Printable View
Yep pretty much.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ignoramus
Try pretty much every game in a while that you've joined. Oh let's sympathize with poor Ignoramus because he doesn't want to actually participate unless he has a role.:bigcry:Quote:
So in the first game in ages that I actually participate in I get bandwagoned simply because I haven't been active in previous games? I wonder why I haven't bothered participating before.
Quite frankly, I expected some sort of competent defence when I posted, or at least some proper reason for you accusing me...instead, a vote on me for a perceived 'bandwagon', when I didn't even vote for youQuote:
Originally Posted by Ignoramus
Unvote; Vote: Ignoramus
As promised :bow:
I would like to hear from the lurkers, though - I seem to say this every game but you're not helping!
Agree. Also, Ignoramus, if you join, play. Or ask for suicide. But causing a debate because of inactivity isn't good.
Vote:Ignoramus
Current Voting Tally:
Ignoramus – 5 (Ichigo, CountArach, Tran, sapi, WH)
sapi – 1 (Ignoramus)
Et tu Horace? Then fall Ignoramus!
Are you accusing me of being a traitor?
By the way, this
is for Citadel of Alamut. Play it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Me
Day II Conclusion
Evening arrived, as always. Everybody gathered in the village square, praying that a evil heretic was now to be taken away. The sheriff stood on his platform as he did the previous evening; it creaked and whined as usual. He slowly counted the all powerful votes, one by one, by the time he had counted the third vote he realised that the conclusion was almost unanimous.
“Ignoramus” he bellowed in his gruff voice “You have been nominated for trial by this village on behalf of the inquisitors.”
The villagers were relieved, yet Ignoramus simply stood their, he offered a prayer upward, yet said nothing to anybody around him, and showed little emotion whatsoever.
“You can take him away” the sheriff abruptly said.
On queue, the red robed inquisitors appeared from the back of the small crowd, took hold of Ignoramus’ hands and began to drag him away.
“Thankyou very much my dear sheriff” one of them said in a rasping and grating tone. “If this suspect is a heretic, then we will make him pay for last night’s murder, you have my sincere word.”
As the gates opened for the inquisitors to drag Ignoramus out of the town, he shed a small tear, although nobody would ever notice. He knew that he was very unlikely to be seen again by anybody - his friends or his family.
Once Ignoramus was out of the town gates the sheriff spoke again.
"Goodnight honourable villagers, I wish you the best of luck in keeping secure this night. Be on guard at all times - avoid the heretic's sting."
He then left the platform and the villagers returned to their homes. They knew that this was to be a long and dangerous night for all of them.
_____________________
Voting Tally:
Ignoramus – 5 (Ichigo, CountArach, Tran, sapi, Warmaster Horus)
sapi – 1 (Ignoramus)
Still Alive:
sapi
Warmaster Horus
pevergreen
CountArach
Tran
greaterkhaan
RoadKill
Ichigo
Sarathos
Killed:
Orb
Under Trial and Torture
Caius Flaminius
Ignoramus
_____________________
It is now the night phase. PMs please from all those who I require them from. Good luck.
Sorry guys, but the Night Phase will have to be further extended as I still require PMs from some of the people I need them from. Apologies for any inconvenience.
Come on guys!
Thats quite funny, people (such as I) get accused and voted for inactivity or for just being new in which i dont see as being a crime. Yet everyone with roles (I do not confirm nor deny that i have one) have not sent their actions in repeatedly. What is going on.........?
People lie.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarathos
For fun.
Night II Conclusion
pevergreen was walking back home after a brisk walk to help himself get to sleep. However, just before he entered the door of his home, a voice spoke to him, although he could not tell which direction it was coming from.
“Greetings pevergreen, enjoyed your walk have you”
pevergreen taking no chances grabbed the farming tool from the outside of his home and hid it behind his back.
“Yes I did, actually”, pevergreen replied.
“Good” responded the stranger in a whispering voice, “because it will be you’re very last.”
pevergreen, upon hearing this, ran into his home as fast as he possibly could and, in the confusion, dropped his only weapon. He locked the door, hoping that he was no longer at risk. He was quite wrong about that, however.
The strange man roared and leaped upon pevergreen from behind a pot within pevergreen’s house. He possessed an almighty wooden club which pevergreen knew had the power to kill him. pevergreen was now captured, sandwiched between the floor and the attacker.
