-
Insight into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
http://www.breitbart.com/article.php...show_article=1
Intersting information. Does this change your feelings from one of the greatest minds of modern thought? I find it fascinating at his definite use of language. I would like to hear how he came to his conclusions and whether he used scientific reasoning for this. The main purpose is just to hear the reaction from my fellow Orgah's and their opinions supporting or disagreeing with Mr. Einstein.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Read it earlier today. He's right about religion IMO.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Devastatin Dave
The main purpose is just to hear the reaction from my fellow Orgah's and their opinions supporting or disagreeing with Mr. Einstein.
Whilst you were silently lobbying for your Senior Membership, we had about 256 threads (:toilet:) about this subject. Before I throw up, let me quickly say that Einstein was wrong on the Bible; you don't have to believe in the sky-God to appreciate the book as a source of wisdom.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
It's spelled out Einstein; E - I - N - S - T - E - I - N. Thank you. :whip:
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Has anyone ever seen "gentlemans agreement" ?
The proffesor in that film always stuck me as a charicature of Einstein
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Whilst you were silently lobbying for your Senior Membership
Just goes to show I should wear my gigs more these days. Congrats on senior member Dave, there's hope for foul-mouthed-me yet! :laugh4: :2thumbsup:
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
I essentially agree with his view on religion, but my prejudice aside, as he made his name in quite a different field, other than that he was clearly an intelligent man I don't think that his views carry any special weight.
I know a reasonable amount about the law, but I don't think it means anyone should pay any more attention to my opinions on general relativity.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Faith, by definition, is a choice. You choose to believe your parents loved you or you don't. There's no objective proof of it, nor is there proof of the existence, or the lack thereof of a supreme being, call Him/Her what you will.
I agree with EA though, that Einstein's preeminent status as a physicist shouldn't necessarily convey 'extra credence' to his views. Physics is the study of the knowable, and theology & dogma are concerned with the unknowable.
'grats on the Senior Membership, Dave. IA, I'm flabbergasted at the oversight. You should have been way ahead of me in line. I'd argue everyone that everyone that has posted in this thread already should be in the club.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don Corleone
Faith, by definition, is a choice. You choose to believe your parents loved you or you don't. There's no objective proof of it, nor is there proof of the existence, or the lack thereof of a supreme being, call Him/Her what you will.
I agree with EA though, that Einstein's preeminent status as a physicist shouldn't necessarily convey 'extra credence' to his views. Physics is the study of the knowable, and theology & dogma are concerned with the unknowable.
I believe that the point of the article is that Einsteins more ambivalent statements have often been used in support of religion.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
I'd argue everyone that everyone that has posted in this thread already should be in the club.
Don't be silly Don , I posted in this thread already .
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
You choose to believe your parents loved you or you don't.
Gives Don a great big ~:grouphug:
Sorry mate, knowing your parents love you is not an act of faith.
Quote:
IA, I'm flabbergasted at the oversight. You should have been way ahead of me in line.
No ta. I'm happy as I am. Unique. :laugh4: :yes: :2thumbsup:
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Einstein
"As far as my experience goes, they are no better than other human groups, although they are protected from the worst cancers by a lack of power. Otherwise I cannot see anything 'chosen' about them."
He might not believe in religion but his words are prophetic.
Nor do I think only priests can say if God exists anymore then McDonald's burger flippers decide what is a good hamburger.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tribesman
Don't be silly Don , I posted in this thread already .
I was well aware of that when I made the statement. ~:cheers:
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don Corleone
I was well aware of that when I made the statement. ~:cheers:
Seconded. :2thumbsup:
We should start a Senior Club and appoint Tribesman honorary president. And then depose him. I mean, come on..
:laugh4:
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
But then I wouldn't be allowed to play. :cry:
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Einstein was an enlightened man indeed....I see no big surprise in his declaration
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adrian II
Whilst you were silently lobbying for your Senior Membership, we had about 256 threads (:toilet:) about this subject. Before I throw up, let me quickly say that Einstein was wrong on the Bible; you don't have to believe in the sky-God to appreciate the book as a source of wisdom.
