Printable View
Well, it may be a tragedy for him, that his fortune is so harsh - but surely it does not give you sufficient grief to attack and abuse the other members here - especially in such a broad manner.
This is of course, unless you required Shlin in order to play the game more effectively. Then your threats and anger may be justified.
I was just looking for some attention. ~D
I could've said it nicer but I always feel like noone listens then so I tried a different approach.
And I don't really buy that people actually suspect shlin in almost every first round, despite that I saw a lot more reasons to vote for other people like prole who IMO is still acting weird or maybe I'm just mean and stupid and will destroy the game for all of you, which would also make me proud. ~:pissed:
Well Husar, as is the case with just about everyone, my first-round vote was semi-random. I didn't know that Shlin always gets lynched! Plus I haven't checked the thread in a while, so while TS actually in retrospect seems to be a better lynch... I was too late!
Insinuating that they are both suspicious? From my limited understanding of other peoples personalities, I'd say not so much as to be sufficiently above the norm. I mean everyone's suspicious atm.Quote:
Originally Posted by Glenn
I'd back your opinion that Sasaki seems to be among the most sensible voters atm. I'd also say that you seem to be very well-reasoned, even if I don't necessarily agree with you.
FOS:The Stranger
:laugh4: But still, PK was providing, imo, some fairly good reasoning for his actions. So he has a lot to say... doesn't mean that hes guilty. So he provides the reasoning behind his arguments and gets jumped on for something he's already refuted! Either you were genuinely confused (tired maybe) or you were delibrately trying to confuse things, and lynch, currently the best contributor to the thread, at least in terms of volume and enthusiasm.Quote:
Originally Posted by The Stranger
Explanation please.
How do you know that? are you two in something?Quote:
doesn't mean that hes guilty
Its a figure of speech... lol.
Edit: I'll expand on that. You may (or may not) have noticed that I type/talk in a very incoherent and crazy way. Pretty much I type exactly how I'd say something in real life. Hence, exaggeration, overreaction, irony, sarcasm, literalism... etc. are all present in my posts.
...I didn't say that I knew anything. Its called musing/asking a question. IMO, atm The Stranger is more suspicious than PK. Soooo, its up to The Stranger to adequately answer it.
Btw: I'm tired and cranky, so apologies for any offence, I didn't mean it...
Glenn you never answered my question.Quote:
What's up with your attitude towards Sasaki? How was it well-intentioned and sensible?
I'll be gone for probably most of today and part of tomorrow.
Hmmm, some of the roles Andres has cooked up will pose interesting in the course of this game. Namely the Prostitute and Juliette.
Wading through the first couple pages of WIFOMs was fairly, um ... useless (:laugh4:). But, it does pose some valuable info into how certain players are approaching this game, and will act as a good means to cross-reference later on.
So far Seamus was a American tourist(?) thus likely a townie. And from the kill write-up
Who smothered him, and used a knife.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
- I'm guessing that Manfredo would have been investigating last night, trying to find Juliette, so I'd rule him out.
- Taketsi was probably also investigating, rather than making hits, (unless of course he/she felt very lucky :laugh4:).
- Gianluca and Luciano would likely be the suspects, depending on the secret role of course.
>>>> So one hit, last night. Two (three?) possibilities:
-- One of them was afraid of being investigated night one, thus didn't kill, indicating experience or believing themselves to be a prime suspect.
-- One of them was AFK, thus indicating a lurker or potential WOG victim.
-- One of them was role blocked, unlikely though if we look at Sasaki's PM from Andres:
Indicating Sasaki was indeed doing nothing, most likely a townie. But, Sasaki is a wily fellow, wouldn't take my eye off him just yet.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
Most of this is probably useless/obvious. :shrug:
I didn't see him as being very suspicious but I'm new and don't know people well enough to tell if someone is acting differently from how they normally act. To me, most of you simply don't talk a lot and I just assume it is the norm for you until a veteran brings up that it is not the norm for that particular player.Quote:
Originally Posted by Husar
I was trying to get The Stranger lynched but he ended up tying with Shlin and lucking out at random.org.