“Goodnight pevergreen” shouted the man. “Enjoy your trip to hell – I’m sure that the evil Satan will like your heretical beliefs.”
The attacker raised his club and struck pevergreen again and again, showing no emotion and ignoring his screams for mercy. By the time the attacker was finished with him, pevergreen was unrecognisable - simply a mass of mutilated flesh and powdered bones.
_____________________
Tran was taking his usual morning stroll through the centre of town early in the morning.
He'd only got to sleep late the night before, as he'd been busy drinking with his mates last night...or that morning - he forgot.
Anyway, in his tiredness, he absently took his usual shortcut through the alleyway behind the baker's shop. Unfortunately for him, he'd done it once too often.
Tran woke, many hours later, to find three men dressed in long, white coats standing around him holding instruments of torture.
"It seems that the pliers didn't work as well as intended last time," said one.
"I wonder whether Tran would object to trying being flayed alive? We've got to keep innovating, you know"
_____________________
The sheriff called his usual morning meeting. Once he has climbed onto his platform he spoke in his usual gruff and abrupt voice.
"Villagers and friends, last night, there were two brutal murders. We know that at least one of these was by the heretics. Remember to be on guard at all times, we don't know what these mentally unstable men will do next." The villagers looked terrified at the fact that the mystical protector of the previous night had not saved anybody this time. "So, vote wisely fellow, avoid lynching simple fellows. Locate the heretics, it's the only way we will be at peace from their perverted ways."
It is now the day phase, voting may now commence.
PMs will be sent out to those whom require them. Good luck!
Still Alive:
sapi
Warmaster Horus
CountArach
greaterkhaan
RoadKill
Ichigo
Sarathos
Killed:
Orb
pevergreen
Tran
Under Trial and Torture
Caius Flaminius
Ignoramus
Omanes, do you do the write-ups?
I'm guessing yes, but I could be wrong.
Anyhow, I'm still gunning for CA. Whoever's the vigilante would likely be better off ceasing judgement calls at the moment.
I think I know who's guilty because I talked to him last night...
Me, never. I'm ashamed that you would think such a thingQuote:
Originally Posted by Tran
Agreed.Quote:
Originally Posted by Orb
For us to have a chance, that role needs to be placed under the town's control (with protection from the mafia once revealed, obviously)
I wrote the vigilante kills, although the vigilante can write it himself if he so desires. The mafia, however, write their own kill. The same is true, though, for the mafia - they don't have to write the kill if they don't want to.Quote:
Originally Posted by Orb
Well, that's nice. Means we can't have any idea whatsoever of the Vigilante. The Mafia, though, if someone thinks it worthwhile they can try to analyse the write-ups.
I also agree with the Vigilante idea. If he attacks the people he targeted in the thread, then we might have an idea who it is. If not, though...
I'm ashamed that you would think I talked with only one person :bow:Quote:
Originally Posted by Ichigo
I'll give it a try; though with so few (and, indeed, with no way of knowing with 100% certainty which is mafia) I don't think we'll get that much out of this.Quote:
Well, that's nice. Means we can't have any idea whatsoever of the Vigilante. The Mafia, though, if someone thinks it worthwhile they can try to analyse the write-ups.
I've decided which is which based on uses of the word 'heretic' in the other two; let me know if you disagree.
Quote:
Orb was taking his morning jog along the marshland to the east of the town when he heard footsteps coming from behind him.
Curious, he turned, to find a man dressed in a black robe, flowing around his body, following him.
"Hello, stranger," Orb said cheerfully. "Looking to keep your fitness up too?"
Hearing no reply, Orb frowned, sighed, and continued running.
Smiling now, the stranger removed a small hunting crossbow from his belt, and shot Orb in the kneecap.
Thrashing in pain, he could do nothing to prevent himself being picked up by the stranger and carried off. Soon, everything went black.
Orb woke to find himself strapped spreadeagled on a rusty metal table, facing the decrepit ceiling above.
Two men approached him, one gripping a pair of pliers in his right hand, the other a hot metal skewer.
"You may have escaped the inquisition...but you will never escape God's judgement"
Three main things I got from the analysisQuote:
Tran was taking his usual morning stroll through the centre of town early in the morning.
He'd only got to sleep late the night before, as he'd been busy drinking with his mates last night...or that morning - he forgot.
Anyway, in his tiredness, he absently took his usual shortcut through the alleyway behind the baker's shop. Unfortunately for him, he'd done it once too often.
Tran woke, many hours later, to find three men dressed in long, white coats standing around him holding instruments of torture.
"It seems that the pliers didn't work as well as intended last time," said one.
"I wonder whether Tran would object to trying being flayed alive? We've got to keep innovating, you know"
- these were probably written by the same person - the phrasing is remarkably similar
- that person can speak english pretty well;
- however they may not be a native speaker, as there are all sorts of needless repetition in the text (eg. "taking his usual morning stroll...early in the morning")
Not much more I can see right now - we'll just have to do a bit more analysis when some more kills get posted...
To add to wht Sapi said, u can tell he has pretty good grammer.
Spot on sapi. Nice work.:thumbsup:
Vote:Roadkill For stating the obvious.
Why?Quote:
Originally Posted by Orb
No one else has anything to say?
To say... such as?
And, sapi, that sounds right.
Such as voting. People have made assumptions, but haven't acted on them..Quote:
Originally Posted by Warmaster Horus
The kill of Tran seems very much in CA's style (sleek, sophisticated and accurate). The first kills were delayed due to a late PM. CA bandwagoned Caius and has voted fairly safely. He also used an extended but insubstantial reason to excuse the bandwagon, which is a mafia tactic. A lesser townie simply throws a vote in without a reason.
'The mafia, however, write their own kill' - the style therefore implicates him.
FOS: Sarathos Just a hunch.
Again, the day phase will be extended - I dislike lynching based upon one person's vote. Sorry for any inconvenience this may cause.
Even if that vote is mine? Ah shucks.Quote:
Originally Posted by Omanes Alexandrapolites
Uh, sorry if I'm making some big reading mistake, but doesn't Orb contradict himself, more or less, in his post?
He first talks against CA, and then puts a FOS on Sarathos?Quote:
The kill of Tran seems very much in CA's style (sleek, sophisticated and accurate). The first kills were delayed due to a late PM. CA bandwagoned Caius and has voted fairly safely. He also used an extended but insubstantial reason to excuse the bandwagon, which is a mafia tactic. A lesser townie simply throws a vote in without a reason.
'The mafia, however, write their own kill' - the style therefore implicates him.
FOS: Sarathos Just a hunch.
Where's the logic in that?
FoS:Orb
Vote:CA
Reason: Orb pointed out plenty of faults, but doesn't act on them. Also, to free up some of his time for RTR7 :yes: :laugh4:
This mini-mafia needs to move :smash: So, vote people!
I'm finding it somewhat difficult to act in my current state of health ;)
Also, I attacked CA in the post, but I didn't have much evidence for Sarathos, so I just added a nice FOS to emphasise that. I've looked over everything again, and I'm not so sure about CA as I was.
Then can you be sure of me.........?
Btw, why is that suddenly all the suspicions fall on me. what did or didnt i do to make me a target. Now i know this is the nature of the game, but to make a accusation dont you need evidence and so far, i have seen none apart from the fact that i am new, im not active enough and i cant make an descent votes. So if anyone has some REAL evidence with a REAL explaination please feel free to share
Sarathos, that's because they're the evil heretics :bow:
Orb is dead :wink:Quote:
Reason: Orb pointed out plenty of faults, but doesn't act on them. Also, to free up some of his time for RTR7
Warmaster, you have made no points of your own to which I can answer. The only points that Orb has made is that the killing is very much my style, a fair enough observation and one to which I have no answer except that there are other people who write to a similar quality.
Vote: Warmaster
AS to Sarathos, I think that most of his faults are just fairly n00bish things, and tbh I haven't seen that much that makes me suspicious.
Well, of course Orb is dead, but why put a FoS on Sarathos, and not on you?
EDIT: Gah! Just noticed Orb was killed...
:oops: Sorry! UnFoS:Orb
:2thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by Orb
Unvote:Roadkill
Vote:Sarathos
For acting weird.
Current Voting Tally
CountArach - 1 (Warmaster Horus)
Warmaster Horus - 1 (CountArach)
Sarathos - 1 (Ichigo)
I'm sorry to say that I don't really wish to prolong this round for multiple days and nights waiting for a strong proportion of votes to be reached. Sadly, henceforth, I will have to kill whomever get two votes to become ahead of the other possible lynch targets. Sorry for any inconvenience.
