Graffiti Mafia [Concluded]

Well as you may all have noticed I went to bed after my last vote; before it I did read the thread, but I didn't get any smarter from it. As to why I withdrew my vote; I wanted to get time for more discussion and thinking.

I'm going to have to assume that GH was guilty. That excludes Xiahou from my suspects list. Also Ituralde was the target of an attempted murder, excluding him.

That leaves me with two options, Doc or Husar. Of the two, Husar has been the more active and also the more suspicious one. Doc again has managed to play through the game with lots of lurking. Both have played with two very different styles and thus makes comparison bloody hard. But I'm going to go with my suspicions, choose Husar and hope that I've made the right decision.

Vote: Husar

DISCO!
Finish it!
Well, he may be asleep...

Vote: Ituralde

Wouldn't it be a bit weird if Duck gave such a long reasoning if he knew Disco will come and finish me anyway?
Ituralde is also a bit insisting on this. only doc or disco to finish it now, I can only hold my breath concerning doc, then again, it's about the whole town, not me alone...

Oh and with Ituralde insisting on a vote he is blocking the process a little bit becauseif he is a townie and say, Duck is a mafioso, we cannot win as long as he insists on his vote, I would see that as a bit counter-productive. You might want to count into that that he would prefer to lose to a mafioso who hid well.:dizzy2: Maybe he was hiding well.
It's a good thing that disco is sleeping though...

Nah... I just want this game to be over, one way or another. We could talk for ages and hope for a slip-up from some Mafioso but that's a rather poor strategy. So I've placed my bet and no one has yet convinced me of anything else.
Someone amongst us is lying, and so far has lied well. I see no angle of attack for me, so I have essentially given up and tried my best educated guess.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Husar

Wouldn't it be a bit weird if Duck gave such a long reasoning if he knew Disco will come and finish me anyway?
Ituralde is also a bit insisting on this. only doc or disco to finish it now, I can only hold my breath concerning doc, then again, it's about the whole town, not me alone...

---

I have no reason to finish it now, Disco can kill you if he wants, if he skips the opportunity that means you're probably mafia, and I'll just finsih you off tomorrow.

Let's end this shall we?

Vote: Husar

Since I clearly can't stop you from killing my guy I might as well bandwagon.

Well, I guess it's over then.

Yes, and I'm not his guy, btw.

Currently I suspect it's Ituralde, but voting for him wouldn't have made a difference.

In that case it was either Xiahou or Ituralde, both whom I excluded as possible suspects.:shame:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by doc_bean

I have no reason to finish it now, Disco can kill you if he wants, if he skips the opportunity that means you're probably mafia, and I'll just finsih you off tomorrow.

---

:wall:

"Let's throw her into the pond - if she floats it means she's a witch!"

I wish I'd have paid attention to the end of this game... :shame:

Husar has been lynched. As the townies stand around the courthouse wondering about their fate, they notice that Xiahou is crouched behind one of the pillars. They have only a few seconds to wonder why before a black mercedes drives by and AggonyDuck, Ituralde, and doce_bean and killed in a rain of bullets from the discovery1's tommy gun.

Killed (13):

Caius Flaminius
Kagemusha
Sigurd Fafnesbane
Warluster-Mason/doctor
Masy
Don Corleone-Amnesiac roleblocker
Sir Boo
Jimbob-little timmy
pevergreen
Redleg
AggonyDuck
Ituralde-Soothsayer
doc_bean

Lynched(7):
Reenk Roink
GeneralHankerchief-Mafioso
Dutch_guy-Mason/doctor
Kommodus-Mafioso
Ichigo
Seamus Fermanagh
Husar

WoG(5):
Divine Wind
Proletariat
Ultrawar
Peasant Phill
Sir Moody-Mason/doctor

Alive: (2):

discovery1-Godfather
Xiahou-Mafia Roleblocker


Mafia Win!

Good game everybody. Write up to follow.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kommodus

:wall:

"Let's throw her into the pond - if she floats it means she's a witch!"

I wish I'd have paid attention to the end of this game... :shame:

---

Err...Kommodus, honey, there wasn't anything *I* could do about it at this point, except hope someone else would withdraw their vote.

Ah, that was satisfying. More than makes up for Godfather 2.

:evil:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

An evil, sinister laugh is heard throughout the town with the fourth vote on Husar. Experts at vocal analysis place it as the late GeneralHankerchief's, but they are uncertain exactly why. Perhaps time will tell.

---

Perhaps time already has :bounce:


ninja edit!

Yeah, notice the edit.

Does roleblocker mean that the person could block someone else's role?

After talking to Sigurd this morning I was about to change my vote to Xiahous, but that hadn't really helped anyway, took four townies(or just all remining townies) to win this.

So, nicely done Disco!:2thumbsup:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro

Mafia Win!

---

Yay! Excellent game by my co-conspirators Xiahou, GeneralHankerchief, and discovery1! Xiahou in particular deserves a round of applause IMO.

:balloon2: :balloon2: :balloon2:

For all my skill as a townsperson, I clearly make a terrible mafioso. I made it pretty far in Mafia III simply because I was still unknown just enough to fly under the radar.

Disco picked me this time simply to disarm my method; I was apparently more useful to him as a dead mafioso than as an easy-lynch villager. We all thought in the beginning that I'd be the first to go, and I certainly would've been if not for the nastiness that took place with GeneralH in the chatroom.

