Printable View
BG, I would have drawn the same conclusions regarding Kukri based on those PMs. Revealing was the right thing to do. You had one guilty result and a second result that you had perfectly good reasons for thinking was off. Most detectives don't get to take down even one mafioso, so a shot at two was well worth revealing.
Good game guys. Thank you Andres :bow:
Now GH... why did you go after me?
Because he knew from me you were delicious. Yum! :dizzy2:Quote:
Originally Posted by Beefy187
Congratulations Ichi!:bow: Brilliant game from you. There simply was no case against you. I disagree that this was a lurker victory. I would say that Ichi played a great game as low key mafia. In my mind if the mafioso is not the loudest in the bunch, does not mean he is a lurker. Ichi was there posting in almost each round of the game. He just did not pull any attention towards himself with ambitious stunts that gets most of the mafiosos killed in these game. Again well played my friend.:bow:
Also big thanks for Andres. This was a great game after my long retirement from these games. Thank you for your efforts in hosting this great game.:bow:
Ha! So my (Kukri) internet character's internet character (Gamo Ujisato) got snuffed because of too many keystrokes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
If that ain't delicious irony, I don't know what is. :laugh4::laugh4::laugh4::laugh4:
@Banquo's Ghost: no harm, no foul. I'd have made the same decision, given the same feedback. And timing a pro-town reveal is always the toughest decision to make in these games IMO. You gotta get the info out there, to help the town, and you gotta do it before you're killed. The two times I've revealed (once as Rogue Detective, once as Resurrector) I was one turn too late to help.
The only hint that Ichigo was dirty was that he was NOT lurking -- but there are plenty of games where he hasn't so.....
Andres:
So? How does it feel to manage 60+? Bit of an experience no? :cheesy:
It feels :sweatdrop: and a bit :freak:, but also :jumping:, :2thumbsup: and :laugh4:Quote:
Originally Posted by Seamus Fermanagh
Hindsight is a false vision here and now of the there and then. You were in a difficult position and did the best you could with the knowledge you had. The one thing I remember about your reveal is that it gave us a sense of hope. Up until that point, the game had been a disaster for the town as far as we knew. Finally we had something solid to go on. Thank you. :applause: That your innocent list later became a liability is not your fault. :shame:Quote:
Originally Posted by Banquo's Ghost
As for the Kukri reading, we were all engaged in putting more meaning into things than was really there as Andres mentions in his game diary...except for ajaxfetish (he got a cookie!).
:bow:
:bow: at this game, who played and who didn't. I was busy with Uni, not almost having access at all. That's why I didn't vote 4 times and then voted.
Beskar was innocent, yet I did not want to believe that. But you were right when you said "mafia needs to keep me alive".
Quite a achievement despite the fact that ATPG died on the first day :yes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Andres
Great game.
Congrats to the ninjas. Thanks for hosting, Andres. It was good fun, I loved the Japanese atmosphere of it all.
The end is endless
just as the void is voidless
and we will start again
In the end I see it was closer than we all thought.
And if I ever play again I shall certainly remember that most important of rules:
Ichigo is guilty.
:laugh4: Yeah, he needs to change his sig image from "glorious" to "guilty". :laugh4:Quote:
Originally Posted by Yoyoma1910
See, I said earlier that I was Cassandra of Trey. :beam:
Brilliant game. Thanks Ichigo, very well played. :bow:
Thanks Andres for hosting this wonderful game. It is truely fitting for the org's ten year's anniversary game, my applause to you sir. :applause:
Cheers all participants for making this the great game it was. ~:cheers:
Sorry for the late, late response. Been really busy lately... :sweatdrop:
See what happens when I change my style from talkative to roleplay? Dead.Quote:
Originally Posted by Beefy187
That was your hint that I was innocent. Oh yes, that and I capped myself. :laugh4:
I wanted everyone to enjoy this one and my constant chatter does drown that out.
I guess I was heading down that path too. :embarassed: And I got offed early as well. A social game where the winning strategy is to shut up seems rather odd.Quote:
Originally Posted by Askthepizzaguy
Although we are still riding high on our lynch the lurker backlash. Guaranteed to destroy a mafia or a less talkative townie!
*not a guarantee.
Andres, you should make sure this gets transferred to the Gameroom before the 10th Anniversary forum shuts down. This needs to be preserved for perusal and reflection along with all the rest. A truly excellent game. :bow:
I :bow: at Andres.
It's one strategy.Quote:
Originally Posted by Gregoshi
Ichigo, actually, did NOT lurk this game. He often does. Actually, several of us missed it -- his average posts per hundred was up at least one SD -- sloppy work by me (too much empire).
Good work. It seems I was only right about Olavi and the fact that ninja and traitors do not work together. I have made a vaaaast list of suspects but none of them seemed to be guilty. I had certain doubts about Yaropolk... but this does not count. There was something strange in the behaviour of Ichigo either (at certain point I realised the only reason I am alive is that I have chosen the wrong person) but personally this was not enough to vote for him.
Andres, about my death... vulgar language is not really typical for me... I expected something more refined. But good work! :thumbsup:
P.S. This was fun but really consumed more time than I had. It is time to retreat into the shadows and deal with limited number of org. responsibilities and vaaast number of RL issues. First, and probably the last Mafia I have ever played... Thank you, Andres! :bow:
Andres provided nice images for the Award for the winners, but I'm very slow to set this up. Sorry.
Congratulations to the ninjas.
Thanks :bow: