Civilization: The West and the Rest
Is anyone else reading this?
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
I watched the docus he did
"The Ascent of Money"
Civilisation is the West History
And the China one called "China Triumph and Turmoil"
He is quite good never read the book though.
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
i watched the TV documentaries too, very good.
his book on empire was likewise good, and quite enjoying his one on counterfactuals.
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Furunculus
i watched the TV documentaries too, very good.
his book on empire was likewise good, and quite enjoying his one on counterfactuals.
Did you see the China one lately I like the term he made "Maostalgia"
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
i think i did, missed that.
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
Haven't read his work but after seeing the documentaries he made I can fully agree with Krugman's conclusion that Ferguson is a poseur who hasn't bothered to understand the basics, relying on snide comments and surface cleverness to convey the impression of wisdom. It's all style, no comprehension of substance
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sarmatian
Haven't read his work but after seeing the documentaries he made I can fully agree with Krugman's conclusion that Ferguson is a poseur who hasn't bothered to understand the basics, relying on snide comments and surface cleverness to convey the impression of wisdom. It's all style, no comprehension of substance
Dont we all
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Sarmatian
Haven't read his work but after seeing the documentaries he made I can fully agree with Krugman's conclusion that Ferguson is a poseur who hasn't bothered to understand the basics, relying on snide comments and surface cleverness to convey the impression of wisdom. It's all style, no comprehension of substance
This also describes 99% of the Backroom.
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
All of us are suspect.
No exceptions.
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
Read it.
Largely a summary of stuff you find in greater detail elsewhere; unfortunately nothing that struck me as original or a "new view". It is nice to have it all in one place to save one from running around looking for "that book".
On a similar theme, but one I found a more interesting read: The Post American World Release 2.0: Fareed Zakaria; 2008,2011.
Not dead yet, but certainly adjusting to a new world of rising powers.
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rhyfhylwyr
This also describes 99% of the Backroom.
Only exception was Tribesman.
Re: Civilization: The West and the Rest
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rhyfhylwyr
This also describes 99% of the Backroom.
Right, and that's why I tell you guys to leave the thinking to me.
Seriously, we're not university professors here.