Printable View
I haven't see these videos here; somebody posted them at twcenter.net
http://www.gametrailers.com/video/ma...hogun-2/709939
http://www.gametrailers.com/video/la...hogun-2/709941
http://www.gametrailers.com/video/na...hogun-2/709943
http://www.gametrailers.com/video/mu...hogun-2/709945
we'll have battlefield ninjas; enjoy:balloon2:
Very nice. Lots of new info, at least from my perspective. I wasn't too excited about the naval battles, but they looked much more interesting in this video. So far I haven't seen or read anything that's been a turn off for the game - I'm still quite psyched for it. :2thumbsup:
I'm not eager to play naval battles, I'll limit my experience here, I'll just use navy to protect my borders and so on. Is looking good, sure, but I just don't feel that naval battles were so important for that period. after all, the race for shogun was played on the soil.
I liked the naval battles in Empire/Napolen Total War because of the period and teh historical set up.
I like that ninjas will not be that good during the day, that's fair enough. should be slaughtered easily in the open field.
Now back to the naval battles I have the feeling that SEGA will produce a DLC with invasion of Korea. Doesn't have sense such a polished naval battle part of the game, only for Sengoku
If I ever get around to finishing my review from when I did the play through in sf. You'll find that i wasnt too keen on naval battles, they seem sluggish but then I was only showed a beta version of the game and so its likely to be more polished when it comes out. By sluggish i dont mean frame rates, i mean the battle just seemed to go slowly even after the action started.
Good find, thanks for the links.
I saw the ashigaru spearmen charge with their swords and pulling out swords for the melee... And my heart just dropped man.
Right then and there, my dreams were crushed. The hope that I would at least have one thing to do on the battlefield that would make this feel like an actual sengoku jidai experience... And the yari ashigaru pulled out their swords...
*sigh*
Alright. Ok.
Only one thing left to do now; hope for moddability.
...zoom out far enough that you can't see this and get a proper perspective on what is happening in the battle you are supposed to be commanding. ~:pat:Quote:
Originally Posted by Revolting Friendship
This is less a question of aesthetics than one of functionality for me. Samurai armies employed pikes primarily as a melee weapon and everyone carried a spear of some description into battle. In fact, the backbone of the army was the ashigaru with their up to 5m long pikes and aside from the skirmish-phase which became increasingly dominant with the introduction of the portoguese arquebus, forests of ashigaru-operated pikes crashing into eachother was the dominant feature of any 16th century battlefield.Quote:
...zoom out far enough that you can't see this and get a proper perspective on what is happening in the battle you are supposed to be commanding.
So in reality this game should be more of a pike and shot fair rather than macho swordplayin, and even if I can appriciate the popular draw of the latter, I wanted at least a nibble of the former... :\
Well I can still be glad they didn't omit firearms in homage to Last Samurai.
People here are of different minds when it comes to historic fidelity. I’m with you, I want the game to look and feel like 16th century Japan. But some patrons want a tactical battle game with lots of different units and stats with OR WITHOUT any regard to reality, with special offense units, defense units and rock, paper, scissors based strengths and weaknesses, all carefully balanced somehow. For them, fun game play, unreal or not, trumps history. For us, fun game play IS history.
In a few weeks we will see who is happier.
I like the RPG system.
And some other patrons want historical accuracy with OR WITHOUT consideration of its impact on gameplay. They play then a few campaigns of excitement and within 4-5 months they conclude that the game "isn't challenging", like econ21 did for MTW2. What a surprise.
In any case, not to worry: no-one will be happier.
Yes, but in other places the spearmen were in close combat and didn't pull out swords. Clearly something more complex is going on, although it's still not necessarily realistic.Quote:
Originally Posted by Revolting Friendship
Also, what's with the horsemen with colourful spheres on their backs?
Nelson:
I honestly believe that if made properly even the strictly historical approach could also be thrilling and tactically satisfying, you'd simply have to rearrange some emphasis and also include some new ones, like for instance chain of command, discovery and application of special tactics (like counter-marching) and compound units and the ability to designate unit-structure. Adding such elements would bring the historical path to life sufficiently to keep it enthralling even for those among us who aren't history-nuts and just want challenges and cool stuff to fiddle around with.
foop:
I saw samurai fighting with those super-short spears yeah (they might as well be swords I mean seriously), I also saw ashigaru spearmen in a spear-wall like formation, but I assume this was just a copy of the way pikemen were presented in ETW. There too they only used their pikes in special formations to stop cavalry. I was happy to recently discover that Darth-mod for ETW fixes the pikemen to use their pikes also in melee, at least it looks less retarded.
