-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
maybe i'm a sucker but dya doesn't really feel like a hit atp
idk
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ColonelLubriderm
me too
What, were you not suspecting him just now/putting him at the bottom of your readlist?
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Montmorency wagon is fine actually; not feeling strongly about the content in the posts, as well as general conviction in reads like in yesterday's EoD/Csargo... also stuff today in general has been fairly shrug!! Quite a bit of being down with the thread sentiment but not entirely getting that it isn't just because that's what other people are saying/where they're at, and also aren't really getting their EoD thoughts!
I'd consider moving there now except I'm not sure where votes are at, and also Visor wagon hype!!!
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ephemeral
maybe i'm a sucker but dya doesn't really feel like a hit atp
idk
Why so?
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Official Tally as of #1764
4 Montmorency (Cuthillius, Esooa, Hally, pzelda)
2 Dolby (Ephemeral, GeneralHankerchief)
2 Maple (dyachei, Raskolnikov)
1 dyachei (ColonelLubriderm)
1 Esooa (Visor)
1 Visor (Arapocalypse)
Not Voting: Dolby, Manasi, Maple, Montmorency
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Arapocalypse
What, were you not suspecting him just now/putting him at the bottom of your readlist?
i currently think GH and everyone above him is some degree of villagyness. I think he isn't a wolf with monte and i think dolby is a wolf, so it just made sense to group them together as 1-2 wolves max
i could probably drop manasi into his section and keep the numbers the same.
I edited on the fly, originally i had it like this
but when i went to put numbers i didnt really think it was accurate since i think there is 1 MAX between dya/esooa, so i finagled around to where i liked it
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ephemeral
maybe i'm a sucker but dya doesn't really feel like a hit atp
idk
I think the towniest post dya made all game was the one a little while ago where they said "chop me, it'll make GH suffer more anyway".
This is not even a joke.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Arapocalypse
Hmm, okay!!
Are you just onto Monty now, or ? as in where are you for suspicions and stuff?
Anything in particular you want to discuss?
THe fact you didn't even bother to put me in your Quantum tier list maybe? :)
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
i feel like i can't even say my thoughts so im gonna go to dinner and probably not come back
gl gl
please kill me wolves, do a colonel a favor
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Hi all. Can we kill esooa
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
and nope.
When I left I was at a POE of roughly Monty, Maple, pzelda, Dolby, with Colonel and Manasi as outsiding chances.
I am just back from a long day work, will have some food then might invest some more time in this game. I've got the feeling you haven't been reading my posts tbh (both the list thing and the fact you sound unaware of my progression. maybe u are the poisoner, dunno
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Amusingly, none of the wagonees have voted yet.
A lot of people are meh to fine for now.
I'm low-key suss of Visor because his pushes seem poor and he's not nearly as invested in them as I would expect. But I can't act without flip associations.
I don't know what Dolbster is doing as a non-3P, but I don't really want him to die atp, especially if he's swamped.
GH, Ara, and Hally are outright bad candidates for D2.
There isn't reason for Dya to stay unresolved.
Visor and Zelda have put mild pressure on Dolbster, so I could reaction-test them with a Dolbster vote, but I'll play it safe with Vote: Dyachei
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
pzelda
Also, I should say that I operate under an assumption that Rask is town a lot rn. If I'm wrong, Visor's probably good and this town might need a strong leader in Visor/GH later. This is why a possible healer might need to let Rask die regardless of his activity today.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Maple
A random thought about the poisoner popped into my head and I was gonna post it then I realized that would be suboptimal so here I am
I had a thought so wild and sudden, yet obvious - did you have it too?
It's the kind of thing that I might shouldn't report to the thread.
:eyebrows:
Although, someone tell me: has Visor ever expressed an opinion on the question of healing Rask?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ColonelLubriderm
I think we yeet outside of dya/gh
have the poisoner hit dya
and re-evaluate tomorrow.
your move
Poisoner's <25% having another shot today. My hunch.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ColonelLubriderm
it had the split wolfteam and the wolves on the otherside also thought i was the real vigi and tried to dayvig me
All this excessive talk of prior games is making me real nervous! /s
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Cuthillius
i gth gh/dya both v at this point but it's a low confidence thing and that's a lot of why i don't like monty's posts today
with regards to your second point i answered that yesterday, i think monty and you specifically did that d2
But it's false. I was literally the first or second person to raise the possibility of all-town wagons.