Vote: Sarthos
What ichigo says is true, your behaviour is extremely akward.
Thanks CA for pointing out the obvious, in which no else really take the time to notice as he is absolutly right. I am a noob, no doubt about it and as for my weird behavouir, how the hell am i supposed to act? I shall state again that his is my first mafia so i do apologise if i do act strange but this is driven by my lack of experiance and the tonnes of critasism plied on by you guys. How am i supposed to act is the real question.
Day III Conclusion
The sheriff stood on his platform at sundown, it groaned as if it knew what was approaching. Then, as usual, he counted the votes. He noticed that today it wasn't very uniform.
"Sarathos!" the sheriff abruptly said.
Sarathos stood up, terribly shocked at the village's choice to have him sent to certain death - terrified of what was coming for him!
"Sarathos, you have been nominated to be handed over to the inquisitors for trial. Take him away."
On que the inquisitors came up behind the now shaking Sarathos and grabbed him by his cloak and begun to take him away.
"Thankyou ever so much sheriff" one of the Inquistors said. "I think that this trial will be most entertaining!"
As Sarathos left the gates, shaking in a terrific wave of fear, people began to slowly walk back home. They knew that this night was going to be very, very exhausting for all of them
_____________________
Voting Tally
CountArach - 1 (Warmaster Horus)
Warmaster Horus - 1 (CountArach)
Sarathos - 2 (Ichigo, RoadKill)
Still Alive:
sapi
Warmaster Horus
CountArach
greaterkhaan
RoadKill
Ichigo
Killed:
Orb
pevergreen
Tran
Under Trial and Torture
Caius Flaminius
Ignoramus
Sarathos
PMs please from all those whom I require them from, good luck.
That wasn't a good idea, I don't think.
We need to find something more substantial to lynch people for than being uncomfortable as a new player :wall:
I would have intervened, but was afk ~:(
Quote:
Originally Posted by Omanes Alexandrapolites
pevergreen lives....MWHAHAHAQuote:
Originally Posted by Omanes again but day 3 conclusion
Hehe, I was gonna mention something about that pever.
That was a mistake, I should think. Both the lynch, and the living list.
Sarathos was a new player, this was his third round of what is supposed to be a very quick mafia game. I'm not saying be fair, but be a fair-player. And, Roadkill, that sounds like a bandwagon to me.
Tran too...!Quote:
Originally Posted by pevergreen
**kills pevergreen**
Sorry guys, copied and pasted the wrong list. I'll be more careful in future. Thanks for notifying me.
Ichigo was not normal - the whole town knew that. But it was not there place to question such an exhaled personage; so they didn't. Instead, they listened to his judgement, and finally consented.
So it was well known around town that Ichigo often stayed up late at nights, happily plotting the downfall of his next victim. The men in the black robes who took him from his room that night didn't appreciate this.
And so Ichigo woke, after a doomed struggle, to find himself strapped face down to a cold, hard table.
A voice spoke up from his right. "It's scum like you who have allowed Christianity to survive this long."
Ichigo squirmed, hearing his faith so dismissed.
"But the real God will judge you," continued the voice.
"Once you've been purified," another interjected.
One of them slowly walked forward, tweezers in hand ready to strip Ichigo to shreds. Ichigo passed out, terrified that his demise was now coming, but just before he did this, he saw a glint of steel chainmail and a spear emerge in the corner of his eye, above the head of one of the attackers.
Ichigo woke up in his home layed on his own straw bed. An armoured man, whom has a nasty wound on the back of his hand, stood over him.
"That was a pretty close call my most honourable friend, good job I got to you in time" he said. "Are you alright?"
"I think so" Ichigo said, still quite nervous "but, who are you?"
But, before Ichigo could look up, the heroic saviour was gone, disappearing into the moonlight.
_____________________
The sheriff, at this morning's gathering, was slightly more pleased than he had been over the past few days.
"Last night" he said in his normal voice "there was an attack, but there was no kill! It seems God has sent a guardian angle down from heaven to help us."
The villagers breathed a sigh of relief.
"However, since there was an attack, you still must remember to keep safe. Be alert, and don't allow anything to trick you during voting today!"
