aware that means one month no beer in the Gameroom guys! :whip:

pevergreen

11-13-2007, 04:55

Xiahou
Beefy
shlin
FactionHeir

Most likely it is FactionHeir

Beefy187

11-13-2007, 04:58

Sorry for long absense apologies..Ive been busy and couldnt post like usual. Now If im a scum I swear I wont use "Busy" as my excuse because I try not to use those trick in this game

Now I know im innocent me self. I would suicide if im asked to if that helps.

Since im innocent the reason of 2 players who voted for me seems scummy especially Xiahou. His one looks like one desperate bandwagon to get someone beside him self lynched.

looks like If we get this wrong we lose.

Vote: Xiahou

pevergreen

11-13-2007, 05:00

yes its lyol.

Xiahou is innocent.

Beefy187

11-13-2007, 05:02

If you are absolutely sure that it must be FH

unvote: Vote: FH

pevergreen

11-13-2007, 05:04

I am not absolutely sure.

Let me check something.

Beefy187

11-13-2007, 08:24

Done yet?

Xiahou

11-13-2007, 10:37

How do we know it's not Beefy?

I thought FH seemed pretty unscummy (but then, I guess that would be the idea wouldn't it?)... :shrug:

pevergreen

11-13-2007, 10:51

I cant find the PM. :angry:

I cant tell who out of the three it is.

Husar

11-13-2007, 12:38

And there we go without a clue,
led astray by the scum,
sitting on our mental bum,
voting away into the blue.

:sweatdrop:

Beefy187

11-13-2007, 13:32

Why not beefy xiahou asked
Ask your heart mate. Do I look like scum?
If you do think im a scum, you better call your mum
Coz everyone knows it. Im not masked.

crappy poem i know

Cant beat husars..:laugh4:

I am pretty sure that I am not and I will not use busy as a excuse in mafia game. I was seriously busy thats why I couldnt post often

If you cant find evidence then im back to Xiahou

unvote: FH Vote: Xiahou

Edited Myrddraal. I shall dance on the table and shout out "LIVERPOOL" to prove me innocence

Myrddraal

11-13-2007, 13:36

Please don't swear to things in Mafia games Beefy... :sad: Just my 2p

FactionHeir

11-13-2007, 15:59

Either Beefy is really desperate to save his hide or he really is innocent.
I'll leave my vote as it is currently, but I'm also interested in hearing what shlin thinks.

Btw, is this really the last round? We are 4 alive and lynch one. So that leaves 3 and mafia kills 1 presumably. So there's 2 left in the last day phase?

Proletariat

11-13-2007, 16:08

That's right, but I think in that scenario, should it occur, mafia would win anyway. Presumably the mafia won't vote for himself and the lone other townie wouldn't have much support in pulling off a 'lynch' so...

By my count, there's two votes for Xiahou and two votes for Beefy atm

FactionHeir

11-13-2007, 16:10

Husar

11-13-2007, 17:07

We have a tie,
the scum is nearby,
we have to make him fly,
the ugly spy.

:juggle2:

So I guess the game is over once someone changes the vote? In that case we have several possible scenarios. If it's shlin or FH, then changing their vote ends the game in their favour with a townie lynch, that may indicate that FH is innocent, shlin didn't post since the latest developments ocurred.
If it's beefy or Xiahou, then switching votes would mean they're dead, neither of them should do that, scum or not (ok, actually if the mafioso would switch to himself that would be very nice of course). If shlin posts now without changing his vote, we know it's either Xiahou or beefy I guess.
Or we get a new deadline, but so far we didn't.

I'm currently leaning towards Xiahou being our criminal mastermind, he'd be the kind of guy to kill all the innocents and the detective, plus our gamemaster early on. The kill of the gamemaster, if you look at it, didn't grant us a single voting round more, we'd just be three instead of four people in the last round then and Xiahou is the kind of guy who'd calculate that, I think. :sweatdrop:
He was the one who cried it was a stupid, wasted kill etc. while in fact, it isn't, we'd have one townie less now, thus one less suspect and the same number of rounds -> great way to make the end more confusing. :inquisitive:

I wouldn't decide it now though, beefie was a bit too quiet to say anything substantial about him.

FactionHeir

11-13-2007, 17:17

There is no tie.

Beefy - FH, XH
XH - Beefy

Proletariat

11-13-2007, 17:29

https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showpost.php?p=1745575&postcount=259

I've got shlin voting for Xiahou two posts after you voted for beefy, FactionHeir. I have been sick and am a bit exhausted, so maybe I'm just over looking something, but I've gone over the votes twice now and still see the same 2-2 tie. Anyway, if I'm wrong, Xiahou's cooked, and if I'm right, first vote that breaks the tie is the next lynch.

shlin28

11-13-2007, 17:55

Wow, a tie... I'll vote for... Unvote, Vote Beefy

You seem really desperate to me :inquisitive:

Husar

11-13-2007, 18:11

:laugh4:

Maybe my post was too long,
maybe my words were too thin,
we'd have to ask shlin,
now we can only wait for the final gong.

