Printable View
My thoughts exactly, although when I was partnered with Andres his kill choices in the initial stages of the game were fairly high profile players. For instance, I believe he wished to kill off Sigurd in the first or second round.Quote:
Originally Posted by Proletariat
I also believe Kommodus would be either choice one or two for the detective, meaning he probably investigated him already.
:balloon2:
As so many times before in GH’s games, I suspect that he is writing the story with few inputs from the Mafia.
At least he tailors them into his story. The flow from the first words to the end is not changing and it is his style.
If these stories are written by the mafia we have to turn to the US for our killer. The term: Bismarck is only used in the US. In Europe and AUS it is called Berliner.
But my initial feel is that it is GH’s writing and the Mafia only provides names and weapons.
Now what is up with the Ichigo/Disco exchange?
Disco was supposed to stay silent? Not supposed to play?
What? Ichigo and Disco are the Mafiosi and since Disco have the habit of getting himself lynched if he opens his mouth it was best that he hid in the background?
My list of suspects is growing:
Sasaki
Andres
Husar
Pannonian
Ichigo
Discovery1
There still isnt any clear evidence in my mind, but i agree with the idea of getting less active players more active so...
Vote: Festershinetop
Even tho I really want to vote Sasaki, Pever might have a point.
Andres is not inactive
Beefy is more active than normal, with better detail, and he has exams
fos Beefy
List of suspects for me:
Beefy
Sasaki
Berliner? What does that mean?Quote:
Originally Posted by Sigurd Fafnesbane
when did i say i got exams? Oh right pever said it. Because i dont do science (never do science!!) and i already had my Ancient history exam i got a pretty easy weekend. (oops had couple chinese exams next week)
i only got math exam which is next next week.
this week i got some work to do but i always tend to slack off on friday and saturday. and besides its weekend so i got pretty much nothing to do but EB and mafia.
My increase in activity is because i have nothing to do. You can confirm it by checking the scores on the Org arcade. you should be able to find my name somewhere on scoring board. My increase in detail is just me trying to improve my playing style in general and try help the town much as i can. + i think i am more confident to express what i think after playing couple games with you lot and learned most of your playing styles I might and I will enjoy killing killfr3nzy early as possible when i become mafia (Sarathos can go in my list of killing as well) but killing pever wont do much good because he never believes me and chases me around with a gigantic sticks in real life.
Just to let you know.. Once i start typing i cant stop. I am one of the top spammers in small forums.
Btw i believe Beliner is people from Berlin. Correct me if im wrong
"Ich bin ein Berliner!!!"~JFKQuote:
Originally Posted by pevergreen
English translation-"I am a jelly filled dougnut!!!"
Gasp!!! The conspiracy theories are true!!! JFK was killed by the mafia!!!
I find Tran going from a random vote, to two back to back admittedly bandwagon votes HIGHLY suspicious. Consider this a FOS on him.
That being said, I've seen nothing out of Andres that in any way remotely soothes my earlier fears about him. In fact, his continued voting for me, with no additional evidence, just makes him look even guiltier (can't admit a mistake, because if he survives, he'll be forced to acknowledge it down the road, more of a concern for mafia then a townie).
What's more, several people have made cases against him. Rather than answering any of them, he blanketly dismisses them as without merit. W/out merit according to whom, Andres? :inquisitive:
Vote: Andres
Everyone, why Andres?
Vote: Andres
He's acting lackadaisical. Witness him posting the picture of the godfather and saying its not personal, its business. He bandwagoned Don Corleone on an obviously fake reveal. Beefy187 just seemed to eager to defend Andres last round even though Andres was in no danger. After viewing GH's previous mafia games it seems he has been choosing one veteran and one relatively new player to be mafia. If that is the case then Andres and Beefy187 appear to be our mafia.
Unvote: Sasaki
Vote: W&F
who's talking about bandwagoning?
Quote:
Sarathos: 7 (Warmaster Horus, shlin28, Husar, sapi, Pannonian, Byzantine Mercenary, Lemur)
Andres: 3 (woad&fangs, Ichigo, Don Corleone)
Husar: 2 (Sasaki Kojiro, Kommodus)
Ichigo: 2 (Destroyer of Hope, Sarathos)
Don Corleone: 2 (Andres, Kagemusha)
Sasaki Kojiro: 2 (Tiberius of the Drake, Xiahou)
woad&fangs: 1 (greaterkhaan)
Pannonian: 1 (RoadKill)
Xiahou: 1 (Xdeathfire)
greaterkhaan: 1 (Stig)
FesterShinetop: 1 (Crazed Rabbit)
Abstained: 8 (Caius Flaminius, Twilightblade, Brave_Sir_Robin, Beefy187, Dutch_guy, Proletariat, Pra Tha Funkee Homo Sapien)
Didn't vote: 7 (Ignoramus, Tran, Killfr3nzy, FesterShinetop, discovery1, CountArach, Fragony)
New list of suspects:Quote:
Andres 5 (Disco, Ichigo, Beefy, Don, W&F)
Festershinetop 2 (CR, ByzantineMercenary)
Kommo 1 (Tran)
Disco 1 (Sasaki)
Tran 2 (Sapi, DoH)
DoH 1 (CA)
Husar 1 (Kage)
W&F 1 (Stig)
Don 1 (Andres)
Sasaki (His acting)
Disco (Sasaki is trying to make a bandwagon, while he knew he wouldn't work. Are they working together)
Beefy (He's supposed to be studying)
Dutch Guy (You never know with him and his abstaining)
W&F (As he isn't bandwagoning)
Also, people who seem to be hunting others:
Don, even tho he claims Andres is hunting him
Ichigo, with some lame reason
W&F, he isn't bandwagoning is he?
