I think there is definitely credence to GH's case on dp101 being a calculated moveQuote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
Printable View
I think there is definitely credence to GH's case on dp101 being a calculated moveQuote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
Mechanically, can there even be a N0 action if there isn't a N0 waiting period?
What, does he get the first PM and 10 minutes to make a decision? What would the point of that even be?
Am I misunderstanding something here?
there were things I was going to say but I forgot what they were unfortunately
usually they do not choose the n0 peek, it's just a random villagerQuote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
Then I don't think anyone should take that possibility into their lynch or kill considerations unless someone explicitly makes the claim. There's no end to the rabbit hole otherwise.
Okay so then what's the point of the previous post that I quoted?Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
"lol wow you all suck i'm so much better than you"
It does nothing. It doesn't help us move forward. It brings town morale down. It's patting yourself on the back for getting something right in which there's a >50% possibility, all other things equal, that you are going to be right.
It's an utterly worthless post.
How's that? Or, why did you use that particular number?Quote:
>50% possibility
I am full of shame.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
Come to think of it I'm pretty sure he did say no cop somewhere or other.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
frymooning.gifQuote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
vote: generalhankerchief
Numerical breakdown has more town than mafia, hence it's more likely to lynch a townie once all other factors are removed.Quote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
I eagerly look forward to your "I stand by my vote, he looked really scummy" justification the day after I get mislynched.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
He was just following orders.
Unvote: Al Sipsclar
Vote: GH
Renata, me finding you scummy isn't reason enough to switch off dp who I found to be the scummiest person in game. I'm always voting for my strongest scum suspect day 1.
Not sure why people are finding you towny, I've felt your tone has been agendary since day 1 which is why I said the more you talk, the scummier you sound.
I think Zack's your scum partner and I'm feeling that Pizza has been surprisingly underwhleming but I refuse to believe he randed scum 3 games in a row.
I'd like to know what about GH is so scummy. He looks OK to me. Is this another lolRenata moment?
As I hinted early on, this speaks more to the similarity in Zack and Renata's playstyles (and perhaps personalities) than to any partnership.Quote:
I think Zack's your scum partner
Why do you mention Pizza in a way bearing no relevance to the preceding clause?
didn't you say dp was a random vote? lolQuote:
Originally Posted by Newyn
He is keeping it polished. As expected. It's the circumstances more than anything that demand scrutiny, and none of his polish has given me confidence.Quote:
I'd like to know what about GH is so scummy. He looks OK to me. Is this another lolRenata moment?
The bolded is very funny to me for reasons I can't discuss (another game I'm in).Quote:
Originally Posted by Newyn
Pizza is in fact underwhelming, I'll agree with you on that much. There's one version of townie-Pizza I think I can read very well, and this isn't it.
He said his gut thought it was a good idea, to be strictly accurate.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
I feel like most of this is meta with respect to dp that I'm never going to understand. I'm not sure what to expect from GH as scum. There's no flaws in his presentation thus far.Quote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
So far at least he has limited himself from discussing co-extant matters.Quote:
There's no flaws in his presentation thus far.
Major non-DP comments on D1:
Quote:
Morning all.
I power-read the past four pages in 10 minutes, can sort of see the case on Riedquat but not budging on DP.
Quote:
I'm not really sure where the parade of Newyn votes came from besides the usual "lol day 1" sentiment but they need to wait because Dp101 really needs to be strung up today.
Good point.Quote:
Originally Posted by Montmorency
I didn't read everything when I voted him but I didn't like what I saw. His posts after my vote didn't change my mind. Not sure where you got the idea that it was random from.Quote:
Originally Posted by Zack
If someone actually manages to read me well, it will be the first time in a long time.Quote:
Originally Posted by Renata
There was that game we both lost miserably to scum Astral Rejection and company on the Dope. I was practically twisting arms trying to keep votes away from you, I was so sure. But this kind of stuff from you, heck if I know.
Also I am kind of an emergency meatbag right now. I wasn't planning on investing time in a game because reasons.
I'm here to vote and give some opinions when I can, and I have. I'm not at 100 percent or close to it.
I need time.Quote:
Originally Posted by Renata
What would be helpful to me is if people explained some of their reads. There's been plenty in the thread but I don't understand what they mean other than as a random declaration.
If people can do that it would be less forcing for me to give my opinion.
What about the possibility that at least some, particularly the early stage, of the wagon on DP101 was a premeditated to mislynch him in particular?
Not as a ride-or-die cause, but as a Plan A going into the game? Day 1 would be a relatively easy time to push that kind of thing over the edge.
Implicated in the first place would be Choxorn and/or GH.