Monty: Maybe all-t wagons?
Cuth: That's so suss
Cuth: Hey, I'm starting to wonder: EOD1 all-t wagons?
:freak:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Raskolnikov
and nope.
When I left I was at a POE of roughly Monty, Maple, pzelda, Dolby, with Colonel and Manasi as outsiding chances.
Didn't Zelda have Monty, Maple, Dya, Visor, with possibly Dolby? Interesting overlap.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
it's a little annoying to be told my push on esooa was dumb but now visor wants to push there
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
@MOnty: maybe. I am not sure why I had mixed feelings about pzelda. I should prolly read him and Dolby I guess.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dyachei
it's a little annoying to be told my push on esooa was dumb but now visor wants to push there
fwiw I doin't think it was dumb per se. But the reasons were not convincing. (to me at least)
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
I find it amusing that even as a mostly consensus lunch and suspected by everyone, dya has less votes on her than Monty.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Is the thread dead because of time or because wolves are happy with its state? Rask, Monty, Dya all town would be a disaster.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
In going to the store
We're out of milk
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
pzelda
I find it amusing that even as a mostly consensus lunch and suspected by everyone, dya has less votes on her than Monty.
If you believe everyone suspects dya, then the current wagon formation might lead you to have a different feeling than amusement.
Such as it being evidence against the proposition that everyone suspects dya (leaving aside the textual evidence throughout D2 posting of skepticism around dya's status).
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Raskolnikov
and nope.
When I left I was at a POE of roughly Monty, Maple, pzelda, Dolby, with Colonel and Manasi as outsiding chances.
I am just back from a long day work, will have some food then might invest some more time in this game. I've got the feeling you haven't been reading my posts tbh (both the list thing and the fact you sound unaware of my progression. maybe u are the poisoner, dunno
Alright then, cool; was mostly wondering if there was other stuff I'd missed, as yes I'm aware of what your list was at previously!!!!
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Raskolnikov
THe fact you didn't even bother to put me in your Quantum tier list maybe? :)
I left you off because you're poisoned, thought that would be obvious!!!
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Hey Manti!!!!
Who do you want to kill today and why? Thoughts on wagons?
Why haven't you shared any food pics?
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Things people have said about me:
I'm too engaged
I'm not posting enough content
I'm posting too much content
I'm not posting enough memes
I'm making posts to fake people out
I have reads too early
I didn't give enough reads
I just wanna grill for gods sake
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Arapocalypse
Hey Manti!!!!
Who do you want to kill today and why? Thoughts on wagons?
Why haven't you shared any food pics?
Dya
I made pancake but didn't take pictures
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
im fine killing dya
or esooa
(i guess gh too?)
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Why: because they don't want to be in the game.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Maple
I just wanna grill for gods sake
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wU9Daiu5XoM
CW:
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Esooa dying would be cool, if we believe we have another poison or smth
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Weird day; overall thoughts on mafia agenda are that they are... not overly distinctive, maybe? Yes, I have Visor lurking in the back of my head; a lot of this is mostly just that we need more flips for anything!!!
I've also been staring at Sunbae's last readlist for the past few minutes, but am not really sure where to put things considering that I'm fairly there on his town and mafia are more shrug, and one of his strengths is being able to re-evaluate well...
@Sunbae What would you be doing here? Please send thoughts through morphogenic field!!!!!!
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Arapocalypse
Weird day; overall thoughts on mafia agenda are that they are... not overly distinctive, maybe? Yes, I have Visor lurking in the back of my head; a lot of this is mostly just that we need more flips for anything!!!
I've also been staring at Sunbae's last readlist for the past few minutes, but am not really sure where to put things considering that I'm fairly there on his town and mafia are more shrug, and one of his strengths is being able to re-evaluate well...
@
Sunbae What would you be doing here? Please send thoughts through morphogenic field!!!!!!
Pinging the n1 kill
Bold move
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Arapocalypse
I left you off because you're poisoned, thought that would be obvious!!!
I think not wanting to read me before flip might hamper your ability to make reads on people voting me, reading me, etc.