About the colorful spheres on the horsemen's back. Those are hori, canvas stretched over a light wooden frame. They were an alternative to the sashimono (flags for the back) and were used by some mounted samurai, commonly bodyguards and messengers.
you shoud google "aka horo shu" (red horo unit) and "kuro horo shu" (black horo unit)
a horo is a kind of sashimono (back flag), shaped as a sphere
Oda nobunaga used these two colors for is bodyguard
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nelson
I don't think that the game should be 100% historically accurate. Some things have to give in order to give us good gameplay. However, we shouldn't need to have fantasy units using fantasy weapons. After all, if some weapons were underpowered in real life, they wouldn't have been invented in the first place.
The best RTS of all time, Starcraft: Brood War, didn't have an RPS system of arbitrary damage bonuses and counters. Units countered each other based on their abilities and design. Shogun shouldn't need one, either.
The game is about Sengoku Jidai. That's roughly mid/late 15th- early 17th century. Quite a lot changed in samurai warfare during that time. The large units of ashigaru with huge pikes became dominant during the later stages, mounted archers were still of use during the early stages. I certainly hope that TWS2 will give us enough time to enjoy both the early, mid and late era (maybe even a switch to turn events of and stay stuck in early or mid). What do we know about turns, will they be months?
I've played some pike and musket like games in totalwar, both in single- and multiplayer. They are different, but certainly not bad for me.
Tosa, the turn will be seasonal like STW.
I prefer historical accuracy as much as possible, but with necessary tweaking to maintain some semblence of game balance. Historical accuracy for the sake of historical accuracy and at the expense of a fun and playable game is just as bad as fantasy units for the sake of making history "cooler" than it was.
I'll not start another thread. A guy at tw center posted some info from a Turkish magazine. most interesting stuff it about teh clans:
Full 10-game clan have selected:
1. Oda
2. Shimazu
3. Mori
4. Togugawa
5. Takeda
6. Uesugi
7. Date
8. Chosokabe
9. Hattori
10. Hojo
* A total of 56 clans in the game, including the states have selected:
1. Amako
2. Anegajoji
3. Asai
4. Asano
5. Ashikaga
6. Ashina
7. Bessho
8. Chosokabe
9. Date
10. Hatakeyama
11. Errno
12. Hojo
13. Honma
14. Hosokawa
15. Iga Ninja
16. Ikko Ikki
17. Imagawa
18. Ishida
19. Ito
20. Jinbo
21. Kikkawa
22. Kiso
23. Kitabatake
24. Kobayakawa
25. Kono
26. Kuroda
27. Matsuda
28. Miyoshi
29. Mogami
30. Mori
31. Murakami
32. Room
33. Uesugi Ogigatsu
34. Otomo
35. Ouchi
36. Rebels
37. Sagara
38. Saito
39. Sakai
40. He
41. Satomi
42. Shimazu
43. Shone
44. Sogo
45. Takaoka
46. Takeda
47. Tokugawa
48. Toyotomi
49. Tsutsui
50. Uesugi
51. Ukita
52. Urakami
53. Utsonomiya
54. Wako
55. Yamana
56. Yamanouchi Uesugi
pirates, ikko-ikki and also rebels.
and of course Iga ninja. I wonder if Iga ninja's horses will also have head cover, like in the presentation of Hattori clan:)
My curiousity has been spiked...Quote:
11. Errno
40. He
32. Room
Also I suppose Shone is Shoni and Anegajoji is Anegakoji.
If even half of those clans can be unlocked somehow I'm going to be a very happy man.
I think is a bad spelling from google translate rather than a room clan
Are you telling me you never read about the ferocious samurai of the Room-clan? ;)
I checked with google translate and apparently oda in turkish translates as room. So perhaps the less famous Oda of Hitachi-province will also be featured.
so all these clans will be the former "STW- rebels" ?
Depends on what you mean. I'm absolutely positive they'll be actual factions, competing with the big ones/player, as opposed to STW where they were just "dressed" rebels waiting around to be eaten. What's debatable is wether they can be unlocked somehow.
The rebels of Shikoku in STW, are the Chosokabe clan that did not make it and was turned into the Shimazu clan instead. You can see their faction leader and his heirs still in the Tosa province there.
The rebels in Kyoto, Ise and around Kaga are the Warrior monks of the great monasteries that made their own fiefs states therein.
The rest of the clans in the list were in the original within the territories of teh playable clans that were not - strictly speaking historically accurate in the Sengoku Campaign.
The different starting eras campaigns available with the MI expansion made a far more historically accurate repersentation of the playable clans in terms of territories, hence they had far more rebels. Within those rebels, lie the clans listed, yes.
Gangsters of Iga Unite!Quote:
15. Iga Ninja
It would be fun to play pirate/ninja only campaign.
hehe, nice one. So "oda" in Turkish means room.Quote:
Originally Posted by Revolting Friendship
I didn't make the connection although in Romanian language we have an archaic word derived from Turkish "oda" with the same meaning: "odaie"
It is used in the southern regions of Romania.
Now back to the topic I don't think that Oda from Hitachi will be featured in the game because the list of 56 factions (we can't call them all clans, e.g. ikko-ikki) is simply resuming the playable factions.