Well, if I don't always bring quality with my posts, at least I bring enthusiasm. I always thought a good stream of conversation and banter was good for a game. And since we don't have an OOC thread, this thread serves multiple purposes. Hence, it is going to fill up relatively fast.Quote:
Originally Posted by Gaius Scribonius Curio
I think he meant that me talking a lot does not automatically make me guilty. Gabby yes, guilty no. I would talk like this no matter what role I had. Because it is me. I struggled before the game to figure out how much I should post because I noticed those who post too little/too much get suspected. But it would be too much work to manufacture posting habits so I will just post like I always do.Quote:
Originally Posted by Caius
I like your analysis. I do hope that we have no non-townie roles going to WoG's or inactive/semi-active players. I want competition, not winning because a role is inactive.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rythmic
I don't think Sasaki was one of the Gianluca/Luciana killers. It just doesn't seem right from what I know. So, I suspect one Carelli killer struck while one laid low. Or one struck while one was logged off and inactive.
I'm also assuming Taketsi and Manfredo investigated. It just seems like what they'd do. Mr trench coat (or black cloak if you prefer) is a mystery. The prostitute was obviously busy beating one of the players with a wooden pole. And Julliette and the Detective were hiding and most likely doing their own investigations. I think that covers every special role I know of.
I guess this post is just one long "I agree with you" post but I'd like to see discussion continue.
What, why was Glenn suspicious of me in the first place?
CR
Because at one stage there seemed to be weak, (Admittedly weak), traces of a conspiracy against GeneralHankerchief.
This has been subsided by other things now.
Ichigo, though you are away I will answer your question, I'm sorry I thought it was obvious already;
PrivateerKev was in a position where players like Sasaki and Omanes Alexandrapolites had ample power to have him lynched.
Instead, both of them made logical replies and changed their votes - and this was most surprising coming from Sasaki - as he is usually quite willing to ramp up any bandwagon, but this time showed self-control.
For this reason, and for reasons of his inactivity and lack of word-twisting posts, I feel that he does not have a major role in this game, and could even be content just to watch.
Especially if he hasn't time due to outside circumstances.
I hope that clarifies my confidence in him.
When players like Caius come forth with frivolous one-liners, attempting to cause dissent amongst players in the most careless style - they aren't really deserving of any reply.
But I am in agreement with Rythmic, in that he has shown a more concrete approach to gathering evidence, and is not succumbing to simple speculation.
I won't comment on anyone again for that reason until we have some proper evidence from the host, (High time we did!).
So, night time. And a long one, at that. This townie can only hope that the Prostitute visits his miserable shack tonight, and forgets the wooden board (splinters, ouch!), and instead brings her healing, fragrant oils and balms, and female mysteries, and intimate murmurs, and swirling fantasies :belly:, and intriguing stories...
... and that she can cook a decent breakfast. :)
Happy Mother's Day to any Mothers out there (Mama-waio and Mrs. Kukri the only two I am aware of)! :DAISeY::balloon2: :DAISeY:
I can't say a lot at the moment. I saw the first vote to GH from CR, and I think there could be something, must reread the whole thing. There could be two things happening, but those are my theories.Quote:
When players like Caius come forth with frivolous one-liners, attempting to cause dissent amongst players in the most careless style - they aren't really deserving of any reply.
1.. 2.. 3...
Come on, breathe, BREATHE!
to my defence.
I realize, after re-reading the thread I made a mistake. I was short on time and slightly distracted by other worldly beauties, so when I read
Prole: Sure. I'm a townie. Investigate away, detective.
PK: Then we have a deal. :D
I immediatly jumped conclusions and voted for PK. I hadn't read the posts before that one, but now I have and I realise I was wrong. About the bandwagon, I hadn't seen a tally so I didnt know I was third, nor that there was a bandwagon.
To andres, I'm short on time and considering withdrawing due exams. Is there any possibility you could arange a replacement?
Night 2- Conclusion.
The tourists and villagers went back to their respective shelters, most of them shocked by the scene of shlin28's lynching.
GeneralHankerchief was at the bar in his hotel, having a drink with several other villagers. As the night continued, and more alcohol was being consumed, the general mood changed and people started to party. While dancing with a local beauty, GeneralHankerchief spilled his Wodka-Martini all over his shirt.
He apologised to the lady and quickly went to his room, to use the bathroom and get another shirt. While he was looking in his closet for a shirt, a well dressed man, a fibre wire in his hand, grabbed the General, aimed under his adam's apple and garrotted him. GeneralHankerchief didn't make a sound while slowly dieing, his last thoughts going to the local beauty he just met a couple of minutes ago...
***
https://i156.photobucket.com/albums/...iftfunivia.jpg
makaikhaan went out for a walk in the village of Taormina.
While thinking about what happened the last few days, he came near the funivia.
All of the sudden, he fell down, after having received a hard knock on his head. A bit later, he woke up, finding himself tied up on one of the funivia's cabines, hanging upside down, twenty meters above the ground.
"Why do you hate my family?"
"Huh? Hey man, come on, untie me, this is dangerous! Are you crazy?" makaikhaan screamed.
"Well, some people indeed call me crazy. But I'll untie you, makaikhaan."
The strange man cut the ropes and makaikhaan fell down. makaikhaan died on impact. His killer grinned.
***
Hiji was in his hotelroom. Last night, the nightmares came back. The former marine didn't want to go through this hell. He grabbed his pistol and shot himself in the head.
***
In another hotel, strange sounds could be heard, coming out of a locked room.
"Aw! That hurts!"
The voice of an angel could be heard. "Come on honey, you wanted to look female. All body hear has to go... Ah, now you look female, darling. Just let me attach these thingies on your nostrils and we can start."
"Crazy woman! I said no electric shocks! Please!"
"You'll like it."
The buzzing sound and the screams for more, more, more,... kept going for several hours.
"I told you you would like it!"
"Hey, come back! I want more electro shocks! Please!"
"Bye sweetheart!"
***
Day 2
https://i156.photobucket.com/albums/...inoPublico.jpg
Taormina - Giardino Publico - 7 a.m.
"Good morning ladies and gentleman," an unshaven Pino greeted the crowd. "I have some bad news."
"We found the body of GeneralHankerchief in his room. It seems like he was strangled. Nobody heard or saw the assasination, probably because of the big party that was going on in the bar. Also, we found makaikhaan's body, at least, what was left of it. Also, we found Hiji's body. The little note we found next to him suggests that he couldn't take the stress anymore and thus he decided to end his life. It seems like we still have some individuals with bad intentions among us, so I suggest you all start voting again."
***
Alive (33)
Ichigo
Tiberius of the Drake
woad&fangs
Omanes
Yaropolk
Caius
Sarathos
Beefy187
Zorg
Glenn
Gaius Sribonius Curio
pevergreen
Crazed Rabbit
Sasaki Kojiro
Husar
TinCow
The Stranger
Northnovas
Rythmic
LittleGrizzly
Kukrikhan
00jebus
Sigurd Fafnesbane
Mithrandir
axel
Haudegen
Makanyane
TwilightBlade
AntiWarmanCake
Hiji
Bananabob
Tratorix
Privateerkev
Proletariat
Killed (3)
Seamus Fermanagh
GeneralHankerchief
makaikhaan
Lynched (1)
shlin28
WoG'ed (0)
Suicide (1)
Hiji
***
It's now day, so you can start voting. No RL obligations the common day, so we're back on normal 24 hour phases. Voting will end on Monday +/- 22h00 (GMT +2)
Vote:00jebus
His reason for voting me last round seemed like something he just pulled out his hat to vote someone.
Vote: Sigurd Fafnesbane
I have a feeling that at least one of the mafiosi is a veteran player.
Would whoever got blocked reveal themselves please?
From the kills it seems the two mafias made kills, so that leaves Manfred, Juliette and the black clocked man, which means if you speak up, we know at least you won't be one of the three mafia :yes:
I would have to agree at least one veteran player. GH is always a target in the early round and a threat to any mafia. A definite town loss.Quote:
Originally Posted by woad&fangs
No vote yet.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Northnovas
Same, I'll wait for a moment before I actually vote.
Lynch Ichigo.
First he stayed in the shadows at the beginning, not lodging his usual vote:sasaki. Then, he starts acting overtly analytical and helpful. His behavior's off, I say take him out.
Vote: Crazed Rabbit
As I have to trust 2 assesments on GH's value, he is an experienced player who voted for him (first I think) last round.
All three deaths so far have been experienced players who have also been major game hosts. I personally believe that it is better for the mafia to leave veterans alive, as experienced players tend to be viewed with more suspicion than newbies. It is easier to hide when there are many possible suspects. I therefore think it is more likely that the mafia are newer or less experienced players... at least whichever of the mafia have been killing so far.
I will reserve my vote until I hear more.
I've been active the entire game. I did vote Sasaki, just because I didn't do it how you expected isn't my fault. I don't know how that's bad, could you explain it to me?Quote:
Originally Posted by makaikhaan
Vote: CrazedRabbit
I want to know why, seeing as GeneralHankerchief failed to be lynched yesterday - that he was a priority for death last night - considering he hasn't even been active.
That simply reeks of the people who bandwagoned him having the same opinion as the Mafia.
FOS: KukriKhan
On the other hand, there is the argument it may be a set-up.
(As for the bit about the electro shocks and body-shaving - Andres has a wil imagination - we can't believe all the things he puts up for truth!)
Most people haven't done enough for me to have an opinion on them yet. Most of the day 1 votes were simple random choice votes. The following have posted enough to merit comment:
Glenn gives me an innocent feel because he talks so much and puts his opinion out there. He is playing just like he did when he was a townie. I haven't seen him play as mafia though.
Privateerkev has posted a lot but I don't have any feeling on him. I think he makes mistakes in judgement but can't tell if that's new-town player or new-mafia player.
TinCow is too cautious for my liking and backed off a shade too strongly.
I don't like Ichigo's vote here. His post count seems up from pre school mafia and his posts also seem cautious. I don't like his going after glenn in post 288. Glenn's posts are easy to pick on and a tempting target for mafia.Quote:
Vote:Sasaki
I don't like the fact that he revealed that he was blocked by the prostitute.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
Quote:
Originally Posted by PK
I don't like that Ichigo is saying he thinks Prole and TinCow are innocent based on analysis of their posts. The number of posts is small so far and neither of them has done anything that strikes me as innocent. He also makes no mention of thinking they are innocent in his initial post where he merely went after glenn's reasoning. If he defends those he thinks are innocent why didn't he defend prole from her other voters? His post strikes me as an overly defensive reaction to PK (who only said it was ironic not suspicious).Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
Vote:Ichigo
I'm not willing to draw conclusions based on the deaths of experienced players. It's happened in several games and I don't believe any correlation has been found. Not a fan of people making claims about it since that's the kind of things I used to do in my first couple games as mafia.
So you think the kills point to someone other than yourself, because you believe it's bad for the mafia to kill experienced players? As I said I don't like this reasoning.Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
Damn, not even a visit from the prostitute before I went. :laugh4:
I'll still be around, don't worry town.
You are quite correct Sasaki - lynching solely on the evidence of night actions is not enough - however my vote remains on CrazedRabbit until he can explain the coincedence.
Vote:Ichigo
Been acted very defensive lately, and been defending people I believed may be wise to watch out for.
Wait.. I have reread the last few pages.
I should have more faith in the strategic ability of the Mafia - killing GH would have been to obvious a move - especially if CR was a criminal.
For now I change my vote in favour of the greatest and most sensible evidence.
Unvote: CrazedRabbit Vote: Ichigo