you switched (probably) town syn with town cape AAAAAAAAAAAA IM SCAREDQuote:
Originally Posted by illario
Printable View
you switched (probably) town syn with town cape AAAAAAAAAAAA IM SCAREDQuote:
Originally Posted by illario
Rask is speaking in heiroglyphics help me
like i was townreading visor and hardly had a progression on them? you mean the wisdom thing? I just believed Wisdom's side looked good
i think ur probably town still, i just included u in there for the sake of clarityQuote:
Originally Posted by Cape90
ok sorry, it's late. (I hate you for making me burning another post, when my first one was perfectly clear :curtain:)Quote:
Originally Posted by Cape90
What was good in Wisdom's progression? which lies in this very post:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wisdom
and the word "deflated'"?
(you find me cryptic because you are scrolling through the thread and missed my joke post about flatulences. not sure I will forgive you and not death tunnel you for it. I'll try but no promise)
to clarify the point of that post was to see where the two overlap. that doesnt necessarily mean just for existing in one line that makes someone a wolf, and even the overlaps can be town for all i know. but i personally think its very strange when vulgard was inno child posting for someone to think his posts are wolfy whilst simulatenously thinking my posts were fine lol, esp when vulgard was posting much better than me.
you also have the people who called out as w/w, which is probably more of a >rand v take because its so ridiculous that i dont think anyone with tmi would make such a take lol. id argue vulgard is the one person i dont have any w/w equity with so far in the lobby
I have no interest in trying to read you early tbh. I thought I had something in a mash with you day 1 and you ended up quitting and flipping town.Quote:
Originally Posted by illario
I also don't see what you see in vul atm.
okay i might be understanding what Rask is saying since he suspects Wisdom.
It's partially a meta thing, Wisdom!town likes making meta reads. There is only 1 Wisdom wolf game I have seen where they seemed like a pretty obvious wolf
I will see how things play out, I was fairly unimpressed by how they popped in a lil bit earlier
I kinda agree with the deflated term though
but I would change it from that to "dry" as I did in my readslist. It came off more dry then deflated to me.
Why do you dodge the question while simultaneously speaking to other people and not me AND taking your read back? lolQuote:
Originally Posted by Cape90
You are talking about the meta read which I summed up with deflated. I was talking about their progression, which you found good. How was it good? The meta read was preexistent I assume.
looking at how the thread is progressing just convinces me more that lapras might indeed be a wolf
nobody is talking about him
nobody has told me why he's town after i asked for reasons why he's town twice
all he's done since the earlygame was omgus (this is slightly unfair but i don't remember him doing anything other than questioning my push on him and then voting me)
i'd likely be re-evaluating the early gut feeling i had on him if not for the fact he hasn't given me a reason to do so and the complete lack of willingness to discuss his slot makes me think he's getting overlooked
---
i think nutella's posts are fine and visor's posts are whatever, nutella slight town, visor down to null
---
@ achro i'm not really sure what you're doing this game to be honest, i think the best parts of your posting are the parts where you're pushing me because unlike everyone else you actually have reasons for it but that could be my bias
i probably sound more frustrated than i actually am as i say this
in regard to my treatment of lapras, the read did feel kinda stale but i asked other people for reads on the slot several times and the slot hasn't done anything to alter my opinion in any way so my early gut feeling turned into a vote and now seeing the threadstate go the way that it has i'm suspecting i might just be correct
you alluded to me not questioning lapras or something but there's nothing to question him about, he hasn't really been producing content, he just asked about my read on him and then voted me
there's nothing to work with here
and if he's town i realize that this push on him from me likely isn't helping, but also if he's town then i frankly expect better from him
basically regardless of alignment's he's not exactly being helpful, but couple that with how the thread seems to be treating him and how i had a negative gut feeling about his early-game posting (which is his most substantive posting, also i went back to the post that made me think he's maybe mafia and i still think it's wolfy), i think this is worth pursuing
---
i don't particularly like the push on wisdom, i don't have a strong tr on wisdom but it feels more like a lazy wagon / shot in the dark to me than anything, nobody really gave good reasons other than "this post wolfy" which is technically the same thing as me talking about lapras but fmpov there is a greater number of factors in my lapras read
---
push on boq is... okay i guess but i've no idea how he plays wolf, he kinda just hasn't played the game imo
meh as i was writing this i realized that i'm just singling out lapras based on a gut feeling but i do think it's strange that nobody can formulate a reason for him being town yet he isn't talked about or suspected or anything (unlike wisdom, boquise, nutella until recently...)