I bet He Clan is Satake.They were definetely important enough to be included.
Aren't you surprised that Ran no Jidai campaign released 3 months before Shogun 2?Quote:
Originally Posted by Kagemusha
source: http://www.twcenter.net/forums/showthread.php?t=423711Quote:
Spear Cavalry
01. -
02. Takeda -
03. Light Cavalry
04. Takeda Light Cavalry
05. Naginata Warrior Monk Cavalry
06. Yari Cavalry
07. Takeda Yari Cavalry
Bow Cavalry
01. Bow Cavalry
02. Takeda Bow Cavalry
Sword Cavalry
01. Katana Cavalry
02. Takeda Katana Cavalry
General
01. Ashikaga Haruuji
02. Chosokabe Motochika
03. Date Masamune
04. Hattori Hanzo
05. Hojo Tsunashige
06. Hojo Ujishige
07. Imagawa Ujichika
08. Imagawa Yoshimoto
09. Ishida Mitsunari
10. Kobayakawa Hideaki
11. Mori Motonari
12. Oda Nobunaga
13. -
14. Shimazu Yoshihiro
15. -
16. General
17. Takeda Katsuyori
18. Takeda Nobukado
19. Takeda Shingen
20. Tokugawa Ieyasu
21. Uesugi Kenshin
22. Uesugi Norimasa
Bow Infantry
01. Bow Ashigaru
02. Chosokabe Bow Ashigaru
03. Bow Ashigaru Garrison
04. Hattori Bow Ashigaru
05. Ikko-Ikki Bow Ashigaru
06. Oda Bow Ashigaru
07. Bow Hero
08. Chosokabe Bow Hero
09. Chosokabe Bow Samurai
10. Hattori Bow Samurai
11. Bow Wako
12. Bow Warrior Monks
13. Chosokabe Bow Warrior Monks
14. Uesugi Bow Warrior Monks
Heavy Infantry
01. Naginata Samurai
02. Hattori Naginata Samurai
03. Naginata Warrior Monk Hero
04. Uesugi Naginata Warrior Monk Hero
05. Naginata Warrior Monks
06. Naginata Warrior Monks Garrison
07. Uesugi Warrior Monks
08. -
Matchlock Infantry
01. Inspired Matchlock Ashigaru
02. Matchlock Ashigaru
03. Hattori Matchlock Ashigaru
04. Ikko-Ikki Matchlock Ashigaru
05. Oda Matchlock Ashigaru
06. Matchlock Samurai
07. Hattori Matchlock Samurai
08. Matchlock Warrior Monks
09. Uesugi Matchlock Warrior Monks
Spear Infantry
01. Yari Ashigaru
02. Yari Ashigaru Garrison
03. Hattori Yari Ashigaru
04. Ikko-Ikki Yari Ashigaru
05. Oda Yari Ashigaru
06. Yari Hero
07. Yari Ronin
08. Yari Samurai
09. Hattori Yari Samurai
Special Infantry
01. Fire Bomb -
02. Hojo Fire Bomb -
03. Kisho Ninja
04. Hattori Kisho Ninja
05. Tokugawa Kisho Ninja
Sword Infantry
01. Sword Ashigaru
02. Katana Hero
03. Shimazu Katana Hero
04. Katana Ronin
05. Katana Samurai
06. Hattori Katana Samurai
07. Shimazu Katana Samurai
08. Katana Wako
09. No-Dachi Samurai
10. Date No-Dachi Samurai
11. Hattori No-Dachi Samurai
12. Samurai -
Cannon Ship
01. Cannon Bune
02. Mori Cannon Bune
Galleon
01. - Trade Ship
02. Mori - Trade Ship
03. The Black Ship
Heavy Ship
01. Heavy Bune
02. Mori Heavy Bune
03. Nihon Maru
04. Mori Nihon Maru
05. -
06. Mori - Wako Bune
Light Ship
01. Siege Tower Bune
02. Mori Siege Tower Bune
03. Medium Bune
04. Mori Medium Bune
05. Sengoku Bune
06. Mori Sengoku Bune
07. Wako Medium Bune
Trade Ship
01. Red - Ship
02. Trade Ship
03. Wako Trade Ship
Siege Units
01. European Cannons
02. Hojo Cannons
03. Fire - Mangonels
04. Hojo Fire - Mangonels
05. Fire Rockets
06. Hojo Fire Rockets
Well my hat is off for the current Mod team of RNJ. During the time i was part of the mod nor afterwards the dev team never had resources of a game studio. I dont want to compare the Mod to the game, but historical accuracy wise can you talk about the two on the same day based on the previews of Shogun 2? Also if you look at some of the units in Shogun 2, some might think CA had quite nice 3d reference models to use to create some Shoggy 2 units and specially their armour colour schemes.Quote:
Originally Posted by antisocialmunky