The villagers sent out a cheer at this valiant comment and then scattered off to their daily business. Their morale was higher than previous days - they knew that the heretics were weak since one man could stop them.
It is now the day phase, voting may now commence. PMs will be sent out to those whom require them. Good luck!
Still Alive:
sapi
Warmaster Horus
CountArach
greaterkhaan
RoadKill
Ichigo
Killed:
Orb
pevergreen
Tran
Under Trial and Torture
Caius Flaminius
Ignoramus
Sarathos
I Liveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! Muwahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Lucky town.
Well this tells us that the Vigilante was probably killed lthe night before (or possibly Day), or chose to curb their enthusiasm this time.
Hmm, its good that we have got another round free. But dont take Ichigo as innocent just yet, mafia could have layed off for a night.
Keep playing well guys :wink:
I don't know about you, but I can't really see the mafia giving up a kill to fool us...
That aside, we now know that we have a 'doctor' type role, and we need to make use of it.
If the vigilante is still alive, I propose that they reveal, in return for protection from the doctor. That way we can use their skills properly, in an ordered manner (in effect, getting two lynchings per turn)
Wasn't there in another mafia a Vigilante/Doctor role? Who could either kill or protect a player?
I would Vote:Roadkill. For what looked like a bandwagon last turn.
An interesting idea, but one that I doubt is present in this game, as a few nights back what seemed to be the vigilante kill was blocked by the doctor role...Quote:
Wasn't there in another mafia a Vigilante/Doctor role? Who could either kill or protect a player?
I'm going to have to put a pressure vote on Roadkill for now, to further explain his reasons behind his lynch vote on Sarathos
EDIT: bolded vote (yes, it did take me a while to notice ;) )
If we're going to get anywhere with pressure votes, we need more of them. So, vote: Roadkill
Tally:
Roadkill 3(Greaterkhaan, Sapi, Warmaster Horus)
Vote: greaterkhaan
That is not pressure voting, that is bandwagonning.
I'm half tempted of unvoting and voting Greaterkhan, but I won't. Roadkill's vote on Sarathos looks much like a bandwagon.
FoS:Greaterkhan.
3 days after Caius' torture. What do we learn?
Day IV Conclusion
This evening, when the villagers arived at the town centre to see whom the victim was, the sheriff was not there as usual. In his place, were the two red robed men. The village was unerved by the presence of these men at first, but soon calmed down and listen to what they had to say.
"Today we have an announcement" one said with a harsh and thick Italian accent. "Caius, whom you gave to us on the first day, was just a simple and humble innocent Catholic man." His voice began to sound quite angry at this. "He was found innocent at the trial, but died soon afterwards from wounds inflicted by the torture's tools! You killed an innocent man - I expect better from you in the futre men - if the heretics win this fight, then I will make sure that you all are deservingly punished, that is, if they keep you alive long enough."
"Thankyou Ferdinando!" The sheriff now emerged from behind the platform, he cleared his throat, and began counting the votes in silence.
"Roadkill" he shouted.
Roadkill looked around in alarm, he immedately began to grovel for mercy terrifed of his approaching death.
"I didn't do it, I worship him, I worship God." As if to prove it, he produced a bible from his back pocket and began to read a tediously long passage. The sheriff immediately silenced him with his usual formal words.
"RoadKill you have been nominated by this village for trail by the inquisition, take him away."
As always the inquisitors grabbed him by his shoulders, despite Roadkills protests of innocence and dragged him away.
"My thanks sheriff, we will make this one speak the truth"
_____________________
Voting Tally
RoadKill - 3 (Warmaster Horus, greaterkhaan, sapi)
greaterkhaan - 1 (CountArach)
Still Alive:
sapi
Warmaster Horus
CountArach
greaterkhaan
Ichigo
Killed:
Orb
pevergreen
Tran
Under Trial and Torture
Ignoramus
Sarathos
Roadkill
Found Innocent at Trial
Caius Flaminius [towniee]
PMs please from all those whom I require them from, good luck.
Well, 5 here. If both mafia are alive still, we're dead.
There's only one left. ~;)Quote:
Originally Posted by Orb
Good positive thinking Ichigo.
Night IV Write Up
CountArach was to be found in the church, every morning, without fail. Some wondered what he had done in the past to make his devotions necessary; but none doubted his sincerity.
When the town came in for morning mass, he was already sitting in the pews, waiting for the ceremony to start.
