Ah, but Kami did! Are you still saying you'r pro-town? :inquisitive:Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
Printable View
Ah, but Kami did! Are you still saying you'r pro-town? :inquisitive:Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
It's not my fault if you think the balance of the roles in this game is off. There were bound to be problems when you introduce the ability to bring people back to life.
I would recommend resurrecting 2 active townies.
Proletariat is one.
Vote Caius, Lurker, he's acting suspiciously and chances are he's mafia, if he isn't then at least we didn't lynch someone that was actually playing, also FOS Kommodus, what's keeping you from using Holmes?
EDIT:Tincow, resurrection of gibson and shlin sounds good.
Current tally of resurrection preferences:
Updated as of post 546:
Shlin: himself
Drisos: Only mafia kills, approves of Shlin and himself
EF: No one, save for later
Rythmic: Shlin, gibson, or Ichigo
FH: Active people, approves of Prole
Hannibalbarc: shlin and gibson
woad&fangs: Ichigo
If anyone else has a preference, please speak up. I'm going to go with the top two votes (unless you lynch me today, which will obviously prevent me from resurrecting anyone).
I support the resurrection of Ichigo. He is a good player and he was killed by the mafia.
Current Lynch Tally (I hope it's correct):
BananaBob - 2 (Mak, pever)
Kommodus - 2 (CR, Bob)
Makanyane - 1 (EF)
pevergreen - 1 (Omanes)
TinCow - 2 (Seamus, GH)
Caius - 4 (FH, Ryth, TC, Hannibal)
Note: EF your vote on post 517 is invalid as you forgot to unvote.
Unvote: Caius; Vote: Abstain
Now the Tally is correct :bow:
Current analysis (copied from Rythmic on page 12)
Killer 1: (TinCow)
Scottishranger - Killed N1, Killer had a multiple pronged whip and a 'blade'. Killer spoke before attacking.
Proletariat - Killed N2, as note the whip, black blade/sword and speaking before the murder.
Tiberius of the Drake - Killed N3, Killer had a whip and a black blade
Drisos - Killed N4, Killer had fiery gaze, lit up completely and shot a beam of fire. Used whip and a black sword.
Killer 2:
Warluster - Killed N1, Killer was 'brawny' and used a club.
DID NOT KILL N2
Twilightblade - Killed N3, Killer was 'brutish' and used a club.
Ichigo - Killed N4, Killer was 'burly' and used massive strength and shortsword. Moved with amazing speed.
Killer 3:
DID NOT KILL N1
Gibsonsg91921 - Killed N2, killer shape-shifted. The killer had many tails. Also killer had claws.
Tratorix - Killed N3, Killer shape-shifted, killer had claws, fangs and was 'animalish'
DID NOT KILL N4
Killer 4:
Shlin28 - Killed N1, Killer used a distraction and ambush, killed him with many swords. Attacked from above suggesting wings
Sigurd Fafnesbane - Killed N2, killer used a sword. Also note the that the attacker surprised Sigurd by attacking from behind and the unusual wings/flight. Sigurd called him the Archangel(?). Note: resurrected
DID NOT KILL N3 and N4 ALTHOUGH SIGURD WAS RESURRECTED N3
Killer 5: (2nd highest vote killer)
DID NOT KILL N1
Sasaki Kojiro - Killed N2, using a scythe, floating and quite eager to play 'cat and mouse' before killing. Was described as 'handsome'
Fahad I - Attacked N3, Attacker has a scythe and was 'handsome'
Bananabob - Attacked N4, Attacker had red piercing eyes and a scythe
This seems to disagree with my suggestion that Killer 2 is a Odd-Night serial killer as he killed N4 (or at least the evidence suits better to him than any others). Still, its possible someone else was impersonating him, as he did not use a club and was merely burly.
Killer 5 is figured out and Killer 1 is confirmed as TC.
Killer 4 seems to be able to resurrect after killing. Either he is mafia and resurrects people to be secret mafia operatives or he has a similar role to TC.
Killer 3 seems definite mafia.
TC mentioned a role blocker. Maybe he blocked someone's action last night? That or we lynched/killed the right person at some point or they were simply inactive.
Haha, I'm not as good a player as I looked in Capo. Don't resurrect me.
Who wants to bet that there is no mafia, only people who believe they have pro-town roles, and in order to get this supposed power they kill the town between them? That would be a twist.
Also do not forget to keep me at a distant second so I don't get band wagoned by the mafia.:sweatdrop:
That would be AWESOME
Why?Quote:
Originally Posted by Elite Ferret
If TinCow dies tonight, then he can no longer resurrect.
I suggest TC resurrects one mafia victim and one of the other victims.
scottishranger and Sasaki or Ichigo seem good choices.
TC and pever, do you have any idea on who might have resurrected Sigurd? Role or name?
I totally agree with GH though, TC's role claim stinks. If Ichigo/Sasaki and scottishranger are not resurrected tonight, then TinCow is the lynch for tomorrow.
Also, TinCow, why not revealing in public round 1? A vigilante going rampage on most likely innocent townies is as dangerous as mafia/Serial Killer. Why not letting the town decide on who you had to kill/no kill? It would have given as a de facto double lynch possibility.
In the meanwhile, I'll Vote : Kommodus
Seamus and FactionHeir, what are your thoughts on Kommo?
Why are you all voting Caius btw? Lurking is his usually style since talking always got him lynched in the past.
yeah change my preference TC, ressurect some active people tonight. Thanks Rythmic, I forgot I had already voted.
unvote:Makanyane vote:Kommodus
The reason I don't want TinCow to resurrect people who got killed by the mafia, is because he insists on it.
Maybe he is mafia and he can only resurrect the ones killed by the mafia, turning them into their puppets :inquisitive:
TinCow needs to resurrect one mafia victim and one non mafia victim.
And I really want to know what pevergreen, BanaBob, Elite Ferret and TinCow (all self proclaimed power-roles) think/know about Sigurd's resurrection.
EDIT: Sigurd must have been contacted by his Necromancer. Unvote : Kommodus ; Vote : Sigurd. I want to hear more from you.
The way TinCow talks rings scumbells all over town and the kill descriptions don't sound like they were made by a protown player. Having him resurrect two townies tonight and follow the towns orders seems the best course of action for the time being.
Unfortunately, no. I have no idea whether it is a pure resurrection role or a different role that could do a one-off resurrection like I could. Presumably if he does it a second time, it's a permanent role ability. It would not surprise me at this point if there was simply a pro-town necromancer role. This seems to be how pever is balancing out the game: give many people the ability to kill, but allow multiple resurrections to keep the population up.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
If I don't pull off the resurrections tonight, I will vote to lynch myself.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
Like I said, the wording of the PM made me think I should try to get 4 kills. There's no way I would have survived long enough to do that if I had revealed on day 1. More likely than not you would have just lynched me immediately.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
Well, a round 1 reveal would not have been suspicious.Quote:
Originally Posted by TinCow
In round 1, the probability of still having a doctor alive, was high.
You could have done what the town said: kill X or don't kill at all and be protected at night.
Also, what if you are mafia and the people you resurrect become mafia puppets?
We really need to know more about this Sigurd resurrection ASAP.
Sigurd, talk :whip:
I for one think BananaBob is right - there is no real enemies!
Current tally of resurrection preferences:
Updated as of post 560:
Shlin: himself
Drisos: Only mafia kills, approves of Shlin and himself
EF: Active people
Rythmic: Shlin, gibson, or Ichigo
FH: Active people, approves of Prole
Hannibalbarc: shlin and gibson
woad&fangs: Ichigo
Andres: One mafia victim, one non-mafia victim, prefers Ichigo, Sasaki, and scottishranger
Summary:
One mafia and one non-mafia seems to be the current preference. I'm kind of confused about what non-mafia means, but presumably the desire is for me to resurrect one of my own victims and one killed by someone else. For other peoples' victims, shlin has 4 votes and Ichigo has 3, so they're the leading options. For my own victims, Drisos, scottishranger, and Prole are all tied at one vote.
Please continue to give more input on who should be resurrected, especially if you want me to bring back one of my own kills. I will happily do so, but I would prefer if it wasn't a choice between three people, all with only one vote.
Why is nobody backing up TinCow's story?
We have 4 self proclaimed pro-town power roles. None of them backs up TinCow. Nobody else seems to back him up either.
Unvote : Sigurd; Vote : TinCow
Sigurd, I still expect some sort of explanation from you.
I approve of Prole's resurrection as well.
:bow:
gah.. I've had enough. forget what I said about lynching kommodus. lynch tincow.
I'm not even sure if I want to be resurrected anymore... I prefer town's side. dead or alive.
and Andres, very good point, Sigurd must know more, and has to talk, or he'll be the next lynch. :whip:
I have no clue. It was not done by me or anyone I know of.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
So, doctors cannot resurrect? Can EF confirm this?Quote:
Originally Posted by BananaBob
Ok, here’s a brief analysis of the remaining players. I gave a version of this to my pro-town contact last night; it’s been updated since. The ones I consider suspicious are marked with an asterisk (*).
Andres
Claims to have been absent from Friday the 21st to Sunday afternoon on the 23rd. This would make him absent for the entire first night phase. Indeed, he made no posts during that time. I think it’s likely he’s innocent.
BannanaBob
He and Elite Ferret support each other’s claims of being doctors. I actually believe their story.
Caius
Holmes indicates he’s probably innocent.
CountArach
Holmes is inconclusive, but has nothing of significance against him. My instinct is that he’s innocent.
Crazed Rabbit*
Holmes is inconclusive, but after reviewing his posts I think he’s suspicious, and should be investigated if he hasn’t been already. There’s just something… off… about him.
EliteFerret
See BananaBob – likely innocent.
FactionHeir*
At first I thought he was innocent, but it worried me that he appeared to be attempting to fly a little under the radar. As time goes on, though, his statistical behavior as measured by Holmes appears to be getting closer and closer to his guilty baseline, obtained from Fimbulwinter. A review of his posts doesn’t make things look any better for him; most of his posts are decidedly unhelpful to the town. Fairly strong possibility of guilt.
Fahad I*
I was fairly suspicious of him before he was attacked and saved. Since then, he’s been very quiet, posting occasionally in other threads. I’m pretty sure he’s not mafia due to the attack, but it’s still possible he’s a serial killer. His continued lurking makes me edgy.
GeneralHankerchief
He’s difficult to profile using Holmes, but at this point I am not very suspicious of him.
Hannibalbarc*
He’s lurking hardcore, yet is completely focused on the game. This may be just normal for him, as he claims, but I have to suspect something’s up. I reviewed his posts and they don’t look very helpful to the town; he’s not really saying much that other people aren’t saying. I tend to be wrong about him, but right now he remains one of my top suspects.
Makanyane
Holmes is inconclusive; my personal intuition is that she’s pro-town.
Mouzafphaerre
Holmes indicates probable innocence.
Northnovas
So far all he’s done is use other people’s logic. Holmes indicates possible guilt, but not very strongly. I’m suspicious but not overly so.
Omanes Alexandropolites
Holmes indicates likely innocence.
Pevergreen*
He quietly claimed to have a pro-town role, a claim that was largely overlooked – but I doubt the mafia/SKs missed it. Therefore I’m suspicious simply because he hasn’t yet been attacked.
Rythmic
Holmes is inconclusive, but after reviewing his posts I think he’s innocent.
Sarathos
Holmes indicates probable innocence. I think he’s just an ordinary townie.
Seamus Fermanagh
Holmes is usually pretty good about predicting his guilt or innocence, and at the moment it indicates he is innocent.
SigurdFafnesbane
I’m pretty sure he’s innocent, due to having been killed by the mafia before (and yes, I think it was the mafia that killed him).
TinCow
Now that he has revealed, I think his role is plausible. In any case he should be left alive for one more night at least, just so that he can raise two townies from the dead. After that, his value to us is only as a vigilante; if he continues to live we may be able to suggest people for him to kill.
woad&fangs
He’s a very clever player, and I think he’s worth an investigation. Holmes is inconclusive.
yes I can, I was as shocked as everyone else. This is a very interesting game, well done Kamikhaan :beam:Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
Also,
Vote: pevergreen
A while ago you claimed to have a pro-town role, yet you haven't been attacked yet. How do you explain this? Can you give us any information about your role?
And for TinCow:
Resurrect: Ichigo and gibsong91921
Why not me? ~:mecry:
Finally holmes comes into this, hmmm... this is interesting, most of whom we considered suspects are thought as innocent by you.
As of now unvote Caius, vote Abstain, likely to change later.