e might as well go for a triple lynch...
Printable View
e might as well go for a triple lynch...
I agree for now.. some people should unvote tiberius and vote GH and hannibalbarc. it's still possible.Quote:
Originally Posted by The Stranger
I missed out the part on GH being investigated as criminal... combined with his behaviour, he's on my lynch list as well. :book: :balloon2: :2thumbsup:
I have doubts about how Holmes caught a new player so easily but the new version of Holmes appears to be very powerful so I'll vote: HannibalBarc. As to what Mydrraal said a few pages back about the two groups facing off outside of JimBobs apartment: He is most likely correct. Me, Pann, and our third would be one of the two groups of doctors.
Lynch Votes:
Tiberius of the Drake = 13 (Ajaxfetish, Dutch_guy, GeneralHankerchief, Haudegan, Kagemusha, Myrddraal, scottishranger, shlin28, TinCow, TruePraetorian, Xehh II, Sarathos, Zorg)
Hannibalbarc = 9 (Sigurd, Sasaki, Pannonian, Kommodus, Cowhead418, CA, Joe Monks, Brave Sir Robin, woad&fangs)
GeneralHankerchief = 7 (Omanes Alexandrapolites, Proletariat, Ichigo, husar, Louis, Jubal Barca, TS)
Glenn = 3 (Andres, Crazed Rabbit, Xiahou)
Kagemusha = 3 (Caius, Glenn, Charge)
Pannonian = 2 (Tiberius of the Drake, JimBob)
Twilightblade = 2 (Tran, Chimyang)
Andres = 1 (Hannibal Barc)
Abstain: 4 (Northnovas, Rythmic, Beefy, Lt.Pinard)
unvote: vote:Hanibalbarc
Lynch Votes:
Tiberius of the Drake = 13 (Ajaxfetish, Dutch_guy, GeneralHankerchief, Haudegan, Kagemusha, Myrddraal, scottishranger, shlin28, TinCow, TruePraetorian, Xehh II, Sarathos, Zorg)
Hannibalbarc = 10 (Sigurd, Sasaki, Pannonian, Kommodus, Cowhead418, CA, Joe Monks, Brave Sir Robin, woad&fangs, TS)
GeneralHankerchief = 6 (Omanes Alexandrapolites, Proletariat, Ichigo, husar, Louis, Jubal Barca)
Glenn = 3 (Andres, Crazed Rabbit, Xiahou)
Kagemusha = 3 (Caius, Glenn, Charge)
Pannonian = 2 (Tiberius of the Drake, JimBob)
Twilightblade = 2 (Tran, Chimyang)
Andres = 1 (Hannibal Barc)
Abstain: 4 (Northnovas, Rythmic, Beefy, Lt.Pinard)
I'm not advocating that double didn't exactly work well last time, there are too many players that can pop in at last minute - and also director is under suspicion apparently...Quote:
Originally Posted by The Stranger
But I don't want to go with the current rolling bandwagon, Tiberious's role pm looked dubious but I'm also slightly suspicious of Pan and w&f who brought up original pm...
Proletariat's reasoning looked best in this so will agree with her conclusion:
Vote:GeneralHankerchief
Select: Louis
have been trying to update tally but everytime I check thread a new vote has come in - I'll do tally in later post if no-one else does....
Capo Tally after post 1205
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
please people check I've got that right now!
@maka: yeah offcourse that could happen, but then atleast we have one... we could try atleast... and when someone comes in last minute and changes the vote... he seriously has something to explain
director gets choice not to lynch at all if there is tie... and there seems to be queries at least about current director, though it would leave him some explaining to do as well. If others still think its worthwhile fine, I just wanted to point out drawbacks...Quote:
Originally Posted by The Stranger
at least this deadline is more sociable time of day for some of us!
Wow, catching up with this has taken a considerable amount of my evening and I started skimming towards the end. However, I don't understand how Glenn still isn't being lynched.
1) He got saved (clearly by another player) on night one and his explanation for this is luck - he denies that anyone else was involved though clearly someone was and the most likely explanation is a Luca (possibly Jimbob).
