would probably add amy with a question mark just like dya because they have external reasons which could affect their play
have you explain the manti read?
02-23-2021, 12:38
Ephemeral
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Esooa
have you explain the manti read?
made post on it early ye
feelings haven't changed
02-23-2021, 12:40
pzelda
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dolby
The posts I’ve seen from him are pretty early game and I thought they were all fine. In Princes I thought he was howling from first posts. I don’t understand why you have him in a wolf slot outside you thinking his posts are disaster OSU bc ???
I think that his posts being more disruptive than anything else is enough to have him as a sr. There are two more concrete reasons. His votes are going completely against the consensus. They have no chance of succeeding and, in case of Hally, he had no good reason. In case of his vote on me, his reasoning was vaguer than I would like it to be. Also, I disliked his meta shade on GH. I admit his newer posts are better constructed, but I haven't find anything 100% towny in them yet (I admit I skimmed over spoilered parts).
02-23-2021, 12:48
Visor
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ephemeral
manti
gh
dya(?)
would probably add amy with a question mark just like dya because they have external reasons which could affect their play
talk to me about manti
02-23-2021, 12:51
pzelda
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
I feel like questioning GH now could lead to me becoming chaotic. It's not out of realm of possibilities that he's a wolf, but I partially sheeped his scumreads. I don't think Eph is in risk of getting eliminated today. GH being a wolf would spew Cuth, Eph and Visor town. Maybe even Amy and Dolby (but Dolby not responding to GH's case and GH jumping back to Amy makes this questionable). I don't want to go there now. Losing town GH would be a greater disaster than letting wolf GH live longer.
I probably won't be very active between now and eod, but I want to reread the thread overnight and focus on Dolby, Monty and GH, while reading it.
02-23-2021, 12:52
Esooa
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ephemeral
mmm
I'm having some trouble finding the right words to express this but
I think he's trying too hard and it feels unnatural
It's kind of like he's trying to put a different spin to what he was doing in rocks inv while doing the same thing
lolwords
Can you talk about this more Eph? If I'm understanding it right, you're saying he's posting more reads and such to contrast with how he was scum read for fluffing too much day 1 of rocks, right? But I don't understand the "while doing the same thing" part
02-23-2021, 13:23
Ephemeral
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Esooa
Can you talk about this more Eph? If I'm understanding it right, you're saying he's posting more reads and such to contrast with how he was scum read for fluffing too much day 1 of rocks, right? But I don't understand the "while doing the same thing" part
idt he was wolf read in rocks for shitposting? At least I definitely didn't wolf read him for that in rocks
and him posting more reads isn't the issue here, it's the fact that it doesn't feel like he believes them nor does he try to do anything with it
02-23-2021, 13:26
Esooa
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ephemeral
idt he was wolf read in rocks for shitposting? At least I definitely didn't wolf read him for that in rocks
and him posting more reads isn't the issue here, it's the fact that it doesn't feel like he believes them nor does he try to do anything with it
ah, maybe it just stands out to me the most cause that's what I gathered was the biggest reason he was wagoned EoD1 and I mostly agreed with it at the time
my convo with gh from earlier was unsatisfactory as a whole
felt like he was just answering my qs for the sake of answering as opposed to actively being interested in moving it forward to get a better feel of where I was at/what I was doing
Doesn't feel like he's actually trying to gauge me to get a better grasp of my alignment
:shrug:
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ephemeral
all good, I'm binging money heist and its gotten me sleep deprived so I'll probably be pretty inconsistent with my response time too :p
Talk to me about manti
And I'd appreciate more on Dolby because I really don't see what you're seeing there
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ephemeral
I wasn't the one who made the post you're referring to w/r/t manti
I made a post about him but it was something else
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ephemeral
I
guess your stuff on dolby is fine? As in, your process is fine
I still disagree with it and think the way he handled it was villagery though, with the caveat that I haven't seen dolby wolf before so if there's a meta telling aspect to it then idk
Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Ah, right, it was this one.
Again, levels. Still doesn't do much for me at this time really.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ephemeral
Not really sure what you mean by levels in this instance
Not exactly sure how I was supposed to meet this standard when you were the one who initiated conversation, asked me about exactly Manti, and then the conversation petered out naturally, but sure. At least the unsatisfactory feeling was mutual!
(I skimmed everything this morning while half-asleep but just wanted to highlight this, will go back and fully reread the overnights in a little while)
02-23-2021, 13:54
Esooa
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
@gh hi
can you give me your current read on eph?