And hope it wasn't shlin. :whip:

Proletariat

11-13-2007, 23:54

It was decided at the last bar that Beefy had to go. FactionHeir pleaded with the group to have the honor, since it was his birthday too, and he wanted to perform an execution like Kage had. FactionHeir pulled out his brand new claymore and sliced Beefy's head off. No one felt any relief though, the night wasn't over, the group was confused. Xiahou and Shlin were then caught off guard as a war-cry bellowing FactionHeir killed the last two drunkards, who couldn't fend off a lone teetotaler in their inebriated condition.

Mafia win! Thanks for playing everyone, hosting was quite fun. Sorry for the few bumps here and there with my posting consistency.

Alive
-----
FactionHeir

Killed
-----
Prole (narrator)
Ichi
pevergreen
Husar
Andres
Xiahou
shlin

Lynched
--------
Waldinger
Sarathos
Craterus
Warmaster
Beefy

WoGed
-------
Caius

Roles: Andres the Designated Driver (DR role), pevergreen the Breathalyser (detective), FactionHeir the Teetotaler (mafia) and Craterus the Evil Detective (mafia detective)

The rest were all townies but Ichi and Xiahou were townies who hated each other, who could've won if they had gotten the other lynched, even if the town lost.

woad&fangs

11-13-2007, 23:56

Great Game

Congratulations to Factionheir on a game well played.

Ichigo must be crying about how close he was to getting Xiahou lynched:laugh4: :laugh4: :laugh4:

pevergreen

11-13-2007, 23:58

Lauf.

Told you it was Faction

GG

Husar

11-14-2007, 00:00

Congratulations FactionHeir.

Well played and you hardly got any suspicion. :2thumbsup:

Also thanks to prole for hosting, well done, even though you were busy at times. :2thumbsup:

FactionHeir

11-14-2007, 00:58

:grin2: Thanks :bow:

I killed Prole N1 after chatting with her for a while and getting this rather funny idea. The confusion was a side effect that I didn't quite anticipate, as that was my first game being the mafia.

I thought Woad would have gotten me at one point, but he changed his mind it seems.

Craterus was the secret role, but I think he will tell you more about it. Good teamwork though while you were alive, although we didn't find the detective until pever privately revealed to us, which led to him being killed the same night of course :laugh4:

P.S.: As for the birthday excuse, that was actually true. It wasn't until too late that I even noticed Craterus being voted and couldn't save him anymore.

Beefy187

11-14-2007, 01:09

Pever you couldnt find any solid evidence. I couldnt do anything but follow my gut

There you go:laugh4:

GG FH nicely done

pevergreen

11-14-2007, 01:35

Investigated:

Ichigo
Husar
Xiahou
Andres

I knew it was one of the people that deduced in chat that i was the detective.
Waldinger (i think) pm'ed me saying that, with some names, i couldnt find it. FactionHeir was one.

woad&fangs

11-14-2007, 01:38

yeah, I remember PMing you saying how we were all in the chat talking about how we knew you were the detective.

Husar

11-14-2007, 02:38

So you had 2 investigations per night? :inquisitive:
I thought only one, IIRC you PMed me after night two saying you found me and Ichi innocent. :dizzy2:

Xiahou

11-14-2007, 04:27

Way to stay below the radar FH. :bow:

Csargo

11-14-2007, 05:42

aww man. XIAHOU SHOULD HAVE DIED

FactionHeir

11-14-2007, 09:39

I let Xiahou live because most people were focussed upon him, giving me a better chance to slip through. Be glad though, he didn't win either because you got killed, not lynched :clown:

pevergreen

11-14-2007, 10:07

So you had 2 investigations per night? :inquisitive:
I thought only one, IIRC you PMed me after night two saying you found me and Ichi innocent. :dizzy2:
Those are the people i investigated.

Ichi n1, you n2, Xiahou n3, andres n4.

Xiahou and Andres may be swapped nights though.

FactionHeir

11-14-2007, 10:35

So who did Andres protect?

Andres

11-14-2007, 11:55

I protected:

Garci
WH
shlin
Beefy

Very enjoyable game. Thnx for hosting Prole. And congrats FactionHeir :bow:

Husar

11-14-2007, 13:48

Those are the people i investigated.

Ichi n1, you n2, Xiahou n3, andres n4.

Xiahou and Andres may be swapped nights though.
B..B..B..But you died in night 3! :inquisitive:

FactionHeir

11-14-2007, 14:00

The game started on a night turn though. I haven't counted whether this makes sense.
I guess pever still got to investigate the night he died, just couldn't tell anyone.

shlin28

11-14-2007, 18:07

Nice game FH! and thanks to Prole for hosting!

Husar

11-14-2007, 18:17

The game started on a night turn though. I haven't counted whether this makes sense.
I guess pever still got to investigate the night he died, just couldn't tell anyone.
He still died in night three, so where's that night 4 investigation coming from?

If I'm not mistaken, night one prole died, night two Ichi and night three pever.