(and yeah, I am really tired here and frustration has come back a bit, sorry for being grumpy smh)
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Maple
Things people have said about me:
I'm too engaged
I'm not posting enough content
I'm posting too much content
I'm not posting enough memes
I'm making posts to fake people out
I have reads too early
I didn't give enough reads
I just wanna grill for gods sake
What are your thoughts on your own play thus far, this game/
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Arapocalypse
What are your thoughts on your own play thus far, this game/
I'm vibing
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Raskolnikov
I think not wanting to read me before flip might hamper your ability to make reads on people voting me, reading me, etc.
(and yeah, I am really tired here and frustration has come back a bit, sorry for being grumpy smh)
I mean... no one's voting you today?
Also, I've said already that I have a bit of a townread on you, to some extent!!!! It is simply not something I've wanted to elaborate on, considering that you're not in consideration for elimination at the end of the day anyways!!
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Official Tally as of #1799
3 dyachei (ColonelLubriderm, Esooa, Montmorency)
3 Montmorency (Cuthillius, Hally, pzelda)
2 Dolby (Ephemeral, GeneralHankerchief)
2 Maple (dyachei, Raskolnikov)
1 Esooa (Visor)
1 Visor (Arapocalypse)
Not Voting: Dolby, Manasi, Maple
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GeneralHankerchief
I think the towniest post dya made all game was the one a little while ago where they said "chop me, it'll make GH suffer more anyway".
This is not even a joke.
Btw, after a significant amount of leveling, I now believe the aforementioned post is NAI.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GeneralHankerchief
Btw, after a significant amount of leveling, I now believe the aforementioned post is NAI.
correct
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Visor
wheres your head at gh
dya probably best for gamestate atp and they could also very much be mafia (even though I'm in for a fun day tomorrow if they flip red), Dolby is my preferred counterwagon and despite what I literally just said I'd also be fine with him going over today.
Not sure where you're coming from w/r/t Esooa and would like some elaboration there because I really don't see it.
ColonelBop correctly ID'd that he'd be taking some sus if dya/Rask (and especially them together) flipped town but I also think it's more than he's letting on because he specifically called for wagons exactly of Csargo/dya/[Amy/Rask] at least two separate times on D1 that I remember and wouldn't really entertain anybody outside those three (I remember him being "fine" with people like Eph/Dolby/Monty maybe? wagons but he said he would still push for the former three, so that doesn't really count to me).
Which means I'm probably back around on going for dya here.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
hi, i’m like half here and half not until EoD. probably mostly not
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
wheres your head at hally
wdyt of dya/esooa/gh
where do you want to go today
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GeneralHankerchief
Btw, after a significant amount of leveling, I now believe the aforementioned post is NAI.
:jumping:
Vote: dyachei
!!!!!!!!!!
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Feeling like it'll probably be a quiet EoD? Back in a bit!!!
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Arapocalypse
Feeling like it'll probably be a quiet EoD? Back in a bit!!!
Yeah I'm having another beer or three and popping back in with like 20 to go.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Official Tally as of #1812
5 dyachei (ColonelLubriderm, Montmorency, Esooa, Visor, Arapocalypse)
3 Montmorency (Cuthillius, Hally, pzelda)
2 Dolby (Ephemeral, GeneralHankerchief)
2 Maple (dyachei, Raskolnikov)
Not Voting: Dolby, Manasi, Maple
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
D2: Dolby gets lynched the same way Csargo did
dya survives to 2098
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
ive wondered if the sunbae kill doesnt just feel like a cuth nightkill
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Visor
wheres your head at hally
wdyt of dya/esooa/gh
where do you want to go today
probably gonna end up on dya. i hate to say it because if i’m wrong i’ll feel like shit but i think they’re just a wolf. and regardless, i feel like the game is so warped around them that we almost have to flip them atp or else it’ll be another day of wheel spinning if we lunch someone else and miss
i think esooa is a villager especially if dya is a wolf. highly doubt they’re w/w but i also think esooa’s villagery on her own anyway. don’t get why you wanna lunch her
i dunno about gh. i still think he looks awful if dya is a wolf and nothing he’s posted today has made me feel differently on that. if anything i feel more strongly about it :shrug: but if dya is a villager it’s all moot and he maybe comes out looking villagery even. dunno, he’s pretty much in limbo for me atm and i find it hard to unfuse him from dya in my head
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
i really don’t get the dolby votes
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
I'm falling asleep. Do I need to vote Dya here? Or is it better that my vote is getting a spicy wagon chance?