02-23-2021, 13:57
Ephemeral
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
Not exactly sure how I was supposed to meet this standard when you were the one who initiated conversation, asked me about exactly Manti, and then the conversation petered out naturally, but sure. At least the unsatisfactory feeling was mutual!
(I skimmed everything this morning while half-asleep but just wanted to highlight this, will go back and fully reread the overnights in a little while)
I mean I engaged you on a few things I was interested in hearing about from you back then, which you did indeed answer to
But seeing as I'm a slot of interest for you I would've expected you to have some questions to press on of your own, and even if you didn't have anything specific in mind I still think you would've shown more interest in engaging actively rather than just answering the questions you were asked and moving on
know what I mean?
02-23-2021, 13:58
GeneralHankerchief
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Esooa
@gh hi
can you give me your current read on eph?
Every read is the same as it was in my posted readslist from around 9 hours ago pending my overnight reread + deep thoughts.
If you don't village read me by like day 4 or 5 I'm going to self vote and have you lynched
I don't actually give a shit about your read in gh and I because it's obviously a reflection of our recent game history and doesn't reflect on this current game much at all.
If eph ends the day voting me, lynch him d2 <3 @Visor @Sunbae
02-23-2021, 14:07
Maple
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
This is a bad read
Amy saying "slank cover" is >rand v
This may not make sense but I'll will this into existence
02-23-2021, 14:07
Maple
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Maple
If you don't village read me by like day 4 or 5 I'm going to self vote and have you lynched
I don't actually give a shit about your read in gh and I because it's obviously a reflection of our recent game history and doesn't reflect on this current game much at all.
If eph ends the day voting me, lynch him d2 <3 @Visor @Sunbae
Rational: ita Tuesday and eod is today. If eph tries to kill me d1 Tuesday, he's outed. Thank
02-23-2021, 14:09
Esooa
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
god I still have 500 posts to catch up on lol
02-23-2021, 14:09
GeneralHankerchief
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
A question for the thread at large: If dya ends up being chopped today and flips red, can I be treated as spewed town for forgetting to include them in my reads list from last night?
A follow-up question: If the answer is "you could have been until you directly pointed this out", can I be treated as spewed town anyway?
02-23-2021, 14:09
Esooa
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
from my reread that is
02-23-2021, 14:10
Maple
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by ColonelLubriderm
Hally
Esooa
Visor
Cuth
Ara
Sunbae
Pzelda
GH
————— above here be town
Dolby
Montmorency
Ephemeral
Maple
Manasi
Dya
————— below be wolves
Ampharos
Csargo
Where I’m at, GH is currently straddling that line shimmying back and forth down it
For some reason what is standing out to me here is the placement of dya manasi and I
Idk why
02-23-2021, 14:10
Maple
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
A question for the thread at large: If dya ends up being chopped today and flips red, can I be treated as spewed town for forgetting to include them in my reads list from last night?
A follow-up question: If the answer is "you could have been until you directly pointed this out", can I be treated as spewed town anyway?
Do you think it's fair of me to read this post and contrast it to the "Sunbae says nice things but he can be doing that as scum and nothing is alignment indicative" post from earlier and be confused?
To me it's come off as if you've started the game from a "posting well isn't alignment indicative" mindset that's approaching things with skepticism and hesitancy and now have shifted to a general "Eh, I'll give town reads to those that are active and figure out any deep scum later" laid back mindset. While I think both mindsets are totally fine and reasonable (I'm personally a big believer in the second one a lot of the time) I'm just a bit confused about what caused the shift between the two.
Secondary question: Can you elaborate a bit on the "p much" portion? That makes it sound like you specifically have an active poster that you don't feel is towny but I could be reading into it too much.
This is eyes emoji
02-23-2021, 14:15
Ephemeral
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Maple
If you don't village read me by like day 4 or 5 I'm going to self vote and have you lynched
I don't actually give a shit about your read in gh and I because it's obviously a reflection of our recent game history and doesn't reflect on this current game much at all.
If eph ends the day voting me, lynch him d2 <3 @Visor @Sunbae
completely false on the gh read
and I don't see how that adds up even in your case where yes, recent games hold a lot of weight
02-23-2021, 14:15
Maple
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by ColonelLubriderm
#theTimeGHforgotDyachei
You remembered within 1 minute and made a show of it
02-23-2021, 14:15
dyachei
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Maple
This is eyes emoji
talk about why?
02-23-2021, 14:15
Maple
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ephemeral
completely false on the gh read
and I don't see how that adds up even in your case where yes, recent games hold a lot of weight
I don't care
02-23-2021, 14:17
Esooa
Re: Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]
Dyachei, can you explain where your at more specifically in regards to finding it hard to get into the game? Why is that?
