Netherworld Mafia [Concluded]

Well now we know that 1 Killer attacks the person with the second most votes we can work it to our advantage or the Doctor can protect them, depending on who the person with the second most votes is.

I've re-thought my position on Omanes, mainly due to how in Capo he seemed pretty innocent until his death. But, also since Makayane also feels that Omanesis suspicious, I'm not going crazy.

Ichigo's vote on TP, a player who was AFK, puts him in the spotlight. Something I'm not willing to let slip right now.

Not to mention that TinCow has been acting strange the last couple pages.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rythmic

Not to mention that TinCow has been acting strange the last couple pages.

---

Something in particular?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kamikhaan

Edit: Sarathos, the flames 'devoured' the book. Its a figure of speech, but I changed the wording anyways. The killer didn't eat the book.

---

Oh, ok.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit

Vampire? It seemed more like a werewolf creature.

---

Its kinda hard to distinguish. For starters its a female, now I not being sexist here but how many female Werewolves do you know? And it bit Tratorix in the neck...I know Werewolves do that, but its sounds more vampiric.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Woads&fangs

My best guess at roles: Mafia-3 = Club dude

---

I not sure if that is an actually character or just Twilight getting WOGed, or maybe not.

But on that note, Vote:pevergreen

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pevergreen

Kill off everyone you know personally

---

You said it yourself...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pevergreen

I actually have a pro-town role this game guys...

---

Prove it.

Id like proof I said kill off everyone I know personally.

Are you dead?

I'd rather stay alive, I have no reason to reveal.

Well if its female, can we assume that since Prole is dead, we need to lynch Makanyane? :grin2:

Vote: Kommodus

From what I understand, there's more than enough posts for Holmes to start producing results by this point. However, Kommodus hasn't been talking. So, start talking. :whip:

Quote:

---

Ive just had a thought, if the kill on the person with the second most votes is certain, can the "protectors" just block it each night, since its certain that they will be attacked? Or we could use it as a way of having the power of two lynches?

---

If this is indeed true (we have only 2 successive results, it might all be coincedence still), indeed, doctors know who to protect,.. but it's not really logic, why would we want someone that we almost voted off to survive?

we just have a sort of double lynch. :book: :2thumbsup:

and, Vote: TinCow

You really seem to be specifically looking for reasons to post and vote. So that you're active and seem to be helping town. However, just voting kommodus because he hasn't come up with a book on holmes results yet? scum, scum, scum..

btw, Rythmic, keep those summary's coming! :book: :yes:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Andres

Something in particular?

---

Mostly the fact he claimed the resurrection of Sigurd was angelic. When the Pentagram and the fact Sigurd said he'd be back for revenge point towards a pro-town/hell role.

Edit: I'm really interested on what Sigurd has to say. Especially his FoS on Drisos.

Edit2: I just had a funny thought, what if the person with the second most votes was the killer who attacks those with the second most votes. :laugh4:

Ah the smell of fresh brimstone and the wailing sound of the damned souls in the morning bring a smile to my face. I live yet again.

Now concerning the killers… I am waiting on the results of night 4 before I will make a thorough analysis.

But I would say that we have a shape shifter that kills since some players seems to be confused about this.
On night 2 it attacked Gibson impersonating Kamikhaan, Gibson witnessed it shape shift to something with several tails.
On night 3 Tratorix was attacked by the shape shifter impersonating a Demoness, Tratorix witnessed it shape shift to something animal like with fangs.
The Balrog like killer with flaming orifices black sword and whip kills every night.

But back to Joe Monks… would any believe me if I had done the same stunt? I find it incredible that someone would just jump in and make a vote without having scanned a few of the previous posts. It is scummy and I will act on it.

Vote: Joe Monks

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TinCow

Vote: Kommodus

From what I understand, there's more than enough posts for Holmes to start producing results by this point. However, Kommodus hasn't been talking. So, start talking. :whip:

---

Frankly, TC, this is scummy. I'm a fairly easy lynch target at the moment, simply because I haven't said much and it's fairly well-known that I tend to lurk as mafia. You appear to be going for the easy lynch. :inquisitive:

Vote: TinCow

I'm not yet ready to discuss results from Holmes. Sorry if this disappoints y'all, but at the moment I don't have anything concrete enough, and I'm not going to post results just to placate the crowd.

We are forgetting to tally. Start of this phase:

Joe Monks 1 (Sigurd Fafnesbane,)

Kommodus 2 (GH, TinCow)

pevergreen 1 (Sarathos)

BananaBob 1 (W&F)

Tincow 3 ( Joe Monks, Driscos, Kommodus)

Abstain: BananaBob, Makanyane

Hopefully this correct. Still undecided with my vote.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rythmic

Mostly the fact he claimed the resurrection of Sigurd was angelic. When the Pentagram and the fact Sigurd said he'd be back for revenge point towards a pro-town/hell role.

Edit: I'm really interested on what Sigurd has to say. Especially his FoS on Drisos.

Edit2: I just had a funny thought, what if the person with the second most votes was the killer who attacks those with the second most votes. :laugh4:

---

Right...
Just to quell some of the thoughts going on here.
I named my killer an archangel because of the way I was killed. I promised revenge because I would be getting in to the game and find my killer and make people vote for him/her. As an innocent dead I can be more dangerous than left alive in the game, if players will listen to me that is. I have no special role and I have no esoteric knowledge as to who my killers were.

My FoS on Drisos was just a shot in the dark like his shot in the dark in Capo II. You never know, I could be as lucky as he was.

But you guys are right.. Tincow seemed to be a little worried that I came back to life and hence a FoS is justified.

As to Kommodus, he had very little time to play Capo II and used his Holmes only twice. I didn't ask him to use it in the service of Corleone and he was mostly absent after his demise. We should give him some more time.

vote:abstain

I don't think anyone looks particularly suspicious at the moment.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sigurd

My FoS on Drisos was just a shot in the dark like his shot in the dark in Capo II. You never know, I could be as lucky as he was.

---

Haha, of course. ~D

I don't believe Joe Monks is the best target. He does have the convinient excuse of being short on time, but I don't think I can vote him. Especially since the actions of TinCow don't seem to add up. Also worth noting that I can't see Joe Monks being a role related to TinCow's, Mafia or otherwise, since he was the first to pick up on TinCow's jab a Sigurd. I'm not willing to rule out him having a secret role though.

Vote: TinCow

Tally as of #374:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Joe Monks - 1 (Sigurd Fafnesbane,)

Kommodus - 2 (GH, TinCow)

pevergreen - 1 (Sarathos)

BananaBob - 1 (W&F)

Tincow - 4 ( Joe Monks, Drisos, Kommodus, Rythmic)

Abstain: BananaBob, Makanyane, Elite Ferret

Edit: Updating tally.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rythmic

Well now we know that 1 Killer attacks the person with the second most votes we can work it to our advantage or the Doctor can protect them, depending on who the person with the second most votes is.

---

This seems rather counter productive, why would we save someone we had been trying to lynch? I suppose it would mean there was a chance the doctor could kill the attacker while protecting the second lynchee. But what about this turn, there are two people with the second most votes. And besides it could all be a big coincidence and someone here is just laughing at us for thinking this.

You're going to lynch me because I'm trying to analyze the situation? People keep telling me that posting gets you noticed and getting noticed gets you lynched, but I don't see the point in staying quiet when some things need to be said. For the record, as I stated, my vote on Kommodus was simply to get a response from him, not to kill him. Since that is now accomplished, I will remove it.

Unvote: Kommodus
Vote: Abstain

If you lynch me, you will be doing the town a disservice. I have a pro-town role and it has been known to (and proved to) another townie for a while now. If you are looking for an explanation for my 'strange' behavior, perhaps consider the fact that I might have more information on the kind of special abilities people might have in this game than some of the rest of you. I am applying the knowledge I have of my own role to what I see happening at night.

Can that townie come forward and vouch for you?

I'll leave that up to him, since it exposes him to the mafia as well.

Just had a brainwave and I think I know who that townie is, but I'm not going to reveal them, if they want to reveal they can themselves. Boy oh boy, so confusing, with so many WIFOMs.

I hesitantly trust Sigurd, so I'm going to Unvote: TinCow, and Vote: Joe Monks.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TinCow

If you lynch me, you will be doing the town a disservice. I have a pro-town role and it has been known to (and proved to) another townie for a while now. If you are looking for an explanation for my 'strange' behavior, perhaps consider the fact that I might have more information on the kind of special abilities people might have in this game than some of the rest of you. I am applying the knowledge I have of my own role to what I see happening at night.

---

Well, as far as I know, we have 2 detectives and 1 or 2 doctors.

And maybe a pro-town Necromancer, unless, this necromancer role is the doctor. After all, we are in hell, so it wouldn't be impossible if the doctor role works different then in regular mafia, i.e. by having the ability to resurrect a murdered townie, maybe with some sort of succes chance.

What's it going to be?

You could at least name the townie who is supposed to be able to vouch for you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TinCow

I'll leave that up to him, since it exposes him to the mafia as well.

---

That's not a satisfying answer.

You claim a role, without giving details. You claim that a townie can confirm your innocence, but refuse to name said townie. If he's just a townie and you have a pro-town power role, then the identity of that townie is not at all important.

I don't see a valid reason to withold the identity of an innocent yet unimportant townie.

Vote : TinCow

Vote: TinCow
Could be a last hope defence, could not be. Lets find out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Andres

I don't see a valid reason to withold the identity of an innocent yet unimportant townie.

---

You've answered your own question.

Unimportant seems to be the key word.

If they are a normal townie, then they will die tonight, same as any normal townie would.

Less chance of a pro-town being killed then.

And if there are two doctors, one can protect you.

I would like to thank the Mafia for stepping forward.

Unvote: Joe Monks Vote: Andres

Please those townies who are left, get your votes on Andres, I'd like to see a townie victory this time.

Edit: FoS pevergreen

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TinCow

You've answered your own question.

---

Nonsense. Why would you risk an important pro-town role (yours) by withholding the identity of a townie?

Or are you claiming to have a power role and that you accidentally stumbled upon another pro-town power role who can confirm your innocence?

You have to understand that it is difficult to believe such a story. I think you are lying.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rythmic

I would like to thank the Mafia for stepping forward.

Unvote: Joe Monks Vote: Andres

Please those townies who are left, get your votes on either Andres or pevergreen, I'd like to see a townie victory this time.

---

~:confused:

Really...

And, eh, what exactly is it that leads you to this sudden change of heart?

EDIT: Interesting to see that you edited your post. Why exactly is it that we suddenly don't have to vote for pevergreen anymore?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rythmic

I would like to thank the Mafia for stepping forward.

Unvote: Joe Monks Vote: Andres

Please those townies who are left, get your votes on Andres, I'd like to see a townie victory this time.

Edit: FoS pevergreen

---

How is trying to make TinCow prove he is innocent making me mafia?

EDIT: No, really how am I mafia?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Andres

~:confused:

Really...

And, eh, what exactly is it that leads you to this sudden change of heart?

---

The way you expertly manipulated the town in Capo for a start, and secondly I know who the townie TinCow mentioned is.

In anycase, voting either way I'll have been 'manipulated', so it doesn't really matter.

(OOC: I'm glad I've got more involved than I did in Capo, makes the game much more fun :2thumbsup:)

Edit:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by pever

EDIT: No, really how am I mafia?

---

I never said that, I just said you're under suspicion.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TinCow

I have a pro-town role and it has been known to (and proved to) another townie for a while now.

---

By those words you made yourself a prime candidate for murder. The God sent sons of she-dogs will think as I do that you are not merely a simple townie.
You said A which will surely kill you... why not say B that will help the town?