2) The 'red' role PMs which we happen to know a lot about. Were they really all in red, Glenn and Jimbob would not have said anything. How could they? They are clearly not allowed to divulge anything about their roles. The defence for this is that it's been cleared by Seamus. However, I think its far more likely that he has not commented publicly or imposed sanctions/WoG is that these roles are simply made up. I mean, come on, they even say their group has 3 members which sounds suspiciously like the starting makeup of a mafia family. Jimbob only arrived when it looked like Don Glenn was done for and then they make up some stupid code word defence? Ugh, I don't believe this one bit.
3) He's annoying and posts utter drivel most of the time. I also think personal attacks are out of line, even in games like this.
Speaking of which, select: Kagemusha. His mafia credentials are impressive, worthy director imo.
Last time there was a tie and the director chose to lynch only one candidate, the director himself was lynched the very next round. Although that could have been because the director was the other tied candidate.Quote:
Originally Posted by Makanyane
Yes, I'm considering four lynches today now, or else I will take propositions for vigilante-killing Glenn. ~D
Sorry, I forgot the tally:
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Unvote: Tiberius of the Drake
Vote: Hannibalbarc
Lynch Votes: as of 1213
Tiberius of the Drake = 12 (Ajaxfetish, Dutch_guy, GeneralHankerchief, Haudegan, Kagemusha, Myrddraal, scottishranger, shlin28, TinCow, Xehh II, Sarathos, Zorg)
Hannibalbarc = 11 (Sigurd, Sasaki, Pannonian, Kommodus, Cowhead418, CA, Joe Monks, Brave Sir Robin, woad&fangs, TS, TruePraetorian)
GeneralHankerchief = 7 (Omanes Alexandrapolites, Proletariat, Ichigo, husar, Louis, Jubal Barca, Makanyane)
Glenn = 3 (Andres, Crazed Rabbit, Xiahou)
Kagemusha = 3 (Caius, Glenn, Charge)
Pannonian = 2 (Tiberius of the Drake, JimBob)
Twilightblade = 2 (Tran, Chimyang)
Andres = 1 (Hannibal Barc)
Abstain: 4 (Northnovas, Rythmic, Beefy, Lt.Pinard)
Director Selections:
Louis VI the Fat = 16 (Prole, LittleGrizzlyTiberius of the Drake, Louis, JimBob, CR, Xiahou, Cowhead418, Ajaxfetish, Husar, Sarathos, Glenn, TinCow, Charge, Lt.Pinard, Makanyane)
Kagemusha = 8 (Kukrikhan, Kage, FactionHeir, Northnovas, Chimpyang, Andres, Joe monks, jubal barca)
Beefy187 = 3 (Kommodus, Zorg, Shlin)
General Hankerchief = 2 (GeneralHankerchief, Hannibalarc)
The Stranger = 1 (The Stranger)
Caius = 1 (Caius)
TruePraetorian = 1 (TruePraetorian)
Omanes Alexandrapolites = 1 (Rythmic)
Husar = 1 (Beefy)
JimBob = 1 (moros)
Abstain = 4 (scottishranger, CountArach, Xehh II, Tran)
Present = 1 (Myrddraal)
Bolded for easier reference :yes:
This is weird, testing Holmes on me, I feel like a lab rat.~D
Vote: Hannibalbarc
My only reason is a double lynch is always better than a single lynch, who knows which one is mafia?
VOTE: Husar for director
Husar voted for me in the first place as director, so i'll extend my courtesy :yes:
Lynch Votes
Tiberius of the Drake = 12 (Ajaxfetish, Dutch_guy, GeneralHankerchief, Haudegan, Kagemusha, Myrddraal, scottishranger, shlin28, TinCow, Xehh II, Sarathos, Zorg)
Hannibalbarc = 12 (Sigurd, Sasaki, Pannonian, Kommodus, Cowhead418, CA, Joe Monks, Brave Sir Robin, woad&fangs, TS, TruePraetorian, Leet Eriksson)
GeneralHankerchief = 7 (Omanes Alexandrapolites, Proletariat, Ichigo, husar, Louis, Jubal Barca, Makanyane)
Glenn = 3 (Andres, Crazed Rabbit, Xiahou)
Kagemusha = 3 (Caius, Glenn, Charge)
Pannonian = 2 (Tiberius of the Drake, JimBob)
Twilightblade = 2 (Tran, Chimyang)
Andres = 1 (Hannibal Barc)
Abstain: 4 (Northnovas, Rythmic, Beefy, Lt.Pinard)
Director Votes:
Louis VI the Fat = 16 (Prole, LittleGrizzlyTiberius of the Drake, Louis, JimBob, CR, Xiahou, Cowhead418, Ajaxfetish, Husar, Sarathos, Glenn, TinCow, Charge, Lt.Pinard, Makanyane)
Kagemusha = 8 (Kukrikhan, Kage, FactionHeir, Northnovas, Chimpyang, Andres, Joe monks, jubal barca)
Beefy187 = 3 (Kommodus, Zorg, Shlin)
General Hankerchief = 2 (GeneralHankerchief, Hannibalarc)
The Stranger = 1 (The Stranger)
Caius = 1 (Caius)
TruePraetorian = 1 (TruePraetorian)
Omanes Alexandrapolites = 1 (Rythmic)
Husar = 2 (Beefy, Leet Eriksson)
JimBob = 1 (moros)
Abstain = 4 (scottishranger, CountArach, Xehh II, Tran)
Present = 1 (Myrddraal)
Ok, and now the tally with my votes included... :furious:
Lynch Votes
Tiberius of the Drake = 12 (Ajaxfetish, Dutch_guy, GeneralHankerchief, Haudegan, Kagemusha, Myrddraal, scottishranger, shlin28, TinCow, Xehh II, Sarathos, Zorg)
Hannibalbarc = 12 (Sigurd, Sasaki, Pannonian, Kommodus, Cowhead418, CA, Joe Monks, Brave Sir Robin, woad&fangs, TS, TruePraetorian, Leet Eriksson)
GeneralHankerchief = 7 (Omanes Alexandrapolites, Proletariat, Ichigo, husar, Louis, Jubal Barca, Makanyane)
Glenn = 4 (Andres, Crazed Rabbit, Xiahou, Craterus)
Kagemusha = 3 (Caius, Glenn, Charge)
Pannonian = 2 (Tiberius of the Drake, JimBob)
Twilightblade = 2 (Tran, Chimyang)
Andres = 1 (Hannibal Barc)
Abstain: 4 (Northnovas, Rythmic, Beefy, Lt.Pinard)
Director Votes:
Louis VI the Fat = 16 (Prole, LittleGrizzlyTiberius of the Drake, Louis, JimBob, CR, Xiahou, Cowhead418, Ajaxfetish, Husar, Sarathos, Glenn, TinCow, Charge, Lt.Pinard, Makanyane)
Kagemusha = 9 (Kukrikhan, Kage, FactionHeir, Northnovas, Chimpyang, Andres, Joe monks, jubal barca, Craterus)
Beefy187 = 3 (Kommodus, Zorg, Shlin)
General Hankerchief = 2 (GeneralHankerchief, Hannibalarc)
The Stranger = 1 (The Stranger)
Caius = 1 (Caius)
TruePraetorian = 1 (TruePraetorian)
Omanes Alexandrapolites = 1 (Rythmic)
Husar = 2 (Beefy, Leet Eriksson)
JimBob = 1 (moros)
Abstain = 4 (scottishranger, CountArach, Xehh II, Tran)
Present = 1 (Myrddraal)
@Prole:
Last time I actually voiced my suspicions I was crucified for "trying to take attention off myself."
I can't win.
Try calling yourself suspicious. ~;)Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Voting and Selection for Day Three is concluded. I will consult with the Director review tallies and post results as quickly as possible hereafter.
Im gonna stop beating around bush. My attempted reveal was pathetic and I realise how stupid ive been so. Im just gonna say that pannonian is actuallyh right and I am Mafia and I bring a message from my Don.
This is I, the Don of Tiberius of the Drake.
I hereby invite the Dons of the other families to a temporary truce and would like to set up a meeting. In your ranks you have those who are either dead or expendable. Send a message to me (via Tiberius) through these persons with the following details:
1. Your family name
2. In the don pm there is a secret codeword in the first section. Name the word(s) in the parenthesis of that first section.
3. Also in the first section under victory condition, name the 3rd word in the first sentence.
If you pass these 3 tests, I will return your messenger to you with details of our meeting where you will be ensured total anonymousity.
I don't see much wrong technically in communicating via expendables, though I must say it seems a little stupid to trust them so, but I have to object to communicating via the dead as somewhat against the spirit of the game (pardon the pun). Dead players should restrict themselves to commenting on the public thread, and not reveal nor indulge in any private communications. The post mortem is such a powerful tool that dead players, especially townies, can unbalance the game if they're allowed to be conduits.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiberius of the Drake
Does the writing style of Tib's Don ring a bell to anyone?
btw, seems no reason why Tib would lie about this stuff. As pro-town, this would be ridiculous. So, we can trust the story.. and he was mafia..
Now let's hope GH is lynched as well. :book: :balloon2:
He is still alive.
FatQuote:
Originally Posted by Tiberius of the Drake
CHANCEQuote:
2. In the don pm there is a secret codeword in the first section. Name the word(s) in the parenthesis of that first section.
SUCKERQuote:
3. Also in the first section under victory condition, name the 3rd word in the first sentence.
Does this mean I'm in? I'm just dying to find out who those Barzini muppets and pink ballerina poofters are. :beam:
:laugh4:
since im not technically dead yet, im not violating the spirit of the game
anonymousity
This word is odd. From a non-English native speaker perhaps. I´m not a native speaker myself, but it´s not in my trusted online dictionary. Does anyone know a language that has a very similar word?
:laugh4:Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiberius of the Drake
It isn't a word Haudegen
I agree, it should be anonymity.Quote:
Originally Posted by Haudegen
lol @ Louis VI the Fat
well... than we can assume he isnt a native english speaker or it was done on purpose to create a diversion
Or we can assume they are a native English speaker with bad spelling and grammar. ~;)Quote:
well... than we can assume he isnt a native english speaker or it was done on purpose to create a diversion
Hmm, does 'secret codeword' remind anyone else of a story that was spouted by a certain spammer who was saved by a mysterious hot dog vender...? I officially rest my case against Glenn, he needs to be lynched next turn, along with Jimbob.Quote:
In the don pm there is a secret codeword in the first section. Name the word(s) in the parenthesis of that first section.
Well, apparently I'm considered to consider myself the boss of everyone.
Good.
I'm beginning to realise two distinct types of people posting here.
The first kind hate my style of playing the game, want me dead simply so they don't have to listen to me anymore, and some of these type sympathise with Andres, and vote for Kagemusha.
Notice that? How some of them write a large summary of how strange I am and then type Kagemusha for governor without explanation?
These people are also totally against the fact that I am bringing lurkers out into the open with bait - and this has certainly worked on Kagemusha, who jumps at the chance to defend himself, even from me.
Then there is the second type.
The type that either puts up with or understands my annoying approach to calling out the enemy, and even at times includes my own suspicions in their write ups.
These people are focused on thos who are continuing to show themselves more dangerous in game - and not just asking,
"Why haven't we killed Glenn yet? I wish he would shut up."
I think the latter are rational, and the former are disturbed by my views and forced therefore to answer them and dismiss them.
As far as I recall, people agree that this is classic mafioso behaviour.
Main thread post #1234 (reads like a trill!)
"Oh, when the sun beats down and burns the tar up on the roof
And your shoes get so hot you wish your tired feet were fire-proof
Under the boardwalk, down by the sea, yeah
On a blanket with my baby is where I'll be
(Under the boardwalk) out of the sun
(Under the boardwalk) we'll be havin' some fun
(Under the boardwalk) people walking above
(Under the boardwalk) we'll be making love
Under the board-walk (board-walk!)"
-- The Drifters
Sunset Day Three:
This voting session was every bit as contentious as the last with accusations flying thick and fast. Most of the accusations -- but by no means all -- had been leveled at Tiberius of the Drake. As the meeting drew to a close and the votes were put in the bin however, it appeared that a number of votes had shifted....
"While our selection for Director for Days 4 and 5 will be Louis VI the Fat by a clear plurality, I regret to inform you that Tiberius of the Drake and Hannibalbarca have each received twelve votes from the Committee," stated Director Andres. "It is therefore MY decision as to what steps to take from here...
[I]Andres paused -- a longish seeming pause -- and then spoke./I]
"The committee feels them to be equally guilty, then the shall suffer an equal fate. Hang them both."
Tiberius and Hannibalhad their hands tied behind their backs and were then frog marched from the room by Fermanaghs strongarms. Followed by the Committee who came to witness, they were both marched down to the loading dock at the side of the Convention center (the back faces the boardwalk). Heavy steel beams lined either side of the loading bay with a heavy railed crane slung between them to haul the sometimes heavy items brought into the Convention Center at the rail spur.
The crane had not been used since the last time Barnum and Bailey's had been in town. It was in use now. Two classic hemp nooses -- one recently put up -- were hanging from the cranes support arms. The two were take by ladder up to the beams, the nooses hauled up and tightly cinched about their necks. Neither was offered a hood.
At a signal from Andres, both were pushed from the support beams and dropped the 15 feet or so to the end of the ropes. Both necks snapped instantly -- since the fall was double that used by the prison system.
Tiberius hung their with his eyes bulging and tongue protruding, blood dripping from his nose. Hannibal's neckbones had ripped apart completely, his neck stretching to more than a foot long when, after a brief pause, his head tore free entirely in a spray of blood. Both body and head landed near each other on the loading bay floor.
"Tonight's proceedings are finished," said Andres. The committee slowly filed out.
The cleaning staff never could completely erase the stain.
OOC
Lynched = Hannibalbarca & Tiberius of the Drake.
Night Three has begun and will continue until 1400 EST 12 FEB 8 (1800 GMT).
I'll try to cycle the next day phase from then until 1000 on the 13th if I can.
Tallies:
To Lynch:
Hannibalbarca = 12 (BSR, CA, Cow, Joe, Kommo, Leet, Pan, Sasaki, Sigurd, True, W&F, Stranger)
Tiberius of the Drake = 12 (Ajax, Dutch, GH, Haudegan, Kage, Myrdd, Sara, Scot, shlin, TinC, X2, Zorg)
GeneralHankerchief = 7 (Husar, Ichi, Jubal, Louis, Mak, Omanes, Prole)
Abstain = 4 (ATPG, Griz, LtP, Rythm)
Glenn = 3 (Andres, CR, X)
Kagemusha = 3 (Caius, Charge, Glenn)
Pannonian = 2 (Jimbob,Tiberius)
Twilightblade = 2 (Chimp, Tran)
Andres = 1 (Hannibal)
To Select:
Louis VI the Fat = 14 (Ajax, Cow, CR, Glenn, Husar, Griz, Louis, LtP, Mak, Prole, Sara, Tiberius, TinC, X)
Kagemusha = 9 (Andres, Chimp, Crat, FH, Joe, Jubal, Kage, Kukri, NN)
Abstain = 4 (ATGP, CA, Tran, X)
Beefy187 = 2 (Kommo, shlin)
Husar = 2 (Beefy, Leet)
A couple of others had one vote, often an auto-vote.
So this is your answer to my questions?~:(Quote:
Originally Posted by Glenn
Rules Broken:
Quote:
Originally Posted by chewy
You didn't ask questions Kagemusha, you just made a statement and said you were being insulted.
You have a look at the arguments against me made by your buddies, and then judge who is being insulted with personal arguments that are non-game related.
The use of the word "nitpicking" to me implies it was Glenn. Similarly, the short paragraphs do that.
Please Glenn.Go back and read the post again. There are three quite clear questions there. Im sure you will find them from there.:yes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Glenn
nvm
Come on Andres, have them both lynched and help your mafia family and the town out.
CR
What rule does funneling pms through someone else break? I was under the impression that this was allowed.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarathos
It was in the first Capo.Quote:
Originally Posted by Brave_Sir_Robin
Double accounts arent allowed.
Perhaps Mafioso-Andres isn't really willing to lynch anyone that isn't pro-town? Why on earth did he become director? :embarassed: :wall:
Well, at least, non-lynching may convince enough people of his guilt to get a lynch done! :book: :balloon2:
I know that. It seems like whoever sent the pm just sent it to someone and used them as a filter.Quote:
Originally Posted by Caius
1209
I now invoke the rule of 751, anything that exonerates one of crime will be ignored.Quote:
2) The 'red' role PMs which we happen to know a lot about. Were they really all in red, Glenn and Jimbob would not have said anything. How could they? They are clearly not allowed to divulge anything about their roles. The defence for this is that it's been cleared by Seamus. However, I think its far more likely that he has not commented publicly or imposed sanctions/WoG is that these roles are simply made up.
I quote, directly from Seamus "The Bear" Fermanagh.
Okay? Good, let's continue.Quote:
2. The mention of the presence of Red text in one's role PM is not, of itself, a contravention of the required confidentiality. How valuable that is, of itself, is a separate question.
This was done once since this was posted. (It was actually the only new information about our role that came out since that post). That post was 938Quote:
Quotation, specific references, or detailed allusion to the material therein are not permissable. SO FAR, no one has crossed the line (though at least 4 players have made indirect allusions). Please keep it that way.
Until then, in the words of our games host (aka the person who makes the rules), there had only been indirect allusions. So yeah, not so much on the "we can't divulge stuff" front, unless there's a probability higher than 100%.
I never put that together. I just said there were three because well, there are three good guys. One of us is still missing. If we were trying to lie why wouldn't we just say it's the two of us? Do you really think we're that stupid?Quote:
I mean, come on, they even say their group has 3 members which sounds suspiciously like the starting makeup of a mafia family.
This line has come up before, and I feel I have not satisfactorily answered it.Quote:
Jimbob only arrived when it looked like Don Glenn was done for and then they make up some stupid code word defence? Ugh, I don't believe this one bit.
The reason I showed up late was that I wasn't on The Org for a few days before the game started, and even into the first few days. Why? I honestly forgot Capo was starting, I had mid-term exams last week combined with the fact that my Ultimate team was hosting a tournament this weekend. So, in sum, I had alot of real world stuff to do. That's where the posting frenzy on the 7th came from. I showed up to the party only to find it had started with one of my partners up on the chopping block. Without him we were next to useless, so I dove in to save him, and hopefully the town.
As to the code words, they exist. And on that note I'd like to deliver a message to our third member, wherever he is.
The blade is ready, the axe is poised. Bring the crown and we can get this on. (We understand each other? Show yourself, seriously, we need to start rooting mafia out and making them dead).
I seriously have no idea whats going on could someone breifly explain it to me?
Someone sent a PM via an intermediary to Sarathos. The questions are: who sent it, and is it against the rules?Quote:
Originally Posted by RoadKill
Well I looked through the rules briefly and didn't see anything about it. The writing style looks like Glenn's though.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pannonian
Using a "blind" to do posting is perfectly legal. As Capo I teaches it is also not a foolproof defense.
Referring to the "red" material in specific fashion, using a blind or not, could get you wogged.
Using a 2nd account of your own, if detected, would not only get you wogged but it might get you banned. TosaInu is NOT amused by such.
So yet another claim to add to his catalogue. I'm pretty sure that, were we to look at the red part of his PM, we will see that he gets 10 investigations per night.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
Plus he's invulnerable to night kills, and if they find their mysterious "third member" will have vigilante kills too. ~:rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Pannonian
Let's make sure we take care of this once and for all with the day 3 lynching.
Well chewy has made one post on this board in the Hail new members thread.
Brother=Glenn? joined 1-30 last activity was todayQuote:
Originally Posted by chewy
Has anyone else received a PM from chewy?
There is also the third type of player, those who both find you annoying and decided to vote for Kagemusha....if you apply critical thinking, the two events are not mutually exclusive and therefore there is hole in your logic there!
I also disagree that you overactive FoS - which has translated into countless posts, have actually helped the town whatsoever. I believe that you have spread the suspicion so wide that we have begin to let events of the past merge into darkness. In fact, we forget the minor hints that may just be the mistake that a mafioso makes. How quickly has this thread forgotten NN's mistake (either innocent or incriminating) on the first day? Did we stop to question? No, because you are intentionally pulling the thread away from such issues. In fact, the chaotic scene (on the face of it, we do not see the flurry of PM's going on) is promoting discord amongst townies themselves. So please, if you are truly pro-town, at least consider my side of the argument.
Anyways, if you refer back to my voting post....you will find that I have put what I consider to be a perfectly valid reason down. You have not queried this reason per se, rather, you decided to attack me with a flippant line of reasoning - one that I couldn't resist countering with sarcasm. So if you have a problem with my initial reasoning, go ahead, ask away, happy to accommodate your questions.
