Representative Democracy [Concluded]

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sooh

No, I can't, because I haven't read the last three pages and I have to go to work.

Also, Zack, you can just go ahead and lynch me. Pretty much done.

---

I'll give you ....

https://media1.giphy.com/media/r4NFWBPT6ksyQ/giphy.gif

https://media.giphy.com/media/5xaOcL...tVYs/giphy.gif

?

Going to work, ok. Not giving reads because behind 3 pages is meh.

In Hackers you commented as you went afaict so this is a direct contradiction.

Why on Earth would you let us lynch you/not contribute the thoughts you have as a Town PR?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Monstrbro

It can only be played as it is

The skeptic-view fostering emotion-charging argumentative internet yelling game that it is

---

But with kitties and <3 between frands.

We can dooooooooooo eeeeeeeeet

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cass_

But with kitties and <3 between frands.

We can dooooooooooo eeeeeeeeet

---

But there is mountains of evidence that we can't

I guess we can try

What are the odds that the entire wolfteam hasn't read the entire thread yet

actually now that i think about it

this isn't how sooh acted at all when things didn't go her way in heroes (as town)

meh i hate how you popped in here and i don't know what to make of it wrt your alignment

i'm not sure if i just dislike it because it's annoying or because it's wolfy

in any case it's probably not worth lynching a potential PR d1

It would be a list that includes (when taking reads into account) maybe six players, three of which have posted twice or less yikes

I just… I dunno. Both Visor and Zack are giving off very similar vibes, both feel like they are playing the role of the pushy experienced one, and both of them are either uber town or uber wolf depending on which way my confirmation bias is heading while reading them. It just feels like both of them are doing Pizza-style wolfing, but the problem is that that school of wolfing is what town does. I just don't know, and feel like venting my frustration.

Thoughts on rest of pg 5/10 for me

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by atheotes

Well, Dp had not yet posted when you voted him as rep. TMI?

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Renata

I'm going to say it one more time. My criteria for voting someone for representative was, primarily, to put someone in there I thought I would be able to read, if they were town. Dp fits that criteria better than anyone else in my group, so I voted for him. He has since posted in ways that make me comfortable with that choice as being someone who actually is town. Do you get it now?

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by atheotes

its the way you phrased it. I read it as "being able to read AND being your town read", which was not possible when you voted. Its something that pinged me. I was hoping to get a second opinion. Nothing more for you to explain on this. I will just keep you in my suspect list for now :bow:

---

Understand both theses PoVs.

Had the same reaction as atheotes initially, read Renata's response to me several times to see if it could come from Town and found I could accept it.

Liked/mindmelded with lots of atheotes early thoughts so leaning him light gut Town for that until I look closer.

Renata trended up for me in tone and responses/questioning widely etc. Gonna be a tricky one for me cos she spooked me early. Think we may have similar paranoia take on game in general.


These two both stood out as kind of shallow justification and possible picking on easy fruit but ?just more direct playstyle?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Winston Hughes

Rereading El Barto, I'm content with my vote.

Defence by meta doesn't wash.

Need to see some actual townie intent, beyond the self preservation.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

This is the kind of reaction/defense post I don't like.

Vote: Sooh

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dp101

I just… I dunno. Both Visor and Zack are giving off very similar vibes, both feel like they are playing the role of the pushy experienced one, and both of them are either uber town or uber wolf depending on which way my confirmation bias is heading while reading them. It just feels like both of them are doing Pizza-style wolfing, but the problem is that that school of wolfing is what town does. I just don't know, and feel like venting my frustration.

---

https://i.imgur.com/QhoOKQp.gif

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I agree tho

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Monstrbro

https://i.imgur.com/QhoOKQp.gif

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I agree tho

---

BUT

They're probably both villagers so I've been rolling with it

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Monstrbro

Dp
Visor
Dice
Cass
Renata probably

Villager list of people that are town friends yay

No strong scum suspects yet

---

QUOTE=Monstrbro;2053729136]A few posts back have had some tone I don't like but this post prolly enough for me to

vote: montmorency

Prolly gone for a while now not sure if I'll make EoD this started at at really hectic time in my life

I'll be around more later tonight if I haven't missed anything

Playing on my phone and skimming because my compuser is broken so idk exactly when deadline is but I'll try to be back[/QUOTE]


Town-hunting is something Monstr does as Town. Not sure about his scum-game.
Mindmeld on the expressed thoughts to here and can ooook those he lists as possi-villagers but lolparanoia want to really catch up on them first.

Lolparanoia included Dice doesn't Town read me early, and you questioned his early GH vote immediately prior to this, why's he Town?


Gonna focus on catching up ITT. Have about 5 mins before family come home and then mafia playing is out-of-bounds until late tonight.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

@atheotes

Do you want this to be the uniform strategy throughout the game?

---

This is my thinking right now. it will change on further information and game state.
Why do i feel this is a redundant question?

cass i assume that was a quote break so you should make a new vote unless you want to vote monty

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zack

i don't even understand what you are talking about in your first paragraph

your second is pretty rich

---

This is just a continuation of your non-engagement with my posts. You do a good job here of making my point, so thank you. Since you no longer appear to have anything valid to say, and when you address my comments it's to belittle them and ignore the content (which you can't counter) I'm going to move on. Barring someone else doing something really strange, I'm pretty sure my vote will stay on you, and I'll be encouraging others to follow. Gday.

Only on post 490 for the moment, but not sure i'll get through all of them tonight, so wanted to drop a line about Dp and Winston.