No one was surprised that he did not move while the priest made his ritual denunciations of the heretics; he never did. No one was surprised when his head remained bowed during the gospel reading; it always did.
But they were surprised when CountArach failed to rise to receive communion. And so a kind townie went over to him, to check if he was feeling well.
It was at that point they noticed the dark stain on his black coat; it was then that they noticed the thin red line traced around his throat...
_____________________
The sheriff stood on the platform as usual.
"Last night, one man was murdered."
The villagers were unerved by the fact that nobody had been saved, but continued listening.
"And, even worse" the sheriff spoke with discust "the heretic scum did it in a church, yes a church!"
This comment was met with almost outrage by most.
"So, let's get one of these stinking hertical scum, today! Good luck!"
It is now the day phase, PMs will now be sent and voting may commence. Good luck!
Still Alive:
sapi
Warmaster Horus
greaterkhaan
Ichigo
Killed:
Orb
pevergreen
Tran
CountArach
Under Trial and Torture
Ignoramus
Sarathos
Roadkill
Found Innocent at Trial
Caius Flaminius [towniee]
Good luck guys.
:daisy:
We need to get one of the mafia today, or we lose :wall:
Presuming that the entire kill on Ichigo was written by the mafia, even though they were blocked, I'll do some quick analysis. Would like Omanes' confirmation on that point though.
Quote:
Ichigo was not normal - the whole town knew that. But it was not there place to question such an exhaled personage; so they didn't. Instead, they listened to his judgement, and finally consented.
So it was well known around town that Ichigo often stayed up late at nights, happily plotting the downfall of his next victim. The men in the black robes who took him from his room that night didn't appreciate this.
And so Ichigo woke, after a doomed struggle, to find himself strapped face down to a cold, hard table.
A voice spoke up from his right. "It's scum like you who have allowed Christianity to survive this long."
Ichigo squirmed, hearing his faith so dismissed.
"But the real God will judge you," continued the voice.
"Once you've been purified," another interjected.
One of them slowly walked forward, tweezers in hand ready to strip Ichigo to shreds. Ichigo passed out, terrified that his demise was now coming, but just before he did this, he saw a glint of steel chainmail and a spear emerge in the corner of his eye, above the head of one of the attackers.
Ichigo woke up in his home layed on his own straw bed. An armoured man, whom has a nasty wound on the back of his hand, stood over him.
"That was a pretty close call my most honourable friend, good job I got to you in time" he said. "Are you alright?"
"I think so" Ichigo said, still quite nervous "but, who are you?"
But, before Ichigo could look up, the heroic saviour was gone, disappearing into the moonlight.
For the analysis itself, there were some pretty stupid grammatical errors (mixing up their/there/they're, then/than) but still pretty literate overall. I'm inclined to say english as a first language, but not something that's been practiced that often.Quote:
CountArach was to be found in the church, every morning, without fail. Some wondered what he had done in the past to make his devotions necessary; but none doubted his sincerity.
When the town came in for morning mass, he was already sitting in the pews, waiting for the ceremony to start.
No one was surprised that he did not move while the priest made his ritual denunciations of the heretics; he never did. No one was surprised when his head remained bowed during the gospel reading; it always did.
But they were surprised when CountArach failed to rise to receive communion. And so a kind townie went over to him, to check if he was feeling well.
It was at that point they noticed the dark stain on his black coat; it was then that they noticed the thin red line traced around his throat...
Seeing as this has been written a bit like Warmaster Horus does his gahzette articles, I'm going to have to use that inside information to vote: horus
I think Sapi raises some good points. I don't see any reasons to vote for anyone else, and the things that Sapi's pointing are simply too valid of reasons to simply dismiss. Lastly, there is no reason to vote anyone else. Ichigo has survived two attempts on his life and is almost certainly innocent. Sapi has been nothing but helpful this entire game. And I'm innocent as well.
So vote: Warmaster Horus
Tally
Warmaster Horus 2(Sapi, Greaterkhaan)
Smart guy :yes:Quote:
Originally Posted by sapi
Error: do not correlate the two write ups without Omanes' confirmation that they were written by mafiosi.Quote:
Originally Posted by sapi
Hum, english is my mother language, which I have been practicing since I was six. And to which I have been subjected since I was born. I wouldn't have made those mistakes. You can check out my entry for the Heresy Contest for another bit of proof.Quote:
For the analysis itself, there were some pretty stupid grammatical errors (mixing up their/there/they're, then/than) but still pretty literate overall. I'm inclined to say english as a first language, but not something that's been practiced that often.