I see Robin sent me a message. To clear things up everyone, chewy is MY little brother, but I didn't ask him to post that. I could easily go on his computer and see who it was if that's not against the rules? If I go on his computer would that be against game policy? Forum Policy?
edit: asked if it was ok
Hmm I missed voting.
Well, this is uncharted waters for mafia rules. I don't know what Seamus thinks, but the issue here might be whatever rules the Org has on logging in on a relative's account. Though, from my experience here I've seen people log on to a relative's account and post, so it shouldn't be a big problem.Quote:
Originally Posted by TruePraetorian
And Seamus does allow intermediaries not in the game to be used. And he also said there are hazards to that. I guess this is one of them. I* say go for it.
CR
*I am not an Org Moderator, nor do I play one on TV.
I don't see why we would need too. The style looks extremely like Glenn's and I'm pretty sure it is his.Quote:
Originally Posted by TruePraetorian
WIthout his permission, it would be a breach of your sib's privacy.Quote:
Originally Posted by TruePraetorian
CR is correct that this is so far outside the realm of what comes into a normal mafia game, that I had not considered the point.
I will make no ruling on this.
I can guarantee you that it is not Glenn's work. Our group has been pursuing other leads, Sarathos has not been a major blip on our radar yet. We really haven't thought about him much, he's not too important to us right now (no offense man~:)).Quote:
I don't see why we would need too. The style looks extremely like Glenn's and I'm pretty sure it is his.
I have Glenn's assurance that he was not the sender of that message. And you have my assurance that our group did not send it.
Bah, missed the voting. My head hurts right now from all the analysis/accusations going on and all I can pretty definately say is that probably a great number of those throwing accusations at each other are scummy because if that any people come up with all of this contradictary "evidence," some people are blatantly lying
Well, that leaves TP. It makes sense. The odds of some mafia player PMing another member of this game's brother is extremely unlikely.
I am willing to join a group.
Ichigo, you have to think how sensless that would make me. If im not mistaken, ip addresses can be traced. PMing possibly the closest link in the forums to do me a favor is hardly reasonable, and I like to think of myself as at least a little reasonable. Honestly, if I were to do it i'd at least select someone that i have no connection to.
Fine decision IMO. :bow: This is Moderator territory, and I trust Andres can/will handle it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Seamus Fermanagh
He might as well have just sent it himself. His brother has one post on the org., which identifies him as TP's brother. It took me about thirty seconds to track that connection down.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
Don't know his passQuote:
Originally Posted by Brave_Sir_Robin
I meant you might as well have just sent it with your account. :oops:Quote:
Originally Posted by TP
But if it was sent from my account then why would my brother be involved at all?
EDIT: oh I see, sent it to him.
Well, I got nothing to hide. I've been in 3 protection groups so far, including tonight, so i hope thats enough to clear my name. Due to the close link with our names i blame no one who accuses me...just hope you can see that me choosing my own brother would be a pretty dumb move on my part. If anyone can think of some way to prove i didn't do it then please let me hear.
I was trying to point out that it would be pointless for you to send pm's through your brother when there is such a clear link between the 2 of you. If you sent a threatening pm to someone through him it would be easily traced back to you.
Ah, I see (in my edit), thats also what im trying to say. Not much I can do about it though, just hope everyone else can reason it out like you.
You're right. I went back and looked at the thread and noticed the post after chewy's first one. It links them pretty clearly, so I'm pretty sure it isn't TP.Quote:
Originally Posted by Brave_Sir_Robin
I was wrong, a double lynch is possible. Congrats to everyone who made that possible.
I have still yet to hear about the exact specifics of holmes, but I guess we'll now be able to see how effective it is.
It makes perfect sense that TP would make a second account, write a very suspicious PM with it and then come here to tell everybody that he has access to that account. :dizzy2:
WIFOM :laugh4:Quote:
Originally Posted by Husar
https://forums.totalwar.org/vb/showthread.php?t=78384Quote:
Originally Posted by Zorg
Thanks for that, it has answered all the questions I had about that. And quite interesting too.:nice:
My bad guys, I read the rules differently.