Andres, as well
All in all:
Andres is innocent imo. I'm thinking the mafia are:
Disco and Sasaki
Sasaki and someone
Beefy and someone
W&F and someone
Triple post woooooh
That is bull"poo", as they are decided randomly, sides last one it was Andres and DG wasn't it?Quote:
After viewing GH's previous mafia games it seems he has been choosing one veteran and one relatively new player to be mafia.
Hmm, Andres doesn't really strike me as guilty atm, just misguided; I think we'd be better off focusing on those who are narrowly avoiding detection though posting the minimum amount possible to be ignored, not just on the active townies...
Okay, so I was wrong about the previous games. I still think Andres is guilty. And whats with your comments about me not bandwagoning?
Meh, I was not satisfied with your defense and this won't make me change my mind.Quote:
Originally Posted by Don Corleone
Like I said before: what cases?Quote:
Originally Posted by Don Corleone
Your vote is nothing more than pure retaliation. In a nice package, yes, but nothing more than pure retaliation.
Eh, I don't understand. You think it's me because the kills are made by an experienced player, on the other hand, maybe it isn't me because I killed high profile players in a previous game :inquisitive: What's it going to be?Quote:
Originally Posted by Dutch_guy
Like eh, for example, hum, oh, our friend Byzantine Mercenary who said:Quote:
Originally Posted by sapi
Suspicious :inquisitive:Quote:
Originally Posted by Byzantine Mercenary
What's your reason for voting Andres?Quote:
Originally Posted by woad&fangs
Type it out, in more than 50 words. If you can't even do that, you're bandwagoning. First you claim that Andres is mafia, because Beefy defended him and GH always picks an experienced and an unexperienced player, which is bull as Beefy played more than you have. Next to that you say that he sounds as a quilty player, if Andres would be mafia he would play it differently, he has been mafia, and we know how he plays, and he doesn't change his style as Sasaki tends to do.
They aren't, as I said before, in all the last games we had experienced players as mafia (Omanes had GH, Ichigo and Sasaki and I had Ichigo and Sasaki (and a third player)). And their strategy was killing the active players, as that way you get rid of all activiness in the game and it slowly begins to die, like Omanes' and my game. That way all you need to do is make one post a round, hardly suspicious.Quote:
You think it's me because the kills are made by an experienced player
Edit to this: the kills aren't likely to be made to someone who's new to .org mafia either, as Sigurd got killed on day 1, might be a stroke of luck, but mostlikely we got 2 mafia who've played a couple of games.
Someone as W&F or Beefy.
Or it's Sasaki, who tricks us again.
My reasoning was 80 words. I am not bandwagoning. I voted for him last round too. I would have voted for him sooner this round but it's not my fault I have to sleep.
Your initial reasoning was flawed, give a proper one.Quote:
Originally Posted by woad&fangs
Perhaps you could explain why you think I'm guilty?
He thinks you suspicious because you continue to attempt to evade his questioning...exhibit A ^^Quote:
Originally Posted by woad&fangs
What Sapi said.Quote:
Originally Posted by woad&fangs
Next to that I did explain it: your reasoning is flawed, and you are unwilling to give a proper reasoning.
First things first, Lemur, KillFr3nzy just got killed so voting for him is rather pointless. I'm still rather confused as to what I have done to be considered guilty. I'm not trying to avoid answering questions, I'm just not sure what the question is. Is it because you believe I am being a hypocrit by "bandwagoning" Andres and using his Don Corleone bandwagon vote as part of my evidence. I have already explained that I voted for him last turn and all of the Andres votes this round occured while I was sleeping.
I urge you all to vote Husar, he should have been lynche yesterday.
unvote,Vote:Husar
Read the posts Andres quoted.
Okay, having already made a fool of myself, I'm going to Vote : Husar. The quote compilation is interesting in all the wrong ways.
Unvote: Tran; Vote: Husar
There is more evidence for Husar than for Tran; and there was no momentum for that lynch anyway.
:shrug:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
They don't want to listen to me :bigcry: