Vote: General Hankerchief. I should have known would be one of the mafia.
Printable View
Vote: General Hankerchief. I should have known would be one of the mafia.
I'm not sure that's allowed.Quote:
Originally Posted by Xiahou
My reasoning for voting GH is as follows:
Disco was PMing someone yesterday so I went back and looked at all the people online during that time. It was between GH and Jimbob so I watched Disco for a while. Then went back and looked at the online users and Jimbob was gone so it was down to GH was the only one left so right after Disco finished PMing I went and looked at GH's profile. Not a minute later GH's profile showed him PMing. Once I found out he was finished I went back and watched Disco's profile. A few minutes later Disco was PMing again. Hence the reasoning for my vote.
It's ok. Unlike pm's, chatlogs can't be faked, because there are witnesses.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
I cleared it before posting. :bow:Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
Interestingly, the same phenomenon occurred later as well, except this time it was:I also grabbed a screenie of that, but am too lazy to crop/upload/post it atm, but I will if it becomes necessary to do so.Quote:
*** GH has signed off IRC (Quit: Ichigo)
I assume this means Ichigo and GH were also chatting. Can anyone explain why that message shows up in chat? Regardless, my vote stays.
And what time exactly was this Csar? I do believe Ignoramus should be able to explain me PMing, or yourself for that matter, if I remeber the time correctly.
Yesterday 4:35 around that time. You can't expect me to remember exactly.Quote:
Originally Posted by discovery1
Why does it matter unless your trying to defend your own mafioso Disco? You screwed yourself by posting that.
I can actually, since I sent you a PM around that same time. You and Ignoramus, and Hepcat but he's not playing.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
I was wrong and editted my post to show that. It was around the time I posted thisQuote:
Originally Posted by discovery1
Well now looking at the evidence posted by Xiahou and Ichigo. I do indeed believe that GH is a mafia so therfore...
Vote: GeneralHankerchief
Vote:GeneralHankerchief
My first prediction seems right..
Looking at the evidence posted by Xiahou as I can't believe Ichigo for various reasons. GH is guilty.
vote:GeneralH
for chatting in private rooms :inquisitive:
I must say that kill/message wise, this has been an interesting night. Only one successful kill and no messages from either the masons or the mafia. So I bet that the masons have managed to stop yet another murder attempt. So how come there was no message from the masons this time? Maybe the masons don't have such an easy access to information as we had previously thought.
Anyway to my vote. GH is definately looking guilty and that's definately enough for me.
Vote: GH
To add to what has been said, remember this?
That was posted right after round 1, when the only graffiti message was from the mafia - as we now know thanks to the soothsayer. Trying to build some credibility for your team's false clues, eh General? :inquisitive:Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
I've still got my eye on Sir Moody, but you were also on my short list of suspects, buddy. Though nice job trying to match your past behavior. :yes:
Vote: GeneralHankerchief
Okay, so the mafia wants a fight? Well, bring it on. Since they can't kill me (this is the second time they've tried, with no luck) they're forced to lynch me in order to take me out of the game. Well, it's not going to be that easy, guys.
So, after barely surviving a lynch vote in the first round, I receive this PM around the same time the one kill is posted:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
And then, I received this when the one kill was posted last night:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
I think, by the one kill last night, the mafia realized that they had stumbled upon an unkillable role, so they put Plan B in action. I must say, it's working rather splendidly. I mean, you get the classic bandwagon-followers, Ignoramus and AggonyDuck, who have done nothing this game but vote with the crowd, against me, so that's two. You get the mafia of course, Ichigo and Xiahou against me (that screenshot is clearly doctored, did you see the weird area around Quit:Lenin?), and their boss, Disco, is even stepping in to defend me. And by the way, that whole PM thing is a load of crap. Does Ichigo have any evidence? Any screenshots? No, he just says "I saw GH PMing, lynch him!" It's working marvelously, you sheep. Congratulations. World-class effort, guys.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
And let me guess. After I die the mafia are going to go to one kill per round so that the guys who voted for me (even those that did nothing but bandwagon) will pat themselves on the back and go "good job, we got ourselves a bad guy lynched."
So yeah, vote for me if you want. I, however, will finish the job that Ichigo tried to do on me twice and that I almost did on him last round before Sigurd stupidly convinced me to do so otherwise.
VOTE: ICHIGO
I don't really know what to think about Xiahou's screenshot. The quite message can be typed in whenever you quit and can be set in certain programs to a standard message in Trillian it's a link to the Trillian homepage by default but that doesn't mean you had a private conversation with the Trillian homepage, does it? Maybe some programs write the priivate conversations in there but we should verify that instead of just assuming it.
Now there is disco jumping in to defend GH somehow. While that would usually make me vote for GH I just took the emergency brake since the mafia tries to make certain people look suspicious with the graffity already. That means disco might jump to aid GH only to get him lynched.
The problem is that disco in his almighty evil position can play with us and we gain nothing at all from it. The chatlog doesn't convince me yet, I want to hear what GH has to say before I do anything.
Very, very interesting.
Food for thought, that *GH's reveal I mean !*
The reveal looks real, but it does come at a time where a reveal usually is the only way out. Plus, the descriptions in the PM's fit your writing style better than they do Sasaki's, plus you do have it in you to forge such PM's. It wouldn't be the first fake reveal now would it.
As said, we should think about it - but to change votes with little thought isn't good either !
:balloon2:
a'right
unvote:GeneralH
vote:Csar
Not buying it this time, GH. :no:
As he has repeatedly said (and as experience makes clear), Sasaki is not much of a writer. I highly doubt he'd send you PMs like that just to tell you that you were attacked when he barely ever even writes a kill/lynch story.
Um, no. :inquisitive: After examining it closely, it looks legit to me. If it's fake that's one heck of a forgery.Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Even if the chat log, my method's predictions, and various other pieces of evidence weren't convincing, your fabricated defense rubber-stamps it. My vote stands.
I was wondering why you took so long to defend yourself, but now I know why.Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
I'm sure you've had this planned out from the beginning. Why would the mafia try to kill you twice in a row if you didn't die the first time? That would be dumb and they'de know that you had some special role that couldn't be killed.
Your contradicting yourself GH. If I attacked you during the second round then how is it possible that I attacked you again in the third? Your evidence has many holes in it. I guess because you weren't ready to false reveal this early. Come back when everything from your reveal is in order then maybe you'll have a chance.
AHAHAHAHAHAHAQuote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
You attempted to kill me in the SECOND round, and then again in the FOURTH round.
4-2=2
Dear god, Disco must be killing himself right now. He picked a mafioso that repeatedly goes after the same person even without little success (ever heard of a doctor, buddy?) and can't even do math.
Oh, and by the way, Kommodus, how do we know that you're not just fudging that list? It would be mighty easy to just pretend that someone is guilty, especially if you consider someone a threat.
Kung fu master? while sasaki has been known to make strange roles up in the past i think that one is way too out there and it doesnt disprove the other mounting facts - General H is also a fine choice for a mafia henchman since he is arguably the most experianced player here
Vote General Hankerchief
time will tell but im as sure as i can be hes a mafia
I know there is no doctor in this game. My bad with the math I didn't go back and count the rounds. Though there's one flaw in everything in that PM. Disco is the one that writes and sends in the PMs to Sasaki.Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
You seem sure of yourself with that evidence, don't you? I know why! Because you suggest to Disco who a good target would be! You probably think I got protected by a doctor or you got blocked by a Thief, decided to take a round off, and then persuade Disco to try your luck again!Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
Your wrong with that one if I couldn't kill you the first time I wouldn't go after you again. Also look back at that last post I edited some of it.Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Well, we don't know that, do we? That's just the thing with saying "no, I would have done it this way" AFTER it happens. It's a bit late, isn't it?Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
Also:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
How can you possibly be sure? MAFIOSO.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
The evidence seems to be piling up against both Ichigo and GH. At the moment it seems to be one word against another so I propose we take action against both players. I say that this round we lynch GH and next round we lynch Ichigo. Its the only way we can be sure that we have got a Mafia at the present time.
Ichigo?
How do you know there is know doctor in the game?
And how do you know that Disco sends in the pms?
No everyone else doesn't know except for me, you and your mafioso buddies.I can't. It would just seem so stupid if Sasaki did something like that.Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Just something that I doubt.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sir Boo
If you look at the last two kills. The orange haired and orange bearded person is an obvious referral to himself. I just put two and two together.
Killing me would be a bad thing for the town since I have an ability that will surely help the town.
"Well, what's the ability?"Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
"I can't tell you."
"Why not?"
"Because it would be bad for the town if I told you."
"Then why should we believe you?"
"Because I have an ability to help the town."
:laugh4: At least I told everyone my ability. What's the matter, Ichigo? Can't think of a good role quickly enough?
So Kage why aren't you posting? Your usually more active. You hiding something?