Vote: Abstain (subject to change)
Too many suspects, too little sense of "rightness" to the charges -- though Hankerchief is putting up better marks.
Printable View
Vote: Abstain (subject to change)
Too many suspects, too little sense of "rightness" to the charges -- though Hankerchief is putting up better marks.
People that cast wide dispersions of suspicion this early in the game almost always are trying to muddy waters. That being said, I'm going to resist the temptation to vote Sasaki. In looking for something else to latch onto, we've had a couple instances of band-wagoning and a couple "I'm going to post so I show up in the tallies, but I'm not going to post anything legitimate". I've got my eye on several of you. I find it odd that General Hank would put it out there that nailing Kommodus would automatically mean a newbie mafia.... yes Kommodus is an experienced player, but Kagemusha and Sasaki would be even more obvious choices using that logic. It's almost like General Hank WANTS us to believe the mafia are newbies.....To that end...
Vote: General Hankerchief
You have learned the craft well. :grin:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sir Moody
Hmmm, after the last game I think I will Vote: Abstain until there is something substantial against someone.
I'm looking at Peasant Phil and GeneralHankerchief. I think Hankercief is the most likely of the two because, well Don said it already
Vote: GeneralHankerchief
As I mentioned in the other mafia thread, my home PC is currently down (man do power supplies stink when they go!) I'm going to try to hit CompUSA on the way home and install it tonight, but I may be offline for the next 14 hours (until I return to work). Please be patient with my lack of reply until then.
Aw, come on Don (if you even see this). If I wanted to manipulate people like that I would have used the chat, like I did numerous times in Godfather 2.
There is the possibility that it's *NOT* a double-bluff, you know.
I'm not going to quote all his posts but Sasaki really made m laugh a lot this time...:laugh4: :laugh4: :laugh4:
Besides this making him highly, erm, suspicious, I am inclined to believe Don since GH is voting in weird ways.
Vote: General Hankerchief
Come on, people. I'm not this bad of a player! The two times where I was a mafioso resulted in a total victory and a close loss that was damn near a win. If I was a mafioso I wouldn't be posting this little analysis that I *thought* would be helpful in the first round! Sheesh. I'd be abstaining.
Fight the bandwagon, people. You're killing an innocent here.
Look, there are two options.
1.) The mafia really are newbies, and have not bothered to write the kills.
2.) The mafia are experienced old-timers and are deliberately trying to frame the newbies.
Personally, I believe option 1. Has anyone noticed that theRTWguru has not posted after the kills yet? He is always one with enthusiasm and regularly posts. Secondly, he has a grudge against me, for my mocking his statement that he was the detective in Mafia V.
I would go for theRTWguru.
15 hours until voting closes.
Why on earth are we lynching GeneralH?
Unvote, Vote: Reenk Roink
Tie it up GH.
Thought I should at least chime in, even if I don't have much to add. What's up with Kage's early vote for prole? Was that just a shot in the dark or based on something?
that's true but come on you accuse me for posting 1 post more than my usual habit?Quote:
Originally Posted by Sasaki Kojiro
Hmm, strange. I've just cleared you and then you accuse me of being a mafiosi. All this because Sasaki said that I don't post a lot? Or is there another reason?Quote:
Originally Posted by JimBob
Vote abstainQuote:
Originally Posted by ignoramus
Why?
Well it's a tough nut to crack and I haven't made my mind up yet. If it were Sasaki or Csar that were killed for example it would no doubt be the work of newbies. You just don't kill off people that attrack attention that easily. Instead they killed Ignoramus and Kommodus, people who have the skills and don't get lynched a lot. Is the mafia hoping that their attention to this game will fade and thus removing two good detectives (not the game role) for no apparent cost? If you believe this, then you definatly should be looking at veteran players like General Hanky but there are enough others to pull of a thing like that.
After what Ignoramus said, I'm also suspicous about TheRTWGuru. But you can't judge after one round about post behavior.
I am inclined to think that you are pointing out the finesse of your own kill here...Quote:
Originally Posted by UltraWar
vote:UltraWar
Unvote: General Hankerchief
Vote: Abstain
Must refrain from voting when too drunk to think.:sweatdrop:
Anyway, I need to reanalyze this game, I somehow cannot remember much of what was posted here, and since I don't feel like it now, I will abstain this round.~:cheers:
well we just hit a dead end in our daily coding grind (you think programming is fun? try doing it for a living :idea2:) at work so i have asome free time heres a status update as my count makes it (just count not who voted for who)
Proletariat = 1
Masy = 1
Jimbob = 1
Ultrawar = 2
Sir Moody = 1
Reenk = 2
GH = 2
so we have a three way tie
Unvote, Vote:Ultrawar
I don't like ties.