I apologise for my causing your nausia. I did not realise that the subject of Einstein's beliefs had been discussed in 256 threads. Strangly enough, I could not find 256, but, much like the belief in a Creator, one must have faith in their fellow man, so I'll take your word for it. :beam:
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Devastatin Dave
Strangly enough, I could not find 256
That's because you're no Einstein. And you're no journalist either or you wouldn't take my word for it. ~;)
-
Re: Insight in into Einstien's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adrian II
We should start a Senior Club and appoint Tribesman honorary president.
There already is a grumpy old men thread...
/runs away
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Man Dave you used to be so sexy. We, the rejected, will just have to rise without you, and rise we will like a purple helmet on a pole.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
I find this thread interesting, I won't say more because Adrian is posting here.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
How about a plumb topped sausage?
Anyway, just as others have said, he was great scientist but I would not ask him to make me cake.
Would be well skunky.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Husar
I find this thread interesting, I won't say more because Adrian is posting here.
Eh? :stunned:
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
See that's why, did you really think we didn't notice?
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fragony
See that's why, did you really think we didn't notice?
So that's.. you mean, you've..
So, you guys found out, huh? :shame:
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
The wisdom of any man, even the smartest ever born on the Earth, doesn't mean much. If God exists, then the wisdom of the wisest man on Earth is foolishness to God. Utlimately, all & any statements about there being no God from the mouth of any man, is merely unfounded speculation. It cannot be proven. Therefore it is unimportant what any man thinks. God or the lack of God is what it is, speculation about it from the smartest man on Earth has no bearing on whether God exists or not.
If the letter described in the article is true, though, then Einstein does indeed lose a lot of credibility. What makes his lack of belief in God - which is simply a guess - any "less childish" than belief in God? There isn't any reasonable answer to that. Therefore, Einstein making a definitive, derogatory statement about the belief in God is based on nothing other than his own personal emotions, not logic or science. As such, Einstein's remark was itself childish.
It should also be noted that Jesus said it is good to accept him and God as children accept him. So while Einstein meant his "childish" comments as a slur against belief in God, in fact a "childish belief in God" may indeed be the best possible thing for human beings to have.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
What's up with the last paragraph? Thought you'd given up on the New Testament as too soft...?
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Geoffrey S
What's up with the last paragraph? Thought you'd given up on the New Testament as too soft...?
I do not agree with everything in the New Testament, at the same time, I do not think it's entirely invalid either nor do I think that Jesus was a sham. That's why I used the word may in my previous post instead of simply making it a definitive statement. I've realized that I can't understand everything for certain, nor can anyone. Which incidentally, is precisely the problem with the alleged statement by Einstein that this thread is discussing.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Navaros
I do not agree with everything in the New Testament, at the same time, I do not think it's entirely invalid either nor do I think that Jesus was a sham. That's why I used the word may in my previous post instead of simply making it a definitive statement. I've realized that I can't understand everything for certain, nor can anyone. Which incidentally, is precisely the problem with the alleged statement by Einstein that this thread is discussing.
So how do you know that it is Christianity that is correct and not Hinduism? I think asking such questions is nearing Einsteins line of thought.
-
Re: Insight in into Einstein's beliefs in God and the Jewish people
Quote:
Originally Posted by Navaros
The wisdom of any man, even the smartest ever born on the Earth, doesn't mean much. If God exists, then the wisdom of the wisest man on Earth is foolishness to God. Utlimately, all & any statements about there being no God from the mouth of any man, is merely unfounded speculation. It cannot be proven. Therefore it is unimportant what any man thinks. God or the lack of God is what it is, speculation about it from the smartest man on Earth has no bearing on whether God exists or not.
If the letter described in the article is true, though, then Einstein does indeed lose a lot of credibility. What makes his lack of belief in God - which is simply a guess - any "less childish" than belief in God? There isn't any reasonable answer to that. Therefore, Einstein making a definitive, derogatory statement about the belief in God is based on nothing other than his own personal emotions, not logic or science. As such, Einstein's remark was itself childish.
It should also be noted that Jesus said it is good to accept him and God as children accept him. So while Einstein meant his "childish" comments as a slur against belief in God, in fact a "childish belief in God" may indeed be the best possible thing for human beings to have.
So far, the best and most thoughtful post within this thread. Thank you Nav.:yes:
