Let's here some abstentions!
Printable View
Let's here some abstentions!
what we really need now is a blow by blow summery -someone needs to go back and produce a list of who voted for who (including unvotes) for every round - im sure we will find some anomolies lurking in the shadows and we can use these to lynch someone apropriate - my money is on Don C his attacks on Kage last round were a perfect cover for killing him - would have been perfect cept the doctor is still with us :2thumbsup: that means we have 2 positive roles to one negative - we are winning
Hmm, I think that proves me innocent, doesn't it?:inquisitive:
Good man, glad to see you volunteering to help the cause :pQuote:
Originally Posted by Sir Moody
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
Vote: MafiaVote: Sasaki
haha, are you protesting my giant red text by quoting it?Quote:
Originally Posted by Reenk Roink
Good point.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
:stupido2: If ya can't beat 'em, join 'em...
Vote: Sasaki
After the smashing sucess of my striptease, I will now play the trumpet. However, I have no idea how to do so and even if I did I know no songs. So now, noise on a trumpet.
Oh yeah, and I abstain and am lead around by others.
Communist.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
I'm not.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sigurd Fafnesbane
However, unless Csar has altered the normal playing rules that prevent a faked failed murder, I have to acknowledge that my suspicions were unfounded.
Good luck staying alive doc.
True, but I suspect such a solo voter would not have much of a chance to apologize....:smash: :smash: :smash: :skull:Quote:
Originally Posted by Xiahou
Name: v,o,t,e,s [total # active votes, 5 possible] (role, if known)
Discovery1: no vote, no vote, no vote, theRTWGuru, Hepcat, abstain [2]
Don Corleone: Gen Hanky, abstain, Kagemusha, theRTWGuru, Discovery1 [4]
Dutch_Guy: no vote, no vote, Proletariat, no vote, Silver Rusher [1]
Kagemusha: Proletariat, no vote, no vote, no vote, Hepcat [2]
Peasant Phil: no vote, Gen Hanky, Proletariat, no vote, Xiahou [3]
Reenk Roink: Sir Moody, no vote, Proletariat, theRTWGuru, no vote, Sasaki [3]
Sir Moody: Reenk Roink, Ultrawar, Proletariat, theRTWGuru, Don C [5]Xiahou: no vote, Ultrawar, Proletariat, JimBob, Hepcat [4]
Cleared by Kagemusha: Gen Hanky, Seamus, ?
Condemned by Kagemusha: Proletariat
-- Doctor still in play
The Case Against:
Disco = very inactive at outset in a game where mafiosi were targeting any active player. Continues to make brief posts and avoid longer discussions
Don= went after Kagemusha after the reveal (so did I) but was the only one to vote with Proletariat for Kag's death; far more active in this thread than in the M5 thread despite being alive in both of these concurrent games.
Phil= has always lodged votes for people not likely to be lynched, aside from the vote for Prole (who was a likely goner at that point). Has taken a somewhat more active posting style this game than in previous ones.
Reenk= as with Phil, votes have been fairly benign. Very active and no abstentions (though this deviation from previous posting behavior is also true of his participation in the concurrent M5)
Moody = hasn't missed a vote, never abstaining. This is a deviation from previous play for him, and stands out a bit more as he is the only survivor in a game where the mafia has specifically targeted all active voters.
Xiahou= voting record is pretty standard. Has voted for 3 lynchees with one outlier. Missed only the first round (which is usually almost random anyway). Posting behavior fairly consistent with previous outings.
On second though
vote: Seamus Fermanagh
This post:Freaks me out. He doesn't seem at all concerned that he could well have lynched the detective.Quote:
I'm not.
However, unless Csar has altered the normal playing rules that prevent a faked failed murder, I have to acknowledge that my suspicions were unfounded.
Good luck staying alive doc.
noooo why are you voting disco, we aren't going to lynch anyone this round. Remember the math!
1/8 + 1/5 =
...
oh seamus is dead nevermind
Interesting. An increase in posting or a change in style are big mafia indicators. I find Don's strange actions in this game interesting. He's far more active and accusatory this game than in mafia V.Quote:
Originally Posted by Seamus
I'll avoid commenting on the others because I'm all too happy to have my suspects killed by the mafia. They'll have to wait till tomorrow. I'd like to hear from Don though (I have a feeling the mafia weren't planning on killing him).
He's already dead DiscoQuote:
Originally Posted by discovery1
atually ive never missed a vote in any of the games ive played - im also normally dead by the 3rd round tho so... and as for posting more im fed up of being dead by the 3rd round so by posting like sas somewhat i hoped id survive longer - its worked so farQuote:
Moody = hasn't missed a vote, never abstaining. This is a deviation from previous play for him, and stands out a bit more as he is the only survivor in a game where the mafia has specifically targeted all active voters.
actually i wouldnt mind being lynched - ive played enough Mafias now to know the ropes and be considered a semi vet - i only need 2 things now to take the final step and become a mafia veteran
1) Sas needs to accuse me of being a mafia... he never has and all the vets need to have this at least once
2) i Need to be lynched - its a kind of "strike me down and i will be become more powerful than you can ever imagine" clause
anyway seriously my opinion is 2 names jump out in that list
first is disco aka mr bandwagon - hes abscent for the first part of the game and then suddenly wakes up and joins the RTWGuru bandwagon (which i started...) and then he joins the Hepcat wagon - 2 votes out of 3 rounds (and a vote off) and both are bandwagons...
second is Don - as noted hes more active, he attacked kage even after everyone else was pretty sure he was the detective and he didnt vote prole(not conlucsive at that point if I was mafia I would have voted for her if only to buy time for yourself)
i sugesst we lynch one and investigate the other- im going with Disco oh and btw i dont agree with the dont vote the only informatio nwe have to go on is voting record - if we all dont vote we only have kage to rely on and theres no guarantee he will hit
Vote: Disco
and now i better don some protective gear... its going to get nasty...