I went back and refreshed myself on my last game with both of them. Dp, out of the box I have to apologize, I had you confused with Psilly, which is quite rude of me given how... off... that fellow is. I have to look back at things with a new perspective, but you're not the flaky, squirrel chasing guy I thought you were. That makes me feel a little less confident in my read. That shouldn't be read as I think you're scummy, just that I don't know if you're towny. I think that makes sense.

On Winston, his play seems fairly consistent to what I saw in the last game. For context, I was scum and he was one of two villagers I chose to pick on throughout the game, so I had a lot of interaction with him. This gives him pretty solid town cred for me, based on d1 contributions.

Going back to reading now.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jabbz

Only on post 490 for the moment, but not sure i'll get through all of them tonight, so wanted to drop a line about Dp and Winston.

I went back and refreshed myself on my last game with both of them. Dp, out of the box I have to apologize, I had you confused with Psilly, which is quite rude of me given how... off... that fellow is. I have to look back at things with a new perspective, but you're not the flaky, squirrel chasing guy I thought you were. That makes me feel a little less confident in my read. That shouldn't be read as I think you're scummy, just that I don't know if you're towny. I think that makes sense.

On Winston, his play seems fairly consistent to what I saw in the last game. For context, I was scum and he was one of two villagers I chose to pick on throughout the game, so I had a lot of interaction with him. This gives him pretty solid town cred for me, based on d1 contributions.

Going back to reading now.

---

@Jabbz don't worry, what you saw was my mafia game. My games here as town have actually been very similar to how Psilly plays, so despite being mistaken you were 100% correct.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jabbz

This is just a continuation of your non-engagement with my posts. You do a good job here of making my point, so thank you. Since you no longer appear to have anything valid to say, and when you address my comments it's to belittle them and ignore the content (which you can't counter) I'm going to move on. Barring someone else doing something really strange, I'm pretty sure my vote will stay on you, and I'll be encouraging others to follow. Gday.

---

congratulations for finding a convenient reason to not progress your reads, make any new ones, and still ignore me asking what your thoughts on current wagons are

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by atheotes

You must be from a parallel universe! :laugh4:
Though you are a lot more proficient in penning your thoughts!

---

Chalk it up to 3 years competing in and 5 years coaching in college speech and debate added to a BA in Communication Studies and an (almost! one semester left!) MA in Communication Education. Having a BA in BS is usefull for these types of games :P

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jabbz

Chalk it up to 3 years competing in and 5 years coaching in college speech and debate added to a BA in Communication Studies and an (almost! one semester left!) MA in Communication Education. Having a BA in BS is usefull for these types of games :P

---

*Uses a copious amount of chalk to vigorously inscribe this information*

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jabbz

Chalk it up to 3 years competing in and 5 years coaching in college speech and debate added to a BA in Communication Studies and an (almost! one semester left!) MA in Communication Education. Having a BA in BS is usefull for these types of games :P

---

You might like our Seamus Fermanagh. He's a Communications professor or sommat, though he seems to have retired from Mafia.

Valid observation, and amusing the rest of us missed it. Perhaps our votes for rep goes through first, then their vote for lynch is tallied?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Schema

Still seven pages from caught up. My own fault, whatever, I'll get there. Also I'm incredibly rusty and haven't played in months, so bear with me as I get up to speed on all the players.

Don't feel too comfortable wrt Mont, Renata, Winston. I'm considering all their posts and any arguments made toward them and a lynch that direction. Feel pretty good about Cass and dice.

First, Cass is just solvey, engaging everyone, asking hard questions. I'm happy with her game play and her follow-through, she seems committed.

I believe I've played with dice before on PerC and idk, I'm getting town vibes from over there this game. Tonally on point, if nothing else.

Okay, few more pages to go. BBL.

---

you get -points right away for having three scum and fishing for lynches while doing one hardish town read and one soft one

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cuthillius

you get -points right away for having three scum and fishing for lynches while doing one hardish town read and one soft one

---

Not disagreeing or agreeing, just wondering, what about that do you dislike?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cuthillius

you get -points right away for having three scum and fishing for lynches while doing one hardish town read and one soft one

---

#ruleofthrees

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Dp101

Not disagreeing or agreeing, just wondering, what about that do you dislike?

---

In a totally not made up statistic, scum are most likely to throw out three names (one of which is prolly their scumbro)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sooh

Yup. I'm pretty sure I'm the ONLY ONE this game who hasn't said much.

Whatever. Even if you find another lynch candidate I'll be dead tomorrow, so.

---

If you are so sure you are going to be lynched, then any reads you have are useful to town. While we won't trust your judgement necessarily, at least we can trust your perspective to be townish, and your words would be the only unimpeachable ones in game. Gives us what you can, and I will be grateful, even if no one else is (which I doubt would be the case).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jabbz

If you are so sure you are going to be lynched, then any reads you have are useful to town. While we won't trust your judgement necessarily, at least we can trust your perspective to be townish, and your words would be the only unimpeachable ones in game. Gives us what you can, and I will be grateful, even if no one else is (which I doubt would be the case).

---

Villagey

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zack

also lolcuth for his whole sequence

i think it's actually a bad look for him to come in townreading me and voting me chancellor

i'd expect villager cuth to come in jizzing his pants to voting me and calling me a wolf based on nothing

---

i'm sorry you have an ego :P

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zack

congratulations for finding a convenient reason to not progress your reads, make any new ones, and still ignore me asking what your thoughts on current wagons are

---

Yeah, sure Zack, I'm using your hounding of me to avoid putting out the town and scum reads I already have to date. I get I misread you dude, but you need to get over yourself when it comes to me, you're just being an ass, and I'm pretty sure it's not contributing anything useful. Cheers.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Visor

what recent game was it that he came in with a hard on for me d1?

---

oh, was that the hydra game?