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
id vote dya
lets get this done
if we're wrong we need the flip at this point to move on
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hally
i really don’t get the dolby votes
i think he fell off to hell but ymmv
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
i’m kinda shocked nobody mentioned gh’s post where he invoked the sunbae theorem to vote dolby. if you’re gonna sunbae theorem anyone itg it should be dya and gh using it to justify a vote on dolby over dya is bananas
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hally
probably gonna end up on dya. i hate to say it because if i’m wrong i’ll feel like shit but i think they’re just a wolf. and regardless, i feel like the game is so warped around them that we almost have to flip them atp or else it’ll be another day of wheel spinning if we lunch someone else and miss
i think esooa is a villager especially if dya is a wolf. highly doubt they’re w/w but i also think esooa’s villagery on her own anyway. don’t get why you wanna lunch her
i dunno about gh. i still think he looks awful if dya is a wolf and nothing he’s posted today has made me feel differently on that. if anything i feel more strongly about it :shrug: but if dya is a villager it’s all moot and he maybe comes out looking villagery even. dunno, he’s pretty much in limbo for me atm and i find it hard to unfuse him from dya in my head
this is probs true ye
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hally
i’m kinda shocked nobody mentioned gh’s post where he invoked the sunbae theorem to vote dolby. if you’re gonna sunbae theorem anyone itg it should be dya and gh using it to justify a vote on dolby over dya is bananas
I... thought the one who made that post was colonel?
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
pzelda
I'm falling asleep. Do I need to vote Dya here? Or is it better that my vote is getting a spicy wagon chance?
dya's p much always the one who goes over today
feel free to do whatever I guess lol
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ephemeral
i think he fell off to hell but ymmv
i don’t think it’s AI though? his last post sounded like he had irl stuff
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ephemeral
I... thought the one who made that post was colonel?
that... would explain why nobody mentioned it lol. guess it was a joke then
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hally
probably gonna end up on dya. i hate to say it because if i’m wrong i’ll feel like shit but i think they’re just a wolf. and regardless, i feel like the game is so warped around them that we almost have to flip them atp or else it’ll be another day of wheel spinning if we lunch someone else and miss
i think esooa is a villager especially if dya is a wolf. highly doubt they’re w/w but i also think esooa’s villagery on her own anyway. don’t get why you wanna lunch her
i dunno about gh. i still think he looks awful if dya is a wolf and nothing he’s posted today has made me feel differently on that. if anything i feel more strongly about it :shrug: but if dya is a villager it’s all moot and he maybe comes out looking villagery even. dunno, he’s pretty much in limbo for me atm and i find it hard to unfuse him from dya in my head
why do you feel more strongly now?
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Ephemeral
I... thought the one who made that post was colonel?
Nope it was me.
I stand by it too! But dya probably still has to go here.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Imagine mafia are frozen because both dya and Rask are about to flip red. :campfire:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hally
i’m kinda shocked nobody mentioned gh’s post where he invoked the sunbae theorem to vote dolby. if you’re gonna sunbae theorem anyone itg it should be dya and gh using it to justify a vote on dolby over dya is bananas
It was GH. Explain the theorem.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
lol one day I'll manage to not get them mixed up
probably
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Totally melding with Hally there. Like her last couple of posts is prolly the most accurate vibe we can get from the gamethread.
secondtotallyunpectedturnaroundofthedayondyafromraskolincoming.gif
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Esooa
why do you feel more strongly now?
apparently the post that made me feel more strongly about it was not, in fact, a gh post
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Montmorency
Imagine mafia are frozen because both dya and Rask are about to flip red. :campfire:
It was GH. Explain the theorem.
Sunbae Theorem = in games with playerlists of a certain quality (which this game qualifies), if you're not sure where to go, you can't really go wrong with just chopping whoever isn't being townie.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Ninjaed! Hally posted two more posts while I was typing!
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
apparently it was, in fact, a gh post
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Anyway:
Speaking selfishly, dya flipping here is an interesting quandary for me.
If they're town: Hooray! I have an easier D3 tomorrow! But OTOH, we've lost something like 5 townies to 0 mafiosi (Rask flip pending) factoring in poisons and nightkills and whatnot.
If they're mafia: Hooray! We got one! But OTOH, I'm in deep :daisy: tomorrow.
So part of me kind of just wants to know where I stand.
-
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Visor
ive wondered if the sunbae kill doesnt just feel like a cuth nightkill
What does this mean?