If the town had been a little more proactive with vigilante groups they could have bumped off quite a few more mafia. Scottishranger got revealed on what, day 3? Yet he's still alive...
Printable View
If the town had been a little more proactive with vigilante groups they could have bumped off quite a few more mafia. Scottishranger got revealed on what, day 3? Yet he's still alive...
just got this from sasaki
"Hey Ironside,
in the thread norwegian seems to be on to you. I think I have a plan to throw him off track but it needs some work, you got any ideas?
Sasaki"
Nice fake PM
I amuse myself :laugh4:Quote:
Originally Posted by norwegian nerd
Didnt the town win the first Capo?
And ill tip my hat to those trying to pysch us out, but unfortunately its not gonna work.
Yea...I got caught trying to start two mafias, yet somehow I am still alive. The town had better people to lynch.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
Anyways, wondering what news the night will bring.
I disagree that the mafia outplayed the town. Almost every WoGed player was townie, which put us at a massive disadvantage. In addition, the only reason the mafia was able to pull off the Kukri lynch was because a few townies went over to the mafia at the very end of the game. The mafia doesn't deserve much credit for that. If the townies had simply stayed pro-town, it would have been a town victory. The only people that deserve any credit at this point are the original mafia members who managed to remain hidden and alive this entire time, particularly Craterus, Kagemusha, Elite Ferret, CountArach, and gibson (nicely done, my friend). The people who simply jumped ship at the end are nothing more than opportunists, not grand strategists in any sense. People like Louis and CR deserve far more praise for their early game efforts.Quote:
Originally Posted by Dutch_guy
Kinda sad to not see my name on your list of greatness :sad: After all, i am the first Made Cunnio..and I DID gain your trust pretty well.Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
One wiseguy switched at end. We had a majority without him. Town could have played much better, face it :yes:Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
@Kukri, it is not the information that the mafia had which is an unfair advantage. The whole point of mafia is that it is meant to be the informed minority vs the uninformed majority.
And that statement also encapsulates the the reason this more of a game-break than a mafia victory.
The informed minority...
In most mafia games, there are at most three mafioso. Anything more and the game gets unbalanced. CDTC can afford to have more mafia because they are supposed to be against each other, as well as the town.
There are certainly mafia players who deserve congratulations, but they deserve it for they play exculding participating in this whimp out of a 'victory'.
As an aside, I like to give heartfelt thanks to Seamus for hosting this game. It has been very fun. I wish it could have ended with a little more daring and tension, the way CDTC is meant to be, but it's still been a great game. One of the best in my inexperience opinion.
What part dont you people understand.It says in each original mafia role description that mafia victory is more important then victory of individual family. If we had not organized in few turns we would have been picked one by one. Maybe that would have make the town more happy and you could have said, what a crappy mafia you were against. I hope we could stop the mud slinging and play the game to the end.:candle:
^^what he said^^
There's not much tension in going down a list of detective results and checking them off one by one. Look at the day Hiji was lynched. There were what, 40 posts tops?Quote:
Originally Posted by Myrddraal
Oh I dunno, I bet the mafia were pretty tense :wink:
Coming from you, that means a lot. Let's see if I can go 2-0 with KOTR, lol.Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
Aw, don't take it personally Kage; you and the others will get a well-deserved "gg m8!" when the game is actually ended. In the meantime (and we're probably looking at another week of play), dead townies are doing what they (we) can to demoralize, confuse and harrass the mafia. We're supposed to do that, according to Seamus' rules and role explanations.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kagemusha
My lynching, though important, is just a battle won, not the entire war. Now, instead of picking on defenseless townies, you have to guess which of your sneaky brothers-in-arms is gonna turn on you first. Then correctly time your assault on him.
Much tougher task.
O RLY? :inquisitive:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
Well played, remaining mafiosi :2thumbsup:
Now, kill those petty townies :evil:
Hehe. Hey Andres: I've finally decided; I DO wanna come over to the dark side. :laugh4:
The town could have played better, for example by utilising all of the townies, as a large number of them (including me) were mostly doing nothing :dizzy2:.
How did all the mafia manages to get to get into Tincow and CR's inner circle anyway?
I'll tell you when the game is actually overQuote:
Originally Posted by shlin28
I was under the impression that several (current) mafioso were townies not long ago. Being dead, the situation is somewhat unclear to me. My apologies if I offended anyone. I do believe that anyone who started as mafioso and is still alive played very well.
or just didn't play much and was largely ignored. :P
this was the first game i've played decently.
Good night,sleep tight town of fatlington.:sharky:
Hmm... I think I've found a flaw in the mafia plan. With all the townies dead, who are they going to shake down and extort? Congratulations, you've cut off your own source of income. You have also conveniently killed all the garbagemen and sewage treatment plant workers. I hope you enjoy living in a very smelly town. Need I mention the fact that when all the doctors are dead, you're probably bound for a slow and painful death?
Silly mafia never think their plans all the way through.
Aye, Craterus and Kagemusha and a few others definately deserve a big congratulations for a game well played.
Do you guys actually think that I can keep a straight face when talking about family loyalty? How many times did I switch sides in this game? 4, 5, maybe more?
If the first thing listed in your victory conditions was a mafia victory no matter what family then I guess y'all aren't doing anything wrong with this mafia truce.
I can't believe the town let Sasaki live this long. TinCow's evidence was the strongest case we could ever hope to have against Sasaki in this type of game.
I'm still curious about who Tiberius of the Drake's Don was.
Well, where were you guys going to drink and gamble when you'd lynched all of us? :smash:Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
I was going to study how to place explosives and sniper training.
Guys, let's not get philosophical. One family should be perfect balance.
lol, looks like it'll be Crate's family, though.
We have the same amount of people as you guys, and no Luca, so what do you mean?Quote:
Originally Posted by gibsonsg91921