Killing Kommodus and Ignoramus is a pretty good move.
While excellent and experienced players, both tend to post/interact less frequently in mafia threads where they have been killed (as do most of us). This means that murdering them early is a valid tool for reducing interaction. As Sasaki's premilinary research suggests, mafia success and low post count/minimalized discussions tend to cohere. Sasaki is the exception in that his death is likely to increase his involvement (if anything), so murdering him early doesn't pay off with a big dividend.
To me, this suggests that at least one of the mafiosi is both experienced and aware of the level of interaction issues vis-a-vis mafia success.
Unlike Sasaki, however, I find ties useful in the 1st/2nd round as they increase the number of votes and comments for analysis. I will, therefore
Unvote: Abstain
Vote: GeneralHankerchief
to create such a tie. GH can break it if he wishes, or someone else may step in, but I am not adverse to leaving it a tie. Note, I'm slightly more likely to vote for Ultrawar's death in the tie-breaker (should one occur) since GH's posts read "true" for me so far.
Prole is mafia, this time so boring that you wont answer to my simple question? Or is should i assume that you are quilty?:inquisitive:
Well, I recommend a Vote: Ultrawar from all, because his post is blatantly ludicrous and more than quite suspicious. He doesn't question my posting, what I've written, or who I've voted for, but rather suggests that I am the type of person to commit these kills. Firstly, basing a vote on something that has nothing to do with a chaps posting (I had not made a significant post up until then, other than asking to join the game) is odd enough, but what's more he bases it on my character, a tenuous assault at best (as far as I recall, I've never met Ultrawar, and I don't believe in Clairvoyance or Psychics). Even if he's basing votes on other games, that's still a weak attack (and something frowned upon I should hope). On the other hand, he could be joking around (bad enough in itself :beam: ), and will change his vote, but we've heard nothing from him since...
Voting closed.
The Chief of Police Csar finally came back after tallying all the votes. It seems we have a tie people. There will be a revote but you can only vote for GH or Ultra War. The voting shall be closed in 24 hours. GET VOTING.
Seamus Fermanagh-GH
GeneralHankerchief-Jimbob
UltraWar-Masy
Sasaki Kojiro-UW
Husar-Abstain
Sir Moody-RR
Prole-Didn't bother
Sigurd Fafnesbane-UW
TheRTWGuru-Didn't bother
Dutch_Guy-Didn't bother
Silver Rusher-Didn't bother
Reenk Roink-Sir Moody
Hepcat-Abstain
Warluster-Didn't bother
Peasant Phill-Abstain
Masy-Ultra War
Jimbob-GH
Kagemusha-Prole
Discovery1-Didn't bother
Don Corleone-GH
Xiahou-Didn't bother
Vote: UltraWar
You may or may not be in the mafia. But I know that I'm not in the mafia. Better we have some chance of offing a mafioso than no chance.
Vote: GeneralHankerchief
Who else can I vote for? I know what consequences my execution will have so I might vote myself and I can't wait what your faces will look like when you've just noticed you've wasted a perfectly good lynch because of my accusations at Masy. I might be wrong about Masy, yet I might be right. It just depends on how in-depth you go. I am prepared if I am lynched as it means yet another of the various fates I have faced in the Mafia Games.
Goodnight Gracie
If you are the detective and have found Masy guilty, this is the time to speak up.Quote:
Originally Posted by UltraWar
For now I see no reason to change my initial vote.
Vote:UltraWar
Vote: GeneralH
Peasant Phil. You were too reasonable.
i really dont know who to vote for i find masys "last minute" vote to tie it suspicous but i dont know why he decided to make us chose between Ultra and GH
because of this ill Vote: GeneralHankerchief but i really dont think either are mafia
Um, that wasn't a last minute vote. He had voted for Ultra much earlier.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sir Moody
The first time you accused me of being mafia it was within minutes of the game starting and I just thought you were joking. Anyway, not mafia once again, and although I doubt either are mafia, I'll go with voteing: ultrawar since it seems silly to lynch GH with what we know so farQuote:
Originally Posted by Kagemusha