i doubt ill beat orb... but its asked so...
Printable View
i doubt ill beat orb... but its asked so...
And that helps why?Quote:
Originally Posted by Stig
And your argument is?
And your response to my argument is?
I'm very happy that you think you'll beat him.
Vote: Stig
How does my first duel suggest not?
I challenge Sapi, because I think he's suspicious. Now me beating him would ofcourse not help as Pan said there were 4 mafia so others could do the kills.
Pan said he has some detective role, and I'm almost sure there's another one like it, maybe even more. They can now easely concentrate on other people. As Sapi has no night action anyway.
That's if I win.
If I lose it's vica versa.
How do we know Mafia can't have some rudimentary detective ability for one of their mafiosos? They did in CDTC. Has Pannonian revealed his actual role to us? I don't recall him doing so. How do we know he isn't some mafia role using his detective abilities to take command of the town?
CR
u talking to me? I think yur stronger than me... i dont know... i just think itQuote:
Originally Posted by Orb
So beating him doesn't help! But, if he beats you then, someone who you find suspicious becomes stronger at duelling. This is a lose-lose situation.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stig
Are you drunk?
I was replying to a post from Sigurd.
dont bother... asking pann to reveal anything will result in him wanting the entire game to suicide with him...Quote:
Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit
btw...
i never checked anyway... Pann what was your role actually in CDTC
@orb...
you might wanna quote.. or post @ since that post isnt even on the page... :P
Only one, not more ... have to get up early tomorrowQuote:
Are you drunk?
This actually:
'Were your original score 9 or not? Your first duel suggests otherwise.
Time to come clean… '
In case you've forgotten Siggy, I don't know his Kung Fu value. Nor do I know TS's. Nor do I know Redleg's. All three duels last round were over in three seconds. Perhaps there is some non-correlation.
what does Non-Correlation mean?
Not very well phrased by me. I meant to suggest that for the sake of the writing style/impact Sasaki may have stretched the differences in skill to make everything end in 3 seconds.
I'm willing to challenge Orb as well now I look at it.
If you want assurance that he has a high score or not.
btw, remember the duels in Midgard, I was equal to Count Arach according to the write up. But in real I was a Jotun with at that moment the highest ingame score.
i already challenge orb.
also to answer your (stigs) question about the write up... either GH or Redleg prolly wrote their own write up...
Its impossible:inquisitive:Quote:
either GH or Redleg prolly wrote their own write up.
We don't. But it's unusual & therefore unlikely.Quote:
Originally Posted by Crazed Rabbit
If you were right, it's far riskier for him to expose himself in such a fashion at such an early stage. Why bother?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Orb
Can you tell us what you were doing those past few nights?Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki
Nothing. Nil. Nada. Nichts.
IIRC, I trained with someone on night one. I've cleaned out my PMs, so I'll go through the havoc of 'My Documents' soon and try to find 'em.
I recall being rather annoyed at that ~DQuote:
Originally Posted by Stig
If one fighter is much better then it will be made evident in the writeup. The write up is not an exact picture of the scores however, e.g. the value of "slight" is not precisely defined.
Right now, I'll vote: Kagemusha.
Where have you been? Please do something, I really don't want Sasaki to start wogging. I also wouldn't mind if we initiated curse of Kagemusha, either.:beam: Also, FoS on Stig, Orb, and the Stranger. We've seen a few kung fu kills, which means that the mafia must have some very high scores, which all three of you seem to have.
Guys, why are you going after Pann so hard? What if his role really is somewhat limited? Then we've lynched an innocent townie when we had evidence of their innocence. As Hugh said, why should he reveal a role so early if he was mafia? It doesn't seem logical to me to try lynching every person who claims a role.
Tally:
Xehh II-2(Xdeathfire, CR)
Orb-2(Pevergreen, Sigurd)
Stig-1(Hughtower)
Kagemusha-1(greaterkhaan)
How am I scummy?
Mafia have never been
Allowed to kill friends.
How strange! How forgetful! You mean you can't remember?Quote:
Originally Posted by Orb
Unvote, Vote: Orb
Your best yet. Well done.Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHaiku
:laugh4:
This is not an answer to my question... I asked first.Quote:
Originally Posted by Orb
Yes, but these fights aren't determined by randomness. This is simply the highest score wins.Quote:
Originally Posted by Stig
I am going to bed now... And seeing that Orb has probably retired too I will place the real reason for me to doubt Orbs claimed score.
Take a closer look at these two fights...Quote:
*****
Orb Vs Ichigo
These fighters are closer to each other's skill level, with a slight edge to Orb. However, Orb's Dragon style is the natural antithesis of Ichigo's White Crane style, and this is enough to allow Orb to soundly defeat Ichigo.
*****
Sigurd Vs discovery1
This fight is a reverse of the previous fight. It is evident that Sigurd is a much better fighter, but disco's praying mantis helps him vs Sigurds dragon. It is not enough however, and disco is defeated.
*****
They were fought in the same round(1). It is clearly stated that they are different.
Two of these combatants had the same starting score whilst their opponents obviously had not.
If I were to reveal to you that one of the winners had a starting score of 9, who would that be?
Oh yes, the loosing combatants in these two fights had the same starting score... and one of the winners had a starting score of 9... but it was not Orb
I think that the mafiosi get more than a +2 for killing using Kung Fu during the night and Orb needed a reason to validate his explosive advance.
Too bad these duels exposed him.
OK, Sigurd. Just back from watching House and Shark.
I don't know what the scores of the respective combatants were, with the exception of myself. Disco is *dead*, meaning that you cannot possibly know his score, because he would not have been allowed by the rules to discuss it after his death.
Bad bluff Siggy.
Vote: Sigurd Fafnesbane
Oh, and just in case you wanted to put this spin on it, the reference to 'closer to each other's skill level' is to the Sapi and Andres' fight (just checked). Sasaki does also not need to use the same phrasing automatically for the same skill difference.
Sorry Orb... Ichigo can confirm this... I discussed this with him and Disco before Disco was killed... or rather just after the duels.Quote:
Originally Posted by Orb
I was going to remedy my block of him by training him. I had to know his score to be sure I had twice as much.
I guess you got caught M8...
'How strange! How forgetful! You mean you can't remember?
Unvote, Vote: Orb'
I do, believe it or not, have a life and several other things to do besides this game, combined with a weird (Edit: Freakish is more the word), selective memory. My usual approach was to just check PMs whenever I needed to, but I'm clearing space for Citadel of Alamut. I've saved them to disk, but My Documents currently has no order or organisation. I'll check who I trained with, and report back sometime after 6.30 (GMT) tomorrow.
'
I think that the mafiosi get more than a +2 for killing using Kung Fu during the night and Orb needed a reason to validate his explosive advance. '
Is this a really bad joke?
Sasaki has, IIRC, said in the thread that they get exactly +2 from a Kung Fu night kill.