WHAT!! Are you trying to mock me further! As if getting me killed isn't enough you now mock my instrument of choice by making horrible sounds on it.Quote:
Originally Posted by discovery1
~:mecry:
Why do you hate me.:embarassed:
well sas sent me a pm trying to persuade me to unvote im not convinced so my vote stand for now but basically im of the opinion that sasakis maths are just that - math
they foget the wonderful human element we dont know what the mafia will do and by not voting everyone is anonymous - we need the votes to trace actions to work out who is what - the only other option is to rely on kage to get lucky and play the odds - oh and btw kage i think you SHOULD post last nights investigation while they are doomed to die it is one more confirmed inocent for those of us who cant investigate people
sorry sas will take some convincing to get me to unvote
Sir moody, by tomorrow we can have 3 people proved innocent. And possible find mafia. It's quite possible to discuss without voting. It's not just math. Best case scenario tomorrow we are choosing between 3 people.
If you were mafia, this would be an easy oppurtunity to bump off an innocent and leave us with only one lynch.
Sir Moody, I am proud to say I was retaliation voted by someone like you. :bow: :2thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sir Moody
Sorry Moody but im not telling who i investigated. So are you into bold mafia tactics my friend? To me Sasaki`s logig is pretty solid one. Maybe we should just lynch you?Since it seems that you are not willing to help the town,but want one townie dead by lynching?
I can't believe I'm being held up as mafia, again! I didn't 'go after' Kagemusha. I simply have pointed out that thus far, he has not offered a single lick of evidence for being the detective. Let's think about this for a second, shall we?
-Kagemusha decides to do an early reveal, when under no compulsion to do so.
-He names Proletariat, who hadn't said boo the entire game up until then.
-He then proceeds to name an innocent who coincidentally gets killed immediately after the investegation. EVERY TIME!!!
And you people don't see anything bizarre in this course of events? Talk about marching to the tune of the pied piper. :clown: :clown: :clown:
Tell you what... if you're all so convinced Kagemusha IS the detective, and I'm the most suspicious person up until now, why hasn't he investegated me? He's had 4 rounds to do it!!!
As for me being more active in this game than Hanky's, I thought I had explained that. I missed the first 4 days of Hanky's because I was away for Thanksgiving. I never really got a chance to understand what was going on. In this one, I was starting from ground zero with the rest of you.
Now, before anybody votes for anybody, I want to hear Kagemusha come up with another incredible 'coincidence', namely that he investegated Husar this round.... :inquisitive: I mean, that's pretty much his MO right? He always 'investegates' the guy he really actually gunned down? I think our real detective got killed before he could reveal.
Sorry Don my friend,but would assasination attempt from Mafia qualify as proof?
hey lynch me if you want - i know im innocent and ill go down with a clean "virtual"Conscience
i dont want to sit here and play the numbers its a gamble i want to activly hound the mafia, to try to catch them at their game if we win because we got lucky how is that a win? its no different from winning the lottery or play the slots - this game is poker and i want to cal ltheir bluff
No, it wouldn't, Kagemusha, mi amigo. You have everyone in the town except for me convinced you're the detective, even the doctor. It's no wonder they protected you, which frankly, I can see you laughing your fool head off. For all we know, there was only one killing ordered. You and your cohort don't have to order two. All Csar said was that the Doctor protected you, not that you were actually targeted by the mafia.
If you really are the detective, why haven't you investegated me yet? Most of the town is convinced I'm mafia, wouldn't I be a natural suspect for you to target? Nope, you want me alive, which is why you haven't joined the bandwagon against me. You need a patsy, and I'm it.
Edit: erh, laughing your fool head off was a figure of speech. No slight whatsoever intended, Kagemusha. You've played this one beautifully. :bow:
Kage investigating those who die is odd, but there was something about Kage that made me doubt he was lying, and now the fact that he was attacked seals the deal. You are our hope Kage. :yes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Kagemusha
oh and dons post is seriously making me want to change my vote to him but it stands for now
All I have to say about that is this.... You all have been saying that any hint of suspicion towards kagemusha not being the detective makes me look very suspicious for several rounds now. If I were really mafia, wouldn't I have stopped by now?Quote:
Originally Posted by Sir Moody
oh jeez - bandwagon? im the only one who voted and i voted disco cause he was acting odd but this just threw you into the "knee jerk" defence and the fact you are defending without really reading back has my hackles upQuote:
Nope, you want me alive, which is why you haven't joined the bandwagon against me. You need a patsy, and I'm it.
change of plans
unvote
Vote Don C
which leaves disco (or more likely me the way im going) to be investigated by Kage