i'm just going to sheep the v reads on cape because apparently everyone but me can read him and i've never been burned on trusting the Consensus Cape Read before
i have no comments about illario's current thought process until he finishes it
This might sound stupid but I am not really sure what I am doing either, so I am hoping to use you as a foundation throughout the day to see how I feel about things.Quote:
Originally Posted by Vulgard
People aren't really sticking with me this game, but you are someone I am familiar with and despite some interpersonal dysfunction at times we've lynched a lot of wolves together.
So if my early hunch on you is right then huzzah, got you. If it is wrong I have thus far been able to find you in previous games so am not too pressed about it.
Lapras is a tough one for me because I have no idea what is going on there whenever I read them in real time except they have failed to vote correctly like 8 times.
Does this site have an iso feature?
cape/rask/ender/syn are my townreads
cape is a sheep of the thread
rask is kinda osmosis but i'm ok with this osmosis
ender i think had a towny way of getting to a v read on syn
and i think syn is v because of the way in which ender got to a v read there, i think those reads are typically correct
others are realistically just light town pings at best, i don't feel like most players have really played the game yet
cleared my d1 bar of towniness:
Boq
Cape
illario
Rask
Syn
Vulgard
Wisdom
POE:
Lapras
Achro
Dya
Ladd
Visor
Ender?
Robyn?
Ender/Robyn are in a middling spot where I probably won't vote them today but can't really say they've been towny
actually i think i should include nutella, i think her posts have been fine so far
forgot about robyn, robyn can be town too
six is ~okay i guess
go back to the main subforum and click on the number of replies for the thread, then click the number of replies again next to the person you want to ISOQuote:
Originally Posted by Achro
Don't talk like that to me or my son ever again.Quote:
Originally Posted by illario
i'm sorry nutella but minus ender/robyn this list looks like "sort by game impact"Quote:
Originally Posted by nutella
which is honestly kinda towny in this gamestate fmpov
maybe i was a bit premature on ender but i think his tr on syn makes syn town in almost every world either way
i don't really care about the rest of this post but i do think it's silly to expect people to have thoughtful town reads on someone in the first 24 hours of D1Quote:
Originally Posted by Vulgard
maybe being under the radar matters once there's been a couple flips but in the early early game? who cares tbh
Quote:
Originally Posted by Vulgard
pretty fair maybe but the trs have all stuck out to me as towny at some point for one reason or another
also the way you describe your feeling on lapras makes me feel even better about him being a hit (as did his reaction earlier)
and your trs on ender and robyn are enough for me to keep them in a higher tier for now
Vote: Lapras
Sheeping ended with Syn.
Vulgard is my new sheep target now.
people were putting lapras in townreads though, or at least there were some implications of people townreading laprasQuote:
Originally Posted by Syn
surely there were reasons for that right? i'm not even asking for a towncase, just a reason
this is incoherentQuote:
Originally Posted by Vulgard
what is this
by the way what was it you mentioned about a postcap? i just checked op and the modposts under it and i didn't see mention of a postcapQuote:
Originally Posted by nutella
it's their favourite digimon character idkQuote:
Originally Posted by Vulgard
maybe my townread on ender was a bit premature, but even if i'm wrong on ender and he's a wolf, i think the way in which he townread you should just make you a villagerQuote:
Originally Posted by Syn
i'm still leaning town on him