Eh, my articles were almost grammatically perfect, no?Quote:
Seeing as this has been written a bit like Warmaster Horus does his gahzette articles
The Gahzette can be read by everyone. They know I'm part of it, because in my sig there's Gahzette Reporter. How difficult would it be for an Australian, or an American to read the articles, and try to adjust their style?Quote:
I'm going to have to use that inside information
I hadn't considered the idea of intentional writing mistakes, but you may have. Both of you are better at mafia than I am (greaterkhaan, congrats again on KFM), so you could have. I would have been the perfect scapegoat, no?
I'm a native speaker, so if you consider what you said, I'm innocent. I loathe grammatical mistakes, being close to a perfectionnist.Quote:
Originally Posted by sapi, analysis of mafia kills
Now, enough against sapi, on to greaterkhaan.
You have posted, as far as I'm aware, twice in game. Once was to put a supposed pressure vote on Roadkill. However, that vote was the third on on him. Ergo, bandwagon.
The second time was voting with sapi. You don't bring reasons of your own, other than the very understandable "I'm innocent". Innocence is easy to claim, but hard to prove in your case. Do you have anything to back it up?
You say Ichigo is innocent because he has been attacked by the mafia. This I do believe is true, and it's a good line of though. But you, however, don't have anything to prove your innocence. In fact, you have stuff going against you. That vote that looks a lot like a bandwagon, for one thing. And, your near complete inactivity doesn't really help you.
I think the town has lost, because I believe sapi and greaterkhaan are mafia.
And now, even though I think the town is lost, I vote:greaterkhaan. I believe I have shown enough suspicion against sapi, too.
Ichigo, please, do the right thing. And vote rightly.
Warmaster, do you have any evidence that either greaterkhann or myself are mafia, other than that desperate accusation?
I will explain my reasoning a bit more, if you'd like, for Ichigo's benefit...
I didn't so much point the finger at warmaster horusbecause of clear inconsistencies in his style, though they were there; I did so from a process of elimination.
It's actually quite easy:
1) Ichigo was attacked by mafia => he's innocent
2) greaterkhaan hasn't struck me as someone with a very good grasp of english, and the kills were written as such
3) I know I'm innocent
ergo, the only remaining player must be mafia - and that's horus. Do you really think that Omanes would have kept the game going if there were two mafia: two townies? It's impossible to get a town win in that situation; since the game is still going there must be only one mafia remaining...
Ahh, I didn't think of that.Quote:
Do you really think that Omanes would have kept the game going if there were two mafia: two townies? It's impossible to get a town win in that situation; since the game is still going there must be only one mafia remaining...
Maybe you aren't mafia, but I'm convinced greaterkhaan is. He's been bandwagonning for his two posts. And the kills haven't been completely written in perfect english: you said so yourself. A few mistakes such as those you pointed out. And, a few of those mistakes can be found in his write-ups for Kung Fu Mafia.
Also, do you have proof of your innocence, something that will permit me to say "yes, of course, you are a townie"?
I would, but Omanes doesn't allow the quoting of role PMs
Can you think of anything that'd prove my innocence?
So you are saying you're the vigilante?
No, I'm the doctor.
I was protecting Ichigo last night, more's the pity ~:(
I think that people should not ignore the possibility that sapi may have written the kills poorly on purpose and that he is, in fact, the mafia. In addition, I am not going to trust his role claim.
I urge a Detective, if the town has one, to come forward.
Any specific evidence - any at all - for that sort of denunciation?
I'm equally interested to hear what the detective may have to say...
You really want to know? I do have it.Quote:
Any specific evidence - any at all - for that sort of denunciation?
Of couse.Quote:
Originally Posted by CountArach
Anything you can give us (without breaching the rules and forcing Omanes to help the mafia) would be much appreciated :yes:
I was the Doctor.
And I'm sure providing proof or corroboration of that would be far too difficult for you to even attempt.
Indeed. But what would I gain from claiming when I am dead, if I am not indeed the Doctor?
And actually, someone else can provide the evidence, I hope. That is why I am hoping for a Detective that investigated one or the other of us.