Everyone can now enjoy a hearty laugh at the expense of me and my suspicious posts and feeble arguments! :laugh4: :laugh4: :laugh4:

Now back to being a simple townsperson, which I much prefer. Disco, I'm honored that you chose me, but I still wish you hadn't. Your selections were so obvious that GeneralH and I were suspected from the first turn. :no:

Good game to all! Sir Moody and the masonic crew: you sure pwn'd me! Did I make it too easy for you? You also did a fine job of blocking our kills for a long time. GeneralH and Xiahou: your fine strategy paid off in the end, delivering victory to the team!

Have a nice day, and happy mafia-ing! :2thumbsup:

Ah, well this was an interesting game. With three hand picked mafia I knew the town would have a hard time, but I don't like detectives much, the town tends to rely on them too much. So I included a soothsayer role instead. Masons with out roles aren't very useful so I gave them all doctor ability, figuring they could save a few lives (they saved masy one round). I gave xiahou roleblocker ability to prevent Ituralde or anyone from claiming and asking to be protected. Don C was the amnesiac roleblocker, in his pm he was told he had a role but had forgotten what it was. He sent me names and I responded with "yes" if he blocked someone and "no" if he didn't. He blocked sir moody one round and prevented a kill from GH one round. He probably would have been able to figure out what had happened and that GH was guilty, but he died that round I think and GH was revealed with the chat error. Jimbob had a semi-information finding ability. It was made rather weak by the way the mafia kills were done though. He sent it to kommodus once but kommo just had X and GH send in the kills. If he had sent it to X when X was the only one left he could have learned something though.

The mafia started off doing really well. The town was completely confused by the the graffiti messages (which were rather slanted in favor of the mafia to be honest, given that the masons had no detective roles) and there were several no lynches. Then GH got caught in the chatroom (apparently he meant to type /leave Lenin to leave private chat but typed /quit lenin instead). They immediately figured out it would be a good idea to have Xiahou post an incriminating screenshot. This "proof" of Xiahou's innocence and the early graffiti messages naming Husar are what eventually won the game for them. Kommodus went down soon after, when it was pointed out he would be a good choice for mafioso and he roleclaimed a little hastily. Besides the GH chat thing, I think the biggest mistake the mafia made was in killing off Sigurd, he was a thorn in their side the rest of the game. Xiahou slipped quietly under the radar though, and won the game in the end.

I can only say damn well played mates. Nothing else to say. :shame:

I guess 2/3 ain't bad. I was completely fooled by that last mafioso Xiahou. That screenshot of GH quiting was pretty smart on the mafioso's part. I guess Sigurd got it right in the end.

That means a new game soon right Sasaki. Nudges Sasaki :grin:

Lesson learned for the town from this game.Stop those bloody no:lynches on the first few rounds.Without the desire of some astonishing proof you would have got GH right on the first round.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kagemusha

Lesson learned for the town from this game.Stop those bloody no:lynches on the first few rounds.Without the desire of some astonishing proof you would have got GH right on the first round.

---

hey, I've been saying that for ages !

Hey, I finally won one! My first time as mafia, I thought I'd be coy and never directly deny being mafia... yada yada. After that turned out to be an abysmal failure, I decided next time I was going to shamelessly lie like a dog. :2thumbsup:

My main strategy was to post like a townie- I would try my best to forget that I was mafia and point out suspicious people and vote like I did when I was a normal townie. GH, Kommodus and Disco were also good sources for advice- they probably saved me from making mis-steps that could've blown the game for me.

Oh, and in case anyone cares, the Sparky the clown murders were the first kills that I've ever had to write. :sweatdrop:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kagemusha

Lesson learned for the town from this game.Stop those bloody no:lynches on the first few rounds.Without the desire of some astonishing proof you would have got GH right on the first round.

---

Even I was saying that and I was mafia.:laugh4:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kagemusha

Lesson learned for the town from this game.Stop those bloody no:lynches on the first few rounds.Without the desire of some astonishing proof you would have got GH right on the first round.

---

Ah, but if I made any contribution to my team at all, it was making a good-sounding argument for not lynching anyone in round 1. Things were looking bad for us already, with both GH and me being named in people's lists of who discovery1 was most likely to choose.

It was almost enough to make me believe in some sort of curse! :dizzy2:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Xiahou

Even I was saying that and I was mafia.:laugh4:

---

It's one of the reasons I didn't really suspect you anymore yet thought AgonnyDuck was the remaining one, after reading through the entuire thread.

VERY well done. :medievalcheers:

Excellent. I have had my revenge for the disgrace that was Mafia IV. A little too close for comfort though.

I take it the who cult thing was in my imagination then?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by discovery1

Excellent. I have had my revenge for the disgrace that was Mafia IV. A little too close for comfort though.

I take it the who cult thing was in my imagination then?

---

I thought you guys made that up to discredit people? You actually thought there was a cult!?

That was my fault actually. Reenk wrote that little PM when I was about to die, I was immediately suspicious and did a little research. Cult seemed pretty close.

I wonder what favor he wanted me to do...?

GAH.Anyway about the curse, revenge will be mine sooner or later.:yes:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

That was my fault actually. Reenk wrote that little PM when I was about to die, I was immediately suspicious and did a little research. Cult seemed pretty close.

I wonder what favor he wanted me to do...?

---

Oh yeah, I still don't know what was up with that. You sounded like you thought I knew what it was all about so I didn't ask. He tried to get you to reveal yourself via pm or something?